Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Form No. J(1)
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Present :
The Hon’ble Justice Rajasekhar Mantha
And
The Hon’ble Justice Rai Chattopadhyay
C.R.A. 575 of 2010
Sk. Momrej
Versus
The State of West Bengal.
For the Appellant
:
Mr. Partha Sarathi Bhattacharyya,
Ms. Sukla Das Chandra.
For the State
:
Mr. Pradip Banerjee, ld. A.P.P.,
Mr. Arijit Bhusan Bagchi.
Hearing concluded on
:
July 14, 2026.
Judgment on
:
July 16, 2026.
Rajasekhar Mantha, J.:
1.
The subject appeal is directed against judgment and order of
conviction dated 30th August, 2010 and 31st August, 2010 passed by the
learned Additional Sessions Judge, Fast Track, 1 st Court, Haldia, Purba
Medinipur in Sessions Trial No. 33 of 2007. The appellant was convicted
under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC.
THE PROSECUTION CASE:
2.
The victim Muktara Bibi was married to the appellant Sk. Momrej
for some time prior to 21st April, 2004. The victim and the appellant were
issueless. They adopted a male child. The victim was often taunted and
tortured by the family of the appellant and the appellant himself for
being unable to bear a child. The family of the appellant proposed to a
second marriage for him. This was objected too by the victim.
3.
On 21st April, 2004, the brothers and parents of the victim were
participating in a festival at an open ground in the village of their
residence, namely, Suklachak. At that point of time, a rickshaw van
puller called Sk. Moti, arrived at the festival ground and announced that
the victim was burnt and was in a critical condition in her house at
village- Bhangagara.
4.
Upon coming to know of the same, the brothers of the victim and
their mother rushed to the marital house of the victim at villageBhangagara. They upon reaching the P.O. found the victim lying on a cot
in a precariously burnt condition. The victim was writhing in pain. At
that point of time, about 40 to 50 local residents had assembled at the
P.O. The victim is stated to have informed her brothers, mother and
sister that her husband poured kerosene on her and set her on fire. The
husband and members of his family had run away from the P.O. after the
incident.
5.
The victim was rushed with an ambulance to Geonkhali I/C Camp
of the Mahisadal P.S. where a complaint was lodged and a G.D. Entry
was made. The victim was later taken to Tamluk District Hospital, Purba
Medinipur. She was examined by PW-7, PW-8 and DW-1, Medical
Officers and Surgeons at such Hospital. The victim is stated to have
informed her sister throughout the journey to the police outpost and
hospital that her husband poured kerosene on her and set her on fire.
The victim is also stated to have told PW-8, the Medical Officer at the
Tamluk General Hospital that she was burnt by her husband.
6.
Based on the above, Mahisadal PS registered formal FIR being No.
49/2004 dated 21st April, 2004 under Sections 498A/326/307/34 of the
IPC. The victim died on the same day late in the night and the early
hours of 22nd April, 2004. The appellant and other accused persons were
apprehended after some time in course of investigation by the Mahisadal
P.S. Investigation was conducted initially by S.I. Sadhan Charan
Chatterjee, who died in course thereof. The investigation was completed
by Dilip Kumar Ghosh (PW-9), the second Investigating Officer who
apprehended
two
of
the
accused
persons.
After
completion
of
investigation, charge sheet was submitted.
THE TRIAL:
7.
The trial began against the appellant, one Sk. Mehebub, Sk.
Momin, Sahina Bibi, Sk. Israil and Tofena Bibi, the family members of
the appellant. Charges were framed under Sections 498A and Section
302 read with Section 34 of the IPC against the accused persons as
named hereinabove, on 13.12.2007.
8.
PW-1 was Zulfikar Ali Khan, brother of the deceased, PW-2 was
Habibul Rahaman, scribe who prepared another complaint after the
victim died.
9.
PW-3 was Mafuja Bibi, the mother of the victim.
10.
PW-4 was Mujlafa Bibi, sister of the victim and PW-6 was Jiaur
Rahaman Khan, the brother of the deceased. Each of the aforesaid PWs
were the family members of the victim had deposed that the victim was
tortured by her in-laws, namely, the accused persons primarily for being
unable to bear a child.
11.
Thy further deposed that the family of the appellant proposed to
get him married of for the second time. The family of the appellant often
taunted the victim by stating that a girl who cannot bear a child ought
not to live. The defence put forth a case to attribute such statement to
the victim herself.
12.
PW-6 further deposed that the victim and the appellant visited his
house on several occasions and were happy in the married life. He also
deposed that he visited the marital home of the victim in the morning of
the fateful day and did not find anything out of the usual.
13.
PW-5 was the SDO who conducted the inquest on the victim’s
body. None of the family members of the victim had stated before the
Inquest Officer the circumstances under which the victim sustained burn
injuries.
14.
PW-7 was Doctor Tridibesh Banerjee, a surgeon at the Tamluk
Hospital. He deposed that the victim was admitted into the hospital by
DW-1, Dr. Nilanjan Chakraborty. He deposed that he did not examine
the patient in the emergency and based on the opinion of the PW-8 had
recorded that the patient was found in a moribund condition. The family
members of the victim were informed. The patient died at 2.50 p.m. on
21st April, 2004.
15.
PW-8 was Doctor Dipak Kumar Bhattacharyya, the Medical
Officer at the Tamluk General Hospital, Purba Medinipur. He desposed
that he had examined the victim. He deposed that the victim who was in
a moribund condition had stated to him that she was set on fire by her
husband, the appellant. He recorded such statement in the treatment
sheet and referred her to the NRS Medical College and Hospital at
Kolkata for better treatment. The referral card and treatment sheet were
exhibited in the Trial Court. He explained in cross-examination that he
did not formally record a dying declaration of the victim as her condition
was rather serious and he was more concerned about the treatment of
the victim. He confirmed that notwithstanding the moribund condition of
the victim she was able to speak. He further deposed that he had
informed the victim’s family in that regard.
