Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.20166 of 2025
======================================================
Sintu Kumar, Son of late Jay Raj Prasad, Resident of Mohalla- Upadhyay tola
Rajgir, P.S.- Rajgir, District- Nalanda.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
1.
The Central Bank of India through its Managing Director and Chief
Executive Officer, Mumbai, Maharashtra.
2.
The Managing Director and Chief Executive Officer, Central Bank of India,
Chandermukhi Building Nariman Point, Mumbai, Maharashtra- 400021.
3.
The Zonal Manager, Central Bank of India, Bihar, Maurya Lok Complex,
Dak Bunglow Road, Patna- 800001.
4.
The HRD Deptt. Central Bank of India, Regional office, Gaya.
5.
The Branch Manager, Central Bank of India Branch, Rajgir, Nalanda.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
:
Mr. Sanjay Prasad, Advocate
For the Respondent/s
:
Mr. Nishi Nath Ojha, Advocate
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PARTHA SARTHY
C.A.V. JUDGMENT
Date : 19-09-2026
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and learned
counsel for the Central Bank of India.
2. The petitioner has filed the instant application for
the following reliefs :“1 That this is an application for
issuance
of
a
writ
in
the
nature
of
Certiorari/mandamus or any appropriate writ,
order, direction commanding the respondents
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
2/13
for direction the respondents
I For quashing of the office order
vide letter ZO/Patna /HCM/2025-26/431 dated
26-08-2025 issued by the Zonal Head Central
Bank of India Regional office, Gaya whereby
claim of the petitioner for appointment on
compassionate ground after death of her
mother who died in service period has been
rejected only on the ground that the petitioner
is married.
II For direction the respondents to
appoint
the
petitioner
as
compassionate
appointment on the post of Peon or any other
post who is younger son of late Nirmla Devi
and died during service period who was posted
as Peon in Central Bank of India branch
Rajgir.
III For passing any order and
direction in the interest of justice and ends of
justice of the petitioner in the facts and
circumstances of the case.”
3. The case of the petitioner in brief is that the mother
of the petitioner who was working on the post of Safai
Karamchari in the Central Bank of India for more than 21 years
having died in harness on 29.3.2024, the petitioner filed an
application for his appointment on compassionate ground which
came to be rejected vide order dated 26.8.2025 mainly on the
ground that the applicant was married and so cannot be
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
3/13
considered as wholly dependent of the deceased employee. This
lead to the petitioner filing the instant writ application for the
reliefs prayed for, as stated herein above.
4. It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioner
that the appointment on compassionate ground in the Central
Bank of India is carried out as per the Scheme dated 8.4.2015
(Annexure R-1 to the counter affidavit) from which it would
transpire that on a permanent employee of a Bank dying while
in service, the dependent family member is entitled for
appointment on compassionate ground. A dependent family
member is defined in Clause 2 of Annexure-1 of the said
Scheme. Clause 2.2 thereof defines Dependent Family Member
as wholly dependent son including legally adopted son. Learned
counsel submits that there is no difference evident therein
between a married and an unmarried son. Further, a wholly
dependent son is not defined in the said Scheme.
5. Referring to the Central Bank of India (Officers’)
Service Regulations, 1979 (Annexure R-2 to the counter
affidavit of the respondent nos.1 to 5), learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that family has been defined in the definitions
clause of the said Regulation which means also ‘wholly
dependent unmarried children’. Explanation-1 of the said
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
4/13
definition defines a wholly dependent family member means
such family members having monthly income not exceeding
Rs.18,000/-.
6. Further referring to the income certificate of the
petitioner dated 5.6.2024 issued by the Revenue Officer,
District- Nalanda, Government of Bihar, learned counsel for the
petitioner submits that the petitioner is shown to have an annual
income of Rs.1,10,000/- and thus he has a lesser monthly
income than Rs.18,000/-. It is thus submitted that the petitioner
being a wholly dependent son and there being no distinction
between a son who is married or unmarried in the Scheme for
compassionate appointment of the Bank, the Bank has erred in
passing the order dated 26.8.2025 rejecting the application on
the ground of him being married and thus cannot be considered
as wholly dependent. The order dated 26.8.2025 be set aside and
the respondent Bank be directed to appoint the petitioner on
compassionate ground.
