Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.10 of 2023
Smt. Chinu Rani Singha,
Wife of Late Indrajit Singha,
Resident of Kushamara, Kakraban,
PS-Kakraban, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura.(Age-57 years)
….Appellant(s)
Versus
Sri Ratan Singha,
Son of Late Jitendra Chandra Singha,
Resident of Kushamara, Kakraban,
PS-Kakraban, Udaipur, Gomati, Tripura, Pin-799105.
….Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
:
Ms. N. Ghosh, Advocate
For Respondent(s)
:
None
Date of hearing
and delivery of
judgment & order
:
29.05.2023
Whether fit for
reporting
:
Yes
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
Judgment & Order (Oral)
This is a second appeal preferred by the original defendant, the
appellant herein against the judgment dated 19.01.2023 and decree dated
31.01.2023 passed by the learned District Judge, Gomati District, Udaipur,
in Title Appeal No.11 of 2021 whereby the judgment and decree passed by
learned trial Court in T.S. 11 of 2018 was upheld.
2.
The facts of the case as projected by learned first appellate
Court may be reproduced hereunder:
“3. The plaintiffs' case as urged before the Ld Trial Court is
that originally Smti Mira Rani Roy, D/O Lt. Amar Chand Roy was the
sole owner in possession of the schedule “A”land mention in the plaint
purchased by registered sale deed No.8239 dated 16.12.1968 and vide
deed No.3967 dated 08.06.1970 executed by Jatindra ch Chowdhuree,
S/O Lt Nabin Chandra Chowdhuree, Balai Chandra Sarkar , S/O Lt
Prafulla Chandra Sarkar and Smti Snahalata Sarkar, D/O Lt. Profulla
chandra Sarkar. After the death of Mira Rani Roy, her legal heirs
namely Babul Ch Roy son and daughter Uma Rani Roy (Datta) became
joint owner in possession with equal shares in the inherited land left by
their mother Mira Rani Roy(now deceased), since 1980. After the death
of their mother one mutual settlement was made between the legal heirs
of Mira Rani Roy and in that settlement it was decided that inherited
land will be divided into two equal shares. On the basis on the said
settlement one registered Gift deed No.1-2225 dated 20.05.1980 was
made by Babul Ch Roy son & legal heir of Mira Rani Roy in favour of
Uma Rani Roy (Datta) daughter. Based on this registered Gift deed
Uma Rani Roy (Datta) acquired title over 0.36 acres of land out of 0.72
acres of land mention schedule “A” land of the plaint. In 1983 being in
urgent need of money, Uma Rani Roy (Datta) sold out 0.16 acres in CS
khatian NO.53. In Sabek dag No.1716, 0.12 acres of land and in sabek
dag No.1566/5253 0.04 acres i.e. in total 0.16 acres of land was sold to
one Ratan ch Singha @ Ratan Singha (plaintiff-respondent herein) by a
registered sale deed No.1-2791 dated 15.11.1983. After purchase of the
schedule “B” land i.e. suit land mentioned in the plaint, the plaintiffrespondent entered into his purchased land and the executor of the
sale deed namely Uma Rani Roy (Datta) handed over possession of the
land to plaintiff-respondent Ratan Ch Singha @ Ratan Singh & since
then the plaintiff was peacefully possessing the suit land announcing
his right, title, interest. It is averred that during the life time of
deceased Mira Rani Roy she never applied for mutation of her
purchased land mentioned in schedule “A” of the plaint and neither did
her legal heirs. The plaintiff many times tried to apply for mutation of
schedule “B” land but due to restrain by the defendants, the system of
mutation could not processed. One day in the middle part of 2017 AD,
the defendants and her agents wrongfully entered into the suit land
and tried to dispossess the plaintiff from the suit land and also
disputed the ownership of the plaintiff over the suit land but due to
strong resistance on the part of plaintiff and his neighbors from the
locality, the attempt of defendant failed. Since, January 2018 plaintiff
had started to reside nearby the suit land in the house of his in laws due
to family affairs. On 20.07.18 in absence of plaintiff the defendant and
her men & agents forcefully entered into the suit land and threw out
the utensils and other articles from his dwelling hut. The plaintiff
informed the matter to OC KKB PS who advised the plaintiff that this
being a civil dispute, plaintiff may take shelter before the civil court and
accordingly plaintiff took shelter before ADR center and requested the
authority to mitigate the dispute. They tried their level best but failed
and hence TS 11 of 2018 was instituted for recovery of possession and
declaration of right, title and interest over the suit land along with cost
of the suit.”
3.
