Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page 1
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RFA 25 of 2019
Sri Sumesh Das,
son of late Suranjan Das, resident of village- Ratiabari, P.O. Ratiabari,
P.S. Kumarghat, District- Unakoti, Tripura
.... Defendant-Appellant
VERSUS
1. Sri Chanchal Kumar Das, son of late Pramesh Chandra Das alias late
Paramesh chandra Das alias late Ramesh Das
2. Smt. Sukriti Das, wife of late Pramesh Chandra Das alias late
Paramesh chandra Das alias late Ramesh Das, C/o Gitanjali Advertising,
Kalyani Bhawan, Dhiren Para, Itanagar, Guwahati-25, Assam
C/o Sri Basanta Dhar, Sukanta Nagar, P.O. Kumarghat, P.S. Kumarghat,
District- Unakoti, Tripura
both of them are represented by their constituted attorney Sri Ranjai
kumar Dey alias Shri Ranjit Dey, son of late Projendra Kumar Dey,
resident of Ratiabari, P.O.+ P.S. Kumarghat, District- Unakoti, Tripura
3. Smt. Krishna Dey, wife of Sri Ranjit Dey, resident of villageRatiabari, P.O. Ratiabari (Pabiacherra), P.S. Kumarghat, DistrictUnakoti, Tripura
... Plaintiff- Respondents
4. Sri Ajoy kumar Das, son of late Arini Mohan Das, resident of villageRatiabari, P.O. Ratiabari (Pabiacherra), P.S. Kumarghat, DistrictUnakoti, Tripura
5. Sri Amarendra Das, son of late Arini Mohan Das, resident of villageRatiabari, P.O. Ratiabari (Pabiacherra), P.S. Kumarghat, DistrictUnakoti, Tripura
6. Smt. Maya Das, wife of Sri Amarendra Das, resident of villageRatiabari, P.O. Ratiabari (Pabiacherra), P.S. Kumarghat, DistrictUnakoti, Tripura
7. Sri Sachindra Sutradhar, son of late Debendra Sutradhar, resident of
village- Ratiabari, P.O. Ratiabari (Pabiacherra), P.S. Kumarghat, DistrictUnakoti, Tripura
... Defendant- Respondents
For Appellant (s )
:
For Respondent (s)
Date of hearing and delivery
of judgment & order
Whether fit for reporting
:
Mr. SM Chakraborty, Sr. Advocate
Ms. A. Pal, Advocate
Mr. S. Lodh, Advocate
:
:
11.03.2022
No.
Page 2
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARINDAM LODH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. CHATTOPADHYAY
JUDGMENT & ORDER (ORAL)
(Arindam Lodh, J.)
1.
Heard Mr. SM Chakraborty, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. A. Pal,
learned counsel appearing for the defendant-appellant No.1 here-in-after referred to
as the defendant as well as Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel for the respondents.
2.
This is an appeal filed under Section 96 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
against the judgment and decree dated 31.05.2019 passed by the learned Civil Judge,
Senior Division, Court no.1, Unakoti District, Kailasahar in case No. Title Suit 31 of
2018 decreeing the suit of the plaintiff-respondent no. 3 against the defendant no. 1appellant.
3.
The suit out of which the present appeal arises was instituted by the
respondents of the present appeal being the plaintiffs impleading the present
appellant as defendant no. 1 for declaration of right, title and interest of the plaintiff
no. 3 over the suit land described in the plaint schedule and for recovery of khas
possession thereof and for compensation and mense profit.
4.
