Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:16929
SOURABH
BHILWAR
SOURABH BHILWAR
Date: 2026.04.17
10:41:33 +0530
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SA No. 557 of 2025
Smt. Dulaurin Bai W/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 68 Years R/o
Bajrang Chowk, Ruabandha Basti, Bhilai, Tehsil And Distt. Durg,
Chhattisgarh.
... Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Abhishek Kumar Verma S/o Ajay Prasad Verma Aged About 38
Years R/o Plot No. 02, Pink Lan, Maitrikunj, Risali, Bhilai Tehsil And
Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
2 - Smt. Savitri W/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 60 Years R/o
Village Khopli, Tehsil And Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
3 - Durga D/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 15 Years Through The
Natural Guardian Mother Smt. Savitri, R/o Village Khopli, Tehsil And
Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
4 - Bharti D/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 13 Years Through The
Natural Guardian Mother Smt. Savitri, R/o Village Khopli, Tehsil And
Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
5 - Mona D/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 12 Years Through The
Natural Guardian Mother Smt. Savitri, R/o Village Khopli, Tehsil And
Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
6 - Rekha D/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 16 Years Through The
Natural Guardian Mother Smt. Savitri, R/o Village Khopli, Tehsil And
Distt. Durg, Chhattisgarh.
7 - Renu Sahu S/o Late Dhalu Ram Sahu Aged About 42 Years R/o
Bajrang Chowk, Ruabandha Basti, Bhilai, Tehsil And Distt. Durg,
Chhattisgarh.
8 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through District Collector, Distt. Durg,
Chhattisgarh.
…. Respondent(s)
(Cause title is taken from CIS)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent/State
: Mr. Akash Kumar Kundu, Advocate
: Mr. Malay Jain, Panel Lawyer
Hon'ble Shri Justice Bibhu Datta Guru
Judgment on Board
13/04/2026
1.
The present Second Appeal has been preferred by the plaintiff
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, assailing
the impugned judgment and decree dated 12.09.2025 passed by
the learned 3rd Additional District and Sessions Judge, Durg (C.G.)
in Civil Appeal No. 147-A/2024 (Smt. Dulaurin Bai vs. Abhishek
Kumar & Ors.), affirming the judgment and decree dated
30.07.2024 passed by the learned Addl. 1st Civil Judge Senior
Division to the Court of 1st Civil Judge, Senior Division, Durg
(C.G.), in Civil Suit No. 119-A/2022 (Smt. Dulaurin Bai vs.
Abhishek Kumar & Ors.), whereby the civil appeal filed by the
appellant/ plaintiff was dismissed. For the sake of convenience,
the parties shall hereinafter be referred to as per their status
before the Trial Court.
2.
The plaintiff has instituted the suit against the defendants seeking
a decree for declaration to the effect that the sale deed dated
16.08.2017 is illegal, void and not binding upon her pleading inter
alia that the agricultural land bearing Khasra Nos. 335/1 and 339,
admeasuring 0.21 and 0.47 hectares, respectively, situated at
Village Khopli, P.H. No. 43, R.N. No. Anda, Tahsil and District
Durg (C.G.), was recorded in the name of the plaintiff and she has
been in possession thereof carrying out agricultural activities. It is
further averred that the defendants, by playing fraud, got the said
land transferred in their name by executing a sale deed dated
16.08.2017, by impersonating the plaintiff and her daughter
through some other persons, as neither the plaintiff nor her
daughter were present before the Sub-Registrar at the time of
execution and registration of the said sale deed. It is further
pleaded that the cause of action arose on 10.07.2020, and the
plaintiff has valued the suit at Rs.7,00,000/- and affixed court fee
of Rs.500/-, praying for a decree declaring the said sale deed as
null and void.
3.
Per contra, defendant No.1 has filed his written statement denying
the entire claim of the plaintiff and has contended that he had
purchased the suit land after paying the full consideration amount
and got the same duly registered in his name. It is pleaded that
prior to execution of the sale deed, an agreement to sell was
executed between the parties, pursuant to which the plaintiff
received the advance amount and thereafter, upon receiving the
balance consideration, remained present before the Sub-Registrar
and got the sale deed registered. It is further averred that the
plaintiff has set up a false and concocted cause of action,
inasmuch as she had earlier filed an application dated 17.06.2019
before the Court seeking to implicate defendant No.1 and other
persons, which has already been rejected. It is also contended
that the plaintiff, in collusion, has unnecessarily impleaded her
daughter Renu Sahu as a defendant. The suit is further stated to
be barred by limitation, and hence, liable to be dismissed.
4.
Defendant Nos. 2 to 8 remained ex parte in the proceedings and
did not file any written statement.
