Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
MAC. App. No.30 of 2022
1.
Shriram General Insurance Company Ltd., B.R. Arcade (3rd Floor),
Opposite Priya Palace Hotel, 21 Janapath, Ulubari, Guwahati-781007.
[Insurer of vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03-B-1784 Mini Truck].
…..Appellant
-V E R S U S-
1.
Smti. Nandita Datta, wife of late Utpal Das.
2.
Smti. Utsa Das (Minor), daughter of late Utpal Das.
Both are residents of Badharghat, P.S. Amtali, Agartala, West Tripura,
presently residing at Chanban P.O. Rajarbag, P.S. R. K. Pur, District:
Gomati Tripura. [Sl. No.2 being minor represented by her mother,
natural guardian, Sl. No.1].
….. Claimant-respondents.
3.
Sri Sahadeb Saha, son of late Nakul Chandra Saha, resident of villageWest Jolaibari, Ashrampara, P.O. & P.S. Baikhora, District: South
Tripura.
[Owner of vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03-B1784 Mini Truck].
4.
Sri Benu Chandra Das, son of Sri Debendra Chandra Das, Prop. Benu
Tea Stall (opposite R.K.Pur Post Office), P.S. R. K. Pur, District:
Gomati Tripura.
[Owner of vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03K-0260 Maruti
Suzuki Omni].
5.
New India Assurance Company Ltd., Agartala Branch, Mantribari
Road, Agartala, West Tripura.
[Insurer of vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03-K-0260 Maruti
Suzuki Omni].
6.
Smti. Rekha Das, wife of Sri Prafulla Chandra Das, resident of East
Badharghat, Ward No.45, Agartala Municipal Council, P.O. Madhuban
(Dukli), P.S. Amtali, Agartala, West Tripura.
.....Respondents
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing & delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. P. K. Ghosh, Advocate.
Mr. T. K. Deb, Advocate.
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. G.S. Das, Advocate.
06.01.2023
YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER [ORAL]
Heard Mr. P. K. Ghosh, learned counsel appearing for the
appellant. Also heard Mr. T. Deb, Mr. S. Lodh and Mr. GS Das, learned
counsel appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This is an application filed under Section-173 of the Motor
Vehicles Act, 1988 against the judgment and award dated 09.03.2022 passed in
Case No.TS (MAC) 57 of 2017 by the learned Motor Accident Claims
Tribunal, Tribunal No.1, Gomati Judicial District, Udaipur Tripura, awarding
Rs.59,30,500/- only against the appellant-opposite party No.2 Shriram General
Insurance @7.5@ interest per annum from the date of filing of the claim
petition i.e. from 05.12.2017 till realization.
[3]
The case of the petitioner’s as discernible from the claim petition
is that on 24.04.2017 the husband of petitioner No.1 Utpal Das (now deceased)
along with two others were proceeding towards Agartala by boarding the
vehicle No.TR-03-K-0260 (Maruti Van). The vehicle was being driven in
moderate speed and was proceeding keeping extreme left side of the road. In
this process when it reached at Office Tilla in front of Bishalgarh Court, it was
dashed by another vehicle bearing No.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck) which was
coming from the opposite direction. Resultantly, an accident occurred and the
passengers of the Maruti Van including Utpal Das and its driver sustained
grievous injuries on their persons. Then and there the injured persons were
taken to Tripura Medical College & Dr. BRAM Teaching Hospital, Hapania
wherein on examination the attending physician declared the husband of
petitioner No.1 as dead.
[4]
It is alleged by the petitioner that the accident occurred due to
rash and negligent driving of the driver of vehicle No.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini
Truck). A police case bearing No.24/2017 under Sections 279/338/304A of
IPC and Section 184/187 of M.V.Act was registered at Bishalgarh PS based on
the suo-moto FIR lodged by Inspector S. Basu Roy Choudhury, O/C
Bishalgarh P/S. It is stated by the petitioner that at the time of death the
deceased was an young energetic and healthy man of 33 years and was a Govt.
Employee serving as Rfn. (GD) under 2nd Battalion, Tripura State Rifles and
used to draw monthly salary of Rs.50,000/-. The claimants were dependent
upon the income of the deceased. Finally, the petitioners claim compensation
to the tune of Rs.01,05,60,000/-.
