Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 20th April, 2023
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------DIVISION BENCH : THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWANATH SOMADDER, CHIEF JUSTICE
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
:
Petitioners
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others
versus
Respondents
:
Union of India and Others
Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Manoj Goel, Senior Advocate with Mr. Naman Kamboj and
Ms. Anusha Basnet, Advocates for the petitioners.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel for Respondent
Nos.1 and 2.
Mr. Vivek Kohli, Advocate General with Ms. Y. W. Rinchen,
Government Advocate (as they were, at the time of hearing) and
Ms. Pema Bhutia, Assistant Government Advocate for
Respondent No.3.
Mr. T. R. Barfungpa, Advocate with Ms. Tshering Laki, Advocate
for Respondent No.4.
None present for Respondent No.5.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
In this Public Interest Litigation the Petitioners inter alia
seek the following reliefs;
“a.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order
or
direction
to
the
respondents
for
the
enforcement of various Constitutional and/or legal
rights of the petitioners and/or enforcement of various
Constitutional and legal duties and obligations of the
respondents; and
b.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to direct the respondents to take all
the requisite steps to consider to reserve seats in the
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
Sikkim Legislative Assembly for different section (sic)
of the people of Sikkim including the Sikkimese
Gorkhas in terms of Article 371F(f); and
c.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to direct the respondents to take all
the requisite steps to consider to provide beneficial
treatment to different sections of the people of Sikkim
including the Sikkimese Gorkhas as provided under
Article 371F(g); and
d.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction thereby directing the respondents to
take all the requisite steps to consider to remove the
name of the Bhutia, except Sherpa, given in the
Constitution (Sikkim) Scheduled Tribes Order, 1978;
or alternatively issue a writ, order or direction
including a writ in the nature of mandamus or any
other appropriate writ, order or direction thereby
directing the respondents to take all the requisite
steps to consider to exclude the creamy layer of the
Bhutia
and
others
included
in
the
Constitution
(Sikkim) Scheduled Tribes Order, 1978; and
e.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to direct the respondents to take all
the
requisite
steps
to
consider
to
withdraw/
discontinue excessive reservation of seats in the
Sikkim State Legislative Assembly in favour of Bhutias
under Article 371F(f) and/or Article 332 and/or Article
342 of the Constitution read with R.P. Act, the same
provisions being only „transitional‟ and having become
spent force; and
f.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of Certiorari or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction thereby striking down/declaring that
the provisions of Sections 7(1A)(a) of 1950 Act and
5A(1)(a), 5A(2)(a) of 1951 Act, so far they relate to
Bhutias, except Sherpa, being essentially transitional
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
in nature, now cease to have any valid effect in law as
well as in fact; and
g.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to the respondents to consider and
take all the requisite steps to increase the total
number of seats in the Sikkim Legislative Assembly
from the present 32 to 60 under Article 170 or to such
other
appropriate
numbers
as
may
be
found
necessary and for reservation of Assembly seats in
proportion to various sections of the people of Sikkim;
and
h.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to the respondents to consider and
to take all the requisite steps to reserve the seats in
the Sikkim Legislative Assembly for Schedule Tribes of
Limboo and Tamangs under Article 332 and/or Article
371F(f) of the Constitution; and
i.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to the respondents to take all the
requisite steps to consider and provide reservation of
Assembly seats to the eligible Scheduled Tribes
strictly in proportion to their respective population;
and
j.
issue a writ, order or direction including a writ in the
nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ,
order or direction to the respondents to take all the
requisite steps to consider and reserve seats in the
Sikkim Legislative Assembly for Gorkha community
strictly in proportion to their population; and
k.
grant all or any of the foregoing prayers either
cumulatively or alternatively.
l.
issue any appropriate order or direction thereby
granting any other relief that the petitioners may be
found entitled to; and
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
m.
issue any other appropriate writ, order or direction as
this
Court
may
deem
fit
and
proper
in
the
circumstances of this case.”
2.
Respondent 3 filed objection to the Petition, wherein it
is averred that in view of the reliefs sought, the Writ Petition is not
maintainable for the reason that prayers (b), (f), (e), (i) and (j) as
reflected hereinabove, were considered by a Constitution Bench of
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in R. C. Poudyal vs. Union of India and
Others .
