Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[1]
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.23 of 2021
Smt. Kalpana Marak (Chakraborty)
W/O- Sri Nayan Chakraborty,
Resident of Nandannagar (Marak Para),
P.S- New Capital Complex,
Agartala, West Tripura
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Majindra Marak,
S/O- Lt. Khidan Marak
2. Smt. Soma Marak (Chakraborty)@
Kaushalya Marak,
W/O- Sri Babul Chakraborty,
3. Sri Manindra Marak,
S/O- Lt. Majendra Marak
4. Sri Sudhan Marak,
S/O- Lt. Lutish Marak
5. Sri Swapan Marak,
S/O- Lt. Raichan Marak
6. Sri Sailendra Marak,
S/O- Sri Jamendra Marak
All are resident of Nandannagar (Marak Para),
P.S.- New Capital Complex, Agartala, West Tripura.
---Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Samar Das, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Rathor, Advocate
Ms. Ranasree Pal, Advocate
Date of hearing and
Delivery of Judgment & Order
:
03.05.2023
Whether fit for reporting
:
Yes
[2]
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
The present second appeal is directed against the judgment
and decree dated 02.09.2021, passed in T.A. No. 53 of 2017 by the Ld.
District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala upholding the judgment and
decree dated 26.10.2017, passed in TS No.105 of 2015 by learned Civil
Judge (Senior Division), West Tripura, Agartala.
2.
The facts, as projected by learned Trial Court, may be
produced here-in-below:“Brief
facts leading to this suit is that one
Majindra Marak was the owner in possession of a land measuring
1.89 acres under mouja-Indranagar and a land measuring 1.06
acres under mouja- Debendra Chandranagar. Said Majindra
Marak died leaving behind five legal heirs namely Nirendra
Marak, Samir Marak, Manindra Marak, Sachindra Marak and
Kaushilya Marak. After the death of Majindra Marak all the
above five legal heirs have made partition of the entire
aforementioned land on the strength of registered deed of
partition bearing No. 1-1514, dated 07.02.2005 and thereby
demarcated and alloted their respective shares by metes and
bounds with proper measurement. As a result of said partition one
of the legal heirs namely Sachindra Marak got a land measuring
0.89 acres including the suit land at Mouja- Indranagar and 0.36
acres at Debendra Chandranagar. Sachindra Marak died on
18.07.2007 leaving behind his wife Jatila Das (Marak) and his
minor son Sumit Marak. After the death of Sachindra Marak both
of them having inherited the property made partition of it
amicably on the strength of registered deed of partition bearing
No. 1-3207 dated 16.04.2015 and as a result of partition Jatila
Das got the suit land and thereby she sold it to the plaintiff on the
strength of registered sale deed bearing No. 1-3472, dated
[3]
28.04.2015. Accordingly, the plaintiff applied for having mutation
which is still under process. Immediately after purchase the
plaintiff has been cultivating the suit land by growing crops and
also by raising bamboo fencing surrounding the suit land. All the
defendants, however, creating disturbance demanding illegal
money from the plaintiff. Allegedly on 28.06.2015 in the morning
the defendants broke and threw some portion of bamboo fencing.
Not only that on 22.07.2015 at about 6 pm the defendants further
broke down the boundary fencing with a view to encroach the suit
land but the plaintiff somehow managed to resist the defendants.
The husband of the plaintiff also lodged a complaint in this regard
in writing with the GB Police outpost under New Capital Complex
Police Station. Even after lodging complaint, on 28.09.2015 all
the defendants further made attempts to encroach the suit land
when husband of the plaintiff managed to resist them and as such
the defendants could not be succeed. Situating thus the plaintiff
approach this court to have a declaration of her title over the suit
land along with consequential relief for perpetual injunction as
stated above.
2.1
On the basis of aforesaid facts, the learned trial court had
framed following issues:“ (i) Is the suit maintainable in its present form and nature ?
(ii) Has the plaintiff any cause of action to file the instant suit?
(iii) Has the plaintiff right, title and interest over the suit land?
(iv) Is the plaintiff in possession of the suit land? If so, is the
plaintiff entitled to an order of perpetual injunction, as
sought for?
(v) Is the plaintiff entitled to a decree, as prayed for?
(vi) What other relief/ reliefs the plaintiff is entitled to?
2.2.
In support of their respective cases, the plaintiff and the
defendants had introduced the following documents:“(i)
Authenticated copy of khatian bearing No.11301 of Mouja
Indranagar (Exbt-1).
