Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 20TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 135 OF 2011 (RES)
BETWEEN:
1.
SMT. JAYAMMA
W/O LATE NARAYANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS
2.
SMT. N. LAKSHMI
D/O LATE NARAYANAPPA
AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS
BOTH ARE RESIDING AT NO.1058,
MANJUNATHA NILAYA, KABIR ASHRAM ROAD,
DESHBANDHUNAGAR, KODIGEHALLI,
BANGALORE - 560 097.
…APPELLANTS
Digitally signed
by
SHARADAVANI
B
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(BY SRI. S. SUSHEELA, SR. COUNSEL FOR
SRI. P.M. NARAYANASWAMY, ADVOCATE)
AND:
1.
T.I.GANAPATHI NAYAK
DEAD BY HUS LRS
1(A). SMT. VIDYA
W/O LATE GANAPATHI NAYAK
AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS
-2NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
1(B). GOWTHAM
S/O LATE GANAPATHI NAYAK
AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS
1(C). VIKRAM
S/O LATE GANAPATHI NAYAK
AHGED ABOUT 20 YEARS
RESPONDENTS NO.1(A) TO 1(C)
ARE RESIDING AT NO.10
3RD CROSS, SADGURU LAYOUT
KANSHIRAM NAGAR
VIDYARANYAPURA POST
BANGALORE - 560 097.
2.
SRI. T.I. JNANADEVA NAYAK
S/O T. LAXMAN NAYAK
AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS
BOTH ARE RESIDING AT NO.62,
THIMMANNA BUILDING,
DODDABOMMASANDRA,
BANGALORE - 560 097.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. M.J. ALVA, ADVOCATE FOR R1(A) AND R2)
THIS RFA IS FILED U/S 96 OF CPC AGAINST THE
JUDGMENT
AND
DECREE
DATED:09.12.2010
PASSED
IN
O.S.9132/2003 ON THE FILE OF THE XIV-ADDL. CITY CIVIL
JUDGE,
BANGALORE
CITY,
DECREEING
THE
SUIT
FOR
POSSESSION AND DAMAGES.
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR HEARING, THIS DAY,
JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER:
-3NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM
ORAL JUDGMENT
The captioned appeal is by the defendants directed
against
the
judgment
O.S.No.9132/2003
and
whereby
decree
the
rendered
plaintiffs'
suit
in
for
possession is decreed and the defendants are directed to
vacate and hand over vacant possession of the suit
schedule property in favour of the plaintiffs.
2. For the sake of brevity, the parties are referred to
as per their ranking before the Trial Court.
3. Facts leading to the case are as under:
The plaintiffs instituted the present suit seeking
recovery of possession in respect of the suit schedule
property bearing Site No.34, measuring 30 feet east-west
and 52 feet north-south, bearing Khata No.34/34, situated
at Kodigehally Village. It is their specific case that they
have acquired valid title to the said property under a
registered sale deed dated 08.03.2002 executed by the
-4NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
ancestors of the defendants. The plaintiffs have further
pleaded that as on the date of purchase, a small dwelling
house was in existence on the suit schedule property.
According
to
them,
though
the
co-owners
of
the
defendants vacated the premises and shifted elsewhere,
the defendants sought some time to make alternate
arrangements and agreed to deliver vacant possession
within a few months from the date of execution of the sale
deed.
Alleging
that
despite
repeated
requests
the
defendants failed to hand over possession and continued
in unlawful occupation, the plaintiffs filed the present suit
seeking delivery of possession and mesne profits at the
rate of `7,500/- per month from 03.12.2003 on the
ground of illegal and unauthorised occupation.
4. Upon service of summons, the defendants entered
appearance and filed their written statement, stoutly
denying the plaint averments in toto. The defendants have
specifically disputed the alleged transaction relating to sale
of 36 guntas in Sy.No.110/3B and have denied that the
-5NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
plaintiffs have acquired any lawful right, title or interest
over the portion claimed in the suit.
5. In view of the rival pleadings, the Trial Court
framed appropriate issues and called upon the parties to
adduce evidence. In support of their case, the plaintiffs
examined the second plaintiff as P.W.1 and another
witness as P.W.2 and relied upon ten documents marked
as Exs.P.1 to P.10. On the other hand, the defendants
examined
the second defendant as
D.W.1 and
two
additional witnesses as D.Ws.2 and 3 and produced
twenty-six documents marked as Exs.D.1 to D.26.
6. The Trial Court, on appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence, particularly the sale deed relied
upon by the plaintiffs marked at Ex.P.1, answered Issue
Nos.1 and 2 in the affirmative, holding that the plaintiffs
have established their title and that the defendants are in
unauthorised possession of the suit schedule property.
