Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 19
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No. 128/2021
…. Petitioner/Appellant(s)
Sikander Sharma
Through:-
Mr. R.K.S. Thakur, Advocate.
V/s
…..Respondent(s)
Additional Commissioner,
Jammu and others
Through:-
Ms. Priyanka Bhat, Advocate vice
Mrs. Monika Kohli, Sr. AAG.
Mr. Ajay Abrol, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
ORDER
09.02.2026
1.
The petitioner, through the present petition, has challenged the order
dated 06.01.2021 passed by the Revisional Authority, i.e., the Court of
Additional Commissioner, Jammu (with the powers of Divisional
Commissioner), whereby the revision petition was disposed of with a
direction to the court below to proceed with the partition in accordance
with the applicable partition rules, after affording an opportunity of
hearing to the interested persons/parties, and thereafter to pass an
appropriate order. While passing the aforesaid order, the Revisional
Authority further directed that any status quo order earlier issued by it
shall stand vacated.
2.
The impugned order was admittedly passed with the consent of
learned counsel for the parties. Before adverting to the rival submissions,
reference is required to be made to order dated 21.10.2019 passed by the
Page |2
concerned Tehsildar, whereby the application for partition filed by
respondent No. 4 was kept in abeyance and the applicants were advised to
file a suit for possession in terms of Rule 12 of the Jammu and Kashmir
Land Revenue (Partition) Rules, 1970.
3.
For facility of reference, Rule 12 of the aforesaid Rules is reproduced
hereunder:
“12. Limitation for appeals, revisions and reviews-(1) [Save as
otherwise provided in this Act.] the period of limitation for an
appeal under the last foregoing section shall be as follows:(a) When the appeal lies to the Collector or an Assistant
Collector of the first class.
(b) When the appeal lies to the Financial Commissioner or
Divisional Commissioner.
Provided that, in the Districts of Ladakh and Gilgit twice the
ordinary period of limitation for appeals under this Section
shall be allowed.
(2) Such provisions of the Limitation Act as apply to
appeals, applications for revision and review in civil suits
shall also apply to appeals, applications for revision and
review under this Act.”
4.
Since the petitioner, in the application filed before the concerned
Tehsildar, admitted that he was not in possession of the land sought to be
partitioned, the Tehsildar recorded a finding that the partition proceedings
were barred under Rule 12 of the aforesaid Rules.
5.
Mr. Thakur, learned counsel for the petitioner, has further drawn the
attention of the Court to another communication dated 23.11.2019 issued by
the Deputy Commissioner, Samba, whereby the concerned Tehsildar was
directed to attend the office along with the partition file, on the ground that
Page |3
he had refused to effect partition at the final stage of the case, despite having
obtained reports from his subordinate staff and field functionaries.
6.
Pursuant thereto, the concerned Tehsildar passed an order dated
19.10.2020, whereby the Naib Tehsildar, Surara, was directed to deliver
possession of the land to respondents No. 3 to 10 (private respondents
herein) by evicting the petitioner. Aggrieved of the said order, the petitioner
preferred a revision petition before the Additional Commissioner, Jammu
(with the powers of Divisional Commissioner), which is the subject matter of
challenge in the present petition.
7.
By virtue of the aforesaid order passed by the Revisional Authority, the
matter was relegated to the court below with a direction to proceed with the
partition in accordance with the applicable Partition Rules, after affording
full opportunity of being heard to all interested persons/parties, and thereafter
to pass an appropriate order. The said order came to be passed with the
consent of learned counsel for the parties.
8.
The petitioner, through the medium of the present petition, has assailed
the said order on the ground that the same is contrary to the facts and law and
is liable to be set aside.
9.
It has been vehemently urged by learned counsel for the petitioner that
respondents No. 3 to 10 and Bharat Bhushan were not in possession of any
portion of the land at any point of time. This fact, according to learned
counsel, had already been admitted by the private respondents before
respondent No. 2. Even in the application for partition, it was not specifically
pleaded that they were in possession of any portion of the land, and rightly
Page |4
so, as their predecessor-in-interest had already transferred his share to
different persons.
