Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010254842024
2026:GAU-AS:3764
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6451/2024
SILPI SIKHA SAIKIA AND ANR
W/O- LT. PRANJAL HAZARIKA,
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- BANMUKH DIHINGIA GAON,
P.O.- JOYAPARA,
DIST.- SIVASAGAR, ASSAM,
PIN- 785640.
2: RAJ PROTIM HAZARIKA
S/O- LT. PRANJAL HAZARIKA
TO BE REPRESENTED BY SMTI SILPI SIKHA SAIKIA (PETITIONER NO. 1)
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE- BANMUKH DIHINGIA GAON
P.O.- JOYAPARA
DIST.- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785640
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 7 ORS
REPRESENTED BY COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF
ASSAM,
HANDLOOM TEXTILE AND SERICULTURE DEPARTMENT,
DISPUR, GUWAHATI- 781006,
KAMRUP(M), ASSAM.
2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
DEPARTMENT OF PENSION
DISPUR
GUWAHATI
Page No.# 2/8
PIN- 781006
ASSAM.
3:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
FINANCE DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
PIN- 781006
ASSAM.
4:THE DIRECTOR OF SERICULTURE
ASSAM
KHANAPARA
GUWAHATI- 781022.
5:THE ACCOUNTANT GENERAL ( A AND E)
MAIDAMGAON
BELTOLA
GUWAHATI- 781029.
6:THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF SERICULTURE
CACHAR
SILCHAR
788001.
7:SMTI DEBAJANI BORAH
D/O- PABAN BORA
VILL- DAHIKHUR
DULAKAKHORIA
P.O.- BAHANA
P.S.- JORHAT
DIST.- JORHAT
ASSAM
PIN- 785101.
8:SRI PRANJAY PRANJAL HAZARIKA (MINOR)
S/O- LATE PRANJAL HAZARIKA
TO BE REPRESENTED BY SMTI DEBAJANI BORAH
VILL- DAHIKHUR
DULAKAKHORIA
P.O.- BAHANA
Page No.# 3/8
P.S.- JORHAT
DIST.- JORHAT
ASSAM
PIN- 785101
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A BARUAH, MR. S J SARMAH,MR. J P MORE
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, SERICULTURE, GA, ASSAM,SC, FINANCE DEPTT.,SC, AG
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SOUMITRA SAIKIA
ORDER
12.03.2026
Heard Mr. A Baruah, learned counsel for the petitioners.
2.
The petitioners before this Court claiming for family pension in respect of
the services rendered by late Pranjal Hazarika, who is stated to be the late
husband of petitioner No. 1 and late father of petitioner No. 2. According the
petitioners, the marriage of petitioner No 1 was solemnized with the late Pranjal
Hazarika on 14.12.2014 and out of the said marriage, the petitioner No. 2 was
born, who is about 8 years on the date of filing of the writ petition. During the
subsistence of their marriage, the late husband married for a second time,
namely the respondent No. 7.
3.
The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that in the employee data
sheet, the name of the petitioner No. 1 and petitioner No. 2 are reflected
besides the name of the father and mother of late Pranjal Hazarika. A next of
kin certificate has also been applied for and received by the petitioner No. 1
showing the name of the parents of late Pranjal Hazarika and the petitioner No.
1 and two sons, including petitioner No. 2 are reflected in the next of kin
certificate. The petitioners represented before the authorities, however, no
Page No.# 4/8
effective orders have been passed on the claims made by the writ petitioners.
4.
It is the claim of the petitioners that in spite of these particulars being
available with the respondent authorities, they have not proceeded to release
the pensionary benefits to the petitioners. It is the submission of the counsel for
the petitioners that in view of the objections raised by the private respondents
No. 7 and 8, the family pensionary benefits have not been commenced.
5.
Notices in the matter was issued as far back as 06.12.2024. Service on
respondents No. 7 and 8 are shown to be complete by the Lawzima court's
order dated 06.11.2025 but none is represented the respondents No. 7 & 8
when the matter is called up.
6.
Mr. R. Dhar, learned State counsel submits that his instructions are
awaited. He would like to file an affidavit in the matter.
7.
The question of entitlement of pensionary benefits by the first wife vis-à-
vis the claims of the other wives is a controversy which gives confronting the
Courts over and above.
8.
In Rameshwari Devi Vs State of Bihar and Ors , reported in (2000) 2 SCC
431, the Apex Court has clearly held that second wives are not entitled to
pension. However, children born out of the marriage with the second wives,
however, would be entitled to get pensionary benefits subject to the parameters
specified in the pension Rules. This has been followed in several judgments by
this Court.
9.
A Full Bench of this Court in Junufa Bibi (Mustt) vs. Padma Begum (Mustt)
& Ors. (W.A. No.160/2018) reported in 2023 (1) GLT (FB) 736 has laid down the
law in respect of the claims towards family pension by second wife, this Court in
the said Judgment as held under:
“………
Page No.# 5/8
15. As reading of Rule 143(1) goes to show that for the purpose of family pension a
family would comprise of the relatives of the officer, which also includes the wife in
case of a male officer. If the second or further wives of a male officer are acceptable
and valid under the personal law governing the parties, we see no reason as to why
such second or further wives would not be construed to be a wife of the male officer.
