Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
\
[ 3448 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE SEVENTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.3566, 3567 and 3575 OF 2023
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3566 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 of the constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 13-10-2023 Passed in l.A No 358 of 2023 lN O.S No.1 12 of 2018 on the file
of the Court of the Vlll Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy
District, at L.B. Nagar.
Between:
Smt. K.Amaravathi, D/o. late Hanmi Reddy @ Hanumath Reddy, Aged about. 63
years, Occupation Household, R/o. Manikonda Jagir Village, Rajendrangar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State.
... Petiti oner/Petitioner/Plai
ntiff
AND
1. Smt K. Eeramma, Wo. late Hanmi Reddy @ Hanumath Reddy, Aged about.
83 years, Occupation . Household, R/o. l/lanikonda JagirVillage,
Rajendrangar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State
2. S. Krishna, S/o. Gandaiah , Aged about. 58 years, Occupation Business, R/o.
lVlanikonda Jagir Village, Rajendrangar [t/andal, Ranga Reddy District,
Telangana State
3. Shaik Ameena Sultana, Wo. Shaik Anwar, Aged about. 41 years, Occupation
. Household R/o. H.No. 12-2-39, Sri Ram Nagar, Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad28
4. Ms. Shaik Alia Sultanr, ,ro. S. Khader Mohinuddin, Aged About. 37 years,
Occupation. Household R/o. H.No. 12-2-39, Sri Ram Nagar, Mehdipatnam,
Hyderabad-28
5. M/s. Lahari Constructions, Rep. by its Managing Director, R/o. 206, Amrutha
Ville, Rajbhavan Road, Opp. Yashoda Hospital, Somajiguda, Hyderabad .
...Res pondents/Respondents/Defe
n da nt
tA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Order V Rule 20 R/w Section'151 of CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleasetl to permit the petitioner to send the notice to the Respondents No,
2Io 4 by way cf substituted service in any local daily newspaper in Saz E Deccan
or any other local newspaper.
CIVIL REVISIOII PETITION NO: 3567 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 of the constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 13-10-2023 Passed in l.ANo.357 of 2023 in O.S No.112of 2018 on thefile
of the Court o.f the Vlll Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy
District, at L.B. \agar.
Between:
smt. K.Amaravathi, D/o. late Hanmi Reddy @ Hanumath Reddy, Aged about. 63
ygars., .o_ccupation . Household, R/o. Manikonda Jagir village, Rajendrangar
lMandal, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State.
... Petitioner/Petitione
r/P la i n tiff
AND
1. smt K. Et:ramma, wo. late Hanmi Reddy @ Hanumath Reddy, Aged about.
83 years, Occupation . Household, R/o. Manikonda Jagir Villale, Rajendrarrgar Mandal, Ranga Reddy Distiict, Telangana State
S. Krishnil, Sio. Gandaiah , Aged about. 58 years, Occupation Business, R/o
Manikonda Jagir Village, Rajendrangar [Vlanilal, Ranga Reddy District,
Telangan;r State
3. shaik Ameena sultana, wo. shaik Anwar, Aged about. 41 years, occupation
. Househcrld R/o. H No. 12-2-39, sri Ram Nagar, Mehdipatnam, Hyderabad28
4. Ms. shaik Alia sultana, D/o. S. Khader Mohinuddin, Aged About. 37 years,
occupaticn._Household R/o. H.No. 12-2-39, sri Ram Nagar, Mehdipdtnam,
HyderabaJ-28
5. M/s. Lahari constructions, Rep. by its Managing Director, R/o. 206, Amrutha
Ville, Rajbhavan Road, opp. Yashoda Hospi-tal, somajiguda,. Hyderabad
.
... Res po nde n URes po n d e n ts/Defe n d a n
t
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under OrderV Rule 20 R/w Section 151 of CPC praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleased to permit the petitioner to send the notice to the Respondents No.
