Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.48 of 2024
1.
Smt. Gita Rani Sarkar
W/O Late Ranjit Sarkar.
2.
Sri Sangram Sarkar, (Minor)
S/o Late Ranjit Sarkar.
3.
Sri Samir Sarkar,
S/o Late Ranjit Sarkar
All are residents of Chandrapur Colony No. 6,
P.O. and P.S. R. K. Pur, Udaipur.
Dist:- Gomati Tripura.
4.
Smti Bipula Sarkar
W/o Sri Pradip Sarkar,
D/o Late Ranjit Sarkar,
Resident of Laxmipati Purba Para,
P.O. and P.S. R.K. Pur.
Dist:- Gomati Tripura.
(Claimant Petitioner No.2 being minor is represented by his
mother and natural guardian i.e. claimant petitioner No.1)
------ Appellants
Versus
1.
Sri Babul Chandra Paul,
S/o Late Asutosh Chandra Paul,
Resident of Matabari, Udaipur,
P.O. and P.S. R.K. Pur,
Dist:- Gomati Tripura.
(Owner cum driver of the vehicle bearing
Registration No.TR-03-3738, Cruiser Jeep)
2.
United India Insurance Company Ltd.,
Udaipur Branch, Subhash road, Udaipur,
Mantribari Road, Agartala,
P.S. R.K. Pur, Dist:- Gomati Tripura,
(Insurer of vehicle No.TR-03-3738, Cuiser Jeep).
------ Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Ms. R. Majumder, Adv,
Mr. B. Banerjee, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. P. Gautam, Adv.
Date of hearing
:
02.12.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment & Order
:
07.12.2024
Whether fit for
reporting
:
YES
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal under Section 173 of M.V. Act is preferred by
the appellant-claimant petitioners challenging the judgment and
award dated 31.05.2023 delivered by Learned Member, MAC
Tribunal No.2, Gomati District Udaipur in connection with case
No.TS(MAC) No.50 of 2021. By the said judgment and award,
Learned Tribunal below has awarded a sum of Rs.9,41,200/along with 6% interest from the date of filing the claim petition
i.e. w.e.f 11.08.2021 to till the date of realization.
2.
Heard Learned Counsel Mr. B. Banerjee and Ms. R.
Majumder appearing for the appellant-claimant petitioners and
also heard Learned Counsel, Mr. P. Gautam representing the
respondent No.2-United India Insurance Company Ltd. None
appears on behalf of the respondent No.1 inspite of service of
notice.
3.
Taking part in the hearing, Learned Counsel for the
appellants first of all drawn the attention of the Court regarding
determination of monthly income by the Learned Tribunal below.
According
to
Learned
Counsel,
in
para
No.14
of
the
judgment/award, Learned Tribunal below determined the daily
income of the deceased as Rs.400/- per day and accordingly,
determined the monthly income of the deceased at the rate of
Rs.8,000/- per month calculating 20 working days a month
which is not at all permissible and sustainable in the eye of law.
According to Learned Counsel for the appellants, it ought to have
Rs.500/- per day as the accident occurred during the year 2020
and for 30 working days, it should be minimum Rs.15,000/- per
month but the Learned Tribunal below without considering the
actual condition has only determined the monthly income of the
deceased for 20 working days at the rate of Rs.8,000/- per
month which was too less and for that, Learned Counsel urged
for interference of this Court by setting aside the judgment.
Learned
Counsel
further
submitted
that
under
conventional head, Rs.15,000/- was awarded as loss of estate,
Rs.40,000/- as loss of consortium and Rs.15,000/- towards
funeral expenses but in view of the principle of law laid down by
the Hon’ble Apex Court in National Insurance Company
Limited v. Pranay Sethi & others reported in AIR 2017 SC
5157, the said amount should be enhanced after three years but
at the time of delivery of judgment, the said principle of law was
not taken into consideration by the Learned Tribunal below. So,
Learned Counsel finally urged for allowing this appeal.
4.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel for the Insurance
Company fairly submitted that the Learned Tribunal below
considering the oral and documentary evidence on record rightly
determined the monthly income of the deceased at Rs.8,000/per month and there was no infirmity in the judgment of the
Learned Tribunal below and urged for dismissal of this appeal
upholding the judgment of the Learned Tribunal below.
5.
Here in the case at
hand, the appellant-claimant
petitioners filed one claim petition before the Learned Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal No.2, Gomati District, Udaipur alleging
inter alia that on 26.09.2020 at about 18:30 hours, Ranjit Sarkar
(deceased) was proceeding towards his house from Kali Mandir,
Chandrapur Colony by walking keeping the extreme left side of
Sabroom-Agartala road and when said Ranjit Sarkar reached
near Kali Mandir, Chandrapur Colony No.7, that time, one vehicle
bearing registration No.TR-03-3738 (Cruiser Jeep) came from
Santirbazar side with an abnormal speed in rash and negligent
manner and dashed against said Ranjir Sarkar for which said
Ranjit Sarkar received grievous injuries on head, chest and other
vital parts of the body. After the accident, the victim was taken
to Gomati District Hospital by the Fire Service vehicle, but during
treatment on the same day at about 22:00 hours the victim
succumbed to his injury.
