Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.67 of 2024
1.
Smt. Kajali Debbarma
W/O Shri Mangal Debbarma.
2.
Shri Mangal Debbarma
S/O Late Nitai Debbarma.
Both of Village – Mongchu Mog Para,
P.O. – South Takma,
P.S. – Santirbazar,
Belonia, South Tripura.
Presently residing at Matarbari,
P.S – R. K. Pur,
Udaipur, Gomati Tripura.
------ Claimant-Appellants
Versus
1.
Shri Rajib Debbarma
S/O Shri Biswa Debbarma,
Resident of Village – Mongchu Mog Para,
P.O. – South Takma,
P.S. – Santirbazar,
Belonia, South Tripura.
(Owner-cum-driver of TR-08-C-8765, Motor Bike).
2.
Reliance General Insurance Company Ltd.,
Ashram Chowmuhani, Agartala,
P.S. – East Agartala,
District – West Tripura,
(Insurer of TR-08-C-8765, Motor Bike).
------ Opposite Party-Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. I. Chakraborty, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Ms. R. Majumder, Adv,
Mr. B. Banerjee, Adv,
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
02.12.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
07.12.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 173 of M.V. Act is preferred by
the appellant-claimant petitioners challenging the judgment and
award dated 17.05.2024 delivered by Learned MAC Tribunal
No.1,
Gomati
District,
Udaipur
in
connection
with
case
No.TS(MAC) No.71 of 2021 for enhancement of the amount of
compensation awarded by the Learned Tribunal below. By the
said judgment and award, Learned Tribunal below has awarded a
sum of Rs.16,22,000/- along with 7.5% interest per annum from
the date of filing the claim petition i.e. w.e.f. 08.08.2021 to till
the date of actual payment and it was also ordered that the
appellant-claimant petitioners will equally get the amount.
Learned Tribunal below by the said judgment and award also
fastened the liability of payment of compensation upon the O.P.
No.1 i.e. Rajib Debbarma (owner of Motor Bike bearing No. TR08-C-8765.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. I. Chakraborty appearing
on behalf of the appellant-claimant petitioners and also heard
Learned Counsel, Mr. B. Banerjee and Learned Counsel, Ms. R.
Majumder representing the respondent-owner-cum-driver of
the vehicle/Motor Bike bearing No. TR-08-C-8765 and also
heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Bhattacharjee appearing on behalf
of the respondent-Insurance Company.
3.
In
course
appellants-claimant
Learned
Tribunal
of
hearing,
petitioners
below,
the
Learned
submitted
Counsel
that
appellant-claimant
for
the
before
the
petitioners
adduced oral/documentary evidence on record in support of their
claim but the Learned Tribunal below only awarded sum of Rs.
16,22,000/- which was too less.
Learned Counsel further submitted that 50% of the
amount was deducted towards the personal living expenses of
the deceased as the deceased was bachelor which was not
permissible in the eye of law. So, Learned Counsel for the
appellants urged for allowing this appeal by setting aside the
judgment and award dated 17.05.2024 delivered by Learned
Tribunal below.
4.
Learned Counsel for the owner-cum-driver of the bike
submitted
that
the
alleged
policy
was
covered
under
a
‘Comprehensive/package policy’ but the Learned Tribunal below
determined the case under ‘Act Policy’ and at the time of delivery
of judgment, fastened the liability of payment of compensation
upon the O.P.-owner-cum-driver of the bike.
5.
Learned
Counsel
for
the
Insurance
Company
also
submitted that the Learned Tribunal below after considering the
oral/documentary evidence on record rightly and reasonably
delivered the judgment/award.
6.
I have heard argument of both the sides and also
perused the judgment delivered by Learned Tribunal below.
7.
