Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
$ % $ &
'(
%$
'
)
! !"
#
$ %&% '
(
RAMESH
MATHAPATI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$ %&% '
%'
$ %&%""'
(
)
-2-
&
% &
'%
*
' "
+ ,
-&&
%
' '
#
#
*
.
/
.
#
#
012 34515167 12 8194: ;7:4<
,?,<1@
;<,@20,
3<6=44:17?2
'%
' "
,7015,
' "
4=5167 % & 68
244@17?
,?,1725
345151674< ,==;24:
<1B4
6%
' '
<4?1254<4:
A;,20
C>
,24
6@,>;@5,
691=4
1:,< 347:17? 67 504 8194 68
#;:?4
1:,< 86< 504 68847=4 3;7120,C94 ;7:4< 24=5167 + , 68
<4D475167 68
6<<;35167
206<5 E504
=5 F
=5
125<1=5 ,7:
86<
04 ,C<1:?4: 8,=52 68 504 =,24 ,<4 50,5
H184! BC1@,
4450,9,?4<4
199,?4
;B7,C,:
,7
B47:B475
4221672
' &
=6B39,17,75G2
-&&
<9
0,<,51>,
7?,7,H,:1
,9;@ 8<6B 9,25
H6<@4<
,5
' >4,<2
-3-
<4A;4254: 504
E
F
019:
;B7,C,:
7?,7,H,:1
475<4
2;CB1554: 56 674
<6I4=5
881=4<
86< 206<5
56 5<,7284< 04< 56 504 D,=,75 3625 68
6' '
,551
H,2 H6<@17? ,2
43,<5B475 ,5
4D4963B475
04 2,1: <4A;425 94554< H,2
06C0, 1 4
C486<4 504
;B7,C,:
1:,<
345151674< ,==;24:
H06
6B47 ,7:
019:
125<1=5
504 H184 68
,54<
498,<4
=6B39,17,75 34<267,99> ,33<6,=04: 504 345151674< ,7: ,5 50,5
51B4 204 :4B,7:4: , 2;B 68
56 ?45 04< H6<@ :674
2 %' ''' ! 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167
2 2;=0 504 =6B39,17,75 ,33<6,=04: 504
691=4 ,7: 1786<B4: 504 2,B4
04<4,854<
<42367:475
!
691=4 ,:D124: 504 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 56 <4=6<: 504 =67D4<2,5167
C45H447 04< ,7: 504 345151674<
, D61=4 <4=6<:4<
345151674<
,54<
==6<:17?9> 504> 0,7:4: 6D4<
504 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 B45 504
!" 51B42 17 04< 6881=4
=6725,759> :4B,7:4:
06H4D4<
2 %' ''' ! ,2 , C<1C4
H184 17!5;<7 1786<B4: 504 2,B4 56 504
<42367:475
! 691=4
<4=41D4:
=6B39,17,75 ,7: <4?1254<4: 504 =,24 17
68847=4 3;7120,C94 ;7:4<
67 '%
' ' <42367:475
04 =6B39,17,75G2
691=4
,2 2;=0)
=6B39,175
<1B4
4=5167 + , 68
504 345151674<
6%
' ' 86< 504
=5
04<4,854<
! 691=4 =67:;=54: 475<;25B475
3,7=0,7,B, ,7: 504<4,854< =67:;=54: 504 <,1: 56 504 6881=4 68
-4-
345151674<
H0194
?<,5181=,5167
8<6B
<42367:475
<4=41D17?
2 "' ''' !
=6B39,17,75G2
H184
,2 1994?,9
;C24A;4759>
! 691=4 =67:;=54: , 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, ,7:
=,;?05 069: 504 ,==;24: ,7: 241J4: 504 5,1754: B674> 8<6B
04<
;<2;,759>
,==;24:
6@,>;@5, 6881=1,92 H,204: 504 0,7:2 68 504
H01=0 5;<74: 1756 317@ =696<
H01=0 D4<> B;=0
47D12,?42 50,5 ,==;24: 0,: ,==4354: 504 C<1C4 ,B6;75 ,2 34<
04< :4B,7:
04<4,854<
691=4 ,926 241J4: 504 <4=6<:2
34<5,1717? 56 504 5<,7284< 68 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 H01=0 H,2 @435
C> 504 345151674< 17 , H,<:<6C4 17 504 6881=4 ,5
3<6:;=4: 504 345151674< C486<4 504 94,<74:
504<4C> 2475 56 I;:1=1,9 =;256:>
<42367:475
34=1,9 #;:?4 ,7:
854< =6B394517? 17D4251?,5167
! 691=4 9,1: =0,<?4 20445 ,?,1725 504 345151674<
86< 504 ,86<4B4751674: 68847=4 ,7: 504 94,<74:
=6?71J,7=4 68 504 68847=4
"
94,<74:
1:,< ,7:
,?125<,54 566@
47=4 5012 34515167
4,<: 504 94,<74: =6;7249 86< 504 345151674< ,7:
34=1,9 =6;7249 86< <42367:475
24<D4: 56 <42367:475
06;?0 7651=4 12
04 <4B,174: ,C2475
3,<5 8<6B ;<?17? 24D4<,9 =6754751672
94,<74:
=6;7249 86< 504 345151674< =67547:4: 50,5 67 34<;2,9 68 504
-5-
=0,<?4 20445 B,54<1,92 76 68847=4 0,2 C447 B,:4 6;5 ,?,1725
504 345151674< ;7:4<
4=5167 + ,
68 504
3<624=;5167 8,194: 56 39,=4
17?<4:14752 68 504 68847=4 1 4
=5 217=4 504
B,54<1,92 56 3<6D4 504
, :4B,7: C ,==435,7=4 ,7:
= H6<@ 475<;25B475 6< H6<@ 347:17?
