Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
WA No.142 of 2023
Shri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy
………Appellant(s);
Versus
The State of Tripura & others
………Respondent(s).
For Appellant(s)
: Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Advocate,
Mr. S. Datta, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
: Mr. D. Sarma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.D. PURKAYASTHA
Order
06/02/2024
Heard Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel for the appellant and Mr.
D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the respondents-State.
2.
By the impugned order dated 18.10.2023, the learned Writ Court
disposed of the writ petition with a direction to the respondents to conclude the
disciplinary proceeding within 4(four) months. Petitioner/appellant herein had
approached the Writ Court with the following prayer:
“I. Issue a rule calling upon the respondents and each one of them to send unto
this Hon’ble Court the records relating to this case.
II. Issue rule calling upon the respondents and each one of them to show cause as
to why a writ of mandamus and or in the nature thereof shall not be issued
mandating/directing the respondents and each one of them to treat the
memorandum dated 21st September, 2012 to have come into inoperative and nonexistent.
III. Issue a rule calling upon the respondents and each one of them to show cause
as to why a writ of mandamus and or in the nature thereof shall not be issued
directing/mandating the respondents and each one of them to treat your humble
petitioner as discharged of the articles of charges vide Memorandum dated 21 st
September, 2012 (Annexure-1 supra).
IV. Issue a rule calling upon the respondents and each one of them to show cause
as to why a writ of certiorari and or in the nature thereof shall not be issued
quashing/ setting aside the proceeding under memorandum dated 21st September
2012 (Annexure-1 supra)
V. Issue a rule calling upon the respondents and each one of them to show cause
as to why a writ of prohibition and or in the nature thereof shall not be issued
prohibiting/restraining the respondents and each one of them from proceeding
continuance of proceedings under Memo dated 21st September, 2012.
VI. Issue a Rule of mandamus mandating/directing the respondents and each one
of them to arrange the payment of pension and other retiral benefits forthwith.
VII. After hearing the parties be pleased to make the rule absolute in terms of 1,2
and above.”
He was proceeded in a criminal case under Section 409 of IPC
under FIR No.86 of 2012 for the following charge:
“8]
After taking into consideration the submissions of the Ld. Counsels of
both sides and on perusal of the record, following points is considered for
determination:POINT FOR DETERMINATION
Whether during the year 2011-12 at any time at Manirampur ADC
village under Hrishyamukh R.D block accused being a public servant committed
criminal breach of trust by withdrawing Rs.3,41,780/- from the joint Account of
TGB HRM branch no.15242?”
3.
He was a Panchayat Secretary in Manirampur village committee
under Hrishyamukh R.D block at the relevant point of time. A departmental
proceeding was initiated against him vide memorandum of charges dated
21.09.2012 by the Directorate of Panchayats, Government of Tripura which
inter alia alleged five articles of charges under Rule 14 of Central Civil
Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965. The substance of the
imputations of misconduct was set out in the statement of articles of charge at
Annexure-I. The statement of imputation of misconduct in support of each
article of charge was enclosed as Annexure-II. A list of documents and a list of
witnesses by whom the articles of charges were proposed to be sustained were
enclosed as Annexure-III & IV.
4.
The imputation of mis-conduct as contained in the 5 Articles of
charges are being extracted hereunder for proper appreciation of the issue at
hand:
STATEMENT OF ARTICLES OF CHARGES FRAMED AGAISNT SRI
SWAPAN CHANDRA DEBROY, RPS, PANCHAYAT SECRETARY
MANIRAMPUR VILLAGE COMMITTEE HRISHYAMUKH RD BLOCK,
SOUTH TRIPURA DISTRICT.
Article-I
Sri Swapan Chandra Deb Roy while functioning as In-charge RPS (Panchayat
Secretary) at Manirampur Village Committee, Hrishyamukh RD Block, the Block
Development Officer, Hrishyamukh RD Block reported vide his letter No.F.1(1A)BDO/HRM/CONFIDENTIAL/2011-12/238, dated 04-05-12, that the Branch
Manager, Tripura Gramin Bank, has intimated vide his letter No.
