Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
CONT.CAS(C) NO.22 OF 2024
Shri Timirendu Bhowmik,
Aged about 59 years,
son of late Gopi Ballabh Bhaumik,
Of Badurtali Lane, Krishnanagar,
P.O. Agartala, P.S. West Agartala, West Tripura.
……Petitioner(s)
Versus
Smt. Kanika Nath(Bhaumik),
Wife of Sri Timirendu Bhaumik,
Daughter of late Pulin Behari Nath,
Resident of Coloniel Chowmuhani,
P.O.-Agartala-7990016, P.S. West Agartala,
District-West Tripura.
.......Respondent(s)
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. Sankar Lodh, Advocate.
Mr. K. Roy, Advocate.
Mr. S. Majumder, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. Datta, P.P.
Mr. A. Baidya, Advocate.
Mr. B.K. Bhattacharyya, Advocate.
Mr. B. Banerjee, Advocate.
Mr. S. Sarkar, Advocate.
Mr. S. Sutradhar, Advocate.
Mr. S. Chakraborty, Advocate.
Mr. Siraj Ali., Advocate.
Date of hearing and delivery of
Judgment & Order
: 11/12/2025
Whether fit for reporting
: Yes
HON’BLE JUSTICE DR. T. AMARNATH GOUD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
J U D G M E N T & O R D E R(ORAL)
T. AMARNATH GOUD(J)
1.
This present appeal has been filed for drawing up contempt
proceedings against the respondent-contemnor for wilful breach of the
undertaking given before this Court by the contemnor, which was recorded in
the order dated 14.12.2023 in connection with F.A. No. 1 of 2023.
2.
Heard Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, as well as Mr. Siraj Ali, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent-contemnor.
3.
When the case is called, both sides are present. The
contemnor is also present in person.
4.
The chronology of the present matter is that firstly, on
04.04.2024, the case came up before the Bench of Hon’ble Mr. Justice Arindam
Lodh and Hon’ble Mr. Justice S.D. Purkayastha. On that day, notice was issued
upon the respondent-contemnor, returnable within three days. Dasti service was
also permitted and the matter was fixed on 16.05.2024. The said order is
reproduced here-in-below:“This Court had passed an order dated 14.12.2023 in F.A. No.01 of
2023 on the basis of the settlement arrived at by the parties in the appeal. For convenience,
order dated 14.12.2023 may be reproduced hereunder:“We have personally heard Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhowmik), the
appellant-wife and Sri Timirendu Bhaumik, the respondent-husband. We have
also heard their daughters, namely, Smt. Sreyashee Bhaumik and Ms. Saheli
Bhaumik virtually.
We have interacted with both the appellant-wife and the
respondent-husband for a considerable time and ultimately they have entered
into the following agreements:1) There shall be a decree of dissolution of marriage between the
appellant-wife and the respondent-husband.
2) The respondent-husband shall purchase a 1 BHK flat with enough
space for drawing and dining rooms under Agartala Municipal Corporation area
within a period of 6(six) months from today and the flat will be furnished at the
expense of the respondent-husband, Sri Timirendu Bhaumik.
3) In addition to that, the monthly maintenance allowance has been
enhanced to Rs.17,000/- (Rupees seventeen thousand) from Rs.10,000/- (Rupees
ten thousand).
4) The respondent-husband shall be responsible for taking care
of the appellant-wife, in case of any serious health issues. For example, if she is
admitted in any hospital for serious medical ailments, then all the expenditures
will be borne by the respondent-husband.
5) Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhowmik), the appellant has agreed and
given undertaking to this Court that she will transfer all the properties, that is,
flats, lands and buildings which are in her name in favour of her two daughters
within 3(three) months from today and the expenditure for such transfer/s by way
of sale or gift shall be borne by the respondenthusband, Sri Timirendu Bhaumik.
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhowmik), being the mother shall always try
to keep in touch with her daughters and pacify them to stay with her.
In terms of above agreements, draw a decree of dissolution of
marriage.
Both the parties have undertaken before this Court to enforce the
above terms as mentioned in this order.
Parties have put their signatures in the order sheet.
Accordingly, the instant appeal stands disposed in the above
terms.
Sd/- Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhowmik)
Sd/- Sri Timirendu Bhowmik”
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that the respondent-contemnor is not responding compelling his client
i.e. the petitioner herein to serve demand notice enclosing draft deed for its
execution. Even then, the respondent-contemnor did not turn up. Mr. Lodh,
learned counsel has further submitted that violation of undertaking amounts to
contempt of court.
