Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010681012022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3397]
MONDAY,THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF JUNE
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENUTHURUMALLI GOPALA
KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL NO: 75/2023
Between:
Smt.kasireddi Parvathamma and Others
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
Smt Vijaya and Others
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. U RAMANJANEYULU
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. GP FOR APPEALS
2. KAMBHAMPATI RAMESH BABU
The Court made the following:
...RESPONDENT(S)
Reserved on 08.05.2026
Pronounced on 15.06.2026
Uploaded on 15.06.2026
HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO
SECOND APPEAL No.75 of 2023
JUDGMENT:
This second appeal under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is
filed aggrieved by the judgment and decree, dated 03.11.2022, in A.S.No.86
of 2018, on the file of the II Additional District Judge, Madanapalle, reversing
the judgment and decree, dated 29.06.2018, in O.S.No.196 of 2010, on the
file of the Additional Senior Civil Judge, Madanapalle.
2.
The plaintiffs initiated action in O.S.No.196 of 2010, on the file of the
Additional Senior Civil Judge,Madanapalle, with a prayer to declare the
clauses 3 and 4 of the compromise decree as invalid, illegal and not binding
by setting the compromise decree accordingly declaring the rights of the
plaintiffs over the same; to divide the entire suit schedule property item Nos.1
to 8 and allot 2/5th share to the 2nd plaintiff and 1/10th share to the 1st plaintiff
by separate metes and bounds; to declare that the 1st plaintiff alone is entitled
for the pension benefits on the death of late Mr. Ramana Kumar Reddy by
directing the defendants 7 and 8 to pay the same to the 1st plaintiff Smt.
K.Parvathamma; and for costs of the suit.
3.
The learned Additional Senior Civil Judge, Madanapalle, partly decreed
the suit with proportionate costs. Felt aggrieved thereby, the unsuccessful
defendant Nos.1 to 4 in the above said suit filed the aforesaid appeal before
the First Appellate Court. The learned II Additional District Judge,
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
Madanapalle, partly allowed the appeal by setting aside the judgment and
decree passed by the learned trial Judge. Aggrieved thereby, the plaintiffs in
O.S.No.196 of 2010 approached this Court by way of second appeal.
4.
The appellants herein are the plaintiffs and the respondents herein are
the defendants in O.S.No.196 of 2010.
5.
For the sake of convenience, both parties in the second appeal will be
referred to as they are arrayed in O.S.No.196 of 2010 before the trial Court.
6. The case of the plaintiffs, in brief, as set out in the plaint averments in
O.S.No.196 of 2010, is as follows:
I.
The plaintiffs pleaded that the plaintiff No.1 is the legally wedded wife
and the plaintiff No.2 is the daughter of late Kasireddi Ramana Kumar
Reddy, S/o Venkata Reddy and the defendant No.1 was the kept
mistress of the deceased Ramana Kumar Reddy, and the defendant
Nos.2 to 4 are the children born through the defendant No.1 to the said
Ramana Kumar Reddy. The plaintiffs further pleaded that in view of
serious marital disputes between the plaintiff No.1 and late Ramana
Kumar Reddy on account of the interference of the defendant No.1 in
their matrimonial life, the plaintiffs instituted O.S.No.22 of 1993 on the
file of the Senior Civil Judge, Madanapalle, seeking maintenance, and
another suit in O.S.No.160 of 1990 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge,
Madanapalle, seeking partition and separate possession of the share of
the plaintiff No.2. The plaintiffs further pleaded that the trial Court
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
decreed the said suits on 27.07.1993, and certain reliefs claimed by
them were disallowed. Aggrieved thereby, the plaintiffs preferred an
appeal before the Composite High Court of Andhra Pradesh vide
A.S.No.2301 of 1999.
II.
The plaintiffs further pleaded that due to severe financial difficulties,
starvation, and mental agony, and being apprehensive about the future
and marriage prospects of the plaintiff No.2, they were compelled to
enter into a compromise before the Composite High Court of Andhra
Pradesh in the said appeal and signed the compromise papers without
knowing the realities of the same and late Ramana Kumar Reddy paid a
sum of Rs.50,000/- and further agreed to pay maintenance at the rate of
Rs.1,500/- per month to the plaintiff No.1 during his service and
Rs.1,100/- per month after retirement, besides paying a sum of Rs.400/per month to the plaintiff No.2 till her marriage. The plaintiffs further
pleaded that upon coming to know of the death of Ramana Kumar
Reddy, they rushed to the village and attended his funeral ceremonies.
At that time, defendant Nos.1 to 4 allegedly set up claims over the
properties of the deceased while denying the rights of the plaintiffs. The
plaintiffs further pleaded that the defendants relied upon certain clauses
in the compromise decree, which were heard by the plaintiffs for the first
time. The plaintiffs further pleaded that the marital tie between the
plaintiff No.1 and late Ramana Kumar Reddy was never dissolved by
divorce and late Ramana Kumar Reddy died intestate on 31.03.2010
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
due to head injuries and as such, the plaintiff No.1, being the legally
wedded wife, alone is entitled to receive the pensionary and other retiral
benefits payable by the Government.
III.
The plaintiffs further pleaded that late Ramana Kumar Reddy failed to
discharge his obligations under Clause No.9 of the compromise decree
and did not attend the marriage of the plaintiff No.2, which was
solemnized in the year 2004. The plaintiffs further pleaded that the
plaintiff No.1 had to incur debts amounting to nearly Rs.4,00,000/- for
conducting the marriage of the plaintiff No.2, and such debts are still
outstanding. The plaintiffs further pleaded that they are entitled to
succeed to the estate of late Ramana Kumar Reddy in accordance with
the law of succession and that the plaintiff No.2 is also entitled to
succeed as a coparcener. The plaintiffs further pleaded that any writing
or compromise contrary to statutory rights cannot deprive them of their
lawful succession rights. The plaintiffs further pleaded that the plaintiff
No.1, being the legally wedded wife of the deceased, is equally entitled
to succeed to the estate of late Ramana Kumar Reddy and alone is
entitled to claim pensionary and other death benefits. The plaintiffs
further pleaded that late Ramana Kumar Reddy constructed the house
described as item No.8 of the plaint schedule property out of the income
derived from the ancestral properties, but got the same nominally
registered in the name of defendant No.5, who is the mother of the
defendant No.1, with an intention to defeat the future claims of the
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
plaintiffs. The plaintiffs further pleaded that they came to know of the
said fact only after the death of late Ramana Kumar Reddy and,
therefore, item No.8 of the plaint schedule property is also liable to be
treated as ancestral property available for partition. Hence the suit.