In this case, the appellants-claimant petitioners filed an
application before the Learned Tribunal with the plea that on
11.03.2021 at about 15:30 hours when their son Birat Debbarma
(since
dead)
was
proceeding
towards
South
Takma
from
Birchandra Nagar by boarding in a bike bearing No.TR-08-C8765 which was being driven by one Rajib Debbarma and on the
way, when they reached the approached road of Pada Para,
suddenly a dog crossed the road in front of the bike and the rider
tried to save the dog but dashed it against a pillar by the side of
the road and as a result of which, both the riders sustained
injuries on their persons and soon after the accident, the son of
the claimant-petitioners was taken to Hospital at Birchandra
Nagar from where considering the gravity of the injury he was
referred to District Hospital, Santirbazar where the attending
doctor declared him as dead. It was further stated that the
deceased was a young, energetic boy of 24 years and he was a
student of B.A. 3rd year and used to do private tuition from which
he used to earn Rs.15,000/- per month.
8.
On the basis of that accident, one police case vide
No.07/2021 was registered at Santirbazar P.S. under Section
279/338/304A of IPC with Section 184 of M.V. Act and
accordingly, the appellant-claimant petitioners filed the claim
petition.
9.
Before the Learned Tribunal below, the owner-cum-
driver of the bike bearing No.TR-08-C-8765 appeared and
contested the same by filing written statement denying the
assertions of the claim petition. It was asserted that there was
no fault on the part of the rider of the motor bike. It was also
stated that the bike was duly insured with O.P. No.2 w.e.f.
19.06.2020 to 18.06.2021 and the vehicle had all the valid
documents like registration certificate and other connected
documents and the rider had valid driving licence.
10.
The Insurance Company as O.P. No.2 also contested the
case by filing written statement denying the entire assertions of
the
claimant
petitioners
in
the
claim
petition
and
finally
submitted that the claim petition was subjected to strict proof.
11.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, four numbers of
issues were framed by Learned Tribunal below which were as
follows:
Issues
1) Whether Birat Debbarma sustained injuries in a
road
traffic
accident
that
occurred
on
11.03.2021 at around 15:30 hours at Pada Para
under Santirbazar Police Station involving
vehicle bearing No.TR-08-C-8765 (Motor Bike)
and subsequently on that day itself he
succumbed to his injuries at Santirbazar
Hospital;
2) Whether the accident caused due to rash and
negligent driving of driver of the said vehicle;
3) Whether the claimant-petitioners are entitled to
get compensation; if so, what will be the just
amount of compensation and who is/are to pay
the same?
4) To what
entitled?
12.
other
relief/reliefs
is
the
parties
To substantiate the issues from the side of the claimant
petitioners,
one
witness
was
examined
and
the
claimant
petitioners relied upon some documents which were marked as
Exhibits in the case which are as follows:
1. Certified copy of FIR, ejahar, post-mortem report
and final report (total 16 sheets) – Ext.1(I to XVI),
2. Copy of Aadhar Card
(compared with original),
of
deceased
–
Ext.2
3. Copy of identity card of deceased – Ext. 3
(compared with original),
4. Copy of PRTC of deceased – Ext.4 (compared with
original),
5. Copy of admit card of deceased – Ext.5 (compared
with original),
6. Copy of death certificate of deceased – Ext.6
(compared with original),
7. Copy of Aadhar Card of petitioner No.1 – Ext.7
(compared with original),
8. Copy of ration card – Ext.8 (compared with
original)
13.
From the side of the claimant petitioners, another
witness Debjit Murasingh was produced who was also examined
as PW-2.
14.
The O.P. No.1 was examined as O.P.W-1 and he adduced
few documents for marking exhibits which were marked as
Exhibits.
1. Registration Certificate – Ext. A,
2. Driving Licence – Ext.B and
3. Insurance policy certificate – Ext.C.
15.
