Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
"
#
#
$
$
%
""
&"
)
!"# $
%
%&
SACHIN
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
!"# $
&
%
!"# $
'"
(
-2-
!
!"# $
'
(
)
!
*
!"# $
%
+
Amendment carried out vide
order dated 15.02.2017
,
!"# $
+ $% %$ #
% )
#
!"# $
% )
#
-3-
!"# $
'
(
-
.
-
-
%( )
%( )
%( )
%( )
)
+#
%( ).
-
&$ $
-
%$ !
#" %$ %
-
-
/
-
--
-
-4-
$
(
)
45 6718298::; 82
33898<217
166517
&$ $
< #" %$ % <2 945 :875 <: 945
528<=
8>87
?3@5
8A1B6?= 41>5 :8753 948;
C417752@82@
A?3@D529
35C=55
31953
%$ ! EB F48C4 945 ;?89 F1; 38;D8;;53
%
45 61=985; ;4177 452C5:<=94 E5 =5:5==53 9< 1;
945B F5=5 1==1B53 E5:<=5 945
F5=5
6718298::;
=817
<?=9
45 166577129;
=5;6<23529;
F5=5
:8753
:<=
61=9898<2 123 ;561=195 6<;;5;;8<2 <: 945 6718298::;G
!94
35:523129;
&(8)
;?89
< #" %$ %
;41=5 82 945 ;?89 ;C453?75 6=<65=985;
F1;
45 ;?89 ;C453?75
6=<65=985; F5=5
1) 1=9
<:
1417E1@1B19
D51;?=82@
6=<65=9B
E51=82@
B
1C=5 <?9 <: & 1C=5;
;89?1953
<
@?291;
-5-
E) 123
6=<65=9B
E51=82@
B
;89?1953
<
1417E1@1B19
% D51;?=82@ ! 1C=5; <:
! @?291;
C)
<?;5 6=<65=9B E51=82@
!&
82 F1=3
D595=; 123 &#
(88)
!%
D51;?=82@ &#
+ ;H?1=5
+ ;H?1=5 D595=; =5;65C98>57B
45 6718298::; C718D53 9419 6718298::
F8:5 123 6718298::
<
<
<
<; % 9<
<
8; 945
1=5 945 C4873=52 <: 35:523129
45B :?=945= C718D53 9419 35:523129
<
123 48;
<:
E=<945=; @<9
! 1C=5; + @?291; 82
B
<
1417E1@1B19
8A16?= 82 945 B51=
+#&
161=9 :=<D
<:
1=3
4<?;5; E51=82@
8A16?=
1C=5
<
!%
!&
<
<:
?9 <: 945 ;183 1@=8C?79?=17 7123 12 5I9529 <:
! @?291; F1; 1CH?8=53 :<= 1 3=1821@5 6=<A5C9 EB 945
89B
?28C8617
<?2C87
8A16?=
<2;5H?5297B 12 5I9529 <: & 1C=5; &
(888)
6718298::
B51=
< % <2
<; % 9<
+ #
@?291; =5D18253
?9 <: 945 1:<=5;183 5I9529 35:523129
48; E=<945=; ;<73 & 1C=5;
35:523129
<
@?291; <2 945 2<=945=2 ;835 9<
" $# %$$
F894<?9 945 C<2;529 <:
123 F894<?9 12B :1D87B 25C5;;89B
-6-
16651=; 9419 945 =5D18282@ 7123 F1; E8:?=C1953 123
2?DE5=53 1;
B
<
E59F552 35:523129
%
<
45=51:95=
82 1 61=9898<2
123 48; E=<945=;
B
<
%
F48C4 D51;?=53 ! 1C=5; ! @?291; 82 @=<;; 123
1C=5; &%
@?291; 82 259 F1; 177<9953 9< 35:523129
<
?9 <: 945
;183 7123 %$ @?291; F1; 1CH?8=53 :<=
198<217
<
&
<2;5H?5297B F419 =5D18253 F894 35:523129
F1; 12 5I9529 <:
1C=5;
<
123 945 6718298::;
45 6718298::; C718D53 9419 945B F5=5 2<9 1F1=5
<: 945 ;175 3553 31953
<
<
% @?291; F48C4 F1; 945 A<829
:1D87B 6=<65=9B <: 35:523129
(8>)
8@4F1B
" $# %$$
5I5C?953 EB 35:523129
123 48; E=<945=; 82 :1><?= <: 35:523129
