Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I 3448 l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
APPEAL SUIT NO: 7 OF 2023
Appeal under Section 96 of C.P C., against the Judgment and Decree dated
12.1O.2022 passed rn OS No 394 of 2015 on the file of the Court of the Xl Additional
Chief Judge, City Civrl Court at Hyderabad
Between
Smt. Anumandla Lakshmi W/o. Srinivasa Reddy, Aged about 44 Years, Occ
Business. R/o. H No 1-9-295132151A, Flat No 492, Poornima fi/ansion, Street
No.7, Vidya Nagar, t\4asjid Lane, Hyderabad, T.S
...APPELLANT/DEFENDANT
AND
K.Lakshma Reddy, S/o Late Krishna Reddy, Aged aboul T2 Years, R/o. H.No.19-27816212, Balaji Nagar Vidya Nagar, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT/PLAINTIFF
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri. S Bhooma Goud
Counsel for the Respondent: Sri. K Shrikanth
The Court delivered the following: Judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TE LANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDI]I.N RAO
APPEAL SUIT NO.7 OF 2023
DATED: 2r.t JANUARY. 2026
BETWEEN:
Smt.Anumanclla Lakshmi, W/o.Srinivasa Reddy.
Appcll.r rt / l)efenrlan t
AND
K.Lakshma Reddy, S/o.Late Krishna Reddy,
Aged about 72 years, R/ o. H. No. 1-9 27 8 / 62 I 2,
Balaji Nagar, Vidya Nagar, Hyderabad.
Respo : lent/Plaintiff
JUDGMENT
1. This Memorandum of Appeal is filed under jection 96 of
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short 'CpCJ z ssailing the
judgment and decree in OS.No.394 of 2015, date 1 12.10.2022
passed by the XI Additional Chief Judge, Ciry ( r.;il Court ar
Hyderabad.
2.
Appellant is the defendant and rcspondent is re plaintrff in
OS.No.394 of 2015.
I
zl1-5
BRMR,J
AS.No.7-2023
3. I . Respondent-plaintiff has filed suit for specific performance of
Agreeme nt of Sale, dated 25.08 20 l4 and the alternate pralrer is to
direct the appellant-defendant Lo rcfund the amount of Rs 10
Lakhs rvith inrcrest @. 24% pcr 2urnum till the date of realization
and to pay Rs.2 Lakhs tor.r'ards compensation for lhe mental agony'
3.2. lt is stated in the plaint that the appellant-defendant is the
owner and possessor of Flat bearing No 4O2, Poornima Mansion
with Municipal bearing No. 1 9-295l32/51A, Vidya Nagar
Hyderabad, consisting of 830 square feets area along rvith car
parking. Appellant defendant has offered to seil the property to
the respondent-plaintiff lor an amount of Rs 2O Lakhs and
Agreement of Sale is executed on 25 O8-20 l4 Respondent-plaintiff
has paid an amount of Rs l O Lakhs towards part sale
cohsideration on the date ol Agreement of Sale Appellanti
defendant has informed the respondent plaintiff that the property
was mortgaged to one smt.Madhavi and on releasing the same she
will execute the sale deed in favour of a respondent-plaintiff'
Respondent-plaintiff has approached the appellant-defendant on
three occasions but she has postponed the same' Thereafter' he
has got issued a legal notice ort 24'lO'2014 calling the appellant-
defendanttoComeforwardtoexecutetheregisteredsaledeedby
E
I
E
E
a
!l
E
i
receiving the balance sale consideration within 7 days of receipt of
the qstice. As she failed to come fonvard, he filed the suit for
3lrs
BRMR,.I
AS.No 7 2023
specific performance of contract in alternate
r refund the
advanced amount of Rs.10 Lakhs u,ith interest (2. .1 .'r,. frer attnum
and also claimed compensation of Rs.2 Lakhs.
4.
Appellant defendant filed written statemen L
nd contr:nded
that Agreement of Sale dated 25.O8.20I4 is created rr the purpose
o[ the suit and she never entered into agree: cnt with the
res ponden t-plaintiff and there
is no part pa\.mer
I
respondent-plaintiff to the appellant-defendant.
rnacle b-t the
re M.Kr:shna
Reddy and the respondent-plaintiff are doing r roner.- ler-rding
business and running Private Chits, the appellant c t t,:Idant is one
of the subscriber of the said Chits and during the s a c. transaction,
M-Krishna Reddy and the respondent-plaintiff have trtained blank
,
signatures of the appellant-defendant on
non- udicial stamp
papers and also on pro-notes, cheques, white 1r pers tov.'ards
securify of the money transaction. There was excha rge of notices
between the parties. In the year 20 t 4, the marker r z rue of the suit
property is more than Rs.4O Lakhs. Therefore, riL execution of
Agreement of Sale for an amount of Rs.2O Lakhs orL 25.O8.2014 is
not reasonable and prayed to dismiss the suit.