2 to 4 in CRP No. 3567 of 2023 by way of substituted service in any local daily
newspaper in Saz-E-Deccan or any other local newspaper.
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 3575 OF 2023
Petition under Article 227 ol the constitution of lndia aggrieved by the Order
dated 13-10-2023 Passed in l.A No.356 of 2023 in O.S No.112of 2O18 onthefile
of the Court of the Vlll Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy
District, at L.B. Nagar.
Between:
Smt. K. Amaravathi, D/o. late Hanmi Reddy @ Hanumath Reddy, Aged about. 63
years, Occupation Household, R/o. Manikonda Jagir Village, Rajendrangar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State.
... Petitioner/Petitioners
/Plaintiff
AND
Smt K. Eeramma, Wo. late Hanmi Reddy @ Hanumath Aged about. 83
years, Occupation . Household, R/o. Manikonda Jagir Village, Rajendrangar
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State
2. S. Krishna, S/o. Gandaiah, Aged about. 58 years, Occupation. Business, R/o.
Manikonda Jagir Village, Rajendrangar [/andal, Ranga Reddy District,
Telangana State
3. Shaik Ameena Sultana, Wo. Shaik Anwar, Aged about. 41 years, Occupation
. Hbusehold R/o. H.No. 12-2-39, Sri Ram Nagar, tVehdipatnam, Hyderabad28
4. Ms. Shaik Alia Sultana, Dlo. S. Khader Mohinuddin, Aged About. 37 years,
Occupation. Household R/o. H.No. 12-2-39, Sri Ram Nagar, Mehdipatnam,
Hyderabad-28
5. M/s. Lahari Constructions, Rep. by its Managing Director, R/o. 206, Amrutha
Ville, Rajbhavan Road, Opp. Yashoda Hospital, Somajiguda, Hyderabad .
... Res pondenURes pondents/Defenda nt
ri;
rl;
iii
rl,
ili
ill
l11
lA NO: 1 oF 2023
Petition under Section 151 of CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
stay all the proceedings in o.S No. 112 of 2018 dt. 1311012023 of the
Vlll Additional [)istrict and Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District, at L.B Nagar till
disposal of the CRP's otherwise I will be put to great loss and irreparable injury, in
the interest of the justice and equity
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Order V Rule 20 R/w Section 151 of CPC praying that in the
circumstances :;tated in the affidavit filed in .support of the petition, the High Court
may be pleaseci to permit the petitioner send the notice to to Respondents No.2 to
4 in the No. :\575 of 2023 by way CRP of substituted service in any daily
newspaper in Saz-E-local or any other local newspaper.
Counsel for the' Petitioners in all CRPs :SRl JAGATHPAL REDDY KASI REDDY
Counsel for the,Respondent No.1 in all CRPs: SRI M A K MUKHEED
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.3 & 4 in all CRPs: SRI SHYAM SUNDER
MURTHY
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
cJvrLEEVrqo
T5QF 20.23
Dated: 7th JANUARY,2o126 "
BETWEEN :
Smt.K.Amaravalhi, D lo.Late Hanmi Reddy @
Hanumath Reddy, Aged about 63 years,
Occupation: Household, R/ o.Manikonda
Jagir Village, Rajendranagar Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State.
.. Petitioner-Petitioner-Plaintiff
AND
I
Smt.K.Eeramma, W/o.Late Hanmi Reddy @
Hanumath Reddy, Aged about 83 years,
Occupation: Household, R/o.Manikonda Jagir
Village, Rajendranagar Mandal,
Ranga Reddy District, Telangana State and Others
...RespondentsRe spondents - D efe ndan ts
COMMON ORDER
CRP.NO.3566 0F 2023
1. This CRP is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India assailing the order passed in IA.No.358 of 2023 in OS.No.112
of 2018 dated 13.LO.2O23 which is filed under Order 18 Rule tT of
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 (for short 'CPC') to recall PW.l for
a
I
2lts
BRMR,J
CRPs-3566-3 567 -357 5-2023
marking Development Agreement dated 29.O8.2OO7 which came to
be dismi,ssed.
