Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
MFA(EC) No.04 of 2022
1.
Smti. Jharna Ghosh, wife of late Sushil Ghosh (48).
2.
Sri Pritam Ghosh, son of late Sushil Ghosh (20).
[Both are residents of village Fulchari, P.S. Kamalpur, District:
Dhalai, Tripura, PIN-799285]
…..Petitioner-appellanta
-V E R S U S-
1.
Sri Prantosh Deb, son of Sukumar Deb, resident of village
Narayanpur, P.O. & P.S. Airport, Agartala, PIN-799009, District:
West Tripura.
[Owner of TATA Indigo C.S. bearing registration No. TR-01Z-0607].
2.
The National Insurance Company Ltd., represented by its General
Manager, A. K. Road P.S. West Agartala, District: West Tripura
[Insurer of TATA Indigo C.S. bearing registration No. TR01-Z-0607].
3.
Sri Goutam Ghosh, son of late Sushil Ghosh, resident of West
Bhubanban, P.O. Ramnagar, P.S. West Agartala, District: West
Tripura.
4.
Smti. Lila Ghosh, wife of late Jitendra Ghosh, resident of
Navagram, P.O. Gandhigram, P.S. Airport, District: West
Tripura, PIN-799012.
….. Opposite Party-respondents.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. D. C. Saha, Advocate.
Mr. T. K. Choudhury, Advocate.
Mr. S. D. Choudhury, Advocate.
Mr. A. Das, Advocate.
NO
Judgment and order dated 18th January, 2023
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. D. C. Saha, learned counsel and Mr. T. K.
Choudhury, learned counsel appearing for the appellant. Also heard Mr. S.
D. Choudhury, learned counsel and Mr. A. Das, learned counsel appearing
for the respondents.
[2]
This appeal has been filed under Section-30 of the Employees’
Compensation Act, 1923 against the judgment and award dated 06.07.2022
holding that the appellant No.1 and 2 are not legal heirs of the deceased and
as such, they are not entitled to get any compensation passed by the
learned Commissioner, Employees’ Compensation, West Tripura, Agartala
in connection T.S.(EC) 05 of 2015.
[3]
The case, in brief, is that the victim Swagatam Ghosh was
employed as driver by the owner of the vehicle bearing no. TR-01-Z- 0607
(TATA Indigo C.S.). On 28.02.2012 at about 01.15 hours the victim
Swagatam Ghosh under instruction of his employer was proceeding a
marriage ceremony of the relatives of his employer and when he reached
near Athletic Club of Resham Bagan, the vehicle was capsized due to
heavy fog skidding in the road and met with an accident. As a result, four
persons including the driver Swagatam Ghosh expired on the spot and one
Jayanta Kapali sustained grievous injuries on his person in the said road
traffic accident.
[4]
After the accident, the local people, fire service personnel and
police personnel rescued all of them and brought to the AGMC & GBP
Hospital, Agartala. On the following morning the appellant no.1 was
informed by her near relatives about the accident and death of her son
Swagatam Ghosh. The whole incident occurred while Swagatam Ghosh
was on duty arising out of and in course of his employment under the O.P.
no.1 and as such the appellants are entitled to get compensation.
Concerning the said accident a police case was registered at East Agartala
Police Station vide East Agartala P.S. Case No.36 of 2012 under Sections
279/338/304(A) of I.P.C.
[5]
It is claimed that at the time of death, deceased Swagatam
Ghosh was 20 years old and would get monthly wages of Rs.5,000/besides daily allowance at the rate of Rs.100/- and in case of night duty he
used to get extra allowance of Rs.300/-. The said accident was within the
knowledge of the owner of the vehicle but subsequently, he was also
verbally informed and requested to pay compensation as per law though he
extended some help towards funeral expenses and assured that he will try
to provide adequate compensation as per law but he remained unattended
with an advice to file application for compensation as the vehicle was duly
insured with the National Insurance Company Ltd. and ultimately, the
present case. Finally, they claimed Rs.14,07,625/- as compensation.
