The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. Situated thus, the amount of compensation be recalculated as under: (i) Monthly income: Rs.12,000/(ii) Rs.12,000 (monthly income) + Rs.4,800/- (40% of future prospects)= Rs.16,800/(iii) 50% be deducted towards personal living expense of the deceased from Rs.16,800/-. The same comes to Rs.8,400/-. Thus, yearly income comes to Rs.8,400 x 12= Rs.1,00,800/-. (iv) With the aforesaid amount multiplier 18 be allowed as per Sarla Verma & Ors. vs. Delhi Transport Corporation & Anr. Thus, loss of dependency comes to Rs.1,00,800/- x 18= Rs.18,14,400/-. (v) With the aforesaid amount Rs.15,000/- be added as loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- be added as funeral expenses as per judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in National Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and Ors. and Rs.40,000/- be added as parental consortium as per judgment of the Magma General Insurance Company Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram, reported in (2018) SCC OnLine 1546. Thus the claimant will be entitled to get Rs.18,14,400/- (loss of dependency) + Rs.15,000/- (for funeral expenses) + Rs.15,000/- (for loss of estate) + Rs.40,000/- (for loss of parental consortium) = Rs.18,84,400/- as total amount of compensation.
12. In the result, the appeal is partly allowed with modification that the claimant will be entitled to get total compensation amounting to Rs.18,84,400/- along with 7% interest per annum in place of 7.5% interest awarded by the Tribunal from the date of filing the claim-petition i.e. w.e.f.
19. 03.2021 till the date of payment. The respondent O.P. No.2 shall be asked to deposit the amount to the Learned Tribunal below within a period of two months from the date of passing of this judgment. In the event of deposit of amount 50% of the total amount of compensation be released in favour of the appellant-petitioner and the rest amount shall be deposited in a Fixed Deposit Certificate in any Nationalized Bank for a period of 10 years by the Tribunal below in the name of the petitioner. A copy of this judgment/order be given free of cost to the Learned Counsel for the appellant for information. A copy of this judgment/order be furnished to Learned Counsel for the respondent No.2 i.e. the Reliance General Insurance Company Limited for information and compliance. With this observation this appeal stands disposed of. Send down the LCR along with a copy of the judgment/order. Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. Purnita
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC App. No.27 of 2024
Smt. Dipali Majumder (Saha),
Wife of Sri Nepal Saha, aged about 57 years,
Resident of Joynagar, P.O.- Birendranagar,
P.S. Jirania, Dist.- West Tripura.
….Claimant- Petitioner-Appellant
Versus
1.
Smt. Badali Debbarma,
Wife of Sri Pradip Debbarma,
Resident of Kunja Behari Para, P.O.-Birendranagar,
P.S.-Jirania, Dist.- West Tripura. Pin-799131.
(Owner of TR-01-BM-0751, Hyundai Verna)
2.
The Branch Manager,
Reliance General Insurance Company Limited of 3rd Floor,
602/J, Ker Chowmuhani, T.G. Road, Agartala,
P.S.- West Agartala, District- West Tripura, Pin-799002
(Insurer of TR-01-BM-0751, Hyundai Verna)
3.
Sri Nepal Saha,
Son of Lt. Gopal Saha,
Resident of vill- Joynagar, P.O.- Birendranagar,
P.S.- Jirania, District-West Tripura, Pin-799131
(Owner of TR-01-S-7955, Motor Cycle)
4.
The Branch Manager,
Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited of 3 rd
Floor, Aitorma, Agartala Sentrum, Sakuntala Road,
P.S.- West Agartala, District- West Tripura,
P.O.-Agartala, Pin-799001
(Insurer of TR-01-S-7955, Motor Cycle)
…….Respondents
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Adv,
Mr. R. G. Chakraborty, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
05.11.2024
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
07.11.2024
NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This appeal is preferred under Section 173 of M.V.
Act challenging the judgment and award dated 22.11.2023
delivered by Learned Member, MAC Tribunal No.2, West
Tripura, Agartala in connection with case No. T.S. (MAC) 54 of
2021. By the said judgment and award, Learned Tribunal below
has awarded a sum of Rs.15,82,000/- in favour of the
claimant-petitioner i.e. the appellant herein and fastened the
liability of payment of compensation upon the O.P. No.2 i.e.
the Reliance General Insurance Company Limited.