Finally, on conclusion of enquiry, Learned Tribunal below
allowed the claim petition by the said judgment and award. The
operative portion of the said judgment and award runs as
follows:
Order
“29. The instant application under Section 166
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 filed by the
claimant-petitioners is hereby partly allowed
and a sum of Rs.16,22,000.00 (Rupees Sixteen
Lac Twenty Two Thousand) only is awarded in
favour of claimant-petitioners as compensation
for the death of late Birat Debbarma, in a Road
Traffic Accident, as aforesaid, and thus whole
amount of compensation shall be paid by OP
No.1, Rajib Debbarma, owner of TR-08-C-8765
(Motor Bike) within a period of one month from
today. The aforesaid amount shall carry
interest @ 7.5% per annum to be paid from the
date of filing of claim-petition, i.e., from
08.10.2021 till the date of payment. The
petitioners
shall
get
the
amount
of
compensation equally i.e. each of them shall
get Rs.8,11,000.00.
30. In the event of deposit of the Awarded
amount with interest, Rs.2,00,000.00 shall be
released in favour of each of the claimantpetitioners out of their respective shares, in
their respective bank accounts for enabling
them to meet necessary expenses and the rest
amount shall be kept in numbers of fixed
deposit schemes each with Rs.2,00,000.00 in
any Nationalized Bank for five years in their
name separately as per their share.
31. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted in
the fixed deposit account nor joint name shall
be allowed nor any cheque book , ATM card can
be issued against fixed deposit account.
However the interest to be credited in the fixed
deposit may be released in favour of the claimpetitioners, as per Bank’s norms.
32. Let a copy of this Award be furnished to the
parties through their Ld. Counsels, for
information.
33. The case is thus disposed of on contest.
Enter the result in the relevant Register.
34. The case is thus disposed of on contest.”
16.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides.
Admittedly, in this case, there was no dispute on record in
respect of the fact of accident on the alleged day and also the
fact of death of the deceased (pillion rider). The claimantpetitioners although asserted that the deceased was a student
and he was earning Rs.15,000/- per month but in this regard,
they could not adduce any cogent evidence on record. So, in my
considered view, Learned Tribunal below rightly after considering
all the factors determined the monthly income of the deceased at
Rs.10,000/-. However, as the deceased was a pillion rider and
Learned Tribunal below on perusal of Exbt.C came to the
observation that the policy was under ‘Act policy’ as no additional
payment was paid for the pillion rider and relying upon the
judgments, United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Shimla v. Tilak
Singh and others reported in (2006) 4 SCC 404, Oriental
Insurance Company Limited v. Sudhakaran K V reported in
(2008) 7 SCC 428, Learned Tribunal below fastened the liability
of payment of compensation upon the O.P.-owner-cum-driver as
pillion rider was not entitled to get any benefit under the Act
policy.
17.
In this regard, Hon’ble Supreme Court of India National
Insurance Company Ltd. V. Balakrishnan and another
reported in (2013) 1 SCC 731 wherein in para Nos.24, 25 and
26 observed as under:
“24. It is extremely important to note here that
till 31-12-2006 the Tariff Advisory Committee
and,
thereafter,
from
1-1-2007
IRDA
functioned
as
the
statutory
regulatory
authorities and they are entitled to fix the tariff
as well as the terms and conditions of the
policies issued by all insurance companies. The
High Court had issued notice to the Tariff
Advisory Committee and IRDA to explain the
factual position as regards the liability of the
insurance companies in respect of an occupant
in
a
private
car
under
the
“comprehensive/package policy”. Before the
High Court, the competent authority of IRDA
had stated that on 2-6-1986, the Tariff
Advisory Committee had issued instructions to
all the insurance companies to cover the pillion
rider of a scooter/motorcycle under the
“comprehensive policy” and the said position
continues to be in vogue till date. It had also
admitted that the “comprehensive policy” is
presently called a “package policy”. It is the
admitted position, as the decision would show,
the earlier Circulars dated dated 18-3-1978 and
2-6-1986 continue to be valid and effective and
all insurance companies are bound to pay the
compensation in respect of the liability towards
an
occupant
in
a
car
under
the
“comprehensive/package policy” irrespective
of the terms and conditions contained in the
policy. The competent authority of IRDA was
also examined before the High Court who
stated that the Circulars dated 18-3-1978 and
2-6-1986 of the Tariff Advisory Committee
were incorporated in the Indian Motor Tariff
effective from 1-7-2002 and they continue to
be operative and binding on the insurance
companies. Because of the aforesaid factual
position, the Circulars dated 16-11-2009 and 312-2009,
that
have
been
reproduced
hereinabove, were issued.