7. The application is opposed by learned counsel
appearing for the Central Bank of India. It is submitted by
learned counsel that the Scheme for compassionate appointment
(Annexure R-1 to the counter affidavit) clearly mentions that
dependent family member is defined as a wholly dependent son.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
5/13
As wholly dependent son has not been defined/explained in the
scheme for compassionate appointment, it is submitted by
learned counsel for the Bank that assistance will be required to
be taken from the Central Bank of India (Officers’) Service
Regulations, 1979 (Annexure R-2) which defines family as
wholly dependent unmarried children. It is thus submitted that
the Regulation of 1979 clearly mentions that the children
including the son in the instant case should be unmarried to
come within the definition of a family. Reference is also made
to the definition of family as contained in the Group Health
Insurance Policy for Serving Staff of the Bank dated 15.9.2025
wherein it is defined to be wholly dependent unmarried
children.
8. Learned counsel for the Bank further refers to the
memorandum of settlement dated 11.11.2020 between the
Managements of 29 Banks as represented by the Indian Banks’
Association on one hand and their workmen as represented by
the All India Bank Employees’ Association and other
Employees’ Associations on other. He submits that there is no
dispute with respect to the fact that the definition of family as
defined in Clause 21 thereof means employees wholly dependent
unmarried children. Further, referring to the Frequently Asked
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
6/13
Questions (FAQs) on Compassionate Appointment taken out by
the Indian Banks’ Association and a copy of which is at page-32 of
the counter affidavit, learned counsel submits that in Clause 15, to
a query as to whether the term ‘wholly dependent’ as defined in
the BPS (Bipartite Settlement) from time to time will be
applicable while ascertaining the dependency of the family
member, the answer given is yes. It is thus submitted that with
the clarification having been issued by the Indian Banks’
Association, there is no vagueness in the definition of family
and which necessarily requires the employee’s dependent
children to be unmarried. There also not being any dispute with
respect to the fact that the petitioner is admittedly married, the
application
of
the
petitioner
for
his
appointment
on
compassionate ground was rightly rejected. There is no illegality
in the order nor any merit in the instant application and thus the
same be dismissed.
9. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused
the material on record.
10. The relevant facts in brief are that the mother of
the petitioner who was working as a Full-Time Safai
Karamchari (FTSK) for more than 21 years and was in the
permanent establishment in the Central Bank of India, Rajgir
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
7/13
Branch died in harness on 29.3.2024.
11. The petitioner who belongs to the EBC category
filed an application for his appointment on compassionate
ground. The application of the petitioner came to be rejected by
order dated 26.8.2025 on the ground that the petitioner is
married and so he cannot be considered as wholly dependent of
the deceased employee.
12. It is against this order dated 26.8.2025 that the
petitioner has filed the instant application praying for quashing
the same and for a direction to the respondents to appoint the
petitioner on compassionate ground.
13. The Scheme for Compassionate Appointment on
Compassionate Grounds or Payment of Lumpsum Ex-Gratia
Amount in the Central Bank of India dated 8.4.2015 (Annexure
R-1) provides that the scheme covers a dependent family
member of permanent employee of a Bank. Clause 2 of the
Scheme defines ‘Dependent Family Member’ and is reproduced
herein below for ready reference :“2. Dependent Family Member
2.1. Spouse; or
2.2. Wholly dependent son (including
legally adopted son); or
2.3.
Wholly
dependent
daughter
(including legally adopted daughter); or
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
8/13
2.4. Wholly dependent brother or sister in
the case of unmarried employee.”
14. It may be observed here itself that a wholly
dependent son as mentioned in Clause 2.2 of the Scheme is not
defined under the scheme of compassionate appointment.
15. It may be mentioned here that in exercise of
powers conferred by Section 19 read with Section 12(2) of
Banking Companies (Acquisition and Transfer of Undertakings)
Act, 1970, the Board of Directors of the Central Bank of India
made the Central Bank of India (Officers’) Service Regulations,
1979 (Annexure R-2) which deals with categorisation,
appointment, promotion, seniority, termination etc. of the
officers. ‘Family’, in case of children is defined to mean ‘wholly
dependent unmarried children’. Based on this definition in the
Regulations of 1979, learned counsel for the Bank submits that
for qualifying as wholly dependent upon the deceased
employee, it is required that the child i.e. the petitioner in the
instant case should have been unmarried.
16. In the opinion of the Court, so far as these
Regulations of 1979 are concerned, they will not be applicable
in the case of the petitioner for the reason that they are
applicable in the case of officers of the Bank. Further officer is
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
9/13
defined in Clause (j) of the definitions as a person fitted into or
promoted to or appointed to any of the grades specified in
Regulation 4 as also any other person who immediately prior to
the appointed date was an officer of the Bank. Thus this
definition of family as wholly dependent unmarried children
will not be applicable in case of the petitioner herein as his
mother at the time of her death was working on the post of FullTime Safai Karamchari.
