Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
MAC APP NO.13 OF 2022
Smt. Champa Sinha,
W/o. Lt. Babu Chan Sinha,
Of Village-AC office Elaka, P.S.-Kumarghat,
District- Unakoti Tripura.
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Sri Nepal Sharma,
S/o Late Jagadish Sharma,
Of Ambassa Colony, P.S.-Ambassa,
District- Dhalai Tripura,
[Driver of TR-04-A-1802(Truck)].
2. Sri Kishaloy Roy,
S/o. Sri K.K. Roy,
Of 86 Hospital, Extension Road,
Agartala, West Tripura,
(Owner of Motorcycle TR-01-N-7181).
3. Sri Nishan Saha,
S/o Nitai Saha,
Of Ambassa Town, P.S.- Ambassa,
District- Dhalai Tripura,
[Owner of TR-04-A-1802(Truck)]
4. The Branch Manager,
New India Assurance Company Limited,
Divisional Office, Mantri Bari Road,
Page NO.1 of 19 Title Suit (MAC) 20 of 2018,
Agartala West Tripura,
(Insurer of Motor Cycle TR-01-N-7181).
5. The Branch Manager,
Future General India Insurance Co. Ltd,
2nd Floor, GRS Towwer RMA Chowmohani,
A.K. Road, Agartala, West Tripura.
[insurer of Motor Cycle TR-04-A-1802(Truck)].
6. Prasenjit Sinha,
S/o. Late Pratap Sinha,
Ward No.3, S.E. Office, Kumarghat,
Unakoti District.
(The name of Sri Prasenjit Sinha added as OP No.6 as per Order dated
30.05.2019).
……. Respondent(s)
MAC APP NO.14 OF 2022
1. Sri Sukumar Sinha,
S/o Late Ram Babu Sinha,
2. Smt. Debakanya Sinha, Age-60
W/o. Sukumar Sinha,
Both are resident of Village-S.E. Complex,
P.S.-Kumarghat, District-Unakoti Tripura.
……… Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Sri Nepal Sharma,
S/o Late Jagadish Sharma,
Of Ambassa Colony, P.S.-Ambassa,
District- Dhalai Tripura,
[Driver of TR-04-A-1802(Truck)].
2. Sri Kishaloy Roy,
S/o. Sri K.K. Roy,
Of 86 Hospital, Extension Road,
Agartala, West Tripura,
(Owner of Motorcycle TR-01-N-7181).
3. Sri Nishan Saha,
S/o Nitai Saha,
Of Ambassa Town, P.S.- Ambassa,
District- Dhalai Tripura,
[Owner of TR-04-A-1802(Truck)]
4. The Branch Manager,
New India Assurance Company Limited,
Divisional Office, Mantri Bari Road,
Page NO.1 of 19 Title Suit (MAC) 20 of 2018,
Agartala West Tripura,
(Insurer of Motor Cycle TR-01-N-7181).
5. The Branch Manager,
Future General India Insurance Co. Ltd,
2nd Floor, GRS Towwer RMA Chowmohani,
A.K. Road, Agartala, West Tripura.
[insurer of Motor Cycle TR-04-A-1802(Truck)].
6. Prasenjit Sinha,
S/o. Late Pratap Sinha,
Ward No.3, S.E. Office, Kumarghat,
Unakoti District.
(The name of Sri Prasenjit Sinha added as OP No.6 as per Order dated
30.05.2019).
……. Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. H.K Bhowmik, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. P. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. D. Debnath , Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 18.07.2023
Whether fit for reporting : YES/NO.
HON’BLE MR JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
Both these appeals are heard and taken up together
for disposal since similar questions of facts and law are involved.
2.
Both these appeals are filed under Section 173 of the
Motor Vehicles Act, 1968.
i.
MAC App No.13 of 2022 has been filed against
the impugned Judgment and Order dated 23.11.2021 passed by
the
learned
Member,
MACT(2nd),
Unakoti
Judicial
District,
Kailashahar in connection with Case No.TS(MAC) No.03 of 2019
arising out of the Misc. petition 24 of 2017(AIR), whereby, learned
Tribunal has rejected the prayer of claimant made under Section
166 of the M.V. Act, being devoid of merit.
ii.