25. It is also worthy to note that the High
Court, after referring to individual circulars
issued
by
various
insurance
companies,
eventually stated :2011 ACJ 1415 (Del)
thus:(Yashpal Luthra case(supra), ACJ p.1424,
para 27)
“27. In view of the aforesaid, it is clear
that the comprehensive/package policy of
a two-wheeler covers a pillion rider and
comprehensive/package
policy
of
a
private car covers the occupants and
where the vehicle is covered under a
comprehensive/package policy, there is
no need for the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal to go into the question whether
the insurance company is liable to
compensate for the death or injury of a
pillion rider on a two-wheeler or the
occupants in a private car. In fact, in view
of the TAC’s directives and those of the
IRDA, such a plea was not permissible and
ought not to have been raised as, for
instance, it was done in the present case.”
26. In view of the aforesaid factual position,
there is no scintilla of doubt that a
“comprehensive/package policy” would cover
the liability of the insurer for payment of
compensation for the occupant in a car. There
is no cavil that an “Act policy” stands on a
different
footing
from
a
“comprehensive/package
policy”.
As
the
circulars have made the position very clear and
IRDA, which is presently the statutory
authority, has commanded the insurance
companies
stating
that
a
“comprehensive/package policy” covers the
liability, there cannot be any dispute in that
regard. We may hasten to clarify that the
earlier pronouncements were rendered in
respect of the “Act policy” which admittedly
cannot cover a third-party risk of an occupant
in
a
car.
But,
if
the
policy
is
a
“comprehensive/package policy”, the liability
would be covered. These aspects were not
noticed in Bhagyalakshmi v. United Insurance
Company Ltd.:(2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 87 and,
therefore, the matter was referred to a larger
Bench. We are disposed to think that there is
no necessity to refer the present matter to a
larger Bench as IRDA, which is presently the
statutory authority, has clarified the position by
issuing circulars which have been reproduced
in the judgment by the Delhi High Court and we
have also reproduced the same.
18.
Further, Hon’ble Apex Court in Jagtar Singh alias Jagdev
Singh v. Sanjeev Kumar & Ors. reported in (2018) 15 SCC 189
in para Nos.2 and 3 observed as under:
2. It is submitted by Mr Yadunandan Bansal,
learned counsel appearing for the appellant
that the controversy is covered by the twoJudge Bench decision in National Insurance Co.
Ltd. V. Balakrishnan:(2013) 1 SCC 731, wherein
the Court has held thus: (SCC pp.743-44, paras
24-26)
“24. It is extremely important to note here
that till 31-12-2006 the Tariff Advisory
Committee and, thereafter, from 1-1-2007
IRDA functioned as the statutory regulatory
authorities and they are entitled to fix the
tariff as well as the terms and conditions of
the
policies
issued
by
all
insurance
companies. The High Court had issued notice
to the Tariff Advisory Committee and IRDA to
explain the factual position as regards the
liability of the insurance companies in
respect of an occupant in a private car under
the “comprehensive/package policy”. Before
the High Court, the competent authority of
IRDA had stated that on 2-6-1986, the Tariff
Advisory Committee had issued instructions
to all the insurance companies to cover the
pillion rider of a scooter/motorcycle under
the “comprehensive policy” and the said
position continues to be in vogue till date. It
had also admitted that the “comprehensive
policy” is presently called a “package
policy”. It is the admitted position, as the
decision would show, the earlier Circulars
dated the admitted postion, as the decision
would show, the earlier Circulars dated 18-31978 and 2-6-1986 continue to be valid and
effective and all insurance companies are
bound to pay the compensation in respect of
the liability towards an occupant in a car
under the “comprehensive/package policy”
irrespective of the terms and conditions
contained in the policy. The competent
authority of IRDA was also examined before
the High Court who stated that the Circulars
dated 18-3-1978 and 2-6-1986 of the Tariff
Advisory Committee were incorporated in the
Indian Motor Tariff effective from 1-7-2002
and they continue to be operative and
binding
on
the
insurance
companies.