The facts of the case, as projected by the learned trial court, may be
reproduced here-in-below:“2. The brief fact of the plaintiffs' suit, inter alia, is that the suit land described in
first schedule of the plaint originally owned and possessed by plaintiff No.1 & 2
and plaintiff No.1 & 2 filed TS 08 of 2011 against the plaintiff No.3 and defendant
No.2 of this suit for declaration title and recovery of possession of the suit land
and by judgment and decree dated 02.12.2011 and 07.12.2011 passed by Civil
Judge, Sr. Divn., Kailashahar it was declared that the plaintiff No.1 & 2 has right,
title and interest over the suit land and decree of recovery of possession was
granted from the plaintiff No.3. Thereafter, plaintiff No.1, 2 & 3 filed TS 08 of
Page 3
2012 against the defendant No.2 to 5 for declaration that the plaintiffs have every
right to maintain their possession and for perpetual injunction against the
defendant No.2 to 5 and by judgment and decree dated 06.01.2017 and
13.01.2017 the said suit was decreed declaring that plaintiffs have right to
maintain their possession over the suit land and defendant No.2 to 5 and their
men and agents were perpetually injuncted and restrained from entering into the
suit land and or in any way disturbing the peaceful enjoyment and possession of
the plaintiffs over the suit land. It is also the plead of the plaintiffs that the
plaintiff No.3, purchased the suit land from the plaintiff No.1 & 2 by registered
sale deed No.1-00100 dated 07.02.2013 and became absolute owner of the suit
land. It is also pleaded that the present defendant No.1 being close associates of
defendant No.2 to 5 was aware of earlier proceeding recently with the assistance
and at the instance of defendant No.2 to 5 and group of persons and agents
unlawfully entered into the suit land w.e.f 15.06.2018 and gradually broke down
four numbers of construction of plaintiff No.3 and took away valuable belongings
and goods of plaintiff No.3 as specifically described in schedule 3 of the plaint and
caused loss of Rs.11,30,500/- and also made construction over the suit land as
described in the second schedule of the plaint. The plaintiff also pleaded about
the filing of violation cases and their consequence against the defendant No.2 to
5 but details of the same is not necessary for this suit. The plaintiff also pleaded
that a notice dated 05.07.2018 was issued by plaintiff upon the defendant No.1
informing about the earlier proceedings for leaving the suit land and for removing
construction by defendant No.1 and also for payment of compensation of
Rs.11,30,500/- but defendant No.1 failed to comply and rather sent one reply
dated 17.07.2018 with false assertion. Hence, this suit. The plaintiffs also prayed
for leave to file a separate execution case against the defendant No.2 to 5 for
violation of perpetual injunction and for filing of this suit by joinder of different
cause of action.
3. The suit of the plaintiffs' is contested by defendant No.1 by filing written
statement denying all the plea and allegation of plaintiffs against him and inter
alia pleaded that the suit is not maintainable and it was not known to him about
any earlier suit and decree and only came to know about the same after receiving
the Advocate Notice dated 05.07.2018. It is pleaded by the defendant No.1 that
he has been possessing the suit land adversely since 2006 and the execution of
the sale deed by plaintiff No.1 & 2 in favour of plaintiff No.3 is merely a paper
transaction as neither the vendor nor the purchaser have any kind of possession
over the suit land since 2006 and the defendant No.1 has been using and
possessing the suit land by constructing dwelling hut over the suit land and has
been living thereon with his family members peacefully and without any
disturbance openly and continuously with the knowledge of locality including the
owner, the plaintiffs and defendant No.2 to 5 adversely along with right and title
of the true owner and his right has been ripened over the suit land by adverse
possession. It is also pleaded that the family members of defendant No.1 i.e., the
wife and children of defendant No.1 were not made party in this suit even though
they are also in possession of the suit land with him. Thus, the defendant No.1
prayed for dismissal of the suit of the plaintiffs.”
Page 4
5.
At the commencement of trial, following issues were framed:
“(i) Whether the suit is maintainable?
(ii) Whether plaintiff No.3 has right, title and interest over the 1st schedule land of
plaint?
(iii) Whether the defendant No.1 perfected title over the 1st schedule land of
plaint by way of adverse possession?
(iv) Whether the defendants illegally possessing the 1 st schedule land since
15.06.2018 and damaged and taken away the subject mentioned in 3rd schedule
of plaint?
(v) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the decree as prayed for and/or any
other relief or reliefs in this suit?”
6.
The parties to the lis had adduced their respective evidences and introduced
documents in respect of their evidences. After hearing arguments of learned counsel,
the learned trial court had passed the following order:
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiffs against the defendant No.2 to 5 is
dismissed being not maintainable and the suit of the plaintiff against the
defendant No.1 is decreed on contest with cost with a declaration that the
plaintiff No.3 has right, title and interest over the suit land as described in 1 st
schedule of the plaint by way of purchase and he is also entitled to recover
possession of the suit land by evicting the defendant No.1 and his men and agents
by demolishing and removing all the obstruction and construction made by
defendant No.1 over the suit land including the 2nd schedule construction of the
plaint.