In view of this, issue notice calling upon the respondentcontemnor to show cause as to why a proceeding under Section 12 of the
Contempt of Courts Act shall not be drawn against her, as prayed for; and/or why
such further and other order(s) shall not be passed as to this Court may deem fit
and proper.
Notice is made returnable within 4(six) weeks.
The petitioner shall take steps for causing service of notice upon
the respondent-contemnor within 3(three) days by registered post with AD.
Dasti service is also allowed.
List the matter on 16.05.2024.”
5.
On 16.05.2024, a last chance was given to the wife–
respondent-contemnor to comply with the terms and conditions mentioned in
the decree of divorce and the matter was listed on 20.06.2024.
6.
On 20.06.2024, the respondent-contemnor was directed to
appear in person before the Court on 27.06.2024 at 10:30 a.m. positively for
breach of the terms and conditions of the undertaking given by her to the Court.
7.
Vide order dated 27.06.2024, the wife, Smt. Kanika Nath
(Bhaumik), agreed and gave an undertaking to the Court that she would execute
the gift deed in favour of her daughters within the month of July, 2024. She
further agreed and undertook that she would execute a gift deed in favour of her
daughter, namely, Smt. Saheli Bhaumik, on 8th July, 2024 itself in respect of the
properties at Agartala standing in her name. She also undertook to visit Kolkata
to register a deed of gift transferring her share in the flat situated at Kolkata in
favour of her daughter, Smt. Sreyashee Bhaumik, within the month of July,
2024. The husband, Sri Timirendu Bhowmik, was to bear all expenses towards
travelling and stay of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) at Kolkata.
The husband agreed and undertook that after handing over
vacant possession of the flat, he would take all necessary steps to furnish the
same within a period of thirty days. The builder was to execute the sale deed of
the flat in favour of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) on 08.07.2024 after receipt of
the consideration money to be paid by Sri Timirendu Bhowmik. The SubRegistrar, Sadar, was directed to register the sale deed of the flat as well as the
gift deeds as stated above in accordance with law on 08.07.2024. The
appearance of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) was dispensed with and a copy of
the order was directed to be forwarded to the learned counsel for both parties as
well as to the Sub-Registrar, Sadar. The matter was listed on 08.08.2024.
8.
Thereafter, in the meantime, while passing the order in I.A.
No. 01 of 2024 dated 06.09.2024, this Court observed that:–:“4.3 During the proceedings of the first appeal, we made
attempts to conciliate the disputes between the couple, but it did not yield any
result. We also heard their two daughters. During interactions, both the
daughters had levelled serious allegations against their mother, Smt. Kanika
Nath (Bhaumik). It is pertinent to mention that both the daughters are major.
One daughter, namely Smt. Sreyashee Bhaumik is a post-graduate in English,
now married. The younger daughter, Smt. Saheli Bhaumik is pursuing her LLB
course in Dehradun. Both the daughters informed this Court that their mother
had abandoned them for her selfish lifestyle and their mother, Smt. Kanika Nath
(Bhaumik) not only tortured them but also their father, Sri Timirendu Bhowmik.
Both the daughters informed this Court that Sri. Timirendu Bhowmik used to
take care of them and played the role as mother in their upbringing. Though, it
was a suit instituted by the wife-respondent, we, on our own notion tried to
persuade the husband-Sri Timirendu Bhowmik to go for divorce as his wife Smt.
Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) was found to be very rigid in seeking divorce. We also
persuaded Sri Timirendu Bhowmik to accommodate his wife substantially.
Accordingly, it was agreed upon that Husband-Sri Timirendu Bhowmik would
purchase a flat for peaceful stay of the wife-Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) and
also to pay a maintenance allowance to the tune of Rs.17,000/- per month. Sri
Timirendu Bhowmik also had undertaken that he would take care of her health
in future i.e. during her entire life. It was also undertaken that he would bear all
the expenditure if Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) is admitted in any hospital out of
some disease. Simultaneously, the wife also had undertaken that she would
transfer the properties, which were purchased by Sri Timirendu Bhowmik in the
name of his wife in favour of her two daughters, namely Smt. Saheli Bhaumik
and Smt. Sreyashee Bhaumik by way of “sale or gift” within the month of July,
2024, which would be revealed from the order dated 14.12.2023 in FA 1 of 2023.