7. The defendant Nos.1 to 4 filed the written statement and the defendant
Nos.8 and 9 also taken same plea in their written statement, which was taken
by the defendant Nos.1 to 4 in their written statement. The case of the
defendant Nos.1 to 4, 8 and 9, as set out in the written statement filed by the
defendant Nos.1 to 4 is as follows:
I.
The defendants pleaded that the suit is not maintainable either in law or
on facts and is liable to be dismissed. The defendants further pleaded
that the defendant No.1 is the legally wedded wife of late Kasireddy
Ramana Kumar Reddy and that defendant Nos.2 to 4 are his legitimate
children. The defendants further pleaded that the said aspects need not
be gone into once again in the present suit, since the evidence relating
thereto had already been adduced in O.S.No.160 of 1990 and
O.S.No.22 of 1991, which were decided by the Composite High Court of
Andhra Pradesh, at Hyderabad on 27.07.1993. The defendants further
pleaded that item No.8 of the plaint schedule property is the exclusive
self-acquired property of the defendant No.5 and that at no point of time
did the said property form part of the estate of late Kasireddy Ramana
Kumar Reddy. The defendants further pleaded that the defendant Nos.5
to 7 have been unnecessarily impleaded in the suit and, therefore, the
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
suit is bad for misjoinder of parties. The defendants further pleaded that
the frame of the suit is defective and the Court fee paid by the plaintiffs
is also incorrect.
II.
The defendants further pleaded that plaintiff No.1 voluntarily and
willingly abandoned the matrimonial company of late Kasireddy
Ramana Kumar Reddy and left his house along with the plaintiff No.2
on their own accord. The defendants further pleaded that they spent
substantial amounts for the medical treatment and care of late
K.Ramana Kumar Reddy during his illness out of love, affection, and
moral obligation. The defendants further pleaded that late Ramana
Kumar Reddy had paid substantial amounts and provided gold
ornaments to the plaintiff No.2 at the time of her marriage and that there
is no cause of action to file the present suit and there are no bonagides
in the suit and as such, the defendants prayed for dismissal of the suit
with costs.
8.
On the basis of above pledings, the learned trial Judge framed the
following issues for trial:
1) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for declaration that the clauses 3 and
4 of the compromise decree as invalid, illegal and not binding by setting
aside the compromise decree?
2) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for division and separate possession
of suit schedule property Items 1 to 8 and allot 2/5th share to 2nd plaintiff
and 1/10th share to 1st plaintiff?
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
3) Whether the 1st plaintiff is alone entitled for the pension benefits of
deceased Ramana Kumar Reddy?
4) Whether the Court fee paid is not correct?
5) Whether the suit is barred by law of limitation?
6) Whether the suit is hit by principles of “Respondent-judicata”?
7) Whether the suit is bad for non-joinder of item No.8 of the plaint
schedule property? and
8) To what relief?
9.
During the course of trial in the trial Court, on behalf of the plaintiffs,
P.Ws.1 and 2 were examined and Exs.A-1 to A-23 were marked. On behalf of
the defendants, D.Ws.1 to 3 were examined and Exs.B-1 to B-23 were
marked. Exs.X-1 to X-4 were also marked.
10.
The learned trial Judge after conclusion of trial, on hearing the
arguments of both sides and on consideration of oral and documentary
evidence on record, partly decreed the suit with proportionate costs. Felt
aggrieved thereby, the unsuccessful defendant Nos.1 to 4 filed the appeal suit
in A.S.No.86 of 2018, before the II Additional District Judge, Madanapalle,
wherein the following points came up for consideration:
1) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to seek the relief of declaring the
clauses 3 and 4 of the compromise decree as invalid, illegal and not
binding on the plaintiffs, before the trial Court? Or not?
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
2) Whether 1st defendant Vijaya is succeeded to get pension benefits of
late K.Ramanakumar Reddy? Or the plaintiff No.1 is alone entitled to
get the pension of late K.Ramanakumar Reddy?
3) Whether the impugned decree and judgment passed by the lower Court
warrants interference? Or not?
11.
The learned first appellate Judge after hearing the arguments,
answered the points and partly allowed the appeal by setting aside the
judgment and decree passed by the learned trial Judge. Felt aggrieved of the
same, the unsuccessful plaintiffs in O.S.No.196 of 2010 filed the present
second appeal before this Court.
12.
On hearing both sides‟ counsel at the time of admission of the second
appeal on 06.10.2023, a learned Judge of this Court admitted the second
appeal and framed the following substantial questions of law:
1) Whether the 1st defendant, who had living relationship with the
deceased Ramana Kumar Reddy, can be treated/upheld as wife of said
Ramana Kumar Reddy for getting family pension?
2) Whether the relationship of deceased Ramana Kumar Reddy with the
1st defendant during the subsistence of legally valid marriage with the
1st plaintiff, can be treated as husband and wife?
3) Whether the First Appellate Court is justified in upholding the 1st
defendant as wife under Section 64(1)(b) of Employees Provident
Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (Act No.19 of 1952),
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
Section 2G of the Employees Provident Fund Scheme, 1952 and Rule
2(v), Rule 25 of A.P. Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964?
4) When the 1st plaintiff sought three (3) distinct reliefs on different causes
of action and paid separate Court fees for it and the Court dismissed
one relief, can other reliefs be rejected without assigning the reasons?