Consequently, the Trial Court held that the plaintiffs are
-6NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
entitled to recovery of possession. Issue No.3 relating to
maintainability
was
also
answered
in
favour
of the
plaintiffs. Accordingly, the suit came to be decreed
directing the defendants to deliver vacant possession of
the suit schedule property.
7. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree, the
defendants preferred the present appeal. During the
pendency of the appeal, this Court, by order dated
17.10.2012, having regard to the additional evidence
sought to be produced by the defendants, directed the
Trial Court to record further evidence in respect of the
additional documents and remit the same to this Court.
8. Pursuant to the said direction, a copy of the
General Power of Attorney and the Agreement of Sale
were produced before the Trial Court. The GPA holder of
the defendants was examined as C.W.1 and additional
documents were received in evidence. The supplementary
-7NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
evidence so recorded has been transmitted to this Court
for consideration in the present appeal.
9. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
defendants,
reiterating
the
grounds
urged
in
the
memorandum of appeal, contends that the additional
evidence, particularly the testimony of C.W.1, decisively
alters the complexion of the case. Drawing attention to the
admissions elicited in the cross-examination of C.W.1, she
submits that even if the GPA coupled with the Agreement
of Sale is accepted, the material on record clearly
demonstrates that out of the total extent of 1 acre 2
guntas in Sy.No.110/3B, only 36 guntas was agreed to be
conveyed through the GPA holder. It is further submitted
that C.W.1, acting under the said GPA and Agreement of
Sale, secured conversion only to an extent of 33 guntas
and that the remaining 3 guntas out of the agreed 36
guntas was utilised for formation of a road.
-8NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
10.
The
learned
Senior
Counsel
would
further
contend that C.W.1 has categorically admitted that the
sites formed within the converted extent of 33 guntas
were sold, and that the three guntas were set apart for
road formation. More significantly, C.W.1 has admitted
that the ancestors of the defendants had retained 6 guntas
of land, which included an RCC house and a borewell, and
that the said residential structure had been in existence
nearly ten years prior to the conversion. It is also elicited
that no house was constructed by C.W.1 after conversion
nor was any constructed house sold by him.
11. Placing reliance on these admissions and the
recitals contained in the GPA and the Agreement of Sale,
the
learned
Senior
Counsel
submits
that
the
said
documents clearly exclude the 6 guntas comprising the
existing residential house. Therefore, it is contended that
the suit filed by the plaintiffs seeking possession of Site
No.34 is misconceived. According to the defendants, under
the guise of seeking possession of Site No.34, the plaintiffs
-9NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
are in effect attempting to assert rights over the retained
portion of 6 guntas containing the residential house and
borewell, which was never intended to be conveyed. On
these grounds, it is urged that the decree passed by the
Trial Court is unsustainable and liable to be set aside.
12. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the
plaintiffs
would
vehemently
contend
that
the
very
foundation of the defendants’ challenge is misconceived.
He would submit that the property agreed to be sold under
the registered sale deed dated 08.03.2002 is a residential
property and that the defendants, in paragraph No.4 of
the written statement, have unequivocally admitted that
they are in possession of the suit schedule property.
According to him, this categorical admission strikes at the
root
of
the
defence
and
substantially
clinches
the
controversy. It is his submission that once the execution of
the registered sale deed and the possession of the
defendants are not seriously disputed, no further burden
- 10 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
lies on the plaintiffs to independently establish their
entitlement to recovery of possession.
13. The learned counsel would further place strong
reliance on the findings recorded by the Trial Court at
paragraphs 12 to 14 of the impugned judgment and
contend that the oral and documentary evidence adduced
by the plaintiffs has been properly appreciated. He would
argue that the defendants have not chosen to challenge
the validity of the sale deed executed in favour of the
plaintiffs through the GPA holder/C.W.1 and, in the
absence
of
any
substantive
challenge
to
the
title
document, the defendants have no locus standi to resist a
suit for possession founded on a registered conveyance.
On these grounds, he would pray for dismissal of the
appeal.
14. This Court, having heard the learned counsel
appearing on both sides at considerable length, has
carefully re-appreciated the pleadings and the entire oral
- 11 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
and documentary evidence available on record. This Court
has also taken into consideration the additional evidence
recorded pursuant to the remand order, particularly the
testimony of C.W.1, as well as the recitals contained in the
registered sale deed marked as Ex.P.1. Upon such reevaluation, the following points arise for consideration in
this appeal:
(i)
Whether
the
plaintiffs
were
justified
in
maintaining a suit for possession simpliciter
without seeking the relief of declaration of title?
