Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP No.23 of 2023
1. Smt. Debalina Choudhury (Chakraborty),
Wife of Late Arindam Chakraborty
2. Smt. Antarlina Chakraborty,
D/O. Late Arindam Chakraborty
-both the claimant-appellants reside at Ramnagar,
Road No.4/5, P.O. Ramnagar, Agartala, West Tripura
District, PIN:799 002
----Claimant-Appellant (s)
Versus
1. Shri Jagannath Prasad,
Son of Late Gouri Sankar Prasad,
34, Nabin Sen Road, Siliguri,
Darjeeling, West Bengal,
Owner of the Oil Tanker bearing No.NL-02-G-9992
2. National Insurance Company Limited,
9, Shakespear Sarani, near Nightingel Nursing Home,
Kolkata-71,(notice to be served through the Divisional
Manager, National Insurance Company Limited, A.K.
Road, Agartala, District: West Tripura,
Insurer of Oil Tanker bearing No.NL-02-G-1992
---- Respondents (s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. C. S. Sinha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. K. Deb, Adv.
Mr. D. J. Saha, Adv.
Along with
C.O.(F.A.) No.12 of 2023
Shri Jagannath Prasad,
Son of Late Gouri Sankar Prasad,
34, Nabin Sen Road, Siliguri,
Darjeeling, West Bengal,
Owner of the Oil Tanker bearing No.NL-02-G-9992
Versus
1. Smt. Debalina Choudhury (Chakraborty),
Wife of Late Arindam Chakraborty
2. Smt. Antarlina Chakraborty,
D/O. Late Arindam Chakraborty
-both the claimant-appellants reside at Ramnagar,
Road No.4/5, P.O. Ramnagar, Agartala, West Tripura
District, PIN:799 002
----Claimant-Appellant-Respondents (s)
3. National Insurance Company Limited,
9, Shakespear Sarani, near Nightingel Nursing Home,
Kolkata-71,(notice to be served through the Divisional
Manager, National Insurance Company Limited, A.K.
Road, Agartala, District: West Tripura,
Insurer of Oil Tanker bearing No.NL-02-G-1992
District, PIN:799 002
----Respondents (s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. A. K. Deb, Adv.
Mr. D. J. Saha, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of Hearing
:
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
Whether fit for
Reporting
:
Mr. C. S. Sinha, Adv.
28.02.2024
05.03.2024
YES/NO
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
By means of this appeal the appellants being the
claimant petitioners have challenged the award dated
25.11.2022 passed in TS (MAC) 02 of 2017 by the Learned
Member, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura,
Agartala seeking relief for modification of the award towards
just and proper compensation. The owner of the offending
vehicle i.e the OP No.1 preferred another Cross-objection as
per Order XLI Rule 22 with Section 151 of CPC challenging
the judgment and award dated 25.01.2022 passed by
Learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, West Tripura,
Agartala in case No. TS (MAC) 02 of 2017. Since both the
appeal and the cross-objection have arisen out of the same
award/judgment, so by this common judgment the matter is
taken up for hearing and consideration.
02.
Heard
Mr.
C.
S.
Sinha,
Learned
counsel
appearing for the claimant-appellants and also heard Mr. A.
K. Deb, Learned counsel representing the respondent, OP
No.2 i.e. National Insurance Company Limited and also
heard Learned counsel Mr. D. J. Saha representing the
respondent O.P. No.1 owner in respect of the appeal and
also the cross-objection filed.
03.
At the time of hearing, Learned counsel Mr. C. S.
Sinha, appearing on behalf of the appellant claimantpetitioners submitted that the claimant-petitioners preferred
an application under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act
before the Learned Tribunal seeking compensation for the
unfortunate death of one Arindam Chakraborty being the
husband of the appellant claimant-petitioner No.1 and the
father of appellant claimant-petitioner No.2. The Learned
Tribunal after exhausting all the processes by the judgment
and award dated 25.11.2022 allowed the claim application
and fasten the liability of making payment of compensation
upon OP respondent No.1 Shri Jagannath Prasad being the
owner of Oil Tanker bearing No.NL-02-G-9992. Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant
claimant-petitioners
further
submitted that to substantiate the case before the Tribunal
the appellant claimant-petitioners adduced two witnesses
and relied upon some documentary evidences which were
marked as exhibits. But at the time of determination of
compensation
the
Learned
Tribunal
did
not
properly
appreciate Exbt.6 i.e. the salary slip of the deceased
resulting which at the time of delivery of judgment/award
wrong calculation was made by Learned Tribunal deducting
professional tax and income tax from the salary of the
deceased which was not at all passed in accordance with the
relevant provisions of the MV Act, thus awarded lesser
amount of compensation to the appellant-claimants. So
Learned counsel for the appellant claimant-petitioners urged
for enhancing the amount of compensation allowed by the
Learned Tribunal below, by allowing this appeal.
