Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:31064
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.NAGARESH
FRIDAY, THE 11TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 21ST CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 15427 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
SHYNA. M.T
AGED 51 YEARS
L.P.S.T., N.I.S.L.P.SCHOOL,
PALOTTUPALLI, MATTANNUR.
RESIDING AT MAYOORAM, PARIYARAM P.O.
KOLARI, PIN - 670702
BY ADVS.
SRI.BEJOY JOSEPH P.J.
SRI.M.RAMESH CHANDER (SR.)
SRI.M.VIJAYAKUMAR
SRI.GOVIND G. NAIR
SRI.BONNY BENNY
SRI.BALU TOM
RESPONDENTS:
THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR OF GENERAL EDUCATION
OFFICE OF THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR OF GENERAL EDUCATION,
JAGATHY, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695014
THE DIRECTOR OF GENERAL EDUCATION
OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR OF GENERAL EDUCATION,
JAGATHY, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,
PIN - 695014
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:2:
DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER
OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER,
THALASSERY, PIN - 670101
ASSISTANT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER
OFFICE OF THE ASSISTANT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER,
MATTANNUR, PIN - 670702
NAZIR. K
HEADMASTER, N.I.S.L.P.SCHOOL,
PALOTTUPALLI, MATTANNUR, PIN - 670702
MANAGER, N.I.S.L.P.SCHOOL
N.I.S.L.P.SCHOOL, PALOTTUPALLI,
MATTANNUR, PIN - 670702
BY ADVS.
C.K.SHERIN
A.LOWSY(K/000914/2002)
SMT.ANIMA M, GOVERNMENT PLEADER-R1-R4
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD
ON 24.03.2025 AND THE COURT ON 11.04.2025 DELIVERED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:3:
N. NAGARESH, J.
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
W.P.(C) No.15427 of 2024
`````````````````````````````````````````````````````````````
Dated this the 11th day of April, 2025
JUDGMENT
~~~~~~~~~
The petitioner, who is working as LPST in the
School managed by the 6th respondent, seeks to quash Ext.P11
and to compel the 1st respondent to direct the Manager to
promote the petitioner as Headmaster in the School.
2.
The petitioner states that she was appointed as
Assistant Teacher in the 4th respondent-School from 09.06.1997.
The appointment was approved as per Ext.P1. The petitioner
has passed all the Departmental Tests.
3.
Sri. Askar K., Headmaster, retired from service
on 30.04.2021 giving rise to a vacancy of Headmaster from
01.05.2021. The petitioner is the seniormost Teacher having
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:4:
more than 24 years of service. As the petitioner has passed all
Departmental Tests, she is eligible to be appointed as
Headmaster.
4.
The Manager, however, appointed the 5th
respondent as Headmaster. The petitioner submitted an appeal
before the Assistant Educational Officer stating that she is the
seniormost Teacher entitled to be promoted as HM and that the
Manager has not followed the procedure laid down by the Full
Bench of this Court while filling up the post of Headmaster. The
AEO, as per Ext.P7 order dated 22.10.2022, rejected approval
to the appointment of the 5th respondent as Headmaster, holding
that the Manager has not followed the dictum laid down by this
Court in Kurian Lizy v. State of Kerala [2006 (4) KLT 264] and
relevant Government Orders. The Manager preferred an appeal
before the District Educational Officer. The DEO also rejected
the appeal as per Ext.P8 order dated 15.11.2022.
5.
The Manager preferred a further appeal before
the Additional Director of General Education. The Additional
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:5:
Director found that the School has minority status and therefore
the Manager can appoint a Teacher of the minority community
as Headmaster.
The petitioner belongs to General Category
and therefore, at the instance of the petitioner, the discretion
exercised by the Manager cannot be interfered with.
The
petitioner is aggrieved by Ext.P11 order dated 01.04.2024 of the
Additional Director.
6.
The counsel for the petitioner urged that a Full
Bench of this Court in Kurian Lizy (supra) has held that in the
matter of appointment of Headmaster/Principal of a School or
College, the selection procedure should be fair, reasonable and
transparent. The eligible members of the minority community
may not have a feeling that they have been superseded without
any valid grounds.
All minority educational institutions
proposing
best
to
select
person
to
the
post
of
Headmaster/Principal ignoring seniority in the feeder category,
should frame and publish Regulations or Bye-laws containing a
transparent procedure governing such selection. The law laid
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:6:
down by the Full Bench in Kurian Lizy (supra) is ignored by the
6th respondent. The 1st respondent is a statutory authority and
the 1st respondent is bound to give cogent reasons for rejecting
the findings of the AEO and the DEO. In the facts of the case,
Ext.P11 is liable to be set aside and the 1st respondent is
compellable to direct the Manager to promote the petitioner,
contended the counsel for the petitioner.
7.
The 5th respondent filed a counter affidavit. The
5th respondent stated that the petitioner heavily relies on the
judgment of the Full Bench of this Court in Kurian Lizy (supra).
In view of Ext.R5(f) judgment of the Apex Court, the principle of
fair procedure stipulated by the Full Bench has become otiose.
Therefore, Ext.P8 order issued by the Deputy Director is not
liable to be interfered with.
8.
I have heard the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the learned Government
Pleader representing
respondents 1 to 4 and the learned counsel appearing for the 5th
respondent.
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:7:
9.
The argument of the petitioner in short is that a
Full Bench of this Court in Kurian Lizy (supra) has held that in
the matter of appointment of Headmaster/Principal in minority
educational institutions, the selection procedure should be fair,
reasonable and transparent and all minority Educational
Isnstitutions intending to appoint Headmaster/Principal ignoring
seniority of Teachers, should frame and publish Regulations or
Bye-laws, containing a transparent procedure governing such
selection. The 6th respondent has not followed the Full Bench
judgment.