Under clause (2) of the terms of settlement it was decided that the husband-Sri
Timirendu Bhowmik would purchase the flat within a period of 6(six) months
from the date of the order dated 14.12.2023. It was also agreed upon that all the
expenses would be borne by Sri Timirendu Bhowmik. With the aforesaid
directions, the first appeal was disposed of by order dated 14.12.2023. Thereafter,
though, Sri Timirendu Bhowmik had purchased the flat but it could not be
registered since the respondent-wife did not come forward for the purpose of
execution and registration of the sale deed as regards the flat as undertaken to be
registered in her name………
4.5. It was agreed upon between the parties that
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) would visit to Kolkata to transfer her share over the
flat as well for registration, and in that case Sri Timirendu Bhowmik would bear
all expenses as regards her travelling and staying in Kolkata. Sri Timirendu
Bhowmik had also agreed and undertaken that after handing over the vacant
possession of the flat at Agartala, he would take all necessary steps to furnish the
same within a period of 30(thirty) days. The builder would execute the sale deed
of the flat in favour of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) on 8 th July, 2024 after
receipt of full consideration money to be paid by Sri Timirendu Bhowmik. For
smooth registration of flat in favour of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik), this Court
also directed the Sub-Registrar of Sadar to register the sale deed of the flat in
favour of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) and simultaneously the gift deed in
favour of Smt. Saheli Bhaumik as statedin that order dated 27.06.2024 on
08.07.2024. The said undertaking dated 27.06.2024 is clear and unambiguous.
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) on her own will and volition had agreed and
undertaken that she would transfer her properties in favour of her two daughters
by executing the registered gift deed. In that meanwhile, from the Registry’s note
dated 02.08.2024 in IA No.1 of 2024 arising out of Cont.Cas(C) No.22 of 2024, it
reveals that the petitioner had submitted an application under Section 151 of the
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 for recalling the order dated 27.06.2024 against
the respondent-contemnor i.e. Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik). The matter came up
on 29.08.2024 before this Court when learned advocates of Smt. Kanika Nath
(Bhaumik) had expressed their intention to retire from the case. Accordingly,
their prayer to retire from the case was allowed and another advocate, namely
Mr. Bikram Banerjee, learned counsel who came from Calcutta High Court had
appeared on behalf of Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik). The main contention of
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) and Mr. Banerjee, learned counsel appearing on
her behalf was to recall the order dated 27.06.2024 whereby and whereunder
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) had given an undertaken to transfer the properties
which are in her name in favour of her two daughters. However, this Court was
not inclined to accept that submission of learned counsel appearing on behalf of
her……..
4.8. Vide order dated 29.08.2024, it was held that Smt.
Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) had already breached her undertaking which she
undertook on 27.06.2024 in Cont.Cas(C) No.22 of 2024. It was also held that vide
order dated 27.06.2024, the undertaking dated 14.12.2023 passed in FA No.1 of
2023 lost its existence and the order dated 14.12.2023 was superseded by
subsequent order dated 27.06.2024. We opined that “the respondent-wife has
caused substantial damage to the dignity of this institution. She has wilfully and
deliberately flouted the order of this Court, in the meantime”. This Court directed
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) to appear in-person before this Court on
05.09.2024 at 10:30 a.m. However, we had given another opportunity to Smt.
Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) to respect and comply the Court’s order dated
27.06.2024 in that meanwhile. The matter came up on 05.09.2024 when neither
Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) nor any of her learned counsel appeared before
this Court. In that way, Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) also deliberately violated
the Court’s order dated 29.08.2024 passed in IA No.1 of 2024 arising out of
Cont.Cas(C) No.22 of 2024.
5. In that circumstance, the Court was compelled to issue a
bailable warrant directing the Officer In-charge, East Agartala Women Police
Station to cause her appearance before this Court today at 12:30 p.m. But as we
observed earlier, the police could not trace her out and has sought for a short
adjournment.