[6]
O.P. No.1 in his written statement stated that the appellants are
not legally entitled to file the present petition as they are not the legal
representatives/survivors of the deceased Swagatam Ghosh. In his written
statement he admitted the averments of the appellants made in their claim
petition. In his written statement he stated that the appellants are not
entitled to get any compensation as they are neither dependent nor the legal
representatives of the deceased. In his written statement he also stated that
the deceased never resides with the appellants at Fulchari, Kamalpur. In his
written statement he also stated that at the relevant date and time of
accident the vehicle was insured with the National Insurance Company Ltd.
[7]
O.P. No.2, National Insurance Company Ltd., in their written
objection denied that the driver of the offending vehicle bearing no. TR-01-
Z-0607 (TATA Indigo CS) was the deceased Swagatam Ghosh and also
denied that the deceased Swagatam Ghosh was driving the vehicle bearing
no. TR-01-Z-0607 on the alleged date and time of accident under
instruction of his employer i.e. the O.P. no.1. O.P. No.2 in their written
objection formally denied about the age, income, profession of the
deceased at the time of accident and sustaining of his injuries and
succumbed to the injuries arising out of and in course of his employment.
[8]
O.P. No.2 in their written objection stated that after the alleged
accident neither the owner nor the appellants informed them about the
alleged accident. In their written objection they stated that they have no
knowledge about any accident which occurred on 28.02.2022 and
Swagatam Ghosh died due to road traffic accident during the course of his
employment. They also stated that neither the notice was given to them nor
the application was filed by the appellants within the stipulated period as
per Employee's Compensation Act.
[9]
O.P. No.3 in his written statement stated that the appellant
No.1 was not the mother of the deceased Swagatam Ghosh and she along
with her son Pritam Ghosh was dependent upon the income of the
deceased. He also stated that the answering opposite party is not the son of
the appellant No.1. In his written statement he admitted that Late
Swagatam Ghosh was a driver of the vehicle bearing no. TR-01-Z-0607
(TATA Indigo CS). O.P. no.3 in his written statement stated that he along
with his full blood brother of Late Swagatam Ghosh and their mother
Jharna Ghosh were residing at Nabagram, Gandhigram in the house of their
maternal granduncle from their childhood due to mental and physical
torture inflicted upon their mother by their father.
[10]
In his written statement he stated that his mother Jharna Ghosh
died on 03.01.2002. He also stated that actual name of the appellant No.1 is
Depali Ghosh and not Jharna Ghosh and she had illicit relation with his
deceased father Late Sushil Ghosh and subsequently, she changed her name
as Jharna Ghosh to grab the property of Late Sushil Ghosh. O.P. no.3 in his
written statement admitted the averments of the appellants made in their
claim petition. In his written statement he stated that the appellants are not
at all entitled to get compensation under the Employee's Compensation Act
due to death of Late Swagatam Ghosh as they are not legal heirs of
deceased Swagatam Ghosh. Lastly, he prayed that he is entitled to get
compensation for death of Swagatam Ghosh.
[11]
The OP No.4 by filing his written statement stated that she is
the grandmother of the deceased Swagatam Ghosh and aged about 70 years
and fully dependant on the income of deceased Swagatam Ghosh and
supported the submission of the OP No.3.
[12]
After hearing both the parties, the Commissioner Employee’s
Compensation, West Tripura, Agartala in case No. TS(EC) 05 of 2015 has
awarded as under:
“In the result, the O.P. no.3 Sri Goutam Ghosh is entitled to get
compensation of Rs.6,73,200/- (Rupees Six Lakh Seventy-three Thousand
Two Hundred) only with interest @ 12% per annum from 28.03.2012 i.e. one
month after the date of accident till realization. O.P. no.2, National
Insurance Company Ltd. will pay the amount of compensation with interest
within 30 days from today.
Out of the total amount of compensation inclusive of interest, 50% shall be
kept in fixed deposit scheme in his name with the UCO Bank, District Court
Branch, Agartala for a period of five years and the balance amount shall be
paid to him through his bank account. Opposite Party No.3 shall be at
liberty to withdraw monthly interest from his fixed deposit account to meet
his day to day expenses. No loan or withdrawal shall be permitted from the
fixed deposit certificate without prior permission of this Commission.”
