Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15810/2023
1.
Smt. Beena Sharma W/o Rajesh Chaturvedi, R/o 2833,
Bagru Walon Ka Rasta, Gopinath Mandir, Chandpole
Bazaar, Jaipur.
2.
Sheela Gupta D/o Ram Gopal Gupta, R/o Ashiyana Vrinda
Garden, Block No. 9, Flat No. 333, Jagatpura, Jaipur.
----Petitioners
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through The Principal Secretary,
Ayurved Department, Secretariat, Jaipur.
2.
Deputy Secretary, Ayush Department, State Of Rajasthan,
Secretariat, Jaipur.
3.
Dr.
Sarvepalli
University,
Radhakrishnan
Kadwad,jodhpur-
Rajasthan
Nagaur
Ayurved
Highway
Road,
Jodhpur- 342037 Through Its Vice- Chancellor.
----Respondents
Connected With
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 11906/2021
Balbir Singh Son Of Shri Ruda Ram Khatana, Aged About 53
Years, Resident Of 13-Gurjar Ka Mohalla, Tamoriwas, P.o.
Kotputli, District-Jaipur At Present Resident Of House No. 98,
Near Gurjar Hostel, Vaishali Nagar, P.o. Kotputli, District-Jaipur
(Rajasthan)
----Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Of Rajasthan, Through Its Principal Secretary,
Department Of Aayurved And Personnel And Indian
Medicines Deptt. Government Of Rajasthan, Government
Secretariat, Jaipur.
2.
Dr.
Sarvapalli
University,
Radhakrishnan
Through
Its
Rajasthan
Registrar,
Dr.
Ayurved
Sarvapalli
Radhakrishnan Rajasthan University, Jodhpur.
3.
Director,
Ayurved
And
Indian
Medicine,
Ajmer
(Rajasthan).
----Respondents
(2 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
For Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. Rishabh Khandelwal
Mr. Rajendra Kumar Soni
Dr. Nitin Soni
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Vishesh Sharma
Ms. Karishma Soni for
Mr. Vinod Kumar Gupta, AGC
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ASHOK KUMAR JAIN
Order
04/02/2026
1.
These writ petitions are preferred by petitioners with
following prayers:
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 15810/2023:
“(i) Pass an appropriate, writ order or direction
directing that the age relaxation benefit of 5 years
for
already
working
Contractual
Ayurvedic
Chakastaks under NHM Scheme, as provided under
condition No. 12 of the advertisement shall be in
addition
to
conditions
the
as
other
age
relaxation
provided
in
the
benefit
advertisement
no.2/2023.
(ii) Pass an appropriate Writ, Order or Direction,
setting aside condition no. 1 of the notes in the
Advertisement
relaxation
No.2/2023,
benefits
have
whereby
been
the
age
as
non-
made
cumulative, i.e. only one age relaxation benefit
condition shall be available to a Candidate.
(iii) Pass an appropriate Writ, Order or Direction,
directing the Respondents to allow the petitioners
to participate in the Selection Process for Ayurvedic
Chikitsak and appoint the petitioners on the posts
of Ayurvedic Chikitsak, if selected in the merit list,
pursuant to the advertisement.
(3 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
(iv) Alternatively, Pass an appropriate Writ, Order
or Direction, directing the Respondents to remove /
relax the upper age limit criteria of less than 45
years
on
1.1.2024
Advertisement
for
as
the
fixed
under
continuously
the
working
Ayurvedic Chikitsaks as Contractual appointees
under
the
National
Rural
Mission
Scheme,
appointed through a Public Advertisement.”
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 11906/2021:
By issuing an appropriate writ, order or direction
quash the final provisional merit list dated 12
October 2021 and provisional merit list 4th of
October 2021 in so far as it relates to deleting the
name of petitioner from provisional merit list dated
27 October 2021 is concerned be set asides and
the petitioner be considered for appointment on the
post of Ayurveda Chikitsadhikari in M.B.C. category
according to his merit treating him within age
against the advertisement dated 22nd of December
2020, with all consequential benefits.
