Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page - 1 of 14
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Smt. Bina Debbarma(Ex-Staff Nurse),
Wife of Sri Ramchandra Debbarma,
Resident of Old Kalibari Lane, Krishnanagar,
P.O-Agartala, P.S-West Agartala,
District-West Tripura, PIN-799001.
-----Appellant(s).
Versus
1.
The State of Tripura,
Represented by the Secretary to the Government of
Tripura, Department of Health & Family Welfare, New
Secretariat Building, P.S & P.O- NCC Agartala, West
Tripura, PIN-799010.
2.
The Director of Health Services,
Government of Tripura, Pandit Nehru Complex,
Gurkhabasti, P.O-Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799006.
3.
The Accountant General (A & E), Tripura,
Malancha Nivas, P.O-Kunjaban, Agartala, West Tripura,
PIN-799006.
----- Respondent(s)
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S. G. CHATTOPADHYAY
For the Appellant (s)
: Mr. S. K. Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Datta, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Date of hearing
: 5th August, 2022.
Mr. B. Majumder, Asstt. S. G.
Mr. D. Bhattacharya, Govt. Adv.
Mr. P. Saha, Advocate.
Date of Judgment & Order : 11.10.2022.12th April, 2022.
Whether fit for reporting
W.A. No.212 of 2020
: Yes.
Page - 2 of 14
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
(S.G. Chattopadhyay, J)
This writ appeal is directed against the judgment and order
dated 26.06.2020 passed by the learned Single Judge in W.P(C) No.923 of
2018 whereby the learned Single Judge dismissed the writ petition which
was filed by the petitioner (appellant herein) challenging her erroneous
pay fixation in the post of Staff Nurse under the Health and Family
Welfare Department, Government of Tripura.
[2]
The factual context of the case is as under:
Appellant, Smti. Bina Debbarma who has retired from service
on 30.06.2009 joined the service as an Assistant Nurse in the Health and
Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura on 23.04.1973
pursuant to her selection and appointment in the post. After rendering
continuous service for about 10(ten) years in the post of Assistant Nurse,
she was promoted to the post of Staff Nurse on 10.08.1983. Her pay was
fixed in the promotional post in usual course. When the Tripura State Civil
Service (Revised Pay) Rules, 1988 (for short ROP Rules, 1988) came into
operation refixation of her pay in the revised scale as per ROP Rules, 1988
in the post of Staff Nurse was done. Accordingly, her pay as on 10.08.1983
in the promotional post of Staff Nurse was revised to Rs.740/- as per ROP
Rules, 1988 but the appellant has claimed that it should have been Rs.810/instead of Rs.740/- as per said ROP Rules, 1988. According to the
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 3 of 14
appellant, her pay revision in the promotional post was grossly erroneous
and as a result of such erroneous pay fixation, she was given a lesser
amount of pay althrough and even after her retirement she is being paid
pension less than her entitlement. After her retirement, the appellant
realised that her pay fixation was erroneously done by the department
because she was getting lesser amount of pension than her colleague.
Immediately she filed representation to the department in the year 2017
alleging erroneous pay fixation which was turned down by the State
respondents. She then approached this Court seeking relief under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
[3]
The respondents filed counter affidavits before the learned
Single Judge. Respondents No.1 and 2 jointly filed counter affidavit on
09.01.2019 and respondent No.3 filed a separate counter affidavit on
20.12.2018. The respondents claimed that a thorough examination of her
service book and other service records revealed that her pay fixation in the
promotional post of Staff Nurse was correctly done by the department and
the Accountant General after verification of the entire service record
finally settled her retirement benefits including her pension. In their
affidavit respondents have given the details as to how the pay fixation of
the appellant was done.
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 4 of 14
[4]
In the counter affidavit submitted before the learned Single
Judge, the Accountant General who was arrayed as respondent No. 3 in the
writ petition asserted as under:
“3.
That, in response to the averments made in
paragraph 6 of the writ petition, I on behalf of the
answering Respondent No.3 state that the office of the
Respondent No.3 is discharging the duties of Authorizing
Authority of pensionery benefits while the concerned DDOs
are the pension Sanctioning Authorities. In discharging the
duty of Authorizing Authority, the office of the Respondent
No.3 is always duty bound to scrupulously follow the rules
and regulations of CCS (pension) Rules alongwith the
direction/orders issued by the Finance Department,
Government of Tripura from time to time in the form of
circular, office Memorandum etc.