(ii)
Whether, in the facts and circumstances of
the case, the plaintiffs are entitled to seek
delivery of possession of a residential house
allegedly retained
by the defendants,
when
Ex.P.1 indicates purchase of Site No.34?
(iii)
What order?
Finding on points No.(i) and (ii):
15. The plaintiffs trace their title to the suit schedule
property
bearing
Site
No.34
on
the
strength
of
a
- 12 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
registered sale deed dated 08.03.2002, marked as Ex.P.1,
said to have been executed by the defendants’ ancestor
through his duly constituted GPA holder. It is the specific
case of the plaintiffs that by virtue of the said registered
conveyance, absolute right, title and interest in respect of
Site No.34, together with all appurtenant rights, stood
transferred in their favour. Since the entire claim of the
plaintiffs hinges upon the nature, identity and extent of
the
property
conveyed
under
Ex.P.1,
and
as
the
controversy in the present appeal revolves around the true
scope of the property described therein, this Court deems
it necessary and appropriate to extract the schedule of
property as described in the sale deed, so as to ascertain
whether the claim for possession made in the suit strictly
conforms to the property conveyed under Ex.P.1. The
schedule reads as under:
"All that piece and parcel of the Property bearing Site
No.34, Khatha No.34/34, Out of Survey No.110/3B,
Converted for Non-agricultural residential purpose vide
official Memorandum No.B.DIS.ALN.SR[NA]52/96-97,
dtd: 2-07-1996, Bangalore, Situated at Kodigehalli
- 13 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
village, Yelahanka Hobli, Bangalore North Taluk,
measuring East to West: 30'-0" (Thirty) feet, North to
South: 52'-0" (Fifty Two) feet, totally 1560 Square feet
and bounded as follows:
East by
:
Kamath's Property,
West by
:
Remaining Portion,
North by
:
Private Property,
South by
:
Road"
16. On a careful and close reading of the recitals
contained in Ex.P.1, this Court finds that the description of
the property conveyed thereunder is explicit, definite and
free from any ambiguity. The document unmistakably
records that what was conveyed in favour of the plaintiffs
is a site bearing No.34, having Khatha No.34/34, with
specific measurements and defined boundaries. The nature
of the property is described as a vacant site, and the
identity of the property is clearly demarcated by its
municipal number, extent and boundaries. There is no
recital
in
the
operative
portion
of
the
conveyance
indicating transfer of a larger extent of land or of any
residential house standing on an excluded portion. The
- 14 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
language employed in the document leaves little room for
interpretative doubt as to what was intended to be
transferred.
17. In this context, one of the crucial covenants that
assumes significance is found at page 6 of the sale deed
marked as Ex.P.1. The said recital throws light on the
scope of the transfer and the intention of the parties at the
time
of
execution
of
the
document.
Since
the
determination of the present controversy largely hinges
upon the true import of this covenant, this Court deems it
appropriate to extract the first paragraph of the said
recital, which reads as under:
"The Vendors have this day relinquished all their rights,
title, interest, claims whatsoever in respect of the
schedule property and delivered the vacant absolute
possession of the schedule property to the Purchasers.
From the date of Sale Deed, the Purchasers shall
possess and enjoy the schedule property as the
absolute owners thereby paying all the future taxes,
cesses, etc., to the concerned authority with the powers
of disposal."
Emphasis supplied
- 15 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
18. On a plain and meaningful reading of the above
extracted
covenant
contained
in
Ex.P.1,
it
becomes
manifestly clear that the vendors, acting through their
duly constituted GPA holder, have unequivocally conveyed
Site No.34 in favour of the plaintiffs and have expressly
recited that possession of the said site was delivered to
the purchasers at the time of execution of the sale deed.
The recital is categorical in its tenor and admits of no
ambiguity. It records not merely the transfer of title but
also the handing over of possession contemporaneously
with the execution and registration of the instrument.
Such a recital, embodied in a registered conveyance,
carries
significant
evidentiary
value
and
prima
facie
reflects the intention of the parties and the nature of the
transaction.
19. However, when this recital is juxtaposed with the
averments made in paragraph No.4 of the plaint, an
apparent
inconsistency
surfaces.
In
the
plaint,
the
plaintiffs have pleaded that although they purchased the
- 16 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
property under the sale deed dated 08.03.2002, the
defendants continued to remain in possession and had
sought time to vacate the residential house standing on
the suit schedule property. This pleading appears to run
counter to the explicit recital in Ex.P.1 which records
delivery
of
possession.