That, prayer (c) invoking Article 371F(g) besides being
vague is a matter in the discretion of His Excellency the Governor.
That, prayer (d) is contrary to the provisions of Article 342 of the
Constitution of India which provides that any exclusion or inclusion
in the Presidential Order can be only by way of Legislation by the
Union Parliament.
The prayer to exclude the creamy layer of
Bhutias and others included in the Constitution (Sikkim) Scheduled
Tribes
Order,
1978,
is
not
applicable
to
Scheduled
Castes/Scheduled Tribes as laid down in Indra Sawhney and Others
vs. Union of India and Others2 and also Ashoka Kumar Thakur vs.
Union of India and Others .
falling
within
Parliament.
the
That, prayer (g) is a subject-matter
exclusive
legislative
competence
of
the
Prayers (a), (k), (l) and (m) are in general terms and
if the other reliefs are not maintainable, as submitted, these
prayers may also be dealt with accordingly.
That, in prayer (h),
the Supreme Court has issued directions in the case of Harry Ram
Pradha (sic) and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others
which is being
pursued by the State Government, hence the Petition be dismissed.
1994 Supp (1) SCC 324
1992 Supp (3) SCC 217
(2008) 6 SCC 1
Writ Petition (Civil) No.90 of 2006 decided on 04-01-2016
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
3.
Respondent Nos.1 and 2 in their joint preliminary
objection while seeking deletion of the name of Respondent No.1
from the array of Respondents as no reliefs were claimed from the
said official, akin to Respondent No.3 averred that prayers (g) and
(h) herein have been dealt with by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Harry Ram Pradha
(supra) and is under consideration of the
Respondent No.2 Ministry.
4.
Although Respondent No.4 entered appearance in the
matter no objection was filed. Respondent No.5 was duly served
with notice but was not represented in the matter.
5.
Petitioner No.6, one Kishan Chettri responding to the
question of maintainability raised by Respondent No.3 contended
inter alia that none of the questions of law raised in the instant
Writ petition were raised in R. C. Poudyal (supra) and the
preliminary objection of the Respondent Nos.1 and 2 is liable to be
dismissed being bereft of merit.
6.
Relevantly, it may be mentioned that I.A. No.10 of
2022 filed on 16-02-2022 was an application for placing on record
inter alia a copy of authorization letter empowering one Balbir
Tamang, President of Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh, for appearing
before this Court in connection with the instant PIL being WP(PIL)
No.10 of 2018.
Vide Order dated 07-12-2021, this Court had
ordered the Petitioners to place on record a copy of the resolution
of the Board of Trustees of the said Trust, reflecting such
empowerment as pleaded in the Writ Petition. I.A. No.11 of 2022
was filed on 19-03-2022 whereby an application for placing of
complete Trust Deed was filed along with a copy of the Trust Deed,
which was taken on record by the Court but the resolution of
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
authorization referred to above was not filed.
There is no
document to indicate that Respondent No.6 was at any point of
time authorized by the Petitioners to file any petition/response on
their behalf.
This circumstance is being flagged in view of the
response filed by the Respondent No.6 to the question of
maintainability raised by the Respondents and the averment of
Balbir Tamang referred to above, that he has been specifically
empowered to appear in this matter by the Petitioners.
7(i).
Having considered the rival verbal contentions of
Learned Counsel for the parties on the maintainability of the Writ
Petition and having perused the pleadings and all appended
documents it is imperative to refer to the Constitution Bench
Judgment of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in R. C. Poudyal (supra).
The prayers in the said Writ Petition are extracted herewith for
convenient reference;
“a. Issue an appropriate, Writ, Order or
direction declaring the Provisions of the
Representation of People (Amendment) Act 1980,
No.8 of 1980 as unconstitutional and illegal.
a. (i)
Issue an appropriate writ, order or
direction declaring Article 371F(f) of the
Constitution (thirty sixth) Amendment
Act, 1975 as unconstitutional.
a. (ii)
Issue an appropriate writ, directions or
order declaring that the Constitution and
continuance of the present Legislative
Assembly of Sikkim is illegal and
unconstitutional.
a. (iii) Issue an appropriate writ, order or
direction restraining respondents No.1 to
3 from holding, in future, the election to
the Legislative Assembly of Sikkim in
accordance with the impugned Act.
