The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. I have heard the counsels and have gone through the records as well as the Law relevant for the purpose and this Court finds the following: (i) The petitioner was admittedly, a Post Graduate Teacher appointed in the school by order dated 06.11.1995 after which her service was regularized and she was working in the said school since then. (ii) She being the senior most teacher in the school after three numbers of teacher, who had crossed the eligibility criteria for being allowed to act as an Incharge Principal, was allowed for the same. (iii) It is not her fault that she went on leave during the order when it was issued, i.e. on 19.07.2025, and when she came back after the period of her leave, she found both the orders, i.e. Order dated 19.07.2025, when she was allowed to work as an In-charge Principal and Order dated 27.08.2025, when that order was kept in abeyance. (iv) It is further seen that the order allowing her to serve as the In-charge Principal of the school was passed by the Director of Secondary Education, Assam and the letter that was written alleging that she had taken leave a number of times and that another teacher would be more suited for the post was by the president of SMDC of the said school. (v) It is also seen that the said letter was in the form of a request for Page No.# 7/8 review of the approval given for appointing the petitioner as Principal In-charge…
22. As such, the order dated 27.08.2025, is quashed by this Court and as a natural corollary the petitioner should be allowed to join as an In-charge Principal of the said school. Further, the Director of Education is given the liberty to proceed against the petitioner if any misconduct is found on her part as per law. Further the Director of Education is also ordered to conduct the selection and appointment of Regular Principal of Higher Secondary School as per the Act without any delay so that the eligible participants do not get over aged for such consideration with time.
23. The writ petition stands disposed of. Comparing Assistant
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010262152025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6920/2025
SMT KAKOLI DEB
W/O SRI SANJIB DAS, SUBJECT TEACHER (LOGIC AND PHILOSOPHY), PM
SHRI JUDHISTHIR SAHA H.S. SCHOOL, BEHARA BAZAR, DIST- CACHAR,
ASSAM, PIN-788817
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 2 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM,
DEPARTMENT OF SCHOOL EDUCATION, DISPUR, GUWAHATI, PIN-781006
2:THE DIRECTOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILLIPARA
GUWAHATI - 781019
3:THE INSPECTOR OF SCHOOL
CDC
CACHAR
SILCHAR
ASSAM
PIN-78800
Advocate for the Petitioner
G J SHARMA
: MR M CHANDA, MR. R GHOSH,MS. K BHATTACHARYYA,DR
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, SEC. EDU.,
Page No.# 2/8
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MRS. JUSTICE SHAMIMA JAHAN
ORDER
Date : 19.06.2026
Heard Mr. G. J. Sharma, the learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. B.
Kaushik, the learned standing counsel for the Secondary Education Department.
2.
By this application the petitioner has endeavoured to invoke the extra
ordinary jurisdiction of this court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
for a writ in the nature of Certiorari for setting aside the order dated
27.08.2025, by which the order appointing the petitioner as In-charge Principal
of PM-Shri Judhisthir Saha HS School, Behara Bazar, District-Cachar (Assam),
was kept in abeyance. The petitioner has also prayed for a writ in the nature of
mandamus, directing the respondents to give effect to the order dated
19.07.2025, by which the petitioner was allowed to act as a Principal In-charge
of the said school. A prayer is also made to appoint the petitioner as a regular
Principal in the said school against any available vacancy.
3.
The case of the petitioner is that she was appointed as a subject teacher
of Logic and Philosophy in PM-Shri Judhisthir Saha HS School, Behara Bazar,
District-Cachar (Assam), by order dated 06.11.1995 and in pursuant to the said
order, the petitioner has joined the said school on 13.11.1995 and her services
was also regularized by order dated 23.09.1999 and since then, the petitioner
has been working as the subject teacher in the said school.
4.
It is also stated by the petitioner that although she was mentioned as the
Assistant Teacher of the said school in few documents but she is the Subject
Teacher, i.e. the Post-Graduate Teacher of the school.
Page No.# 3/8
5.
She further states that during her service career in the said school, a
Seniority List, dated 18.06.2025 was prepared wherein she was placed as Serial
No. 4.
6.
It is the further case of the petitioner that while she was serving as the
Subject Teacher of the said school, the principal of the school retired during the
year 2021 and since then the post of principal was lying vacant. Subsequently,
by order dated 19.07.2025, the petitioner was allowed to act as a Principal Incharge of the said school along with the financial power to draw and disburse
the salary etc. of the staff of the school in addition to her normal duties as
Teacher under F.R.-49(C). It is stated that pursuant to the retirement of the
Principal of the said school as stated above, the Inspector of School was holding
the In-charge Principal of the said school and thereafter, the petitioner was
allowed to act as such.
7.
The petitioner further states that she was on leave when that order was
passed allowing her to join as a In-charge Principal and that before she could
join as Principal In-charge, an order was passed by the Director of Secondary
Education Assam on 27.08.2025, by which the earlier order dated. 19.07.2025,
allowing the petitioner to hold the post of In-charge Principal of the said school
was kept in abeyance till further order. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner
had filed a representation to the Director of Secondary Education Assam, on
08.09.2025, but till date she did not get any response, and as such, she filed
the instant case before this court.
8.
During the pendency of the instant petition, respondent no. 2 filed the
affidavit-in-opposition and in the same, a letter was annexed dated 22.07.2025,
by which, the President of School Management & Development Committee had
Page No.# 4/8
intimated the Director of Secondary Education, Assam that keeping in view the
public interest, he recommends another existing academic In-charge, namely,
Nirupam Nath, to be appointed as an In-charge Principal of the said school. In
the said letter, it was also intimated that petitioner although had the right to go
on leave but the petitioner was stated to have enjoyed both Child Care Leave
(CCL) as well as Earned Leave several times and since the school has a high
enrolment of students, the president of SMDC had expressed his opinion that it
was necessary to appoint an individual, who could render best possible service
to the said school. The respondent no. 2, apart from annexing the letter had
also stated in the affidavit that to maintain administrative decorum of the school
the order dated 27.08.2025 was issued.
