Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
I.No.14.
Form No. J(2)
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon’ble Justice Reetobroto Kumar Mitra
W.P.A.26724 of 2024
Sk. Hasibur Rahaman
Vs.
The Aliah University, New Town
Rajarhat & Ors.
For the petitioner
:
For the University
Heard on
Judgment dictated
in open Court on
Mr. Samim Ahammed,
Mr. Arka Maiti,
Ms. Ambiya Khatun,
Ms. Saloni Bhattacharya,
Ms. Gulsanwara Pervin,
Md. Nasirul Haque,
Ms. Reshma Khatun.
:
:
Mr. Raghunath Chakraborty,
Mrs. Amrita De.
07.01.2026 & 08.01.2026
:
08.01.2026
Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.:1.
The petitioner is aggrieved by the acts of omission and/or
commission of the respondent authorities in not appointing the petitioner
to the post of Audit and Accounts Officer.
2.
The facts in a nutshell may be summarized as under;
(a)
The petitioner has been working as an Accounts Officer in the
respondent No.1.
(b)
Pursuant
to
an
advertisement
dated
June
27,
2015,
applications were invited from eligible candidates for recruitment to
various posts, including that of an Audit and Accounts Officer.
(c)
The petitioner had submitted his academic credentials and
was thereafter called for an interview by the Selection Committee,
sometime in 2020.
(d)
The interview was duly held, though there was no response
from the authorities as to the fate of the participants.
(e)
The petitioner was constrained to make an application under
the Right to Information Act, 2005, sometime in June 2023 to the
concerned officer of the respondent No.1.
(f)
Pursuant to such application, by a communication of July 26,
2023, the petitioner to came to learn that of the eight short-listed
candidates, five had participated in the interview process, amongst
whom the petitioner was the highest ranked person with a
percentage of 47.36.
(g)
However, it appears from the score-sheet disclosed by the
petitioner, which was made available to him under the Right to
Information Act, 2005, all the five candidates who participated,
were found to be “not suitable”. In fact, this score-sheet also finds a
hand written endorsement that “it is resolved unanimously that
none is found suitable for the said post.”
(h)
Upon receipt of such particulars, especially the score-sheet,
the petitioner had made a representation to the Vice Chancellor of
the respondent No.2 on August 24, 2023, in September 2023 and on
May 10, 2024 seeking appointment to the post of Audit and
Accounts Officer.
3.
It is this process, undertaken by the University in not appointing the
petitioner that has been assailed in the present writ petition.
4.
Mr. Ahammed appearing for the petitioner submits that the process
ought to be set aside on two principal grounds.
5.
First, since there was no benchmark set by the interviewing
committee and the marks awarded in the interview was absolutely
subjective.
6.
Second, the distribution of marks for the academic credential and
the interview are contrary to the law set forth by the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court of India in several decisions.
7.
Mr. Ahammed‟s consequential argument is that the process ought
to be set aside and the petitioner should be appointed as the Audit and
Accounts Officer, being the best available candidate for th e post of Audit
and Accounts Officer.
8.
He has relied upon three decisions of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of
India which are as under;
i)
K. Manjusree Vs. State of Andhra Pradesh & Anr.,
reported in 2008(3) SCC 512;
ii)
Barot Vijaykumar Balakrishna & Ors. Vs. Modh
Vinaykumar Dasrathlal & Ors., reported in (2011) 7
SCC 308; &
iii)
Tej Prakash Pathak & Ors. Vs. Rajasthan High Court
& Ors., reported in 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3184;
9.
The decisions of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court relied upon by Mr.
Ahammed are clear and unequivocal. It is not in dispute that benchmarks
ought to be set by an authority prior to embarking on a process for
appointment to a post in an educational institution. Any process where the
benchmark has been set either during the process or thereafter cannot be
sustained in law.
10.
Mr. Chakraborty appearing for the respondents submits that the
petitioner was aware that there was no benchmark set for the selection
process as would appear from the advertisement issued by the University.
11.
With such specific knowledge, the petitioner had participated in the
process without any reservation and hence at a belated stage, cannot be
permitted to question the process undertaken for selection of a candidate
to the post, as aforestated.
12.
