Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/34
GAHC010257342024
2026:GAU-AS:2219
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6437/2024
SIBESH BARMAN AND 9 ORS
S/O NAGEN BARMAN
RESIDENT OF KHAMAR, PS BAGRIBARI, DIST KOKRAJHAR, BTR, ASSAM
783349
2: NILOY KUMAR BHATTACHARJEE
S/O SURENDRA BHATTACHARJEE
RESIDENT OF MAHAMAYA
PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
3: SANJIT BARMAN
S/O LATE BINDU BARMAN
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
4: ALOKESH BARMAN
S/O AROBINDRA BARMAN
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
5: RANJIT KARMAKAR
Page No.# 2/34
S/O LATE HARIPODA KARMAKA
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
6: AKHIL BARMAN
S/O LATE UPEN BARMAN
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
7: ANJALI KARMAKAR
D/O LATE HARIPODA KARMAKAR
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
8: BISWAJIT KARMAKAR
S/O LATE HARIPODA KARMAKAR
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
9: BOLORAM BARMAN
S/O LATE MAHAN BARMAN
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 783349
10: PRADIP BARMAN
S/O LATE CHIKON BARMAN
RESIDENT OF VILLAGE RAJAPARA PART II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM 78334
Page No.# 3/34
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM, GENERAL ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT, DISPUR
GUWAHATI 781006
2:THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
BTR
BTR
SECRETARIAT
KOKRAJHAR
DIST KOKRAJHAR BTR
ASSAM
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
4:THE SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER (CIVIL)
PARBATJORA
KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM
5:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
BAGORIBARI REVENUE CIRCLE
PARBATJORA
KOKRAJHAR
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM
6:THE SRI MAHAMAYA DHAM COMMITEE
MAHAMAYA BOGORIBARI
PARBATJORA
KOKRAJHAR
DIST KOKRAJHAR BTR
ASSA
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. S K SAIKIA, MR. J I BORBHUIYA,MR. L MOHAN,MR A
Page No.# 4/34
HOSSAIN,MR D.S. BHATTACHARYA
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, SC, BTC
Linked Case : WP(C)/953/2025
SOILO BALA BARMAN AND ORS
S/O NURINKARJI
AGE ABOUT 56 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
PHONE NO. 8133963794
GENDER FEMALE
2: JITEN BARMAN
S/O KAMALA KANTA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 41 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
3: HARENDRA MOHON ADHIKARY
S/O DHIRENDRAMOHONADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 56 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
4: MANINDRA BARMAN
S/O SHAMAR NATH BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 39 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
5: DIPAK ROY
Page No.# 5/34
S/O SANIRAM ROY
AGE ABOUT 35 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
6: KANAK CH. RAY
S/O MADAN CH. RAY
AGE ABOUT 35 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
7: ALIPRABHA BARMAN
S/O DHRUBA CH. BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 38 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
8: BISHNU GOPAL RAY
S/O SUSHIL KR. RAY
AGE ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
9: RANJIT BARMAN
S/O MOHENDRA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 53 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - ANGARKATA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
10: DULAL BARMAN
S/O RANJAN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 34 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
Page No.# 6/34
11: BIJOY BARMAN
S/O POBENESWAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 24 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
12: PUJA BARMAN
S/O GOBINDA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 24 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
13: PUSHPO BARMAN
C/O LATE ASHOK KUMAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
14: KHARGESWAR BARMAN
S/O UMANANDA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 54 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
15: PABANESWAR BARMAN
S/O SHATISH BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 52 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
16: LAKHAPATI BARMAN
S/O LATE MAHESWAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 23 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
Page No.# 7/34
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
17: BHOLA BARMAN
S/O LATE MAHESWAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 35 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
18: DULAL BARMAN
S/O JOYRAM BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 43 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
19: MANO BARMAN
S/O SUBAL BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 28 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
20: RAGHU BARMAN
S/O RAMESH BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
21: RAKESH BARMAN
S/O BARUN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 26 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
Page No.# 8/34
22: SHAULOBALA BARMAN
C/O LATE UTTAM BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
23: KHIROD BARMAN
S/O SUBAL CH. BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
24: TULSI BARMAN
S/O NAGEN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
25: RABIN BARMAN
S/O KHOGEN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 47 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
26: CHANCHALA BARMAN
S/O ATUL BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
27: SUSUMA BARMAN
S/O SUSHIL BARMAN
Page No.# 9/34
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
28: MONOJ BARMAN
S/O PRAFULLA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 22 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
29: DHIRENDRANATH ROY
S/O JOYKANTA ROY
AGE ABOUT 51 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
30: PADUMIHALDER
H/O PURANHALDER
AGE ABOUT 30 YEARS
RESIDENT OF BILASIPARA
