Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
07.08.2026
Item No.302
Court No. 8
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
CRA (DB) 380 of 2025
With
CRAN 3 of 2026
Goutam Karmakar @ Majhi (CCL)
-Vs.State of West Bengal and Anr.
For the appellant :
Mr. Subhabrata Chowdhury
Ms. Tripti Pandey
…..Advocates
For the State:
Mr. Kallol Mondal, Ld. PP
Mr. Aditya Tiwari
Mr. Anamitra Banerjee
…..Advocates
Dictated by Apurba Sinha Ray, J.
In Re: CRAN 3 of 2026
1.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the petitioner was juvenile but at the relevant point of time
no Preliminary Assessment Report was filed. However, one
of the CCLs was acquitted by the learned Trial Judge. The
learned State Counsel Mr. Banerjee has also submitted
that the learned Judge did not receive Preliminary
Assessment Report and as such he has left the matter to
the discretion of this Court.
2.
The learned Counsel for the petitioner has further
submitted that non-availability of Preliminary Assessment
Page 2
Report was not brought to the attention of this Court on
07.01.2026 when the bail application of this petitioner was
rejected.
3. Needless to mention that in view of the judgment in Ajeet
Gurjar vs. State of Madhya Pradesh reported in
(2023) 15 SCC 678 and Thirumoorthy vs. State
represented by the Inspector of Police reported in
2024 (2) Crimes 21 (SC), the Preliminary Assessment
Report under Section 15 of the Juvenile Justice (Care
and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 is sine qua non for
ascertaining whether the CCL was matured enough to
understand the consequences of committing the offence
and he should be tried as an adult or not.
4. In this case, the Juvenile Justice Board by its order
dated 16.10.2019 in JJB case No. 18/2019 records that
time and again the authorities were directed to form
Medical Board for the purpose of Preliminary Assessment
Report of the CCL boy but the same was not done due to
non-availability of the clinical psychologist. It appears
from the aforesaid order that the JJB at Purulia have
given sufficient time for production of the counselling
report of the medical board but the same could not be
produced before the JJB, Purulia due to non-availability
of the clinical psychologist. By order dated 16.10.2019 as
aforesaid the JJB has pointed out that the counselling of
the CCL by a competent medical Board cannot be
postponed indefinitely as the same would result in
frustration
of
the
very
purpose
of
preliminary
Page 3
assessment, and thereafter, JJB proceeded to consider
the Preliminary Assessment of the CCL with the aid of
counselling report of the counsellors appointed for the
JJB, Purulia as well as S.I.R. and S.B.R.
After
conducting an inquiry with the CCL by the Board, the
JJB has concluded that CCL had enough mental and
physical capacity to commit such an act as alleged and
he was to be treated as an adult and accordingly, he
should be tried in the jurisdictional children’s Court in
the district of Purulia. Thereafter, the case record was
split up and sent to the Additional Sessions Judge, 2nd
Court, Purulia. On 14.11.2019 the Learned Additional
Sessions Judge passed an order showing that the child
special case no. 03/2019, wherein the present CCL was
an accused, was tagged with SC Special case no.
25/2019 wherein the other adult accused persons were
being tried and thereafter, the learned Judge had
concluded that in order to save the judicial time and to
avoid conflict, the trial of the CCL be held together with
the accused persons of the case being SC Special case
No. 25/2019. The learned Court had recorded that the
learned lawyer for the CCL also asked for the joint trial.
5. Therefore, from the above it appears that the trial of the
present CCL was held alongwith the other adult accused
persons, which is not permissible under the law of the
land.
Moreover,
it
appears
that
the
Preliminary
Assessment Report dated 16.10.2019 was not based on
the Clinical Psychologist’s Report of the CCL. In fact,
Page 4
without such a report it is difficult for any judicial officer
assisted by other members of the JJB to correctly assess
the mental capacity of a CCL. The absence of such a
Clinical Psychologist’s Report makes the Preliminary
Assessment Report dated 16.10.2019 invalid and void ab
initio. The learned Additional Sessions Judge cannot act
upon such Preliminary Assessment Report sans Clinical
Psychologist’s Report. Another defect which is very much
apparent from the order of the learned Trial Court is that
he did not make an independent inquiry under Section
19 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of
Children) Act, 2015.
