Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!
"
!
$
%&' % (
)*
'%
)
+
!
#
"
$#
%
$
&
""
!'(
#
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
$
)
#&
$
*
!'(
&
*
&
%
&
!'('
&
%
+
&
!'(
#
!*
$
)
#&
&
$
-2-
*
% %"
'%(
* &
!
#
$
$
%
+ % %
*
"
*
*
% % %
&
*
**
&
"#%$# $
" + '
*
&$
" % % % % %
(
*
*
&
*
&
,&
*
*
*
*
-&
./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582:
<><:/?
9:<?0.<
<5./3< % %" 022?/5> 34 @9<0. 1:4;228/5>0
<></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 <;;9028
+ % %
7A27
'
2;3/45 '%( 46 &.<:<3/=<
#<:/0/5> 493 46
:/A2
40 % <58 " /5
17 #
$
4 % % % $ :2>/032:28 B= 3.2
47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 02;3/450 " +
" %
% %
% % 46
<58
2;3/45 "#%$#C$ 46
-3-
# :2C253/45 46
3:4;/3/20$
D
;3E$ 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72 46
#
<58
'
$
A258A253
200/45 <58
12;/<7 98>2
%
.2
6<;39<7
% %
<3 <B493
;3 %
' #64: B:2C/3=
88/3/45<7
/03:/;3
/F<=<19:
A<3:/G
"
H.25 :201458253
1A
3.2
;<02
/0
3.<3
4 % <58
./0 6<3.2: #54H 82;2<028 /5 3./0 ;<02$ H2:2 1:4;228/5> /5 <
A434: ;=;72 6:4A 3.2/: <>:/;9739:<7 7<58 34H<:80
7A27 <58
H.25 3.2= :2<;.28 52<:
/3= 04A2
<:5<3<?< &<5? /5
7A27
95?54H5 <;;9028 12:045 H<0 1:4;228/5> 34H<:80 3.2A /5 <
H:45> 8/:2;3/45
.2 0<A2 H<0 @9203/4528 B= 3.2 :201458253
4 % <3 3.<3 3/A2 .2 /564:A28 3.<3 < 3:<;34: /0 1<:?28 45 3.2
:/>.3 0/82 46 3.2 0</8 :4<8 .25;2 .2 /0 1:4;228/5> /5 3.2 H:45>
8/:2;3/45
9:/5> 09;. <732:;<3/45 3.2 0</8 12:045 <00<97328
:201458253
4 % 45 ./0 ;.22? <58 <B9028 ./A /5 6/73.=
7<5>9<>2
.2 0<A2 H<0 @9203/4528 B= 3.2 6<3.2: 46
:201458253
4%
3 3.<3 3/A2 3.2 0</8 12:045 344? 493 < ?5/62
H./;. H<0 B252<3. 3.2 02<3 46 3.2 A434:;=;72 <58 03<BB28 /534
3.2 034A<;. 46 :201458253
4 %,0 6<3.2:
.25 :201458253
4 % A<82 <5 <332A13 34 :20;92 ./0 6<3.2: 3.2 0</8 12:045
<704 3:/28 34 <00<973 ./A
632: /567/;3/5> 09;. /5F9:= 3.2 19B7/;
><3.2:28 3.2:2 <58 @9203/4528 3.2 12:045 H.4 03<BB28
-4-
:201458253
4 %,0 6<3.2: <58 <3 3.<3 3/A2 /3 H<0 :2C2<728 3.<3
./0 5<A2 H<0
C2584:
F/3. 045 46
5<58
<32: :201458253
<58<:>/ <58 .2 H<0 < 6:9/3
4 % <58 ./0 6<3.2: H<0 <8A/3328 /5
3.2 .401/3<7 <58 748>28 3.2 ;4A17</53 <></503 3.2 0</8
/2
<;;9028
'
3:2<3A253 :201458253
9:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46
4 %,0 6<3.2: 09;;9AB28 34 3.2 /5F9:/20
% %
"
5 3.2 03:25>3. 46 ;4A17</53 3.2 *
:2>/032:28 /5
9582:
% %
F/3.
