The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
5. Are the plaintiffs entitled to get decree, as prayed for? trial [8] The trial court by the order dated 28.09.2012 has observed as follows: “In view of the above detailed discussion and findings of this court under the above issues, the present suit of the plaintiffs is hereby dismissed with costs. Decree-sheet be prepared accordingly. File be consigned to records.” [9] Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and decree passed in the original suit, the appellant herein preferred an appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.24 of 2012 in the court of the District Judge, North Tripura Judicial District, Kailashahar. The said court by the order dated 11.04.2013 has observed as under: “15. Hence, judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court are hereby set aside and quashed. The case is remanded back to the learned trial court with the following direction that the learned trial court shall appoint a competent Survey Commissioner with the following writ to decide No.3. Whether the land purchased in auction by Jogendgra Ch. Malakar vide Ext-series for 10 kanis 6 gandas of moujaDurgapur of Khas jote No.4 of the following boundary- West and North –Akshar and others, East-Govt. of Tripura, SouthTaluki boundary, is the present suit land, ie. Khatian No. 4940, plot No. Sabek – 7403, hal -7186, measuring 0.365 acre, plot No. sabek 7398, hal – 7180, land measuring 0.426 of mou…
16. Learned trial court shall enter the case in the Trial Register in its original number and appoint a Survey Commissioner at the cost of the State and shall proceed thereon as per the guidelines of order 26 CPC and shall pass judgment fresh.” [10] The trial court complying the order dated 11.04.2013 of the lower appellate court re-admitted the suit under its original number in the register of the Civil suits, and proceeded to determine the suit as per given direction in the judgment of the appellate court. [11] When the case was re-admitted by the trial court, in order to substantiate the claims of the appellants herein, Smt. Aparna Malakar, Sri Dwijendra Malakar, Sri Satyendra Kumar Chakraborty and Monir Ali have examined themselves as PW-1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively and also submitted several documents in support of their claim and marked them as Exhibit 1 to 17 series. [12] On the other hand, defendants Chandra Krishna Malsom and Smt, Namita Sen Gupta have examined themselves as DW1 and DW2 respectively. They have also submitted several documents supporting their claim and marked them as Exbt-A-E series. [13] While perusing the report of Survey commissioner, the trial court by the order dated 30.09.2013 has observed as follows: “Mr. Basanta Kumar Das, the aforesaid Commissioner, after local inspection by surveying returned and submitted his report in writing and signed by him, t…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 52 of 2018
1. Smt. Arpana Malakar @ Aparna Malakar
daughter of Late Jitendra Chandra Malakar,
2. Smt. Kalpana Malakar
daughter of Late Jitendra Chandra Malakar,
W/o. Sri Parimal Malakar,
3. Smt. Jamuna Malakar
daughter of Late Jitendra Chandra Malakar,
W/o. Sri Bidhan Chandra Malakar,
4. Smt. Kanika Malakar
daughter of Late Jitendra Chandra Malakar,
5. Sri Jyotish Chandra Malakar @ Jyotish Malakar
son of Late Jitendra Chandra Malakar,
All are residents of Village - Durgapur,
P.O. - Paiturbazar, P.S. and Sub-Division - Kailashahar,
District - Unakoti, Tripura.
6. Smt. Rekha Chakraborty
daughter of Late Anil Chakraborty,
W/o. Sri Haripada Chakraborty,
Resident of Village - Durgapur,
P.O. - Paiturbazar, P.S. Kailashahar,
District - Unakoti, Tripura.
7. Sri Jishu Chakraborty
S/o. of Late Anil Chakraborty,
of Village - Durgapur, P.O. - Paiturbazar,
P.S. Kailashahar, District - Unakoti, Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sub-Divisional Magistrate
Kailashahar, District - Unakoti, Tripura.
2. The District Collector
Unakoti District, Gournagar,
P.O. - Gournagar, Sub-Division - Kailashahar,
District - Unakoti, Tripura.
