The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
11. 08.2006 in pursuance of the instruction the DCM, Sadar in presence of the owners of the adjacent R.S. Plot Nos. 2295, 2296, 2297 and 2298 and during spot survey it was revealed that the plaintiff was physically possessing land measuring 0.025 acres instead of 0.040 acres. Thereafter, the Survey team measured the adjacent plots and found the owners of R.S. Plot No.2295 and 2296 are possessing the land measuring 0.015 acres of the plaintiff. The aforesaid plots belong to the defendants. The defendant No. 1 and 2 are possessing 0.005 acres of access land. Similarly the defendants No3 and 4 who are owners of Plot No. 297 are possessing 0.059 acres of land instead of the recorded land in excess of 0.05 acres, so the defendants are also possessing 0.015 acres of access land. [5] The appellant filed the suit in the trial court for recovering of possession of the following schedules. Schedule-A Within District- West Tripura, Sub-Division, Sadar, Pargana, Agartala, Sub-Registry- Sadar P.S. – East Agartala, Tehsil – Indranagar, Mouja - Kunjaban, land measuring 0.04 acres, recorded under Khatian No. 2274, C.S. Plot No. 1340 – 3850 and C.s. Plot No. 2317. Being butted and bounded by:North- At present Chameli Singh and Kamaljit Singh; South – At present Quarter; East – At present Kaizar Debbarma; West – At present Kamljit Singha, Smt. Chameli Singha, Sri Jyotirmoy Paul, Champa Paul & Samir …
01. 12.2006, made prayer for demarcation of land measuring 0.04 acre described in Schedule A.” [14] The first appellate court while appreciating the above pleadings of the plaintiff clearly indicate that Shyamal Sengupta did not handover the possession of 0.04 acre of land within the boundary given in the sale deed otherwise he did not apply for demarcation of land long after the execution of sale deed by him in favour of the plaintiff. The plaintiff did not examine Sri Shyamal Sengupta as witness to prove that he delivered the physical possession of 0.04 acre of land as per recital in the sale deed. [15] Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree of the first appellate court dated 06.06.2016, the appellant has preferred this instant appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. At the time of admitting this appeal, the following substantial questions of law were framed by this court by the order dated 05.03.2019. “Whether the findings of the first appellate court are perverse?” The appellant was given further liberty to raise any other substantial question of law at the time of hearing. It is to be noted that no such endeavour was made rather Mr. K. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has stated that the main ground in this appeal is whether principle of res judicata would operate alternatively whether the suit is barred by limitation or not. and [16] The lower appellat…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA 30 of 2017
Smt. Archana Rani Deb
Wife of Sri Bijoy Debbarma,
Daughter of Lt. Prafulla Kr. Deb,
Resident of Abhoynagar,
P.S.- East Agartala, P.O.- Abhoynagar,
District - West Tripura.
-----Appellant(s)
Versus
1. Sri Kamaljit Singh and Ors.
Son of Chandra Kr. Singh,
2. Smt. Chameli Singh
Wife of Sri Kamaljit Singh,
3. Smt. Shibani Datta
Wife of late Samit Kanti Datta,
4. Sri Jyotirmoy Paul
Wife of Kamini Mohan Paul,
5. Smt. Champa Paul
Wife of Jyotirmoy Paul,
All are residents of Kunjaban, P.O. - Kunjaban,
P.S. - East Agartala, District - West Tripura.
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
Date of hearing and
date of passing
judgment and order
Whether fit for reporting
-----Respondent(s)
: Mr. K. Datta, Adv.
: Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, Sr. Adv.
Mr. S. Sarkar, Adv.
: 24.01.2022
: No
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
Judgment & ORDER
Heard Mr. K. Datta, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant as well as Mr. D. R. Chowdhury, learned senior counsel
assisted by Mr. S. Sarkar, learned counsel for the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the Civil Procedure
code against the judgment dated 06-06-2016 and decree passed by
Additional District Judge, Court No.5, West Tripura, Agartala in Title
Appeal 04 of 2014 arising out of Judgment and decree dated
26.09.2013 passed by Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Court No1, West
Tripura, Agartala in case no. TS 125 of 2011.