16.
PW-9 was Dilip Kumar Ghosh, the second Investigating Officer
who detailed some parts of his investigation. He apprehended two of the
accused persons. He collected PM report from the hospital and submitted
a charge sheet. He did not depose about the number of the persons
whose statements were recorded by his predecessor under Section 161 of
the Cr. P.C. Admittedly, no statements under Section 164 of the Cr. P.C.
were recorded.
17.
All the accused persons were examined under Section 313 of the
Cr. P.C. and circumstances in the offence against them were duly
confronted. The appellant, however, deposed that he was not present in
the P.O. at the time of occurrence and returned home 4 to 5 days
thereafter. He vehemently denied his presence at the P.O. or the
allegation of pouring kerosene on the victim and setting her on fire.
18.
On behalf of the defence, one Doctor Nilanjan Chakraborty was
examined as a witness. DW-1 proved his treatment sheet that was
marked as Exhibit. In the treatment sheet, he recorded the statement of
the victim as having told that she was encouraged to kill herself by her
husband.
19.
Based on the evidence as above, the Trial Judge acquitted all the
family members of the appellant and convicted the latter alone under
Sections 302 read with Section 34 of the IPC.
ARGUMENTS OF THE COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT:
20.
Learned
counsel
for
the
appellant,
Mr.
Partha
Sarathi
Bhattacharyya would firstly argue that the investigation by the PW-9 is
grossly inadequate and this was a case of no investigation at all. He
further submits that the PW-7 and PW-8 did not record any dying
declaration of the victim despite the fact that the victim was moribund
condition and DW-1 had deposed that several staff of the hospital were
present at the time when the victim made the statement as such. He,
therefore, argues that there is no evidence of the appellant either being
present at the P.O. or having committed the offence in question.
21.
It is next argued that as many as 40 to 50 local persons had
assembled at the P.O., none of them were examined by the prosecution.
The said local persons would have been independent witnesses who
could have seen and confirmed the presence of the appellant at the P.O.
In the absence of any independent witnesses, the family members,
namely, PW-1 to PW-4 should not have been given any credence by the
Trial Court. He next argued that the prosecution had failed to bring in
the PM Doctor and DW-1 with a view to hide the true chain of events.
The PM report as well as the DW-1 would have the effect of acquitting the
appellant under Section 302 of the IPC. It is argued that the PM report
indicates that the victim had died by suicide.
22.
It is further argued that DW 1 had clearly deposed that the victim
had stated to him that she was encouraged to kill herself by her
husband. The appellant would at best have been convicted under Section
306 of the IPC but not under Section 302.
ANALYSIS OF THIS COURT:
23.
This Court has carefully heard the argument of Mr. Bhattacharya,
learned counsel for the appellant and the learned counsel for the State.
The evidence on record has been carefully considered. Given the evidence
of DW1 that the victim had stated that she was encouraged by her
husband to commit suicide and the PM report that the victim committed
suicide indeed establishes an offence at best under Section 306 of the
IPC but not under Section 302.
24.
The evidence of PW 6, the brother of the victim cannot equally be
ignored. He deposed that the victim and the appellant visited his house
on several occasions and were found to be happy. He also deposed that
he went to the house of the victim in the morning of the day of
occurrence and found nothing out of the ordinary. There are no other
injury marks on the body of the victim found by the PM Doctor except
burn injuries. This would indicate that there was no evidence of physical
assault of the victim.
25.
The aforesaid evidence of PW 6 read with the evidence of DW 1
throws up serious questions and doubts as regards whether the
appellant set the victim on fire by pouring kerosene. None of the medical
personnel who deposed in the trial indicated any smell of kerosene on
the body of the victim. The only person who deposed about this smell of
kerosene was PW 4, sister of the victim who accompanied her to the
Tamluk District Hospital.
26.
One cannot equally ignore the examination of the appellant under
Section 313. Against three circumstances put in the evidence against
him, he stated that he was not present at the time and place of
occurrence and he was away from the house. He stated that he returned
back four days later. The appellant, however, was not able to provide any
firm evidence of his absence from the place of occurrence or with whom
he was living, where he had gone to at the place and time of occurrence.
This would therefore indicate that the defence version i.e. absence of the
appellant at the place and time of occurrence is doubtful to an extent.
CONCLUSION:
27.
Having regard to the discussions made herein above and
considering the fact that the maximum punishment under Section 306 of
the IPC up to 10 years and failure on the part of the appellant to produce
any firm and clear evidence that he was not present at the place and
time of occurrence, this Court is of the view that the prosecution has not
able to bring home the charge under Section 302 against the appellant
beyond shreds of reasonable doubt. The appellant has admittedly served
incarceration about 15 years 9 months as on date as per the report of the
Midnapore Central Correctional Home dated 15.02.2026. The appellant
shall stand sentenced to the extent of incarceration he has already
suffered.
28.
In the light of the above, the instant appeal being CRA 575 of 2010
is allowed-in-part. The appellant shall stand sentenced to the extent of
about 15 years 9 months which he has already undergone. He shall be
set at liberty forthwith from the custody, if not wanted in any other case,
upon execution of a bond to the satisfaction of the Learned Trial Court,
which shall remain in force for a period of six months under Section
437A of the Code of Criminal Procedure corresponding to Section 481 of
the BNSS, 2023.
29.
Trial Court records along with copy of this judgment be sent back
at once for necessary compliance.
30.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, be
furnished to the parties expeditiously.
Rajasekhar Mantha, J.)
I agree.
(Rai Chattopadhyay, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review