Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 02-05
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No. 420 of 2022
WP (C) No. 430 of 2022
WP (C) No. 433 of 2022
WP (C) No. 112 of 2023
Date of Decision:05.04.2024
1. Shri Rakesh Kumar Sarmah,
Survey of India Campus,
Barik Point, Shillong-793001
Meghalaya.
…….. Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Body under the Department of Science and
Technology (DST), Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
2. Director General,
North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
3. Union of India, Department of Science and Technology Bhawan,
Shaheed Jeet Singh, Marg,
New Delhi-110016.
…. Respondent(s)
1. Shri Simanta Das,
S/o (L) Robin Chandra Das
R/o Survey of India Campus,
Barik Point, Shillong-793001
East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
…….. Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Society under the Department of Science and
Technology, Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
2. The Director General,
North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Society under the Department of Science and
Technology, Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
3. The Chairman,
Governing Council,
NECTAR, Shillong
4. Union of India,
Represented by its Secretary,
Department of Science and Technology
2nd Floor Vishwakarma Bhawan,
ShaheedJeet Singh, Marg,
New Delhi-110016.
…. Respondent(s)
1. Shri Simon Phukan,
S/o Shri Julan Phukan
R/o House No. 16, MG Road,
Uznbazar, Rajbari, Guwahati, Assam
Presently residing at F 103, Pocket A,
Near Phase 1, DDA Flats, Katwaria Sarai
New Delhi.
…….. Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Society under the Department of Science and
Technology, Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
2. The Director General,
North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Society under the Department of Science and
Technology, Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
3. The Chairman,
Governing Council,
NECTAR, Shillong
4. Union of India,
Represented by its Secretary,
Department of Science and Technology
2nd Floor Vishwakarma Bhawan,
Shaheed Jeet Singh, Marg,
New Delhi-110016.
…. Respondent(s)
1. Shri Ankit Shrivastava,
S/o Shri V.K. Shrivastava
R/o Old Hospital Campus, MG Road,
Khargone (M.P) 451001,
Presently residing at 456, DDA Flats,
Section-E2 Near CNG Pump, Vasant Kunj,
New Delhi-110070.
…….. Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Society under the Department of Science and
Technology, Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
2. The Director General,
North East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR)
Autonomous Society under the Department of Science and
Technology, Government of India,
Headquarter at Survey of India Campus,
Bonnie Brae Estate, Barik Point, Shillong-793001,
Meghalaya.
3. The Chairman,
Governing Council,
NECTAR, Shillong
4. Union of India,
Represented by its Secretary,
Department of Science and Technology
2nd Floor Vishwakarma Bhawan,
Shaheed Jeet Singh, Marg,
New Delhi-110016.
…. Respondent(s)
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S. Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance: in WP (C) No. 420 of 2022
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. B.A. Wanswett, Adv.
vice Ms. P.D.B. Baruah, Sr. Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
Appearance: in WP (C) No. 430 of 2022
WP(C) No. 433 of 2022
WP (C) No. 112 of 2023
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. R. Dutta, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
These writ petitions being similar and related to appointments
made from the same advertisement dated 10.07.2021 issued by the North
East Centre for Technology Application and Reach (NECTAR) assailing
the same impugned order dated 07.10.2022, are being disposed of by this
common Judgment and Order.
2.
The writ petitioners in response to the advertisement, being
eligible and possessing the required qualifications had applied for different
posts, which will be detailed hereinafter. Thereafter, after passing through
the Screening Committee, the qualified candidates were then shortlisted for
Personal Interview and after appearing before the Selection Committee, the
petitioners on being successful, offer of appointments were issued to them.
The writ petitioners then joined their respective posts and were working
against the same, when they were served with the impugned letter dated
07.10.2022, whereby they were informed that the advertisement to the
posts they were holding had been considered null and void and the offer of
appointment to the said posts was to be treated as cancelled. Being
aggrieved thereby, the writ petitioners have preferred these writ petitions
before this Court.
3.