:/A2
4% % %
2;3/45 "%" "%
64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72
" + <58 '
89:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46 /5C203/><3/45
<::20328 3.2 <;;9028
;<A2 34 B2
45 %%
9B02@92537=
:201458253
(% %
4 ! 47/;2
9:/5> 3.2 ;49:02 46
./0 /5C203/><3/45 /5 ./0 C47953<:= 03<32A253 .2 :2C2<728 3.<3
<632: 3.2 /5;/8253 .2 20;<128 <58 H253 34
3.2:2<632:
58.:< :<820. <58
<.<:<0.3:< <58 123/3/452:
4 % /0 B:43.2: 46 <;;9028
4 " B2/5> ./0 :27<3/C2
<58 23/3/452:
<;;9028
4 % / 2 <;;9028
2G325828 A4523<:= .271 34 ./A 34
20;<12 6:4A 3.2 ;793;.20 46
47/;2 <58 <;;9028
0.2732: 34 <;;9028
0 09;.
/2
4 " .<0 >/C25
:201458253
! 47/;2
/A17/;<328 3.202 123/3/452:0 /5 3.2 ;:/A2 64: 3.2 46625;2
195/0.<B72 9582:
2;3/450 % % <58 % % 46
632:
-5-
;4A1723/5> 3.2 /5C203/><3/45
:201458253! 47/;2 7</8 ;.<:>2
0.223 <></503 <;;9028
<58 3.202 123/3/452:0 64: 3.2
46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582:
% % 46
72<:528
<58
2;3/450 " + '
2;3/45 "#%$#C$ 46 3.2
" %
#
%
$
12;/<7 98>2 344? ;4>5/I<5;2 46 46625;20
<58
;3
.2
25;2 3.2
123/3/452:0 6/728 3./0 123/3/45 34 @9<0. 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503
3.2A
2<:8 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 <58
72<:528
!
/>.
3<32
49:3
4C2:5A253
201/32 02:C/;2 46 543/;2 :201458253
543 <112<:28 B264:2 3./0
'
72<82: 64: 3.2 :201458253
4 % .<0
49:3
1<:3 6:4A 9:>/5> 02C2:<7 ;453253/450 3.2 72<:528
;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 .<0 ;45325828 3.<3 <8A/33287= 3.2
/5;/8253 H<0 ;<9028 45
'
% %
B23H225 3.2 :201458253
4 % ./0 82;2<028 6<3.2: <58 <;;9028
201458253
4%
/0 <5 2=2 H/35200 34 3.2 /5;/8253 <58 <;;4:8/5> 34 ./A 3.2
<;;9028
1/;?28 91 < @9<::27 H/3. ./A <58 ./0 6<3.2: <58
892 34 3.2 <732:;<3/45 .2 344? 493 < ?5/62 6:4A ./0 A434:;=;72
<58 03<BB28 45 3.2 <B84A25 46 3.2 82;2<028 / 2
:201458253
4%
0 < :20973
3.2 6<3.2: 46
./0 6<3.2: 0903</528 02C2:2
-6-
B7228/5> /5F9:/20 <58 09B02@92537= 09;;9AB28 34 3.2 /5F9:/20
8A/33287=
3.202 123/3/452:0 H2:2 52/3.2: /5 3.2 0;252 46
4;;9::25;2 54: 1<:3/;/1<328 /5 3.2 /5;/8253 8/:2;37= 4: /58/:2;37=
.2 <772><3/45 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 /0 3.<3 <;;9028
H./72 <B0;458/5> .2 344? 0.2732: H/3. 3.2 .271 46 <;;9028
4"
<58
<3
<;;9028
4%
2G325828
A4523<:=
.271
./A
<.<:<0.3:< &93 3.2 ;.<:>2 0.223 A<32:/<7 8420 543 8/0;7402
3.<3 <;;9028
4 % 2G325828 A4523<:= B2526/3 <58 <;;9028
4 " >/C25 0.2732: 34 ./A ?54H/5> 6977= 3.<3 <;;9028
/5C47C28 /5 3.2 ;4AA/00/45 46 3.2 <772>28 ;:/A2
;/:;9A03<5;20
5 09;.
2G;213 3.2 C47953<:= 03<32A253 46 <;;9028
<B0479327= 54 43.2: 1/2;2 46 2C/825;2 A<32:/<70 <C</7<B72
45 :2;4:8 34 /A17/;<32 3.202 123/3/452:0 /5 3.2 <772>28 ;:/A2
&= :27=/5> 45 3.2 F98>A253 46 3.2
2:<7<
/>.