(b)
Pass such other orders which this Hon‟ble
Court deem fit and proper in the interest of
Justice.”
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
(ii)
The majority Judgment was delivered in the said
matter by Venkatachaliah, Verma and Reddy, JJ. At Paragraph 85,
the points for determination therein were enumerated as follows;
“85. On the contentions urged in support of the
petitions, the points that fall for consideration, are the
following :
(a)
Whether the questions raised in the
petitions pertaining as they do to the
terms and conditions of accession of new
territory are governed by rules of public
international law and are non-justiciable
on the „political questions doctrine‟?
(b)
Whether clause (f) of Article 371-F of the
Constitution of India, introduced by the
Constitution (Thirty-sixth Amendment)
Act, 1975 is violative of the basic
features of democracy?
(c)
Whether Section 7(1-A) and Section 25A of the Representation of the People
Act, 1950 [as inserted by Election Laws
(Extension to Sikkim) Act, 1976 and
Representation
of
the
People
(Amendment) Act, 1980 respectively]
and Section 5-A(2) of the Representation
of the People Act, 1951 [as inserted by
the Representation of the People
(Amendment) Act, 1980] providing for
reservation of 12 seats, out of 32 seats
in the Sikkim Legislative Assembly in
favour
of
Bhutias-Lepchas,
are
unconstitutional as violative of the basic
features of democracy and republicanism
under the Indian Constitution?
(d)
Whether the aforesaid provisions and the
reservations
made
thereunder
are
violative of Articles 14, 170(2) and 332
of the Constitution? Whether they violate
„one person one vote‟ rule? Or are these
differences justified in the historical
background of Sikkim and are incidental
to the political events culminating in the
cession of Sikkim?
(e)
Whether the reservation of 12 seats out
of 32 seats reserved for Bhutias-Lepchas
is ultra vires clause (f) of Article 371-F in
that while that provision enabled the
protection of the rights and interests of
different sections of population of Sikkim
and for the number of seats in the
Legislative Assembly which may be filled
by the candidates belonging to such
sections,
the
impugned
provisions
provide for one section alone, namely,
the Bhutias-Lepchas.
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
(iii)
(f)
Whether, at all events, in view of the
Constitution (Sikkim) Scheduled Tribes
Order, 1978, declaring Bhutias and
Lepchas as a Scheduled Tribe, the extent
of reservation of seats is disproportionate
and violative of Article 332(3) of the
Constitution which requires that the
number of seats to be reserved shall
bear as nearly as may be, the same
proportion to the total number of the
seats in the Assembly as the population
of the Scheduled Tribe in the State bears
to the total population of the State.
(g)
Whether the reservation of one seat for
Sangha to be elected by an Electoral
College of Lamaic monasteries is based
purely on religious distinctions and is,
therefore, unconstitutional as violative of
Articles
15(1)
and
of
the
Constitution and as violative of the
principle of secularism?”
With regard to point (a) supra the majority while
elaborating its ultimate reasoning in Paragraphs 101 to 105 of the
Judgment concluded at Paragraph 105; “Contention (a) requires to
be and is rejected.” At Paragraph 104, it was observed thus;
“104. Even if clause (f) of Article 371-F is
valid, if the terms and conditions stipulated in a law
made under Article 2 read with clause (f) of Article
371-F go beyond the constitutionally permissible
latitudes, that law can be questioned as to its validity.
The contention that the vires of the provisions and
effects of such a law are non-justiciable cannot be
accepted.”
(iv)
Points (b), (c) and (d) were taken up next for
consideration. The arguments and reasonings for these points are
elucidated in Paragraphs 106 to 131. At Paragraphs 128, 129 and
131, it was concluded as follows;
“128. From 1975 and onwards, when the
impugned provisions came to be enacted, Sikkim has
been emerging from a political society and
monarchical system into the mainstream of a
democratic way of life and an industrial civilisation.