In brief, the details of the writ petitioners and against which
posts they had applied, is given hereinbelow: i)
WP(C) No. 420 of 2022 (Rakesh Kumar Sarmah)
Post applied – Chief Coordinator (Technical)
ii)
WP(C) No. 430 of 2022 (Simanta Das)
Post applied – Chief Radio Technologist
iii)
WP(C) No. 433 of 2022 (Simon Phukan)
Post applied - Senior Administrative Officer
iv)
WP(C) No. 112 of 2023 (Ankit Shrivastava)
Post applied – Software Engineer
The posts mentioned above against which the writ petitioners
had applied as per the advertisement dated 10.07.2022, were given at Serial
Nos. 3, 4, 5 (Scientific Post) and 11 (Administrative Post).
4.
On behalf of the petitioners, it has been argued by Smti.
P.D.B. Baruah, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. B.A. Wanswett and
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. R. Dutta, that the
appointments had been duly granted approval by the Governing Council of
NECTAR held on 18.04.2022, wherein at Item No. 4, at 4(A) it was clearly
recorded that all the Governing Council members endorsed their approval
and that, not a single representation from any candidate had been received.
It has been submitted that thereafter on 18.08.2022, the 9th Meeting of the
Governing Council was held, wherein the minutes of the 8 th Meeting of the
Governing Council were confirmed and adopted. In assailing the impugned
letter, it has been submitted that the ground for cancellation of the
appointments was stated to be due to certain representations in the matter
of recruitment which however, is belied by the fact that it has been
recorded in the minutes of the 8th Governing Council that not a single
representation had been received. It has been further submitted that though
the respondents have stated on affidavit that an Internal Committee was
formed to look into the recruitment process in NECTAR, the same is vague
as to the reason why a Committee was constituted when the recruitment
process had already been approved by the competent authority.
5.
The learned Senior counsels have also submitted that the
recruitment process having started with an offer, and the same being
accepted following a regular selection process, resulting in the
appointments of the petitioners, any action on the part of the respondents to
scrap the posts and or otherwise affect the employment of the petitioners,
would invite the rigours and safeguards as given in Article 311 of the
Constitution of India. The impugned letter having been issued without
granting any opportunity of hearing, it is contended, is in total violation of
the principles of natural justice and the respondents, after grant of approval
in respect of the appointments cannot now take a U-turn after the entire
selection process had been completed. Reference has also been made to
Rule-9 of the General Bye Laws of NECTAR, wherein it is provided that
each member or his representative of the Governing Body shall have one
vote, and if they be equality of votes on any question, then the Chairman
shall have a casting vote, which they contend in the instant case, the
Chairman’s absence in the said Meeting, wherein approval was granted,
will therefore have no bearing as his representative was present. It has also
been highlighted that under the same selection process, such as the
appointment to the post of Advisor (Technical), the same has not been
cancelled and further the recruitment process, had been carried out for
filling up of 25 number of posts, and only the 4 posts of the writ
petitioners, have been targeted for arbitrary and discriminatory treatment
by the respondents. As such, it is prayed that the impugned letter be set
aside and quashed, and the writ petitioners be allowed to continue in
employment as per the terms of their selection and appointment.
6.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI assisted by Ms. S. Rumthao,
learned counsel for the respondents in reply has submitted that the
advertisement dated 10.07.2021, had invited applications for filling up of
various
regular
posts
on
deputation,
including
short
term
contract/absorption failing which by direct recruitment and that in the
instant case of the petitioners, no effort was made to fill their posts on
deputation and the same were made straight away by direct recruitment.
Further, it is submitted that when the matter was proceeded in the
Governing Council Meeting held on 18.04.2022, the Chairman of the
Governing Council who is the Secretary to the Department of Science and
Technology (DST) GOI, was not available and hence the Meeting was
chaired by the Chief Secretary, Mizoram but that in the said Meeting, it
was also resolved that though all the members endorsed their approval, the
Chairperson desired to place the approval of the Governing Council before
the Secretary DST being the Chairman of NECTAR. The lapses in the
recruitment process were then noticed, he submits for which a Committee
was constituted, which after looking into the same, had recommended the
scrapping of the recruitment process. The matter it is then submitted, was
then taken up in the 9th Governing Council Meeting held on 18.08.2022,
where it was recommended by the Council to take necessary corrective
measures including scrapping of the said recruitment process and for fresh
recruitment to be initiated for recruitment to the 4 posts. He submits that it
was in this backdrop, the impugned letter dated 07.10.2022 was issued for
cancellation of the appointments of the petitioners.