In
view
of
this
noticeable
divergence between the documentary recital and the
pleadings set up in the plaint, this Court deems it
necessary to extract paragraph No.4 of the plaint in
extenso for proper appreciation, which reads as under:
"4. The schedule property consisted of a small dwelling
house wherein the defendants and all the co-owners
were residing together. At the time of execution of the
absolute sale deed the other co-owners had shifted their
residence to different addresses after vacating the
schedule property and the defendants continued to
reside in the schedule property. The defendants had
agreed and undertook to deliver the vacant possession
of the schedule property to the plaintiffs immediately
within few months from the date of the execution of the
sale deed after making alternative To that effect the
defendants had also given an undertaking in the sale
deed itself. But contrary to the undertaking the
defendants have failed to vacate the schedule property
and to deliver the same to the plaintiffs hitherto."
- 17 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
20. On a careful perusal of paragraph No.4 of the
plaint, this Court finds that the stand taken by the
plaintiffs
therein
consistency
and
creates
a
credibility
serious
of
their
cloud
over
the
case.
While
the
registered sale deed dated 08.03.2002, marked as Ex.P.1,
contains a clear and unequivocal recital that possession of
Site No.34 was delivered to the plaintiffs on the date of
execution
itself,
the
plaint
proceeds
on
an
entirely
different footing. In the pleading, the plaintiffs assert that
though the sale deed was executed, the defendants
continued to remain in occupation of the residential house
standing on the property and had sought time to vacate
the same within a few months after making alternate
arrangements.
21. This version, in the considered view of this Court,
is in direct conflict with the express recital contained in the
registered instrument. A registered sale deed carries with
it a presumption of correctness as to the statements
contained therein, particularly when it relates to the
- 18 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
nature
of
the
property
conveyed
and
delivery
of
possession. When the document explicitly records that
possession has been handed over, the parties to the
document are ordinarily bound by such recital. It is well
settled that no amount of oral evidence can be adduced to
contradict, vary or subtract from the terms of a written
contract, except in circumstances recognized in law.
Unless the plaintiffs lay a proper foundation and furnish a
cogent explanation reconciling the inconsistency between
the recital in Ex.P.1 and the averments in the plaint, the
contradictory stand taken in the pleadings cannot be
lightly accepted. In the absence of such explanation, any
oral assertion contrary to the recitals in the registered sale
deed would be legally impermissible and inadmissible in
evidence.
22. The next significant piece of evidence that
warrants close scrutiny is the testimony of C.W.1, which
came to be recorded pursuant to the remand order passed
by this Court. C.W.1 is none other than the GPA holder
- 19 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
through whom the transaction was effected and who, as
admitted, was instrumental in obtaining conversion of the
land and in forming the layout comprising various sites.
His evidence assumes considerable importance, not only
because he was the executing agent under the GPA, but
also because he had direct knowledge of the extent of land
agreed to be conveyed, the portion converted for nonagricultural use, and the manner in which the layout was
formed and sites were dealt with thereafter.
23. In that view of the matter, this Court deems it
appropriate to advert in detail to the relevant portions of
the cross-examination of C.W.1, as the admissions elicited
therein have a direct bearing on the rival claims set up by
the parties. The relevant extract of his cross-examination
reads as under:
"We left 3 guntas of vacant land towards the western
side of the larger portion of Sy.No.110/3B. In the
remaining land of six guntas there was a sheet roofed
house, a RCC house and a bore-well. the landlord
Smt.Jayamma was residing in the said RCC house. It is
true that there is RCC house then a sheet roofed and
house and then a bore-well. 10 Years prior to obtaining
- 20 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
conversion order of land the RCC and sheet roofed
houses were in existence. I do not know that the writing
on the last page of Ex.C.3 pertains to whom. As on the
date of execution of EX.C.3 I had knowledge of the said
writing at page No.5.
We have not constructed and sold any house in
Sy.No.110/3B. We have sold sites formed in 33 guntas
only."
Emphasis supplied
24. On a careful reading of the extracted portion of
the cross-examination of C.W.1, this Court finds that the
entire controversy sought to be projected by the plaintiffs,
namely that they are entitled to claim possession of an
existing residential house under the sale deed dated
08.03.2002, stands substantially resolved against them.
C.W.1, who is none other than the GPA holder through
whom the transaction was effected and who admittedly
formed the layout in Sy.No.110/3B, has made categorical
and unequivocal admissions. He has clearly stated that
though there was an agreement to sell 36 guntas of land,
6 guntas were expressly retained by the original owners.
He has further admitted that in the said retained extent of
- 21 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
6 guntas, there existed a sheet-roofed house and an RCC
house along with a borewell, and that the owners were
residing therein. More significantly, he has specifically
admitted that defendant No.1 – Jayamma
is residing in
the said RCC house.