TGB/HRM/BDO/194/2012/HD Dated 04-05-12, that Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy,
RPS(Panchayat Seceretary), Manirampur Village Committee, submitted a Cheque
bearing No.884296, dated 11-04-2012, to the TGB Hrishyamukh Branch for
withdrawal an amount of Rs.1,45,966/- only with scroll for payment of labourer
wages against the work order No.-16, dated 25-12-2011, and 17(A) dated 25-112011, but the said cheque bounded due to shortage of fund in the Bank Pass Book
which is most irregular as a Government employee and he has submitted the said
cheque for an amount of Rs. 1,45,966/- bearing No.884296, dated 11-04-2012 with
an ill motive to misappropriation of Govt. money at his own interest which is a gross
offense on the part of a Govt. employee and thus he is liable for disciplinary action.
Accordingly, said Sri Deb Roy, RPS(P/S) was placed under suspension vide this
Directorate Order No. 3776-79, dated 18-05-12.
By doing so said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS(Panchayat Secretary),
Hrishyamukh RD Block has failed to (i) maintain absolute integrity (ii) maintain
devotion to duty and made himself liable for the charge. Thus said Sri Swapan Ch.
Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat Secretary), Hrishyamukh RD Block has violated the
provision of Rule-3 of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) rules, 1988 and has
made himself liable for disciplinary action under CCS(CC&A) Rule, 1965.
Article-II
The Block Development Officer, Hrishyamukh RD Block formed a team with Sri
Sankar Debnath, AAO, Sri Amarchand Biswas, Panchayat Extension Officer &
Manoranjan Debnath, Panchayat Extension Officer and Rajesh Debnath, J/E for the
inquiry of the Accounts of the Manirampur ADC Village Committee under
Hrishyamukh RD Block vide his No. 1(6)/BDO/HRM/ESTT/148, dated 23-04-2012.
The inquiry team inquired official records/Register and other related records etc. of
Manirampur village committee office and reported on 04-05-12 that Manirampur
Village committee has received total amount of Rs.24,44,560/- against 6 nos.
sanction Memo from the Programme Officer, (BDO, Hrishyamukh) vide sanction
memo No.(i)No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/BUDGET/2011-12/145 dated 20-411, Rs.3,44,560/- (ii) No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA /BUDGET/ 2011-12/715,
dated
23-06-11,
Rs.7,00,000/(iii)
No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA
/BUDGET/2011-12/1456
dated
19-08-11,
Rs.3,00,000/(iv)
No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/ BUDGET /2011-12/2084 dated 22-10-11,
Rs.7,00,000/- (v) No.F.21(5)/BDO/ HRM/ MREGA / BUDGET/2011-12/2787
DATED
08-12-11,
Rs.3,00,000/&
(vi)
No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM
/MREGA/BUDGET
/2011-12/3225
dated
17-01-12
Rs.1,00,000/- for
implementation of development work of MGNREGA Scheme against the different
project for the year 2011-12. Out of said amount, said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy,
RPS(Panchayat Secretary), Manirampur Village Committee has been executed 18
no. projects/works involving Rs.22,82,812/- during the year 2011-12, but payment
has been made for an amount of Rs.20,60,780/- by Bank Scroll. Said Sri Swapan
Chandra Dey Roy, RPS (P/S) also admitted and giving in writing statement that
total 18 nos development works executed by him during the year 2011-2012 at
Manirampur Village Committee project value is Rs.22,82,812/- payment made by
scroll against work is Rs.20.60,780/- total payment due against following 4 no.
