Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
NAFR
Digitally
RAGHVENDRA signed by
JAT
RAGHVENDRA
JAT
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 8228 of 2023
Order Reserved on : 19.01.2026
Order Delivered on : 28.02.2026
• Smt. Dutiya Pradhan W/o Khemsagar Pradhan, Aged About 45
Years R/o Village Lara, Tahsil Tahsil Pusour, District Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner
versus
1. Smt. Kanti Chauhan W/o Pratap Chauhan, Aged About 48 Years
R/o Village Lara, Tahsil Pusour, District Raigarh, Chhattisgarh.
2. Chief Executive
Chhattisgarh.
Officer,
Janpad
Pusour,
District
Raigarh
3. Collector, District Raigarh, Collector Marg, Chandra Nagar Colony,
Kelo Vihar, Raigarh, Chhattisgarh 496001.
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Hemant Gupta, Advocate.
For Respondent/ State
:
Mr. Hariom Rai, Panel Lawyer.
For Respondent No. 1
:
Ms. Mahima Tandan, Advocate
appearing on behalf of Mr. Shiv
Kumar Banjare, Advocate.
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
C.A.V. Order
1.
The petitioner is assailing the order dated 22.09.2023 passed in
Case No. 83/A89/2021-22 by the learned Court of the Additional
Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur, Camp at Raigarh
(Chhattisgarh), whereby the learned Additional Commissioner set
aside the order dated 07.02.2023 passed by the Collector in Case
No. 6/A89/2020-21 (dated 07.10.2022) and allowed the revision
petition filed by respondent No.1. Being aggrieved by the said
order, the present petition has been preferred seeking following
reliefs :“10.1 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue order/orders, writ/writs and
direction/directions by set aside / quashing the
order impugned dated 22-09-2023 passed by
the
Lt.
Commissioner
in
R.
Case
no.
83/A-89/2021-22.
10.2 This Hon'ble Court may kindly be issue
direction and direct the respondent authority
to strictly comply with orders / circulars of the
State Govt.
10.3 Any other relief/relief's, which this
Hon'ble Court may think fit and proper in the
facts and circumstances of the case, with cost
of the petition, may also please be granted to
the petitioner.”
2.
Facts of the case, in a nutshell, are that the petitioner is a duly
selected and working candidate on the post of Worker –
Anganwadi at Mini Anganwadi Kendra, Lara–1, District Raigarh.
She has been discharging her duties in accordance with the
applicable rules and government policies. Initially, Respondent
No.1 was selected and appointed as Worker – Anganwadi at Mini
Anganwadi Kendra, Lara–1, District Raigarh. However, her
services were terminated vide order dated 06.01.2017 passed by
Respondent No.2 in Order No. 410/Est/A.BA.V.P.RE/2016-17.
Aggrieved by the said termination, Respondent No.1 preferred an
appeal
before
Respondent
No.3,
the
Collector,
Raigarh,
registered as Appeal No. 96/A-89/2016-17, on various grounds.