The learned trial Court has framed the follorvirr 1 issues
Whether the plaintiff is entitled lc r specific
performance of agreement of sale, dated I ; 08.2014
agailst the defendant as prayed for?
I
4l7s
Whether the suit agreement was falsely created by the
plaintiff by obtarning the signatures of the defendant
on non-judicial stamp papers and white papers in
connection rr.ith chit transaction?
Whether the suit property rvas unden'alued and the
Court fee is insulficicnt.)
To ri hat relieP
6.
BRMR,J
AS.r"*o.7 2023
Respondent-plaintiff is examined as PW.1 and got marked
Exs.A1 to A6. Exs.B1 and E}2 are marked in the cross of PW.l'
Appellant-defendant is examined as DW 1, got marked trxs.B3 to
86.
7.
The learned trial Court after analvsing the evidence adduced
by the parties has dismissed the suit lor specific performance of
contract and decreed the suit for refund of amount directing the
appellant-defendant to pay an amount of Rs.1O Lakhs with interest
@ 24%o per annum from the date of hling the suit till the date of
realization. Further, the appellant-defendant is also directed to
pay a sum of Rs.2 Lakhs towards damages/ compensation.
8.1. Learned counsel for the appellant-defendan t submits that
the learned trial Court erred in coming to a conclusion that the
respondent-plaintiff proved that he entered into Agreement of Sale
with the appellant-defendant for purchasing the suit schedule
property. In fact, Ex.A1-Agreement of Sale, dated 25.O8.20i4 is not
proved and the respondent-plaintiff failed to examine the attestors
slTs
]JR\,IR,J
AS. No 7 2023
to Ex.Al, no finding is given by the learned trial r)r>urt regarding
I
non-examination of the two attestors. The learned .r irll Court ought
to have seen that Ex.Bl bears the signature ol r re respondcntplaintiff as it u,trs issued by her as a surct.. for thc Chit.
Respondent-plaintiff admitted that Sri Laxmi Nar': r e iah, Ad..,oca[e
has issued legal notice on 31.05.2014 (Ex.82). Resp r.rde n t- pla intilf
admitted that he has not stated specihcally in the tief affidar,it so
-_-
also in the pLaint about the exact date and timo rr ten he paid to
Rs.10 Lakhs to the appeliant-defendant and he [r-u I rer stated rhat
from the years 2013 to 2016 he did not hle ar 1 lncomc Ta-x
returns. Respondent-plaintiff failed to explain in vhal mor]e he
;
i
I
I
!
!
paid Rs. 10 Lakhs to the appellant-defendant.
8.2. The learned trial court has come to a \,trong c tnclusion that
!
:
the appellant defendant is a Law Graduate but shr: r(]\,er discloseci
{
I
I
I
I
I
,
:
t
I
i
the same in her pleadings or in her chief afhdavi t I n fact, she is
studying Lav,'. The learned trial Court erred ir r :oming to a
conclusion that the respondent-plaintiff has lent Rs. lO Lakhs
tou,ards Agreement of Sale and wrongiy directerl he :rppellant_
defendant to return the amount with interest @ 2t )o per annum
with compensation of Rs.2 Lakhs. The learned tria lourt erred in
not deciding issues No.1 to 3 separately issue wis,: Counsel to
substantiate his contention has relied on the decisit r si in the cases
5lls
BRMR,J
AS.No.7-2023
of (1) Thiruvengada Pillai Vs. Navaneethammal and Anotherl,
(2) G.Hanumantu Vs. T.Rajitha Reddy2, (3) Hotel Asrani Pvt. Ltd ,
Secunderabad Vs. Trilok Singh (died) per LR and Another 3 ,
(4) Ganuga Ranganath ar-rd Anothcr Vs. Hotcl Clarudadri (Pl't ) Ltd',
Hindupur, Ananthapur Districtl, (5) B.Kesavalu Vs. M.Ellappans,
(6) S.R.Suresh Vs. Rudrappa Kabbur6 (7) Namboori 'lanaki T
Ramaiah (Died) per LRs Vs. Gurram Hanumantha RaoT'
9. 1. Learned counsel lor the rcspondent-plainlilf submits that thc
learned trial Court has properly appreciated the facts of the case
and rightty decreed the suit for refund ol amount w'ith interest (a',
24o/o per annum and also awarded compensation of Rs 2 Lakhs, no
interference is called for and prayed to dismiss the Appeal
g.2. Respondent-plaintiff has not filed any Appeal agarnst the
rejection of specific perlormance.