He further submits that the Screening Committee, which had
conducted the interview, consisted of several persons holding high posts
including Vice Chancellor of other University. Records or minutes of the
meeting and/or their deliberation are presently not available.
13.
I have heard learned Counsel for the parties and considered the
documents on record as well as the decisions relied upon by them.
14.
The first and rather strange fact in this matter is that the
advertisement was issued in June, 2015 while the interview was held in
2020 and the present writ petition was filed in 2024 and is pending since.
Mr. Chakraborty has also made it clear that there has been no
appointment to the post of Audit and Accounts Officer and the said post is
presently lying vacant. It is not in dispute and indeed indisputable that the
entire process is somewhat obscure as the academic credentials of
participating candidates were to account for 40% of the marks to be
awarded to the participating candidates. The interview would constitute
for 60% of the marks for the participating candidates in deciding their
eligibility and/or suitability for the post.
15.
Since no benchmark or any parameter has been set forth by the
University to obtain appointment to the post of Audit and Accounts
Officer, this entire process is ex facie vitiated. The decisions relied upon
by Mr. Ahammed of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court of India are clear and
unequivocal. The decision of the Screening Committee is arbitrary as
marks were awarded without any basis and hence cannot be sustained in
any manner.
16.
The issue that remains and begs some consideration is the second
limb of Mr. Ahammed‟s submission that his client, the petitioner herein,
should be appointed as he is the person with the highest marks in the
interview.
17.
This fact is not disputed. Even though he has obtained the highest
marks, he was found “not suitable” for the said post. In the absence of any
definition of the word „suitable‟ in any of the statute or by-laws of the
University, the said word loses any force and lacks any meaning to be
ascribed. There is no objective parameter which was set forth to ascertain
the suitability of the participating candidates. Thus, the entire process of
selection in the absence of any benchmark is nothing short of arbitrary.
Thus, the entire process is vitiated and has to be set aside.
18.
Thus, if the entire process is vitiated, which has been Mr.
Ahammed‟s main thrust, the consequential argument falls short of having
a connect with the main argument. The argument that the petitioner was
the best available candidate is self defeating as there were no parameters
available to assess the same.
19.
In the event, the process is vitiated, not only the petitioner but all
candidates inspite of the fact that they may have a legitimate expectation,
which I very much doubt in the present case, would not be able to
establish a right to be appointed to the post of Audit and Accounts,
Officer.
20.
The reason for my doubt of the legitimacy of the expectation of the
petitioner to be appointed is that the advertisement of June 27, 2015 did
not mention any parameter and the petitioner was well aware of such fact
and ought to have either objected or, as he did, participate. Having
participated in the process, there was no room for any further expectation
of the petitioner.
21.
However, bereft of the petitioner‟s expectation, it is not in dispute
that the entire process is indeed vitiated and falls short of the benchmarks
set forth by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in the three aforestated decisions
and particularly the once reported in 2008 (3) SCC 512 and 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 3184 (Supra).
22.
In these circumstances aforestated, the advertisement seeking an
eligible candidate for the appointment to the post of Audit and Accounts
Officer is set aside and consequentially the interview process undertaken
by the Selection Committee is also set aside.
23.
The respondent University will issue a fresh advertisement for
appointment of an eligible person to the post of Audit and Accounts
Officer by February 15, 2026 and appoint a Selection Committee to
conduct the necessary process within March 15, 2026 and conduct the
necessary process upon setting necessary parameters which should include
a benchmark.
24.
The petitioner will have a right to participate in the process and if
there is a disqualification due to his age, the same will be relaxed and/or
waived by the respondent
authorities in the peculiar
facts
and
circumstances of the case, which shall not be construed as a precedent .
25.
It is further made clear that the employment of the petitioner in the
present post will not be disturbed in any manner as an apprehension has
been expressed by Mr. Ahammed. The petitioner‟s participation in the
selection process will also not be marred by the fact that he has filed the
present proceeding challenging the entire process. The petitioner will be
evaluated independently without any bias of any manner whatsoever .
26.
With these directions, the writ petition is partially allowed and
accordingly disposed of.
27.
There shall be no order as to costs.
28.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given
to the parties on usual undertaking.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review