[3]
At the outset, the controversy that led to filing of the suit
may briefly be introduced. The plaintiff Appellant as Plaintiff instituted
the Title Suit No. TS.125 of 2011 in the Court of Ld. Civil Judge, Sr.
Division, Court No.1, West Tripura, Agartala against the Defendant –
Respondents for confirmation of right title and recovery of possession
by evicting the defendants therefrom.
[4]
In a nutshell the plaintiff’s case is that, she purchased two
gandas of land from one Shyamal Sengupta on 05.07.2005 by a
registered sale deed. Her said purchased land was also mutated in her
name. In the month of November 2006 the defendants encroached
some portion of purchased land of the Plaintiff. The Plaintiff raised
protest, but the defendants forcibly took into their possession of land
measuring 0.015 acres which is a part and parcel of the land measuring
two gandas. The total land of the plaintiff is described in Schedule A
while encroached land measuring 0.15 acres is shown in B, C and D
schedule of the plaint by the plaintiff. On the request of plaintiff the
local people intervened into the matter, but the defendants asserted
that the said land belong to them. Thereafter, the plaintiff as per advise
of the neighbouring people approached the Appropriate Authority for
demarcating her purchased land within the knowledge of Shyamal
Sengupta from whom the plaintiff purchased the land. In pursuance of
the prayer for demarcation, the land of the plaintiff was surveyed on
11.08.2006 in pursuance of the instruction the DCM, Sadar in presence
of the owners of the adjacent R.S. Plot Nos. 2295, 2296, 2297 and
2298 and during spot survey it was revealed that the plaintiff was
physically possessing land measuring 0.025 acres instead of 0.040
acres. Thereafter, the Survey team measured the adjacent plots and
found the owners of R.S. Plot No.2295 and 2296 are possessing the
land measuring 0.015 acres of the plaintiff. The aforesaid plots belong
to the defendants. The defendant No. 1 and 2 are possessing 0.005
acres of access land. Similarly the defendants No3 and 4 who are
owners of Plot No. 297 are possessing 0.059 acres of land instead of the
recorded land in excess of 0.05 acres, so the defendants are also
possessing 0.015 acres of access land.
[5]
The appellant filed the suit in the trial court for recovering of
possession of the following schedules.
Schedule-A
Within District- West Tripura, Sub-Division, Sadar,
Pargana, Agartala, Sub-Registry- Sadar P.S. – East
Agartala, Tehsil – Indranagar, Mouja - Kunjaban, land
measuring 0.04 acres, recorded under Khatian No. 2274,
C.S. Plot No. 1340 – 3850 and C.s. Plot No. 2317.
Being butted and bounded by:North- At present Chameli Singh and Kamaljit
Singh;
South – At present Quarter;
East – At present Kaizar Debbarma;
West – At present Kamljit Singha, Smt. Chameli
Singha, Sri Jyotirmoy Paul, Champa Paul & Samir
Kanti Datta;
Within this boundary land measuring 0.04 acres i.e. 2
(two) gandas, Viti Class of land.
Schedule –B
Land measuring .005 acres and recorded under Plot No.
2295 and 2296, butted and bounded by:North- Presently Kamaljit Singha & Chameli Singha;
South – Jyotirmoy Paul;
East – Plaintiff;
West – Kamaljit Singha & Chameli Singha.
Schedule –C
Land measuring 0.009 acres and recorded under Plot no.
2297, butted and bounded by
North – Kamljit sngha & Chalmeli Singha
South – Samir Kanti Datta,
East – Plaintiff
West- Jyotirmoy Paul and Champa Paul.
Schedule –D
Land measuring 0.001 acres, recorded under
No.2298, butted and bounded byNorth – Jyotirmoy Paul and Champa Paul;
South – Quarter;
East – Plaintiff;
West – Samir Kanti Datta.
Plot
The above mentioned 3 (three) Plots are possessing a
total quantum of land measuring 0.015 acres in excess of
their recorded land.