10. Counsel on record have [rled their written submissions in
support of their contentions.
11. Heard learned counsel on record, perusedlhe material
AIR 2oo8 sc 1541
'z 2oo5
(3) ALD 211
r zo13 (6) ALD s79 (DB)
o
2018 (3) ALD 40 (DB)
t rqauufrru/ogqg/zozo
' AInoNUNE 2o2o KAR
(rs)
Mss
' zozzl+'l t
7lt5
BRMR,J
.lS.No 7 2023
12. Now the points for consideration are:
Whether the learned trial Court fell ir error in
deciding issues No. I to 3 comprehensrr t l.r, if so?
Whe ther the judgment and decree pzLs,r e cl b1, the
k'arncd trial Court suffers from an]' l),, \'crslty or
illcgatitr ? lf so, does it require inLerfc:-,. ,:,: of Ll-ris
Court or not?
3.
lir u,hat relieP
Point Nos. 1 to 3
i3. Ex.Al js the Agreement of Sale, dated 25.0t.l014 executed
by appellant-dcfcndant in favour of respondent-plai r L.fi rt.hich goes
to show thar [he total sale consideration of 1.1L, Flat Nt>.402
Poornima Mansion, Vidyanagar, Hyderabad is slr r,.r.n as Rs.20
Lakhs and an amoun[ of Rs. 10 Lakhs is paid as a ]vance bv the
vendee to thc vendor. The condition in Ex.A1 i
(respondent-p laintiff) has agreed to
rhar vendec
pay ther tr:rlzrnce sale
consideration of Rs. 1O Lakhs to the vendor at thc time of
regrstration urthin 45 days. Ex.Al further goes to ;norv that the
schedule property covered under Ex.Al is ;-rortgaged to
Smr. M.Madhavi, W/o.Srinivas Reddy for an amount cf Rs.4 Lakhs
whrch amount will be paid by the vendee at the tim<: tf registration
and the balance amount wili be paid to the vendor.
14. Ex.A2 is the legal notice got issued by t.t r responclent_
plaintiff to the appellant-defendant on 24.10.2014 ; a.ting that he
.\
\
I
8/ 15
BRMR,J
AS.No.7_2023
is ready to pay the balance sale consideration and requested her to
come lont ard to receive the amount and register the sale deed
within 7 days of receipt of the notice failing which he will be
constrainecl lo proceed to file the suit. Ex.A3 is tl'rc Postal Rcccipt
and Ex.A4 is the Postal Acknou'ledgment. Ex A5 is the BRS
Regularisation of original paper ol plot No.4O2 and Ex A6 is the car
parking of plot No.4O2.
15.
Exs.B1 and 82 are marked tn the cross-examination of PW I
(respondent-plaintiff). Ex.B1 goes to show thal as on IOth
December, 2013, appellant-defendant is liable to pay chir amount
of Rs.43,5OO/- only which is signed b1- the respondent-plaintiff
Ex. 82 is the legal notice got issued by M. Krishna Reddy to the
appellant-defendant and respondent-plaintiff stating that
appellant-defendant has borrowed Rs.5 Lakhs from him on
15.03.2014 and executed pro-note to that effect and that
respondent-plaintiff stood as surety.