DIST - DHUBRI
ASSAM PIN-783348
ASSAM
31: SAKENDRA BRAHMA
S/O PURENDRA BRAHMA
AGE ABOUT 42 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -ALUPARA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
32: KATIRAM BARMAN
S/O HALONG BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 25 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
Page No.# 10/34
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
33: MILI BARMAN
C/O SHIBESH BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 42 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
34: SUKUMAR BARMAN
S/O BIREN CH. BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 37 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
35: LABHESHWARI DEVI
S/O BUDHESHWARNATH
AGE ABOUT 53 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - MAHAMAYA
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
36: PURNABALA BARMAN
S/O DHANESWAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 74 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
37: RADHIKA BARMAN
S/O MINTU BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 29 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
Page No.# 11/34
ASSAM
38: JEGCHORA BARMAN
S/O DEBA PRASAD BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 38 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
39: EKADASHI RAY
S/O KALU RAY
AGE ABOUT 39 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
40: BIJURAM BARMAN
S/O PUNIA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 40 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
41: MONO BALA BARMAN
S/O HEM CH. BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 44 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
42: MUKUL ADHIKARY
S/O NANDALALADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 46 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
43: DELO BARMAN
Page No.# 12/34
S/O MITHARAM BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 39 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - MAHAMAYA
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
44: RANJAN ADHIKARY
S/O LATE - SUDHIRADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 48 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
45: PUTULI BARMAN
C/O DHARANI BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 45 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
46: GANESH ROY
S/O BADAL CH. ROY
AGE ABOUT 41 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
47: LAKHI BARMAN
S/O NIRANJAN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
48: MINTU BARMAN
S/O CHANDANBARMANI
AGE ABOUT 34 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL- RAJAPARA PT-II
Page No.# 13/34
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
49: KANIKABALA RAY
C/O LATE NIPEN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 35 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
50: NIRIMATI ADHIKARY
C/O PRODYUT KR. ADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
51: SAMO BARMAN
C/O SUBAL BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 62 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
52: GITA BARMAN
C/O RAJKUMAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 35 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
53: BANBHASI BARMAN
S/O PUTUL BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 43 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
Page No.# 14/34
ASSAM
54: MITHUN ROY
S/O JATIN ROY
AGE ABOUT 28 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -MAHAMAYA
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
55: HIRESH BARMAN
S/O SAJAL BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 27 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL- RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
56: MINATI BARMAN
S/O SAJAL BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 47 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
57: FULMATI BARMAN
C/O LATE BHAJO BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 41 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
58: ANIMA BARMAN
S/O SOMBARI BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 36 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
59: MARAMI BARMAN
Page No.# 15/34
S/O SAILEN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 18 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
60: DIPALI BARMAN
S/O NAGEN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 57 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
61: MOHAN BALA RAY
S/O BALO BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 27 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
62: KRISHNA BARMAN
S/O TARANIKANTA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 37 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
63: KHIREN BARMAN
S/O NITYANANDA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 64 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
64: RAKHI BARMAN
S/O KRISHNA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 27 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL- RAJAPARA PT-II
Page No.# 16/34
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
65: PROTIBHA BARMAN
C/O ABHISHEK BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 25 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
66: SHONA BALA BARMAN
S/O JAYRAM BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 55 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
67: INDRAJIT ADHIKARY
S/O BIPINADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 49 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
68: CHATU BARMAN
S/O MAHENDRA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 52 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
69: BALEN RAY
S/O JATIN RAY
AGE ABOUT 29 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -MAHAMAYA
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
Page No.# 17/34
ASSAM
70: NABIN BARMAN
S/O LATE BHAJO BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 28 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
