Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3488 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY, THE FOURTH DAY OF AUGUST
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL NO: 796 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patent Appeal Preferred Against the
Order Dated 2910612026, in W.P. No. 16773 of 2026 on the file of the High Court.
Between:
Smt. Chenna Sulochana @ Donthula Sulochana, D/o. Late Chenna Chinnaiah,
W/o. Donthula Laxminarayana, Age about 63 years, Occ_ Housewife, Native of
Brahmanpally (V), Jakranpally (M) Presently Fi/o. H.No. 2-1-2921102,
Vegetable Market, Nallakunta, Hyderabad - 500044.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. Munnuru Kapu Sangam, Brahmanpalli Village, Jakranpally Mandal,
Nizamabad District, Represented by its President B.Gangadhar S/o Mallaiah,
Aged 50 years.
2. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to the Panchayat Raj
and Rural Development Department, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad.
3. The Collector (Panchayat Wing), Nizamabad District, Nizamabad.
4. The Mandal Parishad Development Officer, Jakranpally Mandal, Jakranpally,
Nizamabad District.
5. The Gram Panchayat, Brahmanpalli Village, Jakranpally Mandal, Nizamabad
District, Rep. by its Panchayat Secretary.
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 1OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to suspend
the order daled 2910612026 passed in W.P.No. 16773 of 2026 pending disposal of
the Writ Appeal in the interest of justice.
Gounsel for the Appellant: SRl. D LAXMINARAYANA
Counsel forthe Respondents No 1: SRI K. VENU MADHAV
Counsel for the Respondent No.2 & 3: Ms SHAZIA PARVEEN,
GP FOR PANCHAYAT RAJ AND RURUAL DEVELOPMENT
Counsel for the Respondent No.4 & 5: SRI K. PRADEEP REDDY,
SC FOR GRAM PANCHAYAT
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
I
Iil TTIE HIGH @I,'RT T'iOR TIIE STATE OF TEIANGANA
AT IIYDERABAI)
TTIE HOII"BI,ETIIE CHIF,FJUSTICE SRI A,PARESII XUIUAR SINGH
AND
THE HOIT'BLE SRI WSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
WRIT APPEAL No.796 ol 2o26
DATE: o,4.04.2o.26
Between:
Chenna Sulochana
....Appellant
Ard
Munnuru Kapu Sangam,
Brahmanpalli Village and 4 others
....Respoadents
JUDGMENT
Heard Sri D.Laxminarayana, learned counsel for the
appellant; Sri K.Venu Madhav, learned counsel for respondent
No.
1; Ms.Shazia Parveen, learned Govemment Pleader for
Panchayat Raj appearing for respondent Nos.2 and 3; Sri
K.Pradeep Reddy, learned Standing Counsel for Telangana Gram
Panchayat appearing for respondent Nos.4 and 5 and perused the
record.
2.
This writ appeal is preferred under Clause 15 of the Letters
Patent, against the order dated 29.06.2026 passed by the learned
Single Judge in W.P.No.16773 of 2026. By the said order, the
Iearned Single Judge has set aside the proceedings of the District
Collector (Panchayat Wing), Nizamabad, dated 10.04.2026, which
2.
had cancelled the mutation of the subject property in favour of the
writ petitioner (1"t respondent herein) and directed restoration of
the name of the original owner, late Chenna Chinnaiah and also
granted liberty to the parties to approach competent Civil Court to
establish their rights, title and possession over the subject
property.
Factual matrix
3.
The subject matter of the present proceeclings relates to
property bearing Gram Panchayat House No.3-124, situated at
Brahmanpalll' Village, Jakranpaliy Mandal, Nizamabad District,
admeasuring 2,420 Sq. Yds (2 1,780 Sq' Ft.) (hereafter referred to
as the 'subject property'). The appellant claims that the said
property originally belonged to her father, late Chenna Chinnaiah,
and that, being hrs sole surviving lega1 heir, she succeeded to the
property upon his demise.
4.
The writ petitioner/ 1st respondent claims title and
possession over the subject property under a registered Sale Deed
dated 17.06.2017 bearing Document No.242O of '2017, stated to
have been executed by one Sri Gurai Rajanna. According to the
writ petitioner, Sri Gurai Rajanna had eariier acquired the property
lrom the legal heirs of late Chenna Chinnaiah under an
unregistered Sada Bainama dated rg.or.2oor. It is further case of
the \r.rit petitioner that its name had been
mutated in the Gram
J
)
Panchayat records vide Gram panchayat proceedings No.49 of
20 76, d,ated, I 3.O4.2O 16.