9.
It is also stated in the affidavit that after keeping the order dated
19.07.2025, in abeyance, the Inspector of School, was given the charge of
Principal of the said school.
10.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner has
been working in the school as a Post-Graduate Teacher since the date of her
appointment to the best of her capacity and that she was appointed as the Incharge Principal of the said school. He submits that calling back the order
appointing her as In-charge Principal and keeping it in abeyance was without
any authority of law. He submits that the petitioner had taken leave both CCL
and EL but then those were taken by the petitioner only after applying and after
getting the permission from the appropriate authorities. As such, there cannot
be any misconduct on the part of the petitioner and the same cannot be a
ground for keeping the order allowing her to act as In-charge Principal in
abeyance.
Page No.# 5/8
11.
To substantiate his argument, he has referred to the notification issued on
7th of April, 2025, wherein, the provisions relating to Child Care Leave as well as
Earned Leave were mentioned. He has also placed Section 12 of Assam
Secondary Education (Provincialised Schools) Rules, 2018, wherein, it is
provided that both seniority and eligibility will be seen while giving appointment
to the principal of the school and by showing a Judgment of this Court rendered
in “Bikash Upadhyaya Vs. State of Assam” rendered by this High Court in
Writ Petition No. 2122/2023, he submits that the requirement provided for in
appointment of a regular principal should be also followed during appointment
of In-charge Principal of any school. He as such, submits that the petitioner
being senior to the other candidates was rightly allowed to hold the post of Incharge Principal of the said school.
12.
He further, submits that the teachers, who were senior to the petitioner as
shown in the seniority list had crossed the age limit of 57 years and as such,
they having become ineligible, the petitioner was the only eligible teacher to be
appointed in the said post.
13.
On the other hand, Mr. B. Kaushik, the learned standing counsel for the
Secondary Education Department submits that the letter relied on by the
respondent no. 2, was not in derogatory of the petitioner’s service to the school
but it was only relied with the view to make the school run in the best possible
manner. He further submits that while appointing In-charge Principal of the
school, the norms that are usually followed is that the teacher should be senior
to other candidates.
14.
He also submits that it is an admitted position that the petitioner had
taken leave both CCL and EL a number of times and it is only for the betterment
Page No.# 6/8
of the school that the said order was kept in abeyance by respondent no. 2. He
also submits that petitioner had not gone and join as the Principal In-charge of
the school and that no rights had accrued to her in view of the Order dated
19.07.2025.
15.
I have heard the counsels and have gone through the records as well as
the Law relevant for the purpose and this Court finds the following:
(i)
The petitioner was admittedly, a Post Graduate Teacher appointed in
the school by order dated 06.11.1995 after which her service was regularized
and she was working in the said school since then.
(ii)
She being the senior most teacher in the school after three numbers of
teacher, who had crossed the eligibility criteria for being allowed to act as an Incharge Principal, was allowed for the same.
(iii)
It is not her fault that she went on leave during the order when it was
issued, i.e. on 19.07.2025, and when she came back after the period of her
leave, she found both the orders, i.e. Order dated 19.07.2025, when she was
allowed to work as an In-charge Principal and Order dated 27.08.2025, when
that order was kept in abeyance.
(iv) It is further seen that the order allowing her to serve as the In-charge
Principal of the school was passed by the Director of Secondary Education,
Assam and the letter that was written alleging that she had taken leave a
number of times and that another teacher would be more suited for the post
was by the president of SMDC of the said school.
(v)
It is also seen that the said letter was in the form of a request for
Page No.# 7/8
review of the approval given for appointing the petitioner as Principal In-charge
of the said school and it can by stretch of reasoning be the basis for keeping in
abeyance the order by which the petitioner was allowed to hold the post of Incharge Principal of the said school. If any misconduct is seen in case of the
petitioner an entire procedure is provided for under the rules.
(vi) It is also seen that the petitioner had taken leave in the nature of Child
Care Leave or the Earned Leave after duly applying and obtaining the
permission from the authorities. The respondent had also not stated in the
affidavit about any misconduct of the petitioner.
(vii) Further, it is already settled by this court that the criteria applicable for
appointment to the post of regular principal of the school should be made
applicable even in cases of appointment of In-charge Principal of the school and
in the said rules, both eligibility and seniority should be taken care of and the
detail procedure is provided for appointment to the post of Principal which is by
way of a direct recruitment but in case of appointment of In-charge Principal the
normal criteria followed as could be seen from the case laws is that of seniority.
In view of the same, the petitioner being found senior in the school was allowed
to hold the post of In-charge principal.
(viii) On the other hand, Mr. Nirupam Nath, whose name was recommended
by the SMDC was at Serial No. 7, of the seniority list, i.e, after three candidates
from the petitioner. Furthermore, the teachers appearing above the petitioner
have crossed the 57 years of age for appointment to the post of regular
principal which again should be considered while allowing teachers to hold the
post of In-charge Principal of the school.
Page No.# 8/8
22.
As such, the order dated 27.08.2025, is quashed by this Court and as a
natural corollary the petitioner should be allowed to join as an In-charge
Principal of the said school. Further, the Director of Education is given the liberty
to proceed against the petitioner if any misconduct is found on her part as per
law. Further the Director of Education is also ordered to conduct the selection
and appointment of Regular Principal of Higher Secondary School as per the Act
without any delay so that the eligible participants do not get over aged for such
consideration with time.
23.
The writ petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review