[13]
The appellants herein, being aggrieved by and dissatisfied
with the impugned judgment and award of compensation dated 06.07.2022,
has preferred this present appeal for the ends of justice.
[14]
Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that
the learned Court below has failed to appreciate that most of the documents
produced by Goutam Ghosh was obtained after filing of the claim petition
on 25.03.2015 and as such, judgment and award dated 06.07.2022 is
perverse and nonest in the eye of law.
[15]
The learned Court below has also failed to appreciate that
deletion of name of Goutam Ghosh and Swagatam Ghosh from the ration
card of the appellant No.1 was effected with effect from 17.03.2018 i.e.
after about 3 years of filing of the claim petition collecting the ration card
from the appellant No.1 i.e. Jharna Ghosh and as such resulting erroneous
judgment and award. Goutam Ghosh could not produce any document or
any independent witness to substantiate his statement that his father during
his life time used to torture upon him mother i.e. first wife of Sushil Ghosh.
[16]
He has submitted that the original survival certificate (Exbt.7)
dated 19.05.2006 was issued upon the application of the appellant No.1. In
the survival certificate it is categorically stated “certified that an enquiry on
the petition of Sri /Smt Jharna Ghosh W/o late Sushil Ghosh of
Fulchari****” and as such resulting erroneous judgment and award.
[17]
The learned Court below has failed to appreciate that in the
original survival certificate dated 19.05.2006 was not challenged by
Goutam Ghosh and Swagatam Ghosh before the appropriate forum till date
even after about more than 22 years therefore the original survival
certificate dated 19.05.2006 is valid and as such, the impugned award
needs to be interfered with.
[18]
PW-2 Ranjit Ghosh in his cross-examination has stated that
the wife of Sushil GHosh died when Sushil Ghosh was alive. The wife of
Sushil Ghosh died probably in the year 1995 which is collaborated with the
certificate of Panchayat Pradhan. The learned Court below has failed to
appreciate that the original certificate of the Pradhan, Noagaon Gram
Panchayat Durgachowmohani R.D. Block Kamalpur, Dhalai Tripura stated
that first wife of late Sushil Ghosh namely, Jharna Ghosh expired on
03.01.1995 in their dwelling house of late Sushil GHosh.
[19]
Appellant No.1 as PW-1 deposed that she is the mother of
deceased Swagatam Ghosh and she along with his younger son Pritam
Ghosh was fully dependent on the income of the deceased. She also
deposed that elder son Goutam Ghosh was reluctant to maintain her and
staying separately. She further deposed that deceased Swagatam Ghosh
was employed as a driver by the owner of the vehicle bearing no. TR-01-Z0607 (TATA Indigo CS) under O.P. No.1 namely, Sri Prantosh Deb. She
deposed that on 28.02.2012 at about 01.15 hours her son Swagatam Ghosh
under instruction of his employer was proceeding towards Nabagram of
Gandhigram by driving the said vehicle after attending a marriage
ceremony of the relatives of his employer and on the way, when he reached
near Athletic Club of Resham Bagan, the vehicle was capsized due to
heavy fog skidding in the road and met with an accident. As a result, four
persons including her son Swagatam Ghosh expired on the spot and one
Jayanta Kapali sustained grievous injuries on his person in the said road
traffic accident and the said accident was occurred while her son Swagatam
Ghosh was on duty.
[20]
After accident, the local people, fire service and police
personnel rescued all of them and brought to the AGMC & GBP Hospital,
Agartala. Subsequently, said accident was registered at East Agartala
Police Station vide East Agartala P.S. Case No.36 of 2012 under Sections
279/338/304(A) of I.P.C. Nothing material came from her cross
examination by O.P. No.3 except one reply that she could not say the
address of the driver mentioned in the driving licence submitted by her in
this case.