71: LALMAHON RAY
S/O LATE BADAL CH. RAY
AGE ABOUT 56 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
72: DULALIBALA RAY
S/O RUPARAM BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 33 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - ALUPARA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
73: JONALI BARMAN
S/O SATKUMAR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 23 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
74: DULALIBALA ROY
S/O MADAN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 24 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
75: MINATI ADHIKARY
Page No.# 18/34
C/O DINESH RAY
AGE ABOUT 55 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
76: NILIMABALA RAY
S/O MADAN KR. RAY
AGE ABOUT 42 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL-RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
77: GOKUL ROY
S/O NAGEN ROY
AGE ABOUT 30 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -ALUPARA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
78: NIRMAL BARMAN
S/O LATE KAMALA KANTA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 52 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL- RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
79: SIBANGKAR BARMAN
S/O BARUN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 31 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
80: SISIR KUMAR BARMAN
S/O RANBAHADUR BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 44 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
Page No.# 19/34
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
81: PURNIMA BARMAN
S/O TEPU BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 42 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
82: CHATIK BARMAN
S/O MAHESH BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 54 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
83: PRODYUT KUMAR ADHIKARY
S/O AMIYO KR. ADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 52 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
84: SARASWATI BARMAN
S/O PARESH BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 59 YEARS
RESIDENT OF BAGRIBARI
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
85: MALOTI BARMAN
S/O MATIRAM BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 44 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
Page No.# 20/34
ASSAM
86: BHARATI BARMAN
S/O TAPAN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 37 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
87: KAMINI BARMAN
S/O NALU BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 74 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
88: KASHI BARMAN
S/O NALU BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 55 YEARS
RESIDENT OF RAJAPARA PT-II
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
89: BIKRAM BARMAN
S/O NIRANJAN BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 36 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL - KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
90: RADHIKA ADHIKARY
C/O RANJITADHIKARY
AGE ABOUT 39 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL KHAMAR
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN 783349
ASSAM
91: SABITA BARMAN
Page No.# 21/34
S/O RABIKANTA BARMAN
AGE ABOUT 41 YEARS
RESIDENT OF VILL -RAJAPARA PT-I
PO AND PS BAGRIBARI
DT- KOKRAJHAR
PIN-783349
ASSAM
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM
GENERAL ADMINISTRATION DEPARTMENT
DISPUR GUWAHATI 781006
2:THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
BTR SECRETARIATE
KOKRAJHAR
ASSAM
3:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
DIST KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM. REP. BY THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
4:THE SUB DIVISIONAL OFFICER (CIVIL)
PARBATJORA
KOKRAJHAR
BTR ASSAM
5:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
BOGORIBARI REVENUE CIRCLE PARBATJORA KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM
6:THE SRI MAHAMAYA DHAM COMMITTEE
MAHAMAYA BOGORIBARI
PARBATJORA
KOKRAJHAR
BTR
ASSAM
------------
Page No.# 22/34
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
Advocates for the petitioner(s)
:
Mr. JI Borbhuiya
Mr. SK Saikia
Advocates for the respondent(s) :
Mr. D Nath,
Senior Govt. Advocate, Assam
Date on which Judgment is reserved
:
NA
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment : 10.02.2026
Whether the Pronouncement is of the : NA
Operative Part of the Judgment
Whether the Full Judgment has been : Yes
Pronounced
JUDGMENT & ORDER(ORAL)
Heard Mr. JI Borbhuiya, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the petitioners in both the writ petitions. I have also heard Mr. D Nath,
the learned Senior Government Advocate, Assam, who appears on
behalf of the State of Assam as well as the District Administration and
Mr. BC Muchahary, the learned Standing Counsel, who appears on
behalf of the BTC as well as Sri Mahamaya Dham Committee,
Bogoribari, Parbatjhora, Kokrajhar which is a Committee constituted
Page No.# 23/34
by the BTC.
2.
101 writ petitioners have approached this Court by filing the
instant writ petitions seeking protection from forceful eviction by the
respondents. The materials on record show that the North East
Council had allotted certain funds to the Assam Tourism Development
Corporation Ltd. (for short,’ the ATDC’) for creation of facilities for
tourists at Maa Mahamaya Dham, Bogoribari, Assam. A company
namely, M/s. SBF Commercial Pvt. Ltd was awarded the construction
work with a contract value of Rs.11,35,90,000/- for creation of the
facilities for tourist at Mahamaya Temple Dham. The period of
completion as mentioned in the work order dated 20.11.2023 was
18(eighteen) months. The scope of the work included construction of
a Guest House (G+1 storey building); construction of a rest house
(G+1 storey building); market single storey building; and site
development work including development of the exiting pond;
external electrification work and furniture and fixtures as per
specification.
3.
