Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.169/2015
Date of order: 31.08.2023
State of Meghalaya & ors
Smt. Dorothy Marbaniang
Vs.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. N. Syngkon, Adv with
Ms. L. Phanjom, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. K. Khan, AAG with
Ms. T. Yangi B., AAG
Mr. S. Sengupta, Addl.Sr.GA
Ms. A. Thungwa, GA
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
ORDER: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The petition was disposed of by a judgment and order of March
22, 2016, declining the principal prayer for a reinvestigation into the
circumstances leading to the death of a police official in Patharkhmah.
2.
The petitioner was the mother of the deceased. The grievance of
the petitioner was that the procedure under Section 174 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973 had not been followed in course of the
investigation and that there was an attempt by the investigating agency
to suppress the real facts and give the incident a colour of suicide.
3.
There were three important allegations in the petition filed by
the mother who, unfortunately, has died since. The mother pointed out
an anomaly that the doctor, who had treated the deceased when he was
still alive and was taken to the Patharkhmah community health centre,
indicated that the gun-shot wound that the then patient had suffered was
from behind his head. Such opinion revealed that the then patient had
been shot on the back of his head and the bullet exited the cranium from
the left part of the forehead. However, as the petitioner duly
emphasised, the post-mortem examination conducted at the Civil
Hospital in Nongpoh on the next day indicated that the gun-shot wound
was suffered on the left forehead and the bullet entered the skull from
such part and exited from slightly off the middle of the back of the head.
4.
The second anomaly that the petitioning mother brought to
attention was that her son was right-handed and there could not have
been any good reason for him to either commit suicide or, even if he
did, to use his left hand to pull the trigger. The third aspect alluded to
was that the deceased police official may have earned the wrath of the
mafia which is aggressively active in the State, with connections to the
most influential and the powerful, dealing with illegally-mined coal.
5.
There is no dispute that about 32 trucks laden with coal, almost
invariably illegally-mined, had been stopped at the Patharkhmah
Outpost in the morning of January 24, 2015. The incident pertaining to
what led to the death of the police officer occurred slightly before 9 pm
when two junior police personnel in neighbouring lodgings said that
they heard an explosion and first thought it may have been a firecracker, but later, on hearing a moaning sound, they followed the sound
which took them to the quarters of the in-charge at the outpost and
found such in-charge lying in a pool of blood in his bedroom with the
front door to the modest flat and the bedroom door ajar.
6.
The charge-sheet in this case was filed on October 10, 2015 in
Nongpoh PS Case No.28(1) of 2015 under Section 302 of the Penal
Code, 1860. Charges have since been framed against five persons under
Section 306 of the Penal Code.
7.
At the time that the writ petition was taken up for final disposal,
the relevant Bench noticed that the investigation had been concluded.
The manner in which the final order of March 22, 2016 is worded gives
an impression that the relevant Bench of this Court perceived that since
the investigation had already been completed, it was a fait accompli and
the Court could not do anything further.
8.
Aggrieved by the failure of the High Court to order further
investigation or reinvestigation or a de novo investigation as had been
sought by the petitioner, such petitioner carried a petition for special
leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, being SLP (C) No.15461 of 2016.
The relevant petition was disposed of by the Supreme Court by a recent
order of May 8, 2023. By such order, the matter was remitted to this
Court “to decide and dispose of the writ petition afresh in accordance
with law and on its own merits and taking into consideration the
observations made by this Court in the case of Sushila Devi (supra) …”
9.
Earlier in the Supreme Court order, there is a reference to the
case of Sushila Devi reported at (2014) 1 SCC 269 and an observation
that while disposing of the writ petition this Court had “misapplied
and/or mis-construed the said decision.” According to the order of May
8, 2023, in the case of Sushila Devi, the investigation directed by the
Court to be conducted by the Central Bureau of Investigation had
already been completed and, it was in such circumstances, that the
Court observed that the monitoring of the matter any further was not
warranted.
10.
The Supreme Court went on to notice a judgment rendered in
Criminal Appeal No.13 of 2023 (Anant Thanur Karmuse v. The State of
Maharashtra) and quoted paragraph 11 therefrom which referred to two
other previous judgments reported at (2016) 4 SCC 160 (Dharam Pal v.
State of Haryana) and (2013) 15 SCC 578 (Bharati Tamang v. Union of
India).
11.
In essence, what the order dated May 8, 2023 observed was that
when a Constitutional Court was in receipt of a petition complaining of
irregular or insufficient or faulty investigation, the mere fact that the
investigation had been completed or that a charge-sheet had been filed
or that a final report had been presented under Section 173(8) of the
Code would not deter the Court into looking at the perceived anomalies
and directing further investigation or reinvestigation or a de novo
investigation, if the circumstances so warranted.
12.
