Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010418622023
2026:CGHC:28973-DB
AFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
FA(MAT) No. 15 of 2024
Smt. Anita Yadav W/o Shri Prakash Narayan Yadav Aged About 47 Years
Caste- Yadav, R/o Near Netaji Chowk, Janjgir, Ps And Tehsil- Janjgir, DisttJanjgir- Chama, Cg
--- Appellant
versus
Prakash Narayan Yadav S/o Shri Harnayan Yadav Aged About 49 Years
Caste- Yadav, R/o Near Netaji Chowk, Janjgir, Ps And Tehsil- Janjgir,, District
: Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh
--- Respondent
FA(MAT) No. 338 of 2023
Prakash Narayan Yadav S/o Harnarayan Yadav Aged About 47 Years Caste
Yadav, R/o Village Near Etaji Chowk, Janjgir, Police Station And Tahsil
Janjgir Janjgir, District : Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh
---Appellant
Versus
Smt. Anita Yadav W/o Prakash Narayan Yadav, Aged About 43 Years Caste
Yadav, R/o Infront Of J.K. Jwellers Janjgir, Police Station And Tahsil Janjgir
Janjgir, District : Janjgir-Champa, Chhattisgarh
---- Respondent
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
Digitally signed
by BALRAM
PRASAD
DEWANGAN
For Appellant
(In FA(MAT) No.15 of 2024 &
For Res. In FA(MAT) No. 338 of 2023)
: Mr. J.K. Gupta, Advocate
For Respondent
: Mr. D.N. Prajapati, Advocate
(In FA(MAT) No.15 of 2024 &
For Appellant. In FA(MAT) No. 338 of 2023)
Division Bench
Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
Hon'ble Shri Sachin Singh Rajput, Judge
Judgment On Board
(08.07.2026)
Per Parth Prateem Sahu, J.
1.
As both the above appeals arise out of the common judgment and
decree dated 06.11.2023 passed in Civil Suit No. 66-A/2022 by
Principal Judge, Family Court, Janjgir, District Janjgir-Champa,
Accordingly, they are heard together and are being decided by this
common judgment.
2.
FA (MAT) No. 15 of 2024 is filed by wife questioning the decree of
divorce granted in favour of husband and FA (MAT) No.338 of 2023 is
filed by husband against the direction to deposit a sum of
Rs.10,00,000/- towards permanent alimony as also to pay monthly
maintenance of Rs.10,000/- to wife.
3.
The facts relevant for disposal of these appeals are that a suit under
Section 13 (1) (a) of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 (In short ‘the Act of
1955’) was filed by the applicant-husband against the non-applicantwife seeking a decree for dissolution of the marriage solemnized
between the parties on the ground of physical and mental cruelty and
harassment pleading therein that marriage of respondent-plaintiff was
solemnized with applicant on 12.05.1997 as per Hindu rites and rituals
at village – Tundra. After solemnization of marriage, applicant and nonapplicant resided together as husband and wife and led a happy
married life for a period of approximately 16 years. During the said
period, two daughters and one son were born out of the said wedlock.
It was pleaded that matrimonial relationship between applicant and
non-applicant became bitter after applicant-husband was posted at
Malkharoda in the year 2012. Non-applicant-wife frequently quarreled
with applicant-husband over trivial issues and by the year 2015, the
parties had ceased to live together as husband and wife. During his
posting at Baloda in the year 2017, applicant came to know that nonapplicant-wife had, without informing applicant, obtained an ATM card
and is withdrawing money from his bank account. When the said fact
was enquired, non-applicant started abusing him and stopped
preparing food for him. It was further pleaded that, whenever applicant
returned home from work, non-applicant used to lock the door from
inside, as a result of which he was compelled to reside at Janjgir..
Non-applicant started living separately from February, 2017. It was
also pleaded that despite separation, applicant has purchased land in
the name of non-applicant and is fulfilling all the matrimonial
obligations. His son and non-applicant assaulted him, his mother and
vandalized household items. Non-applicant is very cruel and
aggressive woman. When applicant was assaulted by non-applicant,
her uncle and nephew intervened. On the basis of complaint of
applicant, a FIR/crime was registered against non-applicant, and the
case is pending before the Court. Applicant has been residing
separately for the last five years, and there is no possibility of them
living together as husband and wife.
4.
Defendant/wife
filed
written
statement/reply
denying
the
averments/allegation made in the plaint. It was pleaded that the
applicant-husband himself created such circumstances that it has
become impossible for her to reside with him. Applicant unnecessarily
harassing her and wants to leave her and marry another woman. She
prays for dismissal of suit filed by applicant.
5.