The said appeal was dismissed by Respondent No.3 vide order
dated 27.06.2017. It is pertinent to mention that Respondent No.1
did not challenge the order dated 27.06.2017 passed by the
Collector, Raigarh, before any higher forum. No appeal, revision,
or petition was preferred thereafter, and consequently, the said
order attained finality. Subsequently, the State Government again
issued an advertisement inviting applications for the post of
Worker – Anganwadi at Mini Anganwadi Kendra, Lara–1, District
Raigarh. Respondent No.1, by suppressing the material fact of
her earlier termination and dismissal of appeal, participated in the
selection process and was appointed on the said post vide order
dated 15.07.2020. Being aggrieved by the appointment of
Respondent No.1, the petitioner preferred an appeal before
Respondent No.3, the Collector, Raigarh, inter alia relying upon
the
State
Government
circulars
dated
02.04.2008
and
25.01.2019, which govern eligibility and selection criteria for
Anganwadi workers. The appeal preferred by the petitioner was
allowed by Respondent No.3, the Collector, Raigarh, vide order
dated 07.02.2022, whereby the appointment of Respondent No.1
was set aside. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted a
representation dated 14.02.2022 before Respondent No. 2
seeking her appointment as a suitable and eligible candidate for
the post of Worker – Anganwadi. Thereafter, Respondent No.2
appointed the petitioner on the post of Worker – Anganwadi at
Mini Anganwadi Kendra, Lara–1, District Raigarh, vide order
dated 22.02.2022. After the petitioner joined her duties,
Respondent No.1 preferred a revision petition before the learned
Additional Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur, Camp at
Raigarh, on 08.03.2022, challenging the order dated 07.02.2022
passed by the Collector, Raigarh. The revision was registered as
Revision Case No. 83/A-89/2021-22. The petitioner also filed her
written submissions before the learned Additional Commissioner,
along with copies of the relevant State Government circulars
pertaining to eligibility and selection for the post of Anganwadi
Worker. However, the learned Additional Commissioner, while
ignoring the binding policy circulars of the State Government and
the submissions made by the petitioner, allowed the revision
petition filed by Respondent No.1.
Being aggrieved by the
impugned order passed by the learned Additional Commissioner,
which is arbitrary, illegal, and contrary to the settled government
policy, the petitioner has been constrained to invoke the
extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court by filing the present petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned order
passed by the learned Additional Commissioner is ex facie illegal,
arbitrary, and unsustainable in law. The action of the respondents,
particularly in allowing the revision petition preferred by
Respondent No.1, clearly reflects discrimination and hostile
treatment towards the petitioner and is violative of Articles 14 and
16 of the Constitution of India. The petitioner, who is a duly
selected and appointed Anganwadi Worker, has been deprived of
her legitimate right to continue on the post solely on account of an
arbitrary exercise of revisional jurisdiction. It is further submitted
that the learned Additional Commissioner adopted an unfair and
improper method while adjudicating the revision petition filed by
Respondent No.1. The revisional authority failed to apply the
settled
principles
governing
service
matters
and
acted
mechanically without due consideration of the factual background
and binding government policy. The impugned order does not
reflect any objective or reasoned analysis and, therefore, cannot
be sustained.
Learned counsel submits that the learned
Additional Commissioner completely ignored and overlooked the
State Government Circulars dated 02.04.2008 and 25.01.2019,
which
specifically
govern
eligibility,
appointment,
and
disqualification for the post of Anganwadi Worker. These circulars
were issued with the object of maintaining transparency and
fairness in the selection process and are binding on all authorities
functioning under the State Government. The failure to consider
and apply these circulars vitiates the impugned order and renders
it illegal. It is submitted that the order dated 07.02.2022 passed
by Respondent No.3, the Collector, Raigarh, was just, proper, and
in complete conformity with the aforesaid State Government
Circulars. The Collector, after due consideration of the facts and
applicable policy, rightly held that Respondent No.1 was ineligible
for appointment on the said post and set aside her appointment.
The said order was reasoned, lawful, and deserved to be
maintained. The learned Additional Commissioner erred in
interfering with the well-considered order of the Collector without
any justifiable ground.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that the impugned
order is wholly unjustified and suffers from serious legal
infirmities. The revisional authority committed a grave error by
ignoring the explicit provisions of the State Government Circulars,
thereby acting beyond its jurisdiction. Such disregard of binding
policy amounts to a colourable exercise of power and calls for
interference by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction. It is
specifically submitted that Respondent No.1 had earlier been
terminated from the post of Anganwadi Worker, and her appeal
against the said termination was dismissed by the competent
authority. In view of Clause 1.4 of the State Government Circular
dated 02.04.2008, a candidate who has been terminated from
service is not eligible for re-appointment to the same post. This
disqualification operates automatically and leaves no discretion
with the authorities. Therefore, the subsequent appointment of
Respondent No.1, obtained by suppressing material facts, was
void ab initio, and the impugned order restoring such an
appointment is contrary to law. Learned counsel submits that the
suppression of material facts by Respondent No.1 disentitles her
from any equitable relief. It is a settled principle of law that a
person who approaches the authority with unclean hands is not
entitled to any relief. The learned Additional Commissioner failed
to consider this crucial aspect while allowing the revision petition.