As aforesaid, the Supreme Court perceived that the order of this
Court of March 22, 2016 disposing of the writ petition by, in effect,
refusing the prayers therein gave the impression that merely because the
investigation had been concluded, the High Court was of the view that it
could do nothing else in the matter.
13.
It is in such circumstances that the nature of the investigation,
the anomalies indicated by the petitioner and the circumstances leading
to the death of the relevant official have been gone into in course of the
present set of hearings.
14.
Both the case diary and the detailed charge-sheet, together with
photographs appended thereto, were called for. During this period, the
further conduct of the trial was injuncted, so that it was first ascertained
whether the investigation that was conducted or the report filed
thereupon had to be disregarded or whether any further or fresh
investigation was called for.
15.
It is in such light and on the basis of the Supreme Court
directions that the matter has been assessed. Two junior police
personnel, who were cooking at their lodgings adjacent to the quarters
of the in-charge of the Patharkhmah Outpost, were the first to reach the
place of occurence and it appears from their independent statements that
they heard the sound of an explosion and their first impression was that
it must have been a fire-cracker. They later heard a continuing groan
and followed the sound to the quarters of the in-charge and entered
through the open door of the quarters and into the open bedroom to find
the officer lying in a pool of blood with his face down on the left side.
16.
Such police officials recounted that they did not touch anything
but found that the left hand of the bullet-hit officer clutched a fire-arm.
There were senior police officials nearby, including a person from RiBhoi, who were called and, thereafter, since they found the relevant
officer to still be alive, upon taking photographs on a mobile phone,
they quickly took him to the nearest medical facility which was the
Patharkhmah CHC.
17.
There is no doubt that the doctor who examined the patient
observed that the gun-shot wound suffered by the official appeared to
have been a shot from the back of the head with the bullet exiting the
forehead. However, it must be kept in mind that the person was still
alive and the primary aim of the attending medical personnel would
then have been to resuscitate him and treat the injuries he suffered
rather than concentrate in any great detail as to how the injuries may
have occurred. At any rate, since the relevant doctor found the patient to
still be alive and showing feeble signs of life, and as the facilities at the
relevant CHC were inadequate, the patient was referred to GNRC
Hospital in Guwahati where he was taken and where the official
apparently died.
18.
The relevant doctor at the Patharkhmah CHC was examined in
course of the trial and he repeated that in his view, on the basis of his
observation at the relevant time, he thought that the person had suffered
a gun-shot injury on the back of his head with the bullet exiting the
frontal part of the cranium. The official also admitted that this was the
first time that he had treated a bullet or a gun-shot injury.
19.
A post-mortem examination on the body of the deceased police
official was conducted at the Nongpoh Civil Hospital. The summary of
the observations and the findings have been indicated in the chargesheet filed in the matter. It appears that the doctor who conducted the
post-mortem examination on the body at 10:50 am on January 25, 2015
noticed and recorded that the forehead wound was circular in shape and
measured 1.5 cm in length and 0.9 cm in breadth while the back wound
was irregular in shape and it measured 2.3 cm and 2.5 cm in breadth and
length. It is elementary that, ordinarily, when a bullet first makes
contact with a body or any hard object, the hole that it creates at the
entry point is more regular and of lesser magnitude or dimension than
the larger and more irregular hole that it creates at the exit point, subject
to having covered a bit of a distance through a dense medium in the
interregnum. Thus, it would be evident from the observations of the
doctor who conducted the post-mortem at Nongpoh Civil Hospital that
the wound suffered was inflicted on the forehead and the bullet exited
through the parietal lobe of the cranium.
20.
Following the protest raised by the mother upon the findings of
the post-mortem being made known to her, a further autopsy was
conducted at the crematorium by personnel from the North Eastern
Indira Gandhi Regional Institute of Health and Medical Sciences, which
is an agency under the control of the Union government and not the
State. Upon such second post-mortem examination, the report by the
relevant doctors indicated as follows:
“(T)he entry wound on the frontal region of the head situated 0.5
cm to the left of the midline, the exit wound on the parietal
region of the head situated 2 cm to the right of the midline and
bruise around the left eye.”
21.
Thus, it is evident that the doctors who conducted the second
post-mortem examination agreed with the findings of the doctor who
had conducted the initial examinaton at the Nongpoh Civil Hospital,
that the deceased had been shot on his forehead and the bullet exited the
skull through the back of the head.
22.
The two police personnel who had first discovered the in-charge
of the Patharkhmah Outpost after he suffered the gun-shot injury, did
not report anything untoward or having spotted anyone else. A more
senior official reached the spot immediately as he was staying in the
nearby guesthouse. Photographs were taken contemporaneously of how
the body lay before the then still surviving officer was lifted and taken
to the CHC. There appears to be no material to suggest any foul play or
anything remiss about the place of occurrence warranting any suspicion
that the fatal injury could have been inflicted on the official by any
other person.