(ii) Original copy of registered sale deed bearing No. 1-3472,
dated 28.04.2015 in five pages (Exbt-2).
[4]
(iii) Certified copy of khatian bearing No. 9456 of Mouja
Indranangar (Exbt-3).
(iv) Photo copy of registered deed of partition bearing No. 13207, dated 13.04.2015 in five pages (Exbt-4).
(v) Original copy of death certificate of Sachindra Marak
(Exbt-5) (subject to objection by defendant).
(vi) Original copy of survival certificate of Sachindra Marak
(Exbt-6) (subject to objection by defendant).”
2.3.
The first two issues have been decided in favour of the
plaintiff. Both the courts below held that it is an admitted fact that the
suit land along with other land was originally belonged to one Majindra
Marak. It is further observed by the courts below that there is no
dispute that Jatila Das had transferred the suit land to the plaintiff on
the strength of registered sale deed bearing no. I-3472, dated
28.04.2015.
2.4.
The defendants, however, challenged the competency of the
vendor (Jatila Das) of the plaintiff in transferring the suit land to the
plaintiff on the following grounds:“(i) That, the deed was executed in violation of section 187 of TLR
and LR Act;
(ii) That, the source of acquiring title by Jatila Das vide deed of
partition bearing No. 1-1514 was executed keeping two of legal
heirs of Majindra Marak beyond the partition deed;
(iii) That, Jatila Das obtained survival certificate showing her as
wife of Sachindra Marak. Simultaneously she has been receiving
family pension of Manindra Marak being the wife. Jatila Das also
further sworn an affidavit declaring her and her son to be the wife
and son respectively of Manindra Marak vide affidavit dated
06.02.2006 sworn before notary public.”
[5]
2.5.
Both the courts below had raised serious suspicion in respect
of the fact that whether Jatila Das is the real wife of late Sachindra
Marak or Manindra Marak. It is an admitted position that both
Sachindra and Manindra belong to tribal community, but it is not the
case of the defendants that the suit land had been transferred to a
person belonging to non-tribal community. Both the courts held that
the plea taken by the defendants has an embargo in transferring the suit
land in favour of the plaintiff is devoid of any merit.
2.6.
It is further held that the property left by the original owner,
Majindra Marak was partitioned on the strength of a registered
partition deed between his 5(five) legal heirs including Sachindra
Marak. Majindra Marak had also 2(two) daughters, but they were not
included in the partition deed.
2.7.
On consideration of the overall facts, both the courts held that
Jatila Das, who is the vendor of the sale deed, had failed to prove her
identity and status as the wife of late Sachindra Marak. For the reasons
that some documents, like the Bank account lying with the State Bank
of India and electricity bill, suggest that she is the wife of Manindra
Marak and not wife of Sachindra Marak.
2.8.
Learned trial court held that it surfaced from the evidence
that Jatila Das had been maintaining dual identity being the wife of
Sachindra Marak as well as the wife of Manindra Marak. In this
[6]
situation, the court held that in absence of any cogent evidence as to
the status of Jatila Das as either wife of Sachindra or Monindra, it can
be easily said that Jatila Das had no competency to transfer the suit
land in favour of the plaintiff by way of executing a registered sale
deed and the said document is not enforceable in law. On the basis of
this finding, the learned trial court held that Jatila Das had no right, title
and interest over the suit property while transferring the said land in
favour of the plaintiff and, therefore, the plaintiff has no right, title and
interest over the suit property and he is not entitled to have an order of
perpetual injunction.
2.9.
Accordingly issue nos. (iii), (iv), (v), (vi) and (vii) has been
answered in negative and dismissed the suit.
2.10.
The first appeal being preferred against the said judgment
and decree passed by learned trial court, the learned District Judge,
West Tripura, Agartala came to a similar finding as that of the learned
trial court regarding the issues formulated by the trial court and
accordingly, dismissed the first appeal.
3.
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the said judgments
and decrees passed by the courts below dismissing the suit, the plaintiff
has preferred the present second appeal before this Court.
4.
At the time of admission of this appeal, following substantial
questions of law have been formulated:-
[7]
“I. Whether on a prayer for perpetual injunction the title deed
and mutation record be ignored having disute in vendors
identity?
II. Whether without challenging the Deed of Sale and partition
deed of vendor, the sanctity of title be ignored?