25. C.W.1 has also candidly admitted that he did not
construct any house in Sy.No.110/3B and thereafter sell it.
He has further deposed that all the sites formed in the
converted extent of 33 guntas have been alienated and
that the remaining 3 guntas were utilized for the formation
of
a road.
These
admissions,
elicited
during
cross-
examination by the defendants, go to the root of the
matter. It is also noteworthy that when the plaintiffs
cross-examined C.W.1 on 29.10.2014, they did not choose
to confront him or challenge him on these crucial aspects.
There is a conspicuous absence of cross-examination on
the vital admissions relating to retention of 6 guntas and
existence of the residential house therein. The silence on
this material aspect assumes significance and lends further
- 22 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
credence
to
the
version
emerging
from
the
cross-
examination conducted by the defendants.
26. The documentary recital in the Sale Deed, being
contemporaneous and foundational in nature, assumes
greater evidentiary value and effectively clinches the
controversy regarding the identity and extent of the
property agreed to be conveyed. In that view of the
matter, this Court deems it appropriate to extract the
relevant portion of the Sale Deed which clearly records
that 6 guntas of land, comprising a residential house and
borewell, were retained by the original owners.
"F ªÀÄzsÉå EgÀĪÀ ªÉÄîÌAqÀ 0-36 ªÀÄÆªÀvÁÛgÀÄUÀÄAmÉ «¹ÛÃtðzÀ RĶÌ
d«ÄãÀÄ F PÀæAiÀÄzÀ PÀgÁgÀÄ ¥ÀvÀæPÉÌ M¼À¥ÀnÖgÀÄvÀÛzÉ, ¨ÉÆÃgÉé¯ï ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ªÀÄ£É
¸ÉÃjPÉÆAqÀÄ, ªÀÄ£ÉUÉ §®UÀqɬÄgÀĪÀ SÁ° eÁUÀz°
À ègÀĪÀ JgÀqÀÄ ²Ãmï
ªÀÄ£ÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ªÀÄvÀÄÛ SÁ° eÁUÀªÀ£ÀÄß £ÀªÀÄä vÁ¬ÄAiÀĪÀgÁzÀ ²æÃªÀÄw
dAiÀĪÀÄä£ÀªÀjUÉ jf¸ÀÖgï ªÀiÁrPÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÁV, £ÁªÀÅUÀ¼ÄÀ CAzÀgÉ ²æÃ. J£ï.
dUÀ¢Ã±ï, ²æÃ ²æÃ¤ªÁ¸Á ªÀÄvÀÄÛ J£ï. ªÉAPÀmÉñÀ M¦àgÀÄvÉÛêÉ, ºÁUÀÆ ²æÃªÀÄw
±ÁgÀzÀªÀÄäjUÉ
MAzÀÄ
(1)
®PÀë
gÀÆ¥Á¬ÄUÀ¼À£ÀÄß
£ÀUÀzÁV
jf¸ÉÖçõÀ
¸ÀªÀÄAiÀÄzÀ°è PÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÁVAiÀÄÄ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ ²æÃªÀÄw gÀvÀߪÀÄä¤UÉ 30x40 SÁ°
¤ªÉñÀ£À ಅzÀ°ègÀvÀPÀÌAxÀ ªÀÄ£ÉAiÀÄ£ÀÄß ¸ÀºÀ ©lÄÖ ªÀÄvÀÄÛ 50,000 UÀ¼À£ÀÄß
£ÀUÀzÁV PÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÁVAiÀÄÄ ºÁUÀÆ PÀĪÀiÁj ®Qëöä jf¸ÀÖgï ¸ÀªÀÄAiÀÄzÀ°è MAzÀÄ
®PÀë PÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÁV 1,00,000 £ÀUÀzÁV PÉÆqÀĪÀÅzÁV ºÉýgÀÄvÁÛgÉ."
- 23 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
27.
The
sworn
deposition
of
C.W.1,
recorded
pursuant to the remand order, is fully consistent with and
corroborative of the recitals contained in the Agreement of
Sale executed by the defendants’ ancestors in his favour.
A conjoint reading of the GPA and the Agreement of Sale
unmistakably discloses that while authority was conferred
upon C.W.1 to deal with and develop 36 guntas of land,
there was a specific and express exclusion of 6 guntas
retained by the original owners. The said retained extent
was clearly described as comprising a residential house
and a borewell. Thus, the exclusion of 6 guntas was
neither incidental nor implied, but a conscious and
deliberate reservation incorporated in the very foundation
document under which C.W.1 derived authority.