Accordingly, the defendant No.1 is directed to vacate the suit land and
hand over possession of the suit land to the plaintiff No.3 by removing all
obstruction and construction including second schedule construction of plaint
within 30 days from today.
The suit is disposed of on contest”.
7.
Main contention of Mr. Chakraborty, learned counsel for the defendant
centers around that the plaintiff-respondent no. 3, Smt. Krishna Dey (here-in-after
referred to as the “plaintiff”) is the owner and possessor of the suit land measuring
0.10 acres, and her title and possession was confirmed in a former suit bearing no.
T.S. 08 of 2012 [titled as Sri Chanchal kr. Das & ors. vs. Sri Ajoy kumar Das &
ors.]. Per contra, learned counsel for the defendant has further argued that the
Page 5
defendant has been able to establish his title over the suit land by way of adverse
possession extinguishing the right, title and interest of the plaintiff no. 3 over the suit
land.
8.
On the basis of the aforesaid submissions, we have scrutinized the documents
pertaining to various sale transactions which were made relating to the parties of the
present suit as well as the judgment passed by the courts in the former suit.
9.
We find that the defendant has alleged that he has been in possession of the
suit land adversely against the plaintiffs w.e.f. the 1st part of 2006 with his family
members by constructing huts thereon..
10.
On the other hand, the plaintiffs have claimed that the cause of action of the
suit had arisen w.e.f. 15.06.2018, and thereafter, from the dates of different demands
raised by the plaintiffs including the demand notice dated 05.07.2018 issued upon the
defendant whereupon he was asked to vacate the suit land within a period of 15 days
and from the date of his reply dated 17.07.2018 when he denied the title of the
plaintiffs.
11.
From the evidences of PW-1 and PW-2, it is clearly established that the sale
deed of the suit land vide I-100 dated 07.02.2013 was executed by the plaintiffs no. 1
and 2 in favour of the plaintiff no. 3. The said evidences of PW-1 and PW-2 are
corroborated by PW-3, Sri Mridul Kanti Das, the Deed writer, the scribe of the
plaintiff who deposed that the plaintiffs no. 1 and 2 had executed the sale deed in
favour of plaintiff no. 3 on 07.02.2013 on receipt of consideration money. On
consideration of the evidence, in its entirety, according to us, the plaintiffs had been
Page 6
able to prove the Sale Deed dated 07.02.2013 whereby the plaintiffs no. 1 and 2 had
transferred the suit land in favour of plaintiff no. 3.
12.
The learned trial court has rightly interpreted the law laid down under Rule 15
of the Tripura Land Revenue and Land Reforms (Allotment) Rules, 1962 that if any
transfer of allotted land by way of sale is made within 10 years of allotment, then, it
would not be void ab initio, and merely liable to be cancelled and the Collector may
re-enter into the land. A third person cannot substantiate his plea of possession on the
ground that the transfer of land by such allottee was void ab initio. Moreso, on
perusal of the judgment passed in Title Suit 08 of 2012 instituted by the plaintiffs of
the present suit against Sri Ajoy kumar Das and 3 others i.e. the defendantrespondent no. 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the present appeal , the learned trial court had
observed thus:“On scrutiny of all the documents exhibited by the plaintiffs it is crystal clear that
the oral evidence adduced on behalf of the plaintiffs’ side is supported and
corroborated by the documentary evidence on record. On perusal of certified
copy of computerized copy of khatian no. 992 (Esbt. 2) I find that the suit land
measuring 0.10 acres corresponding to hal dag no. 3507 is recorded in the name
of the plaintiff Chanchal kr. Das and his brother Chandan kr. Das as allottee.
Moreover on perusal of Exbt. 5 I find that the plaintiff No. 1 Chanchal Kr. Das had
sworn an affidavit before the Notary Public, North Tripura, Kailasahar attesting to
the fact that his brother Chandan Kr. Das had died on 03.08.2001 and he and his
mother Sukriti Das are his legal heirs. Moreover, on perusal of Exbt. 9 series
which is the certified copy of judgment passed by Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division)
Kailasahar in TS 08/11 it is clear that the plaintiffs Chanchal Kr. Das and Smt.