work is Rs.2,22,032/- viz (i) payment due Rs.88,574/- against work for creation of
Bamboo plantation for 30 Nos. patta holder beneficiaries, (ii) payment due
Rs.56,758/- against work for creation of Field Levelling of Manirampur community
Hall under MRP ADC Village Group-ii (iii) Payment due Rs.76700/- against work
for irrigation of 2 nos. channel & (iv) payment due Rs.34456/- against work for
Land Reclamation the land of Gobinda Tripura, S/O Samba Sing Tripura. Total
payment due Rs.2,22,032/- (88574+56758+76700 & Rs.34456). After making
payment, the balance amount of Bank Pass Book should have to be Rs.3,83,780/- as
on 09-04-12, but Bank pass book reflect NIL balance for development works. The
inspection team also reported that sais Sri Swapan ch. Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat
Secretary), Manirampur Village Committee has drawn in cash Rs.3,41,780/- time to
time by different self drawl cheque without work order sanction memo or scroll for
payment of labourer wages and vide following cheque No. (i) Cheque No.156360
dated 07-07-11, Rs. 75000/-, (ii) No.Rs.156369 dated 16-09-11 Rs.25000/- (iii)
156372 dated 10-10-11 Rs.50,000/-, (iv) No.884277 dated 10-11-11 Rs.. 25000/- (v)
No.884279 dated 26-11-11 Rs.20,000/- , (vi) No.884282 dated 14-12-11 Rs.50,000/, (vii) No. 884284 dated 23-12-11 Rs.42000/-, (viii) No. 884285 dated 28-12-11,
Rs.25,000/-, (ix) No.884288 dated 13-11-12, Rs.20,000/- & (x) No.884292 dated 1603-12 Rs.10,000/-. The said Rs.3,42,000/- from Joint Account No. 15242 of
MGNREGA Scheme of Manirampur Village Committee during the year 2011-12.
Sri Deb Roy, RPS(P/S) also withdrawn by submitting self drawl cheque remaining
balance amount of Rs.42,000/- showing as payment by scroll against 2 nos
Development Works falsely without work order, but during inquiry, against said
amount of Rs.42,000/- Sri Deb Roy has failed to produce work order for said 2 no.
development works, Master Roll, Bank Scroll, etc. and also did not submitted any
adjustment against said 2 no. works. Said Sri Swapan ch. Deb Roy, RPS(P/S)
Manirampur as implementing Officer were committed irregularities without
maintaining the guideline under NREGA Scheme by withdrawing the said amount
as cash by submitting self drawl cheque and showing payment by scroll against false
labourers. Showing false name of labourers, & self drawl cheque against
Development works of NREGA Scheme, said Sri Swapan ch. Deb Roy, In-charge
RPS Panchayat Secretary, Manirampur Village committee Hrishyamukh RD Block
was withdrawn the amount of Rs.3,41,780/- + Rs.42,000/- total 3,83,780/-, by
keeping in dark to the real labourers as well as beneficiaries with an ill motive
showing false name of labourers scroll & by self drawl cheque to misappropriation
of Govt. money at his own interest which is a gross offense on the part of a Govt.
employee and thus he is liable for the charge of disciplinary action.
By doing so, said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat Secretary),
Hrishyamukh RD Block has failed to (i) maintain absolute integrity (ii) maintain
devotion to duty and made himself liable for the charge. Thus, said Sri Swapan Ch.
Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat Secretary), Hrishyamukh RD Block has violated the
provision of Rule-3 of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 and has
made himself liable for disciplinary action under CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965.
6.
Article-III of the charges inter alia alleged as under:
Article No.III
The inquiry team also reported that during the year 2011-12, as per bank pass
book of Manirampara Village Committee, has credited an amount of Rs.12,315/- as Bank
Interest. But Bank Pass Book shows that total balance amount is Rs.2430/-. Said Sri Deb
Roy, RPS, has also withdrawn in interest money of Rs.9885/- from the Bank Account
Pass Book for his personal affairs i.e. for misappropriation of Govt. money intentionally,
which amount is the property of Village Committee, and the said amount is to be utilized
for the purpose of development works of Village Committee area/office. But Sri Swapan
Ch Deb Roy, has withdrawn the interest money of amount of Rs.9885/- from Bank for
misappropriate the Govt. money for his personal purpose depriving the Village
Committee area or office which is not at all desirable on the part of a Govt. employee.