6. From the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we have no
hesitation to arrive at a conclusion that Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) will not
come forward to perform her part of performance of the undertaking as stated
here-in-above and she has deliberately and desperately avoiding the Court’s
proceedings. Her engaged learned advocates also have chosen to bypass the
Court proceedings. During the entire course of proceeding starting from first
appearance, records speak that she has changed many learned advocates and
they have retired from the case. This conduct of the respondent-wife is highly
deprecated, as being unwarranted and amounts to demeaning the dignity and
sanctity of the court. We have no hesitation to hold that she has no respect to
court. She has flouted and violated the order of the court as well as the law of the
land most deliberately and desperately which is not expected from a litigant. The
framers of law while framing the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908(CPC) could well
visualise of this kind of situation and for this, the framers have incorporated
appropriate provision in the C.P.C. The respondent-wife thinks that if she
remains absent from the Court’s proceeding, the Court will be helpless. But,
court is not helpless and to respond such a situation, the Court has taken the
recourse of law to execute its order in an appropriate and substantive manner
7. In catena of judgments, the Apex Court has held that
High Court in exercise of its contempt jurisdiction can execute its own order. In
the case of Md. Idris and Anr. Vs. Rustam Jehangir Bapuji and Ors, (1984) 4
SCC 216: Air 1984 SC 1826 , the Hon’ble Supreme Court while discussing the
powers of the High Court held that the Court must justify in giving appropriate
directions to close the breach of an undertaking, in addition to punish the party
for contempt of court. As we have already held that Smt. Kanika Nath
(Bhaumik), the respondent-contemnor is evading herself from performing her
part of undertaking, i.e. to transfer the properties which are in her name, in
favour of her two daughters named above by way of gift deed, in this
circumstance, we are constrained to direct the Registrar Judicial, High court of
Tripura to execute and register the gift deed in favour of her two daughters i.e.
the properties of Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) situated at Agartala in the name of
Smt. Saheli Bhaumik and her share over the flat situated in Prince Anwar Shah
Road in Kolkata in favour of Smt. Sreyashee Bhaumik. It is pertinent to mention
herein that the husband, Sri Timirendu Bhowmik has purchased the requisite
stamps for Agartala property for execution and registration of the gift deed in
favour of Smt. Saheli Bhaumik. Therefore, it is directed that the execution and
registration of the gift deed for the property situated at Agartala shall be
completed within a period of 7(seven) days from today.
Sri Timirendu Bhowmik is requested to contact Smt. Mou
Banerjee, Registrar (Judicial) of the High Court of Tripura tomorrow at 10:30
am. Registrar Judicial, High Court of Tripura is requested to peruse the order
and execute the gift deed as observed and directed here-in-above.
The Sub-Registrar, Sadar is also directed to make all
necessary arrangement to register gift deed in terms of this order.
Simultaneously, Smt. Mou Banerjee, Registrar (Judicial),
High Court of Tripura is also requested to execute and register the gift deed in
favour of Smt. Sreyashee Bhaumik as regards the share of Smt. Kanika Nath
(Bhaumik) over the property in Kolkata within a period of 1(one) month from
today. Sri Timirendu Bhowmik shall bear all expenses of travelling and staying
of Registrar (Judicial) in Kolkata.
9. In view of the report submitted by the Officer In-charge,
East Agartala Women Police Station, the previous bail bond is hereby recalled
and we issue fresh bailable warrant against Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik). On
her arrest, respondent-contemnor, Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik) may be released
on bail on furnishing a bond of Rs.10,000/-(rupees ten thousand) with one surety
of like amount to the satisfaction of the arresting officer on her undertaking that
she would appear before this Court on next Thursday, i.e. on 12.09.2024 at 10:30
am.
10. Copy of this order be forwarded to Registrar (Judicial), High Court of
Tripura, the Sub-Registrar, Sadar and District Sub-Registrar, Alipore, Kolkata.
List the matter on 12.09.2024.
9.
On 12.09.2024, in the same I.A. No. 1 of 2024 in Cont.
Cas.(C) No. 22 of 2024, a non-bailable warrant was issued against the
respondent-wife since she was evading the proceedings of the Court and the
previous bailable warrant was recalled.
10.
On 26.09.2024, the Court expressed its concern as the police
failed to apprehend the respondent, Smt. Kanika Nath (Bhaumik). In the said
order, it is also reflected that the respondent-wife preferred an SLP against the
orders dated 27.06.2024 and 29.08.2023 passed by this Court directing
execution of transfer deeds in favour of her daughters. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court dismissed the SLP and directed the respondent to comply with the
directions issued by this Court in its order dated 14.12.2023.
11.