CRP.NO.3567 0F 2023
2.
This CRP is liled under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India assailing the order passed in IA.No.357 of 2023 in OS.No.112
of 2018 rlated 13.10.2023 filed under Section 151 of CPC to reopen
the case of the plaintiff which came to be dismissed.
CRP.NO.3575 0F 20.23
3.
Th s CRP is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of
India assailing the order passed in IA.No.356 of 2023 dated
13.10.2023 in OS.No.ll2 of 20 18 which is filed under Order 7 Rule
14. of CP() to receive the Development Agreement dated 29.08.2OO7
uide docurment No.11 l52l2OO7 which came to be dismissed.
4.
Tht: learned VIII Additional District and Sessions Judge,
Ranga Rr:ddy at LB Nagar has passed common order in IA.No.356
of 2023 (rrnder order 7 Rule 14 of cPC) to receive the Development
Agreemerrt dated 29.O8.2OO7, IA.No.357 of 2013 (under Section
151 of CPC) to reopen the case of the plaintiff and IA.No.358 of
2023 (unrler Order 18 Rule 17 of CPC) to_I9q41_!EU.-l.
d-'a
3/1s
BRMR,J
_2023
C RPs-3 56 6-3 567 _3 57 5
5.1. Petitioner is the petitioner-plaintiff and respondent Nos.1 to
5 are the respondents-defendants.
5.2. Learned counsel for the petitioner-plaintiff submits that
respondent Nos.l,2 and 5 are not necessary parties to the CRPs
and the contesting parties are respondent Nos.3 and 4.
6.
CRP.No.3567 of 2023 is the lead matter. Petitioner-plaintiff
has liled three separate applications. One to Reopen the case of the
plaintiff (IA No.357 of 2023), another application is to recall PW.i
for marking Development Agreement (1A.No.358 of 2023), another
application to receive documents i.e., Development Agreement
dated 29.O8.2OO7 (IA.No.356 of 2023). The affidavit filed by the
petitioner is the same in all the three IA's except the prayer
portion. Hence, for the sake of convenience the contents of the
aflidavit in IA No.357 of 2023 are taken.
7.1. It is stated in the affidavit (IA.No.357 of 2023) that petitioner
is examined as PW.1 in the suit and on behalf of respondent Nos.3
and 4 one Shaik Anwar who is the husband of respondent No.3defendant No.3 has filed his affidavit in the form of DW.l and got
marked Exs.B1 to 86. It is the contention of respondent Nos.3 and
4-defendant Nos.3 and 4 that they have purchased the property
from respondent No.l-defendant No.1 through GPA holder and
at
I
4lL5
BRMR,J
CRPs-3566-3 567
respondont No.4-defendant No.4 in
-357
-2023
turn has entered into
Developrnent Agreement with respondent No.S-defendant No.S i.e,
M/s. Lahari Constructions but they did not file the same before the
Court. Further, DW.l deposed that he does not have any
knowledl3e about the Development Agreement and its date of
execution, so als<> he do not have knowledge about the Flats which
were alkrtted to them, he gave vague answers. The intention of
DW.l is only to defeat the petitioner-plaintiff legal rights, he did
not disclcse the Development Agreement as well as the Flats which
were alkrtted to them. The petitioner-plaintiff being uneducated
and wittr the help of others she could secured the Development
Agreeme:rt which was executed in favour of respondent No.S-
defendar.t No.5 on 29.O8.2OO7 uide document No.LIl52l2OO7.
According to the Development Agreement respondent Nos.3 and 4-
defendart Nos.3 and 4 have got eight Flats.
IiL.No.