5) When the terms and conditions of the Compromise Decree dated
28.03.1997 in A.S.No.2301 of 1997 on the file of this Court indicates
that those terms and conditions applied, operatable and binds on the
plaintiffs during the life time of Ramana Kumar Reddy in respect of
immovable properties, can the plaintiffs debarred to claim legitimate
share in the property of Ramana Kumar Reddy on his intestate death?
6) Whether the 1st plaintiff being legally wedded wife and the 2nd plaintiff
being legitimate daughter are entitled to claim share in the properties of
deceased Ramana Kumar Reddy on his intestate death?
7) When the suit is filed on separate causes of action arose after death of
Ramana Kumar Reddy and the previous suit in O.S.No.160 of 1990 on
the file of Court of Senior Civil Judge, Madanapalle operates resjudicata?
8) Whether the Court below is justified (First Appellate Court/II Additional
District Court, Madanapalle) relying the evidence of agent, when he is
not specifically authorized?
13.
Heard Sri O.Manohar Reddy, learned Senior Counsel, representing
Sri U.Ramanjaneyulu, learned Senior Counsel for the appellants, Sri Avinash
Amarnath, learned counsel, representing on behalf of the learned Government
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
Pleader for Appeals appearing for the respondent Nos.6 and 7 and Sri
Kambhampati Ramesh Babu, learned counsel for the other respondents.
14.
The law is well settled that under Section 100 of CPC, High Court
cannot interfere with findings of fact arrived at by first appellate Court, which is
final Court of facts, except in such cases where such findings were erroneous
being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law, or its settled position on the
basis of the pronouncement made by the Apex Court or based upon
inadmissible evidence or without evidence.
In the case of Bhagwan Sharma v. Bani Ghosh1, the Apex Court held
as follows:
“The High Court was certainly entitled to go into the question as to whether the
findings of fact recorded by the First Appellate Court which was the final Court of fact
were vitiated in the eye of law on account of non-consideration of admissible evidence
of vital nature.”
In the case of Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar 2,
the Apex Court held as follows:
“The High Court cannot substitute its opinion for the opinion of the First Appellate
Court unless it is found that the conclusions drawn by the lower appellate Court were
erroneous being contrary to the mandatory provisions of law applicable or its settled
position on the basis of pronouncements made by the Apex Court, or was based upon
inadmissible evidence or arrived at without evidence.”
15.
The learned Senior Counsel on behalf of the appellants would contend
that plaintiff No.1 being a legally wedded wife of late Ramana Kumar Reddy,
plaintiff No.2 being a legitimate daughter of late Ramana Kumar Reddy, are
entitled to claim a share in the properties of deceased Ramana Kumar Reddy
AIR 1993 SC 398
AIR 1999 SC 471
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
on his intestate death. Per contra, Sri Kambhampati Ramesh Babu, learned
counsel for the respondent Nos.1, 4, 8 and 9, would contend that the appellant
No.1 and late Ramana Kumar Reddy got separated and did not lead the
conjugal life from 1982 till the death of Ramana Kumar Reddy and late
Ramana Kumar Reddy married the respondent No.1 in the year 1984 as per
the Hindu Rites and Customs and three (03) children were born out of the said
marriage. He would further contend that appellants have filed a suit for
partition vide O.S.No.160 of 1990 and a suit for maintenance vide O.S.No.22
of 1991 against late Ramana Kumar Reddy and his mother before the
Subordinate Judge at Madanapally and the said suit was disposed of on
27.07.1993 and in A.S.No.2301 of 1993, the appellants entered into a
Compromise Decree and as per the Compromise Decree, in exchange for
payment of amounts, the appellants unconditionally relinquished their rights in
the property and retirement benefits of late Ramana Kumar Reddy.
16.
The undisputed facts are that the plaintiff No.1 is a legally wedded wife
of late Ramana Kumar Reddy and the plaintiff No.2 is the only daughter of the
plaintiff No.1 and Ramana Kumar Reddy and the marriage between the
plaintiff No.1 and late Ramana Kumar Reddy was performed on 25.09.1974
and the plaintiff No.2 was born to the plaintiff No.1 and Ramana Kumar Reddy
in the year 1977 and the plaintiff No.1 and late Ramana Kumar Reddy did not
live together and did not lead conjugal life since 1982 to till the date of demise
of Ramana Kumar Reddy in the year 2010, as per the own admissions of the
plaintiff No.1. The plaintiffs herein filed suits for partition in O.S.No.160 of
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
1990 and in O.S.No.22 of 1991 against Ramana Kumar Reddy and his mother
before the Subordinate Judge at Madanapally and the said suit was disposed
of on contest on 27.07.1993 and in the said suit in the appeal, the appellants
herein entered into a compromise with Ramana Kumar Reddy and they
received an amount of Rs.50,000/- from Ramana Kumar Reddy and
relinquished their rights in the properties and retirement benefits of Ramana
Kumar Reddy. Sri O.Manohar Reddy, learned Senior Counsel appearing on
behalf of the appellants, contended that the properties shown in the plaint
schedule are the ancestral properties and as on the date of the Compromise
Decree, the appellant No.2 being a coparcener is entitled to 50% share in the
joint family property. He would further contend that the 50% share in the joint
family was relinquished in favour of the father and by virtue of the said
relinquishment, the share with the father got by virtue of relinquishment
becomes his self-acquired property. He would further contend that after the
death of the father, the property standing in the name of the father would
devolve on the legal heirs under Sections 6 and 8 of the Hindu Succession
Act, 1956 and under Section 16 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. He would
further contend that the plaintiff No.2 would be entitled to half share in Item
Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule property and the remaining share has to be divided
between both the plaintiffs and the defendant Nos.2 to 4. He would further
contend that unfortunately the First Appellate Court has not taken into
consideration the same and no shares were allotted to both the plaintiffs in
Item Nos.1 to 7 of the plaint schedule property.
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
17.
As could be seen from the Compromise Decree, Clause No.3 of the
Compromise Decree reiterates as under:
3.
That the 2nd appellant has relinquished her rights in the properties
possessed by the schedule morefully described in the plaint schedule and the
respondent shall be entitled to the properties possessed by the family with
absolute right and title without any interference by the Appellants and he is at
liberty to deal with his properties as he likes.