In the order dated 16.04.2025 passed in the present case, Mr.
Ali, learned counsel appearing for the respondent-contemnor, represented that
his client is repentant for her conduct and seeks unconditional apology to the
Court. She also agreed to cooperate with the petitioner in execution of the deed
of purchase of a flat in her name by the petitioner from the concerned
promoters. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that two deeds have
already been executed in favour of the two daughters of the parties at the
intervention of the Court and the issue of purchase of a flat in the name of the
respondent is pending. Learned counsel for the respondent prayed for bail of the
respondent, stating that pursuant to issuance of warrant, she and her family
members were being harassed by the police. This Court granted interim bail
with condition till the next date upon furnishing a bail bond of Rs.30,000/-.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that on
13.04.2025, the respondent held a press meet at the Agartala Press Club making
unfounded allegations against two Judges of this High Court who were earlier
dealing with the case, which was telecast on various news channels, and a press
release under her own signature was also issued.
12.
Vide order dated 16.05.2025, it is reflected that the deed
which was required to be executed in the name of the respondent-contemnor
could not be executed as she was not present. Learned counsel for the
respondent submitted that she was seriously ill and admitted in Tripura Medical
College and Dr. B.R.A.M. Teaching Hospital and assured that after recovery
and discharge, full cooperation would be extended.
13.
Vide order dated 20.06.2025, it is reflected that although she
was discharged from hospital, she was still unwell and sought further time for
execution of the deed. In view of the allegations made against sitting Judges,
the matter was placed before Hon’ble the Chief Justice for listing before an
appropriate Bench.
14.
Thereafter the same case was listed before this Bench. On
22.07.2025, notice was issued in the contempt petition. On 20.08.2025, this
Court enquired from learned counsel for the contemnor whether she intended to
tender an unconditional apology or to contest the proceedings under the
Contempt of Courts Act. On 27.08.2025, it was represented that the contemnor
was not inclined to tender any apology and intended to contest the matter.
15.
On 05.12.2025, learned counsel for the contemnor
represented that an affidavit had been filed stating that a review petition vide
Diary No. 46494 of 2025 seeking review of the judgment/order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court dated 13.09.2024 passed in Special Leave to Appeal (C) Nos.
20851-20852 of 2024 is pending. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that mere filing of a petition before the Hon’ble Supreme Court does not stall
contempt proceedings in the High Court in the absence of any stay order, and
relied upon judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in support thereof. It was
contended that the conduct of the respondent is a dilatory tactic to avoid
contempt proceedings.
Mr. Siraj Ali, learned counsel for the respondent, submitted
that certain judgments support the respondent’s stand for staying contempt
proceedings and sought time to prepare.
16.
Accordingly, the case was listed today.
17.
It has been submitted by learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner that the contemnor committed contempt by making allegations
against the then sitting Judge, Hon’ble Mr. Justice Arindam Lodh, and by
addressing a press conference in that regard. The cruxes of the allegations are
that:“The then Justice Mr. Arindam Lodh is not
performing his judicial duties well.
The then Justice Mr. Arindam Lodh is doing
favouritism while performing his Judicial duties.
The then Justice Mr. Arindam Lodh has passed
biased Judgment and Order with ulterior motive hampering the spirit of
justice.”
18.
It is seen from the above discussion that this High Court has
taken cognizance of the matter. Notices were issued and reasonable opportunity
was afforded to the respondent-contemnor. Considering her condition, being a
woman and undergoing trauma due to prolonged litigation relating to divorce,
maintenance, permanent alimony, etc., this Court indicated that a lenient view
may be taken if an affidavit of apology was filed. However, upon instructions,
learned counsel for the respondent-contemnor stated that she was not inclined
to tender any apology and was prepared to face the consequences. Still, the
matter was adjourned to afford another opportunity.
19.
Then when the case was called, Mr. Siraj Ali, learned
counsel for the respondent submitted that a review petition is pending before
the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
20.
At that, learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that
mere approaching the Hon’ble Supreme Court would not restrain this Court
from proceeding in the matter. At the request of learned counsel for the
respondent, the matter was adjourned today for placing relevant judgments and
for hearing on merits.
21.
Today, when the case is called, Mr. S. Ali, learned counsel
for the respondent-contemnor, advanced arguments on merits as well as on the
legal issue regarding continuation of contempt proceedings and relied upon the
following judgment:21.1.