16. If the validity and acceptability of the marriage of a second wife or further wives
where parties are governed by Mohammedan Law would be determined by the
personal laws of the parties, and the personal laws provide for the validity and
acceptability of such marriage, the second wife or the further wives where parties are
governed by Mohammedan Law, would have to be construed to be also the family
members of the deceased employee and therefore, under Rule 143(1) of the Pension
Rules of 1969 be entitled to the benefits of a family pension.
17. But a further question remains as to whether being entitled to the benefits of a
family pension would also necessarily mean that the State Authorities providing for a
family pension would have to pay or apportion and pay the family pension to the
second and further wives of a deceased employee separately where the parties are
governed by the Mohammedan Law.
18. For the purpose, we look into the provisions of Note 1 to Rule 143(ii) of the
Pension Rules of 1969. A reading of Rule 143 (i) of the Pension Rules of 1969 makes
it discernable that the wife in case of a male officer would be included as a family for
the purpose of the Rules and a marriage for the purpose of pensionery benefits to
the spouse of a retired official shall mean a marriage before or after retirement. Note
1 to Rule 143 (ii) provides that in cases where there are two or more widows pension
will be payable to the eldest surviving widow and on her death, it will be payable to
the next surviving widow and the term eldest would mean seniority with reference to
the date of marriage. Rule 143 (iii) further provides that the pension so awarded
under Rule 143 will not be payable to more than one member of the officer’s family
at the same time.
19. A conjoint reading of Note 1 to Rule 143 (ii) and Rule 143 (iii) of the Pension
Rules of 1969 makes it explicit and unambiguous that the family pension would be
payable to the eldest of the surviving widow in the event of there being two or more
Page No.# 6/8
widows and further that even if there are minor children who may also be entitled to
the benefits of the family pension, the pension would be paid to only one member of
the family at the same time, where at first instance it would be paid to the eldest of
the surviving widow and thereafter, on her death to the next surviving widow, if any
and in its absence to the minor children.
20. As a corollary to the provisions of the Rule 143 (iii) of the Pension Rules of 1969,
Note 1 to Rule 143 (ii) would have to be read to mean that the family pension would
be payable to the eldest of the surviving widows in the event there are two or more
widows, and thereafter, on her death it would be payable to the next surviving
widow, if any and thereafter, to the minor children if the occasion arises.
21. In the circumstance, the concept of a validity and acceptability of a second
marriage where the parties are governed by the Mohammedan Law and the
consequential entitlement to the benefits of a family pension and the concept to
whom the family pension would be payable under the Pension Rules of 1969 are held
to be two separate and unrelated concepts and the implication of the concept of a
validity and acceptability of a second marriage or further marriages where the parties
are governed by the Mohammedan Law would have no bearing on the concept to
whom the family pension is payable under the Pension Rules of 1969. It is held that
irrespective of the validity and acceptability of a second marriage or further marriages
where the parties are governed by the Mohammedan Law, the family pension under
Rule 143 of the Pension Rules of 1969 would be payable to the eldest of the surviving
widow, which would also be applicable for a family pension where the parties are
governed by the principles of Mohammedan Law, and where there may be a validity
and acceptability of the second wife or further wives in respect of a deceased
Mohammedan employee.
22. We further hold that the family pension being payable to the eldest of the
surviving widow or wife would not mean that the entire family pension so payable
would be the personal property of the eldest of the surviving widow or wife and the
family pension so payable would be held by the eldest of the surviving widow or wife
as a trustee for all such other persons who are entitled to the benefits of the family
pension in terms of Rule 143 of the Pension Rules of 1969.
Page No.# 7/8
23. We also provide that in the event any such other persons who are entitled to the
benefits of the family pension in terms of Rule 143 of the Pension Rules of 1969,
including the second or further wives, in a case where the parties are governed by
the Mohammedan Law, are not appropriately maintained by the eldest of the
surviving widow or wife to whom the pension would be paid, the remedy thereof
would be to make a claim for maintenance in the appropriate forum under the law
and not a claim for a payment of the family pension by the State authorities directly
to such persons. But however, if in a given case the State authorities on their own
volition are of the view that under an acceptable circumstance the authorities are
agreeable or required to pay the pension separately to any such member of a family
of a deceased employee, this judgment may not be construed to be an absolute bar
on such separate payment.”
10. The department is to look into the grievances and pass appropriate orders
in the manner provided. In the terms of the amendments brought by 9 th of
August 2018 to the Assam Services (Pension) Rules, it is provided that in case
where there are 2 or more family members, minor son, unmarried dependent
daughters, etc. present at the death of the widow/widower, the family pension
should be divided to the eldest eligible member who will divide it equally
amongst other eligible members. This however, is the process required to be
adopted in cases where there are 2 or more family members present at the time
of the death of the widow or widower i.e. after the family pension benefits have
already been conferred to the widow or widower of the government employee.
11. However, this policy has also been adopted by this Court in the Full Bench
Judgment, whereby such claims by other family members who claim to be
family members of the government servant, will have to be given their share of
pension by the widow/widower. In view of the law laid down in the full bench,
this Court proceeds to dispose of the writ petition without waiting for the
counter affidavit to be filed by the department
Page No.# 8/8
12. The department will therefore examine the case of the petitioners vis-à-vis
the claims of respondents No. 7 and 8 and if there are any materials available to
suggest that respondent No. 7 is also a wife/widow of late Pranjal Hazarika,
then the family pension should be divided in terms of the directions mentioned
hereinabove.
13.
With the above observation, the writ petition stands disposed of. The
directions be carried out within 60 days from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this order.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review