[6]
The defendants filed the written statement. In the written
statement filed by the defendants No.1 and 2, it has been categorically
stated that the defendant No.2 purchased land measuring 2 ½ gandas
from one Swarup Dasgupta by a registered sale deed No. 1-9510 dated
6-11-2001 and said land was sold by her to the defendant No. 1 by a
registered sale deed No. 1-8972 dated 9.10.2002 within the R.S. Plot
No. 2296 as shown in the sketch map and the aforesaid land was
mutated in the name of the defendant No. 1 and 2 jointly purcahsed
land measuring 0.06 acre from one Shri Manindra Chandra Saha by a
registered sale deed No, 1-1037 dated 3.12.2003 and got delivery of
possession thereof from their vendor immediately after purchase and
the said land was mutated in the name of the defendants No. 1 and 2 in
Khatian NO. 1581 of Mouja Kunjaaban within the R.S. Plot No. 2295
with an area of 0.06 acre and the said purchased land is shown in plot
No. 2295 in the sketch map.
[7]
The defendants No. 1 and 2 also narrated in their written
statement that the land of the defendants NO. 1 and 2 in R.S. Plot NO.
3422 is situated adjacent north of the land of the plaintiff and other
lands of the defendants No. 1 and 2 in RS Plot No. 2295 and 2296 have
no connection with the land of the plaintiff and the land under RS Plot
No. 3422 is the entrance of the dwelling house of the defendants No. 1
and 2 from the nearby road and as such the plaintiff claims a portion of
the land of R.S. Plot No. 3422 belonging to the defendants No. `1 and 2
as part of her purchased land.
[8]
On the basis of the rival pleadings, the Civil Judge (Sr. Div),
Court No.1, West Tripura Agartala hereinafter referred to as the trial
judge, framed the following issues:
A. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and
nature;
B. Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree of
confirmation of her share over the suit land;
C. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to get recovery of
possession of the suit land by way of evicting the
defendants therefrom;
D. Whether
relief/reliefs.
[9]
the
parties
are
entitled
to
get
any
The trial judge while deciding the issue No. B & C has
observed that on the face of the above documents specially documents
of the plaintiff are indicating that she purchased two gandas of land
duly
from
Shymal
Sengupta
with
her
specific
boundary.
The
demarcation report also indicating that land measuring 0.015 acres are
under the possession of the defendants. As I discussed above, the
evidence of defendants as well their documents, in no way are
supporting their claim and thereby I arrived at
decision that the
plaintiff is entitled to get a decree of her confirmation of right, title and
interest over the suit land and she is also entitled to get recovery of
possession of the suit land by way of evicting the defendants therefrom.
These two issues are answered accordingly.
While deciding the issue No. A the trial judge has observed
[10]
that it is clear to the court that the matter of possession of land is not
clear, so the question is related with the title of the land. In this regard
the
party
concern
may
approach
the
Appropriate
Court
for
determination of the title over the suit land. Hence the proceeding is
hereby dropped.
[11]
The trial judge after having examined all the records so
placed in the plaint and also after examining the written statement filed
by the defendants No. 1 and 2 and the PWs in support of the claim, has
observed that the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree of her right title
and interest over the suit land. The plaintiff is also entitled to get
recovery of possession of the suit land as per schedule of the plaint by
evicting the defendants from the suit land. The defendants are
accordingly directed to vacate the handover the possession of the suit
land to the plaintiff by removing their construction thereon, if any,
within a period of two months. The plaintiff is also entitled to get the
cost of the suit.
[12]
Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the judgment and
decree passed in the original suit, the defendants No.3 and 4 as
appellants preferred an appeal being case No. Title Appeal No.4 of 2014
in the court of the Additional District Judge, (Court No.5), West Tripura,
Agartala. The said court while deciding the matter has observed by the
judgment dated 06.06.2016 that the plaintiff therein failed to prove that
the suit land under Schedule B, C, and D are the part and parcel of A
schedule land of the plaintiff. The plaintiff has also failed to prove that
the defendants encroached a part of the A schedule land in the western
side in the month of November, 2006 or any subsequent date or
previously on any date before purchasing of the said land. So, the
findings of the learned trial court declaring the right, title and interest of
the plaintiff over the suit land under Schedule B, C and D and recovery
of possession of the same cannot stand. Accordingly, the impugned
judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court are liable to be
set aside.
