Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA NO.26 OF 2024
Smt. Basanti Banik
…… Appellant(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura and ors.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Roy Barman, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
Mr. K. Nath, Advocate.
Mr. D. Paul, Advocate.
Ms. A. Debbarma, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s) : Mr. Kohinoor N. Bhattacharjee, G.A.
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 16/07/2025
Whether fit for reporting
: NO.
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
T. AMARNATH GOUD(J)
1.
Heard Mr. Dipjyoti Paul, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant, as well as Mr. D. Sharma, learned Additional Government Advocate,
appearing for the respondents.
2.
The brief facts of the case are that the appellant filed WP(C)
610/2023 before this Court, seeking, among other things, necessary directions
upon the respondents to quash and cancel the order dated 28.11.2022 issued by
the Controller of Examinations, Teachers' Recruitment Board Tripura. The
appellant also sought to be treated as T-TET 2021 qualified and eligible for
consideration for the post of Graduate Teacher (VI-VIII) as per the Notification
dated 01.10.2022. Further directions were also sought for recommending the
name of the petitioner-appellant for recruitment to the said post. The learned
Single Judge, vide Judgment and Order dated 30.09.2023, dismissed the writ
petition. Hence, the present writ appeal.
3.
Mr. D. Paul, learned counsel appearing for the appellant,
submitted that the learned Single Judge failed to consider that the Prospectuscum-Instructions for T-TET 2021 clearly stated: "Candidates who are
appearing in the final year of Bachelor Degree in Education (B.Ed.) / Diploma
in Elementary Education (D.El.Ed.), etc., are provisionally allowed to appear
in the T-TET 2021." In view of this condition, it is an admitted fact that, on the
date of the T-TET 2021 Examination (03.10.2021), the appellant was appearing
in the final year of the D.El.Ed. course. Therefore, she ought to have been
considered T-TET 2021 qualified, and her candidature for the post of Graduate
Teacher (VI–VIII) ought to have been duly considered. The learned Single
Judge also failed to appreciate that 03.10.2021, the date of the examination
should have been treated as the cut-off date for determining eligibility to appear
in T-TET 2021. Furthermore, the appellant had secured sufficient marks in the
examination, and considering the fact that the 2019–2021 session of the
D.El.Ed. course was delayed due to the COVID-19 pandemic, an event beyond
the appellant’s control, a compassionate view should have been taken by the
State respondents by declaring her T-TET 2021 qualified.
3.1.
To support his argument, learned counsel referred to Para-9
of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in (2005) 9 SCC 779
titled as Dolly Chhanda Vs. Chariman, JEE and other. The same is produced
here-in-under:“9. The appellant undoubtedly belonged to reserved MI
category. She comes from a very humble background, her father was only a Naik
in the armed forces. He may not have noticed the mistake which had been
committed by the Zilla Sainik Board while issuing the first certificate dated
29.6.2003. But it does not mean that the appellant should be denied her due when
she produced a correct certificate at the stage of second counselling. Those who
secured rank lower than the appellant have already been admitted. The view
taken by the authorities in denying admission to the appellant is wholly unjust
and illegal.”
4.
On the other hand, Mr. D. Sharma, learned Addl. G.A.,
appearing for the respondents stated that the appellant was ineligible to apply
for the T-TET 2021 conducted by the TRBT under advertisement dated
10.02.2021. She was in the first year of the D.El.Ed. course on the cut-off date
for submission of application. Only final year students of D.El.Ed course were
permitted to apply. As such, since the appellant lacked the initial eligibility to
participate in the T-TET 2021, the respondents could not allow her plea, as it
would amount to derogating from the settled principles of law as regards the
eligibility of a candidate on the cut-off date for making an application in such
competitive test for public recruitment. The Controller of Examinations, TRBT
has given due consideration to all the aspects of the matter and despite all-out
efforts and humanitarian considerations, did not find any legal basis to allow
her claim. It is submitted that if any leniency is shown to the appellant, it may
open floodgates which the respondents would not be able to deal with.
4.1.
To support this argument, learned Addl. G.A., relied upon
Para-5 of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in
(1993)AIR(SCW)1488 titled as Mrs.Rekha Chaturvedi(Smt) Vs. University of
Rajasthan and ors. The same is reproduced:“5. The contention that the required qualifications of the
candidates should be examined with reference to the date of selection and not with
reference to the last date for making applications has only to be stated to be rejected.
The date of selection is invariably uncertain. In the absence of knowledge of such
date the candidates who apply for the posts would be unable to state whether they
are qualified for the posts in question or not, if they are yet acquire the
qualifications. Unless the advertisement mentions a fixed date with reference to
which the qualifications are to be judged, whether the said date is of selection or
otherwise, it would not be possible for the candidates who do not possess the
requisite qualifications in praesenti even to make applications for the posts. The
uncertainty of the date may also lead to a contrary consequence, viz., even those
candidates who do not have the qualifications in praesenti and are likely to acquire
them at an uncertain future date, may apply for the posts thus swelling the number
of applications. But a still worse consequence may follow, in that it may leave open
a scope for malpractices. The date of selection may be so fixed or manipulated as to
entertain some applicants and reject others, arbitrarily. Hence, in the absence of a
fixed date indicated in the advertisement/notification inviting applications should be
judged, the only certain date for the scrutiny of the qualifications will be the last
date for making the applications. We have, therefore, no hesitation in holding that
when the Selection Committee in the present case, as argued by Shri Manoj Swarup,
took into consideration the requisite qualifications as on the date of selection rather
than on the last date of preferring applications, it acted with patent illegality, and on
this ground itself the selections in question arc liable to be quashed. Reference in
this connection may also be made to two recent decisions of this Court in A.P.