3. The State Of Tripura
Represented by the Principal Secretary,
Government of Tripura,
Department of Revenue,
having his office at Secretariat Complex,
P.O. -Kunjaban, P.S. - New Capital Complex,
Sub-Division - Agartala, District - West Tripura.
-----Respondent(s)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing
Date of pronouncement
Whether fit for reporting
: Mr. S. Lodh, Adv.
: Mr. D. Bhattacharjee, GA.
: Mr. P. Saha, Adv.
: 17.02.2022.
: 24.02.2022
: No.
HON‟BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the CPC, 1908 against
the impugned Judgment & Decree dated 12.09.2018, passed by the
learned District Judge, Unakoti Judicial District Kailashahar, in Title
Appeal 3 of 2016, whereby learned District Judge, Unakoti Judicial
District, Kailashahar, reversed the Judgment & Decree dated 30.09.2013
& 01.10.2013 respectively, passed by the learned Civil Judge, Senior
Division, Kailashahar, North Tripura District Judiciary in Title Suit No.23
of 2011.
[2]
The short of the plaintiffs’ case (the appellants herein) is that
the land measuring 0.791 acres of khatian no.4940 under Kailashahar
mouja pertaining to Old C.S Plot No.7398(p) corresponding to R.S. Plot
No. 7180 totaling land measuring 0.426 acres and pertaining to CS Plot
No. 7403 corresponding to RS Plot No.7186 totaling land measuring
0.365 described in the 1st schedule in the suit land of this suit. The land
measuring 0.100 acres described in 2nd schedule was sold to plaintiff
nos.6 and 7 by plaintiff no.s 1 to 5 and their deceased mother Maya Rani
Malakar. The land measuring 0.691 acres described in 3rd schedule is the
remaining land in the hand of plaintiff nos. 1 to 5. The plaintiff nos. 1 to 5
are the sole and ultimate legal heirs of their deceased parents Jitendra
Chandra Malakar.
[3]
Originally the suit land along with other land was owned and
possessed by one Jogendra Chandra Malakar on the strength of auction
purchase vides auction certificate case No.113 of 1345 T.E issued by
competent authority of then Govt. of Tripura. The said Jogendra Chandra
Malakar died leaving behind him 3 sons namely (1) Jotindra Chandra
Malakar, (2) Jitendra Chandra Malakar, (3) Digendra Chandra Malakar,
and two daughters namely – (1) Pravashini Malakar and (2) Raj Moni
Malakar. On the death of said Jogendra Chandra Malakar, his above said
legal heirs became sole owners of the suit land and other land left by
him. The two daughters of deceased Jogendra Chandra Malakar gifted
their shares of the land including suit land left by Jogendra Chandra
Malakar to their three sons of Jogendra Chandra Malakar executed and
effected regular partition of the land left by their father amongst
themselves
vides
Registered
partition
deed
No.
1-1436
dated
16.05.1983. In that partition, the suit land along with other land fell to
the exclusive share of Jitendra Chandra Malakar and on his death the
present plaintiff Nos. 1 to 5 being daughters and sons became exclusive
owners and possessors of the suit land and other land.
[4]
Thereafter, Smt. Aparna Malakar and 6 (six) others have filed
the suit against Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Kailashahar Sub-Division,
Unakoti District & 2(two) others for declaration of right, title and interest
and confirmation of possession over suit land.
[5]
The appellant filed the suit in the trial court for recovering of
possession of the following schedules.
1st Schedule (suit land)
District-north
Tripura
PS
Kailashahar,
Tehshil
–
Kailashahar. Mouja – Kailashahar, Khatian No 4940.
I) Old C.S Plot No. 7398/(part) (corresponding R.S
Plot No. 7180, Class- Nal, Area – 0.426 acres.
II) Old C.S Plot No. 7403 Corresponding RS Plot No.
7186, Class-Nal , Area- 0.365 Acre.
Total land area = 0.791 acre.