Learned Family Court based on the pleadings made by respective
parties has formulated as many as three issues for consideration and
upon considering the evidence brought in record by the respective
parties, has allowed the suit/application filed by applicant-husband by
the impugned judgment and decree granting decree of divorce in
favour of applicant-husband on the ground of cruelty.
6.
Learned counsel for appellant/wife (in FA (MAT) No. 15 of 2024) would
submit that learned Family Court fell into error in allowing the suit filed
by applicant -husband without appreciating the evidence brought in
record by the parties in appropriate manner. It is contended that
appellant has always been ready and willing to reside with the
respondent-husband along with her children. However, it is the
respondent-husband who does not wish to reside with appellant. It is
next contended that respondent-husband with intention of marrying
another woman, has made false allegations against appellant and
created such circumstances. Appellant-wife has never left the
respondent-husband and always ready and willing to lead a
matrimonial life with him. It is contended that specific ground of
desertion and irretrievable breakdown of marriage were neither
pleaded in the plaint nor established by the respondent-husband
through cogent and reliable evidence. The finding recorded by the
learned Family Court is based on conjectures and surmises. It is next
contended that respondent-husband has failed to establish any act of
physical or mental cruelty on the part of the wife. It is contended that
the instances or incidents pleaded by respondent-husband do not
constitute physical or mental cruelty in the eyes of law. The allegations
are vague and unsupported by cogent evidence, therefore, cannot be
relied upon to establish cruelty for grant of decree of divorce. To
buttress his submission, learned counsel for appellant has placed
reliance upon the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of N.G.
Dastane (Dr) v. S. Dastane, (1975) 2 SCC 326, A. Jayachandra Vs.
Aneel Kaur, (2005) 2 SCC 22, Samar Ghosh v. Jaya Ghosh, (2007)
4 SCC 511, in case of Gurbux Singh Vs. Harminder Kaur, reported
in (2010) 14 SCC 301, and in case of Joydeep Majumdar Vs. Bharti
Jaiswal Majumdar (2021) 3 SCC 742 and prays that the appeal be
allowed and the impugned judgment and decree passed by learned
Family Court be set aside
7.
Learned counsel for respondent-husband opposes the grounds raised
in appeal and the submission made by learned counsel for appellant
and supports the impugned judgment and decree. It is contended that
allegation levelled against respondent-husband is false and baseless.
On the basis of the documentary and oral evidence brought on record
before the learned Family Court, it has been duly established that the
respondent-husband was subjected to cruelty by the appellant/wife. It
is further contended that evidence adduced by respondent, both oral
and documentary, clearly reflects the conduct and acts of the appellant
which caused mental agony and hardship to the appellant, therefore,
constituted cruelty within the meaning of law. He further submitted that
the testimony of the appellant remained consistent, reliable and
sufficiently proved the allegations of cruelty levelled against the
respondent/wife. Learned Family Court after proper appreciation of
documentary and oral evidence brought in record by the respective
parties has rightly come to the conclusion that the respondenthusband has made out a case for grant of decree of divorce on the
ground of cruelty, which does not call for any interference. However,
he submits that the conditions imposed by the learned Family Court,
directing him to deposit an amount of Rs.10.00 lakhs towards
permanent alimony and to pay a sum of Rs.10,000/- per month as
maintenance are arbitrary. He, therefore, prays for setting aside the
aforesaid conditions imposed by the learned Family Court while
maintaining the decree of divorce.
8.
We have heard learned counsel for parties and perused the
documents placed on record.
9.
The marriage between the parties and the fact that they shared more
than 16 years of matrimonial relationship, during which two daughters
and one son, were born out of the wedlock, are not in dispute. It is also
undisputed that the parties lived together as husband and wife for a
considerable period and maintained a harmonious matrimonial
relationship for several years before differences arose between them.
From perusal of the pleadings made in the application under Section
13 of the Hindu Marriage Act would reveal that the dispute between
the parties started in or around the year 2014, when the respondenthusband was posted at Malkharoda. Respondent-husband filed an
application U/s. 13 (1) (a) of the Act of 1955 seeking decree of divorce
on the ground of physical and mental cruelty allegedly caused by
appellant-wife.
10.
In order to examine allegation of cruelty, principles laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Samar Ghosh (supra), would be a
relevant guideline wherein the Court has indicated certain illustrative
instances at para 101 whereby the inference of mental cruelty can be
drawn. Para 101 reads as under :“101. No uniform standard can ever be laid down for
guidance, yet we deem it appropriate to enumerate some
instances of human behaviour which may be relevant in
dealing with the cases of “mental cruelty”. The instances
indicated in the succeeding paragraphs are only
illustrative and not exhaustive:
(i) On consideration of complete matrimonial life of
the parties, acute mental pain, agony and suffering
as would not make possible for the parties to live
with each other could come within the broad
parameters of mental cruelty.