Therefore, selection and appointment of the 5th
respondent is illegal.
10.
In the judgment in Kurian Lizy (supra), the Full
Bench of this Court held as follows:
We notice that in many cases senior teachers
belonging to the minority community, which runs the
institution are superseded without assigning any
reason. Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India is an
armour to protect the minority against the legislative
and executive actions of the State, which is normally
controlled by the majority. The said armour cannot be
used as a weapon against other members of the
same minority community. The protection under
Article 30(1) is to the minority community and for the
minority community. The Manager may supersede
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:8:
the members of other communities and also
members of the minority community, who are found
unsuitable for promotion to the post of Headmaster.
But there may be teachers, who are, in every respect,
qualified and suitable to head a minority educational
institution. The management may select the best
among them. The selection procedure should be fair,
reasonable and transparent. The eligible members of
the minority community may not have a feeling that
they have been superseded without any valid
grounds. So, all minority educational institutions,
which propose to select the best person to the post of
Headmaster/Principal of a School or College, as the
case may be, ignoring seniority in the feeder category
or ignoring the available teachers, should frame and
publish regulations or bye-laws, containing a
transparent procedure, governing such selection. The
publication can be made in the Notice Board of the
educational institution concerned and a copy of it
should be available in school/college library for
reference. When superseding a senior qualified
member of the minority community the reasons
thereof should be clear from the records.
A reading of the judgment of the Full Bench would indicate that
the procedure is prescribed in order to protect senior Teachers
belonging to the minority community, in the matter of selection
and
appointment
of
Headmaster/Principal
in
minority
educational institutions. The petitioner does not belong to the
minority community.
Therefore, the petitioner cannot impugn
the selection on the basis of non-adherence to the directions
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
:9:
given by the Full Bench.
11.
Furthermore, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held
in the judgment in Manager, Corporate Educational Agency
v. James Mathew and others [(2017) 15 SCC 595] that once
management of a minority educational institution makes a
conscious choice of a qualified person from the minority
community to lead the institution, as the Headmaster or
Principal, court cannot go into the merits of the choice or the
rationality or propriety of the process of choice, as the right
under Article 30(1) of the Constitution of India is absolute.
In view of the law laid down by this Court and by the
Hon’ble Apex Court, I do not find any illegality in Ext.P11 order
passed by the Additional Director
(Academic) of General
Education. The writ petition fails and it is hence dismissed.
Sd/N. NAGARESH, JUDGE
aks/09.04.2025
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
: 10 :
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 15427/2024
PETITIONER’S EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT ORDER DATED
09.06.1997.
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY
THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
DATED 22.11.2018.
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY
THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
DATED 22.11.2018.
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE CERTIFICATE ISSUED BY
THE KERALA PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
DATED 22.11.2018.
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION TO THE
MANAGER DATED 03.08.2021.
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE APPEAL FILED BY THE
PETITIONER TO THE ASSISTANT EDUCATIONAL
OFFICER DATED 10.06.2021.
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE
ASSISTANT EDUCATIONAL OFFICER BEARING
NO. B/10985/2021(1) DATED 22.01.2022.
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE DISTRICT
EDUCATIONAL
OFFICER
BEARING
NO.
B5/197541/2022 DATED 15.11.2022.
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION DATED
11/2023 ISSUED BY THE DIRECTOR OF
GENERAL EDUCATION.
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE HEARING NOTES SUBMITTED
BY THE PETITIONER BEFORE THE DIRECTOR OF
GENERAL EDUCATION DATED 19.12.2023.
Exhibit P11
TRUE
COPY
OF
THE
ORDER
BEARING
NO.
2025:KER:31064
W.P.(C) No.15427/2024
: 11 :
G4/238938/2022 DATED 01.04.2024 ISSUED
BY THE ADDITIONAL DIRECTOR OF GENERAL
EDUCATION.
RESPONDENTS’ EXHIBITS
Exhibit R-5 (a)
TRUE COPY OF THE APPOINTMENT ORDER BY
PROMOTION DATED 01.05.2021 OF THE 5TH
RESPONDENT
Exhibit R-5 (b)
TRUE COPY OF THE JOINING REPORT DATED
01.05.2021
Exhibit R-5 (c)
TRUE COPY OF THE STAFF
SCHOOL AS ON 01.01.2021
Exhibit R-5 (d)
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER F. NO. 761 OF
DATED
25.01.2017
ALONG
WITH
CERTIFICATE DATED 25TH JANUARY 2017
ISSUED BY THE NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR
MINORITY EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
Exhibit R-5 (e)
TRUE COPY OF THE DECISION REPORTED IN
KHC
5043=2007
(1)
KLT
(SECRETARY, MALANKARA SYRIAN CATHOLIC
COLLEGE V. T. JOSE AND OTHERS DECIDED ON
27.11.2006)
Exhibit R-5 (f)
TRUE COPY OF THE DECISION REPORTED IN
2017 (4) KHC 83=2017 (3) KLT 713
(MANAGER, CORPORATE EDUCATIONAL AGENCY
V. JAMES MATHEW AND OTHERS DECIDED ON
11.07.2017)
Exhibit R-5 (g)
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN C.C. NO.
878/2018 DATED 28.09.2022 OF THE COURT
OF THE JUDICIAL FIRST CLASS MAGISTRATE,
KUTHUPARAMBA
LIST
OF
THE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review