It is further submitted that the arbitrary and illegal order passed by
the learned Additional Commissioner has caused grave prejudice
to the petitioner. The petitioner, who was lawfully appointed
pursuant to a valid selection process and was discharging her
duties sincerely, has suffered serious consequences due to the
impugned order. Her service career and livelihood have been
adversely affected, causing irreparable loss and hardship.
Learned counsel also submits that the impugned order is nonspeaking and cryptic in nature, devoid of proper reasoning, and
fails to address the specific contentions raised by the petitioner in
her written submissions. Such an order does not satisfy the
requirement of a reasoned decision and is liable to be quashed on
this ground alone. In view of the aforesaid submissions, learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned order passed
by the learned Additional Commissioner deserves to be set
aside/quashed, and the order dated 07.02.2022 passed by
Respondent No.3, the Collector, Raigarh, deserves to be restored.
It is, therefore, prayed that this Court may be pleased to allow the
present petition in the interest of justice.
5.
Learned counsel for Respondent No.1 respectfully submits that
the present writ petition has been preferred by the petitioner under
Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking issuance of a writ
of mandamus. At the outset, it is submitted that the petition is
wholly misconceived, misleading, and devoid of merit, and is
liable to be dismissed at the threshold. It is submitted that the
petitioner has not approached this Court with clean hands and
has deliberately suppressed material and vital facts which go to
the very root of the matter. On this ground alone, the petition
deserves to be dismissed. The respondent further denies the
correctness, validity, and maintainability of the writ petition in its
entirety.
It is submitted that vide order dated 28.07.2018, the
Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat, Pusour, District
Raigarh, passed an order in favour of Respondent No.1 holding
that her earlier removal from service was wrongful and directing
that she be reinstated to her post, with a specific direction that no
further posting be made on the said post. The said order was
passed pursuant to a resolution of the General Body of the
Janpad Panchayat. This vital fact has been conveniently omitted
by the petitioner. The petitioner has distorted the factual matrix
and has deliberately withheld crucial documents relating to her
own removal from service. The petition is founded on selective
facts, half-truths, and misrepresentation, and therefore the entire
edifice of the writ petition collapses. It is emphatically denied that
Respondent No.1 obtained her appointment by suppression of
facts, misrepresentation, or by any unlawful means. Respondent
No.1 was duly selected and appointed strictly in accordance with
the
applicable
government
guidelines,
circulars,
and
recommendations of the competent authorities. All documents
submitted by Respondent No.1 were duly verified before issuance
of the appointment order. On the contrary, it is the petitioner who
had earlier been removed/terminated and failed to disclose this
vital fact during the subsequent selection process, thereby
disentitling herself from any equitable relief. It is submitted that
the Collector passed the earlier order dated 07.02.2022 without
proper appreciation of the petitioner’s ineligibility and without
considering her previous removal from service. The learned
Additional Commissioner, exercising revisional jurisdiction, after
detailed scrutiny of the entire record, rightly set aside the
erroneous order of the Collector and restored the lawful position.
The contention that the Revisional Authority ignored Government
circulars or acted contrary to law is wholly incorrect and
misleading.