04.
On the other hand, Learned counsel Mr. A. K.
Deb representing the National Insurance Company Limited,
i.e. the respondent No.2 submitted that Learned Tribunal
below rightly determined the amount of compensation at
the time of delivery of judgment and he relied upon one
citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in National
Insurance Company Limited vs. Pranay Sethi and
Others reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680 wherein in para
No.44 it was specifically observed that at the time of
determination of compensation actual income to be decided
after deducting tax and according to Learned counsel,
Learned Tribunal below, after deducting the amount of
professional tax and income tax of the deceased calculated
the monthly income of the deceased. So, according to
Learned counsel, Learned Tribunal below rightly delivered
the
judgment.
In
respect
of
cross-objection
of
the
respondent OP No.1 i.e. the owner of the offending vehicle,
he submitted that in spite of allowing opportunity the OP
owner failed to produce relevant documents like valid
driving license, insurance certificate, registration certificate
and road permit etc. before the Learned Tribunal and as per
law it was the legal obligation of the OP owner to adduce
those
documents
before
the
Learned
Tribunal
to
substantiate his defence, so that compensation, if awarded
be imposed upon the insurance company. But here in the
case, the OP owner in spite of opportunity failed to adduce
any oral as well as documentary evidence to substantiate
his defence and before this court also the cross-objector
failed to adduce any original documents in support of his
contention. So, Learned counsel for the National Insurance
Company fairly submitted that the Learned Tribunal below
rightly delivered the judgment and fastened the liability to
the OP owner and urged for upholding the judgment of the
Learned Trial court below.
05.
Learned counsel for the cross-objector, Mr. D. J.
Saha submitted that the OP owner through his attorney
appeared before the Learned Tribunal and submitted his
written statement/objection mentioning that on the alleged
day, the offending vehicle was duly insured with the
respondent
OP
No.2
vide
Insurance
Policy
No.150601/31/14/6300004515 covering the period from
28.09.2014 to midnight of 27.09.2015 and at the time of
filing
written
statement,
he
has
submitted
all
the
photocopies of relevant documents in support of the
defence, but due to some miscommunication on the day of
adducing evidence neither the OP who is an old and aged
person suffering from illness could appear before the
Learned Tribunal nor his attorney could appear before the
Tribunal along with the original documents in support of his
defence for which the Learned Tribunal below fastened the
liability with the OP owner and submitted that if the cross
objection is not allowed then the cross-objector shall suffer
severe irreparable loss and urged for allowing the OP owner
to adduce those documents either by himself or through his
attorney before the Learned Tribunal below by remanding
back the case to the Learned Tribunal for the sake of
justice.
06.
For the sake of convenience, I would like to
mention
here
in
below
the operative portion of the
award/judgment of the Learned Tribunal
below dated
25.11.2022 which is as under:
“It is, therefore, held that the petitioners are entitled to
get compensation of Rs.97,64,200/- (Rupees Ninetyseven Lakh Sixty four Thousand Two Hundred only) with
interest @ 6% per annum with effect from 02.01.2017 i.e.
the date of filing of the claim petition till the date of
actual payment. The owner of the Oil Tanker namely, Sri
Jagannath Prasad, S/O. Late Gouri Sankar Prasad, 34
Nabin Sen Road, Siliguri, District, Darjeeling, West Bengal
will pay the amount of compensation with interest within
30 days from today.
Out of the awarded amount of compensation
inclusive of interest, the petitioner no.1 will get 60% and
petitioner no.2 will get 40%. Out of the respective share
of petitioners no.1 and 2, 50% each of their share shall
be kept in fixed deposit scheme in their respective name
at the UCO Bank, District Court Branch, Agartala for a
period of five years and remaining 50% of their
respective share shall be paid to them through their
respective bank account. No loan or withdrawal shall be
permitted from any of the fixed deposit certificates
without prior permission of this Tribunal. Petitioners no.1
and 2 shall however be at liberty to withdraw monthly
interest from their fixed deposit accounts to meet their
day to day expenses.