18.
The contention of the plaintiff is that item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule
properties are the ancestral properties and admittedly, the plaintiff No.1 is not
having any right in the Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule property as on the date
of the Compromise Decree. The plaintiff No.2 being a coparcener, she is
having 50% share in the Item Nos.1 to 7 of the plaint schedule property and
her father Ramana Kumar Reddy was having the remaining 50% share in Item
Nos.1 to 7 of the Schedule property. As per clause No.3 of the Compromise
Decree, the plaintiff No.2 received an amount from her father and relinquished
her rights in the properties possessed in the schedule and further agreed that
her father shall be entitled to the properties possessed by the family with
absolute rights and title and without any interference by the appellants herein
and that he is at liberty to deal with the properties as he likes. The
Compromise Decree passed in A.S.No.2301 of 2003 is undisputed by the
appellants. Since the plaintiff No.2 relinquished her total rights in the said
properties and she has given liberty to her father to deal with all his properties
as he likes, therefore, in view of the relinquishment by the plaintiff No.2, the
Item Nos.1 to 7 of the Schedule Properties have become self-acquired
properties of Ramana Kumar Reddy and he is having absolute rights in the
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
said Item Nos.1 to 7 of the plaint schedule property and the said Ramana
Kumar Reddy died intestate on 31.03.2010. As noticed supra, the appellant
No.1 being the wife of late Ramana Kumar Reddy is not having any right in
the plaint schedule property by the date of passing of the Compromise
Decree.
19.
As could be seen from the evidence on record, the plaintiff No.1 and
Ramana Kumar Reddy did not lead the marital life since 1982. It is also the
admitted case of the plaintiff No.1 that herself and Ramana Kumar Reddy did
not lead the conjugal life since 1982 till the date of death of Ramana Kumar
Reddy i.e. on 03.01.2010 and without obtaining divorce from plaintiff No.1,
Ramana Kumar Reddy led marital life with the defendant No.1 Smt. Vijaya as
wife and husband and gave birth to three (03) children i.e. the defendant
Nos.2 to 4 in the suit proceedings before the trial court. As noticed supra,
Ramana Kumar Reddy died intestate in the year 2010. Therefore, the legally
wedded wife of Ramana Kumar Reddy i.e. the plaintiff No.1 herein, the plaintiff
No.2 being the daughter of Ramana Kumar Reddy and the plaintiff No.1, and
“the children of Ramana Kumar Reddy and the defendant No.1” are having
equal rights in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule property. No doubt, clause
No.4 in the Compromise Decree says that the plaintiff No.1/appellant No.1
shall not claim any share in the properties of late Ramana Kumar Reddy, but,
as on the date of the said Compromise Decree, the plaintiff No.1 herein was
not having any rights in the said property. Therefore, the question of
relinquishing her rights in the said property does not arise. In view of the
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
intestate death of her legally wedded husband, she is entitled to 1/5th share in
Item Nos.1 to 7 of the properties of Ramana Kumar Reddy on his intestate
death. By giving cogent reasons, the trial Court rightly held that the Item No.8
of the schedule property is the self-acquired property of the defendant No.5
and the defendant No.5 purchased the vacant site of Item No.8 of the
schedule property under a registered sale deed dated 13.05.1996, i.e. more
than twelve (12) years prior to filing of the suit and subsequently, she raised
constructions in Item No.8 of the suit schedule property and the present suit
for partition was filed in the year 2010.
20.
It was contended by the learned counsel for the respondents that
Ramana Kumar Reddy married the defendant No.1 in the year 1984.
Admittedly, there is no evidence on record to show that Ramana Kumar
Reddy married the defendant No.1 and the said defendant No.1 did not enter
into the witness box. It is undisputed that Ramana Kumar Reddy had not
obtained divorce from his legally wedded wife i.e. the plaintiff No.1 herein.
Therefore, the defendant No.1 is not entitled to any share in the property in
Item Nos.1 to 7 possessed by Ramana Kumar Reddy on his intestate death.
21.
Sri Kambhampati Ramesh Babu, learned counsel for the respondent
Nos.1, 4, 8 and 9, would contend that in view of relinquishment of share of
plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 in the earlier suit filed for partition, again the plaintiff
Nos.1 and 2 are not entitled to file another suit for partition of Item Nos.1 to 7
of the schedule property. As seen from the cause of action mentioned in the
present suit proceedings in the plaint itself, it was reiterated that the cause of
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
action to file the suit arose on 31.03.2010, when Mr. Ramana Kumar Reddy
died intestate by leaving the plaint schedule properties and the plaintiffs herein
got issued a legal notice to the defendant Nos.6 and 7 and the defendant
Nos.6 and 7 failed to give any reply and that the plaintiffs have filed the suit.
The cause of action for the present suit arose on 31.03.2010, when the legally
wedded husband of the plaintiff No.1 and the natural father of the plaintiff No.2
died intestate. Therefore, in view of the fresh cause of action, the present suit
for partition is maintainable.
22.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law of the
Hon‟ble Apex Court in Commissioner of Wealth tax, Kanpur, etc.
Appellants Vs. Chander Sen etc. Respondents3.
The facts and circumstances in the aforesaid case law are different to
the instant case.
23.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Ganta Appalnaidu Appellants Vs. Ganta Narayanamma and others
Respondents4, wherein the Composite High Court of Andhra Pradesh held as
follows:
“S.8 applies to all cases of intestacy of a male Hindu except those to which
Section 6 applies. S.6 applies to a male Hindu having at a time of his death
an interest in mitakshara coparcenary. Since it contemplates devolution of
coparcenary property by survivorship it postulates existence of coparcenary.
A coparcenary cannot consist of single individual. Under the proviso to the
section where a deceased leaves behind a coparcener and also a female heir
AIR 1986 Supreme Court 1753
AIR 1972 ANDHRA PRADESH 258
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
specified in class I of the Schedule to the Act the succession is not by
survivorship but by intestacy.”
