The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. 03.2026 Heard Mr. J.C. Borah, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. A. Phukan, learned counsel for the respondent nos. 1 – 4. The grievance raised in this writ petition pertains to Provincialization Order No. EPD-15/Provin-LP(Act. 2017)/2021/1943, dated 5th February 2021, issued from Kahilipara by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, Kahilipara, Guwahati-19, whereby the services of Respondent No. 5 in this writ petition were provincialized. The orders of this Court reflect that, despite receipt of notice, Respondent No. 5 failed to appear and contest the petition. The writ petition alleges that Respondent No. 5, according to records, joined Bal Bikash Shiksha Sadan (L.P. School) in the year 1990 but obtained her High School Leaving Certificate qualification only in 2002. It is, therefore, the submission of the learned counsel for the petitioner that, in 1990, Respondent No. 5 did not possess the requisite qualification to be appointed as an Assistant Teacher in a L.P. school. It is further relevant to note that, upon provincialization of the services of Bal Bikash Shiksha Sadan (L.P. School), the school was amalgamated into Balmiki L.P. School, which was taken as the base school. Page No.# 3/7 The learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn the attention of this Court to the reply furnished by Respondent No. 5 to the Public Information Officer, Office of t…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/7
GAHC010225932021
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/84/2022
SIPRA DHAR
W/O GOPAL SUTRADHAR, RESIDENT OF VILLAGE SOUTH HAIBARGAON,
R.R.B ROAD (BEBIKANANDA PALLY) PO HAIBARGAON, PS SADAR ,DIST
NAGAON, ASSAM 782001
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 4 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM, DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION (ELEMENTARY) DISPUR,
GUWAHATI 06
2:THE DIRECTOR OF ELEMENTARY EDUCATION
ASSAM
KAHILIPARA
GUWAHATI 19
3:THE DISTRICT ELEMENTARY EDUCATION OFFICER
NAGAON
ASSAM 782001
4:THE DEPUTY INSPECTOR OF SCHOOLS
DISTRICT NAGAON
ASSAM 782001
5:SMTI ARUNA HALDAR
D/O LATE JAYNARAYAN HALDAR
C/O HEADMASTER BALMIKI HINDI BIDYALAYA
PO HAIBARGAON
782002
Page No.# 2/7
DIST NAGAON
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR J C BORAH,
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, ELEM. EDU, MS. Z A ASADIA (R-5)
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH MAZUMDAR
ORDER
10.03.2026
Heard Mr. J.C. Borah, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. A.
Phukan, learned counsel for the respondent nos. 1 – 4.
The grievance raised in this writ petition pertains to Provincialization Order
No. EPD-15/Provin-LP(Act. 2017)/2021/1943, dated 5th February 2021, issued
from Kahilipara by the Director of Elementary Education, Assam, Kahilipara,
Guwahati-19, whereby the services of Respondent No. 5 in this writ petition
were provincialized.
The orders of this Court reflect that, despite receipt of notice, Respondent
No. 5 failed to appear and contest the petition. The writ petition alleges that
Respondent No. 5, according to records, joined Bal Bikash Shiksha Sadan (L.P.
School) in the year 1990 but obtained her High School Leaving Certificate
qualification only in 2002. It is, therefore, the submission of the learned counsel
for the petitioner that, in 1990, Respondent No. 5 did not possess the requisite
qualification to be appointed as an Assistant Teacher in a L.P. school.
It is further relevant to note that, upon provincialization of the services of
Bal Bikash Shiksha Sadan (L.P. School), the school was amalgamated into
Balmiki L.P. School, which was taken as the base school.
Page No.# 3/7
The learned counsel for the petitioner has drawn the attention of this
Court to the reply furnished by Respondent No. 5 to the Public Information
Officer, Office of the Deputy Inspector of Schools, Nagaon, Assam, wherein
Respondent No. 5 herself provided the HSLC Examination Certificate issued by
the Assam Sanskrit Board, Guwahati. The certificate reflects that Respondent
No. 5 passed the Praveshika Examination held in 2002 and was placed in the
3rd Division.
Further, Respondent No. 5 passed the Higher Secondary School Leaving
Examination in 2018 under the Assam State Open School under the Assam
Higher Secondary Education Council.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that, since
Respondent No. 5 was not qualified to hold the post of teacher in a L.P. School
in 1990, her recommendation for provincialization of services was evidently
erroneous and requires interference by this Court.
The learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that, in the absence
of Respondent No. 5, it was the petitioner who should have been recommended
for consideration for provincialization. The learned counsel contends that the
mistake initially occurred at the level of the school when the names were
recommended, and further persisted when the District Scrutiny Committee, did
not carry out proper verification as required under the law.
It is further submitted that the error continued at the State-Level Scrutiny
Committee stage, where the Government, while finalizing the matter, also failed
to verify the antecedents of the persons whose names were being forwarded.
