Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010239122024
2026:GAU-AS:2220
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Cont.Cas(C)/615/2024
SMT. DIBYA LATA HAZARIKA
W/O LATE BHABA KANTA DUTTA, VILL- UJANI BHARALUA GAON, P.O.BHARALUA TINIALI, P.S.-GAURISAGAR, DIST- SIVSAGAR, ASSAM, PIN785664
VERSUS
SMTI SURANJANA SENAPATI, ACS
DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION, ASSAM, KAHILIPARA,
GUWAHATI-19
2:SHRI BIKASH DAS
AFS
DIRECTOR OF PENSION
ASSAM HOUSEFED COMPLEX
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-06
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A F N U MOLLAH, K ZAMAN
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. D SAIKIA, MR B DEURI (R-2),MS K DAS,MR S M T
CHISTIE
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY
JUDGMENT
Date : 16-02-2026
1.
Heard Mr. AFNU Mollah, learned counsel for the
petitioner. Also heard Mr. SMT Chistie, learned counsel for the
Page No.# 2/8
respondents.
2.
The present contempt petition is filed alleging
willful and deliberate non-compliance with the order dated
16.11.2023, passed in WP(C) No.3469/2022.
3.
The aforesaid Writ Petition was filed by the first wife
of Lt. Bhaba Kanta Dutta @ Bhaba Jyoti Dutta, a Government
Servant, claiming family pension.
4.
Such a family pension was not granted to the first
wife on the grounds that the deceased Government Servant
had nominated respondent No.9 (in the writ petition) as his wife
in his service records.
5.
Taking note of the provisions of Rule 143 of the
Assam Services (Pension) Rules, 1969 and the Hindu Marriage
Act,
1955,
the
learned
Judge
order
dated
16.11.2023
concluded that it is the first wife who would be entitled to the
payment of family pension as there cannot be any valid
marriage during subsistence of the first marriage, for persons
professing the hindu faith.
6.
As there was a dispute as to whether the petitioner
is the first wife of the deceased Government Servant, even
though a Next of Kin Certificate has been annexed to the writ
petition, accordingly, on a consensus, the writ petition was
disposed of directing the respondent No.4 therein to cause an
enquiry and give personal hearing to the petitioner and the
respondent No.9 therein, prior to taking a decision, as to
whether, the petitioner or the respondent No.9 is the first wife at
Page No.# 3/8
the time of death of the Government servant.
7.
It was further provided that if any of the parties are
aggrieved with the decision of the respondent No.4, they can
always take recourse to the Civil Court to prove whether either
of them is the first wife of the Government servant. Such a
decision was to be made within two months of receiving the
certified copy of the order.
8.
Alleging non compliance of the said order, the
petitioner in WP(C) No.3469/2022 has filed the present
contempt petition.
9.
The learned counsel for the respondents in the
present petition has argued that a determination was made,
and it was held that the petitioner herein is the first wife and
accordingly, a pension proposal had already been submitted
to the Director of Pension, Assam.
10.
As regards sharing of the family pension between the
first wife of the Government servant and his minor son, namely,
Piyush Krishna Dutta, from his second wife, the Director of
Pension sought a guardian certificate in respect of the minor
son from the second wife, joint photographs of the minor son
with the legal guardian etc.
11.
It is submitted by the learned counsel for the
petitioner that such documents have already been submitted
before the concerned authorities.
12.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has also
brought on record the joint affidavit, sworn by the petitioner
Page No.# 4/8
herein and the second wife of the Government servant,
agreeing to share the pension at a proportion of 60% in favour
of the petitioner herein and 40% in favour of the minor son,
namely, Piyush Krishna Dutta. The said affidavit is quoted
herein below:
“We, (1) SMTI DIBYALATA HAZARIKA, W/O - Late Bhaba
Kanta Dutta, aged about 70 years, R/O - Nazira Namati
Gaon, P.O. & P.S.- Nazira, Dist.- Sivasagar, Assam, (2) SMTI
JYOTI DUTTA, aged about 50 years, 2nd wife of Late
Bhaba Kanta Dutta, R/O Dikhowmukh Ujani Bharalua
Gaon, P.O.- Bharalua Tiniali, P.S.-Gaurisagar, Dist.Sivasagar, Assam, do hereby solemnly declare and affirm
as under.
1. That we are citizens of India by birth and permanent
resident of the above mentioned address.
2. That I deponent No. 1 is the legally married wife of Late
Bhaba Kanta Dutta who died on 20/01/2021 who was a
Govt. teacher of 58 No. Alimur Miri Prathamik Vidyalaya
and his PPO No. ADP/PPO/GPO/22/062832.
