Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC010276932025
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : Tr.P.(C)./93/2025
SMT. BHANITA KALITA
WIFE OF SRI BIKRAM RANJAN DAS, DAUGHTER OF LATE KHANINDRA
DAS, RESIDENT OF HOUSE NO. 18, LALMATI, NEAR IIE, BYE LANE
GANESHPUR, P.O. AND P.S.- BASISTHA, DIST- KAMRUP (M), ASSAM, PIN781029
VERSUS
BIKASH RANJAN DAS
SON OF DR. MAANORANJAN DAS, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- KAHARPARA,
SARUPETA, P.O.- SARUPETA, P.S.- PATACHARKUCHI, DISTRICT- BAJALI,
ASSAM, PIN-781318
Advocate for the Petitioner
NABENDU PATHAK
: MR. DITUL DAS, MR. B J TALUKDAR,MR. M P SARMA,MR
Advocate for the Respondent : MR P P MEDHI, MS. U ROY,MAYURI GOGOI,MR G
BARGAYARY
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
06.04.2026
Heard Mr. D. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. P.P.
Medhi, learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
This petition, under Section 24 read with Section 151 of the CPC, is
Page No.# 2/10
preferred by the petitioner for transferring Misc. G.C. Case No. 04/2022 and
connected Misc. (J) Case No. 13/2023, with all the petitions, pending before the
Court of learned District Judge, Bajali, to the Court of learned District Judge,
Kamrup (M) at Guwahati.
3.
Mr. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the petitioner is
the wife of the sole respondent and they got married on 04.10.2015 as per
social custom and rites and thereafter they lived together as husband and wife
in the matrimonial home at Sarupeta, Patacharkuchi and out of their wedlock,
one baby girl born to them. He further submits that thereafter, marital discord
surfaced between them and ultimately the petitioner had to leave the
matrimonial home, and since then she has been taking shelter, with their minor
child, at her parental abode at Guwahti. Thereafter, petitioner had preferred the
F.C. (Crl.) Case No. 589/2022, under Section 125 Cr.P.C., before the Principal
Judge, Family Court, at Guwahati seeking maintenance from the respondent.
Then the respondent has filed the Miscellaneous Guardianship Case No. 4/2022,
before the court of learned District Judge at Bajali. The said guardianship
certificate case has been filed in contravention to the jurisdictional statutory
provision of the Guardianship and Wards Act, 1890 as it ought to have been
filed at the place where the child is residing. Mr. Das also submits that the
petitioner is suffering from different health issues and also she has minor
daughter and leaving her at Guwahati she cannot undertake travel to Bajali to
contest the said petition and over and above she has no source of her income.
Under such circumstances Mr. Das contended to allow this petition and the
transfer the Miscellaneous Guardianship Case No. 4/2022, from the court of
learned District Judge at Bajali to the court of learned Principal Judge, Family
Court at Kamrup (M) at Guwahati.
Page No.# 3/10
3.1. In support of his submission, Mr. Das has referred to a decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of N.C.V. Aishwarya vs. A.S. Saravana
Karthik Shah, (Civil Appeal No (S), 4894 of 2022 (Arising out of
SLP. (C)No(s) 16465 of 2021).
4.
Per contra, Mr. Medhi, learned counsel for the respondent has vehemently
opposed the petition. Mr. Medhi submits that though no objection petition is
filed by the respondent, yet the respondent is not in a position to concede to
the prayer of the petitioner. Referring to a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in
Anindita Das vs. Srijit Das, Transfer Petition Civil No.(S). 191
of 2005, with Transfer Petition (C) No.146 of 2005, Mr. Medhi
submits that in the prevailing socio economic paradigm in the Indian society,
generally, it is the wife's convenience which must be looked at while considering
transfer, yet leniency cannot be considered always as the same is being misused
by the women. He also submits that like the respondent in the aforesaid
petition, the respondent herein also shall pay all travel and stay expenses of the
petitioner and her companion for each and every occasion when she is required
to attend the Court at Bajali. Under such circumstances Mr. Medhi has
contended to dismiss this petition.
5.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition and the documents placed on
record, and also gone through the decisions referred by the parties.
6.
Section 24 of the CPC provides for transfer of a suit. It reads as under:“(1) On the application of any of the parties and after
notice to the parties and after hearing such of them as
desired to be heard, or of its own motion without such
notice, the High Court or the District Court may at any
Page No.# 4/10
stage
(a) Transfer any suit, appeal or other proceeding
pending before it for trial or disposal to any
Court subordinate to it and competent to try or
dispose of the same, or
(b) Withdraw any suit, appeal or other proceeding
pending in any Court subordinate to it, and
(i)
try or dispose of the same; or
(ii)
transfer the same for trial or disposal to any
Court subordinate to it and competent to try or
dispose of the same; or
(iii)
retransfer the same for trial or disposal to the
Court from which it was withdrawn.