28. In his oral evidence on oath, C.W.1 has candidly
admitted that only 36 guntas were agreed to be conveyed
for
the
purpose
of
development,
that
he
secured
conversion in respect of 33 guntas and utilized 3 guntas
for road formation, and that the remaining 6 guntas,
- 24 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
containing the residential house and borewell, continued to
remain with the defendants’ family. This admission in
evidence is in complete alignment with the documentary
recitals in the Agreement of Sale. Therefore, the plaintiffs,
who trace their title through C.W.1 under a subsequent
sale deed, cannot assert a claim beyond the authority and
interest that C.W.1 himself possessed. When the very
source of their title acknowledges the exclusion of 6
guntas containing the residential house, the plaintiffs are
estopped from contending otherwise.
29. On a holistic appreciation of the entire oral and
documentary evidence on record, this Court is of the
considered view that the plaintiffs have no locus to lay
claim over the residential house situated in the retained 6
guntas of land. The agreement of sale obtained by C.W.1
as GPA holder, which is a contemporaneous document and
forms
the
transaction,
very
foundation
clearly
indicates
of
the
that
subsequent
sale
guntas
land
of
comprising a residential house and borewell were excluded
- 25 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
and retained by the original owners. The GPA, read
conjointly with the agreement of sale, unmistakably
reflects that the authority conferred upon the GPA holder
was coupled with interest, and the extent agreed to be
conveyed was confined to 36 guntas, excluding the
retained portion.
30. When the GPA holder himself acknowledges that
6 guntas of land comprising a residential house and
borewell were retained by the defendants’ family, the
plaintiffs, who claim under a sale deed executed by the
said GPA holder, cannot assert a contrary position. Any
attempt by the plaintiffs to expand the scope of their
purchase so as to include the retained residential house is
clearly impermissible. Though the learned Senior Counsel
for the defendants sought to draw support from certain
admissions said to have been elicited from the defendants
during cross-examination, this Court is of the opinion that
such admissions do not materially advance the plaintiffs’
case, particularly in the face of the clear and categorical
- 26 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
admissions of C.W.1 and the recitals contained in the
documents.
31. This Court further finds that the plaintiffs could
not have maintained the present suit for possession in the
form in which it is laid. While it may be arguable that the
plaintiffs have acquired title to Site No.34 carved out of
the converted extent of 33 guntas, their attempt to seek
possession
of
a
residential
house,
which
is
neither
reflected in the sale deed nor situated within the converted
extent, creates a serious cloud over their title and gives
rise
to
a
substantial
dispute.
The
defendants
have
specifically pleaded that the suit in its present form is not
maintainable. Though the learned counsel for the plaintiffs
sought to contend that the principles laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in Anathula Sudhakar vs. P. Buchi
Reddy (Dead) by LRs. and Others1 are inapplicable to
the facts of the present case, the learned Senior Counsel
(2008) 4 SCC 594
- 27 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
for
the
defendants
has
rightly
drawn
attention
to
paragraph 17(a) of the said judgment.
32. The Hon’ble Apex Court has clearly held that
where a plaintiff seeks possession based on title and the
title is seriously disputed or a cloud is raised over it, the
plaintiff is bound to seek a declaration of title. The
contention that such principles apply only to suits for
injunction and not to suits for possession is misconceived.
Even in a suit for possession founded on title, when the
defendant raises a substantial and bona fide dispute as to
title,
a
mere
suit
for
possession
without
seeking
declaration would not be maintainable. In the present
case, the agreement of sale and the GPA, which are
contemporaneous
documents,
clearly
align
with
the
defence narrative that 6 guntas were retained by the
defendants’ family and that the residential house is
situated
therein.
The
GPA
holder
has
himself
acknowledged in the agreement that the retained portion
comprises a residential house. In these circumstances, the
- 28 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
plaintiffs ought to have sought an appropriate declaratory
relief.
33. In light of the foregoing discussion, this Court is
constrained to hold that the learned Trial Judge has
misapplied the settled principles of law, misread the
evidence on record
and misdirected
himself on the
question of burden of proof. In a suit for possession based
on title, the initial and primary burden lies upon the
plaintiffs to establish that they have acquired valid and
subsisting title to the property in respect of which
possession is sought. Having purchased Site No.34 carved
out of the converted extent of 33 guntas, the plaintiffs
cannot
enlarge
the
scope
of
their
claim
and
seek
possession of a residential house situated in the retained 6
guntas, which, as per the admissions of C.W.1, never
formed part of the converted layout.
