Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.20580 of 2018
======================================================
Shrikant Kumar S/o- Bachha Prasad Yadav, Resident of Kundilpur, P.o.
Bargajwa, P.S. Sikarpur, District- West Champaran, Bihar- 845451.
1.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd. Through its Chairman cum Managing
Director (CMD), Bharat Bhavan, 4 and 6 Currimbhoy Road, Ballard State
Post Box No. 688, Mumbai- 400001.
2.
Chairman-cum-Managing Director (CMD), Bharat Petroleum Corporation
Ltd., Bharat Bhavan, 4 and 6 Currimbhoy Road, Ballard State Post Box No.
688, Mumbai- 400001.
3.
The Board of Directors through Company Secretary, Bharat Petroleum
Corporation Ltd, Bharat Bhavan, 4 and 6 Currimbhoy Road, Ballard State
Post Box No. 688, Mumbai- 400001.
4.
Executive Director, LPG, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd., Bharat
Petroleum Corporation Ltd, Bharat Bhavan, 4 and 6 Currimbhoy Road,
Ballard State Post Box No. 688, Mumbai- 400001.
5.
Chief General Manager, LPG Sales and Marketing, Bharat Petroleum
Corporation Ltd., Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd, Bharat Bhavan, 4 and
6 Currimbhoy Road, Ballard State Post Box No. 688, Mumbai- 400001.
6.
Chief General Manager, LPG Operations, Bharat Petroleum Corporation
Ltd., Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd, Bharat Bhavan, 4 and 6
Currimbhoy Road, Ballard State Post Box No. 688, Mumbai- 400001.
7.
Chief General Manager Retail/LPG East Zone Region, Bharat Petroleum
Corporation Ltd., Bharat Bhavan, Plot No. 31, KIT Sehama 118, Prince
Golam Mohd. Shah Road, Get Green Kolkata- 70095.
8.
Chief Regional Manager, LPG, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd.,
Regional Office- Ashiana Chambers, 3rd Floor, Exhibition Road, Patna.800001.
9.
Territory Manager, LPG, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd, narayanpur,
Near Present Railway Station, Village- Sherpur, P.O. M.K. Bela,
Muzaffarpur - 842005, Bihar.
10. Area Manager, Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd., Narayanpur, Near
Present Railway Station, Village- Sherpur, P.O. M.K. Bela, Muzaffarpur842005, Bihar.
11. Section Offcier (S.O.) Bettiah LPG, Narayanpur, Near Present Railway
Station, Village- Sherpur, P.O. M.K. Bela, Muzaffarpur- 842005, Bihar.
12. The State of Bihar through Collector, West Champaran at Bettiah.
13. The Collector, West Champaran at Bettiah.
14. The Additional District Collector, Panchayati Raj, West Champaran at
Bettiah.
15. The Sub-Divisional Officer, Narkatiyaganj, West Champaran.
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
2/13
16. The Block Development Officer, Narkatiyaganj, West Champaran.
17. The Anchal Adhikari, Narkatiyaganj, West Champaran.
18. The Gram Panchayat Sectary (GPS), Rajpur Turkadiya, West Champaran.
19. The Anchal Nirikshak (Circle Inspector)-cum- Karamchari, Anchal
Narkatiyaganj, West Champaran.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
For the Respondent
BPCL
For the State
:
:
M/s Anshuman Singh
Rakesh Kumar No.1, Advocates
Ms. Aditi Hansarai, Advocate
:
Mr. Rohit Singh, AC to GP 6
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE JUSTICE SMT. G. ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY
ORAL JUDGMENT
Date : 09-09-2026
I.A. No. 1 of 2019:
1. I.A. No. 1 of 2019 is filed to amend the
prayer portion at paragraph 1 of the Writ petition
due to the subsequent developments as 1(D)
2. Accordingly, I.A. No. 1 of 2029 is hereby
allowed, amending the prayer portion. The reliefs
mentioned in paragraph No. 1 thereof would form
part of the Writ petition.
C.W.J.C. No. 20580 of 2018
3. The petitioner has filed the Writ petition
for the following reliefs:
“(A)
To
quash
and
set
aside
the
no.
cancellation
letter
reference
LPG.ER.MUZP.
RAJPUR
(OBC).2018-19
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
3/13
dated 18.09.2018 (Annexure17 herein)
under the signature of Respondent No.
9 cancelling the candidature for the
Gramin
LPG
Distributorship
of
the
petitioner after giving clearance for
fulfilling all the condition of the United
Guidelines
for
Selection
of
LPG
Distributor June 2017 at Location Rajpur
Gram
Panchayat
Rajpur
Block
Narkatiaganj,
Tumkadiya,
District-
West
Champaran under OBC category for
Marketing Plan 2017-18.