4!4:8/5<32 &25;. 46 3.2
49:3 /5 3.2 ;<02 46
.2 ;45325328 3.<3 /5 4:82: 34 /5C4?2
% % <58 % % 46
2;3/45
< 021<:<32 ;<02 .<0 34 B2 :2>/032:28 <58 /3
.<0 34 B2 /5C203/><328 021<:<327= <58 B<028 45 3.2 C47953<:=
03<32A253 3.2 43.2: <;;9028 ;<5543 B2 /A17/;<328 /5 3.2 A</5
;<02
<58
;.<:>2
0.223
;<5543
B2
;;4:8/5>7= .2 1:<=0 34 <774H 3.2 123/3/45
7</8
<></503
3.2A
-7-
3.2 72<:528
4114028 3.2 1:<=2:
B= ;453258/5> 3.<3 3.<3 3.2 ;.<:>2 0.223 A<32:/<70 8/0;7402 3.<3
<;;9028
4 % 2G325828 3.2 A4523<:= .271 34 <;;9028
<;;9028
4 " 1:4C/828 0.2732: 34 <;;9028
<58
/5 < 3./5 0.28 <3
9AB</ 34 20;<12 6:4A 3.2 ;793;.20 46 3.2
47/;2 B= ?54H/5>
6977= 3.<3 <;;9028
2;3/45 " % 46
;4AA/3328 3.2 .2/5490 46625;2 9582:
5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;20
3.2 1:4;228/5>0
;<5543 B2 @9<0.28 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0
;;4:8/5>7= .2
1:<=0 34 8/0A/00 3.2 123/3/45
+
.<C2 >/C25 A= <5G/490 ;450/82:<3/45 B43. 45 3.2
09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/C2
1<:3/20 <58 12:9028 3.2 84;9A2530 A<82 <C</7<B72 45 :2;4:8
(
0 ;4978 B2 ><3.2:28 6:4A :2;4:80
8/01932 3.<3 3.2 /5;/8253 H<0 ;<9028 45
"
1A
% %
<3 <B493
H.25 3.2 82;2<028 <58 :201458253
4 % H2:2
3:<C27/5> /5 3.2/: A434:;=;72 52<:
;;4:8/5> 34 :201458253
4%
'
/3 /0 543 /5
<:5<3<?< &<5? /5
<;;9028
7A27 ;/3=
;<A2 6:4A 3.2
H:45> 8/:2;3/45 /5 < A434:;=;72 <58 3.2:2 H<0 < C2:B<7
<732:;<3/45 B23H225 3.2A H./;. 39:528 /534 < @9<::27 B23H225
:201458253
4 % ./0 6<3.2: <58 3.2 <;;9028
.2:2B=
-8-
3.2 <;;9028
03<BB28
82;2<028
3.2
344? 493 < ?5/62 6:4A ./0 A434:B/?2 <58
/2
6<3.2:
:201458253
4%
.2:2<632: ./0 6<3.2: H<0 0./6328 34 .401/3<7 <58 .2 09;;9AB28
34 3.2 /5F9:/20
C2: 0/5;2 3.25 <;;9028
<58 <632: < 7<102 46 ( A453.0 45 %%
B= 3.2 :201458253! 47/;2
H<0 <B0;45828
(% %
.2 H<0 <::20328
.2:2<632: ./0 C47953<:= 03<32A253
H<0 :2;4:828
3 /0 3.2 <772><3/45 /5 3.2 ;.<:>2 0.223 3.<3 89:/5>
3.2 ;49:02 46 /5C203/><3/45 <;;9028
3.2
47/;2 3.<3 <;;9028
C4795322:28 B264:2
4 % B2/5> ./0 B:43.2: <58 <;;9028
4 " B2/5> ./0 :27<3/C2 >/C25 0.2732: <58 2G325828 A4523<:=
.271 34 <;;9028
34 <B0;458 6:4A 3.2 ;<02
5 12:90<7 46
3.2 253/:2 ;.<:>2 0.223 A<32:/<70 <0 :/>.37= ;45325328 B= 3.2
72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0
03<32A253 46 <;;9028
2G;213 3.2 C47953<:=
<B0479327= 54 43.2: 1/2;2 46
2C/825;2 <C</7<B72 45 :2;4:8 34 /A17/;<32 3.2 123/3/452:0 /5 3.2
;:/A2
.2 03<32A253 46 43.2: H/3520020 <704 8420 543 8/0;7402
3.2 /5C47C2A253 46 <;;9028
:2012;3
40 % <58 " /5 3.2 ;:/A2 /5 <5=
C25 43.2:H/02 /3 /0 543 3.2 ;<02 46 :201458253!147/;2
3.<3 <;;9028
40 % <58 " <:2 >/C25 0.2732: 4: A45/34:= .271 B=
?54H/5> 6977= 3./0 <;;9028
H<0 /5C47C28 /5 3.2 .2/5490
-9-
;:/A2
.2:2 <:2 54 09;. <332A130 A<82 B= 3.2 47/;2 34 :2;4:8
3.2 03<32A253 46 <5= A<32:/<7 H/3520020 34 3.<3 2662;3
3 /0 0233728 140/3/45 46 7<H 3.<3 B<028 45 3.2
03<32A253 46 < ;4!<;;9028 54 12:045 ;<5 B2 /A17/;<328 /5 3.2
;:/A2 <0 <5 <;;9028
3.<3
3 /0 <704 2@9<77= 0233728 140/3/45 46 7<H
/5 4:82: 34 /5C4?2
2;3/45 % % 4: % % 46
3.2
/5C203/><3/45 .<0 34 B2 ;4589;328 B= 147/;2 021<:<327= <632:
>233/5> 12:A/00/45 6:4A 3.2
<>/03:<32 0/5;2 /3 /0 < 8/03/5;3
46625;2 B= :2>/032:/5> < ;:/A2
5 3.2 1:/5;/1<7 46625;2 3.2 ;4!