:?=945= C718D53 9419 35:523129
1@=55D529 <: ;175 31953 &
@?291; 82
B
<
C<2;835=198<2
45B
413 5I5C?953 12
% %$$+ 82 =5;65C9 <: & 1C=5;
% 82 :1><?= <: 35:523129
1 9<917 ;175 C<2;835=198<2 <:
=5C58>53 1 ;?D <:
<
<%
< % :<=
; # $$ $$$ , 123 413
; ! $$ $$$ , 1; 61=9 <: 945 1@=553 ;175
45 E=<945= <: 35:523129
<
F1; 17;< 12
1995;982@ F8925;; 9< 945 ;183 1@=55D529
45 6718298::;
-7-
C718D53 9419 945B F5=5 2<9 1F1=5 <: 945 ;183 1@=55D529
123 9419 945=5 F1; 2< 25C5;;89B 9< ;577 945 ;183 6=<65=9B
123 9419 945 ;183 1@=55D529 F1; 2<9 E82382@ ?6<2 945D
45B
945=5:<=5
;<?@49
:<=
61=9898<2
;561=195
6<;;5;;8<2 <: 9458= ;41=5 82 945 ;?89 6=<65=985;
(8)
45 ;?89 F1; C<295;953 EB 35:523129
F1; 945 6?=C41;5= <: & 1C=5;
3553 31953
" $# %$$
< % F4<
@?291; 82 95=D; <: 1 ;175
123 & 1C=5;
12 1@=55D529 <: ;175 31953 &
@?291; 82 95=D; <:
% %$$+
5 352853 945
1;;5=98<2; D135 82 945 671829 123 C718D53 9419 F452
35:523129
<
6=<65=985; 35:523129
1C=5
1C=5;
<
! @?291; 82
3=1821@5 6=<A5C9 EB 945
(88)
48;
E=<945=;
61=9898<253
F1; 1 D82<=
B
89B
5 17;< 352853
<
F1; 1CH?8=53 :<= 1
?28C8617
<?2C87
8A16?=
5 13D89953 9419 177 945 94=55 E=<945=; ;<73 &
@?291; 82 48; :1><?= 82 95=D; <: 1 ;175 3553 31953
" $# %$$
35:523129
<
C718D53
<945=
E=<945=; <:
F5=5 2<9 1==1B53 1; 61=985; 9< 945 ;?89 123
9419 945=5 F1; 2< 8295=5;9 <: 12B D82<= 82 945 ;?89
-8-
6=<65=9B 19 945 98D5 <: 17852198<2 EB 35:523129
:1><?= <: 35:523129
<%
@?291; 82
% F1; 1CH?8=53 :<=
B
<
123 C718D53 9419 945
<
5 4<F5>5= 13D89953 9419 %$
198<217
8@4F1B
198<217
8@4F1B;
?94<=89B <?@49 9<
41>5 E552 1==1B53 1; 1 61=9B 9< 945 ;?89 1:95= 8;;?82@
2<98C5 ?235=
5C98<2 "$ <: 945
<35 <:
C718D53 9419 ;82C5 9419 F1; 2<9 3<25
8>87
=<C53?=5
945 ;?89 <: 945
6718298::; F1; 781E75 9< E5 38;D8;;53
(888)
5 C<2952353 9419 19 945 98D5 <: 5I5C?98<2 <:
945 1@=55D529 <: ;175 31953 &
% %$$+ 35:523129
<
F1; 945 1E;<7?95 <F25= 1; 65= 945 =5C<=3 <: =8@49; 123
9419 1 ;?89 82
< %&# %$
F1; :8753 :<= 52:<=C5D529
<: 945 ;183 1@=55D529 <: ;175
(8>)
5 :?=945= C<2952353 9419 1:95= 65=?;17 <: 945
=5C<=3; <: 945 =5>52?5 3561=9D529 45 F1; ;?=6=8;53 9<
2<95 9419 35:523129
<
C<2;68=53 F894 6718298::
<;
9<
& 413 E=<?@49 1E<?9 1 =5>52?5 529=B E1;53 <2 1
52C5
45 F1; C<D657753 9< ;55J :<=
C12C577198<2 <: 945 D?9198<2 529=B ;912382@ 82 945 21D5;
-9-
<: 6718298::
<;
9< &
894 945;5 123 ;8D871= =8@D1=<75
C<295298<2; 45 ;?ED89953 9419 945 ;?89 :<= 61=9898<2 8; 2<9
D18291821E75
1;53 <2 945;5 C<295298<2; 945
:=1D53 945 :<77<F82@ 8;;?5;
!