MAC App No.14 of 2022 has been filed against
the impugned Judgment and Order dated 23.11.2021 passed by
the
learned
Member,
MACT(2nd),
Unakoti
Judicial
District,
Kailashahar in connection with Case No.TS(MAC)20 of 2018 arising
out of Misc. Petition 26 of 2017(AIR), whereby, the learned
Tribunal rejected the prayer of the claimants made under Section
166 of the M.V. Act being devoid of merit.
3.
The brief fact of these cases is that on 05.10.2016 at
about 22.30 hours, a truck loaded with wooden logs was parked on
the Kumarghat-Fatikroy Road near Ramkrishna Ashram. At that
time, a vehicle bearing no. TR-01-N-7181 (Motorcycle) was
proceeding from Fatikroy side and dashed on the backside of the
truck. As a result, the rider-Pradip Sinha and the pillion rider-Raju
Sinha of the motorcycle fell down on the road and sustained severe
bleeding injuries. Kumarghat fire service personnel rushed to the
spot and shifted the injured to Kumarghat Hospital, Kumarghat,
and on 06.10.2016 both the injured died. The deceased Raju Sinha
was about 24 (twenty-four) years of age and the deceased Pradip
Sinha was about 32(thirty-two) years of age at the time of
accident. The deceased Raju-Sinha left the claimant of MAC App
No.13 of 2022 as his legal heirs and the deceased Pradip Sinha left
the claimants of MAC App No.14 of 2022 as his legal heir. Both the
deceased were businessmen by profession and their monthly
income was claimed to be about Rs. 6,000/- (Rupees six thousand)
only each.
4.
Due to the sudden unnatural death of the deceased
Raju Sinha, the claimant of MAC App No.13 of 2022 estimated a
claim of Rs. 20,54,000/- (Rupees twenty lakhs fifty-four thousand)
only towards compensation and due to sudden unnatural death of
the deceased-Pradip Sinha, the claimants of MAC App No.14 of
2022 estimated claim is Rs. 16,22,000/- (Rupees sixteen lakhs
twenty-two thousand) only towards compensation. In response to
the show cause, the respondents appeared and filed their
respective written statements.
5.
After perusal of the pleadings of the parties and
documents, learned Tribunal framed the following issues in
T.S.(MAC) No.03 of 2019:“(I) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present
form and nature?
(II) Whether on 05.10.2016 at about 22:30 hours
the victim Raju Sinha had met with an accident at Nidevi near
Ramkrishna Ashram on Kumarghat-Fatikroy road under Kumarghat
PS while he was proceeded towards Kumarghat from Fatikroy as
pillion rider of a motorcycle bearing no. TR-01-N-7181 piled by Pradip
Sinha and dashed on the back side of the vehicle bearing no. TR 04A-1802 (Truck) being negligently and wrongfully parked by driver
Nepal Sharma and the victim fell down and sustained grievous injury
and on 06.10.2016 he died?
(III) Whether the claimant is entitled to get any
compensation, if so, to what extent?
(IV) Who is liable to pay the compensation?
(V) To any other relief/reliefs to which the party is
entitled to, if any?”
6.
Learned Tribunal framed the following issues in
T.S.(MAC) No.20 of 2018:“(I) Whether the suit is maintainable in its present
form and nature?
(II) Whether on 05.10.2016 at about 22:30 hours the
victim Pradip Sinha had met with an accident at Nidevi near
Ramkrishna Ashram on Kumarghat-Fatikroy road under Kumarghat
P/S while he was proceeded towards Kumarghat from Fatikroy by
riding a motorcycle bearing no. TR-01-N-7181 and dashed on the
backside of the vehicle bearing no. TR 04-A-1802 (Truck) being
negligently and wrongfully parked by driver Nepal Sharma and the
victim fell down and sustained grievous injury and on 06.10.2016 he
died?
(III) Whether the claimants are entitled to get any
compensation, if so, to what extent?
(IV) Who is liable to pay the compensation?
(V) To any other relief/reliefs to which the parties are
entitled to, if any?”
7.