[5]
After hearing the parties and perusal of the material evidence on
record, the learned Tribunal has observed as under:
“In the result, it is ordered that, the petitioners and the respondent No.5
are entitled to compensation of Rs.59,30,500/- (fiftynine Lac thirty
thousand and five hundred only) in total. The share of respondent no.5
is determined at Rs.7,50,000/- (Seven lacs fifty thousand) only
considering her advanced age and the fact that claimant No.1 being a
young widow and claimant No.2 being a school going student will be in
need of more money than respondent no. 5 who will always have the
back up of pension of her husband and thereafter will be entitled to
family pension. The O.P. No.2, Shriram General Insurance Company
Ltd., insurer of vehicle No.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck) is directed to
make the payment of compensation to the petitioners within two months
from today along with interest thereon @ 7.5% per annum from the date
of filing of claim petition i.e. from 05.12.2017 till payment/realization of
the same.”
[6]
Mr. P. K. Ghosh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant
insurance company, in his usual manner has contended that the claimantrespondent No.1 has failed to prove rash and negligent driving on the part of
the driver of the vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03-B-1784(Mini Truck)
and on the basis of the charge-sheet, came to an erroneous conclusion that the
appellant was liable to pay the compensation.
[7]
The learned Tribunal while discussing the evidence, has recorded
that the claimant-respondents had denied the suggestion of the owner of the
vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03K-0260 (Maruti Suzuki Omni), the
respondent No.4 herein that the said vehicle had no role. The Court below has
erred both in law and fact by not appreciating the fact that there was a head on
collusion between the two vehicle i.e. on Mini Truck and another Maruti Omni
and the investigating agency by the charge sheet after examining the statement
of witnesses, held that both the vehicles were liable for the alleged accident.
[8]
He has further averred that the learned Court has failed to
appreciate that both the owners of the vehicles stated that the vehicles were not
in fault but, the burden was shifted on the appellant insurance company
holding that the mini truck was liable as he arrived in a conclusion that the said
accident occurred due to the negligence of the driver of the vehicle bearing
registration No. TR-03-B-1784(Mini Truck).
[9]
The award passed by the learned Tribunal is perverse and is one
side as the respondent No.5 herein, adduced evidence as OPW-1 through its
administrative officer and he specifically stated the vehicle which was insured
with them is a private car and carrying on passengers, is illegal, violating the
terms and condition of the policy and a private car cannot use for commercial
purpose. The learned Tribunal considered that the deposition of OPW-1 was
fettled for the owner of the said vehicle bearing registration No. TR-03K-0260
(Maruti Suzuki Omni) and as such, though there was a specific mention in the
charge sheet regarding negligence of both the vehicles.
[10]
He has further contended that the learned Tribunal held that on
the date of accident the drivers of both the vehicles had valid driving license
and both the vehicles had valid registration certificate along with all other
documents and the vehicles were duly insured with the insurance company
covering the date of accident and as such, the liability of paying compensation
is to be shouldered by the insurance company, is quite illegal and false.
[11]
The learned Tribunal while applying the multiplier to determine
the quantum of compensation did not consider that a total loss of income
should not have been calculated as because the survivors of the deceased
would be entitled to family pension and other benefits due to the death of the
deceased. The Tribunal has further held that the vehicle, Mini Truck did not
raise any issue of contributory, but it will be evident from the findings of the
learned Tribunal that the claim of both the owners were that they were to be
exonerated as because their vehicles were insured with the respective insurance
company and it was agitated before the learned Tribunal by both the owners
and their respective insurers that their vehicles were not at fault and the issue
ought to have considered as both the vehicles were head on collusion and both
the vehicles involved in the alleged accident and for that the liability should be
fixed on both the vehicles, but the learned Tribunal fixed only one vehicle, is
quite illegal and it needs to be interfered with.
[12]
Both the witnesses including the respondent No.1 stated that the
accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the vehicle No.TR-03B-1784 (Mini Truck) by its driver. Though they admitted the involvement of
the vehicle No.TR-03-K-0260 (Maruti Suzuki omni) in the accident but they
denied the fact that the said vehicle was responsible for the accident.