Flat No
G-1
G-5
to2
Floor
Ground
Ground
First
First
Second
Second
Third
Third
SFT
t46L
t722
L46l
L46t
t46L
7.2. The certified copy of Development Agreement was received
by her rn 05.06.2023 from MeeSeva, Kuntlur and , the said
\
t-b
e)a
s/1s
BRMR,J
C RPs_3
5 66_3 567 _3 57 5 _2023
document is required for adjudicating the case. The delay caused
in securing the Development Agreement is neither intentional nor
wanton. DW.1 has intentionally suppressed the fact and
approached the court with unclean hands and according to the
cross-examination he do not have any knowledge regarding the
transactions. As a matter of fact, respondent No.3-defendant No.3
has to give evidence because they are aware of the transactions
and she was expecting that the respondents-defendants may file
the crucial document. Further the petitioner-plaintiff came to
know that respondent Nos.2 and 3-defenant Nos.2 and 3 are
collecting a sum of Rs.2 crores from the Builders towards goodwill
and the said amount will not be refunded to the Builder, in that
connection she intended to file the Development Agreement dated
29.o8.2oo7. To avoid complications petitioner-plaintiff has to
amend the plaint as well as add B'schedule property by showing
the allotment of Flats to the respondents-defendants and prayed to
reopen the case of the petitioner-plaintiff, recall pw.1 for marking
Development Agreement (IA.No.358 of 20231 and to receive the
document (IA.No.356 of 2023ll.
8.1. Respondent Nos.3 and 4-defendant Nos.3 and 4 have filed
their counter in all the applications. Hence, the counter filed in
IA.No.357 of 2023 reads as under:
T
6lts
BRMR,J
C RPs-3 566-3 567
-357
-2023
8.2. Re,spondent Nos.3 and 4-defendant Nos.3 and 4 are the
bona fide purchases of the suit schedule property. Petitionerplaintiff, respondent No.1-defendant No.1 have jointly filed suit in
OS No.1 1,59 of 2OO7 seeking retief of declaration along with other
reliefs which is the subject matter of AS.No.533 of 2018 pending
before the High Court. It is to suffice that under the Evidence Act,
husband is a competent witness to'speak on behalf of his wife and
the alleg,etions made by the petitioner-plaintiff in the affidavit are
false, created only to cover up her latches. No case is made out by
the petitloner-plaintiff to reopen the plaintiff evidence, recall PW.1
and to receive documents and prayed to dismiss the same.
g.
Th: learned trial Court has dismissed three applications filed
by the lretitioner-plaintiff uide common order dated 13.10.2023
which ar: impugned in the CRP's.
10. Learned counsel for the petitioner-plaintiff in all the CRPs
contended that the learned trial Court failed to discuss the crucial
documer:t which was filed by tfte revision petitioner, further the
said doc'rment is useful for adjudication of the case, the learned
trial Court ought to have seen that if the suit is decreed in respect
of the p,laint schedule property where already apartment was
construcled, it is very diflicult to execute the decree. The learned
\
trial Cotiit ought to have seen that DW.1 is an Advogate who gave
-/
Tlts
BRMR,J
C RPs_3 566_3 567 _3 57 5 _2023
vague answers in his cross-examination, the Development
Agreement was not marked in the suit and the learned trial Court
failed to observe that the petitioner-plaintiff has filed Development
Agreement which belongs to respondent No.3 to S-defendant Nos.3
to 5 which has to be marked through the petitioner-plaintiff and
the learned trial Court failed to see that the revision petitioner did
not recall Dw. i to mark the document and the learned trial Court
failed to see that the allotment of Flats will be reflected in the
Development Agreement, on the basis of Development Agreement
the schedule property is to be amended as 'B'sched.ule. counsel to
substantiate his contention has relied on the decisions in the cases
of (1) Sudhir Kumar @ S.Baliyan Vs. Vinay Kumar G.B.r
(21 sugandhi (Dead) by LRs. and Another vs. p.Rajkumar
represented by his Power Agent Imam oliz (3) Lukka srinivasa Rao
@ venkateswarlu Vs. Lukka Sivaiah3 (4) Lakshmi priya Exports
(India) Pvt. Ltd. and others Vs. Ramalingam Mills Ltd. and
another+ (5) Indrajeet singh Sethi vs. Harleen singh sethis
(6) Usha Kiran saxena vs. Amit Maheshwari and ors.6 and prayed
to allow the petitions.
t''ttt-
I
lzozr; 13 scc 71
1zozo1 10 scc 706
'2016 (1) ALT 36 (s.8.)