The petitioners herein in both the writ petitions claim that they
are shopkeepers carrying out the business of selling items required for
puja and other ancillary items within the vicinity of the Mahamaya
Temple at Dhubri. They claim that they are mostly carrying on their
Page No.# 24/34
business by setting up their shops below the staircase of the
Mahamaya Dham Temple as was permitted by the Mahamaya Mandir
Managing Committee as far back as on 06.04.1973.
4.
The grievance for which the petitioners have approached this
Court is that in view of the steps being taken for creation of facilities
for tourist at Mahamaya Temple Dhubri they would lose their
livelihood though they were permitted by the Mahamaya Mandir
Managing Committee to establish their shops below the staircase.
5.
When
the
first
of
the
writ
petitions
were
filed,
i.e.
WP(C)No.6437/2024, on 04.12.2024, this Court passed an order of
status-quo with regard to the demolition carried out till the next date.
However, subsequently, by an order dated 24.01.2025, this Court,
while issuing notice observed that the status-quo order so passed on
04.12.2024 shall remain limited to the 10(ten) writ petitioners in
WP(C)No.6437/2024 till the next date of hearing. The interim orders,
as it appears from the materials on record, have been continued
thereafter in WP(C) No.6437/2024.
6.
It is very pertinent to take note of that taking into account that
the order passed on 24.01.2025 was limited to those 10 petitioners,
Page No.# 25/34
who are the writ petitioners in WP(C)No.6437/2024, 91 petitioners
joined together to file the second writ petition on 14.02.2025, which
was registered and numbered as WP(C)No.953/2025.
7.
The record reveals that in pursuance to the filing of the said writ
petition vide an order dated 05.04.2025, this Court issued notice in
WP(C)No.953/2025 and passed an interim order that there shall not
be any demolition of shops of the petitioners and/or eviction process
till the next returnable date. The interim orders so passed in both the
writ petitions have been extended from time to time.
8. It is very pertinent to take note of an order passed by the learned
Coordinate Bench of this Court dated 13.06.2025 whereby, the
learned Coordinate Bench directed the Deputy Commissioner,
Kokrajhar to make an enquiry/survey and file an affidavit thereby
incorporating the detail particulars of such shopkeepers, the location
of their shops, number of shops, if any, proof of payment of rent by
the petitioners, allotment letters issued by the Temple Authority. It
was also mentioned that the State respondents shall also file a
separate affidavit bringing on record the detailed plan of the proposed
market area for just determination of the cases.
9.
The record reveals that an affidavit-in-opposition was filed by the
Page No.# 26/34
respondent No.3 in WP(C) No.6437/2024. It is mentioned at
paragraph No.3 of the said affidavit-in-opposition that prior to the
initiation of the construction work, several rounds of discussions were
held at different levels and the Vendors’ Association were well aware
of the proposed plan of the market complex and committed to
cooperating with the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee. It was
also mentioned that the shopkeepers voluntarily consented to relocate
their shops to a nearby place for temporary adjustment in due time
prior to the commencement of the construction and the shopkeepers
were also assured by the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee that
upon
the
completion
of
the
construction
work,
they
would
permanently be shifted to the newly constructed market complex. It
was also stated that the construction company faced obstructions
during the execution of the construction work, despite repeated
requests by the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee and the
Contractor. The shopkeepers did not relocate their shops from the
construction site and it is under such circumstances, intervention was
sought for from the Sub-divisional Officer (Civil) on 04.11.2024.
10. This Court also finds it very pertinent to take note of the affidavit
filed by the respondent No.3 in WP(C)No.953/2025, inasmuch as, the
said affidavit is in pursuance to the order passed by this Court on
13.06.2025, as referred to herein above. In the said affidavit, it is
Page No.# 27/34
mentioned that an enquiry was conducted by the Additional District
Commissioner and i/c, SDO (Civil) for Parbatjhora Kokrajhar and the
register, documents and records available in the office of the
Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee were taken into considertion.
What is revealed in the enquiry have been mentioned in paragraph
No.5 of the said affidavit. Taking into account the importance of such
revelation, this Court finds it relevant to reproduce the paragraph
Nos.5 and 6 of the affidavit filed in WP(C)No.953/2025 as
hereinunder:
“5.
That in so far as the writ petitioners in W.P.(C) No.
953/2025, the enquiry reveals that (a) The petitioner Nos.12. 17. 21, 23, 24, 29, 30, 32, 33, 34,
35, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 45, 47, 48, 49, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56.