24.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Savitri Amma Appellants Vs. Devki Amma and others Respondents 5 ,
wherein the High Court of Karnataka held as follows:
“Section 6 deals with devolution of coparcenery interest in the case of a male
Hindu dying after the Act, undivided in a Mithakshara coparcenery. It does not
deal with the devolution by inheritance of the separate property of a Hindu
male, which is governed by S. 8, followed by Ss. 9, 10, 11, 12 and 13. Nor
does it deal with devolution by inheritance of the property of a female Hindu
which is governed by Ss. 15 and 16 of the Act.”
25.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Satyanarain Mahto and other Appellants Vs. Rameshwar Mahto and
other Respondents6, wherein the High Court of Patna held as follows:
“Where a Hindu father who has separated from all his sons dies leaving
behind a widow, two daughters, one son and heirs of two predeceased sons,
S.8 and proviso to S.6 would apply to the succession of the coparcenery
property the deceased owned. The property has to be divided equally and
each set of heirs, has to take 1/6 share.”
26.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Rohit Chauhan Vs. Surinder Singh and Others7, wherein the Hon‟ble Apex
Court held as follows:
“Coparcenary property means the property which consists of ancestral
property and a coparcener would mean a person who shares equally with
others in inheritance in the estate of common ancestor. “Coparcenary” is a
narrower body than the Joint Hindu family and before commencement of
AIR 1982 KARNATAKA 67
2013 (9) Supreme Court Cases 419
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005, only male members of the family
used to acquire by birth an interest in the coparcenary property. A coparcener
has no definite share in the coparcenary property but he has an undivided
interest in it and one has to bear in mind that it enlarges by deaths and
diminishes by births in the family. It is not static.”
27.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law of the
Hon‟ble Apex Court in Bharatha Matha and Another Vs. R.Vijaya
Renganathan and Others8.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Sadhineni Rajani and another Vs. Sadhineni Hymavathi and others 9 ,
wherein the Composite High Court of Andhra Pradesh held as follows:
“Section 8 operates in cases where a Hindu male, not being a member of
coparcenary but holding property in his own right, dies. In such an event, the
devolution would be through succession in favour of this class-I heirs, and in
their absence to class-II heirs, and so on.”
28.
In the case at hand, it is undisputed that Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule
properties are ancestral properties. Admittedly, the plaintiff No.1 is not having
any right in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule properties as on the date of the
Compromise Decree. The plaintiff No.2 being a coparcener, she is having
50% share in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule property and her father Ramana
Kumar Reddy was having the remaining 50% share in the plaint schedule
property. As per Clause No.3 of the Compromise Decree, the plaintiff No.2
received an amount from her father and also gave a receipt and the plaintiff
No.2/daughter authorized her father to deal with the said property as he likes.
2010 (11) Supreme Court Cases 483
2012 (2) ALD 777
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
In view of relinquishment of her total rights in the said property i.e. Item Nos.1
to 7 by the plaintiff No.2, the Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule properties have
become self-acquired properties of her father Ramana Kumar Reddy and he
is having absolute rights in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule properties. It is
undisputed that the said Ramana Kumar Reddy died intestate on 31.03.2010,
by leaving his legally wedded wife i.e. the plaintiff No.1 and his natural
daughter i.e. the plaintiff No.2 and therefore, the plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are
entitled to 1/5th share in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the schedule property.
Furthermore, the defendant Nos.2 to 4, who are the children of late Ramana
Kumar Reddy, are also entitled to 1/5th share each in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the
plaint schedule property.
29.
The learned counsel for the respondents placed a case law in Elumalai
alias Venkatesan and Anr. Vs. M.Kamala and Others 10 , wherein the
Hon‟ble Apex Court held as follows:
“14. The property, i.e., „A‟ schedule, was not the ancestral property of Shri
Chandran. Shri Chandran would have acquired rights over the same only if
his father had died intestate. He was, thus, only a heir apparent. Transfer by
an heir apparent being mere spes successonis is ineffective to convey any
right. By the mere execution of Release Deed, in other words, in the facts of
this case, no transfer took place. This is for the simple reason that the
transferor, namely, the father of the appellants did not have any right at all
which he could transfer or relinquish. However, if his conduct was such that
he could be estopped then the execution of the Release Deed would imperil
his right and therefore cast an irremovable shadow on the claim of the
appellants as well unless we find merit in other submissions of Shri Siddharth
Iyer, learned counsel for the appellants.”
2012 (2) ALD 777
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
In the present case, admittedly, the plaintiff No.2 being a coparcener is
having equal rights in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the coparcenary property and she is
having half share only in the said property and she herself relinquished her
total coparcenary rights in the said property by receiving a substantial amount
from her father by giving liberty to her father to deal with the said properties as
his self-acquired properties and her father died intestate in the year 2010.
Therefore, the plaintiff No.1, who is the legally wedded wife of late Ramana
Kumar Reddy and the plaintiff No.2, who is the natural daughter of Ramana
Kumar Reddy and the plaintiff No.1, are entitled to 1/5th share each in Item
Nos.1 to 7 of the plaint schedule property. As stated supra, Item No.8 of the
schedule property is in no way concerned with the present suit proceedings
and it is the absolute property of the defendant No.5.
30.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants would contend that the
plaintiff No.1 is entitled to the death benefits of the deceased employee i.e.
gratuity and other benefits. As could be seen from the Compromise Decree
passed in A.S.No.2301 of 2003, the appellant No.1 herein agreed in the said
Compromise Decree that she shall not prefer any claim for any amount from
her husband and she is also not entitled to make any claim in the provident
fund and other family benefits to be received by her husband after his
retirement and both the appellants received an amount of Rs.50,000/- towards
full satisfaction of their claim in the year 1997 itself.