That, the pensionery benefits in respect of the writ
petitioner was authorized on the basis of regulation of pay
made by the concerned department and the said last pay
stood at Rs.20790/-. It is worthmentioning her that the said
last pay was verified and found correct as per the
calculation of the Respondent No.3 and tallied with the
entry made in the Service Book by the concerned
department. So, the question of anomaly regarding fixation
of pay made in para 6 of the writ petition does not arise.
4.
That, in response to the averments made in
paragraph 7 of the writ petition, the answering Respondent
No.3 state that on receipt pension proposal in respect of
the writ petitioner from the Directorate of Health Services,
Govt of Tripura, the pensionary benefits was authorised in
favour of the writ petitioner vide PPO No.PEN3/TRIP/S/Sup/7425, GPO No.PEN-3/Sup/GPO/7507 and
CPO No.PEN-3/Commtn/Non-Medl/7425 dated 02/2010 on
the basis of regulation of pay last pay at Rs.20790/- which
was at per with the calculation of concerned Department as
well as last pay certificate furnished by the concerned
department. Subsequently revised pension authority was
also issued in favour of the petitioner vide this office
authority No.PEN-3/Trip/Sup/Rev/5287/14290-92 dated
29-10-2013.”
[5]
The crux of the argument of the counsel of the appellant
before the learned Single Judge was that since the appellant held two
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 5 of 14
different posts namely, Assistant Nurse and Staff Nurse after her initial
pay fixation under ROP Rules, 1982, her pay should have been fixed under
sub-clause (b)(ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) of ROP Rules, 1988
and
consequently on the date of her promotion i.e. on 10.08.1083 her pay in
the promotional post of Staff Nurse ought to have been fixed at Rs.810/which was erroneously fixed at Rs.740/-. In response to the plea of the
State respondents that appellant’s case suffered of delay and latches,
learned counsel of the appellant argued before the learned Single Judge
that question of delay and latches was irrelevant since erroneous pay
fixation was a continuous wrong which would give rise to fresh cause of
action from month to month and therefore, plea of delay and latches would
not apply to this case.
[6]
The State counsel on the other hand argued before the learned
Single Judge that her pay fixation was done in the promotional post on
10.08.1983 and she approached the High Court seeking intervention under
Article 226 in 2018 which was grossly belated. Counsel contended that
there was no wrong in the fixation of pay and pension of the petitioner
which was also approved by the Accountant General. It was contended that
appellant’s reliance on sub-clause (b)(ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) of
ROP
Rules, 1988 was totally misplaced. The State counsel also argued that the
appellant never held the post of Staff Nurse for the minimum period of
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 6 of 14
5(five) years to be entitled to an additional increment as per ROP Rules,
1988.
[7]
On appreciation of the pleadings of the parties and the
submissions of their counsel as well as the facts and circumstances of the
case, learned Single Judge viewed that even though the appellant held two
posts during her entire service carrier namely the post of Assistant Nurse
and that of the Staff Nurse, it was of no consequence because she held only
one post during the entire period from the implementation of ROP Rules,
1982 and refixation of her pay in the revised scale as per ROP Rules, 1988
and therefore, her case clearly fell within sub-clause (a) (i) of Rule
7(1)(A)(1) ROP Rules, 1988. Consequently, the learned Single Judge
dismissed her writ petition observing as under:
“7.
Short question that calls for consideration is
was the petitioner’s pay fixation in the revised scale as per
ROP, 1988 correctly done or was the petitioner deprived of
the benefit of sub-clause (ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1)(b) of ROP,
1988. In order to decide this, we may have a look at the
relevant statutory provisions. In exercise of powers under
Article 309 of the Constitution of India, the State of Tripura
had framed the said ROP, 1988 under a notification dated
15.09.1988. These rules were brought into effect from
01.01.1986. As per these rules, pay scales of the employees
of the Government had to be revised as per the provisions
contained therein. Page 6 of 11 Rule 7 of the said rules
pertain to fixation of pay in the revised scale. Relevant
portion of this rule reads as under:
“Fixation of pay in the revised scale.