5.
Questioning the aJoresaid mutation proceedings, the
appellant preferred an appeal under Section 121 of the Teiangana
Panchayat Raj Act, 2018 (for short.2018 ActJ before the District
Collector (Panchayat Wing), Nizamabad. Upon conducting an
enquiry and taking into consideratton, inter alia, the report of the
Forensic Science Laboratory (FSL), which disclosed dissimilarities
in the signatures appearing on the Sada Bainama dated
18.07.2001, the
District Collector,
by proceedings dated
10.04.2026 in Proc.No.B3 / lt1 I 2025, allowed the appeal
and
cancelled the mutation effected in favour of the writ petitioner.
6.
Aggrieved by the said order of the District Collector,
the writ
petitioner instituted W.p.No.16773 of 2026. The learned
Judge, by order dated 29 -06.2026, held that the dispute
Single
between
the parties essentially involved questions relating to title
and
possession over the subject property, which
could onlv be
adjudicated by a competent Civil Court. Consequently,
while
granting liberty to the parties to work out their
remedies before the
Civil Court, the learned Single Judge set aside the
order dated
1O.O4.2026 passed by the District Collector.
7.
Aggrieved thereby, the appellant has preferred
Writ Appeal.
the present
Submisslons on behalf of the appellant
8.
l,earned counsel appearing for the appellant, assailed the
impugned order and has advanced the following submissions:
i)
That the subject property originally belonged to late Chenna
Chinnaiah, who died intestate, and the appellant, being his
sole suniving legal heir, succeeded to the property by
inheritance and is, therefore, entitled to have her rights duly
reflected in the Gram Panchayat records.
i1) That the 1"t respondent/writ petilioner has no lawful title or
locus to claim ownership over the subject property' The very
foundation of its claim is an unregistered 'Sada Bainama'
(unregistered sale deed) dated 18.07.2001 allegedly executed
in favour of Sri Gurai Rajanna, on the basis of which a
registered Saie Deed dated 17.06.2017 bearing Document
No.242O of 201.7 came to be executed in favour of the writ
petitioner. It was contended that an unregistered Sada
Bainama does not convey title to immovable property in view
of Section 54 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 (for short
the 1882 Act') . In support of the said contention, reliance
was placed upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court
in Sura.j La np & Industries hrt. Ltd. u. State ot
t
Haryanat, wherein it was held that title to immovable
property can be transferred only through a duly registered
conveyance and not by way of unregistered documents.
iii) That the District Collector, whiie deciding the statutory
appeal, rightly relied upon the report of the Telangana FSL,
which categorically disclosed dissimilarities between the
admitted signatures and the signatures appearing on the
alleged Sada Bainama dated l8.O7.2OOl, thereby rendering
the document highly doubtful and incapable of conferring
any right upon the writ petitioner.
iv) That the learned Single Judge committed a serious error in
passing the impugned order without duly considering the
detailed counter afhdavit filed by the appellant, wherein the
entire sequence of events, including the alleged fraudulent
creation of documents and the circumstances surrounding
the mutation proceedings, had been specifically brought to
the notice of the Court.
v) That the mutation proceedings dated 13.O4.2016 themselves
stood vitiated by fraud, inasmuch as the mutation notice was
addressed to late Chenna Chinnaiah, who had expired in the
year 1983, and no notice whatsoever was issued to the
appellant, who is his sole Iegal heir. According to the learned
counsel, the mutation was thus effected behind the back of
' (20r2) l scc 656
the appellant and in violation of the principies of natural
justice.
vi) That the objection regarding limitation under Section 122 of
the 2018 Act is wholly misconceived. It was argued that the
appellant acquired knowledge of the impugned mutation and
the alleged fraudulent transactions only in November, 2024,
whereafter she promptly secured the relevant records and
preferred the statutory appeal under Section 121 of the Act'
That in cases where fraud is alleged, limitation commences
only from the clate of knowledge, and therefore, the appeal is
within limitation.
vii) That the learned Single Judge ought not to have interfered
with the reasoned order passed by the District Collector and
ought to have relegated the parties to avail remedy before
civil Courts without setting aside the order of the District
Collector, which had restored the revenue records after
taking into consideration the forensic report and the material
availa ble on record .
