Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2023:SHC:175
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 10th June, 2025
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
:
Petitioners
SICPA India Private Limited and Another
versus
Respondents
:
Union of India and Others
Application under Articles 226 and 227
of the Constitution of India
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Ms. Ankit Kanodia and Mr. Passang Tshering Bhutia, Advocates for
the Petitioners.
Ms. Sangita Pradhan, Deputy Solicitor General of India for the
Respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
The
Assistant
Commissioner,
Services Tax (CGST) and Central
Central
Excise,
Goods
Gangtok
and
Division,
Gangtok, Sikkim, vide Order dated 08-02-2022, rejected the
refund application filed by the Petitioners, claiming unutilized Input
Tax Credit (ITC), lying in Electronic Credit Ledger amounting to ₹
4,37,61,402/- (Rupees four crores, thirty seven lakhs, sixty one
thousand, four hundred and two) only, upon discontinuance of
business.
(i)
The
Commissioner
Petitioners
of CGST
were
before
the
Additional
and Central Excise, Siliguri
Appeals
Commissionerate, assailing the same.
2.
The Appellate Authority, vide Order dated 22-03-2023,
upheld the Order dated 08-02-2022, of the Assistant Commissioner
(supra). It was reasoned that on a combined reading of Sections
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
54(3) and 29 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017
(hereinafter, the “CGST Act”), it is evident that the current
regulations do not provide for refund of unutilized ITC in case of
discontinuation or closure of business.
That, it is evidently clear
from the provisions mandated in Section 54(3) of the CGST Act
which is restricted to circumstances under which the unutilized ITC
is allowed for refund, discontinuation/closure is not one of them.
3.
In the instant Petition, the prayers put forth inter alia
are to quash, delete and set aside the impugned Order dated 2203-2023, passed by the Respondent No.3 rejecting the claim for
refund of unutilized ITC, on closure of its business.
Further, to
order that, proviso to Section 54(3) of the CGST Act is not
applicable in respect of refund of unutilized balance of ITC under
Section 49(6) of the CGST Act.
4.
The Petitioners case summarized is that, it was
engaged in the business of manufacturing security inks and
solutions with GST registration in the State of Sikkim.
The
manufacturing units of the Petitioners were in full operation in the
pre-GST regime.
The Petitioners in January, 2019, decided to
discontinue its operation in the State of Sikkim, pursuant to which
the Petitioners sold all the machineries and manufacturing facilities
from April, 2019 to March, 2020. At the time of sale of assets the
Petitioners had appropriately reversed the ITC as per the applicable
provisions under the GST law.
The Petitioners had accumulated
balance of ITC amounting to ₹ 4,37,61,402/- (Rupees four crores,
thirty seven lakhs, sixty one thousand, four hundred and two) only,
on account of the closure of its business and accordingly claimed
refund of such unutilized ITC balance, in terms of Section 49(6) of
the CGST Act, which entails that the balance in Electronic Credit
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
Ledger after payment of tax, penalty, fee or in every amount
payable may be refunded in accordance with the provisions of
Section 54 of the CGST Act, which was refused as reflected supra
and has given rise to this Petition.
(i)
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners submitted that
Section 49(6) of the CGST Act provides for refund of the balance in
Electronic Cash Ledger and Electronic Credit Ledger after payment
of tax in accordance with the provisions of Section 54 of the CGST
Act which lays down the procedure for refund. Section 54(3) of the
CGST Act is the exception carved out in the provision, which
requires that a registered company may claim refund of unutilized
ITC at the end of any tax period, provided that, no refund of
unutilized ITC shall be allowed except as provided in Section
54(3)(i) and (ii) of the CGST Act.
It is contended that the said
exemption cannot take away the vested right of ITC accrued to the
Petitioners and refund thereof under Section 49(6) of the CGST
Act.
The Appellate Authority has failed to discuss as to why the
provisions of Section 49(6) is not applicable in the Petitioners case.
To buttress the submissions, reliance was placed on Shabnam
Petrofils Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India , The Union of India vs. Slovak
India Trading Company Private Limited
and Eicher Motors Ltd. and
Another vs. Union of India and Others .
5.
Per contra, Learned Deputy Solicitor General of India
for the Respondents contesting the claims argued that, closure of
business is not recognized under the statute as an eligible ground
for
refund
and
independently
provide
2019 SCC OnLine Guj 6910
MANU/KA/0709/2006
(1999) 2 SCC 361
Section
for
49(6)
of
the
CGST
refund
but
is
Act
does
dependent
on
not
the
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
conditions stipulated under Section 54 of the CGST Act. Moreover,
Section 29(5) of the CGST Act provides for reversal of ITC upon
cancellation of registration but not a refund. Besides, an effective
alternative statutory remedy exists under Section 112 of the CGST
Act which has not been exhausted by the Petitioners.