==6<:17? 56 01B ,5 76
36175
:4B,7:4:
51B4
345151674<
0,2
1994?,9
?<,5181=,5167 ,7: 504 =67D4<2,5167 ,994?4:9> <4=6<:4: C> 504
=6B39,17,75 :642 765 :12=9624 2;=0 =67D4<2,5167 ,2 25,54: 17
504 5<,3 B,0,J,< C> 504 7D4251?,5167
H157422
881=4< ,7: 504 3,7=0
4 8;<504< =67547:4: 50,5 504 5,1754: B674> H,2
,994?4:9> <4=6D4<4: 8<6B 504 5,C94 68 504 345151674<
0,7:2 68 504 345151674< H4<4 H,204: H150
269;5167
06;?0 504
6:1;B C1=,<C67,54
504 2,B4 :1: 765 5;<7 1756 317@ =696< ,2 <4A;1<4:
;<504< 504<4 H,2 76 H6<@ 68 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 475<;254: 56
504 ,==;24: :;<17? 5<,3 ,7: 504 <4=6<:2 H4<4 241J4: 8<6B ,
:1884<475 6881=4
7 2;=0 =1<=;B25,7=4 504 3<624=;5167 ;554<9>
8,194: 56 39,=4
B,54<1,92 56 3<6D4 504 :4B,7:
,==435,7=4 ,7: H6<@ 347:47=> C> 504 ,==;24:
%
4 ,926 =67547:4: 50,5 504<4 12 ,7 176<:17,54 :49,>
68 - :,>2 17 96:?17? 504 =6B39,175 C> 504 =6B39,17,75
504 245594: 36215167 68 9,H
2 34<
504 =6B39,175 0,2 56 C4 96:?4:
-6-
H15017 + :,>2 8<6B 504 :,54 68 :4B,7: 68 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167
,7: 504 =6B39,175 0,2 56 C4 A;,204: ,9674 H150 5012 ?<6;7:
,926 =67547:4: 50,5 4D47 18 504 ,994?,51672 B,:4 17 504
,7
=0,<?4 20445 ,<4 5,@47 ,5 5041< 8,=4 D,9;4 ,7: ,==4354: 17 5041<
4751<45> 504 2,B4 :6 765
=672515;54 ,7> 68847=4
,?,1725 504 ,==;24:
6 C;55<422 012 ,<?;B4752 04 <4914: 67
504 I;:?B4752 68 504
67GC94
47=0 68 5012
34K
6;<5 ,7: 504
6!6<:17,54
6;<5 ,2 ;7:4<.
<9
6 %'
' " :,54:
,7I;7,50, D2
5,54 C>
,7: 76504<
<9
'"+
,I; D2
76504<
<9
1D
,913 17?0 D2
<436<54: 17 ' '
6 '' '
6B,<,I; D2
'
:,54:
5,54 68
'
'
6@,>;@5,
<1
691=4
'
'
,<7,5,@,
<1
,7:
:,54:
& ' ' %
5,54 68 7:0<, <,:420
5,54 68
,7:
504<2
==6<:17?9> 04 3<,>2 56 ,996H 504 34515167
94,<74:
<42367:475
34=1,9 =6;7249 ,334,<17? 86<
633624: 504 34515167 C> =67547:17? 50,5 504<4
12 , =94,< :4B,7: 68 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 C> 504 345151674< ,7:
504 2,B4 12 <4=6<:4: 17 , D61=4 <4=6<:4< ,7: 504 =67D4<2,5167
-7-
C45H447 504 345151674< ,7: =6B39,17,75G2 H184 86;7: 17 504 3<4!