5.
After framing the issues and upon due appreciation of the oral as
well as documentary evidence available on record, the learned
Trial Court dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff, holding that the
plaintiff failed to establish her title and possession over the suit
land. Aggrieved by the said judgment and decree dated
30/07/2024, the plaintiff preferred a First Appeal under Section 96
r/w Order 41 of the Code of Civil Procedure before the learned
First Appellate Court. The learned First Appellate Court, on reappreciation of the entire evidence on record, affirmed the
findings recorded by the Trial Court and dismissed the appeal by
the impugned judgment. Hence, the present appeal.
6.
(a)
Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the
impugned judgments and decrees passed by the learned trial
Court as well as the First Appellate Court are wholly illegal,
perverse and contrary to the settled principles of law. He submits
that both the Courts have failed to consider the material
admissions made by defendant No.1 in his cross-examination,
which clearly support the case of the plaintiff, yet the suit has
been erroneously dismissed in disregard of the principle of
preponderance of probabilities. He further submits that the finding
regarding limitation is also unsustainable in law, inasmuch as both
the Courts failed to take into account the order dated 10.01.2022
passed by the Supreme Court in In Re: Cognizance for
Extension of Limitation, whereby the period from 15.03.2020 to
28.02.2022 stood excluded, and therefore, the suit cannot be held
to be barred by limitation.
(b)
Learned counsel also submits that the Courts have gravely
erred in dismissing the suit without appreciating that defendant
No.1 failed to prove payment of consideration and did not
examine any attesting witness to the sale deed, thereby rendering
the transaction doubtful. Learned counsel would contend that the
alleged agreement to sell dated 03.08.2017 (Ex./D-35) has been
wrongly relied upon, as the same was executed only by defendant
No.2, who was neither the sole owner nor competent to deal with
the entire property, which was jointly held by other co-owners.
Thus, the findings recorded by both the Courts suffer from patent
illegality and perversity, giving rise to substantial questions of law
for consideration.
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the appellants on the question of
admission, and the impugned judgments and decrees passed by
the learned trial Court as also the learned First Appellate Court
have been carefully examined.
8.
In the present case, both the learned Trial Court as well as the
learned First Appellate Court, upon due appreciation of the
pleadings and the oral and documentary evidence available on
record, have concurrently held that the suit filed by the plaintiff is
not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed. Both the Courts
have recorded a categorical finding that the plaintiff had
knowledge of the execution of the impugned sale deed dated
16.08.2017 at least by 25.10.2018, as evident from her own
admissions and the documents brought on record, yet the suit
came to be instituted only on 26.04.2022, beyond the prescribed
period of limitation of three years, and without seeking any benefit
under the provisions of the Limitation Act.
9.
Both the Courts have further held that the plaintiff failed to
establish her possession over the suit property and, despite the
defendant being in possession, did not seek the consequential
relief of possession. The Trial Court has also found that the
plaintiff failed to prove her title and entitlement to relief, and
consequently declined the relief of permanent injunction. The
learned Trial Court dismissed the suit on the ground that the
plaintiff had not sought for any relief of possession and hence the
suit for declaration of title simplicitor is not maintainable in view of
the provisions of Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 (for
short, “the Act of 1963”). For the sake of convenience, Section 34
of the Specific Relief Act, 1963 is reproduced hereinbelow :“34. Discretion of court as to declaration of status or
right.- Any person entitled to any legal character, or to
any right as to any property, may institute a suit against
any person denying, or interested to deny, his title to
such character or right, and the court may in its
discretion make therein a declaration that he is so
entitled, and the plaintiff need not in such suit ask for
any further relief:
Provided that no court shall make any such declaration
where the plaintiff, being able to seek further relief than
a mere declaration of title, omits to do so.
Explanation. A trustee of property is a "person interested
to deny" a title adverse to the title of some one who is
not in existence, and whom, if in existence, he would be
a trustee.”
10.
A plain reading of the proviso to Section 34 of the Act of 1963
makes it clear that where the plaintiff is in a position to seek
further consequential relief, such as possession, but omits to do
so, a mere suit for declaration of title is not maintainable. Thus,
the grant of declaratory relief is discretionary and is expressly
barred in cases where the plaintiff, despite being able to seek
complete relief, restricts the claim to declaration simplicitor.
11.
Furthermore, the Apex Court in the matter of Vasantha (Dead)
Through Legal Representative vs. Rajalakshmi Alias Rajam
(Dead) Through Legal Representatives report in (2024) 5 SCC
282, has categorically held that the suit for declaration simplicitor
is not maintainable in view of the provisions of Section 34 of the
Act of 1963.
12.