That, the
impugned Order being reasoned, proportionate and as per the
statutory framework is not erroneous. The Petitioners attempt to
seek refund of unutilized ITC on account of business closure is
devoid of support in the statute.
Consequently, the Petition
deserves a dismissal.
6.
The question that falls for determination in the instant
dispute is whether the refund of ITC under Section 49(6) of the
CGST Act is only limited to companies carved out under Section
54(3) of the CGST Act or does every registered company have a
right to refund of ITC in case of discontinuance of business?
7.
The parties were heard at length, all averments,
documents on record perused as also the impugned Order.
(i)
In the first instance, the argument pertaining to non-
exhaustion of statutory remedy is taken up.
Apposite reference is
made to the decision of the Supreme Court in State of U.P. and
Others vs. M/s. Indian Hume Pipe Co. Ltd. , wherein the Court was
dealing with an Appeal, which raised a short question of law i.e.,
whether or not hume pipes, which were the subject matter of the
case amounted to “sanitary fittings” as contemplated by a
Government notification, under the U. P. Sales Tax Act, 1948. In
opposition of the Petition, it was argued inter alia therein that, the
Court ought not to have entertained the Writ Petition and should
have allowed the assessee to avail of the remedy provided to him
(1977) 2 SCC 724
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
under the U. P. Sales Tax Act, 1948, particularly when a question
of fact had to be determined. The Supreme Court observed that
there is no rule of law that the High Court should not entertain a
Writ Petition where an alternative remedy is available to a party.
It is always a matter of discretion with the Court and if the
discretion has been exercised by the High Court not unreasonably
or perversely, it is the settled practice of the Supreme Court not to
interfere with the exercise of discretion by the High Court.
The
High Court in the said matter had entertained the Writ Petition and
decided the question of law arising in it which the Supreme Court
opined was correct.
(ii)
More recently, in M/s. Godrej Sara Lee Ltd. vs. Excise and
Taxation Officer-cum-Assessing Authority and Others ,
the Supreme
Court yet again observed that the power to issue prerogative writs
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is plenary in nature
and observed as follows;
“4. …………………………….. The power to issue
prerogative writs under Article 226 is plenary in
nature. Any limitation on the exercise of such power
must be traceable in the Constitution itself. Profitable
reference in this regard may be made to Article 329
and ordainments of other similarly worded articles in
the Constitution. Article 226 does not, in terms,
impose any limitation or restraint on the exercise of
power to issue writs. While it is true that exercise of
writ powers despite availability of a remedy under the
very statute which has been invoked and has given
rise to the action impugned in the writ petition ought
not to be made in a routine manner, yet, the mere
fact that the petitioner before the High Court, in a
given case, has not pursued the alternative remedy
available to him/it cannot mechanically be construed
as a ground for its dismissal. It is axiomatic that the
High Courts (bearing in mind the facts of each
particular case) have a discretion whether to entertain
a writ petition or not. One of the self-imposed
restrictions on the exercise of power under Article 226
that has evolved through judicial precedents is that
the High Courts should normally not entertain a writ
petition, where an effective and efficacious alternative
remedy is available. At the same time, it must be
AIR 2023 Supreme Court 781
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
remembered that mere availability of an alternative
remedy of appeal or revision, which the party
invoking the jurisdiction of the High Court under
Article 226 has not pursued, would not oust the
jurisdiction of the High Court and render a writ
petition "not maintainable". In a long line of decisions,
this Court has made it clear that availability of an
alternative remedy does not operate as an absolute
bar to the "maintainability" of a writ petition and that
the rule, which requires a party to pursue the
alternative remedy provided by a statute, is a rule of
policy, convenience and discretion rather than a rule
of law…………………………”
(iii)
It is evident in the instant matter no question of fact
requires determination and the matter was filed before this Court
seeking its interference for the reasons made out in the prayers as
already revealed (supra). The exercise of plenary powers by this
Court as well as exercise of discretion in no manner is limited as
already pointed out by the Supreme Court in M/s. Godrej Sara Lee
Ltd. (supra).
This thereby lends a quietus to the argument raised
by Learned Deputy Solicitor General.
8.
To
comprehend the
matter
regarding the
refund
claimed, it is essential to consider the provisions cited hereinabove.
Section 49(6) of the CGST Act provides as follows;
“49. Payment of tax, interest, penalty and
other amounts.—……………………………………………….............
(6) The balance in the electronic cash ledger or
electronic credit ledger after payment of tax, interest,
penalty, fee or any other amount payable under this
Act or the rules made thereunder may be refunded in
accordance with the provisions of section 54.