Submissions on behalf of the respondents
g.
l,earned counscl appearing for the l"t respondent, learned
Government Pleader appearing for respondent Nos.2 and 3 and
learned Standing Counsel appearing for respondent Nos.4 and 5
have advanced the follou,ing submissions:
!
i) That as seen from the record, the writ petitioner is the
absolute owner and possessor of the subject property, having
purchased the same under a registered Sale Deed dated
17.06.2017 bearing Document No.242O of 2Ol7 executed by
Sri Gurai Rajanna. It was further submitted that the writ
petitioner's name had been duly mutated in the Gram
Panchayat records uide Gram Panchayat Proceedings No'49
of 2016 dated 13.04.2016. Pursuant thereto, the writ
petitioner obtained building permission from the Gram
Panchayat on 04.05.2018 and constructed a function hall in
accordance with the sanctioned plan, and has been in
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the property ever
slnce.
ii) That the mutation in favour of the writ petitioner was
effected as early as 13.O4.2O16 and remained unquestioned
for nearly ten years. The appeilant preferred the statutory
appeal before the District Collector only in t}re yeat 2024,
which was ex facie barred by limitation under Section 122 of
the 2018 Act, prescribing a limitation period of thirty days. It
was, therefore, submitted that the District Collector ought
not to have entertained such a belated appeal.
iii)
That the District Collector lacked jurisdiction to adjudicate
disputed questions of title. According to the respondents, the
controversy between the parties invoives compiicated
questions of fact and 1aw concerning the validity of the
alleged Sada Bainama dated i8.07.2001, the allegations of
fraud, the competing claims of succession, and the respective
title of the parties, all of which can be adjudicated only by a
competent Civil Court and not in proceedings relating to
mutation.
it )
That the District Collector herself recorded a categorical
finding in the impugned proceedings that her ofhce lacked
jurisdiction to decide issues relating to civil rights and title
and that such disputes are required to be adjudicated by the
competent Civil Court. Having recorded such a finding, the
District Collector committed a manifest error in proceeding to
cancel thc mutation effected in favour of the rryrit petitioner.
v) That the learned Single Judge rightly set aside the
proceedings of the District Collector and relegated the parties
to avail their remedies before the competent Civil Court. It
was contended that mutation entries are maintained only for
hscal and administrative purposes and neither create nor
extinguish title over immovable property.
10.
We have taken note of the respective contentions urged
perused the material on record
and
Conaideration by this Court
11. In the present case the appellant's contention itself
demonstrates that the dispute between the parties essentially
concerrls competing claims of title, the validity of the alleged Sada
Bainama dated 18.O7.2OO1, allegations of fraud, and succession to
the subject property. These are matters which cannot be
conclusively determined in mutation proceedings and necessarily
require adjudication by a competent Civil Court upon appreciation
of oral and documentary evidence.
12. It is a settled law that mutation entries in revenue or Gram
Panchayat records neither create nor exLinguish title to immovable
property. Such entries are maintained primarily for fiscal and
administrative purposes, including the assessment and collection
of taxes, and do not confer any proprietary rights upon the person
in whose favour the mutation is effected. The appellant has placed
reliance upon the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Surogi
Lannp's case (supra 1) to contend that an unregistered Sada
Bainama does not convey title to immovable property.
13. As rightly observed by the learned Single Judge, the dispute
between the parties is essentially one relating to title and
consequential civil rights over the subject property. The
adjudication of such issues necessarily requires a detailed
l0
examination o1'the rival claims, the validity and evidentiary value
of the documents relied upon by the parties, and other disputed
questions of fact, which fall within the exclusive domain of the
competent Civil Court.
14. A perusal of the proceedings dated 1O.O4.2026 passed by the
District Collector discloses that the Collector herself recorded a
categorical finding that "this Court/ Office does not haue the
jurisdiction to settle the consequential proyers relating to ciuil in
nature, uhich can be adjudicated before the appropiate forum.'
Having arrived at such a conclusion, the Collector nevertheless
proceeded to cancel the mutation effected in favour of the writ
petitioner. Such a course was clearly beyond the scope of the
jurisdiction vested in the appellate authority under the 2018 Act.
15. It is pertinent to note that the appellate power conferred
under Section 121 of the 2018 Act is intended lo examine the
legaliq' and correctness of administrative actions taken by the
Gram Panchayat in relation to mutation proceedings. The said
provision does not empower the appellate authoritv to adjudicate
disputed questions relating to title, succession, fraud, or the
validity of documents, all of which fall within the exclusive domain
of the competent Civil Court. Further, the view taken by the
learned Single ._rudge that in the absence of jurisdiction
adjudlcate civil disputes, the District
to
Collector ought not to have
proceeded to cancel the mutation, does not warrant interference'
The learned Single Judge was justified in setting aside the order of
the District Collector while leaving it open to the parties to
establish their respective rights, title ald possession before the
competent Civil Court.