(ii) On comprehensive appraisal of the entire
matrimonial
life
of
the
parties,
it
becomes
abundantly clear that situation is such that the
wronged party cannot reasonably be asked to put
up with such conduct and continue to live with
other party.
(iii) Mere coldness or lack of affection cannot
amount to cruelty, frequent rudeness of language,
petulance of manner, indifference and neglect may
reach such a degree that it makes the married life
for the other spouse absolutely intolerable.
(iv) Mental cruelty is a state of mind. The feeling of
deep anguish, disappointment, frustration in one
spouse caused by the conduct of other for a long
time may lead to mental cruelty.
(v) A sustained course of abusive and humiliating
treatment calculated to torture, discommode or
render miserable life of the spouse.
(vi) Sustained unjustifiable conduct and behaviour
of one spouse actually affecting physical and
mental health of the other spouse. The treatment
complained of and the resultant danger or
apprehension must be very grave, substantial and
weighty.
(vii) Sustained reprehensible conduct, studied
neglect, indifference or total departure from the
normal standard of conjugal kindness causing
injury to mental health or deriving sadistic pleasure
can also amount to mental cruelty.
(viii) The conduct must be much more than
jealousy,
selfishness,
causes
unhappiness
possessiveness,
and
dissatisfaction
which
and
emotional upset may not be a ground for grant of
divorce on the ground of mental cruelty.
(ix) Mere trivial irritations, quarrels, normal wear
and tear of the married life which happens in dayto-day life would not be adequate for grant of
divorce on the ground of mental cruelty.
(x) The married life should be reviewed as a whole
and a few isolated instances over a period of years
will not amount to cruelty. The ill conduct must be
persistent for a fairly lengthy period, where the
relationship has deteriorated to an extent that
because of the acts and behaviour of a spouse, the
wronged party finds it extremely difficult to live with
the other party any longer, may amount to mental
cruelty.
(xi) If a husband submits himself for an operation of
sterilisation without medical reasons and without
the consent or knowledge of his wife and similarly,
if the wife undergoes vasectomy or abortion
without medical reason or without the consent or
knowledge of her husband, such an act of the
spouse may lead to mental cruelty.
(xii)
Unilateral
decision
of
refusal
to
have
intercourse for considerable period without there
being any physical incapacity or valid reason may
amount to mental cruelty.
(xiii) Unilateral decision of either husband or wife
after marriage not to have child from the marriage
may amount to cruelty.
(xiv) Where there has been a long period of
continuous separation, it may fairly be concluded
that the matrimonial bond is beyond repair. The
marriage becomes a fiction though supported by a
legal tie. By refusing to sever that tie, the law in
such cases, does not serve the sanctity of
marriage; on the contrary, it shows scant regard for
the feelings and emotions of the parties. In such
like situations, it may lead to mental cruelty.
11.
Case of the respondent-husband seeking a decree of divorce on the
ground of physical and mental cruelty has to be examined in the light
of the aforesaid principles and guidelines laid down by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court. The allegations made, evidence produced, and
circumstances brought on record by the respondent-husband are
required to be considered to determine whether the grounds pleaded
by the respondent-husband are proved in accordance with law.
12.
Applicant-husband to prove his case examined himself as (P.W.-1) and
placed on record various documents of criminal complaint case filed
by Bishnu Bai (mother) against her daughter-in-law (non-applicant)
and grand son. He deposed in his evidence as per the plaint
averments. He stated that, after his transfer from Malkharouda to
Baloda in the year 2017, he resided in a rented house situated on
Budgahan Road. He stated that non-applicant -wife secretly obtained
ATM card of his salary account and withdrew money without his
knowledge or consent and when he came to know about withdrawals
and questioned his wife, she started abusing and physically assaulted
him, stopped communicating with him, and refused to prepare meals
for him. He further deposed that when he used to return back from
work, his wife used to lock the door of the house due to which,
respondent had to stay out of the house. Due to this act of his wife, he
got upset and came to Janjgir and started doing his duty from there.