"
#
"
"
$
#
=817
<?=9
- 10 -
>88)
!
718298::
9<
<
F1; 5I1D8253 1;
I ,
5:523129
D1=J53
I ,
1;
,
123 45 5I1D8253
;1D5
>8771@5
1@=55D529
<:
;175
31953
,
123 ;45
< % F1; 5I1D8253
,% F4< F1; 1 =5;83529 <:
1995;982@
&
F8925;;
% %$$+
9<
<F5>5=
35:523129; 383 2<9 D1=J 12B 3<C?D5291=B 5>8352C5
#(8)
1;53 <2 945 <=17 123 3<C?D5291=B 5>8352C5
=817
<?=9 4573 9419 945 6718298::; :18753 9< 6=<>5 9419
945 ;?89 6=<65=985; F5=5 945 ?238>8353 6=<65=985; <: 945
:1D87B
9 :?=945= 4573 9419 945 6718298::; :18753 9< 5;91E78;4
9419 35:523129
<
35=8>53 945 ;?89 6=<65=985; 82 1
61=9898<2 E59F552 48D 123 48; E=<945=;
9 17;< 4573 9419
945 6718298::; :18753 9< 6=<>5 9419 35:523129
<
F1;
1338C953 9< E13 >8C5; 123 945=5:<=5 45 413 A<8253 4123;
F894
48; E=<945=
5I5C?982@ 945
" $# %$$ 82 :1><?= <: 35:523129
<%
;175
31953
- 11 -
(88)
45 =817
<?=9 :?=945= 4573 9419 35:523129
<%
F1; 52989753 9< 6?=C41;5 1@=8C?79?=17 7123 1; 45 F1; 12
1@=8C?79?=178;9 123 9419 45 413 D135 177 =51;<21E75
52H?8=85; 9< ;198;:B82@ 945 5I8;952C5 <: 75@17 123 :1D87B
25C5;;89B :<= 945 ;175 <: 945 6=<65=9B
=817
<?=9 9452
6=<C55353 9< 38;D8;; 945 ;?89 82 95=D; <: 945 8D6?@253
A?3@D529 123 35C=55
582@ 1@@=85>53 EB 945 ;183
A?3@D529 123 35C=55 945 6718298::; 1=5 E5:<=5 948;
<?=9
(8)
45 751=253 C<?2;57 :<= 945 6718298::; C<2952353
I ,
5;91E78;45; 9419 945 7123 E51=82@
F1; 4573 A<8297B EB 35:523129
<
B
<
123 48; E=<945=;
945=5:<=5 C<29523; 9419 945 :82382@; <: 945
=817
<?=9 9419
945 ;?89 6=<65=9B F1; 2<9 945 A<829 :1D87B 6=<65=9B 8;
F894<?9 12B E1;8;
5 C<29523; 9419 35:523129
<
48; E=<945=; 413 13D899537B ;<73 945 7123 & 1C=5;
@?291; 82 95=D; <: 1 ;175 3553 31953
" $# %$$
1; 65=
I ,& 123 9419 945 6718298::; F4< 1=5 17;< 52989753 9< 12
?238>8353 ;41=5 82 945 ;?89 6=<65=985;
F5=5 258945=
- 12 -
C<2;?7953 2<= 383 945B C<2;529 9< 89 123 945B F5=5 2<9
82:<=D53 1E<?9 945 ;183 ;175
(88)
5 :?=945= C<29523; 9419 F452 945 ;175 3553
31953 " $# %$$
8; C417752@53 <2 945 @=<?23 9419 945=5 8;
2< 75@17 25C5;;89B 9< ;577 945 ;?89 6=<65=9B
89 F1;
82C?DE529 ?6<2 945 6?=C41;5= 9< 133?C5 =51;<21E75
5>8352C5 9< 6=<>5 9419 945=5 F1; :1D87B 25C5;;89B 123
945=5:<=5 945 ;175 3553 8; 2<9 E82382@ <2 945