After exchange of pleadings, learned trial Court had framed
issues. On the basis of issues, evidences were adduced by the parties. The
plaintiff-respondent has produced a original copy of the registered sale
deed which is marked as Exbt.- 2 through which he purchased the suit land
from one Smt. Uma Rani Roy without any objection from the side of the
defendant. Smt. Uma Rani Roy is the daughter of Mira Rani Roy who was
originally the real owner of the suit land. The fact that Mira Rani Roy was
the real owner of the suit land cannot be disputed for the reason that the
defendant herself has stated in her written statement as well as in her
evidence that she has been possessing the suit land since the lifetime of the
real owner of the suit land i.e. Mira Rani Roy.
4.
It is the case of the defendant that Mira Rani Roy during her
lifetime had tried to evict the defendant from the suit land but she failed.
So, the ownership of Mira Rani Roy, the mother of Smt. Uma Rani Roy
over the suit land is an admitted position. Mira Rani Roy was the owner of
a total land measuring 0.72 acres. After her death, there was an amicable
settlement between the son and daughter of Mira Rani Roy. According to
this mutual arrangement, Uma Rani Roy has received her share for a land
measuring 0.36 acres. Out of this 0.36 acres, Smt. Uma Rani Roy had sold
0.16 acres of land to the plaintiff i.e. Sri Ratan Singha in the year 1983 by
executing a registered sale deed(Exbt.-2) and handed over the vacant
possession of the said land in favour of the plaintiff. According to the
plaintiff, the cause of action for institution of the present suit lastly arose
on 20.07.2018 when the defendant forcefully occupied the suit land i.e. the
land of Schedule B mentioned in the plaint. On the basis of those aforesaid
facts and on consideration of the evidences let in by the parties to the lis,
both the Courts below held that the plaintiff Ratan Singha has been able to
prove his title and possession over the suit land after his purchase, and
since then he had been possessing the suit land till his forceful
dispossession from the suit land mentioned in the Schedule B w.e.f.
20.07.2018.
5.
Feeling aggrieved with the findings of both the Courts below
decreeing the suit in favour of the plaintiff, the defendant has preferred the
instant second appeal before this Court.
6.
I have heard Ms. N. Ghosh, learned counsel appearing for
the appellant-defendant.
7.
Ms. Ghosh, learned counsel for the appellant in her quest to
convince the Court for admitting the present second appeal has submitted
that Uma Rani Roy was a permissive possessor as has been recorded in
Khatian no.1109. Ms. Ghosh, learned counsel has further submitted that
the plaintiff has failed to substantiate that Sri Babul Ch. Roy, the son of
Mira Rani Roy had gifted the suit land in favour of his sister, Smt. Uma
Rani Roy.
In support of this submission, Ms. Ghosh, learned counsel
for the appellant quite empathetically has contended that from the gift deed
itself it becomes apparent that there is no endorsement that Uma Rani Roy
being the donee had accepted the gift deed(Exbt.-3). For this reason, it can
be said that she has not acquired title over the gifted land. Learned counsel
for the appellant has further submitted that the certified copy of the sale
deed and gift deed had not been proved in accordance with law. It is
further argued that the defendant is still in possession of the suit land.
8.
I have considered the above submissions advanced by
learned counsel appearing for the appellant and perused the records
annexed to the memo. of this appeal.
9.
The fact of title is a question of fact and both the Courts
below held that the plaintiff has been able to prove his title and possession
over the suit land. This Court in exercise of its jurisdiction under Section
100 of the CPC will not interfere with the findings of the Courts below as
regards the title of the plaintiff over the suit land unless such findings
appear to be perverse by this Court.
10.
Now, to deal with the evidentiary value of certified copies of
registered sale deed or gift deed, needless to say, certified copies of such
deeds are secondary evidence and as such, these are admissible in
evidence. Since it is admissible in evidence, its admissibility cannot be
questioned. However, a party to a suit can question the mode of proof of
such certified copies. But, challenge has to be made at the time when such
certified copies were tendered during the course of recording evidence.
Again, once a document is admitted, the contents of the documents are also
admitted in evidence, though, those contents may not be a conclusive
evidence. However, burden lies upon the opposite party to rebut or counter
such admitted evidence tendered by other party. It is well-settled that,
once a document has been properly admitted, the contents of the
documents would stand admitted in evidence, and if no objection has been
raised with regard to its mode of proof at the stage of tendering in
evidence, no such objection will be allowed to be raised at a later stage of
the case in appeal or revision. This principle of law is re-iterated in a
recent decision by a full-bench of the Hon‟ble Supreme court in Neeraj
Dutta vs State(NCT of Delhi), (2023) 4 SCC 731[SCC pp767, 768, para
62].
