The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
04. 10.2022 was rejected being devoid of merit. [7] There was an unexplained delay of 15 days by the State authorities while disposing the representation submitted by the petitioner. The detention order is challenged on the following grounds:a) there was non-application of mind and the detention order was passed in a casual and mechanical routine manner without applying judicious mind; b) mandatory provisions of the PIT-ND&PS Act were violated; c) no specific reason for rejecting the representation was given. The Central Govt. is yet to dispose the representation of the petitioner. It is prayed that the detention order be set aside. W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023 Page |5 [8] The State Respondent filed counter affidavit stating that the petitioner was taken into custody for involving in illegal manufacture of brown sugar in commercial quantity from raw opium material and so far, 15 coaccused are still absconding and in order to prevent this and for protection of illegal drug, she was taken into custody. It is stated that there is no delay or lapses on the part of the State Government in dealing with the detention order while forwarding the representation to the Central Government and while deciding the representation by the State Government. It is prayed that the same may be set aside. The Central Government has not filed any counter affidavit. [9] Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the…
20. 10.2022, the Deputy Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur forwarded the parawise comments to the Central Government with respect to the representation submitted by the petitioner and the representation dated 04.10.2022 was forwarded to the Central Government on 06.10.2022. Inspite of this, the Central Government has not acted upon the representation and did not even file a response in this case. There is no explanation for the delay of 5(five) months for not considering the representation by the Central authority and the detention order is liable to be set aside on this ground alone. [12] Accordingly, the detention order dated 02.09.2022 is set aside for non-consideration of the representation for 5(five) months and the detenu, Smt. Aktari (42), W/O Shamshurudin of Kiyam Leitanpok be released from detention immediately if not required in any other case. [13] The writ petition is allowed. No cost. This Court do not appreciate the conduct of the Central Government in keeping the representation submitted by the detenu pending for 5(five) months and the detention order is set aside on this ground alone, as there ought to be strict compliance of the mandatory provisions while dealing with a case of preventive detention. In the case of Union of India v. Paul Manickam and Anr. reported in (2003) 8 SCC 342, at para 16 where it was held that meticulous compliance of the procedural saf…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page |1
Digitally
KABOR signed by
KABORAMBA
AMBAM M LARSON
LARSO Date:
2023.04.03
14:53:29
N
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR
AT IMPHAL
+05'30'
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Smt. Aktari aged about 42 years W/O Shamshurudin of Kiyam
Leitanpok, P.O. & P.S. – Thoubal, Thoubal District, Manipur.
……. Petitioner/s
– Versus –
1. The Special Secretary (Home), Govt. of Manipur, Babupara, Old
Secretariat Building, P.O. & P.S. – Imphal, District – Imphal West,
Manipur – 795001.
2. The State of Manipur, represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt. of
Manipur, Old Secretariat Building, P.O. & P.S. – Imphal, District –
Imphal West, Manipur – 795001.
3. The Deputy Secretary (PIT-NDPS), Ministry
Department of Revenue, New Delhi – 1110001 and
of
Finance,
4. The Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail, Imphal, Old
Nambulane, P.O. & P.S. – Imphal, Imphal West District, Manipur.
…. Respondent/s
BEFORE
HON’BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE M.V. MURALIDARAN
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE A. GUNESHWAR SHARMA
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, Advocate
For the Respondents
:
Mr. O. Ratankumar, Dy.GA for State Govt.
Mr. W. Darakishwor, Sr.PCCG for Central Govt.
:
02.03.2023
Date of Hearing &
Judgment and Order
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |2
JUDGMENT &ORDER
(ORAL)
(A. Guneshwar Sharma, J) :
The petitioner, Smt. Aktari was one of the 9(nine) accused
arrested in connection with FIR No.104(06)2022 Thoubal Police Station U/S
21(c)/29 ND&PS Act. She was arrested on 23.07.2022 by a team of Thoubal
Police. The FIR was lodged on 14.06.2022 with regard to manufacture of
drug and preparation in commercial quantity at the house located at Moijing
Mina Bazar, Thoubal District.