<: 51C4 <: 945 6718298::; 82 & 1C=5;
(888)
@?291; 82
@?291;
5 :?=945= C<29523; 9419 1:95=
B
<
!94 ;41=5
1C=5;
% :577 9< 945 ;41=5 <: 35:523129
%
<
45 ?21?94<=8K537B 123 F894<?9 945 2<98C5 123 J2<F753@5
<: 945 6718298::; 413 5I5C?953 1 ;175 1@=55D529 31953
&
% %$$+ 82 :1><?= <: 35:523129
<%
5>52 94<?@4
945=5 F1; 2< C<==5;6<2382@ :1D87B 25C5;;89B
5 94?;
C<29523; 9419 945 6718298::; 1=5 52989753 9< C718D 9458= ;41=5
1C=5; % @?291; 82
B
<
%
- 13 -
(8>)
5 ;?ED89; 9419 35:523129
<%
F4< 8; 945
6?=C41;5= 383 2<9 5>52 D1J5 12 1995D69 9< 67513 F419 945
75@17 25C5;;89B F1; F48C4 C<D657753 35:523129
5I5C?95 12 1@=55D529 <: ;175 <: & 1C=5;
<
%
<
9<
@?291; 82
B
5 945=5:<=5 C<29523; 9419 945
=817
<?=9
C<DD89953 12 5==<= 82 38;D8;;82@ 945 ;?89 <2 5I9=125<?;
@=<?23; 123 6=1B; 9419 945 8D6?@253 A?3@D529 123
35C=55 E5 ;59 1;835 123 945 ;?89 :8753 EB 945 6718298::; E5
35C=553
%
<
&
945 751=253 C<?2;57 :<= 35:523129
;?ED89; 9419 35:523129
<
41; 2<9 :8753 12B F=89952
;9195D529 123 945=5:<=5 8; 2<9 82 1 6<;898<2 9< 91J5 12B
;9123 82 945 D1995=
<F5>5= 45 13D89; 9419 35:523129
< % 413 :8753 1 ;?89 :<= ;65C8:8C 65=:<=D12C5 <: 945
1@=55D529 <: ;175 31953 &
% %$$+ 123 9419 945 ;183 ;?89
F1; 61=97B 35C=553 38=5C982@ =5:?23 <: 945 1@=553 ;175
C<2;835=198<2 1@182;9 F48C4 35:523129
<!
< % :8753
%$ " F48C4 17;< C1D5 9< E5 38;D8;;53 123 9419
- 14 -
< %$$%%
%$%$ 8; 652382@ C<2;835=198<2 E5:<=5 948;
<?=9
+(8)
45 751=253 C<?2;57 :<= 35:523129
< % <2 945
<945= 4123 ;?ED89; 9419 945 ;175 3553 82 =5;65C9 <: & 1C=5
@?291; F1; 5I5C?953 <2
945 6718298::; 123 35:523129
" $# %$$
<
5 ;?ED89; 9419
F5=5 =5;8382@ 82 945
;1D5 4<?;5 5>52 1; <2 945 3195 <: :8782@ <: 945 ;?89
945=5EB 8238C1982@ 9419 89 8; 35:523129
945 6718298::; 9< :875 945 ;?89
<
F4< 413 ;59 ?6
5 :?=945= ;?ED89; 9419 945
;175 3553 89;57: E51=; =5:5=52C5 9< 945 :1C9 9419 35:523129
<
413 ;<73 945 ;?89 6=<65=9B 9< D559 :1D87B 25C5;;8985;
(88)
5 C<29523; 9419 35:523129
<
123 48;
E=<945=; 413 17;< C<2;52953 9< 945 :1C9 9419 945=5 F5=5
C5=9182 :1D87B 25C5;;8985; F48C4 C<D657753 945D 9< ;577 945
;?89 6=<65=985;
5 :?=945= C<29523; 9419 89 F1; :<= 945
6718298::; 9< 5;91E78;4 9419 945 :1D87B F1; F577,<:: <=