(2) Where any suit or proceeding has been transferred
or
withdrawn under
sub-section (1),
the Court
which 1[is thereafter to try or dispose of such suit or
proceeding] may, subject to any special directions in
the case of an order of transfer, either retry it or
proceed from the point at which it was transferred or
withdrawn.
(3) For the purposes of this section,
(a) Courts of Additional and Assistant Judges
shall be deemed to be subordinate to the District
Court;
(b) Proceeding includes a proceeding
execution of a decree or order].
for
the
(4) The Court trying any suit transferred or withdrawn
under this section from a Court of Small Causes shall,
for the purposes of such suit, be deemed to be a Court
Page No.# 5/10
of Small Causes.
(5) A suit or proceeding may be transferred under this
section from a Court which has no jurisdiction to try
it.”
6.1. It the instant case, the applicable provision is 24(1)(ii) of CPC. Before a
discussion is directed into the issue, it would be in the interest of justice to
understand the principles, governing transfer of cases, presently occupying the
field.
6.2. In the case of Indian Overseas Bank vs. Chemical Construction
Company, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 358, while dealing with considerations
that has to be taken into account for transferring a case, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held as under :“16. The principle governing the general power of transfer and
withdrawal under Section 24 of the Code is that the plaintiff is
the dominus litis and, as such, entitled to institute his suit
in any forum which the law allows him. The court should not
lightly change that forum and compel him to go to another court,
with consequent increase in inconvenience and expense of
prosecuting his suit. A mere balance of convenience in favour of
proceedings in another court, albeit a material consideration,
may not always be a sure criterion justifying transfer.
17. As compared with Section 24, the power of transfer of civil
proceeding to another court, conferred under the new Section 25
on the Supreme Court, is far wider. And, so is the amplitude of
the expression, “expedient in the interest of justice” which
furnishes a general guideline for the exercise of the power.
Whether it is expedient or desirable in the interest of justice
to transfer a proceeding to another court, is a question which
depends on the circumstances of the particular case.”
6.3. There is, however, unanimity of opinion that ‘balance of convenience’
Page No.# 6/10
is
the
prime
consideration
for
transfer
of
a
suit.
The
expression
‘balance of convenience’ has inspired profound legal thought and has
acquired the gloss of many judicial interpretations. Restated in simple terms, it
is a question of fact in each case. ‘Balance of convenience’ is neither the
convenience of the plaintiff alone nor of the defendant alone, but the balance of
convenience of both. In determining the balance of convenience for the trial of a
suit, the Court has to take into consideration the following:“(1) Convenience or inconvenience of the plaintiff and the
right of the plaintiff to choose his own forum;
(2) Convenience or inconvenience of the defendant;
(3) Convenience or inconvenience of the witnesses required
for a proper trial of the suit;
(4) Convenience or inconvenience of the particular place of
trial having regard to the nature of the evidence on
the main points involved in the suit and also having
regard to the doctrine of ‘forum convenience’; and
(5)
6.4.
Nature of issues in the suit.” (Ref. Baburam Agarwalla
vs. Jamunadas Ramji And Co. reported in AIR 1951 Cal
239)”
Again, in the case of Mrs. Maneka Sanjay Gandhi and Anr. vs. Ms.
Rani Jethmalani, reported in (1979) 4 SCC 167, Hon’ble Supreme Court has
emphasized the necessity to ensure fair trial, observing as hereunder:“Assurance
of a fair trial is the first imperative of the
dispensation of justice and the central criterion for the court
to consider when a motion for transfer is made is not the
hypersensitivity or relative convenience of a party or easy
availability of legal services or like mini-grievances.
Something more substantial, more compelling, more imperiling,
from the point of view of public justice and its attendant
Page No.# 7/10
environment, is necessitous if the Court is to exercise its
power of transfer. This is the cardinal principle although the
circumstances may be myriad and vary from case to case. We have
to test the petitioner’s grounds on this touchstone bearing in
mind the rule that normally the complainant has the right to
choose any court having jurisdiction and the accused cannot
dictate where the case against him should be tried. Even so, the
process of justice should not harass the parties and from that
angle the court may weigh the circumstances.”
6.5. Although, Mrs. Maneka Sanjay Gandhi (supra), relates to a criminal
case, yet the context is same i.e. transfer. Therefore, this Court is of the view
that the principle enunciated therein can be applied in other cases also.
6.6.
Thus, it appears that though the plaintiff is dominus litis, yet, the
aforesaid right can be interfered with by the court on consideration of several
factors and out of the same ‘balance of convenience’ is the prime
consideration.