<;;9028 ;<5543 B2 /A17/;<328 9582: 3.2 0</8 1:4C/0/45
5 3.<3
C/2H 46 3.2 A<332: 2C25 /6 3.2 253/:2 <772><3/45 <></503 3.202
123/3/452:0 /0 <;;21328 45 /30 6<;2 C<792 <704
3.2 <772><3/45
A<82 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 84 543 A<?2 493 <
;<02 64: 3.2 46625;20 9582:
2;3/450 % % 4: % % 46
5 09;.
;/:;9A03<5;20 3.2 ;453/59<3/45 46 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.202
123/3/452:0 /0 543./5> B93 <5 <B902 46 3.2 1:4;200 46 ;49:3
.2
45-B72
12G
49:3 /5 3.2 ;<02 46
:214:328 /5
"
! #$% .278 3.<3 3.2
!!
49:3 4H20 < 893= 34 744? /534
A<5= 43.2: <33258/5> ;/:;9A03<5;20 543 457= 3.2 *
4: ;.<:>2
- 10 -
0.223 <772><3/450 H./72 @9<0./5> 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <58 3.2
49:3
4H20 < 893= 34 744? /534 A<5= 43.2: <33258/5> ;/:;9A03<5;20
2A2:>/5> 6:4A 3.2 :2;4:80 46 3.2 ;<02 4C2: <58 <B4C2 3.2
<C2:A2530 <58 /6 522828 B2 H/3. 892 ;<:2 <58 ;/:;9A012;3/45
3:= 34 :2<8 /5 B23H225 3.2 7/520
.2
F9:/08/;3/45 9582:
:
2;3/45
(% 46
49:3 H./72 2G2:;/0/5> /30
4:
:3/;72 %%
46 3.2
4503/393/45 5228 543 :203:/;3 /30276 457= 34 3.2 03<>2 46 < ;<02
B93 /0 2A14H2:28 34 3<?2 /534 <;;4953 4C2:<77 ;/:;9A03<5;20
72<8/5> 34 3.2 /5/3/<3/45 4: :2>/03:<3/45 46 3.2 ;<02 <0 H277 <0
3.2 A<32:/<70 ;4772;328 /5 3.2 ;49:02 46 /5C203/><3/45
/503<53 ;<02
<0 8/0;90028
5 3.2
3.2:2 <:2 54
A<32:/<70 17<;28 B= 3.2 1:402;93/45 34 ;453/592 3.2 1:4;228/5>0
<></503 3.202 123/3/452:0
25;2
<A 46 3.2 ;450/82:28 C/2H
3.<3 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.202 123/3/452:0 /0 7/<B72 34 B2
@9<0.28
;;4:8/5>7=
1:4;228 34 1<00 3.2 64774H/5>J
/
.2 123/3/45 /0
//
.2
&
1:4;228/5>0
123/3/452:0 <;;9028
#
$
+ % %
<></503
3.2
40 % <58 " /5
# :/A2
4% % % $
- 11 -
:2>/032:28 B=
7A27
47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;2
195/0.<B72 9582: 02;3/450 " +
% %
% % 46
#
$
<58
;3 %
" %
2;3/45 "#%$#C$ 46
' 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72
88/3/45<7
/03:/;3 <58
98>2
/F<=<19:
12;/<7
'
200/45 <58
/0
.2:2B=
@9<0.28
4H2C2:
/3 /0 A<82 ;72<: 3.<3
;453/592 <></503 <;;9028
3.2 1:4;228/5>0 0.<77
,*
%
!
)
!
/03
%
%
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review