1::7?529 123 9419 945=5 F1; 2< 25C5;;89B 9< ;577 945 ;?89
6=<65=985;
5 945=5:<=5 C<29523; 9419 945
=817
<?=9 F1;
A?;98:853 82 38;D8;;82@ 945 ;?89 82;<:1= 1; 945 6=<65=985;
- 15 -
C<>5=53 ?235= 945 ;175 3553 31953
" $# %$$
( I ,&)
1=5 C<2C5=253
(888)
;
=5@1=3;
1@=55D529 31953 &
C<295298<2
;175
% %$$+ F1; 5I5C?953 F894<?9 945
2<98C5 123 J2<F753@5 <: 945 6718298::; 45 C<29523; 9419
35:523129
<
F1; 945 J1=941 <: 945 :1D87B 123 945=5:<=5
F1; 52989753 9< 52C?DE5= 945 6=<65=985; <: 945 :1D87B 9<
D559 :1D87B 25C5;;8985;
5 C<29523; 9419 945 H?5;98<2 1;
9< F45945= 945=5 F1; 12B :1D87B 25C5;;89B <= 2<9 8; 1
H?5;98<2 <: :1C9
5;91E78;4
91J82@
F48C4 945 6718298::; F5=5 E<?23 9<
5 945=5:<=5 C<29523; 9419 945
829<
1CC<?29
=817
C8=C?D;912C5;
<?=9 1:95=
41;
=8@497B
38;D8;;53 945 ;?89 :8753 EB 945 6718298::; :<= 61=9898<2 123
;561=195 6<;;5;;8<2 <: 9458= ;41=5 82 945 ;?89 6=<65=985;
(8>)
; =5@1=3; 945 4<?;5 6=<65=985;
45 ;?ED89;
9419 45 41; 2< <EA5C98<2 :<= 35C=5582@ 945 ;?89 :<=
61=9898<2
- 16 -
$
5 41>5 C<2;835=53 945 ;?ED8;;8<2; D135 EB
945 751=253 C<?2;57 :<= 945 6718298::; 1; F577 1; 945 751=253
C<?2;57 :<= 35:523129
<;
123 %
45 6<829; 9419 1=8;5; :<= C<2;835=198<2 82 948;
166517 1=5
(8)
L 45945=
38;D8;;82@
;?89
=817
5>52
5;91E78;453 9419 35:523129
<
<?=9
F1;
A?;98:853
94<?@4
3<C?D529;
413 35=8>53 945 ;?89
6=<65=9B 19 1 61=9898<2 E59F552 48D 123 48; E=<945=;MN
(88)
L 45945= 945=5 F1; 12B 71F:?7 25C5;;89B 9419
C<D657753 945 35:523129
1C=5;
@?291; <:
<
123 48; E=<945=; 9< ;577 &
1417E1@1B19 :<= 945 6?=6<;5 <: :1D87B
25C5;;8985; 9< 35:523129
< % 82 95=D; <: 945 ;175 3553
31953 " $# %$$ MN
%
48; ;?89 8; :8753 82 =5;65C9 <: 94=55 61=C57; <:
6=<65=985; F48C4 1=5 21==1953 82 61=1@=164
45 :8=;9 61=C57 F1; 945
@?291; 82
B
<
< & 1E<>5
1C=5 <: 7123 <?9 <: & 1C=5;
48;
1C=5 8; 6?=6<=9537B 945
&=3
- 17 -
;41=5 <: 35:523129
<
82 945 ;183
B
<
45 ;175
3553 F48C4 8; D1=J53 1;
I ,& ;4<F; 9419 945 7123 F1;
C<2>5B53 EB 35:523129
123 48; E=<945=; 9< 35:523129
<%
9<
D559 945
5:523129
<
;183 ;175 3553
<
71F:?7 25C5;;8985; <: 945
:1D87B
123 48; 9F< E=<945=; F5=5 61=985; 9< 945
45B 1=5 2<9 5I1D8253 E5:<=5 945
<?=9 9<
38;6=<>5 945 :1C9 9419 945=5 F1; 12B :1D87B 25C5;;8985;