He further stated that his office colleagues made efforts to counsel his
wife in order to resolve the matrimonial dispute; however, she refused
to accept their advice or counselling. He also deposed that, while they
were residing at Janjgir, the non-applicant wife threw his belongings
out of the house, physically assaulted him, and abused him by stating
that, "from today, you are dead to me." He further stated that she
broke her bangles and wiped off the vermilion from her forehead. It
was also stated that, thereafter parties started living separately. Nonapplicant-wife, along with Tushar, assaulted applicant-husband and his
mother on several occasions. In cross-examination, he admitted that
he has not lodged any report against wife. He also admitted that he
and his wife spent more than 16 years of happy matrimonial
relationship. In his cross-examination, he stated that the dispute
between the parties arose on account of the ATM card, alleging that
the non-applicant-wife had secretly obtained the ATM card of his salary
account without his knowledge and withdrew money. He admitted that
he has not lodged any report against wife obtaining ATM and
withdrawal of money by her. However, he voluntarily stated that he
filed a complaint before the Bank, but he has not placed on record the
copy of complaint made to the Bank. In cross-examination, he further
admitted that he has not lodged any report against non-applicant-wife
for assaulting him, for stealing household articles and of causing
damage to the house hold articles.
13.
Bishnu Bai (P.W.-3), mother of applicant-husband has also deposed in
her examination-in-chief, in accordance with version of applicant
regarding minor incidents that occurred between applicant and nonapplicant as also with regard to matrimonial disputes between them. In
her cross-examination, she clearly admitted that her son had not made
any report to the police regarding quarrel that had taken place
between her daughter-in-law and her son. She stated that she had
lodged report about disputes between applicant - non-applicant to the
police station on three occasions and thereafter, she stated that she
had lodged police report against her daughter-in-law and her grandson
alleging that they had assaulted her. In paragraph 13 of her crossexamination, she categorically admitted that neither her daughter-inlaw nor her grandson had assaulted her son i.e. the applicant.
14.
Yash Kumar Ogre (P.W.-2) has stated in his examination-in-chief that
one day he went to the house of applicant and found applicant
standing outside the house and the house was locked from inside and
upon asking he was informed by applicant that he has no talk with his
wife and she has locked the house from inside. He was also informed
that they have no relation as husband and wife and his wife used to
abuse and assault him. He was also informed about secretly obtaining
of ATM card and withdrawing money by his wife. He further stated that
he was informed by applicant - husband that at Janjgir, his wife threw
his belongings and committed marpit. In cross-examination, this
witness admitted that he had not personally witnessed the nonapplicant -wife abusing or assaulting applicant-husband. He further
admitted that he had not seen the non-applicant
wiping off her
vermilion or breaking her bangles. The witness also deposed that nonapplicant-wife wiping off her vermilion, locking the door, abusing, and
assaulting the applicant was based solely on what had been narrated
to him by the applicant-husband.
15.
Non-applicant-wife examined herself as NAW-1 and deposed that
applicant-husband had subjected her and her children to physical and
mental cruelty. She further stated that applicant himself created such
circumstances that she became distressed by his conduct and leave
him. She also deposed that the applicant, under the influence of his
mother, frequently abused her and her children on petty grounds. She
further deposed that the applicant-husband, without any justifiable
reason, wanted to leave her and marry another woman. Her mother-inlaw was an old aged lady and non-applicant-wife herself performed all
household works. She further stated that she wishes to reside with her
husband and continue her matrimonial life. In her cross-examination,
she denied all the adverse suggestion given to her by applicant. She
also denied the suggestion that she used to lock the door of house
when applicant returned home from work and would not open it even
after he called her. She further denied that she had not maintained
matrimonial relations with the applicant since 2015. In paragraph 16 of
her cross-examination, she also denied the suggestion given by
applicant that she had withdrawn money using the applicant's ATM
card without his knowledge.
16.
Hon’ble Supreme in case of N.G. Dastane (Dr) v. S. Dastane, (1975)
2 SCC 326, has considered the ground of mental cruelty and observed
thus :“30. An awareness of foreign decisions could be a
useful asset in interpreting our own laws. But it has to
be remembered that we have to interpret in this case a
specific provision of a specific enactment, namely,
Section 10(1)(b) of the Act. What constitutes cruelty
must depend upon the terms of this statute which
provides:
“10. (1) Either party to a marriage, whether
solemnized before or after the commencement of
this Act, may present a petition to the District Court
praying for a decree for judicial separation on the
ground that the other party—
(b) has treated the petitioner with such cruelty as to
cause a reasonable apprehension in the mind of the
petitioner that it will be harmful or injurious for the
petitioner to live with the other party;”
The inquiry therefore has to be whether the conduct
charged as cruelty is of such a character as to cause in
the mind of the petitioner a reasonable apprehension
that it will be harmful or injurious for him to live with the
respondent. It is not necessary, as under the English
law, that the cruelty must be of such a character as to
cause “danger” to life, limb or health or as to give rise to
a reasonable apprehension of such a danger. Clearly,
danger to life, limb or health or a reasonable
apprehension of it is a higher requirement than a
reasonable apprehension that it is harmful or injurious
for one spouse to live with the other.