02.
Heard Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Lodh representing
the claimant-petitioner i.e. the appellant herein and also heard
Learned Counsel, Mr. R. G. Chakraborty representing the
respondent O.P. No.2 i.e. the Reliance General Insurance
Company Limited and Learned Counsel, Mr. S. Chakraborty
representing the respondent O.P. No.4 i.e. the Bajaj Allianz
General Insurance Company Limited. None appeared on behalf
on behalf of the respondent Nos.1 and 3 inspite of service of
notice.
03.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Counsel
for the appellant-claimant first of all drawn the attention of the
Court that in the claim-petition the appellant shown the
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.12,000/- per month and
accordingly,
the
appellant
adduced
evidence
before
the
Learned Tribunal below and PW2 Sanjoy Sarkar in course of his
examination stated that he has appointed the deceased as his
driver and used to pay Rs.12,000/- per month as his salary
and in addition to monthly salary he also used to pay Rs.50/per day to him as food allowance which was mentioned in para
No.2 of his examination-in-chief in affidavit submitted before
the Tribunal and the testimony of the said witness has
remained unrebutted/unshaken by the contesting O.Ps before
the Learned Tribunal below but the Learned Tribunal below at
the time of delivery of the judgment determined the monthly
income of the deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month which should
be atleast 12,000/- per month and urged for allowing this
appeal on the said ground.
Learned Counsel further submitted that the Learned
Tribunal below in the operative portion of the judgment only
released Rs.2,00,000/- in favour of the appellant-claimantpetitioner and ordered for deposit of the balance money to the
fixed deposit certificates which should also be modified as the
appellant-petitioner being major having no other source of
income and if the entire amount is kept in Fixed Deposit, in
that case she would suffer financial inconvenience and also
urged for modification of the order of the Learned Tribunal
below.
04.
On the other hand, Learned Counsel Mr. R. G.
Chakraborty appearing on behalf of the respondent O.P. No.2
i.e.
the
Reliance
General
Insurance
Company
Limited
submitted that the Learned Tribunal below based on the
oral/documentary evidence on record rightly and reasonably
determined the amount of compensation and delivered the
judgment and furthermore, before the Learned Tribunal below
the
Insurance
petitioner
Company
regarding
objected
amount
of
the
contention
monthly
income
of
the
of
the
deceased and he also drawn the attention of the Court
referring the evidence of PW2 and submitted that PW2 himself
is a driver, so, no reliance can be placed upon his evidence and
urged for dismissal of the appeal. Learned Counsel for another
Insurance Company did not submit anything in course of
hearing of argument.
05.
The present appellant as claimant filed a claim
petition before the Tribunal under Section 166 of M.V. Act
seeking compensation on the death of her son Prasenjit Saha
who died due to a road traffic accident. According to the
appellant on 18.02.2021 the deceased Prasenjit Saha was
proceeding towards his house from Ranirbazar along with his
friend by riding his motor cycle bearing registration No.TR-01S-7955 by the left side of the road and at about 2130 hours
when he reached at Bashkobra Near Kali Mandir on NH-8
Assam-Agartala road that time one vehicle bearing registration
No.TR-01-BN-0751 (Hyundai Verna) was proceeding towards
the same direction but the driver due to his rash and negligent
driving and excessive speed lost control over the vehicle and
dashed behind the motor cycle of the deceased Prasenjit Saha,
as a result of which Prasenjit Saha sustained fatal injuries and
after the accident, he was immediately shifted to Jirania
Hospital where the attending doctor declared him as dead. It
was further submitted that the accident occurred due to rash
and negligent driving by the driver of the said Hyundai Verna.
The appellant further asserted that at the time of accident, the
deceased
was
a
driver
by
profession
and
was
earning
Rs.12,000/- per month and at the time of death he was
unmarried and 22 years of old. Hence, the appellant filed the
claim-petition.