Sukriti Das through their attorney Alok Dey had filed a suit for declaration and
recovery of possession against defendant no. 1 Ajoy Kr. Das and present plaintiff
No. 3 Smt. Krishna Dey relating to the present suit land and that suit was decreed
in favour of the plaintiffs vide judgment dated 02.12.2011 in the following words:
“In view of the above detail discussion and findings of this court under the
above issues, the present suit of the plaintiffs is hereby decreed on contest
without costs. The right, title and interest of the plaintiffs over the suit property
are hereby declared. The plaintiffs do recover the suit land from the defendants
by evicting them therefrom. The plaintiffs are also entitled to get or realize and
recover a compensation or mesne profit of the suit property at Rs. 1,000/-
Page 7
(Rupees one thousand) per month from the month of January, 2005 and till the
recovery of the suit property from the defendant no. 1. Parties are to bear their
own costs of the suit. Decree sheet be prepared accordingly in time. File be
consigned to records”
Moreover, on perusal of Exbt. 13 series which is the certified copy of judgment
dated 30.03.2015 passed by the learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division), Kailasahar in
Title Suit 09 of 2014 it is crystal clear that the present defendant No. 1 Ajoy Kr.
Das had filed the suit against the present plaintiffs with a view to set aside the
judgment and decree passed by the court of Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Division),
Kailasahar in TS 08/2011 but the said suit was dismissed by the learned court vide
judgment dated 30.03.2015.
What emerges from the above discussion is that from both the judgments of the
Court of Learned Civil Judge (Sr. Divn.) Kailasahar discussed above it is clear that
the plaintiffs Chanchal Kr. Das and Sukriti Das are entitled to maintain their
possession over the suit land as such possession has been judicially recognized
and endorsed by the said judgments which have by now attained finality with the
efflux of time.
Moreover on perusal of Exgt. 12 i.e. original registered kabala No. 1-100 dated
07.02.2013 it is clear that the plaintiff No. 1 Chanchal Kr. Das had inducted the
plaintiff No. 3 Krishna Dey into the suit property as tenant as per the terms and
conditions set out in the registered kabala.
The sub & substance of the above discussion is that the oral evidence of PW-3
to the effect that she is in possession of the suit property as tenant of the plaintiff
Nos. 1 & 2 is supported by the documentary evidence on record discussed above.
A conjoint reading of the oral and documentary evidence on record discussed
above leads this Court to the unhesitating conclusion that the plaintiffs are
entitled to declaration that they have right to maintain their possession over the
suit property described in schedule to the plaint. Moreover it is significant to note
that the defendants have failed to contest the suit and rebut the claims of the
plaintiffs in spite of proper service of summons which creates a negative
inference against them to the effect that the case set up by the plaintiffs is true”.
13.
From the aforesaid judgment passed in Title Suit 08 of 2012, what has been
transpired that had the defendant of the present suit been in possession of the suit
since 2006, then, there was no reason for the plaintiffs not to implead him as one of
the defendants alongwith others in the said suit. The dispute espoused in Title Suit 08
of 2012 clearly demonstrates that the litigations were going on between the parties
relating to the suit land and the defendant, Ajoy kumar Das (the defendantrespondent no. 4 of the present appeal) of T.S. 08 of 2011 never stated that the
Page 8
defendant was in possession of the suit land. The said fact leads us to believe the
facts, as stated by the plaintiffs in the present suit that the defendant is a mere
trespasser and he had entered into the suit land only in the year 2018. According to
us, the defendant had entered into the suit land in the year 2018 only to frustrate the
decree passed in Title Suit 8 of 2012 passed by the learned Civil Judge, Junior
Division, Kailasahar, Unakoti District, and he is a mere trespasser.
14.
More importantly, after perusal of the evidences on record, we are convinced
that the defendant has failed to prove his hostile possession against the plaintiffs.
Thus, the plaintiff no. 3 is entitled to a decree declaring his right, title and interest
over the suit land and recovery of possession, as ordered by the learned trial court.
As a corollary, the judgment and decree passed by the learned trial court granting
reliefs to the plaintiff no. 3 is hereby affirmed and upheld. Moreover, there is a well
known maxim that “possession follows title”. A person claiming adverse possession
has to first prove that by efflux of time, the title of the owner has been extinguished
entitling him to claim acquisition of title by way of adverse possession and in that
case, all the elements of adverse possession have to be proved by cogent evidence,
which is absent in the present suit.
15.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, we do not find any merit in the present
appeal. Accordingly, the instant first appeal stands dismissed. Send down the LCRs
for enforcement of the decree.
JUDGE
Saikat
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review