III. Whether the Ld. Court below appreciated the title deed of
Appellant (Exbt-2) and Partition Deed (Exbt-4) in the light
of Section 44 of T.P Act?”
5.
I have heard Mr. D. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. Samar Das, learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiff/appellant. Also heard Mr. P. Rathor, learned counsel
appearing for the defendant/respondents.
6.
Mr.
Bhattacharya,
learned
senior
counsel
for
the
plaintiff/appellant has contended that the sanctity of the partition deed
(Exbt.-4) as well as the sale deed (Exbt.-2) executed by Jatila Das in
favour of plaintiff/appellant cannot be challenged unless and until these
two documents are cancelled by a competent court and both the
documents stand good till the declaration that these two documents are
void ab initio and non est. Mr. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel has
further submitted that there is no record in the instant suit that the
Khatians created in favour of Jatila Das had been challenged or
cancelled by the competent authority. He has further argued that there
is no proof that Jatila Das had transferred minor’s property. To
substantiate this submission, Mr. Bhattacharya, learned senior counsel
has tried to persuade this court that there is a registered partition deed
[8]
executed between Jatila Das, the wife of Sachindra Marak and Sumit
Marak, being their only son and on the strength of this partition deed,
Smt. Jatila Das had sold a portion of her share in favour of the plaintiff,
Smt. Kalpana Marak (Chakraborty).
Learned senior counsel has further contended that both the
courts below have decided the suit on different connotations and has
totally been misdirected. Learned senior counsel has drawn the
attention of this Court as regards the survival certificate issued by the
competent authority in favour of Jatila Das and Sumit Marak, being
wife and son of late Sachindra Marak. Mr. Bhattacharya, learned senior
counsel has urged this Court to allow this appeal dismissing the
judgments and decrees passed by the courts below.
7.
On the other hand, Mr. Rathor, learned counsel for the
defendant/respondents has submitted that both the courts below have
rightly held that the plaintiff has miserably failed to establish the
source
of
title.
According
to
learned
counsel
for
the
defendant/respondents, Jatila Das is not the wife of late Sachindra
Marak, because in the statement of account lying with the State Bank
of India and from electricity bills, it clearly reveals that the name of the
husband of Jatila Das has been recorded as Manindra Marak and not as
Sachindra Marak. In the pension document also, the name of Manindra
Marak has been written as the husband of Jatila Das.
[9]
Learned counsel for the defendant/respondents has strongly
submitted that neither the partition deed nor the sale deed has been
proved in accordance with law. Mr. Rathor, learned counsel has led
much emphasis on the point that Jatila Das had sold her minor son’s
property without taking guardianship certificate from the competent
court and it is settled law that minor’s property cannot be transferred in
any manner whatsoever and any such transfer should be declared as
void ab initio and non est.
Mr. Rathor, learned counsel has also submitted that from the
two sale deeds under Exbt. F and G respectively, it comes to fore that
Jatila Das had executed the sale deeds for a land which measures in
excess of the land which she obtained as inheritor of the deceased
Sachindra Marak.
8.
I have given my thoughtful considerations to the submissions
advanced by the learned counsel appearing for the parties. It is settled
proposition of law that the court while exercising its jurisdiction under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure will confine itself within
the substantial question of law formulated by the court.
8.1
During the course of hearing, none of the learned counsel has
proposed any other substantial question of law. As such, this court has
proceeded to dispose of the present case on the basis of the substantial
questions of law as already had been formulated by this Court. The first
[10]
substantial question of law that “whether on a prayer for perpetual
injunction the title deed and mutation record be ignored having dispute
in vendors identity?”. The answer of the substantial question of law
should be in negative. As long as the title deed as well as the record of
right created in favour of a person stand good, the prayer for granting
of perpetual injunction cannot be ignored. Till today, there is no record
before this Court that title deed executed in favour of the plaintiff and
record of right created in favour of her have been declared as void ab
initio and non est. As such, it is held that plaintiff is entitled to get a
decree of perpetual injunction on the basis of title deed and the record
of right created in favour of her.
8.2.
The second substantial question of law that “Whether
without challenging the Deed of Sale and partition deed of vendor, the
sanctity of title be ignored?”. In my opinion, the answer of the
substantial question also should be in negative. There is no record
before this Court that the defendant/respondents in this suit have ever
raised objection by way of counter claim that the sale deed executed in
favour of the plaintiff and the record of right created in favour of her
have been challenged and claimed to be cancelled the same. Unless and
until, it is challenged and on the basis of such challenge if the said
documents are not cancelled, then it should be treated as good in the
eye of law and the sanctity of these documents cannot be ignored.