Which is most irregularities & gross offense on the part of a Govt. employee and thus he
is liable for the charge of disciplinary action.
By doing so said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat Secretary),
Hrishyamukh RD Block has failed to (i) maintain absolute integrity (ii) maintain devotion
to duty and made himself liable for the charge. Thus said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS
(Panchayat Secretary), Hrishyamukh RD Block has violated the provision of Rule-3 of
the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 and has made himself liable for
disciplinary action under CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965.
Similarly Article No.IV & Article No.V of the charges alleged as under:
Article No. IV
Sri Swapan Chandra Deb Roy while functioning as In-charge RPS (Panchayat
Secretary) at Manirampur Village Committee Hrishyamukh RD Block, Manirampur
Village Committee received total Rs.24,44,560/- under MNREGA fund. Bank interest
earned Rs.12,315/-. Payment made by Sri Swapan Debroy Rs.20,60,780/-. Balance
amount to be Rs.3,96,095/-, as per Bank Account Pass Book No.15242 balance amount is
Rs.2,430/-, thus it is proved that Sri Swapan Chandra Deb Roy while functioning as Incharge RPS (Panchayat Secreatary) at Manirampur Village Committee Hrishyamukh RD
Block, has misappropriated total amount of Rs.3,93,665/- with an ill motive to
misappropriation of Govt. money at his own interest which is a gross offense on the part
of a Govt. employee and thus he is liable for the charge of disciplinary action.
By doing so said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat Secretary),
Hrishyamukh RD Block has failed to (i) maintain absolute integrity (ii) maintain devotion
to duty and made himself liable for the charge. Thus said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS
(Panchayat Secretary), Hrishyamukh RD Block has violated the provision of Rule-3 of
the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 and has made himself liable for
disciplinary action under CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965.
Article No. V
Sri Dulal Nama, Present RPS, (P/S) Manirampur Village Committee under
Hrishyamukh RD Block has given written statement 10.04.2012, on which the Pradhan,
Manirampur Village Committee assigned, that he has joined at Manirampur Village
Committee on 09.04.2012 as per order of the BDO, Hrishyamukh RD Block, vide Memo
No.F.4(2)/BDO/HRM/Panch/2011-12/3984, dated 22.03.2012. But he did not able to
taken over the charge from his reliever Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS (P/S). All
papers/documents of Manirampur Village Committee under kept in the custody of said
Sri Deb Roy, RPS, (P/S) before issue suspension order. And after receiving the
suspension order, in place to handed over the charge of Manirampur Village Committee
to his predecessor, Sri Deb Roy taken over all the papers/Documents etc. of Village
committee and Sri Dulal Nama, Present RPS, (P/S) has faced trouble & failed to trace out
the relevant papers/documents from the period from 01.04.2011 to 31.03.2012. Said Sri
Deb Roy RPS, (P/S) has made a gross irregularities without handing over the charge of
Manirampur Village Committee to his predecessor, which is not desirable. By doing so
Village Committee office as well as villagers of Manirampur is facing hard problem
which is most irregularities & gross offense on the part of a Govt. employee and thus he
is liable for the charge of disciplinary action.
By doing so said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS (Panchayat Secretary),
Hrishyamukh RD Block has failed to (i) maintain absolute integrity (ii) maintain devotion
to duty and made himself liable for the charge. Thus said Sri Swapan Ch. Deb Roy, RPS
(Panchayat Secretary), Hrishyamukh RD Block has violated the provision of Rule-3 of
the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 and has made himself liable for
disciplinary action under CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965.
The list of documents by which articles of charges were to be proved is also
enumerated hereunder:
“ANNEXURE-III
LIST OF DOCUMENTS BY WHICH ARTICLES OF CHARGE
FRAMED AGAINST SRI SWAPAN CHANDRA DEB ROY, RPS
(Panchayat Secretary) MANIRAMPUR VILLAGE COMMITTEE
HRISHYAMUKH RD BLOCK, SOUTH TRIPURA DISTRICT ARE
PROPOSED TO BE SUSTAINED.
