Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.55 of 2024
1. Smt. Dipali Sarkar, wife of Late Swapan Sarkar and mother of Late
Sudip Sarkar, a Constable 169th Battalion, BSF, resident of Dhaleswar,
Road No.18, P.S. East Agartala, District: West Tripura, PIN: 799 285,
aged about 64 years
---Appellant(s)
Versus
1. The Union of India, represented by its Secretary, Department of Home
Affairs, Government of India, having his office at South Block, New
Delhi, PIN-1100001
2. The Commissioner & Secretary, Home Department, Government of
Tripura, having his office at Secretariat Building, Pandit Nehru
Complex, P.O. Kunjaban, PS- New Capital Complex, Sub-Division:
Agartala, District- West Tripura, PIN-799 006
3. The Commanding Officer, HQ 169 Battalion BSF, Raninagar, Jalpaiguri,
District-Jalpaiguri, West Bengal, PIN-735133
4. Ajeet Kumar, Commandant, 169 Bn BSF, C/O APO, PIN-193222
5. Director General, BSF, 10, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi,
PIN-110003
----Official-Respondent(s)
6. Rumpa Sarkar, wife of Late Sudip Sarkar (deceased BSF soldier)
7. Subhra Sarkar, daughter of Late Sudip Sarkar (deceased BSF soldier)
8. Atithi Sarkar, daughter of Late Sudip Sarkar (deceased BSF soldier)
----Private-Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
:
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Somik Deb, Sr.Adv.
Mr. Pannalal Debbarma, Adv.
Mr. B. Majumder, Deputy S.G.I.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Mr. T. K. Deb, Adv.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
12/12/2024
The appellant is the writ petitioner and mother of the martyr Sudip
Sarkar who died on duty upon receiving multiple bullet injuries fighting with
the infiltrators in Machal Sector, Kupwara, State of Jammu and Kashmir on 8 th
November, 2020 while working as a Constable in 169th Battalion, BSF.
2.
The writ petitioner-appellant approached the writ court with a
prayer to direct the official-respondents not to disburse further money in favour
of the widow, respondent No.6 till final disposal of the writ petition and further
direct them to distribute the monetary and other benefits admissible to the
Class-I legal heirs including the petitioner in strict conformity with the
statutory mandate contained in Section-8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
3.
Upon the unfortunate death of Sudip Sarkar while on the call of
duty, the petitioner-appellant and the respondent No.6 were paid Rs.2,50,000
(two lakh fifty thousand) each from the Chief Minister‟s Relief Fund, Tripura.
She was also paid Rs.10,00,000/- on account of „Bharat Ke Veer Fund‟ through
bank transfer on 24.03.2021 as a welfare measure to the parent of a BSF martyr
communicated vide letter dated 13.05.2021 [Annexure-4].
4.
The dispute between the appellant-mother and the respondent
No.6-widow is said to have arisen on a claim by the widow for sharing the
amount received under „Bharat Ke Veer Fund‟ to enable her to purchase a flat.
According to the appellant, she paid a sum of Rs.2,00,000/- out of the said
Rs.10,00,000/-. However, this contention has been denied by the widow in her
counter-affidavit.
5.
The appellant contends
which stands corroborated by the
documents annexed by the official-respondents that the deceased made certain
nominations in favour of the wife during his lifetime to receive amounts under
Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity, Family Pension, GPF, Financial assistance
from Central Welfare Fund, Government Employees Insurance Scheme and
Golden Jubilee Seema Prahari Kalyan Kavach. The following payments were
disbursed to the widow (Annexure-R-2, Page-59) as per the statement issued
by the Commandant, 169 Bn BSF which are as follows:
Details of Payments made to NOK Smt. Rumpa Sarkar by BSF is as under:
i.
Family Pension (LPA)- Rs.37,500/- w.e.f. 09.11.2020 to till death
ii. DLI + GPF final payment – Rs.1,31,790/iii.
CGEGIS – Rs.42,794/iv.
DCRG – Rs.8,77,500/v.
GJSPKK – Rs.40,00,000/vi.
Leave Encashment – Rs.2,80,800/vii.
FA- Rs.70,000/viii.
BKV – Rs.15,00,000/ix. Ex-gratia compensation
6.