The learned Trial Court, while adjudicating the issue relating to
possession, has placed reliance on the inspection report (Ex.
P/30) prepared by the concerned Patwari, which clearly indicates
that the possession over the suit property was with defendant
No.1. The said report, being a contemporaneous official record,
remained unrebutted and unchallenged by the plaintiff during trial.
On the basis of the said inspection report, the Trial Court has
recorded a categorical finding that the plaintiff was not in
possession of the suit land.
13.
Moreover, a bare perusal of the evidence of the plaintiff further
fortifies the aforesaid finding, inasmuch as in paragraph 14 of her
cross-examination she has candidly admitted that defendant No.1
has constructed a room over the suit property, that he frequently
visits and uses the said premises, and his name is recorded as
Bhumiswami in respect of the suit land. Though the plaintiff has
taken a plea that the alleged construction on the suit land was
raised by defendant No.1 during the pendency of the suit, no
application was ever moved by her before the Trial Court seeking
appropriate relief in that regard. These clear and unequivocal
admissions on the part of the plaintiff go to establish that the
possession of the suit property was with defendant No.1 and not
with the plaintiff, thereby rendering the plaintiff disentitled to a
decree for declaration simplicitor in absence of a prayer for
recovery of possession and consequently, in absence of any relief
for recovery of possession, the suit for declaration simplicitor was
held to be not maintainable.
14.
Thereafter, the learned First Appellate Court, while re-appreciating
the entire evidence, has affirmed the findings of the Trial Court
and held that although there was material indicating irregularities
in the execution of the sale deed, the plaintiff, having failed to
institute the suit within limitation and having omitted to seek the
necessary consequential relief, is not entitled to any declaration in
law. The Appellate Court thus upheld the dismissal of the suit on
the grounds of limitation and non-maintainability under Section 34
of the Act of 1963.
15.
Thus, the concurrent findings recorded by both the Courts are
based on proper appreciation of evidence and settled principles of
law, and no perversity, illegality, or substantial question of law
arises so as to warrant interference in exercise of jurisdiction
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
16.
Even otherwise, the scope of interference in a Second Appeal
under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is extremely
limited. Interference is permissible only when the appeal involves
a substantial question of law. Concurrent findings of fact recorded
by both the Courts cannot be interfered with unless such findings
are shown to be perverse, based on no evidence, or contrary to
settled principles of law.
17.
In the present case, both the Trial Court and the First Appellate
Court have concurrently recorded findings, on the basis of
evidence available on record, that the appellant/ plaintiff failed to
establish her case by placing cogent and sufficient material. The
appellant failed to demonstrate any perversity, illegality, or
misapplication of law in the findings so recorded.
18.
The questions sought to be raised in the present Second Appeal
essentially relate to re-appreciation of evidence and challenge to
concurrent findings of fact. Such questions do not give rise to any
substantial question of law within the meaning of Section 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure.
19.
It is well established that when there is a concurrent finding of
fact, unless it is found to be perverse, the Court should not
ordinarily interfere with the said finding.
20.
In the matter of State of Rajasthan and others Vs. Shiv Dayal
and another, reported in (2019) 8 SCC 637, reiterating the settled
proposition, it has been held that when any concurrent finding of
fact is assailed in second appeal, the appellant is entitled to point
out that it is bad in law because it was recorded de hors the
pleadings or based on misreading of material documentary
evidence or it was recorded against any provision of law and
lastly, the decision is one which no Judge acting judicially could
reasonably have reached.
21.
Be that as it may, the argument advanced by learned counsel for
the appellant and the proposed question of law cannot be
regarded as satisfying the test of being ‘substantial question of
law’ within the meaning of Section 100 of CPC. These questions,
in my view, are essentially question of facts. The appellant failed
to raise any substantial question of law which is required under
Section 100 of the CPC. In any event, the Second Appeal did not
involve any substantial question of law as contemplated under
Section 100 of the CPC, no case is made out by the appellant
herein. The judgments impugned passed by the learned trial
Court as as well as by the learned First Appellate Court are just
and proper and there is no illegality and infirmity at all.
22.
Having heard learned counsel for the appellant and on perusal of
the record of the case and in view of the above settled legal
proposition, I find absolutely no merit in this appeal, involving no
question of law much less substantial question of law within the
meaning of Section 100 of the CPC. In my view, the judgment and
decree passed by both the Courts appear to be just, proper and
legal. The findings recorded are based on proper appreciation of
evidence available on record and there is no illegality or perversity
in the same and they does not call for any interference.
23.
Accordingly, the Second Appeal fails and is hereby dismissed
resulting in upholding of the judgment and decree of the trial Court
as well as the Appellate Court.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
$. Bhilwar
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review