The process and pace of this political transformation is
necessarily reliant on its institutions of the past. Mere
existence of a Constitution, by itself, does not ensure
constitutionalism or a constitutional culture. It is the
political maturity and traditions of a people that
import meaning to a Constitution which otherwise
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
merely embodies political hopes and ideals. The
provisions of clause (f) of Article 371-F and the
consequent changes in the electoral laws were
intended to recognise and accommodate the pace of
the growth of the political institutions of Sikkim and to
make the transition gradual and peaceful and to
prevent dominance of one section of the population
over another on the basis of ethnic loyalties and
identities. These adjustments and accommodations
reflect political expediencies for the maintenance of
social equilibrium. The political and social maturity
and economic development might in course of time
enable the people of Sikkim to transcend and
submerge the ethnic apprehensions and imbalances
and might in future — one hopes sooner — usher in a
more egalitarian dispensation. Indeed, the impugned
provisions, in their very nature, contemplate and
provide for a transitional phase in the political
evolution of Sikkim and are thereby essentially
transitional in character.
129. It is true that the reservation of seats of
the kind and the extent brought about by the
impugned provisions may not, if applied to the
existing States of the Union, pass the constitutional
muster. But in relation to a new territory admitted to
the Union, the terms and conditions are not such as to
fall outside the permissible constitutional limits.
Historical considerations and compulsions do justify
inequality and special treatment. ………….
………………………………………………………….
131. We are of the view that the impugned
provisions have been found in the wisdom of
Parliament necessary in the admission of strategic
border-State into the Union. The departures are not
such as to negate fundamental principles of
democracy. We accordingly hold and answer
contentions (b), (c) and (d) also against the
petitioners.”
(v)
For points (e) and (f) the discussions obtained at
Paragraphs 132 to 135 wherein at Paragraphs 133, 134 and 135 it
was held as follows;
“133. Shri Jain contended that Bhutias and
Lepchas had been declared as Scheduled Tribes under
the Constitution (Sikkim Scheduled Tribes) Order,
1978 and that the extent of the reservation in their
favour would necessarily be governed by the
provisions of Article 332(3) of the Constitution which
requires that the number of seats to be reserved shall
bear, as nearly as may be, the same proportion to the
total number of seats in the Assembly as the
population of the Scheduled Tribes in the State bears
to the total population of the State. But, in our
opinion, clause (f) of Article 371-F is intended to
enable, a departure from Article 332(3). This is the
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
clear operational effect of the non-obstante clause
with which Article 371-F opens.
134. Shri Jain pointed out with the help of
certain demographic statistics that the degree of
reservation of 38 per cent in the present case for a
population of 20 per cent is disproportionate. This
again has to be viewed in the historical development
and the rules of apportionment of political power that
obtained between the different groups prior to the
merger of the territory in India. A parity had been
maintained all through.
135. We are of the opinion that the provisions
in the particular situation and the permissible
latitudes, cannot be said to be unconstitutional.”
(vi)
On
point
(g),
discussions
were
detailed
from
Paragraphs 136 to 138 of the Judgment and at Paragraph 137 it
was held that;
“137. The Sangha, the Buddha and the
Dharma are the three fundamental postulates and
symbols of Buddhism. In that sense they are religious
institutions. However, the literature on the history of
development of the political institutions of Sikkim
adverted to earlier, tend to show that the Sangha had
played an important role in the political and social life
of the Sikkimese people. It had made its own
contribution to the Sikkimese culture and political
development. There is material to sustain the
conclusion that the „Sangha‟ had for long associated
itself closely with the political developments of Sikkim
and was interwoven with the social and political life of
its people. In view of this historical association, the
provisions in the matter of reservation of a seat for
the Sangha recognises the social and political role of
the institution more than its purely religious identity.