The petitioner, Smt. Aktari was one of the 9(nine) accused
arrested in the follow-up action on the revelation of the main accused,
Thoubalmayum Ahamadi Bibi and illegal manufacturing unit of brown sugar
in commercial quantity was going on and there was a recovery of 222.85 Kg.
of brown sugar seized in connection with the present case.
She filed a bail application being Cril.Misc.(B) Case No. Nil of
2022 in the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal.
[2]
Vide order dated 02.09.2022, Special Secretary (Home), Govt. of
Manipur issued detention order under Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Illicit
Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act for taking into
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |3
preventive detention of the petitioner to prevent her from further involvement
in illicit trafficking of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances for a period
of 3(three) months until further order.
It is also stated that the petitioner, Smt. Aktari filed bail
application in the Court of Special Judge (ND&PS), Thoubal and suspected
that on release, she would continue in illicit trafficking of drugs and
psychotropic substances.
[3]
Vide letter dated 06.09.2022, Special Secretary (Home), Govt. of
Manipur furnished grounds of detention to the petitioner stating that she was
involved in the illegal manufacturing of brown sugar in huge commercial
quantity and 16(sixteen) persons involved in the case were still absconding.
As an alternative, she has been taken under preventive detention.
[4]
The petitioner, Smt. Aktari filed three similar representations all
dated 04.10.2022 to the State Advisory Board, the Chief Secretary, Govt. of
Manipur and the Deputy Secretary (PIT-ND&PS), Ministry of Finance,
Department
of
Revenue,
New
Delhi,
Govt.
of India
through
the
Superintendent of Manipur Central Jail, Imphal for revoking the detention
order dated 02.09.2022 on the ground that there is no evidence against her
and her arrest was done on fabricated documents.
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |4
[5]
Vide letter dated 06.10.2022, Deputy Secretary (Home), Govt. of
Manipur forwarded the representation submitted by the petitioner to the
Deputy Secretary (PIT-ND&PS), Ministry of Finance, Department of
Revenue, New Delhi for consideration.
[6]
Vide letter dated 20.10.2022, the Deputy Secretary (Home),
Govt. of Manipur informed the petitioner that her representation dated
04.10.2022 was rejected being devoid of merit.
[7]
There was an unexplained delay of 15 days by the State
authorities while disposing the representation submitted by the petitioner.
The detention order is challenged on the following grounds:a)
there was non-application of mind and the detention order was
passed in a casual and mechanical routine manner without
applying judicious mind;
b)
mandatory provisions of the PIT-ND&PS Act were violated;
c)
no specific reason for rejecting the representation was given.
The Central Govt. is yet to dispose the representation of the petitioner.
It is prayed that the detention order be set aside.
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |5
[8]
The State Respondent filed counter affidavit stating that the
petitioner was taken into custody for involving in illegal manufacture of brown
sugar in commercial quantity from raw opium material and so far, 15 coaccused are still absconding and in order to prevent this and for protection of
illegal drug, she was taken into custody.
It is stated that there is no delay or lapses on the part of the
State Government in dealing with the detention order while forwarding the
representation to the Central Government and while deciding the
representation by the State Government. It is prayed that the same may be
set aside.
The Central Government has not filed any counter affidavit.
[9]
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
there is delay of 15(fifteen) days which has not been duly explained by the
State authorities in disposing the representation by the State Government
and the detention order is liable to be set aside on this ground alone.
Moreover, the Central Govt. is yet to pass any order on the representation
dated 04.10.2022 submitted by the petitioner and the same was duly
received by the Central Govt. on 06.10.2022 and even after 5(five) months,
the Central Govt. has not acted upon the representation. The detention order
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |6
is liable to quashed as it infringed the right of a citizen as conferred by Article
21 of the Constitution.
Mr. Ajoy Pebam, learned counsel for the petitioner refers to an
order dated 20.01.2023 passed by a Division Bench of this Court in
W.P.(Cril.) No.45 of 2022 relying upon Rajammal vs. State of T.N and
another [(1999) 1 SCC 417], Professor Khaidem Ibocha Singh vs. The State
of Manipur [AIR 1972 Supreme Court 438], Sarabjeet Singh Mokha vs. The
District Magistrate, Jabalpur, and others [(Criminal Appeal No.1301 of
2021, decided on 29.10.2021 = 2021 SCC Online SC 1019] wherein the
detention order was set aside for unexplained delay in the disposal of the
representation.