16. The evidence of the respondent-plaintiff is the same n'ith that
of his plaint averments. In his cross-examination he stated that
Ex.BI bears his signature and Krishna Reddy is known to him and
appellant-defendant has subscribed two chits with Krishna Reddy
and she lifted the same and she requested him to stand as surcty
for both the chits and that G. Laxmi Narsaiah, Advocate has got
I]RMR,J
AS.No.7 2023
issuecl legal notice under Ex.B2 dated 31.05.2014 and he was
lorccd to collect the chit amounts from the app: lant-defenclant
when she defaulted. On 10-10.20i4, he demandc( the defenciant
(appcllant herein) to execute sale deed and the lif,: of tu,o chits is
20 months. He got prepared the draft copy of Agr::ment ol Sale
and gave it ro the defcndant (appellant herein) aftr r her approval
he got prepared the fair copy. Witness adds tha t t.he draft u,as
approved bv the defendant after lunch on 25.08.2.(t .1. Ar the. time
of cxccution of trx.A1 two rvitnesses were pres<,tr rvho a csted
Ex.A1-Agreement ol Sale, dated 25.O8.2014 ir r,1 in Ex.A1,
delcndant (appellant herein) is shown as vendor anr] she is cited as
malc person, similarll,he is shown as female persor, u,rtness adds
that it is a typographical mistake. At the time of exr r r-rtion of Ilx.A1
thcre u,as no denomination of Rs.2,000/- and he ha s not filed any
piece of paper to prove his financial capacit5r of pal,ir e Rs. 10 Lakhs
to the defendant (appellant herein) and he is r.: . Income Tax
assessee, he has not filed any Income Tax returns. fur the period
from 2013 to 2016 and the amount of Rs. 1O Lakhs ,l r,:s not belong
to hrm, witness adds that it is of his daughter by r ame pratibha
Redd1, who is 40 years old. PW. 1 denied the suggesti ,n that he has
obtained the signatures of the defendant (appell: -rt herein) on
bond paper and other blank papers and later he gc1 it transferred
them into Ex.A 1 on the plea that he has obtaint.r those blank
"'. \
I
10/ 1s
RRMR,J
AS.No.7 2023
signed papers to be given to M.Krishna Reddy for chit purpose and
utilised them for the purpose of the case. He has lodged a
complaint before P.S. Nallakunta for non-execution of sale deed
against the defendant (appellant herein) and [l-tc polir:c has advised
him to approach the Court. He denied the suggestion that he has
not paid Rs. 10 Lakhs to the defendant (appcllant herein) on the
date of execution of Ex.A1-Agreement of Sale , dated 25.O8.2O14.
17. The evidence of the appellant-defendant is the same with
that of her u,ntten statement. In her cross-examination she stated
that she has no document to show that Lakshma Reddy is doing
Chit business along with Krishna Reddy and shc has Iilted tu o
chits after six months of its subscription which are for an amount
of Rs.S Lakhs each and she has received Rs.3.25 Lakhs from
Krishna Reddy and Lakshma Reddy (respondent- plain tiff) lor one
chit and t:ne 2"d chit lifted by her is in the ninth month of its
subscription and she has received Rs.3,55,OO0/ - and in the 2nd
chit, Lakshma Reddy (respondent-plaintiff) has given suret-v. And
the chits were completed in the year 2014, u'hich u'ere for
20 months @ Rs.25,OO0/- per month for each chit. She gave reply
to Ex.B2-lega1 notice and as per the contents of Ex.B2 she has
taken loan of Rs.5 takhs from Krishna Reddy' She has received the
Iegal notice got issued by respondent-plaintiff under Ex.A2 but she
did lot give any reply. Witness adds that plaintifi himsell stated
('
ru75
BRTlR,J
AS. No.7_2023
that reply is not required and she has not givcr any notice to
return the bond papers nor lodged complaint fo r rrisuse of the
same. She ad mitted rvtth regard to Ex.AS-BRS r.r glulzrrization of
original paper ol plor No.4O2 and trx_A6-car parkir.l :f plot r.r-o.402
and the plaintilt (respondent herein) is retired Gor c r rment servant.
DW. 1 denicd the suggestion that she entered ir) ( Agreement oI
Sale under Ex.Al on 25.Oa.2O14 and she receivecl ls.10 Lakhs as
part sale consideration. She also denied the suggcs ion that she is
Iiablc to execute the salc deed.
18. Learned c'ounsel lor the appel.lant-defenda . - submits the
learned trial Cr>r-rrl ought to have discussed iss,r Lr: Nos. 1 to 3
separately and ought to have given separate findings
19. In G.Hanumanthu2, the High Court observe(l r.hat ,,the trial
Court to deai u.ith issues separately or by clubbi r13 interrelated
issues, lraming several issues and dealing wilh t]r::rr together is
not proper".