2nd Schedule (Sold out land)
District- P.S Tehshil- Mouja- Kailashahar, Khatian No. 4940,
Old CS Plot No. 7403(part) Corresponding R.S Plot NO.
7186 (part), at the south-western portion of plot. Class-Nal,
Area- 0.100 Ac. Begin bounded as belowNorth- Land of plaintiff nos, 1/2/3/4/5
South- Land of plaintiff nos, 1/2/3/4/5
East- Land of plaintiff nos, 1/2/3/4/5
West- late kunjabihari Barma & late Bilash Moni
Chakraborty.
3rd schedule (Remaining Land)
District, PS, Tehshil, Mouja – Kailashahar, Khatian No. 4940.
I) Old C.S Plot No. 7398, Corresponding RS Plot NO.
7180, Class-Nal , Area – 0.426 Acrs.
II) Old CS Plot No. 7403 (Part), Corresponding RS
Plot No. 7186(Part), Class-Nal, Area, 0.235 Acres
Total Land area- 0.691 Acs.
[6]
In the written statement filed by the defendants (the
respondents herein) it has been stated that plaintiffs counterfeit the
registered instrument of Nani Gopal De, S/o Dwarika Nath De of Chantali
with intention to cause it to be believed that such document was
executed in the office of the Sub-Registry, Kailashahar on 29.06.1981.
Anil Kumar Das, son of late Jatindra Kumar Das executed a sale deed in
favour of Nani Gopal Deb s/o late Dwarika Nath De on 29.06.1981
against the plot No.4111 of Khatian No. 2066 of mouja Kailashahar vides
Registered deed No. 1-2113, dated 29.06.1981 Sl. 2398 , Vol No. 4, SPL
Page232-34. Thereafter, the plaintiff willfully and with intend to defraud
falsifies the registered document of Nani Gopal De and abet the omission
or alteration of particular land from the registered instruments of Nani
Gopal De and inserts valuable Govt. Khas land of plot No. 7186 and khas
plot No. 7180 against Khatian Nos. 1/36 and 1/41 with an area 0.365
acres and 0.426 acres in favour of Jitendra Chandra Malakar, S/o
Jogendra Kumar Malakar and Smt. Maya Rani Malkar. Thereafter the
plaintiffs approached to one Tapan Gupta the then Teshildar of
Kailashahar T. K with an application in the prescribed form no. 21 of the
Act for incorporation in the mutation registers.
[7]
After considering the pleadings and submission of both sides,
the trial court has framed the following issues for discussion:
1. Is the suit of the plaintiffs not maintainable in its
present form?
2. Whether the suit is barred by law of limitation and other
laws?
3. Whether the plaintiffs have their rights, title and
interest over the suit land/property?
4. Whether the plaintiffs are in possession of the suit
land/property?
5. Are the plaintiffs entitled to get decree, as prayed for?
trial
[8]
The trial court by the order dated 28.09.2012 has observed
as follows:
“In view of the above detailed discussion and findings of
this court under the above issues, the present suit of the
plaintiffs is hereby dismissed with costs. Decree-sheet be
prepared accordingly. File be consigned to records.”
[9]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree passed in the original suit, the appellant herein preferred an
appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.24 of 2012 in the court of the
District Judge, North Tripura Judicial District, Kailashahar. The said court
by the order dated 11.04.2013 has observed as under:
“15. Hence, judgment and decree passed by the learned
trial court are hereby set aside and quashed. The case is
remanded back to the learned trial court with the following
direction that the learned trial court shall appoint a
competent Survey Commissioner with the following writ to
decide No.3.
Whether the land purchased in auction by Jogendgra
Ch. Malakar vide Ext-series for 10 kanis 6 gandas of moujaDurgapur of Khas jote No.4 of the following boundary- West
and North –Akshar and others, East-Govt. of Tripura, SouthTaluki boundary, is the present suit land, ie. Khatian No.
