Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Petitioner
:
Sikkim Public Service Commission
versus
Respondents :
Sikkim Information Commission and Another
Application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Aarohi Bhalla, Senior Advocate with Mr. Bhusan Nepal, Advocate
for the Petitioner.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Advocate for the Respondent No.1.
Respondent No.2 present in person.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing
:
02-04-2026
Date of Judgment
:
02-04-2026
Date of Uploading
:
03-04-2026
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The
instant
application
under
Article
of
the
Constitution of India has been filed by the Sikkim Public Service
Commission (SPSC), the Petitioner herein, impugning the Orders
dated 17-06-2025 and 22-07-2025, of the State Information
Commission, Sikkim, Respondent No.1, in Appeal No.7/SIC/2025
[Mrs. Reha Bhandari vs. State Public Information Officer (SPIO),
Sikkim Public Service Commission, Gangtok, Sikkim].
2.
The facts, briefly summarised, are that, the Respondent
No.2 herein filed an application under the Right to Information Act,
2005 (hereinafter, “RTI Act”), dated 07-12-2024, before the
Petitioner, State Public Information Officer (hereinafter, “SPIO”),
SPSC, inter alia, seeking the disclosure of consolidated merit list of
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
all candidates who appeared in the interview/viva-voce for the
Sikkim Services (Combined Recruitment) Examination, 2022. The
Petitioner vide communication dated 26-12-2024 informed the
Respondent No.2 that the information sought would be considered
on completion of the examination process. On 19-03-2025 the
requisite information was furnished to the Respondent No.2.
(i)
The Respondent No.2
being dissatisfied with such
information, filed an Appeal before the First Appellate Authority, i.e.,
the Secretary, SPSC, on 04-04-2025 under the provisions of the RTI
Act.
(ii)
After hearing the parties, the First Appellate Authority,
SPSC, vide its Order dated 19-05-2025, disposed of the Appeal with
the direction that the SPIO, SPSC, shall initiate the process of
seeking consent from the selected candidates for disclosure of their
marks in accordance with Section 11 of the RTI Act.
(iii)
The Respondent No.2 being dissatisfied by the Order of
the First Appellate Authority, SPSC, preferred a Second Appeal
before the Respondent No.1, State Information Commission, on the
same date, i.e., 19-05-2025.
(iv)
The Petitioner submitted its counter statement on 10-
06-2025 before the Respondent No.1, highlighting the legal aspects,
as two matters concerning the said examination were pending
before the High Court. The Respondent No.1, it is urged by Learned
Senior
Counsel
for
the
Petitioner,
without
considering
the
submissions put forth by the Petitioner passed an Order dated 1706-2025 directing the SPIO, SPSC, to provide the consolidated merit
list of all candidates who appeared in the interview/viva-voce
including their marks, within fifteen days from the date of Order and
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
to file a compliance report on or before 03-07-2025 to the
Respondent No.1. It is further contended by Learned Senior Counsel
for the Petitioner that, despite the two Writ Petitions pending before
this Court, the Respondent No.1 vide its Order dated 22-07-2025
directed the Petitioner to file a compliance report, in detail, along
with the documentary proof as to how furnishing the information to
the Petitioner, Respondent No.2 herein, would hamper the matters
pending before this Court.
(v)
It was also contended that the provisions of the RTI Act
provides a limited mechanism to deal with third party information
under Section 11 of the RTI Act. In the instant matter, the Petitioner
issued Notice to the third party, under Section 11(1) of the RTI Act,
but did not receive consent from the third parties except from one
candidate. Recourse was also taken to Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act
and it was urged that the information sought was personal
information and an invasion of privacy, consequently, the entire
information could not be furnished to the Respondent No.2. The
impugned Orders, according to Learned Senior Advocate, were
passed in a mechanical manner, without any reference to the
threshold of the larger public interest nor do the Orders record any
findings as to why such interest outweighs the right of a third party.
Information cannot be disclosed without complying with the express
provisions contained in the RTI Act and such direction cannot be
sustained in the eyes of law being contrary to the Statute. Hence,
the impugned Orders dated 17-06-2025 and 22-07-2025 passed by
the State Information Commission, Respondent No.1, be set aside
being without jurisdiction and contrary to the provisions of the RTI
Act. It was further prayed that this Court declare that the Petitioner
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
was justified in denying disclosure of the information sought being
exempted under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act.
3.
The Respondent No.2 did not file any written response,
however she is present in the Court room and submitted that she
had in fact no submissions to make before this Court.
The Court
informed her that being a woman, she is entitled to “free legal aid”
and should she require, the Court would immediately engage a
Counsel for her from the panel of legal aid lawyers present in the
Court room or an Advocate of her choice. The Respondent No.2 in
the open Court room submitted that she did not desire to engage
any Advocate to represent her and she would make her submissions
which were to the extent that, all that she had required from the
Petitioner, was the consolidated list of marks of the selected
candidates as the examination, viz., Sikkim Services (Combined
Recruitment) Examination, was to a public office and, according to
her, the marks obtained by the candidates ought to have been put
out in the public domain.
4.
Heard
Learned
Counsel
for
the
parties
and
the
Respondent No.2 in extenso and perused the documents relied on
by the Petitioner.
5.