2.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of Smt. Beena Sharma
and Sheela Gupta submitted that pursuant to advertisement
dated 28.01.2016 issued for recruitment under the NHM on
contractual basis, the petitioners have filed application and
they were selected wherein upper age limit for selection was
55 years. He further submitted that since then, petitioners
are working as Ayurvedic doctors on contractual basis. He
further
submitted
that
respondent
have
issued
an
advertisement dated 20.04.2023 for regular selection under
the
Rajasthan
Ayurvedic,
Unani,
Homeopathy
and
Naturopathy Service Rules, 1973, (hereinafter referred as
"Rule of 1973"), for recruitment of Ayurvedic doctors on 639
(4 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
posts. He further submitted that petitioners have challenged
the certain conditions of the advertisement by filing a writ
petition wherein this Hon'ble Court has passed an interim
order dated 26.05.2023 whereby the petitioners were
allowed to submit their application form and participate in
the recruitment process provisionally.
3.
He
further
submitted
that
the
advertisement
dated
20.04.2023 was revoked by the respondent and now a new
advertisement for selection on 652 posts of Ayurvedic
doctors have been issued for inviting applications. He further
submitted that the upper age limit for determining eligibility
for selection has been fixed as 45 years as on 01.01.2024
but certain age relaxations provisions were made in the
advertisement, but same are insufficient unless their writ is
allowed. He further submitted that in the advertisement
issued in the year 2016, the upper age limit was fixed as 55
years but in the current advertisement, the upper age limit
after availing relaxation is fixed 50 years, which would oust
the petitioners.
4.
He also submitted that petitioners are female candidates and
they are entitled for cumulative benefit of relaxation, being
female candidate and additionally age relaxation of 3 years
as provided under the advertisement. He further referred the
grounds
and
submitted
that
the
respondents
have
committed serious error by not providing cumulative age
relaxation to the petitioners. Learned counsel for petitioners
has placed reliance upon judgment dated 21.05.2024 in
Dr. Mohd. Yunus versus State of Rajasthan and others,
(5 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 16633/2023, decided by a
coordinate bench of this Court at Principal Seat, Jodhpur and
submitted
that
a
coordinate
bench
has
quashed
the
provisions of relaxation of age limit with non-cumulative
effect and directed the respondents to give age relaxation in
cumulative manner.
5.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of petitioner Balbir
Singh
has
submitted
that
petitioner
belongs
to
most
backward class (MBC) category and after passing BAMS
examination in 2014, he was appointed in NRHM on
13.06.2016 as Ayurvedic doctor. He further submitted that
the respondent have advertised 450 posts of Ayurvedic
doctor on 22.12.2020 and it was further modified on
21.06.2021 and posts were increased to 590. He further
submitted that petitioner was found eligible in MBC category
and placed at serial number 4 in provisional merit list of MBC
category, but during document verification, due to some
misconception about the age of petitioner, the name of
petitioner was not included in the select list, though
petitioner has secured 73.48 percentile and candidates
having lower percentile up to 48.72 were selected.
6.
Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of respondents have
opposed the contentions raised by learned counsels for the
petitioners and submitted that in both the cases issue
pertains to relaxation of age and the manner in which
petitioners have claimed relaxation is not permissible under
the rules. He further submitted that issue pertaining to age
relaxation was considered recently by a Division Bench of
(6 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
this Hon'ble Court in case of State of Rajasthan and Ors.
versus Ali Taqi and others, D.B. Special Appeal Writ
No. 1123/2024 decided on 09.09.2025 at Principal Seat
Jodhpur wherein it was held that if the rules provides for
non-cumulative relaxation, then same must be respected.
7.
He further referred judgment dated 29.04.2016 in Alsa
Ram Meghwal versus RPSC and another, D.B. Special
Appeal Writ No. 1141/2008 decided by a Division Bench
of this Hon'ble Court at Principal Seat Jodhpur and order
dated 27.09.2023 in
S.B. Civil Writ Petition
No.
13782/2023, Dr. Dayaram Saran and others versus
State of Rajasthan and others decided by a Coordinate
Bench at Principal Seat Jodhpur, and submitted that age of
relaxation on cumulative basis of already turned down.
8.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material placed on record. Also considered the judgments as
referred by learned counsel for the parties.
9.
The issue pertains to age relaxation and controversy is
whether the provision of age relaxation be read as it has
been provided in the advertisement or rules or the Court
may interpret and opine differently and direct to provide age
relaxation on cumulative manner.
10.
Here in these cases, the petitioners have claimed cumulative
age relaxation formula be adopted so that they may become
eligible
in
terms
of
age,
but
the
respondents
have
vehemently opposed the formula and submitted that the rule
provides only non-cumulative age relaxation, therefore,
(7 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
petitioners are not entitled for more age relaxation, by
counting two categories together.
11.