5<,3
3,7=0,7,B,
2,B4 :431=52
50,5
345151674<
:4B,7:4: 504 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 86< 5<,7284< 68 =6B39,17,75G2
H184
4 ,926 =67547:4: 50,5 504 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, 8;<504<
:431=52 50,5 C486<4 504 <,1: ,7 475<;25B475 3,7=0,7,B, H,2
=67:;=54: ,7: 3047693050,9417 36H:4< H,2 ,33914: 56 504
=;<<47=> 76542 ,7: 0,7:4: 6D4< 56 504 H184 68 504 =6B39,17,75
,7: 50624 =;<<47=> 76542 H4<4 <4=41D4: C> 504 ,==;24: 504
2,B4 H,2 241J4: C> 504
6@,>;@5,! 691=4 ,7: 0,7:2 68 504
,==;24: H4<4 H,204: H01=0 5;<74: 1756 317@ =696<
7 2;=0
=1<=;B25,7=4 ,==435,7=4 68 504 C<1C4 12 ,926 3<6D4:
;<504<
504 5<,7284< ,3391=,5167 68 504 H184 68 =6B39,17,75 H,2 @435 C>
504 345151674< 17 504 6881=4 68 504
019:
498,<4
43,<5B475
1:,<
43;5>
1<4=56<
6B47 ,7:
7 2;=0 =1<=;B25,7=4
=,7765 C4 2,1: 50,5 504 345151674< 0,2 B,:4 6;5 ,
=,24 56 A;,20 504 3<6=44:17?2
==6<:17?9> 04 3<,>2 56 :12B122
504 34515167
+
0,D4 ?1D47 B> ,7K16;2 =6721:4<,5167 C650 67 504
2;CB1221672 B,:4 C> 504 94,<74: =6;7249 86< 504 <4234=51D4
3,<5142 ,7: 34<;24: 504 :6=;B4752 B,:4 ,D,19,C94 C486<4 5012
6;<5
-8-
&
7 34<;2,9 68 504 =6B39,175 ,7: 504 =0,<?4 20445
B,54<1,92 15 =6;9: C4 ?,504<4: 50,5 504 =6B39,175 96:?4: C> 504
=6B39,17,75 86< :4B,7: 68 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 68
C> 504 345151674< H06 H,2 504
,5
68 =6B39,17,75G2 H184 8<6B
7?,7,H,:1
7?,7,H,:1
475<4
6 ' ' ,5
2 %' ''' !
;B7,C,: 86< 5<,7284<
;B7,C,:
475<4
6 +& 56
04 =0,<?4 20445
3,34< <4D4,92 50,5 504 :4B,7: B,:4 C> 504 ,==;24: 345151674<
0,D17?
C447
<4=6<:4:
,
D61=4
<4=6<:4<
,7:
=67D4<2,51672 86;7: 17 504 3<4!5<,3 3,7=0,7,B,
34<;2,9 68 504 2,B4 504<4 12 , =94,< :4B,7: 68
50624
7 =,<48;9
2 "' ''' ! C>
504 345151674< ,2 ,:D,7=4 C486<4 504 5<,7284< 68 =6B39,17,75G2
H184
;<504< 17 504 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, 15 12 =94,<9> 25,54: 50,5
17 504 3<4247=4 68 =6B39,17,75G2 H184
,7: 504
=6B39,17,75 3,7=0,2
691=4 6881=1,92 504 345151674< =,;?05 069: <4: 0,7:4:
,7: , 2;B 68
2 "' ''' ! H,2 <4=6D4<4: ,5 04< 1725,7=4 ,967?