7.
On another aspect, it has been argued that the appointment of
the other appointee to the post of Adviser Technical was not cancelled as
the same was given ex-post facto approval by the Governing Council and
moreover the Chairman, NECTAR himself, was in the Selection
Committee. It has also been submitted that in WP(C) No. 433 of 2022, the
writ petitioner therein was himself a member of the Screening Committee
and thereafter was declared as the selected candidate for the post of Senior
Administrative Officer. He finally submits that the entire selection process
was vitiated and in order to ensure fair and transparent selection in
accordance with the Recruitment Rules, the DST based on the report of the
Inquiry Committee had taken the decision to scrap the recruitment and to
do the same afresh.
8.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties. It is first to be noted
that the recruitment that was to be conducted, was to be as per the
Approved Recruitment Rules and Bye Laws of NECTAR. In this exercise
pursuant to the advertisement, as is evident from the materials and records
available, the Governing Council in its 7th meeting held on 14.10.2021, had
noted at Item 8 of the minutes, with regard to the revival of sanctioned
posts, its satisfaction in the progress of the recruitment process. Thereafter,
in the 8th meeting of the Governing Council held on 18.04.2022, at Item 4,
under the heading ‘Status of Recruitment Process and Approval of
Governing Council’, it was recorded at Sub-Para:4(A) as follows.
“Sub Para:4 (A)
GC was apprised about the recruitment process relating to
“Group-A” posts carrying Grade Pay of Rs.6600/- & above.
The criteria mentioned in the Recruitment Rules (RRs) and
role of GC in terms of rule 3(i) of Service Bye-laws of
NECTAR for regularization of Group-A posts carrying
Grade Pay of Rs.6600/- & above was explained in general
for seeking approval of GC.
Chairperson asked DG (NECTAR) to clarify whether
recruitment rules (RRs) of NECTAR as approved by the
appropriate authority (DoPT/MoF/DST) have been followed
in the matter.
DG, NECTAR assured the Chairperson and all other GC
members that RRs have been scrupulously followed and also
the procedure. Selection of candidates has been made by the
Selection Committee/Interview panel duly approved by the
Chairman, NECTAR in a transparent manner. Score sheet
of marks awarded by the Selection Committee duly signed by
each member of Committee is available for perusal and
records. The scores of each candidate were displayed on the
website of NECTAR. Not a single representation from any of
candidates has been received in this regard.
The offers of appointment were sent to the candidates in
order of merit following the precedent adopted by NECTAR
in recruitments made earlier and approved by GC as well.
Further, the status of recruitments has already been brought
to the kind notice of GC members through circulation vide
this office letter no. NECTAR (403)/DST/2020 dated
25.02.2022 for approval, for regularization of these
appointments in terms of para 3(i) of Service Bye-laws of
NECTAR and as advised by DST vide Under Secretary (A.I.
Division), letter no. AI/16/05/Misc/NECTAR/2020 dated
16.03.2022 (copy enclosed).
Executive Council of NECTAR has already approved these
recruitments during its meeting held on 21.02.2022.
It was also informed that approval of five (05) GC members
i.e., from Chief Secretary, Meghalaya, Manipur, Nagaland,
Sikkim and Secretary, NEC has already been communicated
through correspondence, as such approval of remaining GC
members was also sought for in terms of provisions
contained under Rule 9 & 10 Part-III of General Bye-laws
of NECTAR.
All the GC members endorsed their approval. Chairperson
desired to place approval of GC before Secretary DST being
Chairman NECTAR.”
9.
A perusal of the above quoted proceedings clearly shows that,
there was no quarrel or dispute as to whether there was any divergence
from the approved Recruitment Rules, inasmuch as, it is recorded therein
that, the RR’s had been scrupulously followed as also the procedure, and
that, the selection of candidates had been made by the selection
committee/interview panel, duly approved by the Chairman of NECTAR.