[13]
It has been found by the first appellate court that the
plaintiff was not put in physical possession of the entire purchased land
of 0.04 acre by her vendor Shyamal Sengupta after selling of the said
land and the said fact is also evident from the pleadings of the plaintiff
at Paragrapah-6 of the plaint which is as follows:“……..Plaintiff also brought Shyamal Sengupta into
picture, from whom, the plaintiff purchased the land,
measuring 0.04 acre and Shyamal Sengupta, after visiting
the said land and after having talks with the plaintiffs and
others, asserted that, he had clear title of the land
measuring 0.04 acre and having his title, he transferred
the land to the Plaintiff and the Defendants cannot make
any claim on the said land. Thereafter, it had been decided
that, Shyamal Sengupta would make an application before
the appropriate authority for demarcation of the land
measuring 0.040 acre, described in the Schedule A.
Accordingly, Shyamal Sengupta, vide an application dated
01.12.2006, made prayer for demarcation of land
measuring 0.04 acre described in Schedule A.”
[14]
The first appellate court while appreciating the above
pleadings of the plaintiff clearly indicate that Shyamal Sengupta did not
handover the possession of 0.04 acre of land within the boundary given
in the sale deed otherwise he did not apply for demarcation of land long
after the execution of sale deed by him in favour of the plaintiff. The
plaintiff did not examine Sri Shyamal Sengupta as witness to prove that
he delivered the physical possession of 0.04 acre of land as per recital
in the sale deed.
[15]
Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree of the
first appellate court dated 06.06.2016, the appellant has preferred this
instant appeal under Section 100 of the CPC. At the time of admitting
this appeal, the following substantial questions of law were framed by
this court by the order dated 05.03.2019.
“Whether the findings of the first appellate court are
perverse?”
The appellant was given further liberty to raise any other
substantial question of law at the time of hearing. It is to be noted that
no such endeavour was made rather Mr. K. Datta, learned counsel
appearing for the appellant has stated that the main ground in this
appeal is
whether
principle
of res judicata would
operate
alternatively whether the suit is barred by limitation or not.
and
[16]
The lower appellate court has travelled beyond the scope of
its appeal and set aside the decree in its entirety and allowed the
appeal under law and the same is not permissible. The appellant before
the lower appellate court is the defendant No. 3 and 4 i.e. Jyotirmoy
Paul and Champa Paul respectively and at the stage of execution
proceedings, the matter has been compromised between the appellant
as well as the plaintiff in respect of “C” Schedule Property (as per the
plaint).
[17]
In view of the said compromise, the appellant herein seeks
to get the appeal allowed since the matter has been settled between the
appellant before the lower appellate court and the present appellant of
this plaint. In view of the same, the appeal is accordingly allowed.
[18]
Mr. D. C. Saha, learned counsel who appears for the
defendant No 1 and 2 in the suit and respondent No. 1 and 2 in the
present appeal Kamaljit Singh and Chameli Singh submitting on the
strength of Order 41 of Rule 4 and 33 of the CPC submits before this
court that once it is a common judgment, even if all parties of the suit
have not challenged, the benefit has to be extended to all the parties
and in order to support his contention he relied on a judgment passed
by Punjab-Haryana High Court in Brij Mohan Lal Murli Dhar vs Raj
Kishore and Anr (judgment dated 06.03.1959). With due respect, this
court has no hesitation to say that the said judgment has no relevance
to the facts of the instant case. The subject matter in the judgment is a
dispute between the land lord and the tenants in respect of subject
property where the father passed away and his legal heirs sons
contested the matter in respect of rented property. But in the present
case, there are Schedule A, B, C and D properties and the suit has been
decreed in favour of all schedules. Schedule B property is confined to
defendant No.1 and 2 and Schedule C is confined to the appellants
before the lower appellate courts i.e. defendants No 3 and 4.
[19]
It is pertinent to note the defendant No. 1 and 2 Kamaljit
Singh and Chameli Singh respectively have accepted the decree and the
same has not been challenged and accordingly in so far as Schedule B is
concerned, it has become final. Appeal suit has been preferred by
defendant No. 3 and 4 and the same has been allowed by setting aside
the entire decree. When the appellant has right, title and interest only
in respect of the Schedule C property, the lower appellate court cannot
travel beyond the scope of the appeal and set aside the decree in so far
as Schedule A, B, and D is concerned.
In view of the above observation, the order passed by the
lower appellate court is set aside and the appeal is accordingly allowed
as per the observation indicated above.
JUDGE
Dipak
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review