The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. As such, the impugned order is set aside. The learned appellate court shall take a fresh decision on the prayer of the appellants/petitioners herein for adducing of additional evidence in terms of Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC without granting unnecessary adjournments to the parties. Let it be made clear that no observation made hereinabove would be treated as comments on the merits of the case of the parties or the prayer made by the Appellants for adducing additional evidence.
11. The instant revision petition is disposed of. Pending application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of. (APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ Pijush/
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CRP No.40 of 2023
Smt. Hiranbala Malla & others
......... Petitioner(s);
Versus
Smt. Ramani Bala Malla & others
.........Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent(s) :
Mr. Ratan Datta, Advocate.
None.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
Order
24/11/2023
Heard Mr. Ratan Datta, learned counsel for the petitioners. Despite
valid service of notice, respondents have not entered appearance.
2.
Petitioners, who are the appellants in T.A. No.04/2022 before
learned Additional District Judge, South Tripura, Sabroom, have approached
this Court on rejection of their prayer to adduce additional evidence under
Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 [CPC, for short]. The
Title Suit No.13/2008 was instituted by the plaintiffs/respondents herein for
declaration of right, title and interests of the plaintiffs over the land described in
Schedule-A of the plaint and also for a direction upon the defendants to deliver
the vacant possession of the lands described in Schedule-B of the plaint with
cost. Schedule-A of the suit property is 0.82 acres of land being portion of
Mouja Chetakchar (Satak Sori), under Sabroom Tehsil Kachari, comprising in
Khatian No.371, stated in CS (Old) Plot No.328 and 327/1211, now stated in
CS (New) Plot Nos.897 and 898. The suit was disposed of in favour of the
plaintiffs on 30.07.2011. In second appeal, the matter was remanded to the Trial
Court and subsequently on fresh trial, the suit was once again adjudicated and
judgment was delivered on 08.04.2019. On the second occasion also, the suit
was decreed in favour of the plaintiffs, whereafter the T.A. No.04/2022 has
been preferred by the aggrieved defendants, who are the petitioners herein.
3.
The chronology of facts above and the pleadings on record
indicate the checkered history of the litigation between the parties. The
plaintiffs had set up a case that predecessor of the plaintiffs Late Himangshu
Malla got allotment of 0.82 acres of land in Mouja Chetak Chari as described in
Schedule-A and reclaimed the same and constructed his home and hearth
thereupon. The defendants of the suit, who are full blooded brother of the
predecessor of the plaintiffs, came to India and were permitted to live in the
house complex of the plaintiff’s predecessor considering their miserable
condition. After the death of the predecessor of the plaintiff, the legal
representative of the plaintiff no.8 requested her uncle i.e. the defendant Sri
Narayan Malla to vacate the land and deliver the vacant possession of the suit
land; but he flatly denied. Hence, the suit for declaration of right, title and
interests of the plaintiffs was filed. In the written statement, the defendants took
a plea that the predecessor of the plaintiffs, Himangshu Malla was in possession
of the suit land except for a few days when he had been residing with the
defendant in the same family in 1975. During emergency, he managed to obtain
an order of allotment of the suit land from the Government behind the back of
the defendant and left Tripura for good immediately thereafter. The defendant
came to know about the allotment in the first week of August, 2008 and filed
application before the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sabroom, South Tripura for
cancellation of said allotment. The defendants also made further averments
denying the claim of the plaintiffs.
4.
In this background, the present issue revolves around the prayer of
the defendants/appellants, who are legal heirs of the original defendant, for
adducing additional evidence in the nature of an inquiry report submitted by the
Revenue Inspector, Sabroom, South Tripura bearing letter No.218 dated
21.11.2012 to the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Sabroom, South Tripura. The
appellants in their application before the learned Court under Order XLI Rule
27 of the CPC contended that the fate of the said cancellation proceedings was
never communicated to the applicants/appellants which was initiated by son of
the original defendant, Sri Pradip Malla. After frantic search, they have found
that the cancellation proceeding was disposed of on 05.03.2014 on the ground
of pendency of the matter in the High Court. Appellants further contended that
they had never gone to the High Court for cancellation proceedings, as it was
entirely in the domain of the Allotment Authority, and not within the
jurisdiction of the Civil Court.
5.
Referring to the contents of the inquiry report dated 21.11.2012
specifically paragraph 4 onwards, Mr. Datta, learned counsel for the petitioners,
submits that the allottee i.e. the plaintiff’s predecessor was found to have not
used the allotted land within two years from the date of allotment as per the
condition imposed under the TLR & LR (Allotment of Land) Rules, 1980 and
as such, the aforesaid land particulars could be recorded as khas land to the
Government of Tripura. The report also mentions that the applicant’s opposite
party i.e. Smt. Swapna Malla/plaintiff No.8, daughter of Late Himangshu
Kumar Malla, the allottee, had also filed a case before the Sub-Divisional
Judicial Magistrate, Sabroom for eviction from the land which was pending.
Learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the instant Title Suit instituted
by Swapna Malla is the case which has been referred to by the Revenue
Inspector in his report dated 21.11.2012. It is submitted that the instant
documents could not be obtained despite due diligence during the proceedings
of the suit though they have a significant bearing on the outcome of the dispute
between the parties which is pending before the learned Appellate Court. In
such circumstances, the prayer for adducing additional evidence under Order
XLI Rule 27 of the CPC was made. It is submitted that the learned Appellate
Court has, on the first date itself, rejected the prayer without even calling for
response from the plaintiffs/respondents and without considering whether the
document in question was material or not for pronouncing judgment. An
application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC is to be considered at the time
of hearing of appeal on merits, so as to find out whether the documents and/or
the evidence sought to be adduced have any relevance or bearing on the issue
involved. This position stands settled in view of the decision rendered by the
Apex Court in a number of cases such as Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin &
another reported in (2012) 8 SCC 148 and has been profitably referred to in the
case of A. Andisamy Chettiar v. A. Subburaj Chettiar reported in AIR 2016
SC 79 at Paragraph 16.
6.
It is submitted that perusal of the impugned order would show that
the parties were asked to make their points of arguments on the next date; but
before the hearing of the appeal on merits, the learned Appellate Court has
rejected the application for adducing additional evidence without considering
the grounds laid down under Order XLI Rule 27 as to whether such additional
evidence was worthy to be allowed to be adduced at the appellate stage by the
defendants/appellants/petitioners herein. In view of the interim order, the
appeal is pending. The respondents do not appear to be interested in contesting
the plea raised by the petitioners herein as despite valid service of notice, they
have not chosen to appear. In such circumstances, the matter may be remitted to
the appellate court for fresh consideration on the prayer for adducing additional
evidence in accordance with law after due opportunity to the other side.
7.
I have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
petitioners and taken note of the relevant materials placed from the record. I
have also gone through the impugned order and the decision cited on behalf of
the petitioners.
8.
The factual background leading to the present controversy needs
no reiteration at this stage, lest it would affect the merits of the prayer made by
the petitioners for adducing additional evidence before the learned appellate
court. However, it is apparent from perusal of the impugned order dated
02.08.2023 that the learned appellate court has, in a cryptic manner before the
stage of hearing of the appeal on merits, rejected the prayer for adducing
additional evidence without dealing with the specific grounds as are required to
be made out and dealt with in terms of Order XLI Rule 27 of the CPC. Order
XLI Rule 27 is extracted hereunder :
“27. Production of additional evidence in Appellate Court. - (1) The parties
to an appeal shall not be entitled to produce additional evidence, whether oral or
documentary, in the Appellate Court. But if –
(a) the Court from whose decree the appeal is preferred has refused to
admit evidence which ought to have been admitted, or
[(aa) the party seeking to produce additional evidence, establishes that
notwithstanding the exercise of due diligence, such evidence was not within
his knowledge or could not, after the exercise of due diligence, be produced
by him at the time when the decree appealed against was passed, or]
(b) the Appellate Court requires any document to be produced or any
witness to be examined to enable it to pronounce judgment, or for any other
substantial cause,
the Appellate Court may allow such evidence or document to be produced or
witness to be examined.”
9.
As such, since the appeal is at the stage of hearing in the fitness of
things, the prayer of the appellants/petitioners herein requires to be considered
afresh by the learned appellate court in accordance with law. In this regard, it is
apposite to refer to the opinion expressed by the Apex Court as relied upon and
referred to in the case of A. Andisamy Chettiar (supra) at Paragraph 16 quoted
hereunder:
“16. In Union of India v. Ibrahim Uddin and another, this Court has held as
under:“49. An application under Order 41 Rule 27 CPC is to be considered at
the time of hearing of appeal on merits so as to find out whether the documents
and/or the evidence sought to be adduced have any relevance/bearing on the
issues involved. The admissibility of additional evidence does not depend upon
the relevancy to the issue on hand, or on the fact, whether the applicant had an
opportunity for adducing such evidence at an earlier stage or not, but it depends
upon whether or not the appellate court requires the evidence sought to be
adduced to enable it to pronounce judgment or for any other substantial cause.
The true test, therefore is, whether the appellate court is able to pronounce
judgment on the materials before it without taking into consideration the
additional evidence sought to be adduced ...........”
10.
As such, the impugned order is set aside. The learned appellate
court shall take a fresh decision on the prayer of the appellants/petitioners
herein for adducing of additional evidence in terms of Order XLI Rule 27 of the
CPC without granting unnecessary adjournments to the parties. Let it be made
clear that no observation made hereinabove would be treated as comments on
the merits of the case of the parties or the prayer made by the Appellants for
adducing additional evidence.
11.
The instant revision petition is disposed of. Pending application(s),
if any, shall stand disposed of.
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
Pijush/
MUNNA SAHA
Date: 2023.11.29 14:41:27 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review