Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
RSA No.40 of 2022
Sri Subhasish Datta @ Apu Datta,
Son of late Nirode Ranjan Datta,
Resident of Jail Ashram Road,
P.O. Dhaleswar, P. S. East Agartala,
District: West Tripura
Presently residing under the
Care of Shri Sebabrata Biswas, Matri Villa,
Near Curcuit House, Kunjaban,
Agartala, West Tripura, PIN:799 006
----Defendant-Appellant (s)
Versus
Shri Pintu Debnath,
Son of Shri Pulin Chandra Debnath,
Resident of Nalgaria, P.O. & P.S. Ranirbazar,
District: West Tripura
---- Plaintiff-Respondent (s)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. S. M. Chakraborty, Sr. Adv.
Ms. A. Pal, Adv.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. A. Sengupta, Adv.
Date of Hearing
:
11.12.2023
Date of delivery of
Judgment and Order :
21.12.2023
Whether fit for
Reporting
YES/NO
:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Judgment & Order
This is an appeal under Section 100 of CPC filed
against the judgment and decree dated 28.04.2022 passed
by Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in Title
Appeal No.50/2019 affirming the judgment and decree
passed by Learned Trial Court in T.S.134 of 2016.
02.
The gist of the appeal in short is that the
respondent-plaintiff
Pintu
Debnath
filed
one
suit
for
declaration under Section 34 of the Specific Relief Act and
also for realization of security deposit money before the
Court of the Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), Court
No.1,
West
Tripura,
Agartala
against
the
appellant-
defendant vide Case No.T.S.134 of 2016 and after hearing
both the sides Learned Trial court below by the judgment
dated 03.06.2019 decreed the suit of the respondentplaintiff with costs. The operative portion of the order of the
Learned Court below is reproduced below:
“In the result, the suit of the plaintiff is decreed on
contest with costs. The plaintiff is entitled to a decree
declaring that the defendant committed serious breach of
contract with the plaintiff by not delivering the vacant
possession of the rented premises to the plaintiff in
compliance of the tenancy agreement. The plaintiff is also
entitled
to
the
decree
declaring
that
the
cancellation/revocation/termination
of
the
tenancy
agreement by the plaintiff is lawful.
The plaintiff is also entitled to get a refund of
security deposit money amounting to Rs.3,50,000/(Rupees three lakhs fifty thousand only) from the
defendant.
The plaintiff is also entitled to get interest at the
rate of six percent per annum from the date of final
demand notice dated 25.10.2016 till the date of payment.
The defendant is directed to refund the security
deposit amounting to Rs.3,50,000/- (Rupees three lakhs
fifty thousand only) to the plaintiff within two months
from the date of passing of the decree of this suit at the
rate of six percent per annum from the date of final
demand notice dated 25.10.2016 till the date of
payment.”
03.
Challenging the judgment of Ld. Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Court No.1, Agartala, West Tripura the
present appellant preferred an appeal before the court of
Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala which was
numbered as Title Appeal 50 of 22019 and after hearing
argument of both the sides Learned First Appellate Court
delivered the judgment on 28.04.2022 of the appellantdefendant and dismissed the appeal affirming the judgment
of the Learned Trial Court. The operative portion of the
order of Learned First Appellate Court is given below:
“In the result, this title appeal filed by the defendant
appellant is dismissed.
The judgment and decree of the Learned Trial Court
passed in Title Suit No.134 of 2016 is upheld and
affirmed.
Prepare the appellate decree accordingly.
This Title Appeal stands disposed of on contest.”
Now the defendant-appellant has preferred this
second appeal challenging the judgment of the First
Appellate Court.
04.
Before the court at the time of admitting this
appeal, the following substantial question of law was
formulated by order dated 05.09.2022:
“Whether a party to an agreement can take the
advantage of any action done in contravention of the
terms and conditions of the written agreement, which
was consciously executed by the parties to the same?”
05.
In course of hearing Learned senior counsel Mr.
S. M. Chakraborty appearing for the appellant submitted
before the court that the plaintiff-respondent did not make
any prayer in the plaint, that the alleged lease/tenancy
agreement was void. There was also no such condition in
the agreement
that
in the
event
of non-delivery of
possession of the lease hold property, the tenancy will come
to an end. Learned senior counsel further submitted that in
the plaint it was asserted by the plaintiff-respondent that he
gave the security deposit and paid monthly rents to the
appellant for a certain period. If it is so, is it a believable
story that without taking possession of the lease hold shop,
the plaintiff-respondent has given monthly rents to the
present appellant. Learned senior counsel has also argued
that both the Learned courts below have misinterpreted the
recital of Clause-10 of alleged lease/tenancy agreement.
06.
Mr. Chakraborty, Learned senior counsel again
submitted that in para-7 of the plaint filed by the plaintiffrespondent before the Learned court below, it was clearly
mentioned that by a notice dated 25.10.2016 he has
revoked, cancelled and terminated the tenancy agreement
and furthermore in the said para of the plaint it was further
asserted by the plaintiff-respondent that on receipt of the
said notice dated 25.10.2016, the appellant-defendant by a
reply dated 08.11.2016 informed that he did not receive
any security money from the plaintiff-respondent and also
stated that the respondent-plaintiff has been possessing the
shop
premise
at
Datta
market
near
Sakuntala
road,
Agartala. Learned senior counsel further argued that since
the Learned courts below failed to appreciate clause-10 of
the tenancy agreement properly. So the judgment passed
by Learned Appellate court cannot be sustained in the eye
of law. Furthermore, according to the Learned senior
counsel a void agreement cannot be legally enforced. As the
tenancy agreement was silent in respect of steps to be
taken in the event of non-delivery of possession of the suit
premise, so no relief could be granted and Learned senior
counsel in support of his contention relied upon a decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in Tarsem Singh vs. Sukhminder
Singh reported in AIR 1998 SC 1400 and finally urged
before this court to allow this appeal by setting aside the
judgment of Learned First Appellate Court.