16. Section 122 of the 2Ol8 Act prescribes a period of limitation
of thirly days for preferring an appeal before the District Collector.
In the present case, the mutation proceedings were issued on
13.04.2016, whereas the appellant preferred the appeal only on
28.11.2024, after a lapse of nearly eight years and seven months.
The appellant seeks to explain the delay by contending that she
acquired knowledge of the impugned mutation and the alleged
fraud only in November, 2024 an:d that the appeal was preferred
immediately thereafter.
17. The plea advanced by the appellant that the alleged fraud
came to her knowledge only in November, 2024, and that limitation
would commence from the date of such knowledge, cannot be
examined in isolation. Equally, the contenLion of the writ petitioner
that the appea-l was barred by limitation raises questions as to
when the appellant acquired actual or constructive knowledge of
the mutation, whether there was any suppression of material facts,
and whether the plea of fraud is sustainable on the evidence. These
are disputed questions of fact which necessarily require
appreciation of oral and documentar5r evidence and cannot be
satisfactorily adjudicated in proceedings arising out of mutation or
in the exercise of writ jurisdiction.
18. Further, the appellant has alleged that the Sada Bainama
dated 18.07.2001 is a forged document and that the mutation in
favour of the writ petitioner was secured in collusion with the then
Panchayat Secretary. In support of the said allegations, reliance
has been placed on the report of the Telangana Forensic Science
Laboratory, ivhich, according to
the appellant, discloses
dissimilarities in the signatures appearing on the said document.
19. It is to l)e noted that the question as to whether the Sada
Bainama is genuine, whether the mutation was procured by fraud,
whether the subsequent registered Sale Deed dated 17.06.2017
conveys a valid tit1e. and the legal consequences flowing therefrom,
are al1 disputed questrons involving mixed questions of fact and
law- The adjudication of these issues necessarily requires
appreciation of oral and documentary evidence, which falls outside
the scope of the jurisdiction exercisable by the District Collector
under the 20 18 Act as well as the writ Court in exercise of Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
2o. In this regard, the learned Single Judge has nghtly observed
that the dispute between the parties essentially relates to title and
consequential civil rights. In such circumstances, relegating
the
parties to the competent Civil Court is not only proper but also in
consonance with the settled legal position. This Court is unable to
accept the contention of the appellalt that in view of the
proposition laid down in
the decisions in Komatlreddg
Janakirann Reddg a. The State o:f Telangdna2 and Sural La n1t
& Industrles Prrt. Ltd. (supra 1) interference with the impugned
order by this Court is warranted. The controversy in the present
case involves disputed questions relating to title and alleged fraud,
which can appropriately be adjudicated only by the competent Civil
Court.
Conclusion
21. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered
view that the learned Single Judge has rightly held that the dispute
between the parties pertains to title and consequential civil rights,
which cannot be adjudicated in mutation proceedings and are
required to be determined by the competent Civil Court. Therefore,
this Court finds no ground warranting interference with the
impugned order. The writ appeal is devoid of merit.
22. Accordingly, the Writ Appeal is dismissed. The order dated
29.06.2026 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P.No. 16773 of
2026 is affirmed. It is, however, made clear that the parties are at
'w.A.No.651 of 2o2t dated 04.o2.2o22
,r
t4
liberty to avail their remedies before the competent Civil Court,
where all issues shall be decided on their own merits, in
accordance with law, and uninfluenced by any observations made
in the order of the learned Single Judge or in the present
judgment.
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, pending if any, stand
closed. No costs
SD/. V.HARI PRASAD
DEPUW REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To,
'1
. One CC to SRl. D LAX[/INARAYANA, Advocate [OPUC]
- Two CCs to GP FOR PANCHAYAT RAJ AND RVEAL DEVELOPMENT 'Hish
Court ior the State of Telangana At Hyderabad [OUT]
3. One CCto SRI K. PRADEEP REDDY, SC FORGRAM PANCHAYAT
loPUCl
(
4. One CC to SRI K. VENUIVADHAV, Advocate IOPUCI
5. Two CD CoPies
DAN
TKS
\6l6
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0410812026
JUDGMENT
WA.No.796 o12026
rHE
\
14 t
e
c
2O AUG 2026
(j
,+
t
t
-i--
DISMISSING THE WRIT APPEAL
WITHOUT COSTS
^seI
-b ccR'
&o
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review