Relevant portion of the Order as indicted herein of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court reported in 2022 LiveLaw (SC) 950 titled as Reliance
Industries Limited Vs. Vijayan A(Authorised Representative of Securitas and
Exchange Board of India):“Therefore, this Court observed that when the stay
application is yet to be heard and decided and disposed of, the contempt
proceedings cannot be initiated.”
21.2.
Paras-3 and 7 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court Judgment
reported in (1992) 4 SCC 167 titled as State of J & K Vs. Mohd. Yaqoob Khan
and ors., in Civil Appeal No.3472 of 1992 decided on August 26, 1992:“3. The respondent No. 1 filed a writ petition under Article
226 of the Constitution registered as Writ Petition No. 133 of 1990 for the
implementation of, what has been described by Mr. Bhandare, the learned
Counsel for the respondents, as a decree modified subsequently by a
compromise between the parties. On 19.03.90 an ex-parte interim order was
passed by the High Court directing notice to be issued to the respondents in the
writ petition as also in the stay matter with a direction that the case would be
listed in the second week of May, 1990. The order further said that in the
meantime, out of the agreed timber in accordance with the compromise entered
into between the writ petitioner and the Government, 50% of the timber shall be
given to the writ petitioner on his furnishing a bond. According to Mr. Salve,
the learned Counsel for the appellant, the appellant and its officers were
expecting that they were not required to immediately obey the interim direction,
as the stay matter was fixed to be heard in the second week of May, 1990, and
specially as there was no time indicated for compliance of direction. However,
the writ petitioner, without waiting for the next date in the case, filed the
application on 02.04.90 on which the impugned order was passed. According to
Mr. Salve the stay application was still pending final disposal and the appellant
was to be heard. Then again, there was no occasion for assuming that the exparte order, which did not even mention any period for compliance, had to be
obeyed immediately. At this stage it has to be appreciated that the aforesaid
direction although passed as an interim order in a pending interlocutory matter
was, in substance, a final order allowing the writ petition in part without
hearing the other side. The direction was not for maintenance of status quo; nor
again was it restraint order on the State authorities forbidding from taking any
step to which the writ petitioner could have an objection. As a result of the
interim direction, the writ petitioner was to receive the fruits of the decree (in
the language of the learned Counsel for the respondents before us, that is, the
writ petitioner) to the extent of half. The facts disclose that the stakes in the case
are very high. According to the State it had already paid a huge amount of
money. Mainly it has discharged its obligation in full. Hence it is not liable to
pay anything further or to deliver any timber as claimed by the writ petitioner.
That issue remains to be decided at the time of the final hearing of the writ
petition.
7.
We, therefore, hold that the High Court should have first taken up the
stay matter without any threat to the respondents in the writ case of being
punished for contempt. Only after disposing it of, the other case should have
been taken up. It is further significant to note that the respondents before the
High Court were raising a serious objection disputing the claim of the writ
petitioner. Therefore, an order in the nature of mandatory direction could not
have been justified unless the Court was in a position to consider the objections
and record a finding, prima facie in nature, in favour of the writ petitioner.
Besides challenging the claim on merits, the respondent is entitled to raise a
plea of non-maintainability of a writ application filed for the purpose of
executing a decree. It appears that at an earlier stage the decree in question was
actually put in execution when the parties are said to have entered into a
compromise. According to the case of the State the entire liability under the
decree (read with the compromise) has already been discharged. The dispute,
therefore, will be covered by Section 47 of the CPC. It will be a serious question
to consider whether in these circumstances the writ petitioner was entitled to
maintain his application under Article 226 of the Constitution at all. We do not
want to decide any of these controversies between the parties at this stage except
holding that the orders passed in the contempt proceeding were not justified,
being pre-mature, and must, therefore, be entirely ignored. The High Court
should first take up the stay matter in the writ case, and dispose it of by an
appropriate order. Only thereafter it shall proceed to consider whether the State
and its authorities could be accused of being guilty of having committed
contempt of Court.”
21.3.