23.
As to the mother’s suggestion that since her son was right-
handed he would scarcely use his left hand to shoot himself, it does not
appear that using the left hand to hold a gun next to one’s forehead and
pull the trigger would cause any great difficulty to even the most
compulsive right-handed person whose left hand may be as nonfunctional as possible. It is not difficult to imagine a gun being lifted by
the lesser hand, such hand being brought close to the forehead and the
trigger being pulled without difficulty. In the scenario when there is
nothing else which stands out as an anomaly or even remotely
suspicious, it cannot be conjectured as to why the deceased used his left
land, as long as it is evident that there may not have been any other
person at the place of occurrence or any trace of any person being
present at the time of occurrence.
24.
There is no doubt that the power of the mafia that runs the
illegal coal business and the ancillary coke plants in this State is wide
and almost all pervasive. Indeed, despite there being a prohibition on
the mining of coal in the State, other than by adopting the lawful
scientific method, by the National Green Tribunal and such order being
expressly endorsed by the Supreme Court by or about the year 2016, the
illegal mining of coal continues to be rampant in the State. For any
person even with impaired vision, the train of overladen trucks carrying
coal is all there to see on the National and State highways in
Meghalaya; but the administration, for reasons best known to it, turns a
Nelson’s eye to such activities. Repeated orders of this Court over the
last 18 months would reveal the frustration experienced because of the
lack of action on the part of the administration. It now appears that
some form of action, over the last month or so, may have been taken;
but it appears to be only token action to appease the Court and not
intended to arrest either the kingpins or the political supporters of the
masterminds who are, obviously, on the gravy train. The malaise
appears to go right to the top.
25.
Returning to the matter at hand, in the light of what has been
discovered by this Court of the flourishing business in illegal mining,
there is no doubt that the owners of the 32 trucks or the coal that such
trucks contained wielded considerable authority and influence and a part
of the report is quite damning against the Block Development Officer of
the area. Doubtless, no action has been taken against such official or
others who may have instructed him to act in the manner that he did.
While the mendacity of the entire coal business is plain to see, it is quite
another to suggest that one or more of the persons involved with the
trucks that had been apprehended may have been involved in killing the
concerned official.
26.
Ordinarily, even if a tailor-made investigation report is prepared,
which the Indian judge has enough experience to discover, there are
some anomalies or traces of contradiction. At any rate, in this case what
is evident from not only the case diary and the charge-sheet but also
from the evidence that has come on record at the trial is that it was the
official himself who may have pulled the trigger on himself and not any
other. As to who drove such person to commit suicide or who would be
liable under Section 306 of the Penal Code, is the object of the exercise
being conducted at the trial. On a careful reading of the material
produced, it does not appear that any person who may have been
intricately involved in the matter has been left out or protected and,
proving a charge under Section 306 of the Penal Code, is always a high
ask.
27.
At the end of the day, it cannot be lost sight of that a young
police officer, who may not have agreed with the manner in which the
illegal coal mining activities were being continued, lost his life. There
can be nothing but sympathy for the family, including an apology on
behalf of the State to the now deceased mother of the officer for the
State having failed to protect him adequately. However, upon going
through the material it does not appear that the gun-shot injury that
killed the official was fired by any person other than the officer himself.
On the basis of the material produced and upon it being gleaned for any
anomalies, it cannot be said as to who or what may have pushed the
officer to such desperation or impelled him to take his life. It is for the
trial court to endeavour to unearth the truth in such regard.
28.
For the reasons aforesaid, upon considering the matter afresh in
the light of the directions issued by the Supreme Court and upon being
alive as to the extent of the authority available to a Constitutional Court
when any anomaly as to any investigation is brought to its notice, it
does not appear that, particularly after eight years after the incident, any
further investigation or a fresh or de novo investigation is called for.
29.
It is recorded that the matter has been gone into in considerable
detail by reason of its very nature, despite the original petitioner being
no longer available. Counsel originally engaged by the petitioner has
been allowed to participate in the proceedings. Upon hearing both the
State and Counsel formerly engaged by the original petitioner, it does
not appear that this is a fit case for any further or fresh investigation to
be directed.
30.
It is hoped that the compensation due on account of the untimely
and unnatural death of the concerned official has been paid in
accordance with law to the persons entitled thereto.
31.
No observation here should prejudice or influence the trial court
in any manner whatsoever as the object of the present exercise was
completely different. It is hoped that the trial resumes immediately and
the matter is brought to its logical conclusion in accordance with law as
expeditiously as possible and, preferably, within six months from date.
32.
WP (C) No.169 of 2015, which was revived pursuant to the
Supreme Court order of May 8, 2023, is disposed of.
33.
There will be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
31.08.2023
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review