10. In the aforesaid factual backdrop and in view of the admission of
respondents No. 3 to 10, the petition for partition was held to be not
maintainable and, accordingly, a reasoned order dated 21.10.2019 came to be
passed by respondent No. 2, whereby further proceedings in the partition
application were suspended with a direction to respondents No. 3 to 10 to
file a suit for possession, as required under Rule 12 of the Partition Rules.
The said order was not challenged before any appropriate fora and has,
therefore, attained finality. The subsequent order dated 19.10.2020 passed by
respondent No. 2 is, thus, dehors the law, without jurisdiction, and a nullity
in the eyes of law, and is liable to be set aside.
11. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on Rule 12 of the
Partition Rules, which provides that where the parties are not in possession
of any portion of the land, the Revenue Officer shall lay his hands off and
suspend the proceedings, granting liberty to the applicants to file a regular
suit for possession before the competent court of law. It is submitted that the
said provision is mandatory in nature. Therefore, once a valid order dated
21.10.2019 was passed in conformity with Rule 12, the Revenue Officer had
no jurisdiction to proceed further in the partition application.
12. It is further contended that respondents No. 3 to 10 admittedly did not
file any suit for possession in respect of the land which was made the subject
matter of the partition application. Accordingly, the further proceedings
conducted by respondent No. 2 and the order dated 19.10.2020 were without
jurisdiction and void ab initio.
Page |5
13. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for respondents No. 3 to 7
submitted that the petitioner and the private respondents are co-sharers in
land measuring about 182 kanals in Village Surara, Tehsil Hiranagar and
since the land remained undivided and continues to remain same till date.
14. Mr. Ajay Abrol, learned counsel appearing on behalf of private
respondents, submits that the private respondents herein are descendants of
Sh. Punnu Ram and their father Sh. Parmanand, who was survived by three
sons and two daughters, and that they had rightly filed a petition under
Section 105 of the Land Revenue Act seeking partition of the joint land
among co-sharers. The matter ultimately came to be decided by the
Revisional Authority on 06.01.2021.
15. Learned counsel for the private respondents further submitted that the
order passed by the Revisional Authority merely remands the matter to the
concerned Tehsildar to proceed in accordance with the Partition Rules and,
therefore, the present petition challenging the remand order is devoid of
merit. According to learned counsel, the only plea raised before the
Revisional Authority was that the petitioner had not been heard by the Court
below while passing the impugned order, which plea, it is contended, is
contrary to the record.
16. It has also been argued that the impugned order has been passed by
respondent No. 1 with the consent of learned counsel for the parties and
suffers from no legal infirmity. It is further submitted that the petitioner as
well as the answering respondents continue to be co-sharers and are entitled
to claim their respective shares in the land in question. In addition, it has also
been urged that the private respondents have filed the petition under Section
Page |6
105 of the Land Revenue Act strictly in accordance with the Rules, being cosharers in the land, and are thus entitled to seek partition of their shares.
17. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
18. With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, the instant petition
is taken up for final disposal.
19. The order passed by the Revisional Authority was limited to directing
the Court below to proceed with the partition in accordance with the
applicable Partition Rules and, that too, after affording an opportunity of
being heard to all interested persons/parties, and thereafter to pass an
appropriate order. Thus, before passing any final order, the authority below
was required to satisfy itself, in terms of the Partition Rules, whether
partition was permissible and to do so only after granting due opportunity of
hearing to the interested persons/parties.
20. Once the order, which is the subject matter of the present petition, was
passed by the Revisional Authority with the consent of learned counsel for
the parties, the petitioner is estopped in law from questioning the same
through the medium of the present petition. A bare perusal of the operative
portion of the said order shows that no prejudice has been caused to the
petitioner, as the direction to the Court below is only to proceed in
accordance with the Partition Rules after providing an opportunity of hearing
to the interested persons/parties. In the absence of any plea of fraud, coercion
or patent lack of jurisdiction, a consent order cannot ordinarily be reopened.