Public Service Commission. Hyderabad and Another Vs. B. Sarat Chandra and
Others. and District Collector and Chairman. Vizianagaram Social Welfare
Residential School Society, Vizianagaram and Another Vs. M. Tripura Sundari
Devi.”
4.2.
Learned Addl. G.A., also relied upon the Para-19 of the
Judgment of the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi titled as Punjab National Bank
Vs. Ghanshyam Kumar and ors bearing No.LPA 28/2019 & C.M.
Appl.2075/2019. The same is produced here-in-under:“16. The legal position in ths regard has been settled in the
decision of a three Judge Bench of the Supreme Court of India in Ashok Kumar
Sharma v. Chander Shekhar IB (supra). That decision was rendered by reviewing
the earlier judgment in Ashok Kumar Sharma v. Chander Shekhar 1993 Supp (2)
SCC 611 where by a majority of 2:1, the Supreme Court held that the relevant date
for determining eligibity could be the date of interview. On this issue the Review
Bench disagreed and held:
"So far as the first issue referred to in our order dated 1st September, 1995 is
concerned, we are of the respectful opinion that majority judgment (rendered by the
Dr. T.K. Thommen and V. Ramaswami, JJ) is unsustainable in law, the proposition
that where applications are called for prescribing a particular date as the last date
for filing the applications, the eligibility of the candidates shall have to be judged
with reference to that date and that date alone, is a well-established one. A person
who acquires the prescribed qualification subsequent to such prescribed date
cannot be considered at all. An advertisement or notification issued/published
calling for applications constitutes a representation to the public and the authority
issuing it is bound by such representation. It cannot act contrary to it. One reason
behind this proposition is that if it were known that persons who obtained the
qualifications after the prescribed date but before the date of interview would be
allowed to appear for the interview would be allowed to appear for the interview,
other similiarly placed persons could also have applied. Just because some of the
persons had applied notwithstanding that they had not acquired the prescribed
qualifications by the prescribed date, they could not have been treated on a
preferential basis. Their application ought to have been rejected at the inception
itself. This proposition is indisputable and in fact was not doubted or disputed in
the majority Judgement. This is also the proposition affirmed in Rekha Chaturvedi
(Smt.) v. University of Rajasthan and others [1993 Suppl. (3) S.C.C 168). The
reasoning in majority opinion that by allowing the 33 respondents to appear for the
interview, the Recruiting Authority was able to get the bests talent available and
that such course was in furtherence of public interest is, with respect, an
impermissible justification. It is, in our considered opinion, a clear error of law and
an error apparent on the face of the record. In our opinion, R.M. Sahai, J. (and the
Division Bench of the High Court) was ight in holding that the 33 respondents
could not have allowed to appear for interview." (emphasis supplied).
5.
Heard and perused the evidence on record.
6.
It is revealed from the record that the appellant appeared
Part-1 D. El. Ed examination in September, 2021 and result was published on
29.12.2021, which essentially means when notice for T-TET 2021 was issued
on 10.02.2021, she was in the first year of D.El.Ed course. As such, it is
clearly established that the appellant was in the first year of the D.El.Ed.
course as on the cut-off date for submission of applications under the
notification dated 10.02.2021 for T-TET 2021. The eligibility condition, as
expressly mentioned in the Prospectus-cum-Instructions, permitted only
candidates appearing in the final year of the D.El.Ed./B.Ed., course to apply.
The appellant, admittedly not in the final year at the relevant time, lacked the
minimum requisite eligibility. Her application itself was violative of the
declared terms and conditions of the recruitment process.
7.
The argument advanced by the learned counsel for the
appellant that the appellant was allowed to sit provisionally and scored
qualifying marks cannot override the legal requirement of eligibility as held
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Mrs. Rekha Chaturvedi vs. University of
Rajasthan(supra). Eligibility criteria must be strictly adhered to, and any
deviation would not only amount to illegality but also set a precedent
detrimental to the integrity of public recruitment processes.
Further, the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi in Punjab
8.
National Bank vs. Ghanshyam Kumar & Ors.,(supra) held that a person
who acquires the prescribed qualification subsequent to such prescribed date
cannot be considered at all.
10.
As such, this Court finds no illegality or perversity in the
order passed by the learned Single Judge and the same is confirmed as
because the appellant was ineligible on the date of application and had
violated the basic eligibility norms of T-TET 2021. No compassionate or
equitable consideration can be invoked to override a statutory recruitment
condition. Further the Judgment as cited by the learned counsel appearing for
the appellant is not relevant to the fact of this case.
11.
Accordingly, the present appeal fails and is hereby
dismissed. As a sequel, stay if any stands vacated. Pending application(s), if
any also stands closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
B. PALIT, J
suhanjit
signed by
SABYASAC Digitally
SABYASACHI GHOSH
2025.07.17
HI GHOSH Date:
15:19:34 +05'30'
DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review