After hearing the argument of both sides, the learned
Tribunal as per Judgments and Orders dated 23.11.2021 rejected
the prayer of the claimants being devoid of merit. Being aggrieved
and dissatisfied with the aforesaid judgment and Order of
rejection, this present appeals have been preferred seeking the set
aside the impugned Judgments and Orders dated 23.11.2021.
8.
Heard Mr. H. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for
both the appeals as well Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned counsel
appearing for the respondent-New India Assurance Company Ltd,
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel for respondent No.2 and Mr. D.
Debnath, learned counsel appearing for respondents No.1 and 3.
9.
Mr. H. Bhowmik, learned counsel appearing for the
appellants submits that the truck driver negligently parked his
truck on the road and due to the negligence of the driver of the
truck the accident occurred. This statement is also supported by
the written statement in the FIR wherein the Officer-in-Charge
Kumarghat Police Station stated that he saw a truck loaded with
wooden logs wrongly parked in the middle of road and the accident
occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the truck. Learned
counsel further stated that even if it is presumed that the accident
occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the driver of the
motorbike, but, the claimant of deceased Raju-Sinha ought to have
received the compensation as he was the pillion rider. Learned
counsel further submitted that the learned Trial Court without any
exhibited documents came to the conclusion that the involved
motorbike was not insured.
10.
counsel
On the other hand, Mr. P. Chakraborty, learned
appearing
for
respondent
No.4
i.e.
the
insurer
of
Motorcycle No. TR.01-N-7181 submits that due to the rash and
negligent driving of the motorcycle, the same hit the stationary
Truck due to which the accident occurred. He further submitted
that if any liability is to be fasten, the same is to be fastened on
the insurer of the Truck bearing No.TR-04-A-1902.
11.
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
registered owner of the Motorbike submits that his client has
already leased out the Motorbike to respondent No.6 for the terms
of 3(three) years. Mr. D. Debnath, learned counsel appearing for
respondent No.3 i.e., the owner of the Truck stated that his vehicle
was insured with respondent No.5 herein i.e., Future General India
Insurance Company Ltd, and if any liability is to fasten then the
said liability is to be fasten on the insurance-Company. He further
submitted that there was no negligence on the part of the driver of
the truck because though the truck was parked in the middle of the
road, but, it was due to mechanical failure and the driver of the
vehicle was trying to fix the vehicle.
12.
Heard both sides and perused the evidence on record.
13.
There is no evidence with regard to the fact that the
vehicle i.e. the Truck bearing No.TR-04-A-1802 which was parked
in the middle of the road has taken proper care and measures by
putting parking lights or further steps while attending the repair.
As per the evidence of the eye-witness, i.e., the Officer-in-Charge
Kumarghat Police Station who is the complainant indicated that the
vehicle i.e. the
Truck
bearing
No.TR-04-A1802
was
parked
negligently and the accident had taken place due to this. But in the
final report filed by the investigating officer, who was examined
before the camera by the learned Tribunal below indicated that the
mistake was committed by the 2(two) wheeler motorcycle which
dashed the parked Truck in a rash and negligent manner.
The
investigating officer has filed the final report but has not indicated
the source as to how he came to the conclusion that due to rash
and negligent driving of the 2(two) wheeler vehicle, it hit the Truck
especially when the eye-witness i.e., the statement of the Officerin-charge, Kumarghat Police Station is otherwise.
14.
In terms of the above discussion, this Court is of the
opinion that compensation is to be awarded to the claimants of
both appeals as this Court finds sufficient ground to allow these
appeals.
15.
Now in terms of the compensation, the deceased-Raju
Sinha, at the time of death, was 24 (twenty-four) years of age.
The deceased was a businessman by profession. So, his minimum
monthly income as per the claimant is Rs.6,000/- per month. If he
had been alive, he might have worked up to the age of 60 (sixty)
years. So, as per schedule, he ought to have earned {(Rs. 6,000/X 12) X 36) = Rs. 25,92,000/-.
16.