21. The issue involved in the present case is squarely covered by the
judgment of this Court in ‘Sooba and another vs. Amar Nath Krishan Lal’,
Civil 1st Appeal No. 15 of 1981, decided on 29.09.1987, has held as under:
Page |7
“7. The other point canvassed by the learned counsel for the appellants is
that the agreement entered into between the parties was not reduced in
writing by the trial Judge and in absence of such statements it cannot be
said that the parties consented to the order being passed. In my opinion,
this argument is also not tenable because their need not be any written
terms of agreement between the parties placed before the court and it is
enough if the judgment discloses that the decree was passed on the basis
of the consent of the parties. Advocates of both the parties are authorized
agents for the parties and their statements before the court would bind the
parties and the parties are estopped from resiling there from in appeal by
saying that it was not a deeree u/s 96(3) C.P.C. In the present case the
counsel for the parties arrived at certain agreement and because of the
consent given by them, the trial Judge passed the consent decree. The
decree thus passed by the trial court was a consent decree and as
contemplated u/s 96(3) C.P.C. the present appeal is incompetent.”
22. The principle laid down in the aforesaid judgment of this Court clearly
settles that statements made by learned counsel, acting as authorized agents
of the parties, are binding upon them and operate as an estoppel. Once the
record reflects that an order has been passed on the basis of consent so given,
it is not open to a party to subsequently contend that such consent was not
validly given or that the order is not binding. The ratio of the said judgment
squarely applies to the facts of the present case.
23. The Hon’ble Supreme Court in ‘Ajanta LLP vs. Casio Keisanki
Kabushiki Kaisha d/b/a Casio Computer Co. Ltd. and another’, 2022
LiveLaw (SC) 127, has observed:
“12. A judgment by consent is intended to stop litigation between the
parties just as much as a judgment resulting from a decision of the Court at
the end of a long drawn-out fight. A compromise decree creates an estoppel
by judgment. It is relevant to note that in Byram Peston Gariwala (supra),
this Court held that the Appellant therein did not raise any doubt as to the
Page |8
validity or genuineness of the compromise nor a case was made out by him
to show that the decree was vitiated by fraud or misrepresentation. While
stating so, this Court dismissed the Appeal.
13. …..Correspondence between the advocates for the parties who are experts
in law would show that there is no ambiguity or lack of clarity giving rise to any
misunderstanding. Even assuming there is a mistake, a consent decree cannot be
modified/ altered unless the mistake is a patent or obvious mistake. Or else,
there is a danger of every consent decree being sought to be altered on the
ground of mistake/ misunderstanding by a party to the consent decree.”
24. The law, therefore, stands settled that consent given by learned
counsel, acting within the scope of their authority, binds the parties whom
they
represent.
In
the
absence
of
any
allegation
of
fraud,
misrepresentation or patent mistake, a consent order cannot be permitted
to be challenged merely because a party subsequently wishes to resile
from the position taken through its counsel.
25. Applying this settled position to the present facts, since the order of
the Revisional Authority was passed with such valid consent and remains
unchallenged on grounds of fraud or mistake, the procedural mandate
contained therein must now be given full effect. It was, therefore,
incumbent upon the Court below to proceed strictly in conformity with the
Partition Rules and to grant an opportunity of being heard to the interested
persons before passing any appropriate order. However, that stage has not
arisen, as the order passed by the Revisional Authority came to be
challenged before this Court, whereupon status quo was granted on
01.02.2021. As a result, the Court below was not permitted to proceed with
the partition proceedings in terms of the Partition Rules.
Page |9
26. This Court is of the view that continuation of the interim direction is not
in the interest of justice. Accordingly, the ends of justice would be met if the
interim restraint imposed by this Court is lifted and the order passed by the
Revisional Authority is revived by relegating the parties to the court below,
with a direction to proceed with the partition in accordance with the Partition
Rules, after affording an opportunity of being heard to the interested
persons/parties. Such course would enable adjudication on merits by the
competent authority in the first instance.
27. In view of the foregoing discussion, and particularly in light of the
settled legal position governing consent orders, this Court finds no
illegality or jurisdictional error in the order dated 06.01.2021 passed by
the Revisional Authority. The said order merely directs the Court below to
proceed in accordance with the applicable Partition Rules after affording
opportunity of hearing to all interested persons and does not cause any
prejudice to the petitioner.
28. Accordingly, the interim order dated 01.02.2021 passed by this Court
is vacated. The order dated 06.01.2021 passed by the Revisional Authority
is upheld and the matter is remitted to the court below to proceed strictly
in accordance with the Partition Rules, after granting opportunity of
hearing to all concerned, and to pass an appropriate reasoned order.
29. The petition is, accordingly, disposed of.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
Jammu:
09.02.2026
Michal Sharma/PS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review