****
46. In regard to the conduct of the respondent as
reflected in her admissions, two contentions raised on
her behalf must be considered. It is urged in the first
place that the various letters containing admissions
were written by her under coercion. There is no
substance in this contention. In her written statement,
the respondent alleged that the appellant's parents had
coerced her into writing the letters. At the trial she
shifted her ground and said that the coercion proceeded
from the appellant himself. That apart, at a time when
the marriage had gone as under and the respondent
sent to the appellant formal letters resembling a
lawyer's notice, some of them by registered post, no
allegation was made that the appellant or his parents
had obtained written admissions from her. Attention
may be drawn in this behalf to the letters Exs. 299 and
314 dated March 23 and May 6, 1961 or to the
elaborate complaint Ex. 318 dated May 19, 1961 which
she made to the Secretary to the Government of India,
Ministry of Food and Agriculture. Prior to that, on
September 23, 1960 she had drawn up a list of her
complaints (Ex. 424) which begins by saying: “He has
oppressed me in numerous ways like the following”. But
she does not speak therein of any admission or writing
having been obtained from her. Further, letters like Exs.
271 and 272 dated respectively June 23 and July 10,
1960 which besides containing admissions on her part
also contain allegations against the appellant could
certainly not have been obtained by coercion. Finally,
considering that the respondent was always surrounded
by a group of relatives who had assumed the role of
marriage-counsellors, it is unlikely that any attempt to
coerce her into making admissions would have been
allowed to escape unrecorded. After all, the group here
consists of greedy letter-writers.
17.
In case of V. Bhagat v. D. Bhagat, (1994) 1 SCC 337, Hon’ble
Supreme Court while dealing with the issue of mental cruelty has
observed as under :“16. Mental cruelty in Section 13(1)(i-a) can broadly be
defined as that conduct which inflicts upon the other party
such mental pain and suffering as would make it not
possible for that party to live with the other. In other words,
mental cruelty must be of such a nature that the parties
cannot reasonably be expected to live together. The
situation must be such that the wronged party cannot
reasonably be asked to put up with such conduct and
continue to live with the other party. It is not necessary to
prove that the mental cruelty is such as to cause injury to
the health of the petitioner. While arriving at such
conclusion, regard must be had to the social status,
educational level of the parties, the society they move in,
the possibility or otherwise of the parties ever living
together in case they are already living apart and all other
relevant facts and circumstances which it is neither
possible nor desirable to set out exhaustively. What is
cruelty in one case may not amount to cruelty in another
case. It is a matter to be determined in each case having
regard to the facts and circumstances of that case. If it is a
case of accusations and allegations, regard must also be
had to the context in which they were made.”
(Emphasis supplied)
18.
In case of A. Jayachandra v. Aneel Kaur, (2005) 2 SCC 22, Hon’ble
Supreme Court, while dealing with the issue, has observed as under :“10. The expression “cruelty” has not been defined in
the Act. Cruelty can be physical or mental. Cruelty
which is a ground for dissolution of marriage may be
defined as wilful and unjustifiable conduct of such
character as to cause danger to life, limb or health,
bodily or mental, or as to give rise to a reasonable
apprehension of such a danger. The question of mental
cruelty has to be considered in the light of the norms of
marital ties of the particular society to which the parties
belong, their social values, status, environment in which
they live. Cruelty, as noted above, includes mental
cruelty, which falls within the purview of a matrimonial
wrong. Cruelty need not be physical. If from the conduct
of the spouse same is established and/or an inference
can be legitimately drawn that the treatment of the
spouse is such that it causes an apprehension in the
mind of the other spouse, about his or her mental
welfare then this conduct amounts to cruelty. In a
delicate human relationship like matrimony, one has to
see the probabilities of the case. The concept, proof
beyond the shadow of doubt, is to be applied to criminal
trials and not to civil matters and certainly not to matters
of such delicate personal relationship as those of
husband and wife. Therefore, one has to see what are
the probabilities in a case and legal cruelty has to be
found out, not merely as a matter of fact, but as the
effect on the mind of the complainant spouse because
of the acts or omissions of the other. Cruelty may be
physical or corporeal or may be mental. In physical
cruelty, there can be tangible and direct evidence, but in
the case of mental cruelty there may not at the same
time be direct evidence. In cases where there is no
direct evidence, courts are required to probe into the
mental process and mental effect of incidents that are
brought out in evidence. It is in this view that one has to
consider the evidence in matrimonial disputes.