[10]
Mr. O. Ratankumar, learned Dy.GA for the State submits that
there is no delay on the part of the State while deciding the representation
and prayed that the writ petition may be rejected. It is stated that the
petitioner was taken into preventive detention as she was involved in illicit
manufacture of brown sugar in a large scale and if she is released on bail,
she would likely to continue her illegal activities.
[11]
Considered the submissions of the learned counsels for the
parties and perused the materials on record including the original file
submitted by the State Government.
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |7
On perusal of the original file, it is seen that vide letter dated
20.10.2022, the Deputy Secretary (Home), Government of Manipur
forwarded the parawise comments to the Central Government with respect
to the representation submitted by the petitioner and the representation
dated 04.10.2022 was forwarded to the Central Government on 06.10.2022.
Inspite of this, the Central Government has not acted upon the
representation and did not even file a response in this case. There is no
explanation for the delay of 5(five) months for not considering the
representation by the Central authority and the detention order is liable to be
set aside on this ground alone.
[12]
Accordingly, the detention order dated 02.09.2022 is set aside
for non-consideration of the representation for 5(five) months and the
detenu, Smt. Aktari (42), W/O Shamshurudin of Kiyam Leitanpok be
released from detention immediately if not required in any other case.
[13]
The writ petition is allowed. No cost.
This Court do not appreciate the conduct of the Central
Government in keeping the representation submitted by the detenu pending
for 5(five) months and the detention order is set aside on this ground alone,
as there ought to be strict compliance of the mandatory provisions while
dealing with a case of preventive detention. In the case of Union of India v.
Paul Manickam and Anr. reported in (2003) 8 SCC 342, at para 16 where it
was held that meticulous compliance of the procedural safeguard provided in
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |8
a preventive detention, however, technical, is mandatory. It is reproduced
herein below:
“16. In a case of preventive detention no offence is proved, nor is any
charge formulated and the justification of such detention is suspicion or
reasonability and there is no criminal conviction which can only be
warranted by legal evidence. Preventive justice requires an action to
be taken to prevent apprehended objectionable activities. (See R.
v. Halliday and Kubic Dariusz v. Union of India). But at the same
time, a person’s greatest of human freedoms i.e. personal liberty
is deprived, and, therefore, the laws of preventive detention are
strictly construed, and a meticulous compliance with the
procedural safeguard, however technical, is mandatory. The
compulsions of the primordial need to maintain order in society, without
which enjoyment of all rights, including the right of personal liberty
would lose all their meanings, are the true justifications for the laws of
preventive detention. This jurisdiction has been described as a
“jurisdiction of suspicion”, and the compulsions to preserve the values
of freedom of a democratic society and social order sometimes merit
the curtailment of the individual liberty. (See Ayya v. State of U.P.). To
lose our country by a scrupulous adherence to the written law, said
Thomas Jefferson, would be to lose the law, absurdly sacrificing the
end to the means. No law is an end in itself and the curtailment of
liberty for reasons of the State’s security and national economic
discipline as a necessary evil has to be administered under strict
constitutional restrictions. No carte blanche is given to any organ of the
State to be the sole arbiter in such matters.”
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
Page |9
In the present case, the petitioner has been alleged of involving
in the illegal manufacturing of heroin brown sugar in commercial quantity and
the detention order is set aside on the ground of non-disposal of the
representation by the Central Government for 5(five) months (as done in
most of the cases). The endeavour of the State Government to fight the
problem of drug menace in the State through the ‘War on Drug’ will only be a
casualty due to the indifferent attitude of the authorities.
[14]
Copy of this order be sent to the Chief Secretary, Govt. of
Manipur and Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Govt.
of India for information and necessary action.
JUDGE
FR/NFR
-Larson
W.P.(Cril.) No.12 of 2023
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review