Supply copy of this award free of cost to the
parties.
The claim petition stands disposed of on contest.
Enter the result in the relevant register as well as
in the CIS.”
07.
I have heard detailed argument of Learned
counsels at length and perused the record of the Learned
Tribunal below as well as the memo of appeal and the
cross-objection filed by the objector. Admittedly, in the
case, there was no dispute on record in respect of the death
of the deceased Arindam Chakraborty due to road traffic
accident on 08.07.2015 inside Agartala Airport on link road
near IOC complex. To substantiate the claim the appellant
claimant-petitioners
adduced
two
witnesses
i.e.
the
claimant-petitioner No.1 as PW-1 and one Pranay Sarkar as
PW-2 and relied upon some documentary evidences which
were marked as Exbt.1-7. The contesting respondent OPs
by the art of cross-examination could not discard the
evidence of the appellant claimant-petitioner No.1 and their
witnesses save and except denial and also the respondent
OPs in support of their defence did not adduce any
oral/documentary evidence on record and finally after going
through the pleadings of the parties and on perusal of the
documentary evidence on record the Learned Tribunal below
delivered the award as aforesaid.
08.
In course of hearing of argument, Learned
counsel appearing for the appellant claimant-petitioners
relied upon one judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in United India Insurance Company Limited vs.
Laxmamma and Others reported in (2012) 5 SCC 234.
In para-26 Hon’ble the Apex court observed as under:
“26. In our view, the legal position is this: where the
policy of insurance is issued by an authorised insurer on
receipt of cheque towards the payment of premium and
such a cheque is returned dishonoured, the liability of the
authorised insurer to indemnify the third parties in
respect of the liability which that policy covered subsists
and it has to satisfy the award of compensation by reason
of the provisions of Sections 147(5) and 149(1) of the MV
Act unless the policy of insurance is cancelled by the
authorized insurer and intimation of such cancellation
has reached the insured before the accident. In other
words, where the policy of insurance is issued by an
authorised insurer to cover a vehicle on receipt of the
cheque paid towards premium and the cheque gets
dishonoured and before the accident of the vehicle
occurs, such insurance company cancels the policy of
insurance and sends intimation thereof to the owner, the
insurance company’s liability to indemnify the third
parties which that policy covered ceases and the
insurance company is not liable to satisfy awards of
compensation in respect thereof.”
Learned counsel Mr. Sinha also relied upon
another judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Karnataka in
M.F.A. NO.7043/2014 (MV-I) dated 02.12.2022. In para15 of the judgment Hon’ble Karnataka High Court observed
as under:
“15. The counsel for the respondent also brought to
notice of this Court the manner of receipt of premium
regulations of 2002 and I have already discussed
regulation Nos.3 and 4 with regard to mode of payment
as well as commencement of risk. The issue involved
between the parties also considered by the Apex Court in
the case of ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. 14 LTD., vs
INDERJIT KAUR AND OTHERS reported in (1998) 1 SCC
371. The counsel would contend that the Apex Court has
not discussed the same but in this judgment particularly
Insurance Act, 1938, Section 64VB was discussed by the
Apex Court regarding liability of insurer when cheque
received towards premium dishonoured but policy not
avoided. Insurer issuing insurance policy on receiving
cheque towards premium, cheque dishonoured, insurer
informing the insured that the cheque having been
dishonoured, the insurer would not be at risk. In such
circumstances, the insurer, even if he was entitled to
avoid the policy for not having received the premium,
held, nonetheless liable for third party risks as the public
interest served by an insurance policy must prevail over
the insurer’s interest. It is further observed that the
insurance policy, left open, public interest. It is held that
despite the bar created by Section 64VB of the Insurance
Act, the appellant, an authorized insurer, issued a policy
of insurance to cover the bus without receiving the
premium therefore. By reason of the provisions of
Sections 147(5) and 149(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, the
appellant became liable to indemnify third parties in
respect of 15 the liability which that policy covered and to
satisfy award of compensation in respect thereof
notwithstanding its entitlement (upon this question the
supreme Court did not express any opinion) to avoid or
cancel the policy for the reason that the cehque issued in
payment of the premium thereon had not been
honoured.”
Referring the same, Learned counsel appearing
for the appellant submitted that both the aforesaid cases
are relevant for decision of this appeal.
09.
On the other hand, Learned counsel Mr. A. K.