Before the Tribunal, the O.P. No.1 i.e. the owner of
vehicle bearing No.TR-01-BN-0751 (Hyundai Verna) appeared
and submitted WS denying the assertions of the claimant
petitioner and also took the plea that her vehicle was duly
insured with the Reliance General Insurance Company Limited
vide policy No.991492123740003782.
O.P. No.2 i.e. the Reliance General Insurance
Company Limited appeared and submitted that the claimpetition is subjected to strict proof by the claimant-petitioner.
O.P. No.3, owner of the motor cycle bearing No.TR01-S-7955 appeared and denied the averments made in the
claim-petition and submitted that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving by the driver of the vehicle bearing
No.TR-01-BN-0751 (Hyundai Verna). It was further submitted
that the said motor cycle was duly insured with O.P. No.4 i.e.
the Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Company Limited and the
deceased Prasenjit Saha had valid driving licence at the time of
accident.
O.P. No.4 i.e. the Bajaj Allianz General Insurance
Company Limited appeared and filed written statement and
stated that the owner and driver of the vehicle bearing
registration
No.TR-01-BN-0751
(Hyundai
Verna)
was
responsible for the alleged accident.
06.
Upon the pleadings of the parties following issues
were framed:
(I) Is the claim maintainable
present form and nature ?
in
its
(II) If the death of the deceased
Prasenjit Saha caused due to road traffic
accident on the alleged date, time and
place on account of rash and negligent
driving on the part of the driver of
vehicle
bearing
No.
TR-01-BN0751(Hyundai Verna)? If so, is the
claimant petitioner entitled to get
compensation as prayed for?
(III) What should be the quantum of
compensation and who shall be liable to
pay the compensation?
(IV) Relief/Reliefs?
07.
To substantiate the issues the appellant herself was
examined as PW1 and adduced another witness as PW2 and
relied upon some documents which were marked as Exhibit1(i) to 1(xxxi). The O.P. Nos.1 and 3 also filed their
examination-in-chief in affidavit.
08.
Finally on conclusion of the proceeding Learned
Tribunal below allowed the claim-petition filed by the claimant-
appellant and awarded a sum of Rs.15,82,000/- along with
7.5% interest from the date of filing the claim-petition till the
date of payment. For the sake of convenience the operative
portion of the judgment/award dated 22.11.2023 runs as
follows:
ORDER
22.
The
instant
application
under
Section-166 of the Motor Vehicles Act,
1988 filed by the claimant-petitioner is
hereby partly allowed and a sum of
Rs.15,82,000.00(Rupees Fifteen Lakh
Eighty Two Thousand) only is awarded in
favour of claimant – petitioner as
compensation for the death of her son
late Prasenjit Saha, in a Road Traffic
Accident, as aforesaid, and thus whole
amount of compensation shall be paid by
OP No.2, the reliance General Insurance
Co. Ltd., being insurer, within a period of
one month. The aforesaid amount shall
carry interest @ 7.5% per annum to be
paid from the date of filing of claimpetition, i.e., from 19.03.2021 till the
date of payment.
23. In the event of deposit of the
awarded
amount
with
interest,
Rs.2,00,000.00 shall be released in
favour of of the claimant-petitioner, in
her bank account for enabling her to
meet necessary expenses because at this
stage the claimant might require money
to sustain her livelihood and the rest
amount shall be kept in numbers of fixed
deposit
schemes
each
with
Rs.5,00,000.00 in any Nationalized Bank
for five years in her name separately.
24. No loan or withdrawal shall be
permitted in the fixed deposit account
nor joint name shall be allowed nor any
cheque book, ATM card can be issued
against fixed deposit account. However
the interest to be credited in the fixed
deposit may be released in favour of the
claim-petitioner as per Bank's norms. 25.
Let a copy of this Award be furnished to
the parties through their engaged Ld.
Counsels, for information. 26. The case is
thus disposed of on contest. Enter the
result in the relevant Register.
09.