[11]
9.
I have taken into consideration the submission of learned
counsel appearing for the plaintiff/appellant that the sale deed has not
been proved in accordance with law. During the course of hearing, I
put a specific question to Mr. Rathor, learned counsel for the
defendant/respondents whether the sale deed was produced before the
court in original is a primary document or not. Learned counsel has
firmly submitted that it being a document of primary evidence is
admissible in evidence.
This question has been raised in so many appeals as regards
evidentiary value of such a document even if it is exhibited.
10.
In the instant case, when the sale deed (Exbt.-2) has been
introduced
in
evidence
and
marked
as
exhibit,
the
defendant/respondents has not raised any objection regarding the mode
of proof of the said sale deed or to be brought it into the evidence. In
the opinion of this Court, in this circumstance, the party, that is the
defendant/respondents here-in, who have disputed the document, i.e.
the sale deed, as a whole, then, such objection must be raised at the
earliest point of time when such deed was introduced in evidence
before the trial court.
11.
The Privy Council in the case of Padman Vrs. Hanwanta,
AIR 1915 PC 111, [SCC OnLine PC 21] did not permit the appellant
to take objection to the admissibility of a registered copy of a Will in
[12]
appeal for the first time. It was held that this objection should have
been taken in the trial court. Further, it was observed that:- [AIR p.112]
“The defendants have now appealed to His majesty in Council,
and the case has been argued on their behalf in great detail. It
was urged in the course of the argument that a registered copy
of the will of 1898 was admitted in evidence without sufficient
foundation being laid for its admission. No objection, however,
appears to have been taken in the first Court against the copy
obtained from the Registrar’s office being put in evidence. Had
such objection been made at the time, the District Judge, who
tried the case in the first instance, would probably have seen
that the deficiency was supplied. Their Lordships think that
there is no substance in the present contention.”
“21.
In this regard, I may again fortify myself from a
decision of Privy Council rendered in Bhagat Ram Vrs. Khetu
Ram & Anr., 1929, SCC OnLine PC 5: AIR 1929 PC 110,
where their Lordships held that when no objection is taken to
the admissibility of a document at the trial, it is not necessary to
consider whether the document was admissible under
the law. Similar view was expressed in the case of Dol Govinda
Das Vrs. Makbul Sekh’s infant heir and Ors., 1935 SCC OnLine
Cal 142: AIR 1936 Cal. 164] that objection has to be raised at
the earliest opportunity as envisaged under Section 5 of the
Evidence Act. The said principle of law was further followed by
Hon’ble Supreme Court in P.C. Puroshothama Reddiar Vrs. S.
Perumal, 1972 (1) SCC 9: AIR 1972 SC 608.
22. In the instant case, admissibility of the certified copy of the
sale deed dated 21.04.1980 has not been challenged and only
the mode of proof of the certified copy of the said sale deed has
been challenged alleging the same to be irregular or
insufficient. In the former case, mere marking the document as
“an exhibit” shall not exclude the aggrieved party from raising
objection regarding its admissibility even at a subsequent stage
or even in appeal or revision, but, in the latter case, when the
admissibility of the document is not challenged and it is
allowed to be brought on record, then, objection to the mode of
[13]
proof cannot be raised at a later stage as a matter of rule of
fair play. Order 13 Rule 4 CPC provides for every document
admitted in evidence in the suit being endorsed by or
on behalf of the court, which endorsement signed or initialed by
the Judge amounts to admission of the document in evidence.
An objection to the admissibility of the document should be
raised before such endorsement is made and the court is
obliged to form its opinion but the question of admissibility and
express the same on which opinion would depend the document
being endorsed as admitted or not admitted in evidence. The
crucial test is whether an objection, if taken at the appropriate
point
of
time, would have enabled the party tendering the evidence to
cure the defect and resort to such mode of proof as would be
regular. The omission to object becomes fatal because by his
failure the party entitled to object allows the party tendering the
evidence to act on an assumption that the opposite party is not
serious about the mode of proof. On the other hand, a prompt
objection does not prejudice the party tendering the evidence,
for two reasons; firstly, it enables the Court to apply its mind
and pronounce its decision on the question of admissibility then
and there; and secondly, in the event of finding of the Court on
the mode of proof sought to be adapted going against the party
tendering the evidence, the opportunity of seeking indulgence of
the court for permitting a regular mode or method of proof and
thereby removing the objection raised by the opposite party, is
available to the party leading the evidence. Such practice and
procedure is fair to both the parties. Out of the two types of
objections, referred to here- in-above, in the latter case, failure
to raise a prompt and timely objection amounts to waiver of the
necessity for insisting on formal proof of a document, the
document itself which is sought to be proved being admissible
in evidence. In the first case, acquiescence would be no bar to
raising the objection in a superior court. [Ref: (2003) 8 SCC
752,
R.V.E.Venkatachala
Gounder
Vrs.