6.
Accordingly, R.K. Pur P.S. case No.03 of 2021 under
Section 279/338/304A of IPC was registered and accordingly, the
appellant-claimant petitioners filed the claim petition before the
Learned Tribunal below.
7.
Before the Tribunal, the O.P.-owner cum rider appeared
by filing written statement denying the assertions of the
claimant-petitioners and it was further asserted that the accident
did not occur due to the fault of the owner-cum-driver and the
O.P. No.1 also asserted that the vehicle had valid registration
and other relevant documents and the same was insured with
O.P. No.2 on that relevant point of time and the driver had valid
driving licence. The Insurance Company also contested the case
by filing written statement and denied the assertions of the
claimant-petitioners and it was further submitted that the claim
petition was subjected to strict proof by the claimant petitioners.
8.
Upon the pleadings of the parties, two nos. of issues
were framed by the Learned Tribunal below. To substantiate the
issues,
both
the
parties
have
adduced
oral/documentary
evidence on record and finally, on conclusion of hearing of
argument, Learned Tribunal below by the judgment and award
dated 31.05.2023 allowed the claim petition filed by the
claimant-petitioners.
The
operative
portion
of
the
judgment/award runs as follows:
ORDER
“16. In the result, it is hereby ordered that the
claimant-petitioners
are
entitled
to
get
compensation of Rs.9,41,200 (Rupees nine lacs
forty one thousand two hundred) only. The OP
No.2 i.e. the OP No.2 United India Insurance
Co. Ltd., the insurer of the offending vehicle
bearing Registration No.TR-03-3738 (Cruiser
Jeep) is directed to make the payment of
compensation
to
the
claimant-petitioners
within 30 (thirty) days from today along with
interest thereon @ 6% per annum from the
date of filing of cliam petition, i.e., from
11.08.2021 till payment/realization of the
same.
17. Out of the said amount the claimantpetitioner No.1 is entitled to get Rs.3,00,100/and rest three claimant-petitioner Nos.2, 3 & 4
each are entitled to get an amount of
Rs.2,13,700/-. The claimant-petitioner No.1 be
paid Rs.1,50,100/- in her favour out of her
amount of Rs.3,00,100/- and rest amount of
Rs.1,50,000/- should be kept in fixed deposit in
her respective account in any Nationalized
Bank for the period of 5(five) years. The total
amount of Rs.2,13,700/- of the claimantpetitioner No.2 be kept in fixed deposit in his
respective account in any Nationalized Bank for
the period of 10(ten) years or till his attaining
the majority whichever is earlier. The claimantpetitioner No.3 & 4 each be paid Rs.50,000/- in
their favour out of the amount of Rs.2,13,700/and rest amount of Rs.1,63,700/- each should
be kept in fixed deposit in their respective
account in any Nationalized Bank for the period
of 5(five) years. In the case in which
investment in long term in the nature of fixed
deposit is made on condition that the Bank will
not permit any loan or advance on the Fixed
Deposit and interest on the amount invested is
paid monthly directly to the claimants or their
legal heir, as the case may be. Further the
claimant-petitioners are also granted liberty to
apply for withdrawal in case of an emergency.
To facilitate the payment of amount of the
claimant-petitioners and the fixed deposit
amount on maturity, the claimant-petitioners at
the appropriate time shall file photo copy of
their Bank Pass Book in their name containing
photograph, account number, IFSC number and
the RTGS number duly certified by the Banker
and a copy of Passport Size photograph before
making payment so as to enable this Tribunal
to transfer the amounts directly to his Bank
Account.
18. The case is disposed of on contest.
19. Enter the result in the relevant register.
20. Supply a copy of the award to the parties
free of cost and also email an authenticated
copy of the award to the insurer i.e. OP No.2 at
earliest.”
9.
I have heard both the sides at length and also perused
the judgment delivered by Learned Tribunal below.
On perusal of the judgment, it appears that in para
No.14 of the judgment, Learned Tribunal below came to the
observation that the deceased was earning Rs.400/- per day by
doing his job and treating that he was working for 20 days in a
month, assessed the monthly income at Rs.8000/- which in my
considered view was not proper because for a worker or
unskilled labourer, if we presume that he was earning Rs.400/per day still he might have worked during that time not less than
25 days in a month because in a given month, it may so happen
that he may not get work for all the days in a month. So,
considering the situation, in my considered view, if we count 25
working days of the deceased in a month that he worked, in that
case, at the rate of Rs.400/- per day as determined by the
Tribunal, his monthly income would be assessed to Rs.10,000/-.