11. The expression “cruelty” has been used in relation
to human conduct or human behaviour. It is the conduct
in relation to or in respect of matrimonial duties and
obligations. Cruelty is a course or conduct of one, which
is adversely affecting the other. The cruelty may be
mental or physical, intentional or unintentional. If it is
physical, the court will have no problem in determining
it. It is a question of fact and degree. If it is mental, the
problem presents difficulties. First, the enquiry must
begin as to the nature of cruel treatment, second the
impact of such treatment in the mind of the spouse,
whether it caused reasonable apprehension that it
would be harmful or injurious to live with the other.
Ultimately, it is a matter of inference to be drawn by
taking into account the nature of the conduct and its
effect on the complaining spouse. However, there may
be a case where the conduct complained of itself is bad
enough and per se unlawful or illegal. Then the impact
or injurious effect on the other spouse need not be
enquired into or considered. In such cases, the cruelty
will be established if the conduct itself is proved or
admitted. (See Shobha Rani v. Madhukar Reddi [(1988)
1 SCC 105 : 1988 SCC (Cri) 60 : AIR 1988 SC 121] .)
12. To constitute cruelty, the conduct complained of
should be “grave and weighty” so as to come to the
conclusion that the petitioner spouse cannot be
reasonably expected to live with the other spouse. It
must be something more serious than “ordinary wear
and tear of married life”. The conduct, taking into
consideration the circumstances and background has to
be examined to reach the conclusion whether the
conduct complained of amounts to cruelty in the
matrimonial law. Conduct has to be considered, as
noted above, in the background of several factors such
as social status of parties, their education, physical and
mental conditions, customs and traditions. It is difficult
to lay down a precise definition or to give exhaustive
description
of
the
circumstances,
which
would
constitute cruelty. It must be of the type as to satisfy the
conscience of the court that the relationship between
the parties had deteriorated to such an extent due to
the conduct of the other spouse that it would be
impossible for them to live together without mental
agony, torture or distress, to entitle the complaining
spouse to secure divorce. Physical violence is not
absolutely
essential
to
constitute
cruelty
and
a
consistent course of conduct inflicting immeasurable
mental agony and torture may well constitute cruelty
within the meaning of Section 10 of the Act. Mental
cruelty may consist of verbal abuses and insults by
using filthy and abusive language leading to constant
disturbance of mental peace of the other party.
13. The court dealing with the petition for divorce on the
ground of cruelty has to bear in mind that the problems
before it are those of human beings and the
psychological changes in a spouse's conduct have to
be borne in mind before disposing of the petition for
divorce. However insignificant or trifling, such conduct
may cause pain in the mind of another. But before the
conduct can be called cruelty, it must touch a certain
pitch of severity. It is for the court to weigh the gravity. It
has to be seen whether the conduct was such that no
reasonable person would tolerate it. It has to be
considered whether the complainant should be called
upon to endure as a art of normal human life. Every
matrimonial conduct, which may cause annoyance to
the other, may not amount to cruelty. Mere trivial
irritations, quarrels between spouses, which happen in
day-to-day married life, may also not amount to cruelty.
Cruelty in matrimonial life may be of unfounded variety,
which can be subtle or brutal. It may be words, gestures
or by mere silence, violent or non-violent.
14. The foundation of a sound marriage is tolerance,
adjustment and respecting one another. Tolerance to
each other's fault to a certain bearable extent has to be
inherent in every marriage. Petty quibbles, trifling
differences should not be exaggerated and magnified to
destroy what is said to have been made in heaven. All
quarrels must be weighed from that point of view in
determining what constitutes cruelty in each particular
case and as noted above, always keeping in view the
physical and mental conditions of the parties, their
character and social status. A too technical and
hypersensitive approach would be counterproductive to
the institution of marriage. The courts do not have to
deal with ideal husbands and ideal wives. It has to deal
with a particular man and woman before it. The ideal
couple or a mere ideal one will probably have no
occasion to go to Matrimonial Court. [See N.G. Dastane
(Dr.) v. S. Dastane [(1975) 2 SCC 326 : AIR 1975 SC
1534] .]
19.
In case of Naveen Kohli v. Neelu Kohli, (2006) 4 SCC 558, Hon’ble
Supreme Court examined the concept of cruelty and observed thus :“38. D. Tolstoy in his celebrated book The Law and
Practice of Divorce and Matrimonial Causes, (6th Edn.,
p. 61) defined cruelty in these words:
“Cruelty which is a ground for dissolution of
marriage
may
be
defined
as
wilful
and
unjustifiable conduct of such a character as to
cause danger to life, limb or health, bodily or
mental, or as to give rise to a reasonable
apprehension of such a danger.”
39. The concept of cruelty in matrimonial matters was
aptly discussed in the English case in Bertram v.