20. Issue No. I framed by the learned trial Court is rvith regard to
the entitlement of specific performance of cor tract by the
respondent-plaintiff and issue No.2 is with regar<l c whether the
suit agreement was created by the responcl()j rt.-plaintiff by
obtaining the signatures of appellant-defendant ,r r non-judicial
s
tadlp paper and whitc papers in connection with (: Lit transaction
i
tzlts
BRMR,J
AS.No.7 2023
and issue No.3 is q,ith regard to the undervaluation of the suit. The
learned trial Court thought it ht that issues No. 1 to 3 are
interrelated and dealt u'ith them logether holding that the issues
are interrelated with each other. This Court finds that thc learned
trial Court has rightly thought it ht to club all the issues together
as they are interrelated rvith each other and rightly discussed
them.
2 i. 1. Plaintiffs came to Court alleging that the first defendant had
executed an Agreement of Sale in his favour. The first defendant
having denied it, the burden was on the plaintiff to prove that the
first defendant had executed the agreement and not on the hrst
defendant to prove the negative. The issues also placed the burden
on the plantiff to prove the document to be true : See Thiruvengada
Pillai1. The same view is followed in S.R.Suresh6.
21 .2. In Hotel Asrani Pvt. Ltd.3, the High Court has reduced the
interest rate from 24%o per annum to l2ok per annum in granting
the decree for relund of amount. The same view is taken in Ganuga
Ranganath and anothera, B.Keshavulus, Namboori Janaki
T.RamaiaT.
22. It is the defence of the appellant-defendant that respondentplaintiff and Krishna Reddy have obtained her signatures on b/ank
t
I
I
I
t3lts
BRMR,.I
AS.No.7 2023
whlte paper, bond papers, pro-notes and also oblei-red cheques as
a security towards the money transaction.
Burden is placed on the appeilant-defenda r t in respect of
Issue No.2. If really the appellant-defendant has ,igned on non-
judicial stamp paper, dehnitely she would have gir-r rr notice to the
re spondent-plaintiff and M.Krishna Reddy to nr>
to misuse the
same. Respondent-plaintiff has got issued Ex.A2-1e5 al notice to the
appellant-defendant u'hich is received by her under Ex.A4.
Furthermore, she also admitted in her cross-exami;r rtion about the
receipt of legal notice got issued by respondent - claintiff under
Ex.A2. Appellant-defendant failed to give reply to tr:< lL2-1egal notice
dated 24.IO.2014 nor gave any explanation why slL has not given
any reply to Ex.A2, but went on to say that the resp, ,ndent-plaintiff
haB informed her not to give any reply. A suggt,r tion is put to
respondent,plaintiff in the cross-examination that -t : has obtained
the signatures of appellant-defendant on one bond c .lper and other
blank papers and later got it transformed into Ex..a 1 . The learned
trial Court rightly arrived at a conclusion that sin: : the schedule
property is already mortgaged with Smt.Mandad. Ivladhavi, has
:
I
rightly decreed the suit for return of Rs. 1O
I
respondent-plaintiff.
t
,,akhs to the
I
L
141ls
RRMR,J
AS.No.7 2023
23. In so far as interest part is concerned, learned trial Court
has directed the appellant defendant to pay Rs.10 Lakhs with
interest (a',,24ok per annum from the date of filing the suit till the
date of realizatiorr. Awarding of interest @,24% per annum is on a
l-righer side and the decisions cited by the appellant counsel in
Hotel Asrani Pvt. Ltd.3, Ganuga Ranganath+, B.Keshavulus,
Namboori Janaki T. RamaiaT are applicable to the case on hand
hence, this Court is of the vier,"' that interest awarded by the
learned trial Court @ 24% per annum from the date of Iiling the
suit till rhe date ol realizalion has to be reduced @ 12% per annum
from the date of Iiling the suit till the date of decree and thereafter
l
i
@ 60/o per annum from the date of decree tili realization.
I
I
I
I
i
I
!
I
i
i
I
I
I
I
I
24. lnsofar as claim of damages/compensation of Rs.2 Lakhs is
concerned, respondent-plaintiff has not claimed any compensation
in trx.A2-legal notice, dated 24.1O.2O14. Furthermore, there is no
pleading in the plaint for claiming damages/compensation of
Rs.2 Lakhs except in the prayer portion. Respondent-plaintiff has
i
I
!
I
I
not adduced any evidence to that effect. Hence, the observation of
I
I
I
the learned trial Court with regard to
II
damages/compensation of Rs.2 Lakhs to the respondent-plaintiff is
awarding
ti
I
i
i
not based with any evidence on record. Hence, the same i2 [aqle to
be set asrde.