7.(1)
The initial pay of a Government servant—
(i)
Who elects or is deemed to have elected under subrule (3) of Rule 6 to be governed by the revised scale on
and from the 1st January, 1986.
Or,
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 7 of 14
(ii)
who elects under the proviso to Rule 5 to be
governed by the revised scale and on from the date on
which he earns in the existing scale his next or any
subsequent increment after 1-1-86 but not later than 31-1287 in respect of the post held by him on 1-1-86,
shall, unless in any case the Governor by a special
order otherwise directs, be fixed separately in respect of his
substantive pay in the permanent post on which he holds a
lien or would have held a lien had his lien not been
suspended, and in respect of his pay in the officiating post
held by him, in the following manner, namely:(A)
In cases of all employees, the following components
of emoluments shall be determined first:
(A)(1) Basic Pay:
The basic pay of the Government servant in the
existing scale on the 1st day of January, 1986, or where the
Government servant elects under Rule 5 to be governed by
the Revised pay on and from the date on which he earns in
the existing scale his next or any subsequent increment
falling after 1-1-86 but not later than 31-12-87 in respect of
the post Page 7 of 11 held by him on 1-1-86, the basic pay
of the Government servant on such later date, shall be
determined as follows:
(a)(i) Where the post in which the pay of the
Government servant shall be fixed under these rules is the
one and the same post in which he was brought over to the
revised scale under the Tripura Government Services
(Revised Pay) Rules, 1982,
Or,
(a)(ii) Where the Government servant held more
than one post during the period from the date on which he
was brought over to the revised scale under the Tripura
Government Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1982 upto the
date from which his pay shall be fixed under these rules,
And
where no “modified present scale” is specified in
column 5 of Schedule III in relation to any of the posts
aforesaid,
the basic pay of the Government servant for the
purpose of Sub-clause (A)(1) shall be the pay and the
personal pay, if any, in the existing scale on the date of his
coming over to the revised scale under these rules.
Provided that if the Government servant earns his
normal yearly increment on the date of his coming over to
the revised scale, the basic pay shall be inclusive of such
increment.
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 8 of 14
(b)(i) Where a “modified present scale” is specified
in column 5 of Schedule III in relation to the post referred
to in (a)(i), the basic pay of the Government servant shall
be notionally refixed in the „modified present scale‟ at the
stage Page 8 of 11 next above the pay earlier fixed in the
existing scale under the Tripura Government Services
(Revised Pay) Rules, 1982 (17th Amendment) or otherwise
and regulated thereafter upto the date of his coming over to
the revised scale under these rules. The pay thus notionally
refixed shall be the basic pay for the purpose of sub-clause
(A)(1).
Provided that if the Government servant earns his
normal yearly increment on the date of his coming over to
the revised scale, the basic pay shall be inclusive of such
increment.
(b)(ii) Where a Government servant held more than
one post on promotion or otherwise, after his pay was
initially fixed under the Tripura Government Services
(Revised Pay) Rules, 1982 (17th Amendment) or otherwise,
including the post in respect of which pay shall be fixed in
the revised scale under these Rules, the basic pay of the
Government servant shall be notionally refixed in the
“modified present scale” in the manner prescribed in (b)(i)
in respect of the first post, in order of the date of
appointment, in relation to which a modified present scale
is specified. Thereafter, the pay shall be regulated upto the
date on which the Government servant comes over to the
revised scale under these rules granting normal yearly
increments and refixing notionally his pay in the modified
present scales or the existing scales, as the case may be, of
the posts to which he was subsequently appointed,
including the post in respect of which his pay shall be fixed
in the revised scale under these rules.
Provided that notional regulation of pay in respect
of different posts to which the Government servant was
Page 9 of 11 subsequently appointed on promotion or
otherwise, shall be made with reference to the pay plus the
personal pay, if any, admissible to the Government servant
applying the rules and orders including the provisions of
Tripura Govt. Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 1982, which
applied to the Government servant earlier.
Provided further that where a personal pay in
addition to pay is admissible on the date on which the Govt.
servant comes over to the revised scale under these rules as
a result of such notional refixation, the basic pay for the
purpose of sub clause (A)(1) shall be inclusive of such
personal pay.