Learned counsel further submits that the legal
grounds raised by the petitioner, including alleged violation of
principles of natural justice, discrimination, breach of circulars, or
arbitrary exercise of power, are frivolous, baseless, and
unsupported by any evidence. Respondent No.1 has strictly
adhered to every rule, guideline, and procedure applicable to the
appointment. No legal or fundamental right of the petitioner has
been infringed, nor has any prejudice been caused to her by the
acts of Respondent No.1. It is further submitted that the petitioner
has challenged the appointment of Respondent No.1 mainly on
the ground of alleged non-compliance with the State Government
circulars dated 02.04.2008 and 25.01.2019. However, the factual
matrix clearly demonstrates that Respondent No.1 was earlier
appointed on 29.04.2011 as Anganwadi Worker at Lara Dipapara
and had rendered more than six years of service. Her services
were terminated on 06.01.2017 on the ground of alleged
unauthorized absence, which termination was subsequently found
to be wrongful by the General Body of the Janpad Panchayat,
Pusour, resulting in a resolution dated 27.07.2018 for her
reinstatement. It is submitted that thereafter, an advertisement
was issued by the Janpad Panchayat, Pusour, for appointment to
the posts of Anganwadi Worker, Mini Anganwadi Worker, and
Anganwadi Assistant. Respondent No.1 participated in the
selection process and was appointed as Mini Anganwadi Worker
vide order dated 15.07.2020 following due procedure. Though the
appointment was initially set aside by the Collector on 07.02.2022,
the same was rightly restored by the learned Additional
Commissioner vide order dated 22.09.2023 upon a detailed
examination of the entire record.
Respondent No.1 has
continuously remained in service since 15.07.2020 and is
discharging her duties satisfactorily against a regular sanctioned
post. There has been no complaint whatsoever against her during
her tenure. Her appointment is legal, valid, and in consonance
with the applicable rules and policies.
6.
Learned counsel for the respondent No. 1 submits that the case
of Respondent No.1 is squarely covered by the law laid down by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka vs.
Uma Devi (2006) 4 SCC 1 and further clarified in Jaggo v. Union
of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826, wherein it has been held
that where appointments are not illegal but suffer from procedural
irregularities, the same cannot be brushed aside mechanically,
and the rights of employees cannot be defeated on hypertechnical grounds. It is further submitted that the termination of
Respondent No.1 on 06.01.2017 was wrongful, and the
subsequent resolution dated 27.07.2018 passed by the General
Body of the Janpad Panchayat, Pusour, clearly acknowledges this
fact. No irregularity was ever committed by Respondent No.1
during her service period from 29.04.2011 to 06.01.2017. In view
of the aforesaid facts and submissions, learned counsel for
Respondent No.1 submits that the petitioner is not entitled to any
of the reliefs sought in the writ petition. The petition is devoid of
merit, substance, and bona fides, and is liable to be dismissed at
the threshold, with costs, in the interest of justice.
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the respective parties and
perused the documents annexed along with the petition with
atmost circumspection.
8.
The petitioner has assailed the order dated 22.09.2023 passed by
the learned Additional Commissioner, Bilaspur Division, Bilaspur,
Camp at Raigarh, in Revision Case No. 83/A-89/2021-22,
whereby the revision preferred by Respondent No.1 was allowed
and the order dated 07.02.2022 passed by the Collector, Raigarh,
was set aside. The petitioner seeks quashing of the said
revisional order and restoration of the order passed by the
Collector.
9.
The foundational facts are largely undisputed. Respondent No.1
was initially appointed as Anganwadi Worker and was removed
from service vide order dated 06.01.2017. Her appeal against the
said order was dismissed by the Collector on 27.06.2017.
Subsequently, a resolution dated 27.07.2018 was passed by the
General Body of Janpad Panchayat, Pusour, holding that the
earlier removal of Respondent No.1 was wrongful and directing
her reinstatement. Thereafter, pursuant to a fresh advertisement
and selection process, Respondent No.1 was appointed as Mini
Anganwadi Worker vide order dated 15.07.2020. The appointment
was later set aside by the Collector on 07.02.2022 on the appeal
preferred by the present petitioner, which order was ultimately
reversed by the learned Additional Commissioner in revision.
10.
The principal contention of the petitioner is that the impugned
revisional order is contrary to the State Government circulars
dated 02.04.2008 and 25.01.2019, violative of Articles 14 and 16
of the Constitution of India, and suffers from arbitrariness and
non-application of mind. It is further contended that once
Respondent No.1 had been terminated earlier, she was rendered
permanently ineligible for re-appointment in view of Clause 1.4 of
the circular dated 02.04.2008. On the other hand, Respondent
No.1 has placed reliance on the subsequent resolution dated
27.07.2018 of the General Body of Janpad Panchayat, Pusour,
and the order of the Chief Executive Officer dated 28.07.2018,
whereby her earlier removal was declared wrongful and
reinstatement was directed. It is also contended that the
appointment dated 15.07.2020 was made after due verification
and in accordance with the prevailing policy, and that the learned
Additional Commissioner, while exercising revisional jurisdiction,
has rightly corrected the manifest illegality committed by the
Collector.