H150 504 =04B1=,9 ,33914: =;<<47=> 76542 0,7:4: 6D4< 56 504
=6B39,17,75G2 H184 :;<17? 3<4!5<,3 3,7=0,7,B,
504 0,7:2 68 345151674< H4<4 H,204: H150
91A;1: H01=0 5;<74: 1756 317@ =696<
;C24A;4759>
6:1;B C1=,<C67,54
2 2;=0
<4D4,92 50,5 504 345151674< ,==4354: 504 C<1C4 ,B6;75 8<6B 504
=6B39,17,75G2 H184
-9-
-
6 :6;C5
504 <4=6<:2 34<5,1717? 56 5<,7284< 68
=6B39,17,75G2 H184 H4<4 765 17 504 6881=4 68 345151674< 06H4D4<
504 5<,3 3,7=0,7,B, :12=96242 50,5 50624 <4=6<:2 H4<4 @435 C>
504 345151674< 17 504 6881=4 68
4D4963B475
43,<5B475
43;5>
1<4=56<
6B47 ,7:
019:
1:,< 17 , H,<:<6C4 ,7: 504 2,B4
H,2 241J4: ,5 504 1725,7=4 68 345151674<
7 2;=0 =1<=;B25,7=4
,2 <1?059> =67547:4: C> 504 94,<74:
34=1,9 =6;7249 86< 504
<42367:475! 5,54 504<4 ,<4 2;881=1475
B,54<1,92 ,<4
39,=4: ,?,1725 504 345151674< ,C6;5 04< 17D69D4B475 17 504
=<1B4
'
06;?0
94,<74:
=6;7249
86<
345151674<
D404B4759> =67547:4: 50,5 504<4 12 , :49,> 17 81917? 504
=6B39,175 ,2 34<
4=5167 + , 68 504
=5 504<4 12 76 51B4
91B15 86< 81917? 504 =6B39,175
04 :49,> 17 81917? 504
,==6<:,7=4 H150
4=5167 &
68 504
56 5012 =,24
4=5167 & 12 86< 3;C91= 24<D,75 56 96:?4 ,
,2
=5 12 765 <494D,75
=6B39,175 ,?,1725 504 34<267 H06 17:;=42 504 3;C91= 24<D,75 56
,==435 1994?,9 ?<,5181=,5167 =6BB679> @76H7 ,2 E<4D4<24 5<,3F
67GC94
34K
17 504 =,24 68
!"# #$
#
%"# #$
- 10 -
049: 50,5 17 , =,24 <4?1254<4: 504 234=1,9 25,5;54 1 4
=5
, A;,2017? 68 504 68847=42 ;7:4< 504 2,1: ,=5 H6;9: 0,D4 ,
?<,D4 ,7: 2;C25,751,9 1B3,=5 765 I;25 67 504 3,<5142 17D69D4:
C;5 ,926 67 504 26=145> ,5 9,<?4
;<504<
67/C94
;3<4B4
&
<436<54: 17 #
+
$
+,
6;<5 17 =,24 68
' ()*
049: 17 3,<,?<,30
62 & ,7:
- ,2 86996H2.
!
"
#
$
#
"
!
%
&'
$
!#
& '
#
$
& '
%
$
"
$
$
! #
%
(
!
!
#
#
$
#
- 11 -
#
!
$
! )
#
!
*
#
$
#
!
!
%
+,
,
#
,
+ &
!#
!
!#
' -
#
%
!
"
!
$
!
%
$
"
$
$
$
%
%
*
#
%
$
%
$
"
#
$
$
- 12 -
%
#
%
"
$ %
,
!
.
$
,
!
%
!
#
-
$
,
-
!
$
$
,
/
!
#
*
!
$ #
$
!
#
#
,
!
$
$
$
!
$
!
!
!
!# !
- 13 -
)
#
$
$
# #
!
!
$
#
$
!
!
%
,
!
!
&
!
2 3
5066 7
; !
#
89:
$
&4 ' #
*"; &06= '
0'
<
"
$
!
!
$ $
#
$
$
#
!
$ ,
"
$
$
$
-
!
!
$
- 14 -
"
!
#
!
#
!
!
,
$
,
!
/
#
$
$
!
#
506697
&
;
>
= =
<
#
*"; &066='
;
?
5066:7 =
#
A9:
#
5066=7 A
>
<
#
B
5066A7
#
>
*"; &066='
#
86A
&? #
< % % #
>
# 1
;
506667 8
!
*"; &0666'
@
; %
< % % # >
>
>
(
6 8
(
:6'
"
$
!
!
!
$
/
$
-
!
- 15 -
%
$
#
!
!
$
$
!
!
!
C
#
$
#
,
#
#
!
"
&
'# 3
D
5066 7 8
80A
$
#
$
,
$
#
$
$
$
$
$
#
$
#
+&
!
'
- 16 -
$ #
E$
/
$
$
!
!
#
$
$
F
7 504 1725,75 =,24 ,2 :12=;224: 2;3<, 504 3<1B,<>
17?<4:14752 68 504 68847=4 ;7:4<
4=5167 + , 68 504
=5 12
B,:4 6;5 C> 504 3<624=;5167 ,7: 504 2,B4 0,2 56 C4 54254: 17
, :45,194: 5<1,9
6;<5 =,7765 =67:;=5 , B171 5<1,9 ,5 5012
25,?4 56 069: 50,5 H04504< 504 ,==;2,5167 B,:4 ,?,1725
345151674< H199 3<6D4 6< 765
20445 B,54<1,92
7 ,7 4751<4 34<;2,9 68 =0,<?4
,B 68 504 D14H 50,5 =67517;,5167 68 =<1B17,9
3<6=44:17?2 ,?,1725 504 345151674< ,==;24: H199 765 ,B6;75 56
,C;24 68 3<6=422 68
2,B4 12
6;<5
47=4 34515167 9,=@2 B4<15 ,7: 504
*
*(
$
6.
6 . "'
'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review