4940, plot No. Sabek – 7403, hal -7186, measuring 0.365
acre, plot No. sabek 7398, hal – 7180, land measuring 0.426
of mouja- Kailashahar?
16. Learned trial court shall enter the case in the Trial
Register in its original number and appoint a Survey
Commissioner at the cost of the State and shall proceed
thereon as per the guidelines of order 26 CPC and shall pass
judgment fresh.”
[10]
The trial court complying the order dated 11.04.2013 of the
lower appellate court re-admitted the suit under its original number in
the register of the Civil suits, and proceeded to determine the suit as per
given direction in the judgment of the appellate court.
[11]
When the case was re-admitted by the trial court, in order to
substantiate the claims of the appellants herein, Smt. Aparna Malakar,
Sri Dwijendra Malakar, Sri Satyendra Kumar Chakraborty and Monir Ali
have examined themselves as PW-1, 2, 3 and 4 respectively and also
submitted several documents in support of their claim and marked them
as Exhibit 1 to 17 series.
[12]
On the other hand, defendants Chandra Krishna Malsom and
Smt, Namita Sen Gupta have examined themselves as DW1 and DW2
respectively. They have also submitted several documents supporting
their claim and marked them as Exbt-A-E series.
[13]
While perusing the report of Survey commissioner, the trial
court by the order dated 30.09.2013 has observed as follows:
“Mr.
Basanta
Kumar
Das,
the
aforesaid
Commissioner, after local inspection by surveying returned
and submitted his report in writing and signed by him, to
the Court. The court after receiving the report in writing
dated 27-08-2013 of the commissioner invited the both the
parties to put objection, if any from their part against the
report. Neither party put objection against the report in
spite of opportunity given them. Accordingly, the court
scrutinized the report carefully as to whether the
investigation was in conformity with the writ or not. The
Court in his considered view found the report being the
investigation by survey had been conducted in conformity
with the spirit of the „WRIT‟ issued by the Court, and
accordingly accepted the same and marked Ext.C-1 without
examination the Commissioner.”
[14]
While deciding the issue No. 3, the trial court has observed
that the auction purchase certificate Ext.4 series is the document of title
and it being a document of 30 years old is admissible in evidence under
Section 90 of the Evidence Act. This Ext.4 series clearly shows that the
predecessor of the plaintiffs had purchased the lands embodied in the
Certificate. There is no dispute that parties are the successors of the
purchaser of the land of document Ext.4 series. Therefore, since the suit
lands fall within the boundaries of the land purchased vide document Ext.
4 series and since the said Auction purchase certificate is the document
of title and latter on the land of the Ext.4 series was partitioned, an
irresistible conclusion is that plaintiffs have their title over the suit lands.
Resultantly, this issue is decided in favour of the plantiffs.
[15]
The trial court after having examined all the records so
placed in the plaint and also after examining the written statement filed
by the defendant-appellant, depositions of PWs and DWs in support of
the claim, has observed by the judgment dated 30.09.2013 as herein
under:
“In view of the above detailed discussion and
findings of this court under the above issues, the present
suit of the plaintiffs is hereby decreed without costs and on
contest. The rights title and interest of the plaintiff nos. 1 to
5 over the suit land of 3rd Schedule and the Rights, title and
interest of the plaintiff nos. 6 and 7 over the land of 2nd
Schedule are hereby declared. The plaintiffs, possessions
over their respective lands of 3rd and 2nd schedule are also
hereby confirmed. The defendants, their men and agency
are hereby perpetually restrained from interfering with the
respective possessions of the plaintiffs over the lands of 3rd
and 2nd schedules.