3. That I deponent No. 2 is the 2nd wife of Late Bhaba
Kanta Dutta and out of our wedlock 3 children were
borne namely at (1) Prerona Dutta (married), (2) Pran
Krishna Dutta (20 years), (3) Piyush Krishna Dutta (16 years).
4. That I deponent No. 2 do hereby declare that as my son
Piyush Krishna Dutta is a minor therefore I am executing
this affidavit on behalf of him.
5. That we both have agreed regarding the ratic between
the Deponent No. 1 and Piyush Krishna Dutta at 60:40 l.e.
60% in favour of the Deponent No. 1 and 40% in favour of
the minor Piyush Krishna Dutta.
6. That we hereby declare that the aforesaid ratio will be
applicable in case of the arrear amount and the family
pension amount till Piyush Krishna Dutta attend the age of
Page No.# 5/8
18 years old.
7. That the contents of this affidavit are true and correct to
the best of my knowledge and belief and nothing
materials has been concealed therein.”
13.
In the aforesaid backdrop the learned counsel for
the respondent Director of Pension as well as the employer
contends that in terms of the Rule 1969, only one pension
payment order (PPO) can be issued and such PPO can only be
issued exclusively in favour of the first wife of the deceased
Government servant and no separate or additional PPO can
be issued in favour of any person, including the Minor.
Therefore, they seek a direction in the present proceeding so
that the petitioner herein can be obliged to disburse the
already agreed share to the minor till the minor attains the age
of majority.
14.
The learned counsel for the petitioner agrees to the
aforesaid
proposition
of
the
learned
counsel
for
the
respondents.
15.
Thus, from the aforesaid, what is the concern in the
present proceeding is only the distribution of family pension
payable in respect of the respondent Government servant,
namely, Bhaba Kanta Dutta, amongst the claimants, namely,
Smti Dibyalata Hazarika legally wedded first wife of the
deceased and the minor, namely, Piyush Krishna Dutta born
out of the wedlock with the second wife, namely, Smti Jyoti
Dutta.
Page No.# 6/8
16.
The parentage and dependency of the minor are
not in dispute. In the joint affidavit of consent, both parties
have unequivocally stated that they have voluntarily agreed
without coercion to share the family pension in the proportion
of 60% to the first wife and 40% to the minor son. It is submitted
by the learned Counsel for the petitioner that such an
arrangement is in the best interest of the minor and that neither
party shall raise any dispute in future in respect of the said
agreement.
17.
This court records here that there is a statutory
limitation under the scheme of the Rules 1963 for issuance of
two PPO’s inasmuch as such provision permits issuance of only
one PPO in respect of the family pension, and such PPO must
be issued in favour of the first wife. The said rule does not
permit the issuance of multiple PPO’s or the division of pension
at the treasury level. This statutory position is accepted by all
parties and is not disputed.
18.
A family pension is a statutory welfare benefit
payable in accordance with pension rules. While the rule
regulates the mode of disbursement, it does not prohibit a
court-approved consent-based arrangement governing the
application
of
pension
proceeds
after
receipt
by
the
authorised pensioner.
19.
This court is also of the opinion that recording of such
a consensual arrangement as recorded herein above does not
violate Rule 143; does not require issuance of more than one
Page No.# 7/8
PPO; does not dilute the primacy of the widow, and does not
create any independent pensionary right in favour of the
minor. Such an agreement preserves the statutory priority of the
first wife; secure the welfare of the dependent minor, and is
founded entirely on voluntary consent.
20.
Since the arrangement is consensual and lawful, this
court sees no impediment to recording or enforcing it.
21.
Accordingly, this court is of the opinion that the
respondents are not in contempt of the order dated 16.11.2023
passed in WP(C) No.3469/2022.
22.
However, it is clarified that the PPO shall be issued
only in the name of the first wife, and the sharing shall operate
after receipt of the pension, arrears/currant, as a binding
obligation arising from the agreement.
23.
Accordingly, the respondent shall issue the PPO in
the aforesaid term. However, in terms of the recorded consent
and this order, out of the monthly family pension received
under the PPO, the petitioner Smti. Dibya Lata Hazarika shall
retain 60% and disburse 40% every month to the minor, Piyush
Krishna Dutta, through the natural guardian, for the minor's
maintenance, education, and welfare. The first wife shall hold
the share of the Minor in a fiduciary capacity, and the
obligation to disburse the same shall continue till the minor
attains majority.
24.
This arrangement does not create any permanent or
independent pensionary right in favour of the minor and shall
Page No.# 8/8
not require alteration of the PPO.
25.
It is needless to say that failure to comply with this
arrangement shall render the defaulting party liable to
appropriate proceedings in accordance with law.
26.
For clarity, it is provided that this order is consent
based, fact specific and shall not operate as a precedent.
27.
Accordingly, the contempt petition stands closed.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review