Accordingly, the learned counsel for the petitioner has prayed that the
order dated 05.02.2021, insofar as it relates to the provincialization of the
Page No.# 4/7
services of Respondent No. 5, namely, Smti Aruna Haldar, Tutor in the Balmiki
L.P. School, be interfered with, and further orders be passed directing the
respondent authorities to consider the case of the petitioner for provincialization
under the same terms and conditions on which the services of other teachers of
the venture L.P. School have been taken up by the respondent authorities.
Mr. Phukan, learned counsel for the state respondents, has referred to the
affidavit-in-opposition filed by the Director, wherein the process of scrutinization
has been elaborated. It has been stated that the District Scrutiny Committee
initially recommended the services of two other teachers without including the
names of either the petitioner or Respondent No. 5 in the first instance.
However, by a letter dated 19.12.2019 submitted by the District Elementary
Education Officer, certain corrections were made in the recommendation, to the
extent that the name of Respondent No. 5 was included. Thereafter, as per the
affidavit of Respondent No. 2, two persons, namely Jaylal Prasad Mahato and
Respondent No. 5, were recommended for provincialization.
The stand taken by the Director in the affidavit is that the name of the
petitioner was not recommended by the District Scrutiny Committee, Nagaon,
for provincialization as an Assistant Teacher; therefore, the petitioner’s services
could not be provincialized.
As regards the qualification required for appointment as an Assistant
Teacher of an L.P. School prior to 10.11.1995, the Director has taken the stand
that the minimum requisite qualification for the post of assistant teacher was
HSLC passed. Respondent No. 2, in the affidavit, has further stated that after
the notification of 10.11.1995 (sic. 2005), the minimum qualification for
appointment as an Assistant Teacher was Higher Secondary or any other
examination of equivalent standard with at least 45% marks in any of the
Page No.# 5/7
qualified exams (HSLC or Higher Secondary) for general category candidates,
and a minimum of 40% marks for reserved category candidates.
The specific stand of the Director is that, at the time when Respondent
No. 5 was shown to be appointed to the school, the requisite qualification for an
Assistant Teacher of an L.P. School was HSLC. It is further stated that
Respondent No. 5 passed the HSSLC examination in the year 2002.
Mr. Phukan, learned counsel for the respondents, has referred to the list of
untrained in-service teachers in unaided recognized schools given at page 28 of
the
amended
writ
petition,
which
is
a
tabulation
made
by
the
Headmaster/Principal of the school, showing that Respondent No. 5 passed the
HSSLC examination in 2002.
This Court has heard the learned counsel for contesting parties and
perused the materials available on record. The records reveal that Respondent
No. 5 procured the Class X (HSLC) certificate in 2002, and therefore, at the time
of her appointment in 1990, she did not possess the requisite qualification to be
appointed as an Assistant Teacher of an L.P. School.
The Court has also noticed other inconsistencies, such as the tabulation
forwarded by the headmaster/principal showing the respondent’s HSSLC
qualification as on 2002. Additionally, the data submitted on 30th September
2009 under the signature of the Headmaster and Secretary shows Respondent
No. 5 to have the highest qualification as HSLC. The documents submitted by
Respondent No. 5 and attached to the reply of the RTI application itself indicate
that she obtained her HSSLC qualification in 2018.
Thus, it appears to this Court that the entire exercise for consideration of
the services of Respondent No. 5 for provincialization was conducted on the
Page No.# 6/7
basis of fraudulent and incorrect information supplied by the school authorities
to the District Level Scrutiny Committee, which was then forwarded to the State
Level Scrutiny Committee without proper verification of records. The State Level
Scrutiny Committee also failed in its duty by forwarding the recommendation to
the Government for approval without making proper inquiry into the information
supplied by the school authorities.
It is settled law that fraud vitiates the entire proceedings, and in the
present case, when the very recommendation from the school was based on
fraud, the final orders of provincialization cannot stand the scrutiny of law.
In such circumstances, the Provincialization Order dated 05.02.2021
issued by the Director in so far as it relates to the provincialisation of
respondent no.5, is interfered with by this Court and is accordingly set aside and
quashed.
As a consequential relief, Respondent No. 2, namely, the Director of
Elementary Education, shall initiate appropriate steps from the school level itself
to verify the records of the school and to take up the case of the petitioner for
consideration for provincialization of her services in accordance with law. The
Director shall also take appropriate steps to cause an inquiry into how and
under what circumstances fraudulent information was supplied by the school
authorities to the district-level authorities, providing unverified and false
information during the process of provincialization of Respondent No. 5.
It is clarified that, since the provincialization of the services of Respondent
No. 5 was based on fraudulent and false information, the provincialization of her
services stands voided ab initio.
The case of the petitioner for provincialization shall be taken up within a
Page No.# 7/7
period of 45 days from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order, and
the process shall be completed within 90 days thereafter. The Director shall
ensure that all necessary inquiries, as required by law, are made to verify the
credentials of the petitioner while considering her case for provincialization of
services.
This Writ Petition is disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review