11.
Upon a careful examination of the record, this Court finds that the
learned Additional
Commissioner
has
exercised
revisional
jurisdiction within the permissible limits of law. The revisional
authority
has taken into consideration
the
entire
factual
background, including the resolution of the General Body of the
Janpad Panchayat, which held the earlier termination of
Respondent No.1 to be wrongful. Once the competent local
authority itself declared the termination to be unjustified, the rigour
of Clause 1.4 of the circular dated 02.04.2008 could not have
been applied mechanically against Respondent No.1.
12.
The contention of the petitioner that the disqualification under
Clause 1.4 operates absolutely and permanently is misconceived.
The said clause cannot be read in isolation and must be
interpreted in a purposive manner. Where the very foundation of
termination is subsequently found to be wrongful by the
competent authority, such termination cannot be treated as a valid
disqualification so as to forever debar a candidate from
consideration. The learned Additional Commissioner has rightly
appreciated this legal position.
The order dated 07.02.2022
passed by the Collector, Raigarh, does not appear to have
considered
the
subsequent
developments,
particularly
the
resolution dated 27.07.2018 and the consequential order dated
28.07.2018. The Collector proceeded on the assumption that the
earlier termination had attained finality, which assumption was
factually and legally incorrect in view of the later resolution of the
General Body. The revisional authority was, therefore, justified in
interfering with such an order.
13.
The allegation of violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
of India is wholly unfounded. The petitioner has failed to
demonstrate any hostile discrimination or unequal treatment
meted out to her. The mere setting aside of an order passed in
her favour does not ipso facto amount to violation of constitutional
guarantees. Equality before law does not mean negative equality,
nor does it confer a right to perpetuate an illegality.
The
submission that the impugned order is non-speaking or cryptic is
also without substance.
14.
A perusal of the impugned order dated 22.09.2023 reveals that
the learned Additional Commissioner has considered the relevant
facts, documents, and policy provisions before arriving at a
conclusion. Merely because the conclusion is adverse to the
petitioner, the order cannot be branded as arbitrary or
unreasoned. So far as the reliance placed by the petitioner on the
State Government circulars dated 02.04.2008 and 25.01.2019 is
concerned, this Court finds that the revisional authority has not
ignored the said circulars but has interpreted them in the light of
the peculiar facts of the case. Administrative circulars are
intended to guide decision-making and cannot be applied in a
rigid or mechanical manner divorced from the factual context. The
petitioner’s plea that her service career has been adversely
affected, though sympathetic, cannot override legality.
15.
The writ jurisdiction of this Court is concerned with the legality and
correctness of administrative action and not with equitable
considerations alone. No vested or indefeasible right has accrued
in favour of the petitioner merely by virtue of her temporary
continuance on the post pursuant to the Collector’s order. This
Court also finds merit in the submission of Respondent No.1 that
the writ petition suffers from selective disclosure of facts. The
petitioner has not placed due emphasis on the resolution and
orders
which
formed
the
basis
of
Respondent
No.1’s
reinstatement and subsequent appointment. A litigant invoking
extraordinary jurisdiction is expected to make full and fair
disclosure of all material facts.
16.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that no case for interference is made out. The impugned
order dated 22.09.2023 passed by the learned Additional
Commissioner does not suffer from illegality, perversity, or
jurisdictional error warranting interference by this Court.
17.
Accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. The impugned order
dated 22.09.2023 is upheld.
Sd/-(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
The date when The date when The date when the judgment is
the judgment is the judgment is uploaded on the website
reserved
pronounced
19.1.2026
Raghu Jat
28.2.2026
Operative
Full
-
28.2.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review