The petitioner-mother approached the writ court to stop further
disbursement of any amount in favour of the widow and also a direction upon
the official respondents to disburse the admissible Death-cum-Retirement
benefits amongst the Class-I legal heirs including the writ petitioner. Counteraffidavit was filed by the official-respondents and also by the widow contesting
the case. The writ petition has been dismissed with the following observations:
“[8] Having considered the submission as advanced by the counsel for the
parties and having perused the entire record, specifically the Rules 50, 51, 52
and 53 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972, this court is of the
opinion that none but the widower (the respondent No.6) is the nominee of
the deceased soldier who is eligible to get all the monetary benefits since her
name is reflected in the nomination form. In the nomination form under the
Rules and also the Rules indicate the word “Nominee” or “Nominees” that
means it could be one person or more. In the instant case, the deceased has
only indicated the name of his wife as nominee. Thus giving value to the will
of deceased, this court feels it needs to be accepted the way it is and needs no
interpretation. Thus widow of the deceased soldier is nominee as per pension
papers. Moreover, the pension is to be given under the provisions of the
Pension Scheme and therefore, only the person who is entitled to get the
pension as per the Scheme would get it.
[9]
The argument made by Mr. T. Chakraborty, learned counsel in
reference to the Hindu Marriage Act is not applicable to the case in hand. The
petitioner has not placed on record nor before the official-respondents any
judgment & decree obtained from competent court to say that the petitioner‟s
case under Hindu Law as Class-I heir can be considered. So far as the
petitioner is concerned, though it does not fall under the category of pension
and further not to deprive the petitioner of any monetary benefit, she has been
given Rs. 10,00,000/- under Bharat Ke Veer Fund and the State Government
has also extended the financial benefit of Rs. 2,50,000/- to the petitioner
(Total Rs.12,50,000/-). It appears that the petitioner has not approached with
clean hands before this court and she has failed to make out her case. Hence,
the instant writ petition stands dismissed.
[10] As a sequel, stay, if any, stands vacated. Pending application(s), if
any, also stands closed.”
Being aggrieved the petitioner is before us in appeal.
7.
Learned senior counsel for the appellant has questioned the
findings of the learned Writ Court which is to the effect that it is the nominee
of the deceased soldier, i.e the respondent No.6 who is only eligible to get all
the monetary benefits since her name is reflected in the nomination form.
Learned senior counsel for the petitioner submits that the expression 'nominee'
and its connotation has been explained in the Advanced Law Lexicon by P.
Ramanatha Aiyar, 3rd Edition, 2005 to mean a person appointed by a member
of the fund to receive the benefits arising from such membership in the event of
his death. In the case of Datar Switchgears Ltd. Vs. Tata Finance Ltd. &
Another reported in (2000) 8 SCC 151, the expression has been referred to as
under:
“26. In P. Ramanatha Aiyar's Law Lexicon (2nd Edition) at page 1310-11, the
meaning of the word 'Nomination" is given as follows:1.The action, process or instance of nominating;
2. The act, process or an instrument of nominating; an act or right of
designating for an office or duty.
"Nominations" is equivalent to the word "appointments", when used by a
mayor in an instrument executed for the purpose of appointing certain
persons to office."
8.
It is submitted that nomination does not amount to entitlement of
the nominee to appropriate the entire claim. It is only for the purpose of
receiving the amount. The amount so disbursed is to be distributed amongst the
legal heirs. In this case, since the deceased was a Hindu guided by Hindu
Succession Act, 1956 the disbursement could be in terms of Section-8, the 1st
Schedule in which the mother is also a Class-I legal heir apart from the widow.
The learned Writ Court, therefore, fell in error by dismissing the writ petition.
9.
On part of the respondent-Union of India, it is contended that the
pensionary benefit and other dues of the deceased have been rightly disbursed
in favour of the widow who was nominated by the deceased during his lifetime
in prescribed manner.
Learned counsel for the widow, respondent No.6, has also
contested the claim of the writ petitioner and submitted that the admissible
pensionary benefits and other dues have been rightly disbursed in her favour on
the basis of the nomination made by her husband/employee. Therefore, the
learned Writ Court had rightly rejected the prayer.
10.
We have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the relevant materials placed from records from either
side. As it appears from the body of pleadings of both the sides, dispute is in
relation to the claim of the amounts disbursed in favour of the respondent No.6,
widow on the basis of the nomination made by the deceased employee during
his service. It is evident from the documents placed by the official-respondents
that such nomination was made by the deceased employee in favour of his
wife, respondent No.6, to receive the following amounts under these heads:
Details of Payments made to NOK Smt. Rumpa Sarkar by BSF is as under:
i.
ii.
iii.
iv.
v.
vi.
vii.
viii.
ix.