6.7. Further, it is well settled in the case of Anindita Das(supra) that in
matrimonial matters, wherever Courts are called upon to consider the plea of
transfer, the Courts have to take into consideration the economic soundness of
both the parties, the social strata of the spouses and their behavioural pattern,
their standard of life prior to the marriage and subsequent thereto and the
circumstances of both the parties in eking out their livelihood and under whose
protective umbrella they are seeking their sustenance to life.
6.8. In the case of Anindita Das (supra) Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
that the cardinal principle for exercise of power under Section 24 CPC is that the
ends of justice should demand the transfer of the suit, appeal or other
proceeding. It has also been held that when two or more proceedings are
Page No.# 8/10
pending in different Courts between the same parties, which raise common
question of fact and law, and when the decisions in the cases are
interdependent, it is desirable that they should be tried together by the same
Judge so as to avoid multiplicity in trial of the same issues and conflict of
decisions.
7.
It is to be noted here that the gguardianship cases in India are primarily
governed by the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, and must be filed in the
District Court (or Family Court where applicable) based on the minor's ordinary
residence or property location. Section 9 of the said Act provides for Court
having jurisdiction to entertain application. Sub-Section 1 provides that - If the
application is with respect to the guardianship of the person of the minor, it shall
be made to the District Court having jurisdiction in the place where the minor
ordinarily resides. Section 9(2) provides for filing of application either in the
court of the minor's ordinary residence or where they hold property; when the
application is filed in respect of property of the minor and the courts may
transfer if more convenient elsewhere.
8. In the instant case, indisputably, the minor in respect of whose guardianship
the application was filed, is residing with the petitioner herein, who has been
residing in her parental abode, at Guwahati. Therefore, as mandated by SubSection 1 to Section 9 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 the petitioner
ought to have been filed at Guwahati. But, instead, the respondent herein had
opted to file the same in the Court of learned District Judge at Bajali. In view of
the mandate of the said Section, the submission of Mr. Das, learned counsel for
the petitioner, bears sufficient force.
8.1. It is also not in dispute that another case, being F.C. (Crl.) Case No.
589/2022, under Section 125 Cr.P.C., is pending before the Principal Judge,
Page No.# 9/10
Family Court, at Guwahati so filed by the petitioner herein, seeking maintenance
from the respondent. As held in the case of Anindita Das (supra) by Hon’ble
Supreme Court the cardinal principle for exercise of power under Section 24 CPC
is that the ends of justice, and when two or more proceedings are pending in
different Courts between the same parties, which raise common question of fact
and law, and when the decisions in the cases are interdependent, it is desirable
that they should be tried together by the same Judge so as to avoid multiplicity
in trial of the same issues and conflict of decisions.
8.2. Though the issue involved and the question of facts in the both the
proceeding here are different, yet decisions in the cases would be
interdependent, since the minor, whose guardianship is being sought for, in the
Miscellaneous Guardianship Case No. 4/2022, the issue of granting maintenance
in her favour is also involved in F.C. (Crl.) Case No. 589/2022, under Section 125
Cr.P.C., which is pending before the Principal Judge, Family Court, at Guwahati.
8.3. Under such circumstances also it is desirable that they should be tried
together by the same Judge so as to avoid multiplicity in trial of the same issues
and conflict of decisions.
8.4. Further, the petitioner herein has no source of income to contest the
proceeding before the court at Bajali, by undertaking a tedious journey from
Guwahati on each and every date leaving her minor daughter at Guwahati.
Though Mr. Medhi, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that like the
petitioner in the case of Anindita Das(supra) the respondent herein is also ready
to bear the expenditure yet, weighing the dominus litis, of the respondent
with that of the balance of convenience, which is one of the prime consideration
in a petition under Section 24 CPC, this court has found the balance tilting in
Page No.# 10/10
favour of the ‘balance of convenience’ of the petitioner, besides the
mandate of Sub-Section 1 to Section 9 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890.
8.5.
In the result, this court finds sufficient merit in this petition, and
accordingly, the same stands allowed. Consequently, Miscellaneous Guardianship
Case No. 4/2022, alongwith connected Misc Case, if any, pending before the
court learned District Judge, Bajali, stands transferred to the court learned
Principal Judge, Family Court No.1, Kamrup, at Guwahati, where the F.C. (Crl.)
Case No. 589/2022, under Section 125 Cr.P.C., which is pending.
9. The petitioner shall obtain a certified copy of this order and place the same
before the learned District Judge, Bajali, and on receipt of the same, the learned
District Judge, Bajali, shall take necessary steps for transmitting the record of
Miscellaneous Guardianship Case No. 4/2022, to the Court of learned District
Judge, Kamrup (M) at Guwahati.
10. In terms of above, this transfer petition stands disposed of. Interim order
passed earlier stands vacated.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review