31.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants would contend that the
marriage between late Ramana Kumar Reddy and the defendant No.1 was
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
not proved and they are living as wife and husband for a long time and a
presumption is drawn that she is a second wife. He would further contend that
in view of Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, the second marriage
during the subsistence of the first marriage is void and the widow mentioned in
the Family Pension Rules can only be entitled to be treated as the legally
wedded wife and that the plaintiff No.1, who is the legally wedded wife alone is
entitled to the family pension. Per contra, Sri Kambhampati Ramesh Babu,
learned counsel for the respondent Nos.1, 4, 8 and 9, would contend that
since 1984 till the date of the death of Ramana Kumar Reddy, the defendant
Nos.1 to 4 have taken care of the needs and health of Ramana Kumar Reddy
till his demise and he lived in the house of the defendant Nos.1 to 4 and the
defendant No.1 is the second wife of late Ramana Kumar Reddy and the First
Appellate Court rightly awarded 50% monthly pension to the plaintiff No.1 and
the remaining 50% monthly pension to the defendant No.1. The learned
Government Pleader for Appeals would contend that Rule 50(8)(c) of the CCS
(Pension) Rules, 2021 states that when the deceased Government servant or
a pensioner is survived by more widows than one, the family pension shall be
paid to the widows in equal shares and on the death or ineligibility of a widow,
her share of the family pension shall become payable to her child or children
who fulfill the eligibility conditions mentioned in sub-rule 9.
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
32.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law of the
Hon‟ble Apex Court in Rampyari Bai Vs. Municipal Corporation and
Another11.
The facts and circumstances in the aforesaid case law are different to
the instant case.
33.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
State of Gujarat Through Chief Secretary and Others Vs. Savitri Devi 12,
wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court held as follows:
“6.
The question is whether mother is a dependent. In view of the express
definition of the family, mother has not been included as a member of the
family to claim any family pension from the Government, much less after the
maximum period of ten years. Under these circumstances, in either event, the
decree of trial court as affirmed by appellate court and second appeal, are
clearly illegal.”
But, the facts and circumstances in the aforesaid case are different to
the incident case.
34.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in G.L.
Bhatia Vs. Union of India and Another13, wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court
held as follows:
“The sole question that arises for consideration in this appeal is whether the
appellant, who happens to be the husband of the deceased government
servant, is entitled to family pension under the provisions of the Central Civil
1987 (Supp) Supreme Court Cases 263
(1996) 1 Supreme Court Cases 558
(1999) 5 Supreme Court Cases 237
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
Services (Pension) Rules (for short “the rules”) notwithstanding the fact that
the deceased wife in her nomination did not include the husband.”
The facts and circumstances in the aforesaid case laws are different to
the instant case.
35.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Smt. Violet Issaac and Others Vs. Union of India and Others 14, wherein
the Hon‟ble Apex Court held as follows:
“4.
…The Family Pension Scheme under the Rules is designed to provide
relief to the widow and children by way of compensation for the untimely
death of the deceased employee. The Rules do not provide for any
nomination with regard to family pension, instead the Rules designate the
persons who are entitled to receive the family pension. Thus, no- other
person except those designated under the Rules are entitled to receive family
pension. The Family Pension Scheme confers monetary benefit on the 'wife
and children of the deceased Railway employee, but the employee has no
title to it. The employee has no control over the family pension as he is not
required to make any contribution to it. The Family Pension Scheme is in the
nature of a welfare scheme framed by the Railway Administration to provide
relief to the widow and minor children of the deceased employee. Since, the
Rules do not provide for nomination of any person by the deceased employee
during his life time for the payment of family pension, he has no title to the
same. Therefore, it does not form part of his estate enabling him to dispose of
the same by testamentary disposition.”
36.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in Nitu
Vs. Sheela rani and Others 15 , wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court held as
follows:
(1991) 1 Supreme Court Cases 725
(2016) 16 Supreme Court Cases 229
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
“17.
It is pertinent to note that in this case the pension is to be given under
the provisions of the Scheme and therefore, only the person who is entitled to
get the pension as per the Scheme would get it. Similar issue had arisen
before this Court in the case of Violet Issaac (Smt.) v. Union of India (1991)
1 SCC 725 and after considering the relevant provisions, this Court came to
the conclusion that family pension does not form part of the estate of the
deceased and therefore, even an employee has no right to dispose of the
same in his Will by giving a direction that someone other than the one who is
entitled to it, should be given the same.”
37.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Union of India and another Vs. Lakshmi Suri16, wherein a Division Bench of
the Composite High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad held as follows:
“36.
Sub-clause (i) of clause (a) of sub-rule (7) enables the distribution of
family pension in equal shares among widows, only in cases where family
pension is payable to more widows than one. The expression used in the rule
is “where payable”. The question that arises in these cases is whether it is
payable at all. It is only if family pension is payable lawfully to someone that
the question of paying the same in equal shares under sub0rule (7) would
arise. The word “payable” clinches the issue.”
38.
The learned Senior Counsel for the appellants placed a case law in
Pramila Bai Vs. E.Rukmini Bai and another17, wherein a Division Bench of
the High Court of Telangana at Hyderabad held as follows:
“20.
With regard to the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant
about the name of the plaintiff being shown in the service records of late
Lakshman Rao as her nominee, a decision of the Division Bench of the
Andhra Pradesh High Court in Gettam Israil Vs Gettam Siromani & Ors.3,
answers the said contention.”
2018 (1) ALD 697 (DB)
2018 (1) ALD 697 (DB)
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
39.
In a case of Tulsa Devi Nirola v. Radha Nirola18, the Hon‟ble Apex
Court held as follows:
“10. Rule 35 (5) provides that for the purpose of Rules 36, 37 and 38, family in relation
to a government servant means wife or wives, including judicially separated wife. Rule
38 provides for nomination to be made by the government servant in Form 1 or 2 or 3
conferring on one or more persons, the right to receive death come retirement gratuity
that may be due to him. In view of the partition deed the deceased while filling his
nomination in the prescribed Form under Rule 38 mentioned the name of respondent
no.1 only as the sole beneficiary of family pension. We are of the considered opinion
that Rule 40(6) is conditional in nature and does not vest an automatic statutory right in
appellant no.1 to equal share in the family pension. The family pension would be
payable to more than one wife only if the government servant had made a nomination
to that effect and which option was open to him under the Pension Rules.
“40. Family Pension (6) (a) (i) Where the family pension is payable to more widows
than one, the family pension shall be paid to the widows in equal shares….”