1. BDO, Hrishyamukh letter. F.1(1-A)BDO/HRM/CONFIDENTIAL/2011-12/
238, DATED 04.05.2012;
2. Tripura Gramin Bank, letter No.TGB/HRM/BDO/194/2012/HD, dated
04.05.2012
3. Copy of Tripura Gramin Bank, Cheque bearing No.884296, dated 11.04.2012
4. Report of the inquiry team dated 04.05.2012
5. Copy of Sanction Memo No. (i) No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/BUDGET/
2011-6. Copy of 12/145, dated 20.04.2011, Rs.3,44,560/- (ii) No.F.21(5)/BDO/
HRM/MREGA/BUDGET/2011-12/715, DATED 23.06.2011, Rs.7,00,000/- (iii)
No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/BUDGET/2011-12/1456, DATED 19.08.
2011, Rs.3,00,000/- (iv) No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/BUDGET/2011-12/
2084, Dated 22.10.2011, Rs.7,00,000/-, (v) No.F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/
BUDGET/2011-12/2787, dated 08.12.2011, Rs.3,00,000/- & (vi) No.
F.21(5)/BDO/HRM/MREGA/BUDGET/2011-2/3225,
dated
17.01.2012,
Rs.100,000/6. Counterfoil of Check No.156360, dated 07.07.2011 (ii) No.156369 dated
16.09.2011, (iii) No.156372 dated 10.10.2011 (iv) No.884277 dated 10.11.2011
(v) No.884279 dated 26.11.2011, (vi) No.884282 dated 14.12.2011 (vii) No.884
284 dated 23.12.2011, (viii) No.884285 dated 28.12.2011, (ix) No.884288 dated
13.11.2012 (x) No.884292 dated 16.03.2012.
7. Copy of Joint Account T.G.B Pass Book bearing No.15242 of MGNREGA
scheme
8. Transfer order vide Memo No.F.4(2)/BDO/HRM/Panch/2011-12/3984, dated
22.03.2012
9. Written statement dated 10.04.2012, submitted by Sri Dulal Nama, Present
RPS, (P/S) Manirampur Village Committee;”
The list of witnesses through whom the proposed charges were to be sustained
is also enumerated hereunder:
“LIST OF WITNESS BY WHOM THE ARTICLES OF CHARGES
FRAMED AGAINST SRI SWAPAN CHANDRA DEB ROY,
MANIRAMPUR VILLAGE COMMITTEE UNDER HRISHYAMUKH
RD BLOCK, SOUTH TRIPURA DISTRICT, ARE PROPOSED TO BE
SUSTAINED.
1. Sri Keshab Kar, BDO, Hrishyamukh RD Block.
2. Sri Sankar Debnath, A.A.O, Hrishyamukh RD Block.
3. Sri Amarchand Biswas, Panchayat Extension Officer, Hrishyamukh RD
Block.
4. Manoranjan Debnath, Panchayat Extension Officer, Hrishyamukh RD Block.
5. Rasjesh Debnath, J/E, Hrishyamukh RD Block.
6. Sri Dulal Nama, Present RPS, (P/S) Manirampur Village Committee;
7. Sri Parameswar Sarkar, Pradhan, Manirampur Village Committee.”
7.
The departmental proceeding is underway and has not yet been
concluded. Appellant was acquitted of the charge of criminal misappropriation
of a sum of Rs.3,41,780/- from the joint account of Tripura Gramin Bank,
Hrishyamukh Branch No.15242 by judgment dated 18.05.2022 passed by
learned Judicial Magistrate, First Class, South Tripura, Belonia in PRC (WP)
No.184 of 2012. On account of his acquittal in the criminal case, appellant
sought quashing of the disciplinary proceeding initiated vide memorandum of
charges dated 21.09.2012.
8.
The learned Writ Court by the impugned order, instead of quashing
of the charges, directed completion of the disciplinary proceeding within a
period of 4(four) months with which the writ petitioner/appellant herein, being
aggrieved, is before us.