If it is so, the calculation would be as follows:
Monthly income – Rs.10,000/- along with that amount, there
should be an addition of 10% of his yearly income in view of the
law laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court reported in AIR 2017
SC 5157 in National Insurance Copany Limited v. Pranay
Sethi & others as per para 61, sub-para (iv). Since the
deceased was aged about 51 years so the income of the
deceased towards future prospect would be 10% in addition i.e.
total income is Rs.1,32,000/- ((Rs.10,000 x 12) + Rs.12,000/i.e. 10% of Rs.1,20,000/-).
10.
Then, along with that amount, there would be multiplier
of 11 in pursuance of the judgment of Smt. Sarala Verma &
Ors. V. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. reported in
(2009) 6 SCC 121 as per para 21. Since the deceased was 51
years, so, the total loss of dependency would be Rs.1,32,000 X
11 = Rs.14,52,000/-.
From the said amount, there would be 1/4th of deduction
on account of personal and living expenses of the deceased since
the deceased, was a married person. So, after deduction, total
contribution
to
the
family
(dependents)
would
comes
to
Rs.10,89,000/- i.e. (Rs.14,52,000/- - (1/4 X 14,52,000/-) i.e.
Rs.3,63,000/-).
11.
Thereafter, the Learned Tribunal below also awarded
Rs.15,000/- as loss of estate, Rs.40,000/- as loss of consortium
and Rs.15,000/- as funeral expense. Thus, total amount of
Rs.70,000/-(Rs.15,000/- + Rs.40,000/- + Rs.15,000/-) comes
under conventional head.
12.
Further, as submitted by Learned Counsel for the
appellant-claimant petitioners at the time of hearing of argument
regarding enhancement of 10% in a span of 3 years in respect of
conventional heads, I have also seen the judgment of the
Hon’ble Apex Court in National Insurance Company Limited
v. Pranay Sethi and others reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680
wherein in para No.52, Hon’ble Apex Court observed as under:
“52. As far as the conventional heads are
concerned, we find it difficult to agree with
the view expressed in Rajesh v. Rajbir Singh
:(2013) 9 SCC 54. It has granted Rs 25,000
towards funeral expenses, Rs 1,00,000
towards loss of consortium and Rs 1,00,000
towards loss of care and guidance for minor
children. The head relating to loss of care
and minor children does not exist. Though
Rajesh (supra) refers to Santosh Devi v.
National Insurance Company Ltd. :(2012) 6
SCC 421, it does not seem to follow the
same. The conventional and traditional
heads,
needless
to
say,
cannot
be
determined on percentage basis because
that would not be an acceptable criterion.
Unlike determination of income, the said
heads
have
to
be
quantified.
Any
quantification must have a reasonable
foundation. There can be no dispute over the
fact that price index, fall in bank interest,
escalation of rates in many a field have to be
noticed. The court cannot remain oblivious to
the same. There has been a thumb rule in
this aspect. Otherwise, there will be extreme
difficulty in determination of the same and
unless the thumb rule is applied, there will
be immense variation lacking any kind of
consistency as a consequence of which, the
orders passed by the tribunals and courts are
likely to be unguided. Therefore, we think it
seemly to fix reasonable sums. It seems to
us that reasonable figures on conventional
heads, namely, loss of estate, loss of
consortium and funeral expenses should be
Rs 15,000, Rs 40,000 and Rs 15,000
respectively. The principle of revisting the
said heads is an acceptable principle. But the
revisit
should
not
be
fact-centric
or
quantum-centric. We think that it would be
condign that the amount that we have
quantified
should
be
enhanced
on
percentage basis in every three years and
the enhancement should be at the rate of
10% in a span of three years. We are
disposed to hold so because that will bring in
consistency in respect of those heads.”
13.
The accident took place in the year 2020. Under
conventional heads, Learned Tribunal below has already awarded
Rs.70,000/-. So, in view of the principle of law laid down by the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the aforenoted case, the appellantpetitioner also would get additional amount Rs.7000/- (10% of
Rs.70,000/- under conventional heads). Thus, the total amount
of compensation after counting all factors would comes to
Rs.11,66,000/- (Rs10,89,000/- + Rs.70,000/- + Rs.7,000/-).
14.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellants is
hereby partly allowed with modification that the appellantclaimant petitioners would get Rs.11,66,000/- as compensation
with 6% interest per annum from the date of filing the claim
petition i.e. w.e.f. 11.08.2021 to till the date of realization. The
respondent-Insurance Company be asked to deposit the said
amount within a period of 6(six) weeks from today to the
Registry of the High Court, if not yet deposited. However, the
disbursal
of amount
of compensation would
be
made
in
pursuance of the judgment and award dated 31.05.2023
delivered by the Learned Tribunal below.
With this observation, this appeal is disposed of. A copy
of this judgment be supplied to Learned Counsel for the
appellant-claimant-petitioners. Also, a copy of this judgment be
furnished to Learned Counsel for the respondent-Insurance
Company.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of this judgment.
Pending applications(s), if any, also stands disposed of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA
DATTA
Deepshikha
DATTA
Date: 2024.12.09 10:35:06
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review