[21]
Sri Ranjit Ghosh as PW-2 deposed that he is a neighbour of
the appellants of this case and he is well conversant with the facts and
circumstances of the case. He also deposed that the O.P. No.3 Goutam
Ghosh is the full blooded brother of deceased Swagatam Ghosh and father
of the deceased Swagatam Ghosh as well as Goutam Ghosh was never
separated from his family in the year 1993. He further deposed that Goutam
Ghosh is the full blooded brother of deceased Swagatam Ghoshand half
blooded brother of Sri Pritam Ghosh. In his evidence he deposed that
Goutam Ghosh being driver by profession never dependent upon deceased
Swagatam Ghosh. He also deposed that he witnessed the first wife of Late
Sushil Ghosh namely, Jharna Ghosh who expired on 03.01.1995 in the
house of Sushil Ghosh situated at Noagaon Gram Panchayet, Kamalpur
leaving behind the O.P. No.3 and deceased Swagatam Ghosh.
[22]
He further deposed that after sad demise of first wife, Sushil
Ghosh socially married another lady whose name is also Jharna Ghosh in
the last part of the year 1995 to look after his two minor children namely,
Goutam Ghosh, O.P. No.3 and the deceased Swagatam Ghosh and he
knows Smti. Jharna Ghosh who is the appellant No.1 of this case. In his
cross by O.P. No.3 he stated that the distance between his house and the
house of Jharna Ghosh will be 2½ kilometer approximately. He also stated
that the wife of Sushil Ghosh died probably in the year 1995 when Sushil
Ghosh was alive. Except these nothing material came out from his cross
examination. Nothing material also came out from his cross examination by
O.P. No.1 and 2.
[23]
O.P. No.1 Sri Prantosh Deb as OPW-1 in his cross by the O.P.
No.2 he stated that on the intervening night of 27.02.2012 and 28.02.2012
at about 1.15 a.m. his vehicle met with an accident when it was returning
from Kashipur and at that time the vehicle was duly insured with the
National Insurance Company Ltd. He also stated that after the accident he
informed the matter to the insurance company but he did not submit any
document as proof of the same before this Court. He further stated that in
the charge-sheet it has been mentioned that the driver of the vehicle was in
drunken condition while driving the vehicle at the time of accident. In his
cross by the O.P. No.3 and 4 he stated that his driver Swagatam Ghosh is a
resident of their locality and was residing in the house of his grandmother
Lila Ghosh along with his brother. He also stated that the parents of
Swagatam Ghosh expired while he was very young and since that time he
and his brother are residing in the house of their grandmother.
[24]
O.P. No.4 Smti. Lila Ghosh as OPW-3 has stated that issue of
torture was cropped up due to illicit relation between Sushil Ghosh and
Deepali Ghosh. Subsequently, Deepali Ghosh changed her name as Jharna
Ghosh to grab the property of Sushil Ghosh and in the mean time her
daughter Jharna Ghosh died on 03.01.2002 due to torture of her husband
Sushil Ghosh. Except denial nothing material came out from her cross
examination by O.P. no.1. In her cross examination by O.P. no.2 she stated
that on the date of incident her grandson Swagatam Ghosh went on a trip
along with passengers in the vehicle bearing no. TR-01-Z-0607
(TATAIndigo CS).
[25]
Sri Joydeep Ghosh as OPW-4 deposed that he is the Divisional
Manager of National Insurance Company Ltd. and he is acquainted about
the facts and circumstances of the case. He also deposed that he collected
the charge-sheet in connection with the East Agartala P.S. Case No.36 of
2012 under Sections 279/335/304(A) of IPC and on perusal of the
chargesheet he found that the deceased Swagatam Ghosh drove the vehicle
in drunken condition and the claimant appellants have no relation with the
deceased Swagatam Ghosh as they are not dependent upon the deceased.
During examination he exhibited three documents namely, certified copy of
Ejahar in connection with East Agartala P.S. Case No.36 of 2012 as well as
printed FIR form in connection with the said case as Exbt.K, certified copy
of two seizure lists in connection with the aforesaid case as Exbt.L and
certified copy of charge-sheet in connection with the aforesaid case as
Exbt.
[26]
In his cross examination by O.P. No.1, 3 and 4 stated that he
did not witness the accident and did not submit any medical document as
proof that the deceased was driving the vehicle in drunken condition at the
time of accident and also did not cite any doctor as witness to establish that
the deceased was in drunken condition.