Bertram [1944 P 59 : 113 LJP 52 : 171 LT 167 (CA)] (P
at p. 60) per Scott, L.J. observed:
“Very slight fresh evidence is needed to show a
resumption of the cruelty, for cruelty of character
is bound to show itself in conduct and behaviour.
Day in and day out, night in and night out.”
40. In Cooper v. Cooper [1950 WN 200 : 48 LGR 377
(HL)] it was observed as under:
“It is true that the more serious the original
offence, the less grave need be the subsequent
acts to constitute a revival.”
41. Lord Denning, L.J. in Kaslefsky v. Kaslefsky [(1950)
2 All ER 398 : 1951 P 38 (CA)] (All ER at p. 403 H)
observed as under:
“If the door of cruelty were opened too wide, we
should soon find ourselves granting divorce for
incompatibility of temperament. This is an easy
path to tread, especially in undefended cases.
The temptation must be resisted lest we slip into
a state of affairs where the institution of marriage
itself is imperilled.”
20.
In case of Gurbux Singh (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court while
dealing the issue of cruelty, observed that matrimonial life has to be
assessed as a whole, and that a few isolated incidents occurring over
a period of time would not, by themselves, constitute cruelty and held
as under :-
“15. It is true that even a single act of violence which is
of grievous and inexcusable nature satisfies the test of
cruelty. Persistence in inordinate sexual demands or
malpractices by either spouse can be cruelty if it injures
the other spouse. There is no such complaint by the
appellant. In the case on hand, as stated earlier, the
appellant has projected few instances in which,
according to him, the respondent abused his parents.
We have verified all the averments in the petitions, reply
statement, written submissions as well as the evidence
of both parties. We are satisfied that on the basis of such
instances, marriage cannot be dissolved.
16. The married life should be assessed as a whole and
a few isolated instances over certain period will not
amount to cruelty. The ill conduct must be precedent for
a fairly lengthy period where the relationship has
deteriorated to an extent that because of the acts and
behaviour of a spouse, one party finds it extremely
difficult to live with the other party no longer may amount
to mental cruelty. Making certain statements on the spur
of the moment and expressing certain displeasure about
the behaviour of elders may not be characterised as
cruelty. Mere trivial irritations, quarrels, normal wear and
tear of married life which happens in day to day life in all
families would not be adequate for grant of divorce on
the ground of cruelty. Sustained unjustifiable and
reprehensible conduct affecting physical and mental
health of the other spouse may lead to mental cruelty.
Both the appellant and the respondent being highly
qualified persons, the appellant being Principal in ITI
College, the respondent working as a Librarian in a
government institute, an isolated friction on some
occasion like festival of lohri even in the presence of
others cannot be a valid ground for dissolving the
marriage.”
21.
It is a well-settled proposition of law that the burden of proving the
allegation of cruelty lies upon respondent-husband, who is required to
adduce reliable and admissible evidence in support of the grounds on
which the petition has been filed. Upon careful consideration of the
pleadings, evidence, and material available on record, this Court is of
the considered view that the respondent-husband has failed to prove
the allegations of physical and mental cruelty against the appellantwife by leading cogent, reliable, and convincing evidence. Although
respondent-husband has alleged various acts of cruelty, including
assault, abuse, refusal to maintain matrimonial relations, locking of the
house, and unauthorized withdrawal of money through ATM, his
allegations remained unsubstantiated. In his cross-examination, he
admitted that he had not lodged any report against the appellant-wife
regarding the alleged incidents of assault, unauthorized withdrawal of
money, theft of household articles, or damage to household property.
He also failed to produce any document regarding the alleged
complaint made to the Bank in respect of withdrawal of money through
ATM. Version of respondent-husband was not corroborated by another
witness PW-3, Yash Kumar Ogre, this witness has admitted that he
had not personally witnessed the appellant-wife abusing or assaulting
the respondent-husband, nor had he seen her breaking bangles or
removing vermilion. His testimony regarding such incidents was based
only on the information supplied by the respondent-husband. Similarly,
PW-2, Bishnu Bai, mother of the respondent-husband, also failed to
support the allegation of physical cruelty, as she categorically admitted
that
neither
appellant-wife
nor
her
grandson
had
assaulted
respondent-husband. On the contrary appellant-wife denied the
allegations levelled against her and stated that she was willing to
continue her matrimonial relationship with the respondent-husband.
Her testimony remained consistent, and no material evidence was
brought on record during her cross-examination to disbelieve or
discredit her statement. Pleading made in application under Section 13
of the Act of 1955 of assault to respondent-husband to be bald in view
of the evidence of his mother.