Because of the aforesaid factual position, the
Circulars dated 16-11-2009 and 3-12-2009,
that have been reproduced hereinabove,
were issued.
25. It is also worthy to note that the High
Court, after referring to individual circulars
issued by various insurance companies,
eventually stated :2011 ACJ 1415 (Del)
thus:(Yashpal
Luthra
case(supra),
ACJ
p.1424, para 27)
“27. In view of the aforesaid, it is clear
that the comprehensive/package policy of
a two-wheeler covers a pillion rider and
comprehensive/package
policy
of
a
private car covers the occupants and
where the vehicle is covered under a
comprehensive/package policy, there is
no need for the Motor Accidents Claims
Tribunal to go into the question whether
the insurance company is liable to
compensate for the death or injury of a
pillion rider on a two-wheeler or the
occupants in a private car. In fact, in view
of the TAC’s directives and those of the
IRDA, such a plea was not permissible and
ought not to have been raised as, for
instance, it was done in the present case.”
26. In view of the aforesaid factual position,
there is no scintilla of doubt that a
“comprehensive/package
policy”
would
cover the liability of the insurer for payment
of compensation for the occupant in a car.
There is no cavil that an “Act policy” stands
on
a
different
footing
from
a
“comprehensive/package policy”. As the
circulars have made the position very clear
and IRDA, which is presently the statutory
authority, has commanded the insurance
companies
stating
that
a
“comprehensive/package policy” covers the
liability, there cannot be any dispute in that
regard. We may hasten to clarify that the
earlier pronouncements were rendered in
respect of the “Act policy” which admittedly
cannot cover a third-party risk of an
occupant in a car. But, if the policy is a
“comprehensive/package
policy”,
the
liability would be covered. These aspects
were not noticed in Bhagyalakshmi v. United
Insurance Company Ltd.:(2009) 3 SCC (Civ)
87 and, therefore, the matter was referred to
a larger Bench. We are disposed to think that
there is no necessity to refer the present
matter to a larger Bench as IRDA, which is
presently the statutory authority, has
clarified the position by issuing circulars
which have been reproduced in the judgment
by the Delhi High Court and we have also
reproduced the same.
3. In view of the aforesaid, we think it
appropriate to set aside the judgment and
order passed by the High Court and remit the
matter for consideration whether the policy in
question is a “comprehensive/package policy”
or exclusively an “Act policy”. After such
consideration it shall pass a reasoned order.
Needless to say, if any other contention is
available to the insured, he will be at liberty to
raise the same before the High Court.”
From the aforesaid principles of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court and also on perusal of Ext.C as relied upon
by OP-owner-cum-driver, it appears that Ext.C i.e. the Insurance
Policy
certificate
comes
under
the
purview
of
package/comprehensive policy but the Learned Tribunal below
opined that the same falls under Act policy for which the matter
needs to be remanded back to the Learned Tribunal below to
determine afresh in respect of Ext.C, if necessary, by examining
the officials of Insurance Company.
19.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant is
disposed of on contest and the case is remanded back to the
Learned Tribunal below with a direction to examine as to
whether Ext.C comes under Comprehensive/package policy or
Act policy or not, if necessary by calling upon the officials of
Insurance Company and also by affording scope to the parties to
adduce fresh evidence, if they so desires and to deliver a fresh
judgment in accordance with law in the light of the aforesaid
judgments of the Ho’nble Supreme Court.
With this observation, this appeal is disposed of.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
MOUMITA DATTA
Date: 2024.12.09 10:35:48
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review