It
appears
that
the
Petitioner
had
issued
an
advertisement on 29-09-2022, inviting online applications for the
posts of Deputy Superintendent of Police, Under Secretary and
Accounts Officer under the Sikkim Services (Combined Recruitment)
Examination, 2022 and the results of the preliminary examination
was
declared
on
07-01-2023.
examination was conducted.
On
04-02-2024,
the
Mains
On 07-10-2024, a Notice was issued
for scrutiny of original documents and conduct of the viva-voce of
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
the qualified candidates for the advertised posts and on 05-12-2024
Notice of the final results of the selected candidates for the three
posts was declared. The Respondent No.2 admittedly failed to get
selected. On 07-12-2024, the Respondent No.2 filed the RTI Act
application before the SPIO, SPSC, who undertook to furnish the
information after completion of the entire selection process.
The
information was accordingly given to the Respondent No.2 on 1903-2025. In the information supplied to the Respondent No.2, it was
replied inter alia that the information sought by the Respondent
No.2 relates to a third party and information is of a personal nature
and as such it is exempted from disclosure under Section 8(1)(j) of
the RTI Act.
(i)
The Respondent No.2 approached the First Appellate
Authority, SPSC, who vide its Order dated 19-05-2025, observed
inter alia as follows;
“……………………………………………………………
1. The SPIO shall initiate the process of seeking
consent from the selected candidates for
disclosure of their marks, in accordance with
Section 11 of the RTI Act, 2005.
…………………………………………………………………”
The First Appeal was accordingly disposed of.
(ii)
On the same day, i.e., 19-05-2025, before the SPIO
could even comprehend the Order of the First Appellate Authority,
the Respondent No.2 was before the State Information Commission,
Respondent No.1, in Second Appeal, aggrieved by the Order of the
First Appellate Authority, SPSC.
(iii)
The
Respondent
No.1,
the
State
Information
Commission (the Second Appellate Authority) in Second Appeal,
after hearing both parties on 17-06-2025 advised the Petitioner to
release the information, i.e., the consolidated merit list with marks
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
of written and viva-voce of all selected candidates on its website, to
reduce the burden of individual RTI Act applications and to uphold
transparency as per Section 4 of the RTI Act. On 22-07-2025, the
Respondent No.1 issued another Order, observing therein that, the
Order of the Respondent No.1 had directed the Petitioner to provide
the consolidated merit list of all selected candidates, including their
marks in written and viva-voce within fifteen days from the date of
Order and to file a compliance before the Commission.
(iv)
The Petitioner however informed the Respondent No.1
that in relation to the Sikkim Services (Combined Recruitment)
Examination, 2022, two matters are pending before the High Court
of Sikkim and disclosure of the consolidated marks could prejudice
the pending judicial proceedings. The Respondent No.1 was of the
contrary view that the Petitioner ought to file a compliance report in
detail with the documentary proof as to how the information would
hamper the proceedings before this Court.
(v)
From the obtaining circumstances, it is apparent that on
19-05-2025 the Petitioner was to initiate the process of seeking
consent from the selected candidates for disclosure of their marks in
accordance with Section 11 of the RTI Act. Section 11 provides for
third party information and as the marks sought was with regard to
third persons, the consent of the persons who was selected was
sought by the Petitioner. Section 11(3) of the RTI Act provides that,
the State Public Information Officer shall within forty days after the
receipt of the request under Section 6 (i.e., request for obtaining
information), if the third party has been given an opportunity to
make a representation under sub-Section (2), the SPIO shall make a
decision as to whether or not to disclose the information, or record,
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
or part thereof and give in writing the Notice of his decision to the
third party.
(vi)
Thus, it is clear that the said provision requires the
concerned authority to take steps within forty days after receipt of
the request, however instead of waiting for the time period as
prescribed therein, the Respondent No.2 had immediately on the
same day, i.e., 19-05-2025, dissatisfied with the Order of the First
Appellate Authority approached the Respondent No.1, the Second
Appellate Authority, against the Order of the First Appellate
Authority, SPSC.
(vii)
Besides the Second Appellate Authority failed to address
the apprehensions raised by the Petitioner that the information was
of a personal nature, by putting forth its own opinion as to how such
information was not of a personal nature or how disclosure of such
information satisfied larger public interest.
6.
The
application
of
the
Respondent
No.2,
in
my
considered view, was a premature application and the Respondent
No.1 before passing the impugned Orders failed to take note of the
Orders of the First Appellate Authority, which had invoked the
provisions of Section 11(3) of the RTI Act, 2005.
Besides the
application of the Respondent No.2 at Serial No.4 itself is ambiguous
and reads as follows;
“……………………………………………………………
4. Marks Obtained:
o
Kindly provide the marks I obtained in the
Mains Written Examination for each paper.
o
Please include the marks separately for
subjective papers and objective papers.
………………………………………………………”
[emphasis supplied]
WP(C) No.56 of 2025
Sikkim Public Service Commission
7.
vs. Sikkim Information Commission and Another
The impugned Orders dated 17-06-2025 and 22-07-
2025 of the Respondent No.1 are quashed and set aside being
contrary to the provisions of the RTI Act as discussed hereinabove.
8.
The Respondent No.2 is however at liberty to take steps
in the instant matter, before the First Appellate Authority and the
Respondent No.1, in terms of the legal provisions.
9.
With the above observations, the Writ Petition stands
disposed of.
10.
Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
02-04-2026
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review