F48C4 C<D657753 35:523129
1C=5;
@?291; 82
B
<
<
123 48; E=<945=; 9< ;577 &
45 35:523129
<
945 6718298::; 1=5 =5;8382@ 82 945 ;1D5 4<?;5 123 945=5:<=5
945=5 16651=; 9< E5 2< C<2:78C9 <: 8295=5;9 E59F552 945D
45 35:523129
" $# %$$
<
F4< 8; 1 6=8>B 9< 945 ;175 3553 31953
D?;9 41>5 5295=53 945 F8925;; E<I 123 91J5 1
;9123 1; 9< F4B 945 7123 413 9< E5 ;<73
&
9 D1B E5 9=?5 9419 F4525>5= 12 17852198<2 <:
A<829 :1D87B 6=<65=9B 8; H?5;98<253 89 8; :<= 945 6?=C41;5=
9< 6=<>5 945 :1D87B 25C5;;89B
<F5>5= 945 6718298::; 1=5
2<9 9<9177B 5I5D69 :=<D 5;91E78;482@ 9419 945 :1D87B F1;
1::7?529 <= 6<;;5;;53 <: ;?::8C8529 :?23; 123 9419 945=5
- 18 -
F1; 2< 25C5;;89B 9< 52C?DE5= <= 17852195 945 6=<65=985; <:
945 :1D87B
9 8; =575>129 9< 2<95 9419 F452 945 ;?89 F1;
:8753 82 945 B51= %$ % 6718298::
< % F1; 1@53 1E<?9 %$
B51=; F4875 6718298::
F5=5 1@53 1E<?9
<; & 123
% B51=; =5;65C98>57B 123 F5=5 =56=5;52953 EB 9458=
D<945=
45 6718298::; 123 35:523129
945 ;1D5 4<?;5
35:523129
<
<
F5=5 =5;8382@ 82
45=5:<=5 89 C<?73 H?895 E5 6<;;8E75 9419
1:95= 41>82@ ;<73 $& 1C=5
:1><?= <: 35:523129
< % 82
B
<
@?291; 82
413 ;59,?6 945
6718298::; 9< C417752@5 945 17852198<2 123 C718D 9458= ;41=5
82 945 ;?89 6=<65=985; 82 =59178198<2 9< 945 C718D D135 EB
35:523129
< % 82 =5;65C9 <: $& 1C=5;
B
6?=;?129 9< 12 1@=55D529 <: ;175 5I5C?953
<
EB 35:523129
<
<2 &
% %$$+
@?291; 82
45=5:<=5 945 6718298::;
1=5 2<9 A?;98:853 82 71B82@ 9458= C718D :<= 9458= ;41=5 82
=5;65C9 <: $& 1C=5;
@?291; 82
C<2>5B53 EB 945 35:523129
<: 35:523129
<%
<
B
<
9419 F1;
123 48; E=<945=; 82 :1><?=
52C5 945 :82382@ =5C<=353 EB 945 9=817
<?=9 9419 945 6718298::; 1=5 2<9 52989753 9< 1 ;41=5 82 $
- 19 -
1C=5 <?9 <: $& 1C=5;
@?291; 82
B
<
8; A?;9 123
6=<65= 123 3<5; 2<9 F1==129 12B 8295=:5=52C5
2;<:1= 1; 945 C718D <: 945 6718298::; 82 =5;65C9
<: $
1C=5
% @?291; 82
6718298::;
B
F5=5
6=<65=985; 123 35:523129
<
% 89 8; =575>129 9< 2<95
17;<
8295=5;953
<
;?89
F1; E<?23 9< 6=<95C9 945
8295=5;9 <: 945 6718298::; F4875 52C?DE5=82@ 945 6=<65=985;
<: 945 :1D87B 9< 35:523129
<%
9 8; =575>129 9< 2<95 9419
945 :1D87B <: 945 35:523129
<
123 945 6718298::; 383 2<9
41>5
<945=
B
12B
<945=
<
6=<65=9B
45=5:<=5
B
<
!