6. Section 19 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of
Children) Act, 2015 in Subsection 1 is hereinbelow:
“19. Powers of Children's Court. (1)After the receipt
of preliminary assessment from the Board under
section 15, the Children's Court may decide that‘(i) there is a need for trial of the child as an adult
as per the provisions of the Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1973 and pass appropriate orders
after trial subject to the provisions of this section
and section 21, considering the special needs of
the child, the tenets of fair trial and maintaining a
child friendly atmosphere;
(ii) there is no need for trial of the child as an adult
and may conduct an inquiry as a Board and pass
appropriate orders in accordance with the
provisions
of
section
18……………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………
………”
7.
From the above it appears that even after receipt of
preliminary assessment report from the Juvenile Justice
Board, the Children’s Court is under a duty to decide
whether there is a need for trial of the child as an adult
Page 5
under the provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure or
whether, there is no need for trial of the child as an adult.
In this regard, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ajeet Gurjar
(supra), held as hereunder:“9. There are two parts to sub-section 1 of Section
19. The first part requires the children’s Court to
decide whether there is a need for trial of the child
as an adult as per the provisions of the Code of
Criminal Procedure, 1973. If the Court is satisfied
that the child needs to be tried as an adult as per
the provisions of Cr.P.C., the Children’s Court can
proceed with the trial and thereafter pass an
appropriate order subject to the provisions of
sections 19 and 21 of the JJ Act.
10. Clause (ii) of sub-section 1 of Section 19 is
very crucial which indicates that though the word
‘may’ have been used in the opening part of subsection 1 of Section 19, the same will have to be
read as ‘shall’. Clause (ii) provides that after
examining whether there is a need for a trial of the
child as an adult, if the children’s Court comes to
the conclusion that there is no need for the trial of
the child as an adult, instead of sending back the
matter to the Board, the Court itself is empowered
to conduct an inquiry and pass appropriate orders
in accordance with provisions of Section 18 of the
JJ Act. The trial of a child as an adult and his trial
as a juvenile by the Juvenile Justice Board has
different consequences.
11. Therefore, holding an inquiry in terms of
clause (i) of sub-section 1 of Section 19 is not an
empty formality. The reason is that if
the
Children’s Court comes to the conclusion that
there is no need to try the child as an adult, he
will be entitled to be treated differently in the
Page 6
sense that action can be taken against him only in
terms of Section 18 of the JJ Act.”
8.
In the judgment of Tirumoorthy (supra), it has
been clearly laid down that the procedure provided under
Sections 15 and 19 of the Act have been held to be
mandatory and in this regard the Hon’ble Apex Court
again referred to the decision in Ajeet Gurjar (supra).
According to the Hon’ble Court, in the absence of
preliminary assessment being conducted by the Board
under Section 15(1) read with Section 18(3), it was
impermissible for the trial court to have accepted the
chargesheet and to have proceeded with the trial of the
accused.
9.
However,
in
Tirumoorthy
(supra)
case,
no
preliminary assessment was done by the Board, so as to
find out whether or not the accused should be tried as an
adult.
In the case in hand such preliminary assessment
was done by Juvenile Justice Board, Purulia but without
the support of the Clinical Psychologist’s Report, and,
thereafter, it reported that the petitioner, although was a
minor, had sufficient maturity to understand the nature of
the offence and he should be tried as an adult.
10.
Therefore, the petitioner has been able to make out
an arguable case in his favour. It prima facie appears that
the Preliminary Assessment of the CCL was done without
Clinical Psychologist’s Report. Secondly, after receipt of the
Preliminary Assessment Report dated 16.10.2019, the
learned Special Judge did not make any independent
Page 7
inquiry under Section 19 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and
Protection of Children) Act, 2015 to decide whether there is
a need for trial of a child as an adult under the provision of
the Code of Criminal Procedure and thirdly, it prima facie
appears that the CCL was tried with the other adult
persons which is also not permissible under the law.
11.
In view of the above, we are inclined to allow the
prayer as made in CRAN 3 of 2026 and we do so.
12.
The CCL Goutam Karmakar @ Majhi be released on
a personal bond of Rs. 10,000/- without any surety with a
direction that he shall remain within the geographical
limits of Purulia and shall not enter the jurisdiction where
the victim or her family members reside and shall remain
represented before this Court through his learned counsel
on each and every date of hearing of this appeal.
13.
Accordingly, CRAN 3 of 2026 is hereby disposed of.
14.
All parties shall act in terms of server copy of the
order downloaded from the official website of this Court.
15.
Urgent photostat certified copies of this Order, if
applied for, be supplied to the parties on compliance of all
necessary formalities.
(ARIJIT BANERJEE, J.)
(APURBA SINHA RAY, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review