[16]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree dated 30.09.2013 passed in the Title suit No. 23 of 2011 , the
respondents herein preferred an appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.3
of 2016 in the court of the Unakoti District Judge, Kailashahar. The said
court has observed by the order dated 12.09.2018 as herein under:
“On my perusal of the entire case record of the
trial court I find that the land in question was
purchased by Jogendra Chandra Malakar in the year
1347 TE. It is not clear from the record when said
Jogendra Chandra Malakar died. It is also not
explained what was the position of the land after
coming into force of the TLR & LR Act in the year
1960 admitted case of the present respondents is
that in the year 2006 the suit and was recorded in
their names under new Khatian No. 4940 for land
measuring 0.791 acres. Though it is explained in the
original plaint that in the year 1983 there was
partition of the suit land among the three sons of
Jogendra Chandra Malakar and it was registered but
after that partition the suit land was not recorded by
them in the revenue records.
….
Hence, in my considered view the findings of
the trial court in deciding the aforesaid issue is found
to be unjustified.
In consequence, it was ordered by the appellate court by the
order dated 12.09.2018 as herein under:
“In the light of my above discussion, the appeal
preferred by the appellants is allowed setting aside the
judgment and decree dated 30.09.2013 passed in TS 23 of
2011 by the Ld. Civil Judge (Sr. Div) Kailashahar.”
[17]
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree of the first
appellate court dated 12.09.2018, the appellant herein has preferred this
instant appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. At the time of admitting this
appeal, the following substantial question of law was framed by this court
by the order dated 20.12.2018.
1) Whether the Judgment & Decree of the Learned First
Appellate Court is perverse?
2) Whether the learned First Appellate Court was legally
correct in interfering with the report of the survey
commissioner (Exbt.C1) in absence of any challenge
by defendant-respondent.
3) Whether without complying with the provisions of
Order XXVI Rule 10(2) and Rule 10(3) of the CPC
learned First Appellate Court below was correct in
setting aside the Judgment & Decree of the learned
Trial Court?
[18]
Heard counsel for the parties.
[19]
It is the case of the appellant that his predecessors
purchased the property vide registered sale deed by way of an auction
from the government and subsequently from him the respondents
purchased the property. Since then he has uninterrupted possession.
When the appellant went for the correction of records and the
government said it was the land of government and at that juncture, he
filed a suit. The suit was decreed accordingly. Aggrieved thereby the
appellant-plaintiff moved to the appellate court and the appellate court
remanded back the case setting aside the judgment and decree dated
28.12.2012. Thereafter, when the trial court complying the order of the
appellate court re-admitted the matter, the same has been decreed
relying
on
the
survey
commissioner’s
report.
The
said
survey
commissioners report was not opposed and no objection were filed since
the same has been accepted and the trial court has decreed the suit in
favour of the appellant-plaintiff. In the appeal filed by the state, the
appellate court has not relied the survey commissioner’s report and has
raised serious doubts on the issues which were not before the trial court
and the trial court and he has set aside the judgment and the decree and
allowed the appeal by the order dated 12.04.2016. Aggrieved thereby the
present appeal is filed. Mr. S. Lodh, counsel for the appellants thus
therefore prayed for upholding the lower court judgment and decree and
set aside the same since the same is perverse.
[20]
Mr. D. Bhattacharee, GA in his reply to the contention as
advanced by the counsel for the appellant that the land in question is not
the piece of land which was auction by the government in favour of the
appellant-plaintiffs. He further prayed that a thorough investigation with
regard to the land in question be made enabling the competent authority
to decide the matter on its merit.
[21]
At this juncture, this court is of the view that over the years
with the changing circumstances in the government and the revenue
department with regard to the records and change in numbers, the
identity of the property has become the main issue.
[22]
In view of the same, this court feels that it is just and proper
to allow the appeal setting aside the order of the lower appellate court
and remand the matter back to the lower appellate court to re-examine
the matter on the strength of its evidence and merits and also given an
opportunity to the plaintiff for filing application seeking to conduct survey
and identify the land which has been auctioned by the government in
favour of the predecessors of the plaintiff and mark boundaries and
receive the report in this regard. On receipt of such report, the lower
appellate court shall decide the matter on merit in accordance with law.
This exercise by the appellate court shall be completed within a period of
six months.
Accordingly, the appeal stands disposed of with above
observations.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review