34. The mere fact that the defendants have denied
the transaction in its entirety does not relieve the plaintiffs
- 29 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
of their obligation to prove their title to the specific
property claimed. On a closer scrutiny of the written
statement,
it
is
evident
that
the
defendants
have
consistently asserted their right over the retained 6 guntas
and the residential house standing thereon. Therefore, any
perceived admissions in the pleadings cannot override the
clear
documentary
evidence
and
the
categorical
admissions of C.W.1. The plaintiffs, having approached the
Civil Court seeking possession on the strength of title,
were required to demonstrate that the residential house
formed part of the property conveyed under Ex.P.1. The
recitals in Ex.P.1, however, clearly indicate purchase of a
site, and C.W.1 has admitted that no residential house
exists within the converted extent of 33 guntas.
35. The findings recorded by the Trial Court, in
overlooking these material aspects, suffer from perversity
and are palpably erroneous for want of proper appreciation
of evidence. The Trial Court has failed to advert to the true
import of the title document and the admissions of the
- 30 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
GPA holder. While the plaintiffs may legitimately claim
ownership over Site No.34, they cannot, under the guise
of such title, seek recovery of a residential house which is
demonstrably situated in the retained portion of 6 guntas.
The testimony of C.W.1, read in conjunction with the
recitals in Ex.P.1 and the agreement of sale, decisively
clinches the issue.
36. Accordingly, for the reasons stated above, Point
Nos.(i) and (ii) are answered in the "Negative".
Conclusions and Reasons for Reversal
37.
The learned Trial Judge has fundamentally
misread the pleadings and the nature of the property
involved in the suit. The plaint schedule and the recitals in
the registered
sale deed
dated
08.03.2002
(Ex.P.1)
unequivocally disclose that the plaintiffs purchased a
vacant site bearing No.34 carved out of a converted
extent. The sale deed expressly records delivery of
possession of the said site. However, contrary to the clear
- 31 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
tenor of their own title document, the plaintiffs have
sought possession of an already existing residential house,
which, as admitted by C.W.1 — the GPA holder of
Narayanappa — was situated in the retained 6 guntas and
never formed part of the converted layout. The suit claim,
therefore, travels far beyond the scope of the conveyance
under Ex.P.1.
38. In that view of the matter, the finding of the Trial
Court that the plaintiffs have succeeded in proving that the
defendants
are
in
unauthorized
possession
of
the
residential house is perverse and directly contrary to the
documentary evidence on record. The conclusion reached
by the Trial Court overlooks the specific recitals in Ex.P.1
and proceeds on an erroneous assumption that the
residential structure forms part of Site No.34, though no
such recital is found in the title deed.
39. The Trial Court has further committed a serious
error in shifting the burden of proof onto the defendants
- 32 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
on the ground that they did not challenge the GPA and
sale deed. In a suit for possession based on title, the
primary burden lies squarely on the plaintiffs to establish
that the property in respect of which possession is sought
forms part of their conveyance. The defendants’ consistent
case has been that 6 guntas, comprising a residential
house and borewell, were retained. This position is fortified
by the categorical admissions of the GPA holder examined
as
C.W.1.
Therefore,
the real
issue
which
required
adjudication was whether the plaintiffs, on the strength of
the registered sale deed dated 08.03.2002 (Ex.P.1), could
lawfully claim possession of a residential house admittedly
not covered under the GPA and agreement to sell relating
to 36 guntas. The Trial Court failed to address this core
issue.
40. The learned Judge has also grossly erred in
ignoring the crucial admissions elicited in the crossexamination
of
C.W.1.
The
GPA
holder
has
clearly
admitted that out of 36 guntas agreed to be conveyed,
- 33 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
only
guntas
were
converted
for
non-agricultural
purposes, while 3 guntas were utilized for road formation.
He has further admitted that all sites formed in the
converted 33 guntas have been alienated and that none of
those
sites
comprised
unequivocally
stated
a
that
residential
the
house.
residential
He
has
house
and
borewell are situated in the retained 6 guntas and that
defendant
No.1
continues
to
reside
therein.
These
admissions strike at the very root of the plaintiffs’ claim,
yet the Trial Court has failed to assign due weight to them.
41. The Trial Court has also overlooked the material
inconsistency between the recital in Ex.P.1 recording
delivery of possession on the date of execution and the
plaint averment alleging that the defendants sought time
to vacate the residential house. This contradiction raises a
serious doubt regarding the plaintiffs’ version and casts a
cloud over the true nature of the property claimed. The
Trial Court failed to reconcile or even examine this
material inconsistency.
- 34 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
42. The suit, in the form presented, was not
maintainable. When a serious dispute was raised regarding
the identity and extent of the property and when the
plaintiffs sought to extend their claim beyond the recitals
of the registered sale deed, they were bound to seek
declaratory relief. The failure to do so renders the decree
for possession unsustainable in law.