11. The Pension Rules therefore recognize the nomination of a wife or wives for the
purpose of family pension. True, the family pension did not constitute a part of the
estate of the deceased. If the settlement deed had not been executed and acted upon
different considerations may have arisen. The right to family pension in more than one
wife being conditional in nature and not absolute, in view of nomination in favour of
respondent no.1 alone, appellant no 1 in the facts of the case can also be said to have
waived her statutory right to pension in lieu of benefits received by her under the
settlement deed. The deceased resided exclusively with respondent no.1 and
occasionally visited appellant no.1. The deceased was exclusively taken care of by
respondent no.1 during his illness including the expenditure incurred on his treatment.
In view of the statutory rules, it is not possible to accept the argument that respondent
no.1 was nominated only for purpose of receipt of the family pension and per force
was required to share it equally with appellant no.1.
12. In Vidhyadhari (supra), this Court accepted the claim of the second wife to receive
inter alia pension based on nomination since, like the present case, the deceased was
residing with the second wife to the exclusion of the first. The grant of succession
certificate to the second wife was held valid. However, to balance equities, this Court
granted 1/5th share to the first wife in the properties. We may have also considered
2020 SCC OnLine SC 283
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
the balancing the equities if the deceased had not executed a settlement deed with
regard to his movable and immovable properties and which was accepted and acted
upon by the appellant no.1.”
40.
In the case at hand, the plaintiff No.1, who is the legally wedded wife of
Ramana Kumar Reddy admitted in her evidence in cross-examination that she
got separated from her husband late Ramana Kumar Reddy in the year 1980
and she had not led any conjugal life with him since then till the death of her
husband. It was admitted by the plaintiff No.1 in her evidence that since 1984
till the death of Ramana Kumar Reddy, she did not lead the conjugal life with
Ramana Kumar Reddy. There was evidence on record that since 1984
onwards till the death of late Ramana Kumar Reddy, the respondent No.1
herein and her children cared for late Ramana Kumar Reddy and that late
Ramana Kumar Reddy faced health issues and the appellants herein did not
even visit him and did not take care of him throughout his life from 1984
onwards till the date of his death i.e. in the year 2010, which is approximately
twenty-six (26) years. Moreover, the defendant No.1's name was shown as a
nominee in the official pension records by late Ramana Kumar Reddy.
41.
The material on record clearly reveals that in the Form of Application for
Service Pension-Gratuity, the defendant Nos.1 to 4 are shown as the wife and
the children of deceased employee late Ramana Kumar Reddy and in PartII(b) of the sanction of pension orders, the defendant No.1 was shown as a
family pension beneficiary by the Pension Sanctioning Authority. Furthermore,
in Annexure-I, the joint photograph of Ramana Kumar Reddy and defendant
No.1 was affixed by the Head of Office and the same was attested by the
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
Head of the Office. The signature of the deceased employee and defendant
No.1 was taken by the Head of Office as defendant No.1 as a wife of late
Ramana Kumar Reddy and identification marks of both the deceased
employee and defendant No.1 were also noted. In the Annexure-II
Nomination, the defendant No.1 is shown as the wife by the deceased
employee in the Nomination Form in the presence of two (02) witnesses, who
are his colleagues i.e. junior lecturers in his college and they have attested the
Nomination Form, which was countersigned by the Head of Office. Rule 6(a)(i)
of the Andhra Pradesh Revised Pension Rules, 1980 reiterates as follows:
6(a)(i) Where the family pension is payable to more widows than one, the
family pension shall be paid to the widows in equal shares.
42.
In a case of Gaddam Ruth Victoria Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh,
Rep.by its Principal Secretary and Others19, wherein a Division Bench of
this Court by referring the case laws of the Hon‟ble Apex Court in
Vidhyadhari v. Sukhrana Bai (2008) 2 SCC 238; Tulsa Devi Nirola v.
Radha Nirola 2020 SCC OnLine SC 283; Badshah v. Urmila Badshah
Godse (2014) 1 SCC 188, a Division Bench of this Court held as follows:
“32. In view of the aforesaid judgments, we are of the considered view that in
such matters, even if it is found that the second wife does not acquire the
status of wife, for the marriage having been contracted during the subsistence
of the first marriage, still for the service benefits and service claims of the
deceased husband, she is entitled for protection. The endeavour of the
Courts has always been to balance the equities amongst two wives though
the second may not be understood in the strict sense as „wife‟, a legally
2023 SCC OnLine AP 1690
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
wedded. For balancing the equities, the Courts can pass appropriate orders
in favour of both the wives.
33. In the present case also, we have observed above and have found that
the first wife left the deceased Gaddam Danam in 1979, thereafter the
deceased Gaddam Danam got the service in 1980, he married the present
5th respondent during the subsistence of the first marriage with the petitioner.
There is nothing on record to show any customary divorce. On the other
hand, the divorce case was filed in the year 2011, but the same came to end
due to the death of Gaddam Danam during its pendency. There is also
nothing on record to indicate that during the long years, since 1979 till the
death of Gaddam Danam, the first wife ever took care of Gaddam Danam. It
was only for the first time in the year 2010 the claim for maintenance was filed
just before the retirement of Gaddam Danam, and for enforcement of such
claim of maintenance, as was granted, the order of attachment was passed in
2011 which was set aside by this Court, but the amount was directed to be
kept in abeyance till passing of fresh orders on matter having been remitted.