17. Learned counsel for the Bank thereafter places
reliance on the definition of family as wholly dependent
unmarried children as defined in ‘Group Health Insurance
Policy for Serving Staff’, contained in letter no.681 dated
15.9.2025 (Annexure R-3). The heading of this circular itself
makes it clear that the same is for the purpose of Group Health
Insurance Policy for Serving Staff and not for compassionate
appointment. As such, in the opinion of the Court, reliance by
learned counsel for the Bank on this circular is misplaced.
18. It was next submitted by learned counsel for the
Bank that on account of queries being raised by the Banks in
connection with the scheme of compassionate appointment
contained in Circular no.476 dated 11.8.2014, the Indian Banks’
Association came out with clarification in the form of FAQs,
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
10/13
Clause 15 of which reads as follows :Q.No.
15.
Query
Answer
Whether the term ‘wholly dependent’ Yes.
as defined in the BPS from time to
time will be applicable while
ascertaining the dependency of the
family member?
19. It may be mentioned here that as against the
‘Scheme for Compassionate Appointment on Compassionate
Grounds in Public Sector Banks’ contained in Circular no.476
dated 11.8.2014, so far as the Central Bank of India is
concerned, they came out with the ‘Scheme of Compassionate
Appointment on Compassionate Grounds or Payment of
Lumpsum Ex-Gratia Amount’ enclosed with the letter no.017
dated 8.4.2015. This Court finds that this is a complete scheme
in itself and thus the definitions for example of ‘dependent
family member’ as defined in Clause 2 of the Scheme has to be
taken as mentioned therein and cannot be supplemented by
importing part definitions from outside the Scheme like
Regulations of 1979 or the circular dealing with the Group
Health Insurance Policy for Serving Staff in the Bank. Further,
so far as the FAQs on compassionate appointment referred to
herein above is concerned, Clause 15 of which is being relied
upon by learned counsel for the Bank, in the opinion of the
Court, the same is a clarification issued by the Indian Banks’
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
11/13
Association with respect to Circular no.476 dated 11.8.2014
while so far as the Central Bank of India in the present case is
concerned,
the
applicable
scheme
for
compassionate
appointment came to be formulated later as contained in
Circular no.017 dated 8.4.2015.
20. It may be noted here that wholly dependent family
member is not defined under the scheme for compassionate
appointment. As per the Regulations of Central Bank of India,
they have been explained to be such member of the family
having a monthly income not exceeding Rs.18,000/-.
21. So far as the facts of the instant case is concerned,
it would be relevant to take note of the fact that the object of the
scheme for compassionate appointment is to provide immediate
financial relief to the family of the deceased. In the opinion of
the Court, as the definition of ‘dependent family member’ under
the scheme for compassionate appointment as reproduced herein
above includes in Clause 2.2 a wholly dependent son, the use of
the term ‘wholly dependent unmarried children’ under the
Regulations of 1979 as also under the Group Health Insurance
Policy for Serving Staff clearly shows that the officers of the
Bank drafting the scheme for compassionate appointment
purposely left out the word ‘unmarried’ while defining
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
12/13
‘dependent family member’ as wholly dependent son or wholly
dependent daughter. In these circumstances, the respondentBank cannot be permitted to introduce the word ‘unmarried’ in
the definition of ‘dependent family member’ in their scheme of
compassionate appointment.
22. In view of the facts and circumstances stated
herein above, no distinction having been made between a
married and an unmarried son or daughter in grant of
compassionate appointment under the relevant Scheme of the
Central Bank of India, the respondent-Bank committed an error
in rejecting the application of the petitioner for his appointment
on compassionate ground for the reason that he is married and
so cannot be considered as wholly dependent of the deceased
employee. Thus the order rejecting the petitioner’s application
cannot be sustained and requires to be set aside.
23. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case,
the office order bearing no.ZO/PATN/HCM/2025-26/431 dated
26.8.2025 issued under the signature of the Zonal Head, Central
Bank of India, Regional Office, Gaya is unsustainable and is
hereby set aside.
24. The respondent-Central Bank of India is directed
to consider the case of the petitioner for his appointment on
Patna High Court CWJC No.20166 of 2025 dt.19-09-2026
13/13
compassionate ground in view of the observations made herein
above as also the applicable Scheme for compassionate
appointment. The consideration be done expeditiously and
appropriate orders be passed within a period of three months of
receipt/production of a copy of this order.
25. The application stands allowed.
(Partha Sarthy, J)
avinash/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
NAFR
15.09.2026
19.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review