In the historical setting of Sikkim and its social and
political evolution the provision has to be construed
really as not invoking the impermissible idea of a
separate electorate either. Indeed, the provision
bears comparison to Article 333 providing for
representation for the Anglo-Indian community. So far
as the provision for the Sangha is concerned, it is to
be looked at as enabling a nomination but the choice
of the nominee being left to the „Sangha‟ itself. We
are conscious that a separate electorate for a religious
denomination would be obnoxious to the fundamental
principles of our secular Constitution. If a provision is
made purely on the basis of religious considerations
for election of a member of that religious group on the
basis of a separate electorate, that would, indeed, be
wholly unconstitutional. But in the case of Sangha, it
is not merely a religious institution. It has been
historically a political and social institution in Sikkim
and the provisions in regard to the seat reserved
admit of being construed as a nomination and the
Sangha itself being assigned the task of and enabled
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
to indicate the choice of its nominee. The provision
can be sustained on this construction. Contention (g)
is answered accordingly.
138. For the foregoing reasons, all the
petitions are dismissed without any order as to
costs.”
8.
In light of the discussions and decisions extracted
above, it is apposite to now consider the prayers raised by the
Petitioners in the instant Writ Petition.
Prayer (a) in the instant
Writ Petition is nebulous and unfathomable as it fails to specify
which constitutional and legal rights of the Petitioners and various
constitutional and legal duties of the Respondents are sought to be
enforced.
Insofar as the other prayers enumerated by the
Petitioner are concerned, points (b), (c) and (d) in R. C. Poudyal
(supra) answers the reliefs sought for in prayers (b), (d), (e), (f)
and (j) of the instant Writ Petition. The remaining relief sought for
in prayer (d) of the instant Petition seeking exclusion of the creamy
layer of Bhutia and others included in the Constitution (Sikkim)
Scheduled Tribes Order, 1978 cannot be considered by this Court in
light of the pronouncement of the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in Indra
Sawhney
(supra) and Ashoka Kumar Thakur (supra).
In Ashoka
Kumar Thakur (supra) the Supreme Court observed that;
“186. Moreover, right from the beginning, the
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes were treated
as a separate category and nobody ever disputed
identification of such classes. So long as “creamy
layer” is not applied as one of the principles of
equality, it cannot be applied to the Scheduled Castes
and Scheduled Tribes. So far, it is applied only to
identify the socially and educationally backward
classes. We make it clear that for the purpose of
reservation, the principles of “creamy layer” are not
applicable for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled
Tribes.”
Discussions in points (e) and (f) of R. C. Poudyal (supra) are
directly related to prayers (c) and (i) of the reliefs sought in the
Writ Petition herein. Hence, these prayers are determined by the
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
ratio in R. C. Poudyal (supra). As submitted by Learned Counsel for
the Respondent Nos.1 and 2, prayers (g) and (h) of the instant
Writ Petition have been dealt with by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in
Harry Ram Pradha (supra) and the matter is under consideration of
the Respondent No.2 Ministry.
9.
In terms of Article 141 of the Constitution of India, the
Judgments of the Supreme Court are the law of the land and
binding on all Courts and Tribunals.
In this context, reference is
made to Namit Sharma vs. Union of India5 and M/s. East India
Commercial Co. Ltd., Calcutta and Another
vs. Collector of Customs,
Calcutta .
10.
This Court is indeed aware that the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court has observed at Paragraph 128 of the ratio in R. C. Poudyal
(supra) that “Indeed, the impugned provisions, in their very
nature, contemplate and provide for a transitional phase in the
political evolution of Sikkim and are thereby essentially transitional
in character” and the Petitioners in prayers (e) and (f) have sought
for a direction that excessive seats in the Sikkim Legislative
Assembly in favour of Bhutias be withdrawn, the provisions being
transitional. However, the “transitional phase” is to be considered
and determined by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court in view of its
observation supra.
11.
Consequently, this Court cannot delve into matters duly
considered and determined by the Hon‟ble Supreme Court as
discussed above.
(2013) 1 SCC 745
AIR 1962 SC 1983
WP(PIL) No.10 of 2018
Sikkim Gorkha Jagaran Sangh and Others vs. Union of India and Others
12.
The Writ Petition stands disposed of accordingly.
13.
No order as to costs.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
ds
( Biswanath Somadder )
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review