'2oL6 (z) ALT s37 (s.8.)
' 2024 SCC Online MP 12BO
ueruu/Np/oo33l2ozs
1'
BRMR,J
8i 1s
C RPs-3 566-3 567 _3 57 5
-2
O23
11. Learned counsel for respondent Nos.3 and 4 submits that
the learned trial Court has properly appreciated the facts of the
case and rightly dismissed the applications filed by the petitioner-
plaintiff. Counsel further submits that the petitioner-plaintiff has
filed IA.ltto.6OO of 2023 under Order 6 Rule 17 of Civil Procedure
Code, 1()08 to amend the plaint i.e., amendment is sought
pertaining to Development Agreement bearing No.1 1 l52|2OOT
dated 29.O8.2OOT said to have been executed in favour of
respondent No.S-defendant No.S which came to be dismissed by
the learned trial Court on 31.12.2OO4 and the petitioner-plaintiff
has carried the matter in CRP No.96 L of 2025 which came to be
dismisse<l on O4.04.2025. Since the amendment sought by the
petitioner'-plaintiff to the plaint in respect of Development
Agreement is dismissed, cause in the CRPs does not survive and all
the CRP's; are liable to be dismissed.
12- Petitioner's counsel has filed common synopsis in all the
CRP'S
13.
Heilrd learned qgunsel on record, perused the material
L4. Norv the point for consideration is: Whether the common
orders passed by the learned trial court suffers from any perversiqr
or illegaliry? If so, does it require interference of this Court?
9lrs
BRMR,J
C RPs_3 566_3 567 _3 57 5
-2023
i5. It is stated in the synopsis by the petitioner-plaintiff that
GPA was created in the name of respondent No.l-defendant No.l
by respondent No.2-defendant No.2 and sold the suit propert5r to
respondent Nos.3 and 4-defendant Nos.3 and 4 within a span of
one month. Petitioner-plaintiff and respondent No.1-defendant
No.1 came to know about the forged and created document thereby
they both fiIed suit for declaration and for cancellation of GPA
dated 22.O6.L992 uide document No.l459/ 1992 and sale deed
document No.109361 1992 uide OS.No.1157 of 2007 which came to
be decreed by the II Additional District Judge at Ranga Reddy,
L.B.Nagar declaring the documents as null and void. Respondent
Nos.3 and 4 who are the parties in OS.No.1157 of 2OOT preferred
Appeal before the High Court uide AS.No.533 of 2018 and obtained
stay of execution of judgment and decree in OS.No. ll57 of 2OO7.
16. Petitioner-plaintiff has filed all the three applications i.e., to
reopen the evidence of petitioner-plaintiff, recall of PW.1 and
receive documents on 12.06.2023 before the learned trial Court
after the conclusion of the arguments of the contesting
respondents-defendants.
L7.1. Petitioner-plaintiff has filed OS No.Ll2 of 2Ol8 against the
respondents-defendants seeking partition of the suit schedule
property that she is entitled to 2f 3ra share and respondent No.l-
\._\
/
i
BRMR,J
10/15
i
CRPs-3566-3 567
i
-357
5 2023
.
I
i
defendant No.i is entitled to 1/3ra share and put her in possession
i
I
;
of the same and to award mesne profits for illegal possession of
respondent Nos.2 to S-defendant Nos.2 to 5 at Rs.2 Lakhs from the
date of suit till delivery of possession and to restrain them from
alienatinl3 the propert5r by virtue of alleged GPA document
No.i4597 1992, dated 22.06.1992 and sale deed dated 21.LO.1992
uide d,octiment No.10396 of 1992.