(B) For direction to the Respondents 1st
Set
authorities
to
approve
the
application for appointment and award
Distributorship for LPG Gramin Vitrak at
Location Rajpur Gram Panchayat Rajpur
Tumkadia, Block Narkatiaganj, District
West Champaran, under OBC category
for Security Deposit of Rs. three (3)
lacs. vide Advertisement on 18.06.2017.
(C) For any other relief/reliefs for which
the petitioner found to be entitled for in
accordance with law.
(D) For issuance of Writ/ Writs order/
orders, direction / directions to quash
the and set aside Respondent No. 1
Bharat
Petroleum
Corporation
Ltd
Advertisement dated 07.10.2018 in the
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
4/13
Dainik
Jagaran
News
Paper
giving
noticefor draw of Lottery on 12.10.2018
for location, already the same had been
awarded to this petitioner as per their
advertisement
dated
18.06.2017
in
Dainik Jagaran News Paper Annexure 1
at the running page no. 24 of the
connected Writ petition) at location
Rajpur Gram Panchayat Rajpur, Block
Narkatiaganj District West Champaran,
Category OBC for Rural Market (Gramin)
for Marketing plan 2017 2018.”
4. The brief facts culled out of the Writ
petition, are that the petitioner applied pursuant to
the
advertisement
dated
18.06.2017
for
appointment of LPG Gramin Vitrak at Rajpur, Gram
Panchayat Tumkadia, Block Narkatiyaganj, District
West Champaran, under the OBC category. He was
declared successful in the draw of lots and,
thereafter, deposited the requisite amount and
submitted all the documents demanded by the
Respondent-BPCL.
5. The documents submitted by
the
petitioner and the land offered by him were
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
5/13
verified during Field Verification of Credentials. The
only discrepancy subsequently noticed was that
Khesra No. 459 had inadvertently been mentioned
as Khesra No. 259 in the registered lease deed
dated 15.07.2017. According to the petitioner, it
was a bona fide typographical error. On the advice
of the BPCL authorities, the petitioner got the error
rectified through a registered Correction Deed
dated 04.04.2018 and also submitted the requisite
affidavits and fresh Land Possession Certificate.
6. However, by letter dated 18.09.2018,
the Respondent-BPCL cancelled the petitioner's
candidature
solely
on
account
discrepancy.
The
petitioner
of
the
said
challenged
the
cancellation, contending that the error had already
been rectified, all eligibility conditions had been
fulfilled and his credentials had been duly verified.
7. It is further the case of the petitioner
that, despite pendency of the Writ petition and
knowledge thereof, the Respondent-BPCL issued
further
advertisements
dated
07.10.2018
and
06.01.2019 for holding fresh draw of lots for the
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
6/13
same location, thereby seeking to create thirdparty rights in respect of the distributorship.
8. The Learned counsel for the petitioner
submits that the petitioner was duly selected in the
draw of lots pursuant to the advertisement dated
18.06.2017 and had fulfilled all the requirements of
the Respondent-BPCL. The cancellation was based
only on a bona fide typographical error in the
Khesra number, which was subsequently rectified
through a registered Correction Deed on the advice
of the BPCL authorities themselves.
9. The Learned counsel for the petitioner
further submits that the petitioner's credentials
and land offered by him had already been verified
and found satisfactory. Therefore, the cancellation
of his candidature was arbitrary and unjustified. It
is also submitted that during pendency of the Writ,
the Respondent-BPCL could not have issued fresh
advertisements and proceeded to create thirdparty rights, in respect of the same distributorship.
Learned counsel, accordingly, seeks quashing of
the cancellation letter dated 18.09.2018 and the
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
7/13
subsequent
advertisements/letters
dated
07.10.2018 and 06.01.2019, and consequential
relief in favour of the petitioner
10. The Learned counsel for the petitioner
also submits that the error in mentioning the
Khata/Khesra number in the original application
was only
a mistake,
boundaries
of
the
while the identity
land
remained
the
and
same.
Reliance has been placed upon the judgment of
the Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in Civil Appeal
No.2702 of 2022 (Rupesh Kumar Verma Vs.
Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. & Ors.), to contend
that such a rectifiable error ought not to defeat the
candidature where the identity of the land is
otherwise established.
11. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rupesh
Kumar Verma (supra) held as follows:
"Since the mistake came to the
notice of the appellant after the field
verification conducted by was the officials
of the respondents, the appellant has got
theregistered lease deed rectified by a
registered document. However, it may be
stated that the boundaries in both the
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
8/13
same. original lease deed and the rectified
lease deed are the Therefore, there is no
dispute about the identification of the plot
but only the description of the plot which
was corrected by virtue of the rectification
deed. Since it is case of mistake apparent
on record and was only in the Khata
number and plot number, we deem it
appropriate to allow the appeal in the
facts of the present case.
Therefore, the order passed by
the Division Bench of the High Court on
26.06.2019 is set aside and that of the
Single Judge is restored. The respondents
shall issue letter of intent to the appellant
forthwith."
12. The Learned counsel for the petitioner
accordingly
submits
that
the
petitioner's
candidature was rejected on technical grounds
without considering the substance of his claim and
the subsequent compliance made by him, and that
the action of the respondents is arbitrary and calls
for interference by this Court.
13. A counter affidavit was filed on behalf
of the respondent- BPCL. The Learned counsel for
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
9/13
the respondents submits that the petitioner's
candidature was cancelled strictly in accordance
with the Unified Guidelines for Selection of LPG
Distributors, 2017, as the Khasra No. mentioned in
his application and registered lease deed was 259,
whereas the Land Possession Certificate produced
at the time of FVC mentioned Khasra No. 459.
14.
The
Learned
counsel
for
the
respondents submits that the Field Verification of
Credentials was conducted on 14.07.2018 and the
FVC
Committee
specifically
noticed
the
said
discrepancy and did not recommend issuance of
the Letter of Intent. It is further submitted that the
Industry Record Note dated 06.04.2018 specifically
required rejection of an application where there
was a mismatch in the Khasra/Gata number,
irrespective of whether the discrepancy was due to
an error in the application or in the lease deed.
15.
respondents,
The
Learned
therefore,
counsel
submits
for
the
that
the
subsequent correction deed could not cure the
discrepancy in the particulars originally furnished
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
10/13
by the petitioner, particularly in view of the
declaration made by him in the application form.
The cancellation dated 18.09.2018 was, therefore,
in accordance with the applicable guidelines and
calls for no interference in exercise of Writ
jurisdiction. The Writ, accordingly, deserves to be
dismissed.
16. Heard the Learned counsel for the
petitioner as well as learned counsel appearing for
the
respondents
and
perused
the
materials
available on record.
17.
Having
considered
the
rival
submissions and the materials available on record,
this Court finds that the candidature of the
petitioner came to be cancelled only on account of
the discrepancy in the Khesra number, i.e. Khesra
No.
having
been
mentioned
in
the
application/lease deed, whereas Khesra No. 459
was subsequently reflected in the Land Possession
Certificate.
18. The petitioner has consistently taken
the stand that the said discrepancy was a bona
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
11/13
fide mistake. The same was subsequently rectified
by a registered Correction Deed dated 04.04.2018.
It is also not in dispute that the land offered by the
petitioner was identifiable and that the boundaries
of the land remained unchanged. Thus, the dispute
relates only to the description of the land by its
Khesra number and not to the identity of the land
itself.
19. In the facts of the present case, this
Court finds that the issue is squarely covered by
the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in
Rupesh Kumar Verma
(supra), wherein the
Hon'ble Supreme Court, in circumstances relating
to a mistake in the Khata and plot number which
was
subsequently
rectified
by
a
registered
document, held that where the identity of the plot
was
otherwise
established
by
the
same
boundaries, such rectifiable mistake ought not to
defeat the candidature.
20. Applying the aforesaid principle to the
facts of the present case, this Court is of the view
that the subsequent rectification of the Khesra
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
12/13
number, coupled with the fact that the identity and
boundaries of the land remained undisputed, ought
to have been considered by the respondents. The
cancellation of the petitioner's candidature solely
on the basis of the discrepancy in the Khesra
number,
despite
its
subsequent
rectification,
cannot, in the facts of the present case, be
sustained.
21. Accordingly, the cancellation letter
dated 18.09.2018 is hereby quashed and set aside.
The respondents are directed to consider the
candidature of the petitioner in the light of the
judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Rupesh
Kumar
Verma
accordance
with
(supra)
law.
and
Since
the
proceed
in
subsequent
advertisements were issued for the same location
during the pendency of the Writ, any consequential
action taken pursuant thereto shall abide by the
decision to be taken by the respondents in terms of
this order.
22.
allowed.
The
Writ
petition
is,
accordingly,
Patna High Court CWJC No.20580 of 2018 dt.09-09-2026
13/13
23. Interlocutory Application(s), if any,
shall stand disposed of.
(G. Anupama Chakravarthy, J)
Spd/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
NAFR
NA
11.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review