I have heard argument of both the sides and
gone through the record of the Learned Tribunal below
including the judgment award delivered by Learned Tribunal
below. In para No.14 of the judgment, it appears that Learned
Tribunal below did not rely upon the evidence of PW2. So, in
absence of cogent proof the Tribunal below determined the
monthly income of the deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month like
an unskilled worker. As already stated in the claim-petition the
appellant asserted the monthly income of the deceased at
Rs.12,000/- and the appellant as PW1 also reiterated the same
fact. But PW2 who was also a driver by profession stated that
he used to pay Rs.12,000/- per month to the deceased as his
salary and in addition to that he used to pay Rs.50/- as daily
food allowance to the deceased. But that part of evidence
remained unshaken by the other contesting parties save and
except denial. The incident took place on 18.02.2021. The
Tribunal without any basis determined the monthly income of
the deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month like an unskilled
worker.
10.
It is the admitted position that said deceased was a
driver by profession. So, assuming that the deceased was a
driver and in the year 2021 by driving vehicles he could easily
earn Rs.400/- per day. So, taking into account the daily
income at Rs.400/- per day, the Tribunal ought to have
consider Rs.12,000/- per month as monthly income as a driver
on that relevant point of time. Thus, in my considered view,
the Tribunal below erred in deciding the monthly income of the
deceased at Rs.10,000/- per month being a driver. So, after
hearing both the sides, it appears that the Learned Tribunal
below committed error in deciding the monthly income of the
deceased. So, this Court after hearing both the sides comes to
the conclusion that the deceased during the year 2021 easily
could earn atleast Rs.400/- per day i.e. Rs.12,000/- per
month.
So,
his
monthly
income
would
be
assessed
to
Rs.12,000/-.
11.
Situated thus, the amount of compensation be
recalculated as under:
(i) Monthly income: Rs.12,000/(ii) Rs.12,000 (monthly income) + Rs.4,800/- (40%
of future prospects)= Rs.16,800/(iii) 50% be deducted towards personal living
expense of the deceased from Rs.16,800/-. The same comes to
Rs.8,400/-. Thus, yearly income comes to Rs.8,400 x 12=
Rs.1,00,800/-.
(iv) With the aforesaid amount multiplier 18 be
allowed as per Sarla Verma & Ors. vs. Delhi Transport
Corporation & Anr. Thus, loss of dependency comes to
Rs.1,00,800/- x 18= Rs.18,14,400/-.
(v) With the aforesaid amount Rs.15,000/- be
added as loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- be added as funeral
expenses as per judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India in National Insurance Company Limited vs.
Pranay Sethi and Ors. and Rs.40,000/- be added as parental
consortium as per judgment of the Magma General Insurance
Company Ltd. vs. Nanu Ram, reported in (2018) SCC OnLine
SC
1546.
Thus
the
claimant
will
be
entitled
to
get
Rs.18,14,400/- (loss of dependency) + Rs.15,000/- (for funeral
expenses) + Rs.15,000/- (for loss of estate) + Rs.40,000/- (for
loss of parental consortium) = Rs.18,84,400/- as total amount
of compensation.
12.
In the result, the appeal is partly allowed with
modification that the claimant will be entitled to get total
compensation amounting to Rs.18,84,400/- along with 7%
interest per annum in place of 7.5% interest awarded by the
Tribunal from the date of filing the claim-petition i.e. w.e.f.
19.03.2021 till the date of payment. The respondent O.P. No.2
shall be asked to deposit the amount to the Learned Tribunal
below within a period of two months from the date of passing
of this judgment. In the event of deposit of amount 50% of the
total amount of compensation be released in favour of the
appellant-petitioner and the rest amount shall be deposited in
a Fixed Deposit Certificate in any Nationalized Bank for a
period of 10 years by the Tribunal below in the name of the
petitioner.
A copy of this judgment/order be given free of cost
to the Learned Counsel for the appellant for information.
A copy of this judgment/order be furnished to
Learned Counsel for the respondent No.2 i.e. the Reliance
General Insurance Company Limited for information and
compliance. With this observation this appeal stands disposed
of.
Send down the LCR along with a copy of the
judgment/order.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed
of.
JUDGE
MOUMITA DATTA DATTA
Date: 2024.11.08 16:33:02 +05'30'
Purnita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review