43.
The
Trial
Court
has
misdirected
itself
in
appreciating the burden of proof. Instead of insisting that
the plaintiffs strictly establish that the residential house
formed part of Site No.34, the Court erroneously drew
adverse
inference
against
the
defendants
for
not
challenging the sale deed, though the defendants’ case
was that the house was never conveyed. Such approach is
legally
untenable
and
contrary
to
settled
principles
governing suits for possession based on title.
44. The impugned judgment suffers from nonconsideration
of
material
evidence,
misreading
of
- 35 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
documentary recitals, and erroneous application of legal
principles. The findings recorded are therefore vitiated by
perversity and cannot be sustained.
45. In view of the clear recitals contained in the
Agreement of Sale, the categorical admissions made by
C.W.1 in his sworn testimony, and the unambiguous
description of the property conveyed under Ex.P.1, this
Court conclusively holds that the residential house situated
in the retained 6 guntas never formed part of the property
conveyed to the plaintiffs, and therefore, the plaintiffs are
not entitled to seek possession of the said residential
house on the strength of the sale deed dated 08.03.2002.
46. The plaintiffs, having admittedly purchased Site
No.34 under a registered sale deed, are presumed in law
to have exercised due diligence prior to entering into the
transaction. A prudent purchaser of immovable property is
expected to verify the parent documents of title, examine
the layout plan, ascertain the nature and extent of the
- 36 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
property conveyed, inspect the physical features of the
land, and satisfy himself as to possession and boundaries
before completing the purchase. When the sale deed itself
clearly describes a vacant site bearing No.34 carved out of
a converted extent, an irresistible inference arises that the
plaintiffs were fully aware of the nature of the property
purchased.
47. In spite of such clarity in the title deed, the
plaintiffs have chosen to set up a claim over a residential
house situated in a retained portion of 6 guntas, which, as
discussed supra, never formed part of the converted
layout
nor of
the
conveyance
in
their
favour.
The
institution of the suit in the year 2003, asserting a claim
beyond the recitals of their own document, has resulted in
protracted litigation spanning over two decades. The
defendants have been compelled to defend their lawful
possession and title over the retained residential house for
nearly 23 years. The matter has traversed through trial,
appeal, remand for
additional evidence,
and
further
- 37 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
consideration
before
this
Court,
thereby
entailing
substantial expenditure, loss of time, and mental agony to
the defendants.
48. This Court cannot lose sight of the fact that the
appeal has been pending since 2011 and that, pursuant to
the remand order, additional evidence had to be recorded,
resulting in further delay and costs. The defendants have
thus
been
dragged
into
unwarranted
and
avoidable
litigation on account of a claim which, on the face of the
documents, was unsustainable. Courts cannot encourage
such speculative or overreaching claims, particularly when
they are contrary to the recitals of a registered instrument
executed in favour of the very party who approaches the
Court.
49. In these circumstances, this Court is of the
considered view that the present suit not only lacks merit
but also warrants imposition of exemplary costs. The
plaintiffs, having invoked the jurisdiction of the Civil Court
- 38 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
on
a
misconceived
claim
and
having
subjected
the
defendants to prolonged and unnecessary litigation, must
bear the consequences in terms of costs. Accordingly, the
suit deserves to be dismissed with exemplary costs so as
to compensate the defendants and to send a clear
message that frivolous and overreaching claims will not be
countenanced by Courts of law.
50. For all the aforesaid reasons, the judgment and
decree of the Trial Court are liable to be set aside, and the
suit filed by the plaintiffs deserves to be dismissed with
costs.
51. For the foregoing reasons, this Court passes the
following:
ORDER
i.
The Regular First Appeal is hereby allowed.
ii.
The judgment and decree dated 09.12.2010
passed in O.S.No.9132/2003 by the Trial Court
are set aside.
- 39 NC: 2026:KHC:10729
RFA No. 135 of 2011
HC-KAR
iii.
Consequently, the suit filed by the plaintiffs in
O.S. No.9132/2003 stands dismissed.
iv.
The
plaintiffs
shall
pay
costs
quantified
at
Rs.50,000/- (Rupees Fifty Thousand only) to the
defendants within a period of eight weeks from
the date of receipt of certified copy of this
judgement.
v.
In the event of failure to pay the said costs within
the stipulated period, the defendants are at
liberty to recover the same in accordance with
law.
vi.
Draw decree accordingly.
Sd/(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM)
JUDGE
HDK
List No.: 1 Sl No.: 4
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review