9.
Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel for the petitioner/appellant
herein, has drawn the attention of this Court to the following decisions in
support of his submissions:
(a) Paragraph 7 in the case of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation
Ltd. and others v. Sarvesh Berry reported in (2005) 10 SCC 471.
(b) Paragraphs 24, 25 & 27 of the judgment dated 04.12.2023 in
the case of Ram Lal v. State of Rajasthan & others in Civil Appeal No.7935 of
2023 arising out of SLP(C) No.33423 of 2018.
It is submitted that since the acquittal in the criminal trial is on the
same set of charges for which the petitioner/appellant herein is facing
departmental proceeding based on same set of facts and the evidence in both the
proceedings are common, the continuance of the departmental proceeding after
acquittal of the appellant would lead to miscarriage of justice. It is further
submitted that though the position in law as regards simultaneous proceedings
in criminal case and departmental proceedings are well settled, but in case the
departmental proceedings are on same set of facts, evidence and charges, the
memorandum of charges deserves to be quashed. Therefore, the impugned
order may be set aside and the articles of charges initiated vide memorandum of
charges dated 21.09.2012 may be quashed.
10.
Mr. Deb, learned senior counsel for the appellant, has also pointed
out from the judgment of acquittal that the appellant was acquitted not on the
basis of benefit of doubt, rather the prosecution had failed to prove that the
accused appellant was entrusted with the joint account and the said money was
misappropriated by the accused person himself. As such, following the ratio
rendered by the Apex Court in the case of Ram Lal v. State of Rajasthan &
others, this Court, on a scrutiny of the material charges in the departmental
proceeding and on perusal of the entirety of the judgment of acquittal, may
deem it proper to quash the entire disciplinary proceeding itself.
11.
Mr. D. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate for the
respondents-State, has opposed the prayer. He submits that the departmental
proceedings are not on identical charges. While the criminal trial was based on
the allegations of criminal breach of trust by withdrawal of Rs.3,41,780/- from
the joint account of Tripura Gramin Bank, Hrishyamukh Branch No.15242 by
the petitioner/appellant herein, who was a Panchayat Secretary of Manirampur
village committee under Hrishyamukh R.D block; but the disciplinary
proceedings have been initiated on several charges which include failure to
maintain absolute integrity and devotion to duty in breach of the Tripura Civil
Services (Conduct) Rules, 1988 and also commission of irregularities in
maintaining the guidelines under MGNREGA scheme by showing false name
of labourers, self drawl cheque against development works of MGNREGA
scheme with an ill motive to misappropriate government money.
12.
Mr. Sarma, learned Additional Government Advocate, further
submits that a bare perusal of the articles of charges would show that the
petitioner/appellant herein has been proceeded against not only for criminal
breach of trust or misappropriation of government money, but for his failure to
perform his duties in maintaining the official records as per guidelines of the
MGNREGA scheme. The lists of witnesses are also not same. Moreover, the
list of documents proposed to be adduced in support of the charges also referred
to a wide spectrum of records which appellant in the capacity of Panchayat
Secretary of Manirampur village committee was required to follow and observe
as per MGNREGA guidelines. Therefore, the principle of law, laid down by the
Apex Court when applied to the case at hand, does not call for quashing of the
entire disciplinary proceeding. The standard of proof in both the criminal trial
and the departmental proceeding are also not same. As such, the learned Writ
Court rightly directed the disciplinary proceeding to be completed within a
period of 4(four) months, as the petitioner/appellant herein had already retired
and was not getting any pensionary benefits.
13.
We have considered the submission of learned counsel for the
parties. We have also scrutinized the records relating to the departmental
proceeding as extracted hereinabove in substance and also gone through the
judgment of acquittal rendered by the learned Trial Court.
We are conscious of the fact that the criminal trial proceeded
against the petitioner/appellant herein on allegations of criminal breach of trust
for withdrawal of Rs.3,41,780/- from the joint account of Tripura Gramin Bank,
Hrishyamukh Branch No.15242 by the appellant while he was a Panchayat
Secretary at the Manirampur village committee under Hrishyamukh R.D block.