17.2. The schedule of the property is land admeasuring Acs.O-10
guntas f<>rming part of survey No.3SEE, situated at Manikonda
(Village &, Jagir), Rajendranagar Mandal, Ranga Reddy District with
specific boundaries.
18. Respondent No.1-defendant No.1 has filed her written
statement and prayed to pass decree as prayed for and allot 1/3ra
share to her.
19. Resipondent Nos.3 and 4-defendant Nos.3 and 4 have hled
their written statement and contended that they are the absolute
owners and in possession of the suit schedule property having
purchaseC the same for valuable sale consideration uid.e registered
sale dee<[ bearing document No.LO3g6/Lgg2 dated 2l.IO.Igg2
from Raji Reddy and respondent No.l-defendant No.1 represented
by her GtA holder respondent No.2-defendant \o.2.
*^*
*/
1U1s
BRMR,J
CRPs_3 566_3 567 _3 57 5 _2023
2o.L. It is stated in the plaint at para No.6 that respondent Nos.3
and 4-defendant Nos.3 and 4 have purchased the property in the
year lgg2 as such they are in possession of the suit property, as a
matter of fact the GPA and sale deed are sham and bogus
documents. Further their names are not reflected till 2oor in any
record even though they have entered into Development Agreement
with respondent No.S-defendnat No..5. The plaint further goes to
show that in the year 2008 respondent Nos.2, 3 and S-defendant
Nos.2, 3 and 5 have started the construction by grabbing the suit
survey number and constructed apartment illegally. Further
according to the knowledge of the petitioner-plaintiff, in survey
number 35EE, where they have constructed about trS Flats and the
same was let out to various tenants on monthly rent of Rs.2 Lakhs
per month as the schedule property is situated in prime area and
the apartment is known as "Harivillu".
2o.2. [n the cause of action para of the plaint it is mentioned that
respondent Nos.3 to S-defendant Nos.3 to 5 have approached the
suit land in the month of August , 2oo7 for the first time when they
tried. to dispossess the petitioner-plaintiff and respondent No.1defendant No.1 under the guise of illegal document.
2L-l- In sudhir Kumar @ s.Baliyanr, the supreme court held that
"even if there is delay in prod,ucing the document the safi-r€ ought
\-\
*Z
I
I
i
l
BRMR,J
L2lLs
CRPs-3566-3 567
-357
52023
not to l>e ground to reject or dismiss the application, if the
document is found to be genuine and necessary for deciding the
real controversy procedure is handmaid of justice not its mistress".
21.2. tn Sugandhi (died) by LRs.2, the Supreme Court held that
"procedu re is the handmaid of justice. Procedural and technical
hurdles shall not be allowed to come in the way of the Court while
doing substantial justice".
21.3. In Lukka Srinivasa Rao3, the High Court of Judicature at
Hyderabad hetd t-hat "if the Court is convinced that the documents
which are sought to be produced are essential for proper and
effectual adjudication of the dispute and that production of such
documents at a belated stage would not prejudice the adversary
party, it must overlook the failure of the party in putting forth
convincing reasons".
21.4. IrL Lakshmi Priya Exportsa, the High court at Hyderabad
observecl that "the Court should firstly award appropriate costs to
the other party to compensate for the delay and the Court should
take up and complete the case. The Court should ensure that
process loes not become a protracting tactics'.
21.5. I.e Indrajeet Singh Sethis, the High Court of Madhya
Pradesh held that "when the document was in the opposi,te part5r's
\ \-
.*?
l3lLs
BRMR,J
C RPs-3 566_3 567 _3 57 5 _2023
custody, it's belated Iiling by the petitioner cannot be treated as
malafide and the trial Court's refusal amounts to failure to exercise
jurisdiction vested under law".
21.6. In Usha Kiran Saxena6, the High court of Madhya pradesh
held that "rejection of document merely due to delay defeats the
very object of justice delivery, courts should permit protection of
necessary documents subject to a cause".