22.
Respondent-husband in para-13 of
his evidence has stated that
dispute with appellant/wife started on account of his salary and ATM.
He also made statement before the Court that appellant/wife herself
got ATM prepared. He also admitted he has not made any compliant or
report against appellant/wife of preparing ATM and withdrawal of
amount. Though he had stated that he had made report in the Bank,
however, no documents in this regard has been submitted and further
admitted that he has not placed in record the copy of complaint made
to the Bank. From the aforementioned evidence it is apparent that
dispute between the appellant/wife and respondent/husband is not of
such nature that it can be said that appellant/wife treated
respondent/husband with cruelty. In application U/s.13 of the Act of
1955, it is pleaded that respondent/husband is being assaulted by
appellant/wife along with his son Tushar, however, Bishnu Bai Yaday
(P.W.-2) (mother of the applicant) in para-13 of her evidence had
admitted that her daughter-in-law (appellant) and her grand son had
not assaulted his son (respondent). From the aforementioned facts it is
appearing that respondent/husband by way of amendment in the copy
of plaint in para 8-A pleaded about assault by appellant/wife along with
her son upon respondent, is absolutely false and baseless.
23.
From documents exhibited by respondent/husband it is reflecting that
dispute started on account of demand of money made by
appellant/wife with her husband as also the demand of money made
by her son Tushar from her grand mother for the purpose of meeting
livelihood and other expenditure. From the contents of memo
submitted by the police before the Chief Judicial Magistrate (Ex.P-5), it
is appearing that complaint of appellant/wife her children are that
respondent/husband was not taking care of his wife and children,
therefore, they are required to make demand of money time and
again. Demand of money by wife from her husband and children from
their father to meet out their day to day expenses and towards
expenditure of daughters’ studies of respondent in the opinion of this
Court cannot be cruel act committed by wife/appellant or her children
against her husband/respondent but in the opinion of this Court it will
fall within illustration made in case of Samar Ghosh (supra) by
Hon’ble Supreme Court of trivial irritations, quarrels, normal wear and
tear of married life which happens in day to day life and it would not be
adequate for grant of divorce on the ground of mental cruelty.
24.
Criminal case lodged by Bishnu Bai Yadav was initially against her
grand-son, who came to her and demanded money to meet the
expenses to which she denied and thereafter, some altercation took
place. Another report which is lodged to police against appellant and
her son in Crime No.23 of 2022 would show that Tushar came to
complainant therein (grand mother) demanding money for purpose of
studies of his sister. The allegations made against appellant in that
crime was that few days ago, she damaged television. In the
aforementioned facts of the case reasons assigned by complainant for
lodging criminal case appears to be of a demand of money for meeting
their day to day needs.
25.
From the aforementioned evidence adduced by respondent/applicant it
is apparent that dispute arose only on account of alleged obtaining of
ATM card from Bank of account of husband and withdrawal of money.
ATM is to be prepared by the Bank at the request of account holder
after completing formalities. Even if the said statements of the
respondent/husband is to be accepted, then after coming into
knowledge, appellant could have lodged report against his wife as also
the bank employees, no such documentary evidence is placed on
record, therefore, the said allegation of respondent/husband remain
unsubstantiated.
26.
To constitute cruelty as provided under Section 13 of the Act of 1955,
the conduct complained of such be grave and weighty so as to come
to the conclusion that petitioner spouse cannot be reasonably
expected to live with the other spouse. It must be something more
serious than ordinary wear and tear of married life.
27.
One more thing is important in the facts of the case that allegation of
manhandling
by
mother
of
respondent
is
against
son
of
respondent/husband against his grand mother, therefore, the act of
one person can not be attributed to the another.
28.
From the aforementioned discussions, it is appearing that learned
Family Court has not properly evaluated the evidence brought in
record by the respondent/husband in the facts of the case where the
dispute between the parties is arising from family law and have
erroneously came to the conclusion that act and behaviour of the
appellant/wife against respondent/husband was cruel, therefore, the
said finding recorded by the learned Family Court is not sustainable
and it is liable to be set-aside.
29.
Accordingly, the appeal preferred by the appellant-wife bearing
FA(MAT) No. 15 of 2024 deserves to be and it is hereby allowed. The
impugned judgment and decree of divorce dated 06.11.2023 is setaside.
30.
Since the impugned judgment and decree dated 06.11.2023 has been
set aside, no further orders are required to be passed in FA (MAT) No.
338 of 2023 filed by respondent-husband. Accordingly, FA (MAT) No.
338 of 2023 stands dismissed.
31.
Accordingly decree be drawn.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
Balram
Sd/(Sachin Singh Rajput)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review