[13]
In support of their case they have submitted the certified copy of
FIR (Ext.2). It is a suo-moto FIR lodged by the Police which revealed that both
the vehicles collided each other face to face on the road due to rash and
negligent driving by the drivers and damage caused in front side of both the
vehicles. As a result of accident all the passengers of Maruti Van including
Utpal Das, husband of the petitioner, sustained injuries and on the way to
hospital Utpal Das died. Due to rash and negligent driving of both the vehicles
the accident occurred and accordingly, police lodged suo-moto FIR against the
drivers of both the vehicles. After investigation police also came to the
conclusion that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the
drivers of both the vehicles and in the accident the husband of the respondent
No.1 sustained injuries and on the way to hospital he succumbed to his injuries
and accordingly, they submitted charge-sheet against the driver of both the
vehicles.
[14]
General presumption is that a truck is more powerful and bigger
in size than a private car (Omni) which is smaller and less powerful.
Whenever, these two types of vehicles collided face to face there is every
possibility of causing more casualty/damage to the private car than the truck .
Only because the extent of casualty/damage of the private car is higher, it
would not be safe to assume that the accident occurred due to fault of the truck
vehicle.
[15]
However there is no doubt that husband of the respondent No.1
died in a road accident and that the accident occurred due to negligence of the
driver of the offending vehicles and that deceased had no contributory
negligence in the matter being a passenger only. In National Insurance
Company Ltd Vs Chamundeswari and ors., reported in 2021 ACJ 2558 of
2019, it was held that the evidence adduced in the Tribunal shall have
preference over what is written in FIR and in case FIR runs contrary to the
evidence recorded before tribunal then evidence before tribunal shall prevail.
In this case both the witnesses deposed that accident occurred due to fault of
the truck driver. The evidence of PW.2 is more specific and reliable.
[16]
He is a survivor of the accident. He deposed that the Maruti
Omni was proceeding on extreme left and in moderate speed. Inspite of that the
truck hit it from opposite direction. Thus the fault lies with the truck driver. In
Kalpana Majumder and ors vs Sankar Debnath and anr (2017) 2 TLR 74 it
was held that reliance cannot be placed on contents of police investigation
report to disbelieve the case of the respondent. Therefore, it is evident that
Utpal Das sustained injuries on 24.04.2017 in a road traffic accident out of the
use of the offending vehicles bearing registration Nos.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini
Truck) and TR-03- K-0260 (Maruti Suzuki omni) and consequently died. As
such, the respondent No.1 has prima-facie discharged her liability of proving
that death of her husband occurred due to accident caused by the negligence of
the driver of offending vehicles specially that of TR-03-B- 1784 (Mini Truck).
[17]
As regards respondent No.5 Smt. Rekha Das it appears that she is
the mother of the deceased Utpal Das and the petitioner No.1 also admitted that
her mother-in-law is alive. According to the petitioner, her mother-in-law is
not dependent upon the income of her husband as her father-in-law is a
pensioner. The respondent No.5 also admitted the fact that her husband is a
Pensioner being retired Govt. Employee but averred that the amount is meagre.
Moreover, the respondent No.6 herein is a legal heir of the deceased & she is
also entitled to compensation for the death of her son in road traffic accident
more so because the bond of a mother and a son is not dissolved on his
marriage and a son is duty bound to maintain his mother even after marriage.
[18]
The respondent No.1 stated that her husband i.e. the deceased
Utpal Das was a Government Servant and serving as Rifleman under 2nd Bn.
TSR, R.K.Nagar. In this regard she submitted the salary certificate (Ext.6)
issued by the DDO (Asstt. Commandant, 2nd Bn. TSR, R.K.Nagar) whereby it
appears that in the month of April, 2017 the gross salary of the deceased was
Rs.32,633/-. Since the respondent No.1 has submitted the salary certificate of
the deceased issued by his DDO, Lalhim Molsom, Asstt. Commandent, 2nd. Bn
TSR, R.K.Nagar, having DDO Code No.2002, this Court finds no reason to
disbelieve the monthly income of the deceased. The salary certificate shows
that there was monthly deduction of Rs.208/- towards professional tax and
Rs.150/- towards General Insurance Scheme.
[19]
Had the deceased been alive he had to pay these two amounts
throughout his service life. So, after deducting the professional tax and the
premium under General Insurance Scheme, the monthly salary comes at
Rs.32,275/-. As per guideline given by the Hon’ble Apex Court in Sarala
Verma and Ors. V. Delhi Trasport Corporation & Anr., reported in (2009) 6
SCC 121 the multiplier ‘15’ is adopted to determine the compensation.