The prosecution adduced the following witnesses in support of the case:
“5]
In order to prove the case, the prosecution examined altogether 06(six)
witnesses:
Pw-1
Sri Keshab Kar,
Pw-2,
Sri Manoranjan Debbarma
Pw-3,
Sri Amarchand Biswas,
Pw-4,
Sri Haripada Debnath,
Pw-5,
Sri Swapan Bhowmik, and
Pw-6,
Insp. Bimal Baidya”
14.
At this instance, it is pertinent to point out that the witnesses
proposed to be adduced in the departmental proceedings are seven in number
and only three of them are common to the criminal trial namely Sri Keshab Kar,
Sri Amarchand Biswas and Sri Manoranjan Debnath. Comparison of the
charges framed during the criminal trial with those under five articles of
charges in the disciplinary proceeding do lead to a clear impression that the
disciplinary proceeding, though also related to allegations of misappropriation
of about Rs.3,93,665/- from the MGNREGA account in lieu of execution of
certain works, but the charges also show that petitioner/appellant herein, as a
Panchayat Secretary, had committed irregularities in maintaining the guidelines
under MGNREGA scheme and failed to produce work orders for two number
of development works, muster roll, bank scroll, etc. and also did not submit any
adjustment against the said two number of works as evident from Article No.II
of the charges.
15.
Appellant also took over all the papers/documents, etc. of the
village committee without handing it over to his successor for the period
01.04.2011 to 31.03.2012 and thereby committed gross irregularities in handing
over of charge of the Manirampur village committee to his successor which was
not desirable. This led to serious problems. As such, he failed to maintain
absolute integrity and complete devotion to duty and made himself liable for
official misconduct under Rule 3 of the Tripura Civil Services (Conduct) Rules,
1988 for being proceeded departmentally under CCS (CC&A) Rules, 1965.
Acquittal in a criminal trial for the charges of criminal breach of trust, therefore,
would not amount to exoneration in the disciplinary proceedings which relates
to charges of official misconduct apart from allegations of criminal
misappropriation of MGNREGA funds. As such, it cannot be said that the
departmental proceedings and criminal case are based on same set of
allegations/charges and the evidence in both the proceedings are also common.
16.
Following the ratio rendered by the Apex Court at paragraph 7 in
the case of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. and others (supra) and also
the opinion of the Apex Court in the case of Ram Lal (supra), this Court is of
the considered view that the acquittal of the petitioner/appellant herein in
criminal trial does not ipso facto entail exoneration in the departmental
proceeding. The case of Ram Lal related to allegation of altering of date of
birth of the appellant from 21.04.1974 to 21.04.1972 in his 8th standard
marksheet to project himself as having attained majority at the time of the
recruitment. The present case is one where a government official, holding the
post of Panchayat Secretary and entrusted with the task of execution of
MGNREGA works in the entire panchayat in the concerned block, has been
alleged to have failed in maintaining official records and following guidelines
under the MGNREGA scheme, which led to illegal withdrawal of certain
MGNREGA funds. Appellant has also been alleged to have shown lack of
integrity and absolute devotion to duty, and further failed to hand over custody
of all papers/documents of the Manirampur village committee.
17.
Considered thus, we are of the view that the prayer of the
petitioner/appellant herein for quashing of the memorandum of charges dated
21.09.2012 on the strength of his acquittal in a criminal case does not merit
acceptance. The disciplinary proceeding is said to be underway. The direction
of the learned Writ Court to conclude the departmental proceedings should be
carried out by the respondents in right earnest.
18.
The
instant
appeal
is
accordingly
dismissed.
Pending
application(s), if any, shall stand disposed of.
(S.D. PURKAYASTHA), J
SIDDHARTHA
LODH
Pijush/
SIDDHARTHA LODH
Date: 2024.02.21 17:04:32
+05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH), CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review