…………………………………………………………………………………”
(i)
Section 49 of the CGST lays down the method of
payment of tax, interest, penalty and other amounts.
Section
49(6) of the CGST Act extracted hereinabove deals with how the
balance after payment of tax, interest, penalty, fee, etc., is to be
dealt with. It lays downs that the refund of such balance will be
made in accordance with the provisions of Section 54 of the CGST
Act. Section 54 of the CGST Act provides as follows;
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
“54. Refund of tax.—(1) Any person claiming
refund of any tax and interest, if any, paid on such
tax or any other amount paid by him, may make an
application before the expiry of two years from the
relevant date in such form and manner as may be
prescribed:
Provided that a registered person, claiming
refund of any balance in the electronic cash ledger in
accordance with the provisions of sub-section (6)
of section 49, may claim such refund in the return
furnished under section 39 in such manner as may be
prescribed.”
(ii)
Section 54(3) of the CGST Act reads as follows;
“54. ……..…………………………….………………..…………………
(3) Subject to the provisions of sub-section
(10), a registered person may claim refund of any
unutilized input tax credit at the end of any tax
period:
Provided that no refund of unutilized input tax
credit shall be allowed in cases other than—
(i)
zero rated supplies made without
payment of tax;
(ii)
where the credit has accumulated on
account of rate of tax on inputs being
higher than the rate of tax on output
supplies (other than nil rated or fully
exempt supplies), except supplies of
goods or services or both as may be
notified by the Government on the
recommendations of the Council:
Provided further that no refund of unutilized
input tax credit shall be allowed in cases where the
goods exported out of India are subjected to export
duty:
Provided also that no refund of input tax credit
shall be allowed, if the supplier of goods or services or
both avails of drawback in respect of central tax or
claims refund of the integrated tax paid on such
supplies.”
(iii)
The Appellate forum in the impugned Order dated 22-
03-2023, was of the view that Section 54(3) of the CGST Act was
applicable only to the two circumstances mentioned in the said
Section and would not extend to refund of unutilized input tax on
account of closure of business.
(iv)
On this facet, we may relevantly consider the decision
in Slovak India Trading Company Private Limited (supra) where the
High Court of Karnataka, at Bangalore, was considering;
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
(a) Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
Tribunal is right in ordering for refund, even if there is no provision
in Rule 5 of CENVAT Credit Rules, 2002, to refund the unutilized
Credit?; (b) Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case
the Tribunal is right in ordering refund even if there is no
production and there is no clearance of finished goods? ; and (c)
Whether under the facts and circumstances of the case the
Tribunal is right in holding that respondent is entitle for refund
even if it goes out of MODVAT Scheme or Company is closed. The
Court considered Rule 5 of CENVAT Credit Rules, which deals with
Refund of CENVAT Credit and observed as follows;
“5. There is no express prohibition in terms of
Rule 5. Even otherwise, it refers to a manufacturer as
we see from Rule 5 itself. Admittedly, in the case on
hand, there is no manufacture in the light of closure
of the Company. Therefore, Rule 5 is not available for
the purpose of rejection as rightly ruled by the
Tribunal. The Tribunal has noticed various case laws
in which similar claims were allowed. The Tribunal, in
our view, is fully justified in ordering refund
particularly in the light of the closure of the factory
and in the light of the assessee coming out of the
Modvat Scheme. In these circumstances, we answer
all the three questions as framed in para 17 against
the Revenue and in favour of the assessee.”
9.
As can be seen in Slovak India Trading Company Private
Limited (supra) the company had applied for refund for unutilized
input credit which was available, at the time of closure of unit. The
Customs, Excise And Service Tax Appellate Tribunal (CESTAT)
allowed the refund stating inter alia that it cannot be rejected on
closure of the company.
The High Court agreed and opined that
there is no express prohibition in Rule 5 of the CENVAT Credit
Rules, 2002.
(i)
Similarly, in the instant matter there is no express
prohibition in Section 49(6) read with Section 54 and 54(3) of the
CGST Act, for claiming a refund of ITC on closure of unit.
2023:SHC:175
WP(C) No.54 of 2023
SICPA India Private Limited and Another vs. Union of India and Others
Although, Section 54(3) of the CGST Act deals only with two
circumstances where refunds can be made, however the statute
also does not provide for retention of tax without the authority of
law.
Consequently, I am of the considered view that the
Petitioners are entitled to the the refund of unutilized ITC claimed
by them and it is ordered so.
10.
The impugned Order dated 22-03-2023, in Appeal File
No.GAPPL/ADC/GSTP/1208/SLG-Appeal, of the Appellate Authority
is set aside.
11.
Writ Petition is accordingly allowed and disposed of.
( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
10-06-2025
Approved for reporting : Yes
sdl
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review