Paras 4 and 5 of the Judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court reported in 1995 Supp (4) Supreme Court Cases 465 titled as Modern
Food Industries (India) Ltd and Anr. Vs. Sachidanand Dass and anr., in Civil
Appeal No.3932 of 1992 decided on September 21, 1992:“4. Before the High Court, appellants urged that before any
contempt proceedings could be initiated, it was necessary and appropriate for
the Division Bench to examine the prayer for stay, or else, the appeal itself
might become infructuous. This did not commend itself to the High Court
which sought to proceed with the contempt first. We are afraid, the course
adopted by the High Court does not commend itself as proper. If, without
considering the prayer for stay, obedience to the Single Judge's order was
insisted upon at the pain of committal for contempt, the appellants may find, as
has now happened, the very purpose of appeal and the prayer for interlocutory
stay infructuous. It is true that a mere filing of an appeal and an application for
stay do not by themselves absolve the appellants from obeying the order under
appeal and that any compliance with the learned Single Judge's order would be
subject to the final result of the appeal, But then the changes brought about in
the interregnum in obedience of the order under appeal might themselves be a
cause and source of prejudice. Wherever the order whose disobedience is
complained about is appealed against and stay of its operation is pending before
the Court, it will be appropriate to take up for consideration the prayer for stay
either earlier or at least simultaneously with the complaint for contempt. To
keep the prayer for stay stand-by and to insist upon proceeding with the
complaint for contempt might in many conceivable cases, as here, cause serious
prejudice. This is the view taken in State of J & K v. Mohd. Yaqoob Khan.
5. In the present case, under the threat of proceedings of contempt, the
appellants had to comply with the order of the learned Single Judge
notwithstanding the pendency of their appeal and the application for stay. The
petitioners are confronted with a position where their stay application is
virtually rendered infructuous by the steps they had to take on threat of
contempt.”
22.
While relying quoted paras of these above judgments, the
learned counsel for the respondent prayed that the since the matter is pending
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court, this Court cannot go into the contempt case.
23.
To counter the said argument, Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel
appearing for the petitioner relied upon the order of the Hon’ble Apex Court
reported in (2020) 20 SCC 400 titled as Asit Kumar Das Vs. J. Panda, Chief
Post Master General and ors in Civil Appeal No.1227 of 2025 dated 22nd
January, 2015. The same is produced here-in-under:“1. Leave granted, We have heard the learned counsel for the parties.
We find no justifiable reason for the High Court to direct the contempt petition
filed by the petitioner "to go out of list for the present," merely on the statement
made on behalf of the alleged contemnor that a special leave petition had been
filed in this Court. Contempt proceedings shall always be maintainable unless
the appellate court finds it fit to stay the operation of the order/judgment of
which contempt is alleged.”
24.
Referring to the above-mentioned order of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Asit Kumar Das (supra), learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner reiterated that mere approaching the Hon’ble Supreme Court does not
operate as an embargo on contempt proceedings unless the Hon’ble Supreme
Court takes cognizance and grants an interim stay of proceedings pending
before the High Court.
25.
Heard both sides and perused the records.
26.
From the records, it is evident that the contemnor made
statements alleging that the then Justice Mr. Arindam Lodh was not performing
his judicial duties properly, was indulging in favouritism and had passed biased
judgments with ulterior motive, thereby hampering the spirit of justice. This
Court takes serious note of such conduct and reiterates that if any litigant is
aggrieved by an order, legal remedies are always available. However,
addressing the media and issuing press statements is not a remedy that can be
appreciated by this Court.
27.
This Court is also unable to accept the submission that the
pendency of a review petition before the Hon’ble Supreme Court would, by
itself, stall the present contempt proceedings. It is well settled that mere filing
of a petition before the Hon’ble Supreme Court does not operate as a stay of
proceedings before the High Court unless there is a specific order of stay passed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court. In the absence of any such stay, the contempt
proceedings are maintainable and liable to be proceeded with. Consequently,
the judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the respondent is not
applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case.
28.
Hence, this Court finds the respondent guilty of the
allegations and decides to punish the contemnor.
29.
The contemnor being present in Court, as a measure of
punishment, this Court directs that she shall stand in the Court till the Court
rises. Considering her status as a woman and taking a lenient view, the said
punishment is imposed. Accordingly, the contempt case stands disposed of.
30.
As a sequel, stay, if any, stands vacated. Pending
application(s), if any, also stand closed.
B. PALIT, J
suhanjit
signed by
SABYASAC Digitally
SABYASACHI GHOSH
2026.01.01
HI GHOSH Date:
15:01:21 +05'30'
T. AMARNATH GOUD, J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review