22.L. Petitioner-plaintiff has also fited petition under order 6 Rule
17 of cPC, 1908 to amend the plaint with regard to Development
Agreement dated 29.o8.2oo2 bearing document No. lrls2l2oo7
uid.e rA No.6o0 of 2023. The learned trial court uide order d.ated
31.L2.2o24 h.as dismissed the Amendment application filed by the
pe titioner-plaintiff.
22.2. Petitioner-plaintiff aggrieved by
the order in
IA.No.600 of 2023 dated 31.L2.2o24 Iiled cRp No.96r of 2o2s
before the High court which came to be dismissed uide order dated
o4.o4.2o25 and she carried the matter before the Supreme court
vide sLP civil Diary No.52463 of 2o2s which also came to be
dismissed on 24.1t.2025leaving it open to the petitioner-plaintiff
to raise all permissible contentions at the stage of preparation of
final decree including those relating to the developments.
bs/
L4lt5
BRMR,J
CRPs_3 566_3 567 _3 57 5
-2023
23. Pe titioner-plaintiff wants to file the very same document i.e.,
Developrnent Agreement dated 29.O8.2OO7 in the suit and mark it
through PW.1.
24. TLLe learned trial Court in para No.l I of its order observed
that the respondents-defendants evidence is closed on 19.O1.2023
and the suit is posted to 25.0L.2023 for arguments. Arguments
from both the sides were heard on 23.02.2023 and the suit is
posted for reply arguments of the petitioner-plaintiff on
28.04.2023. Thereafter, it is adjourned to 07.06.2023, 12.06.2023
and on which date the petitioner-plaintiff has filed all the three
applications.
25. Surit is of the year 2018, all the three applications came to be
filed on 12.06.2023 after the conclusion of the arguments of the
respondr:nts-defendants, affidavits filed by the petitioner-plaintiff
are bereit of material facts, no proper explanation is offered by her
for the delay in filing the applications.
26. Power of the High Court under Article 22T of the
constitution of India is to be sparingly exercised in cases where
errors a::e apparent on the face of the record or exercising its
jurisdiction in a perverse manner (See K.Valarmathi and others
Vs. Kumrrresan- 2025 SCC Online SC 985).
\-
I
1s/1s
Anfvfn.l
CRPs-3 5 66-3 567 .357 5
-2023
27. The decisions cited by the petitioner's counsel stated supra
at para Nos.21.1 to 21.6 are distinguishable from the facts of the
present case and thus the ratio of those cases would not apply to
the case on hand.
28. The learned trial Court has properl5r appreciated the
contentions raised by the parties therein and rightty dismissed the
applications liled by the petitioner-plaintiff and this court is of the
view that the petitioner-piaintiff has not made out any case in the
cRPs. cRPs lack merits and the same are liable to be dismissed
and are accordingly dismissed.
29. All the CRP's are dismissed. There shall be no order as to
costs.
Interim Orders if any shall stands vacated. Miscellaneous
petition/ s stands closed.
SD'- MOHD. ISMAIL
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY'/
To,
The Vlll Additional District and sessions
L'B' Nagar
SECTION OFFICER
Judge, Ranga Reddy District' at
REDDY, Ativocate toPucl
One Cfto SRI JAGATHPAL REDDY KASI
Advocate [OPUC]
3 One CC to SRI M A K IVIUKHEED'
Advocate [OPUC]
MURTHY,
4 one cc to sRt sHyIM SUNDER
5 Two CD CoPies
ADK/PSL
vk
I
j
.':.
..: tZ_
F
HIGH COURT
DATED i0710112026
THE S
o
ll 6 i{AR 2026
*
COMMO]TI ORDER
CRP.Nos.3566, 3567 and 3575 of 2023
DISMISSING ALL THE CRPs
WITHOUI'COSTS
*,Pde
tu
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review