Arulmigu
Viswesaraswami & V.P. Temple & Anr.]
12.
Applying the aforesaid principle of law enunciated by the
above authoritative decisions, I may easily come to the conclusion that
[14]
if the objection is not raised at the earliest by the time when the
document was introduced in evidence, then the party opposing the
admission of these documents cannot raise objection at a later stage.
13.
In view of the above discussions on this point of law, I do
not find any merit in the submission of learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the defendant/respondents challenging the mode of proof at
the second appellate stage. Accordingly, this submission is repelled.
As a corollary, the sale deed and the record of right till today
stands good in favour of the plaintiff/appellant.
14.
The third substantial question of law is that “Whether the Ld.
Court below appreciated the title deed of Appellant (Exbt-2) and
Partition Deed (Exbt-4) in the light of Section 44 of T.P Act?”
At the outset, I should refer to Section 44 of TP Act which
reads as under:“44. Transfer by one co-owner--Where one of two or more
co-owners of immovable property legally competent in that
behalf transfers his share of such property or any interest
therein, the transferee acquires, as to such share or interest,
and so far as is necessary to give effect to the transfer, the
transferor’s right to joint possession or other common or part
enjoyment of the property, and to enforce a partition of the
same, but subject to the conditions and liabilities affecting, at
the date of the transfer, the share or interest so transferred.
Where the transferee of a share of a dwelling-house
belonging to an undivided family is not a member of the family,
nothing in this section shall be deemed to entitle him to joint
possession or other common or part enjoyment of the house.”
[15]
14.1.
It is admitted position that partition deed amongst the legal
heirs of the original owner, i.e., Majindra Marak had been executed and
registered, though two daughters of Majindra Marak being his legal
heirs have not been included in the partition deed. But till today, that
partition deed has not been challenged by those two daughters and
unless and until this partition is cancelled, such partition deed stands
good and as long as it stands good, the source of title of the co-owner
cannot be challenged. The defendants in the suit are the beneficiaries of
the partition deed. They have not challenged the said partition deed by
way of any counter claim. In view of this, Section 44 of the TP Act will
come into play. Since the partition deed stands good, which is the
source of title of Smt. Jatila Das being the wife/inheritor of the coowner, i.e. late Sachindra Marak is valid in the eye of law till today and
on the strength of this valid deed, Jatila Das had transferred the suit
land in favour of the plaintiff/appellant and after such transfer the
plaintiff/appellant has created a record of her right without any
objection from any co-owner including the defendants, in view of this,
the title has been divested to the plaintiff. The plea taken by the learned
first appellate court that, the sale deed, i.e. Exbt.-2 is liable to be
treated
as illegal and void ab initio is only misdirected and
unwarranted for the reason that minor has not come forward to
challenge the said sale deed. Moreso, there is specific averment that
there is a partition of the total land which has been inherited to Jatila
[16]
Das and Sumit Marak due to the death of Lt. Sachindra Marak in equal
shares and Jatila Das had sold the land from her share. There is no
evidence or there is no issue framed by the courts below whether Jatila
Das had sold that land in excess of her share. As such, this court sitting
in second appeal will not enter into this fact in question.
15.
In the light of above, in my opinion, the plaintiff is entitled to
get a decree of declaring right, title and interest over the suit land and
also a decree of perpetual injunction. Accordingly, it is ordered that the
plaintiff has acquired right, title and interest over the suit property and
she is entitled to get a decree of perpetual injunction. Accordingly, it is
ordered that the defendants are permanently and perpetually restrained
from interfering with the peaceful possession of the plaintiff over the
suit land.
Accordingly, the instant second appeal stands allowed. As a
corollary, the judgments and decrees passed by the learned courts
below as afore-stated, stand set aside and quashed.
Draw a decree accordingly.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed.
Send down the LCRs.
JUDGE
Rohit
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review