The three daughters were born out of the wedlock of Danam with the 5th
respondent, and even if it be taken that the marriage of 5th respondent is void
for the reason of having been solemnized during subsistence of first
marriage, the children would be legitimate. The 5th respondent resided with
the deceased Gaddam Danam since after her marriage and also attended
him during his illness for which the original medical bills were filed. During the
lifetime, Gaddam Danam also nominated her, of which there is entry in the
service book. Though that is disputed by the petitioner, being suspicious, and
even though in that respect an order of the Tribunal in the same O.A, dated
18.03.2016 is there, in which the Tribunal observed that such entry creates
an amount of suspicion, but, we are of the view that there is nothing on record
to show that the entry in the service record was forged. Merely because the
entry was made with different ink etc., and might have been seen with
suspicion by the Tribunal in its previous interlocutory order dated 18.03.2016,
but in passing the final order, such alleged suspicion did not prevail with the
Tribunal. It is settled in law that the suspicion, howsoever strong, it may be,
cannot take the place of proof. We are of the view that the entry in the service
records, when considered in the light of the undisputed fact that in the family
members details submitted by the deceased at the time of his pension
proposals, he gave the particulars of the 5th respondent and the three
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
daughters, it can be said that the deceased during his lifetime had nominated
the 5th respondent in the service records, and such an entry cannot give rise
to any suspicion. Filing of the divorce petition by Gaddam Danam against his
first wife, in 2011, is also indicative of the fact that he wanted that after his
death there may not arise any dispute, for the benefits in favour of the 2nd
wife and wanted to secure the interests of the 2nd wife and the children from
her, may be because the first wife started litigation against Gaddam Danam
for maintenance etc., in the year 2010.”
34.
…
35. Before we deal with the aforesaid submission of the learned counsel for
the petitioner, we would refer to the relevant provisions as hereinafter. We
observe that this provision Rule 50 is a beneficial provision in favour of
woman with whom the government employee contracts another marriage
during subsistence of the first marriage. This provision is therefore required to
be construed liberally to achieve its very object of the grant of family pension
after the death of the government employee in favour of and to the extent
reasonably possible to make available, both the wives, the family pension,
and none of them be deprived of the same, in particular to the 2nd wife with
whom the deceased government employee solemnized 2nd marriage during
subsistence of first marriage. The issue requires coinsideration from the view
point of social justice as well.
36 to 48.
.…
49. In our view, Rule 50 of the Rules, 1980 is with intend to give relief to the
woman becoming wife. Under such circumstances, even the wife from the
second marriage was made entitled for family pension, as the main object of
this rule was to give family pension to the wives i.e., more than one, and for
that reason, to clarify the expression „wife‟ used in Rule 50 (12) of the Rules,
1980, Circular Memo dated 11.09.1996 was issued providing that irrespective
of the personal Laws. The onlything that requires consideration is the
permission from the department for second marriage.
50. We have already referred to the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in
Vidhyadhari (supra) & Tulsa Devi Nirola (supra) that family pension is not the
estate of the deceased. The nominee shall be the sole beneficiary. If the
nomination is in favour of the second wife, she would be entitled to the family
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
pension and not merely for the purpose of receipt of the family pension. There
being nomination in favour of the 5th respondent by the deceased made
during his lifetime, as per the pension proposals, as also entry in the service
book, the 5th respondent would be entitled to family pension because of the
nomination, irrespective of the fact that there was no permission taken from
the department by the deceased government employee for second marriage.
The point of permission may become relevant, if the 2nd wife also claims
family pension, but there is neither permission for 2nd marriage to the
government employee nor nomination in favour of 2nd wife.
The facts in the aforesaid cases are similar to the facts of the present
case.
43.
In the present case, the plaintiff No.1 got separated from her husband in
the year 1982 and she did not lead any conjugal life with late Ramana Kumar
Reddy from 1982 onwards till the death of Ramana Kumar Reddy in the year
2010 and even, it was admitted by the natural wife of Ramana Kumar Reddy
i.e. the plaintiff No.1 that she got separated from late Ramana Kumar Reddy
in the year 1982 and she had not led any conjugal life with him since then.
Furthermore, there is evidence on record that since 1984 onwards till the
death of late Ramana Kumar Reddy, the respondent No.1 and her children i.e.
the defendant Nos.2 to 4, cared for late Ramana Kumar Reddy and Ramana
Kumar Reddy also faced health issues and the appellants did not even visit
late Ramana Kumar Reddy and the Respondent No.1 i.e. the defendant No.1,
cared for him throughout from 1984 onwards till the demise of late Ramana
Kumar Reddy in the year 2010 i.e. approximately twenty-six (26) years.
Moreover, the defendant No.1 herein was also shown as a nominee in the
official documents by late Ramana Kumar Reddy and the same was accepted
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
by the Head of the Office of late Ramana Kumar Reddy. As noticed supra, in
all official records, the defendant No.1 was shown as the wife of the deceased
employee, which was attested by the Head of the Office. On considering the
ratio laid down in the aforesaid case law of the Division Bench of this Court
and on considering the relevant material available on record, since, the
defendant No.1 led marital life with late Ramana Kumar Reddy for about
twenty-six (26) years and they lived as wife and husband and gave birth to
three (03) children i.e. the defendant Nos.2 to 4 herein and the plaintiff No.1
deserted the deceased employee from the year 1982 till the death of the
deceased employee in the year 2010 and the defendant No.1 only attended to
the deceased from 1984 onwards till his death including during the period of
his illness and she had taken care of the deceased, this Court is of the
considered view that the learned First Appellate Judge rightly held in its
judgment that the plaintiff No.1 and the defendant No.1 are equally entitled to
receive the monthly family pension of late Ramana Kumar Reddy.
44.
On considering the aforesaid circumstances and on considering the
ratio laid down in the aforesaid case laws, as noticed supra, this Court is of
the considered view that the plaintiff No.1, the plaintiff No.2, the defendant
Nos.2 to 4 are entitled to 1/5th share each in Item Nos.1 to 7 of the plaint
schedule property and the plaintiff No.1 and the defendant No.1 are equally
entitled to receive the monthly family pension of late Ramana Kumar Reddy.
Therefore, the monthly family pension of late Ramana Kumar Reddy shall be
paid to the plaintiff No.1 and the defendant No.1 herein in equal shares by the
VGKR, J.
SA_75_2023
defendant Nos.6 and 7. With the above observations, the second appeal is
allowed in part.
45.
In the result the second appeal is partly-allowed. Pending applications,
if any, shall stand closed. Each party do bear their own costs in the second
appeal.
__________________________
V. GOPALA KRISHNA RAO, J.
Date: 15.06.2026
SRT
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review