The same also records that the Executive Council of NECTAR, had already
approved the recruitments during its meeting held on 21.02.2022. All the
members of the Governing Council then, endorsed their approval and the
Chairperson desired that, the approval of the GC be placed before the
Secretary DST, being the Chairman of NECTAR.
10.
Thereafter only, it is noted that, the recruitments were then
sought to be scrapped in the 9th meeting of the Governing Council of
NECTAR, wherein in Item 14, under the heading ‘Any other item with
the permission of the Chair’ it was resolved to concur to the decision of
the Secretary DST, on the scrapping of the 4 posts, and for a fresh
recruitment to be gone into. This decision it is seen, was not on the basis of
an agenda item, and the decision was taken, even though at Item No. 1 of
the same meeting thereof, the minutes of the 8th meeting of the Governing
Council had been read out, confirmed and adopted. This in itself, leaves a
big question mark, as to the decision making process, in arriving at the
conclusion to scrap the recruitment. From the submissions of the learned
DSGI earlier, it had been asserted that, the recruitment was scrapped as the
Chairman of the Governing Council was not available on the 8 th meeting,
which was chaired by Dr. Renu Sharma, the Chief Secretary, Mizoram,
when the approval was accorded. The absence of the Chairman of the
Governing Council on the said meeting, however, speaks otherwise on an
examination of the Bye Laws of NECTAR itself, Bye Law 7 reads as
follows.
“7. A person holding the membership of the Governing Body
or the Governing Council by virtue of an office held by him
(ex-officio) shall normally attend the meetings himself in
person but in exceptional circumstances shall have the right
to nominate a representative, not below the level of Joint
Secretary to the Government of India, to act on his behalf.
The representative shall also have the voting right of the
member.”
As such, the absence of the Chairman therefore, cannot be a
ground to vitiate the recruitment process.
11.
Bye Law 9, has further provided that, each member or its
representatives shall have one vote, and if there be an equality of votes, on
any question to be decided, the Chairman shall have a casting vote. In the
absence of the Chairman, on a plain reading of the Rules and Bye Laws, in
a meeting of the Governing Council, as given in Rule 1 of the Rules, under
the heading ‘Proceedings of the Governing Council’, the same can also
be presided by a member, selected from amongst the members present. The
8th GC meeting, which had approved the recruitment, on being chaired by
the Chief Secretary of Mizoram, in the absence of the Chairman i.e. the
Secretary DST, therefore cannot be said to have acted without jurisdiction
and beyond the scope of its powers and functions, as given under the Rules
and Regulations of NECTAR, and its Bye Laws. It may be added that,
though the Secretary DST, by virtue of being the Chairman of NECTAR,
as per the Rules does not enjoy any special powers over and above the
General Council, to nullify and scrap a decision taken, passed and
confirmed by the General Council.
12.
The other aspect, which cannot be ignored by this Court, is that
in arriving at the impugned decision, which has been stated to be on the
basis of an Inquiry Report, is the total absence of any opportunity of
hearing being afforded to the writ petitioners, who on their appointments
have been visited with civil consequences. The total non-adherence to the
Principles of Natural Justice, notwithstanding any other circumstances, is
sufficient enough to cause interference with the impugned order. The other
grounds put up by the respondents that, the writ petitioner in WP(C) No.
433 of 2022, was himself a part of the Screening Committee, will also not
serve any purpose as the selection was conducted by a duly selected
committee, and as is well known, the Screening Committee is only to
examine the eligibility of candidates.
13.
The recruitment of the writ petitioners, as per the facts laid out
herein above, cannot be said, or held to be irregular or illegal, and at the
most due to the stipulation in the advertisement, that efforts should have
first been made to fill up the post by deputation including short term
contract, be said to have been made with a slight deviation from the
advertisement. In the instant case, the Recruitment Rules being followed,
and the approval accorded as per due process, the appointments of the
petitioners which are neither illegal or irregular, are therefore liable to be
reconsidered by the respondents, for regularization of appointment, subject
to the Rules as contained in the Service Bye Laws of NECTAR.
14.
Accordingly, in view of the findings and discussions made
herein above, these writ petitions are allowed, and the impugned letter
dated 07.10.2022, is hereby set aside and quashed.
15.
No order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
05.04.2024
“V. Lyndem PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review