[emphasis supplied]
11.
In the instant case, it is noticed that the plaintiff has tendered
original copy of the sale deed(Exbt.-2) by which he purchased the land of
Schedule „B‟ of the plaint from Smt. Uma Rani Roy, the daughter of the
original owner, i.e. her mother Mira Rani Roy. The plaintiff has also
produced during the course of evidence the certified copies of the
registered title deeds (Exbt.-4 and 5) in the name of Mira Rani Roy. When
those certified copies of the title deeds, in proof of the ownership of Mira
Rani Roy over the suit land, tendered in evidence, the defendant did not
raise any objection and permitted the plaintiff to tender those certified
copies to be admitted in evidence, and the Court had accepted those
certified copies in evidence since such certified copies are admissible in
evidence and accordingly, marked as exhibits. Similarly, the plaintiff has
also tendered certified copy of the gift deed(Exbt.-3) without any objection
from the defendant.
12.
To deal with the question, learned counsel for the appellant
has raised, that the plaintiff has not acquired title over the land under the
gift deed since she has not accepted the said gift in express terms in the
deed. In this regard, I have no hesitation to say that whether a person
accepts a gift or not, can be established by way of his/her subsequent acts
and conduct. In the instant case, Smt. Uma Rani Roy, the donee after the
execution and registration of the gift deed by her brother had taken over
the possession of the gifted land of Schedule „A‟ and after few days she
sold a portion of the land of said Schedule “A” described in Schedule “B”
of the plaint to the plaintiff and there is no material on record that the
donor of the gift deed had raised the issue of non-acceptance of the gift
relating to the land of Schedule „A‟ which he donated to Smti. Uma Rani
Roy, his sister. Added to it, her subsequent sale of „B‟ Schedule land to the
plaintiff is a glaring proof of her acceptance to the gift deed. She also tried
for mutation of the land in her favour, which has been objected by the
defendant as apparent on the face of the written statement and evidence.
PW-2, in her evidence has categorically stated that after the purchase of
schedule land from Uma Rani Roy, the plaintiff started to possess it by
way of construction of huts, etc. He also tried to mutate the land in his
favour. Such conduct of the plaintiff is the manifestation of the fact that his
vendor, that is, Smt. Uma Rani Roy had accepted the gift deed(Exbt.2).
So, the submission of learned counsel for the appellant in this regard is
repelled.
13.
Considering the submission of Ms. Ghosh, learned counsel
appearing for the appellant that a permissive possessor cannot institute a
suit for recovery of possession and declaration of title, as reflected in the
Record of Right (Khatian), in the opinion of this Court, Khatian is not the
conclusive proof of one‟s title or possession. It can be rebutted by way of
appropriate evidence. There is no dispute in the present case that Uma Rani
Roy is the daughter of Mira Rani Roy, the original owner of the suit land.
This fact of ownership has been further confirmed by the defendant when
she has asserted in her written statement and evidence that Mira Rani Roy
being the owner of the suit land had tried to evict the appellant in the year
1983 itself. So, this is a clear admission on behalf of the appellant that it
was Mira Rani Roy, but none else, was the original owner of the suit land.
As such, Uma Rani Roy cannot be a permissive possessor, but, an owner
and a possessor of the suit land being one of the inheritors of the original
owner of the suit land and also by dint of the Gift deed(Exbt.-3), executed
by her full-blooded brother.
14.
Another aspect required to be noticed is that there is no
mention of the appellant, Chinu Rani Singha in any of the columns of the
said Khatian no.1109, to say the least, as regards her nature and character
of possession. Contrary thereto, Uma Rani Roy has successfully
established that she inherited her share being the daughter of Late Mira
Rani Roy, the original owner of the entire land of Schedule-“A” measuring
0.36 acres, which she received by way of gift out of an amicable settlement
between her and Babul Ch. Roy. In view of this, creation of Records of
Right i.e. Khatian has been wrongly made showing the name Smt. Uma
Rani Roy as permissive possessor, which is necessary to be corrected by
the concerned authority.
15.
Furthermore, I am in agreement with the findings of the
Courts below that the defendant has failed to prove his plea of adverse
possession.
16.
Based upon the aforesaid conclusions, I do not find any
merit in the present second appeal to interfere with the findings of the
Courts below declaring the right, title and interest of the plaintiff of the
said land and directing the defendant to hand over the vacant possession of
the suit land.
Accordingly, the instant appeal stands dismissed at this stage.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed.
JUDGE
Snigdha
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review