In case of Dr. Mohd. Yunus versus State of Rajasthan
and others (supra), a Coordinate Bench of this Court while
considering age relaxation on post of Unani Medical Officer in
NRHM
has
observed
that
the
provision
under
the
advertisement in question for relaxation of age limit with
non-cumulative effect is quashed and the respondents are
directed to give cumulative relaxation of age to eligible
petitioners with consequential benefit, considering their
candidature as per their merit position.
12.
On the other side, the issue relating to age relaxation was
considered by a Division Bench of this Court in case of Alsa
Ram Meghwal (supra), and opined that different upper
age limit having been prescribed under the rules, service
candidates treating them to be a distinct class, no distinction
can be made between government servants so as to make
them entitled to claim relaxation under proviso (1) or (14) to
Rule 13 being member of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled
Tribes or other backward classes, as the case may be. It is
well settled that the function of the Court is to interpret the
law and not to legislate, therefore, it is not possible to
interpret Rule 13 of the Rules on the merits, as suggested on
behalf of appellants so as to extend applicability of relaxation
in age as provided under the rules.
13.
In case of Dr. Dayaram Saran (supra), a Coordinate
Bench has considered relaxation in age and observed that
the petitioners are entitled for relaxation of maximum five
(8 of 10)
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
[CW-15810/2023]
years and since they have attained the age of 53 to 57
years, so they are overage in terms of provision of the rules.
14.
In case of State of Rajasthan versus Dr. Ali Taqi and
others (supra), a Division Bench of this Court after
considering the provisions under the Rajasthan Ayurvedic,
Unani, Homeopathy and Naturopathy Service Rules, 1973 in
a
matter
relating
to
recruitment
notification
dated
13.07.2023 has considered judgment in case of Malik
Mazhar Sultan versus UPSC, (2006) 9 SCC 507 and
Ashish Kumar versus State of U.P., (2018) 3 SCC 55,
wherein Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that statutory rule
prevails over any contrary condition in advertisement. After
considering the advertisement and the provisions under the
Rules of 1973, the Division Bench has observed the current
legal position as under:
"7.15. In this backdrop, the correct legal position can
be summarized in the following manner:
• If the Rule itself provides for
cumulative relaxation, the same must
be respected.
• If the Rule prescribes non-cumulative
relaxation, then the Rule will prevail.
•
If
the
Rule
is
silent,
the
advertisement
will
govern
the
recruitment (as in the present case).
•
If
both
the
Rule
and
the
advertisement are silent, the default
position is that relaxation will be noncumulative.
• If the State intends to extend
cumulative benefit, it must do so by
express stipulation in the Rule or the
advertisement.
• Thus, if the Rule is speaking, the Rule
will prevail; if silent, the advertisement
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
(9 of 10)
[CW-15810/2023]
will prevail. (“Rules of the game cannot
be changed midway after the process of
appointment to public post has already
begun.”)
7.16.
Tested
on
these
touchstones,
the
respondents/writ
petitioners
cannot
claim
cumulative relaxation, as the Rules of 1973 are
silent and the advertisement explicitly rules out
such aggregation. Thus the binding terms of the
advertisement cannot be disregarded and
travelled beyond the governing framework.
7.17. Thus, in view of the foregoing discussion, this
Court holds that the Rules of 1973 do not
envisage cumulative age relaxation across
different categories. Each relaxation under Rule
9 of the said Rules is to be applied independently
within its own sphere. The express stipulation in
the advertisement that relaxations shall be noncumulative is consistent with the statutory
framework and cannot be termed arbitrary or de
hors the Rules. Therefore, the learned Single
Judge was not justified in directing the
appellants to extend cumulative relaxation to the
respondents."
15.
Having considered the judgment of Division Bench of this
Court at Principal Seat Jodhpur in case of State of
Rajasthan versus Dr. Ali Taqi and others (supra),
petitioners are not entitled for age relaxation in cumulative
manner as same has not been provided under the Rules of
1973. Thus, the judgment referred by learned counsel for
petitioners in case of Dr. Mohd. Yunus versus State of
Rajasthan (supra), is not applicable upon facts of the case.
16.
In view of discussion made hereinabove, the petitioners have
failed to show any provision of rule which provides for age
relaxation in cumulative manner. Thus, the petitioners are
not entitled for any relief on any of the grounds mentioned in
the writ petitions.
[2026:RJ-JP:5476]
17.
(10 of 10)
[CW-15810/2023]
As a result, these writ petitions are hereby dismissed with
pending application, if any.
(ASHOK KUMAR JAIN),J
PREETI VALECHA /118-119
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review