11.
Family Pension (LPA)- Rs.37,500/- w.e.f. 09.11.2020 to till death
DLI + GPF final payment – Rs.1,31,790/CGEGIS – Rs.42,794/DCRG – Rs.8,77,500/GJSPKK – Rs.40,00,000/Leave Encashment – Rs.2,80,800/FA- Rs.70,000/BKV – Rs.15,00,000/Ex-gratia compensation
The official-respondents including the BSF, therefore, have
released the aforesaid amount in favour of the respondent No.6-widow.
However, „nomination‟ as explained in Advanced Law Lexicon by P.
Ramanatha Aiyar and also dilated upon in the case of Datar Switchgears Ltd.
Vs. Tata Finance Ltd. & Another (supra) means appointment of a person for a
specific purpose in this case to receive the amount against the enumerated
heads towards Death-cum-Retirement benefits and other dues or welfare
measures by the widow of the deceased.
12.
In the case of Shipra Sengupta Vs. Mridul Sengupta & Ors,
reported in (2009) 10 SCC 680 the Apex Court has explained the effect of the
nomination by the deceased employee for payment of terminal benefits. Para
14 & 18 of the report is extracted hereunder:
“14. In Sarbati Devi [(1984) 1 SCC 424 : 1984 SCC (Tax) 59] this Court has
laid down that a mere nomination does not have the effect of conferring to the
nominee any beneficial interest in the amount payable under the life
insurance policy, on death of the insurer. The nomination only indicates the
hand which is authorised to receive the amount on payment of which the
insurer gets a valid discharge of its liability under the policy. The amount,
however, can be claimed by the heirs of the assured in accordance with the
law of succession.
…….
18. In view of the clear legal position, it is made abundantly clear that the
amount under any head can be received by the nominee, but the amount can
be claimed by the heirs of the deceased in accordance with the law of
succession governing them. In other words, nomination does not confer any
beneficial interest on the nominee. In the instant case the amounts so received
are to be distributed according to the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.”
13.
Similarly in the case of Shakti Yezdani & Anr. Vs. Jayanand
Jayant Salgaonkar & Ors., reported in (2024) 4 SCC 642 the Apex Court has
observed as under:
“41. A consistent view appears to have been taken by the courts, while
interpreting the related provisions of nomination under different statutes. It is
clear from the referred judgments that the nomination so made would not lead
to the nominee attaining absolute title over the subject property for which
such nomination was made. In other words, the usual mode of succession is
not to be impacted by such nomination. The legal heirs therefore have not
been excluded by virtue of nomination.”
14.
The petitioner-mother has raised a claim for share being a Class-I
legal heir under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 as per Schedule-1 of the
Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Since the dispute on the claim for share as a
Class-1 legal heir under Hindu Succession Act, 1956 is between the motherwrit petitioner and the widow-respondent No.6, two private parties, such an
issue or claim is not fit to be entertained in exercise of the writ jurisdiction of
the Court. However, the stand of the official-respondents to disburse the
amount in favour of the widow on the basis of the said nomination cannot be
faulted. If the petitioner has claim for share in any of these amounts on the
basis of being a Class-I legal heir, she is at liberty to raise her cause of action in
an appropriate proceeding before the competent Court of civil jurisdiction
where inter se right between the parties can be adjudicated upon on the basis of
pleadings and evidence placed by the parties.
15.
This Court in exercise of powers under writ jurisdiction is not
required to get into the inter se dispute between the two private parties on the
claim of share. To that extent, the impugned judgment warrants interference.
Observations, if any, made by the learned Writ Court as to the entitlement of
the petitioner towards share in the Death-cum-Retirement benefits and other
dues or funds under welfare schemes of the BSF would not stand in the way of
the writ petitioner to raise her claim and cause of action in an appropriate
proceeding before the competent Court of civil jurisdiction. The observations
and finding, if any, in the impugned judgment to that effect shall not have
effect in any fresh proceeding placed by the writ petitioner as observed
hereinabove.
16.
This writ appeal stands disposed of with the aforesaid
observations in the manner indicated above.
Pending application, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(B. PALIT), J
MOUMITA
DATTA
Moumita
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
DATTA
Date: 2024.12.19 04:36:07
+05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review