Therefore, the yearly income of the deceased comes at Rs.3,87,300/- and
applying multiplier the amount comes at Rs.3,87,300/- x 15 = 58,09,500/-. As
per the ratio set forth in Sarala Verma (supra), personal and living expenses of
the deceased should be taken as one third (1/3rd) as the dependent family
members of the deceased consisted of three members only and as such, the
amount towards loss of dependency comes at Rs.38,73,000/- after deducting
Rs.19,36,500/- for personal expense.
[20]
As per ratio laid down in National Insurance Company Ltd. vs.
Pranay Sethi reported in (2017) 16 SCC 680 an addition of 50% of actual
salary/ income of the deceased towards future prospects, where the deceased
had a permanent job and was below the age of 40 years is to be awarded. In the
case in hand, deceased was a permanent Govt. Employee and he was below the
age of 40 years. Therefore, as future prospect the respondent-claimant are
entitled to a further sum of Rs.19,36,500/- as loss of future prospective income.
[21]
In addition to this amount the respondent-claimant are also
entitled to Rs.15,000/- as loss of estate, Rs.15,000/- as funeral expenses. A
further sum of Rs.40,000/- as spousal consortium is awarded to claimant
respondent No. 1 Smt. Nandita Datta. The minor daughter of the deceased
Utpal Das is also entitled to Rs.40,000/- as parental consortium in terms of the
ratio laid down in Magma General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nanu Ram @
Chuhru Ram & Ors., (2018) 18 SCC 130, affirmed in United India Insurance
Company vs. Satinder Kaur, reported in (2020) SCC Online 410. Thus, the
total conventional amount comes to Rs.1,10,000/-. In Pranay Sethi supra the
Apex Court directed that these conventional amounts should be increased by
10% every three years. Since that judgment already 5 years have passed. Thus,
1,10,000/- awarded under heads loss of estate, consortium & funeral
expenditure is increased to Rs.1,21,000/-. Therefore, in total the compensation
comes to Rs.59,30,500/-(Rs 38,73,000+Rs 19,36,500/-+Rs 1,21,000/-).
[22]
Now, the question arises who is to pay the compensation. It is
already concluded that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving
of the driver of vehicle No.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck). The claimants have
also made claim against TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck) only and adduced
evidence to that effect. After investigation, police held both the drivers of the
vehicles responsible for the accident. The liability to pay compensation in a
case of composite negligence is both joint as well as several. The insurance
company or owner of TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck) did not raise the issue of
contributory negligence on the part of the other vehicle and for apportionment
of the compensation amount. Therefore owner of TR-03- B-1784 (Mini Truck)
is fastened with liability to pay the compensation.
[23]
As regards vehicle No.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck), its owner
submitted the registration certificate, insurance certificate and driving licence
of the driver which were marked as Ext.E, Ext.F and Ext.G respectively. On
perusal of the registration certificate and driving licence same are found to be
valid on the date of accident. The driver was competent to drive the vehicle as
per driving licence. It appears from the policy papers of insurance that the
offending vehicle bearing registration No.TR-03-B-1784 (Mini Truck) was
duly insured covering the date of accident and type of policy was package
policy, which includes third party damage.
[24]
It was argued by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant-
insurance company that the vehicle No.TR-03-K-0260 (Maruti Suzuki Omni)
is a private car and the owner of the vehicle used the vehicle for commercial
purpose by carrying passengers. Any use of private car for commercial purpose
is in violation of the terms and conditions of the insurance policy. As such, the
insurer of the vehicle is not liable to pay any compensation. Moreover the New
India Assurance Company Ltd. could not show by adducing cogent evidence
that the offending vehicle was used for commercial purpose.
[25]
I have gone through the factual and legal aspects of the instant
appeal and this Court is of the considered opinion that the findings as returned
by the learned Tribunal need not be interfered with. As such, I find no infirmity
in the judgment of the learned Motor Accident Claims Tribunal and it has not
been interfered with. Thus, the appeal stands dismissed. Draw the decree
accordingly and thereafter LCRs be sent back. It is further made clear that the
claimants are at liberty to withdraw the amount deposited to their respective
shares, as per procedure. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending,
if any, shall stand closed.
CHIEF JUSTICE (ACTING)
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review