Provided further that where the Government
servant earns his normal yearly increment on the date of
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 9 of 14
his coming over to the revised scale, the basic pay shall be
inclusive of such increment.
Note:-The personal pay referred to in (a) and (b) of
this sub-clause shall mean personal pay other than the
personal pay referred to in sub-clause (A)(2) of this Rule.”
8.
As per sub-rule (1) of Rule 7 thus the initial
pay of a Government servant would be fixed separately in
respect of substantive pay in the permanent post on which
he holds a lien as provided thereafter. As per sub-clause
(A)(1) the basic pay of the Government servant in the
existing scale as on 01.01.1986 or on a deferred date if so
elected by the Government servant under Rule 5 would be
determined as per the sub-clauses provided therein. In this
context, this rule envisages two situations. First situation is
Page 10 of 11 where the post in which the pay of the
Government servant is to be fixed is the one and the same
post in which he was brought over to the revised scale
under the Tripura Government Services (Revised Pay)
Rules, 1982 (hereinafter to be referred to as ROP, 1982).
Second situation is where the Government servant held
more than one post during the period from the date on
which he was brought over to the revised scale under ROP,
1982. These different situations noted above would be
governed by the provisions of pay fixations provided in
sub-clauses (i) and (ii) respectively of Rule 7 (1)(A)(1)(b)
of ROP, 1988. As noted, according to the petitioner and her
counsel, the petitioner’s case would fall under the second
category and consequently her pay ought to have been
fixed in terms of sub-clause (ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1)(b) of the
said rules. I do not find that this is a correct position. As
noted, the first situation envisaged in sub-clause (i) of Rule
7(1)(A)(1)(a) is where the post in which the pay of the
Government servant is to be fixed is the one and the same
post in which he was brought over to the revised scale
under ROP, 1982. The second situation covered under
sub clause (ii) is where the Government servant held more
than one post during the period from the date on which he
was brought over to the revised scale under ROP, 1982 up
to the date of fixation of his pay under ROP, 1988. The
petitioner was promoted to the post of Staff Nurse on
10.08.1983. Her pay Page 11 of 11 was thus fixed in the
said promotional post under ROP, 1982. Thus, she held
only one post during the entire period from the
implementation of ROP, 1982 till the occasion arose to
refix her pay in the revised scale as per ROP, 1988. Her
case thus clearly fell within sub-clause (i) of Rule
7(1)(A)(1)(a) of ROP, 1988. The petitioner did hold two
positions during her service career namely that of Assistant
Nurse and Staff Nurse. However, for the purpose of
application of Rule 7(1) of ROP, 1988, this was not of any
consequence. What was important was, did the petitioner
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 10 of 14
serve on two different posts after being brought over to the
revised scales as per ROP, 1982 till the time of her pay
fixation as per ROP, 1988. The answer clearly is in the
negative. The petitioner’s pay fixation, therefore, was not
to be done under sub-clause (ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1)(b) of
ROP, 1988.”
[8]
Aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the judgment of the
learned Single Judge, the writ petitioner has approached this Court for
setting aside the judgment of the learned Single Judge. The basic stand of
the appellant (the original writ petitioner) is as under:
Fixation of her pay should have been done under sub-clause
(b) (ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) of the ROP Rules, 1988 since she held two posts
namely Assistant Nurse and Staff Nurse during the implementation of
ROP Rules, 1982 till refixation of her pay under ROP Rules, 1988.
[9]
Heard Mr. S. K. Deb, learned Sr. advocate appearing for the
appellant along with Mr. S. Datta, learned advocate. Also heard Mr. D.
Bhattacharya, learned Government Advocate appearing along with Mr. P.
Saha, learned advocate for the State respondents. Mr. B. Majumder,
learned Asstt. S. G. is representing respondent No.3. Examined the service
record of the appellant produced before us pursuant to our order dated
22.07.2022.