58. 59. 61. 64. 69. 70. 72. 75.76, 77. 79, 81, 82,83, 84,85, 86
and 89 in W.P. (C) No. 953/2025, there is no record as shop
keeper in the Register of Mahamaya Mandir Committee. The
aforesaid petitioners never paid any revenue / rent for their
shop to the Mandir Committee and they are not genuine shop
keepers.
(b) The record available with the Mahamaya Mandir Managing
Committee reveals that the aforesaid writ petitioners had
unauthorisedly run their shop at the proposed construction
Page No.# 28/34
site or below the stair case of Mahamaya Mandir premises.
(c). That the enquiry further reveals that the writ petitioners
No.5, 65, 73 & 74 are neither recorded shopkeeper nor any
shop is in their possession below the staircase of Mandir
Premises Committee. They have never paid any rent to the
Mandir Managing Committee.
(d) That in so far as the petitioner No. 1 in W.P. (C) 953/2025,
on perusal of the Register it is found that one Shoilobala
Barman, W/O- Lt. Sushil Barman of Village Rajapara has been
enlisted as shop keeper. No person in the name of Soilobala
Barman, S/O- Nurin Karji of Vill- Rajapara Pt-II had been
authorized by Mandir Committee to run a shop there.
(e) That the records shows that the writ petitioner Nos. 2, 3,
4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19, 20, 22, 25, 26, 27,31
36, 42, 44, 46, 50, 51, 57, 60, 63, 66, 67, 68, 71, 78, 80, 87
and 88 in W.P. (C) No. 953/2025 are the genuine shop
keepers, who have been running their respective shop there
and also paid Revenue/ rent to the Mandir Managing
Committee, till the month of December, 2023. The authority
has no intention to demolish any shop and it is clear that the
genuine shops that are required to be shifted will be allotted
a site/shop in the newly constructed market complex on the
Page No.# 29/34
completion of the construction works. The shop are located
below the staircase of the Mahamaya Mandir premises and
beside both side of the road followed to the Mandir.
(f) The enquiry further reveals that the petitioner no. 33 Mili
Barman is the wife of Sibesh Barman, S/O: Nagen Barman
(president of Vendor Association), has been unauthorisedly
running a shop there. Sibesh Barman is also the petitioner
no.1 in WP(C) No. 6437/2024. Further petitioner no. 90,
Radhika Adhikari, wife of Ranjit Adhikari, (Secretary of Vendor
Association) has no shop in her name there. Besides, Ranjit
Adhikari being Govt. employee, who is running a shop there
in the name and style of Hotel Nandan Kanon in the bank of
Mandir Pond which obstructs in continuation of proposed
development of pond work. Same is the fact with petitioner
no.91 wherein revenue was paid by Rabikanta Barman but
writ petition is filed by Sabita Barman.
6. That in so far as the writ petitioners in W.P.(C) No. 6437/2024
is concerned, the deponent begs to state that the 9 (nine) Nos. of
writ petitioners in the writ petition do not have any shop located
at the construction site that are required to be relocated. Further
the petitioner No. 2, Niloy Kumar Bhattacharjee is not a
shopkeeper.”
Page No.# 30/34
11.
From the above-quoted paragraph Nos.5 and 6, it appears that
in respect to 44 out of 91 writ petitioners in WP(C)No.953/2025, there
are no records as shopkeepers in the register of Mahamaya Mandir
Managing Committee. There are also no records that those petitioners
paid any revenue/rent for their shops to the Mandir Committee, and
as such, they are not genuine shopkeepers.
12.
It further appears that the writ petitioner Nos.5, 65, 73, and 74
of WP(C)No.953/2025 are neither recorded shopkeepers nor any shop
is there in their possession below the staircase of the Mandir
premises. Further to that, it is also mentioned that the petitioner Nos.
2, 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14, 15, 16, 18, 19, 20, 22, 25, 26, 27, 31,
36, 42, 44, 46, 50, 51, 57, 60, 63, 66, 67, 68, 71, 78, 80, 87, and 88
in WP(C)No.953/2025 are genuine shopkeepers, who are running
their respective shops by paying revenue/rent to the Mahamaya
Mandir Managing Committee till the month of December 2023.
13.