[27]
From the certified copy of Judgment dated 27.08.2016 passed
in T.S.(MAC) 305 of 2012 by the Learned Member, Motor Accident
Claims Tribunal No.4, West Tripura, Agartala under Exbt.3 it is found that
the Learned Tribunal came to the finding that the accident had occurred
due to rash and negligent driving of the vehicle bearing No. TR-01-Z0607(TATA Indigo CS). Similarly, from the certified copy of Judgment
dated 16.01.2017 passed in T.S.(MAC) 20 of 2014 by the Learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala
under Exbt.6 it is also found that the Learned Tribunal came to the finding
that the TATA Indigo CS bearing registration No.TR-01-Z-0607 was solely
responsible for the accident. From certified copy of Charge-sheet under
Exbt.'M' it is found that the Investigating Officer after investigation came
to the finding that the accident had occurred due to rash and negligent
driving of the vehicle by its driver namely Swagatam Ghosh and a prima
facie charge under Sections 279/338/304(A) of I.P.C. was well established
against the driver of the vehicle bearing No. TR-01-Z-0607 (TATA Indigo
CS).
[28]
Certified copy of ejahar under Exbt.2, certified copy of
Judgment dated 27.08.2016 passed in T.S.(MAC) 305 of 2012 by the
Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal No.4, West Tripura,
Agartala under Exbt.3, certified copy of Judgment dated 16.01.2017 passed
in T.S.(MAC) 20 of 2014 by the Learned Member, Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal No.1, West Tripura, Agartala under Exbt.6, certified copy of
charge-sheet under Exbt.M concerning the East Agartala P.S. Case No.36
of 2012 under Sections 279/338/304(A) of I.P.C. and written statement of
O.P.1 corroborate with each other about the accident and death of the
deceased Swagatam Ghosh arising out of and in course of his employment
under the O.P. No.1. In the Charge-sheet it is mentioned that all of them
were allegedly in drunken condition but specifically there is no mention
whether the driver of the vehicle was in drunken condition or not at the
time of accident and the OPW4 in his cross examination by O.P. Nos.1, 3
and 4 stated that no medical document was submitted by him as proof of
the same and also did not cite any doctor as witness to establish that the
deceased was in drunken condition.
[29]
Considering the above discussion, it is established that the
accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the vehicle
bearing registration No. TR-01-Z-0607 (TATA Indigo CS) by its driver
Swagatam Ghosh and the said accident had occurred arising out of and in
course of his employment under the O.P. No.1 as a driver of the said
vehicle. As such the legal heir(s) is/are entitled to get some compensation.
On perusal Survival Certificate dated 16.05.2018 issued by the SubDivisional Magistrate, Mohanpur, West Tripura District under Exbt.E, it is
found that Sri Goutam Ghosh is shown as surviving member on the death
of deceased Swagatam Ghosh and as such Sri Goutam Ghosh is only
entitled to get compensation.
[30]
As per Exbt.5 (Insurance policy), the vehicle bearing No. TR-
01-Z-0607 (TATA Indigo CS) was insured with the National Insurance
Company Ltd. for the period from 14.02.2012 to 13.02.2013 and the
accident had occurred on 28.02.2012 i.e. within the period of policy. As per
driving licence of the deceased (Exbt.4) he was authorized to drive 3W-NT
and LMV-NT and the validity of the non transport vehicle was w.e.f.
13.07.2010 to 12.07.2030 though the accident had occurred on 28.02.2012.
So, the Driving Licence of the deceased was valid at the time of accident.
There is no evidence adduced from the side of Insurance Company that the
insurer had violated any terms of policy. Thus, liability of payment of
compensation is fixed upon O.P. No.2, National Insurance Insurance Co.
Ltd. Thus, liability of payment of compensation on behalf of O.P. No.1 is
saddled upon O.P. No.2, National Insurance Company Ltd.
[31]
In the backdrop of above analysis, this Court is of the view
that the findings as arrived at by the learned Court below vide its judgment
and award dated 06.07.2022 passed in T.S. (EC) 05 of 2015, needs no
interference and thus, the same stands affirmed. Consequently, the present
appeal filed by the appellants, stands dismissed. As a sequel, miscellaneous
applications pending, if any, shall stand closed. Send down the LCRs
forthwith.
Chief Justice [acting]
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review