[10]
Undisputedly, the refixation of the pay of the appellant in the
post of Staff Nurse was made by the department in the year 1983 after she
got promotion to the post of Staff Nurse from the position of Assistant
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 11 of 14
Nurse but the appellant approached this Court seeking relief under Article
226 of the Constitution for erroneous refixation of pay by filing the writ
petition in the year 2018. The State counsel therefore, raised the plea of
delay and latches on the part of the appellant. Since it is a settled law that
erroneous fixation of pay is a continuous wrong, the plea of delay and
latches does not apply to this case and therefore, the issue does not require
any further examination.
[11]
The short question which requires our consideration is
whether sub-clause (b)(ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) of ROP Rules, 1988 would
apply to the case of the appellant. In this regard, the learned Single Judge
has quoted the entire Rule which have been reproduced by us in the
preceding paragraphs. Section 7 of the ROP Rules, 1988 as amended up to
date provides for fixation of pay of the employees of the State
Government. Under the said ROP Rules, sub-clause (b)(ii) of Rule
7(1)(A)(1) contemplates that where a Government Servant has held more
than one post on promotion or otherwise after initial fixation of his or her
pay under the ROP Rules of 1982 or otherwise, including the post in
respect of which pay would be revised under ROP Rules, 1988, the basic
of the
Government servant shall be notionally fixed in the modified
present scale following the procedure provided in sub-clause (b)(i) of Rule
7(1)(A)(1) of the present ROP Rules, 1988. Thereafter the pay shall be
regulated up to date on which the Government servant comes over to the
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 12 of 14
revised scale under the present ROP Rules, 1988 granting normal yearly
increments and refixing notionally his pay in the modified present scales
or the existing scales, as the case may be of the posts to which he was
subsequently appointed including the posts in respect of which his pay
shall be fixed in the revised scale under ROP Rules, 1988.
[12]
Further question which arises in view of the above discussion
of sub-clause (b)(ii) is whether the appellant held two different posts after
being brought over to the revised scales as per ROP Rules, 1982 till her
pay fixation was done as per ROP Rules, 1988 so as to decide whether
sub-clause (b)(ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) would apply to her case.
[13]
The service record of the appellant clearly indicates that after
her appointment in 1973 in the post of Assistant Nurse in the Health and
Family Welfare Department, Government of Tripura her pay was modified
to Rs.470 – 1025/- from Rs.430 – 850/- w.e.f 1.1.82 notionally and by the
same entry in her service book (Vol.-II) her pay was revised to Rs.650/- on
1.1.82 with D.N.I on 1.3.82. The said entry with regard to revision of her
pay in terms of ROP Rules 1982 was signed by the Medical
Superintendent, V.M. Hospital, Agartala (as it was then).
[14]
It is thus crystally clear that pay of the appellant was revised
w.e.f. 1.1.1982 as per ROP Rules of 1982 and at that time the appellant
was an Assistant Nurse.
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 13 of 14
[15]
Thereafter, she was promoted to the post of Staff Nurse on
10.08.1983 and her service book (Vol.-II) indicates that her pay was fixed
at Rs.1870/- in the revised pay scale of pay of Rs.1450 – 3710/- w.e.f.
10.08.1987 and her D.N.I was due on 1.8.1988. The relevant entry in the
service record is also endorsed by the Medical Superintendent, V.M.
Hospital (as it was then), Agartala.
[16]
There is, therefore, no ambiguity in the proposition of the
appellant that she
served in more than one post namely the post of
Assistant Nurse and the post of Staff Nurse after being brought over to the
revised scales as per ROP Rules, 1982 till the time of her pay fixation as
per ROP Rules, 1988 and as such, the department (State respondents)
should have revised her pay and allowances in terms of sub-clause (b) (ii)
of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) of ROP Rules, 1988.
[17]
Resultantly, the judgment and order of the learned Single
Judge is set aside and the appeal stands allowed. The respondents are
directed to provide the benefit of revision of the pay of the appellant as
claimed by her in terms of sub-clause (b)(ii) of Rule 7(1)(A)(1) of ROP
Rules, 1988. She will also be entitled to enhanced rate of pension arising
from such revision of pay. The respondents are further directed to
complete the entire exercise within a period of 4(four) months from today.
W.A. No.212 of 2020
Page - 14 of 14
[18]
In terms of the above, the writ appeal stands disposed of.
Department’s file be returned to learned Government Advocate forthwith.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Dipankar
W.A. No.212 of 2020
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review