Now for personal and living expenses, the Hon’ble
Apex Court in Para-31 of its landmark Judgment passed in Sarla
Verma(Smt.) and ors. Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and
anr., reported in (2009) 6 SCC 121 held as under:“31. Where the deceased was a bachelor and the claimants
are the parents, the deduction follows a different principle. In regard to
bachelors, normally, 50% is deducted as personal and living expenses,
because it is assumed that a bachelor would tend to spend more on
himself. Even otherwise, there is also the possibility of his getting married
in a short time, in which event the contribution to the parent/s and siblings
is likely to be cut drastically. Further, subject to evidence to the contrary,
the father is likely to have his own income and will not be considered as a
dependant and the mother alone will be considered as a dependent. In the
absence of evidence to the contrary, brothers and sisters will not be
considered as dependents, because they will either be independent and
earning, or married, or be dependant on the father.”
The Hon’ble Apex Court reiterated its stand in Para41 of its Judgments passed in National Insurance Company
Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi and ors., reported in (2017)16 SCC 680,
which is reproduced herein under:“41. On a perusal of the analysis made in Sarla Verma which has
been reconsidered in Reshma Kumari, we think it appropriate to state that
as far as the guidance provided for appropriate deduction for personal and
living expenses is concerned, the tribunals and courts should be guided by
conclusion 43.6 of Reshma Kumari. We concur with the same as we have
no hesitation in approving the method provided therein.”
17.
In the case is hand, the sole claimant-appellant
herein is the mother of the deceased Raju Sinha who was a
bachelor. So, in terms of the above discussion, 50% is to be
deducted as personal and living expenses of the deceased. So,
after a deduction of 50% of Rs.25,92,000/- for his personal and
living
expenses,
the
deceased
would
have
contributed
Rs.12,96,000/- only towards his family. For funeral expenses,
Hon’ble Apex Court in Magma General Insurance Company
Ltd. Vs. Nanu Ram Alias Chuhru Ram an ors., reported in
(2018) 18 SCC 130 awarded Rs.15,000/- towards funeral
expenses,
and
the
same
is
awarded
herein.
Further
in
Magma(supra) Rs.40,000/- each was awarded for loss of filial
consortium. Accordingly, in this case also the same is awarded as
filial consortium.
So, the compensation for the claimant of MAC
APP
No.13
of
comes
to
Rs.12,96,000/-+Rs.15,000/-
+Rs.40,000/- =Rs.13,51,000/- (Rupees thirteen lakhs and fiftyone thousand) only along with interest @ 7.5% p.a. from the date
of filing of this claim petition till payment.
18.
Now in the Mac App. No.14 of 2022, the deceased
Pradip Sinha at the time of death was 32 (thirty-two) years of age.
The deceased was a businessman by profession. So, his minimum
monthly income as per claimants is Rs.6,000/- per month. If he
had been alive, he might have worked up to the age of 60 (sixty)
years. So, as per schedule, he ought to be earned {(Rs. 6,000/- X
12) X 28) = Rs. 20,16,000/-. The claimants in this case are the
mother and father of the deceased and the deceased was a
bachelor. In terms of Sarala Verma(supra), 50% is to be
deducted as personal and living expenses of the deceased. So after
a deduction of 50% of Rs.20,16,000/-, then, he would have
contributed Rs.10,08,000/- only towards his family. In terms of
Magma(supra),
Rs.15,000/-
is
awarded
towards
funeral
expenses. Further in Magma(supra) Rs.40,000/- each was
awarded for loss of filial consortium. Accordingly, in this case for
both claimants, Rs.40,000/- each is awarded as filial consortium.
So, the compensation for the claimants of MAC APP No.14 of 2022
comes
to
Rs.10,08,000/-
+
Rs.15,000/-
+
Rs.80,000/-
=Rs.11,03,000/- (Rupees eleven lakhs and three thousand) only
along with interest @ 7.5% p.a. from the date of filing of this claim
petition till payment.
19.
Since the Truck bearing No.TR-04-A-1802 is insured
with the Future General India Insurance Company Ltd, this Court
fastens the liability to pay the compensation to the said Insurance
Company within a period of 2(two) months from today. On
depositing the said above compensation amounts, the claimants
are at liberty to withdraw the same unconditionally as per the
procedure.
20.
With the above observation and direction, these
present appeals are allowed and thus disposed of. As a sequel,
stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if any also
stands closed.
JUDGE
suhanjit
signed by
RAJKUMAR Digitally
RAJKUMAR
SUHANJIT SUHANJIT SINGHA
Date: 2023.07.25
SINGHA
16:16:42 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review