I
BRMR,J
1s/1s
AS.No.7 2023
25. The decision cited by the appellant counse in Tiruvengada
II
Pillail and S.R.Suresh6 are not applicable to the r:ir ,t: on hand and
E
I
i
the ratio of those cases would not apply to the presc rt ca se.
26. [n vieu'of the reasons above, the appeal is ;t L:tly'allorved to
the extent of reducing the rate of interest from 21) per annum to
l2o/o per arinum from the date of Iiling the surt
,ill the date of
decree thereatter @1 6% per annum from the dat : of decree till
realization and the damages/ compensation awardec by the learned
trial Court of Rs.2 Lakhs is also set aside.
27. ln the result, Appeal is partly allowed. Th,: judgment and
decree passed by the learned Xl Additional Chief .I rCge, Cit_v Civil
Court, Hyderabad in OS No.394 of 2015, datecl 12.10.2022 is
confirmed in respect of return of refund of Rs.1O I akhs. In terest
part of 24%o per annum is scaled down to l2ok per a rnum from the
date of hling the suit till the date of decree and the -, tLfter @ 6%o pet
annum from the date of decree till the date of realization.
Damages/compensation of Rs.2 Lakhs granted b1- t r,: learned trial
Court is also set aside. Parties to bear their own cor; S.
Interim Orders if any stands vacated. Miscellaneous
application/ s stands closed.
D/. t\I RAMANA KRISHN
JOt
AR
/
U 1WE
blY v
SECTION O FFICER
To
The XlAdditional Chief Judge, City Civil Court
at Hyder: rad
9n" 99 to SRI S Bhooma"Goud'A;r;";6ibluii'
9n" 99 to SRt K Shrikanth. AJ;;.ri; topu
Two CD Copies
Mi
'?aps
I
I
,//
)
HIGH COURT
DATED:21 10112026
."1 :,'r,L ) ir'.it
,4
t'
JUDGMENT+DECREE
AS.No.7 of 2023
PARTLY ALLOWING THE APPEAL
n(
0,
i
v
2 0 f EB 202[ ',*
it :
.\
\1- )
\'
\
t.
+,
j
\
r,()
\:
+
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE B.R.MADHUSUDHAN RAO
'
APPEAL SUIT NO: 7 OF 2023
Between
Smt. Anumandla Lakshmr, Wo. Srinivasa Reddy, Aged about 44 Years, Occ.
Business, R/o, H No. 1-9-295132151A, Flat No.492, Poornima [t/ansion, Street
No.7, Vidya Nagar, Masjid Lane, Hyderabad, T.S.
..:APPELLANT/DEFENDANT
AND
K.Lakshma Reddy, S/o- Late Krishna Reddy, Aged aboulT2 Years, R/o. H.No-19-27816212, Balaji Nagar. Vidya Nagar, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT/PLAINTI FF
Appeal under Section 96 of C.P.C., against the Judgment and Decree dated
12.10.2022 passed in oS No. 394 of 2015 on the file of the court of the Xl Additional
Chief Judge, City Civil Court at Hyderabad.
This appeal coming on for hearing and upon perusing the grounds of
appeal, the Judgment and Decree of the Court below and the material papers in
the IVVOP and upon hearing the arguments of Sri. S Bhooma Goud, Advocate for
the Appellant and Sri. K Shrikanth, Advocate for the Respondent.
This Court doth Order and Decree as follows:
'1
. That this Appeal suit be and hereby is partly allowed.
2. Thal the judgment and decree passed by the learned Xl Additional Chief
Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad in OS.No. 394 of 2015, dated
12.10.2022 is confirmed in respect of return of refund of Rs.10 Lakhs;
3. That the lnterest parl of 24o/o per annum be and hereby is scaled down to
12% per annum from the date of filing the suit trll the date of decree and
thereafter @ 6Yo per annum from the date of decree till the date of
realization;
4. That the damagesi compensation of Rs.2 Lakhs granted by the learned trial
Court is also set aside;
:.ritr
5. That the parties to bear their own costs;
6. That save as aforesaid, the decree of the Tribunal s I al{ stands confirmed
in all other respects.
SD/- I\I IIAMANA KRISHNA
,JOINT REGISTRAR -//TRUE COPY'
i \_--_._-ISECTION OFFICER
To
1. The Xl Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court at Hyder; rad
2. Iwo CD Copies
PrlPSL
w
HIGH COURT
DATED:21 10112026
DECREE
AS.No.7 of 2023
PARTLY ALLOWING THE APPEAL
v
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review