35:523129
945=5 D?;9 41>5 E552 ;<D5
A?;98:8C198<2 :<= 35:523129
@?291; 82
<
9< 52C?DE5= $& 1C=5
82 :1><?= <: 35:523129
<%
65=?;17 <: 945 F=89952 ;9195D529 :8753 EB
< % ;4<F; 9419 945=5 8; 2<9 5>52 1 F48;65=
1E<?9 945 25C5;;8985; 9419 C<D657753 945 35:523129
<
9< 5295= 829< 12 1@=55D529 <: ;175 9< C<2>5B $& 1C=5;
@?291; 82
B
<
45=5:<=5 F5 41>5 2< 45;89198<2
9< 4<73 9419 945 6718298::; 1=5 2<9 E<?23 EB 945 1@=55D529
- 20 -
<: ;175 31953 &
% %$$+ 5I5C?953 EB 35:523129
:1><?= <: 35:523129
B
<
6718298::
% <:
<; % 9<
6=<65=9B 82
<
< % 82 =5;65C9 <: $& 1C=5;
1417E1@1B19
@?291;
<295D6<=125<?;7B 945
E582@ 945 C<,61=C525=; 82 =5;65C9 <: 945
% 17<2@ F894 6718298::
<
1=5
52989753 9< 12
5H?17 ;41=5 F894 35:523129
<
B
1417E1@1B19
<
<
B
<
% <:
;;?D82@ 9419 35:523129
41; 5I5C?953 12 1@=55D529 <: ;175 82 :1><?= <:
35:523129
< % 9419 F<?73 <27B C<2C5=2 945
35:523129
<
#
B
<
!94 ;41=5 <:
% 123 2<9482@ D<=5
; =5@1=3; 945 4<?;5 6=<65=9B 35:523129
<
41; 2<9 C<295;953 945 ;?89 <: 945 6718298::; 123 35:523129
< % 413 2< C718D 82;<:1= 1; 945 4<?;5 6=<65=985; 1=5
C<2C5=253 123 452C5 945 9=817
<?=9 D?;9 41>5 35C=553
945 ;?89 :<= 61=9898<2 82 =5;65C9 <: 945 4<?;5 6=<65=985;
2 >85F <: 945 1:<=5;183 F5 41>5 2< 45;89198<2
9< 4<73 9419 945 9=817
<?=9 C<DD89953 12 5==<= 82 2<9
35C=5582@ 945 ;?89 <: 945 6718298::; 82 61=9 82 =5;65C9 <: $
- 21 -
1C=5;
% @?291; 82
4<?;5 6=<65=985;
B
<
% <:
1417E1@1B19 123 945
52C5 945 :<77<F82@ <=35= 8; 61;;53
8)
45 166517 8;
88)
45 8D6?@253 A?3@D529 123 35C=55 31953
&$ $
%$ ! 61;;53 82
<?=9 <: 945
< #" %$ % EB 945
33898<217
528<=
8>87
?3@5
8A1B6?= 8; ;59 1;835 123 945 ;?89 <: 945
6718298::; 8; 35C=553 82 61=9
888)
<?9 <: $
1C=5;
% @?291; 82
6=<65=985; E51=82@
1=3
123 &#
<
B
<
% <:
!94 ;41=5 82 945 4<?;5
1417E1@1B19 123 17;<
8>)
!94 ;41=5
45 6718298::; 1=5 4573 52989753 9<
<; !%
8A16?= D51;?=82@ &#
!&
<:
+ ;H D9=;
+ ;H D9=; =5;65C98>57B
9 8; D135 C751= 9419 945 ;175 1@=55D529 31953
&
% %$$+
35:523129
6?=6<=9537B
<
5I5C?953
82 :1><?= <: 35:523129
EB
< % 82
- 22 -
=5;65C9 <: $& 1C=5;
<:
B
<
%
1417E1@1B19 ;4177 E5 52:<=C51E75 <27B 9<
945 5I9529 <:
B
@?291; 82
<
!94 ;41=5 <: 35:523129
<
% D51;?=82@ $ 1C=5; % @?291;
1=985; 1=5 38=5C953 9< E51= 9458= <F2 C<;9;
>)
*'
&
(
*'
&
8;9
<
<
%"
%
(
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review