It is of importance to note the statement made at paragraph
5(e) as quoted above that the authority has no intention to demolish
any shops and the genuine shops that are required to be shifted
would be allotted a site/shop in the newly constructed market
complex on the completion of the construction work. Further to that,
it
is
also
mentioned
that
the
Nos.
of
petitioners
in
Page No.# 31/34
WP(C)No.6437/2024 do not have any shops at the construction site
that are required to be relocated. In addition to that, the petitioner
No.2 in WP(C)No.6437/2024 is not a shopkeeper.
14.
The
petitioners
thereupon
had
filed
a
reply
in
WP(C)No.6437/2024, reiterating their stand in the writ petition.
15.
This Court had heard the learned counsels appearing on behalf
of the parties and had also perused the materials on record.
16. During the course of the hearing, Mr. D Nath, the learned Senior
Government Advocate, who appears on behalf of the State
Government as well as the District Administration placed before this
Court 3(three) photographs, a Site Plan of the proposed construction
to be carried out for the market. It was submitted during the course
of the hearing that the area wherein the market complex would be
constructed is within the Blue Line as shown in the said photographs.
The said photographs are kept on record and marked with the letters
‘A’, ‘B’, and ‘C’. In addition to that, the Site Plan which is placed is kept
on record and marked with the letter ‘D’.
17.
In the background of the above pleadings as well as the
Page No.# 32/34
documents which were placed before this Court, the question,
therefore, arises as to whether this Court should interfere with the
construction to be carried out in terms with the work order dated
11.02.2023, issued to M/s. SBF Commercial Pvt. Ltd.
18.
In the previous segments of the instant judgment, while
considering the affidavit so filed by the respondent No.3 in
WP(C)No.953/2025, it is mentioned that those genuine shopkeepers,
who have to be relocated in view of the construction to be carried out
would be accommodated in the newly constructed market complex.
19.
This Court cannot turn a blind eye to the fact that if there are
shopkeepers carrying on business in the area which belongs to the
Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee without any permission, they
are not entitled to any equitable relief, taking into account that the
said persons knew it very well at the time of establishing their shops
that they have no right to do so. Be that as it may, this Court finds it
pertinent to observe that an opportunity should be given to all the
petitioners, who have been mentioned as not genuine shopkeepers in
the affidavit filed by the respondent No.3 to prove that they are
genuine shopkeepers having set up shops with due permission as well
as
paying
Committee.
rent/revenue
to
the
Mahamaya
Mandir
Managing
Page No.# 33/34
20.
Considering the above, this Court, therefore, disposes of both
the writ petitions with the following observations and directions:
(i). The respondent authorities herein shall be at liberty to carry
out the necessary constructions for the creation of tourist facilities in
the Mahamaya Temple Dhubri, Assam. In doing so, if there is a
requirement
of
carrying
out
any
demolition,
the
respondent
authorities are at liberty to do so. However, in respect to those
genuine shopkeepers, who have to shift or relocate or whose shops
have been demolished, those shopkeepers have to be accommodated
in the new market complex which is proposed to be constructed as it
is the undertaking given before this Court at paragraph 5(e) of the
affidavit filed by the respondent No.3 in WP(C)No.953/2025 that they
would be provided site/shop in the proposed market complex.
(ii). This Court further observes that in the circumstance, the
other petitioners herein, who have been held to be not genuine in the
affidavit filed by the respondent No.3 in WP(C)No.953/2025 are in
possession of documents which would show that they with the
permission of the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee have set up
their shops and further have been paying the rent to the said
Committee, they shall be at liberty to approach the respondent No.3
as well as the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee seeking
allotment in the market complex which is to be constructed. Such
petitioners would be required to submit respective representations
Page No.# 34/34
along with documents for proving that they have set up their shops
on the basis of permission and they have been paying the rent to the
Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee till the month of December,
2023.
(iii). The respondent No. 3 i.e. the District Commissioner,
Kokrajhar as well as the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee shall
look into such grievances and shall do the needful. It is observed that
in the circumstance, if the petitioners referred to at Clause (ii)
hereinabove are successful in showing that they have established the
shops with due permission and have also been paying the
rent/revenue to the Mahamaya Mandir Managing Committee till
December, 2023, then in such circumstances, those petitioners shall
also be similarly situated with the other petitioners, who have been
referred to at Clause (i) hereinabove and should be provided
allotment in the proposed new market complex.
JUDGE
Shivani Gautam Gautam
Date: 2026.02.16 15:23:03
+05'30'
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review