Deb representing the Insurance Company, in course of
hearing of argument relied upon the judgment of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in National Insurance
Company Limited (supra) in para No.44 where the Apex
court observed as under:
“44. At this stage, we must immediately say that insofar
as the aforesaid multiplicand/multiplier is concerned, it
has to be accepted on the basis of income established by
the legal representatives of the deceased. Future
prospects are to be added to the sum on the percentage
basis and “income” means actual income less than the
tax paid. The multiplier has already been fixed in Sarla
Verma which has been approved in Reshma Kumari with
which we concur.”
Referring the same Learned counsel for the
insurance company submitted that at the time of delivery of
the award Learned Tribunal below in para No.14 on perusal
of Exbt.6 i.e. the salary slip for the month of June, 2015 of
the deceased determined the monthly gross salary of the
deceased as Rs.1,11,870/- and from that amount he
deducted Rs.180/- and deducted Rs.16,923/- as income
tax. Thus he calculated his monthly income after deducting
the aforesaid taxes amounting to Rs.95,397/-. After that he
added 15% of the said income as future income in view of
the aforesaid judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10.
So after going through the Exbt.6 it appears to
me that the Learned Tribunal below did not commit any
error or wrong in calculating monthly income of the
deceased. So the submission of the Learned counsel for the
claimants that Exbt.6 was not properly appreciated by the
Learned Tribunal below was not correct for which the
judgment of the Learned Tribunal needs no interference to
the extent as stated above. The citations as referred by
appellant-claimants are not relevant for the decision of this
case. Now in respect of fastening the liability to the crossobjector i.e. the owner of the offending vehicle it appears
that
before
the
Learned
Tribunal
the
OP
owner
on
27.03.2019 submitted his written statement through his
attorney Abhay Kant Kumar and submitted the photocopy of
attorney and other documents before the Learned Tribunal.
But at the time of recording evidence neither the OP owner
Jagannath
Prasad
nor
his
Attorney
as
stated
above
appeared along with the original documents to substantiate
the written statement rebutting the claim of the appellant
claimant-petitioners for which the Learned Tribunal below
rightly fastened the liability of payment of compensation to
the OP owner for want of proving of original insurance policy
and other connected documents. Since the OP owner took
the plea that on the alleged day the offending vehicle had
all the valid documents of the vehicle including valid
insurance policy and valid driving license of the driver, so it
appears that for the sake of justice opportunity be given to
the cross-objector is the respondent OP owner to adduce his
oral as well as documentary evidence to substantiate his
defence so as to exonerate him from the liability of payment
of compensation as per award of the Tribunal if he actually
has got valid documents of the offending vehicle on the day
of alleged accident.
11.
In the result, the appeal filed by the appellant
claimant-petitioners stands dismissed being devoid of merit
and the cross-objection filed by the respondent OP owner as
well as the prayer for adducing additional evidence is
hereby allowed. The case be remanded back to the Learned
Tribunal below with a direction to give an opportunity to the
respondent OP owner to adduce his oral as well as
documentary
evidence
with
opportunity
to
the
other
contesting parties to cross-examine the OP. The Learned
Tribunal shall deliver a fresh judgment after taking evidence
of the OP owner and at the time of delivery of judgment the
rate of interest @6% p.a. as imposed earlier with effect
from 25.11.2022 to till date i.e. date of delivery of this
present judgment be fixed upon the OP owner as due to his
fault that liability has fasten upon the insurance company.
The entire exercise shall be completed within a period of
one month from the date of receipt of the copy of this
judgment by the Tribunal. Learned counsels for the parties
are hereby requested to cooperate with the Tribunal for
early disposal of the case. The OP owner shall appear before
the Learned Tribunal on 15.03.2024 and adduce his
oral/documentary evidence, if any. With this observation,
the award of the Learned Tribunal is modified to the extent
above and both the cases are disposed of accordingly.
Pending application(s) if any, stands disposed of.
A copy of this judgment be supplied to the
Learned counsel Mr. C. S. Sinha for the appellant claimantpetitioners and Mr. A. K. Deb, Learned counsel representing
the respondent, OP No.2 i.e. National Insurance Company
Limited
and
also
Learned
counsel
Mr.
D.
J.
Saha
representing the respondent O.P. No.1. Send down the LCRs
along with a copy of this judgment.
JUDGE
SABYASACHI
BHATTACHARJEE
BHATTACHARJEE Date: 2024.03.07 05:03:55 -08'00'
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review