07.
On the contrary, Mr. A. Sengupta, Learned
counsel appearing for the respondent-plaintiff at the time of
hearing has submitted before this court that the present
appellant-defendant in his written statement before the
Learned Trial Court admitted that he has received the rent
of the let out premises from the respondent-plaintiff and
furthermore
DW-1
Subhasish
Datta(Appellant)
in
his
examination-in-chief on affidavit before the Learned Trial
court in para No.5 specifically stated that:
“That, I say that, the plaintiff did not taken the premises
for the business purpose as there was no complete
construction of shop premises. The shop premises is open
and there is no roof and further there is no door, window
in the said premises.”
Similarly, DW-2 Rupak Debnath in para-5 of his
examination-in-chief on affidavit stated that:
“That, I say that, the shop premises is till now
incomplete and there is no boundary wall, door, window,
plastering works, roof etc.”
Thus from the admission of the defendantappellant and his witness it is crystal clear that no
possession
was
given
to
respondent-plaintiff
by
the
appellant-defendant.
08.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondent-
plaintiff further drawn the attention of the court that the
rent
receipts
which
were
adduced
by
the
plaintiff-
respondent were marked as exhibits without any objection
from the appellant-defendant side during trial before the
Learned Trial court. Learned counsel Mr. Sengupta again
submitted that the notice issued by the respondent-plaintiff
was lawful. So in summing up Learned counsel for the
respondent-plaintiff submitted before the court that both
the Learned courts below had rightly delivered the judgment
with reasonable grounds. So Learned counsel appearing for
the respondent-plaintiff prayed for dismissal of this present
appeal.
09.
I have heard detailed argument of both the sides
and also gone through the records of the Learned court
below. As I have already stated that the respondent-plaintiff
filed the suit before the Learned Trial court below for
granting a decree of adjudication under Section 34 of the
Specific Relief Act and also for realization of security deposit
money in support of suit shop. On consideration of the
pleadings of the parties Learned Trial court framed the
following eight number of issues:
10.
(i)
Whether the suit is maintainable in its present
form and nature?
(ii)
Whether there is any cause of action for filing
the suit?
(iii)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree
declaring that the defendant committed
serious breach of contract with the plaintiff by
not delivering the vacant possession of the
rented premises to the plaintiff in compliance
of the tenancy agreement?
(iv)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a decree
declaring that the cancellation/ revocation/
termination of the tenancy agreement by the
plaintiff is lawful?
(v)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get a refund
of security deposit money amounting to
Rs.3,50,000/- from the defendant?
(vi)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get interest
@ 12% per annum from the date of final
demand notice dated 25.10.2016 till the date
of payment?
(vi)
Whether the plaintiff is entitled to get the
decree, as prayed for?
(vi)
Whether the parties are entitled to get any
other relief/relieves?
To
substantiate
the
issues
the
plaintiff-
respondent adduced four numbers of witnesses and relied
upon some documentary evidences which were marked as
Exhibit-1 to Exhibit-19 and at the same time the present
appellant-defendant
did
not
adduce
any
documentary
evidence on record in support of his defence. But they
adduced only
two
witnesses including the
defendant-
appellant himself. Regarding execution of lease/tenancy
agreement
(Exhibit-1)
there is
no
dispute on
record
amongst the parties. It was the case of the respondentplaintiff
that
as
per
tenancy
agreement
he
gave
Rs.3,50,000/- as security deposit to the appellant-defendant
and paid monthly rents for a certain period. But inspite of
his request the appellant-defendant did not hand over the
possession of suit premise to him. So by the notice dated
25.10.2016
(Exbt-4)
he
has
revoked,
cancelled
and
terminated the tenancy agreement which the present
appellant-defendant objected stating that the same was
illegal, inoperative and not binding upon the appellant in
view of the fact that same was contrary to the clause of the
said tenancy agreement (Exbt.1). More so, in the event of
non-delivery of possession of the suit shop as alleged, there
was no scope to revoke the tenancy agreement by the
respondent-plaintiff. Learned Trial court below at the time of
decision of the suit decided all the issues in favour of the
respondent-plaintiff and relied upon Section-10 of the
Indian Contract Act and came to a conclusion that tenancy
agreement (Exbt.1) was a valid contract in the eye of law.
From the exhibited documents further it appears that the
respondent-plaintiff could prove the money receipts of
security deposit towards payment of security deposit money
amounting to Rs.3,50,000/- to the present appellantdefendant and also the money receipt towards payment of
monthly
rents
to
the
appellant-defendant
and
those
documents were exhibited without any objection from the
side of appellant-defendant of this appeal. So there is no
scope to disbelieve the evidence on record regarding
payment of security deposit money by the respondent-
plaintiff to the present appellant of this case and also
regarding payment of monthly rents to the appellantdefendant.
11.
Now for the sake of convenience, this court
would like to refer herein below the definition of lease as
defined under Section 105 of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882, which is as follows:
“105.Lease defined.—A lease of immoveable property is a
transfer of a right to enjoy such property, made for a
certain time, express or implied, or in perpetuity, in
consideration of a price paid or promised, or of money, a
share of crops, service or any other thing of value, to be
rendered periodically or on specified occasions to the
transferor by the transferee, who accepts the transfer on
such terms.”
From the above definition it appears that the
paramount consideration of a valid lease is that “there shall
be transfer of right to enjoy any property made for a certain
time, express or implied, or in perpetuity in consideration of
a price paid or promises, or of money etc.”
12.
As I have already stated that there is no dispute
on record regarding execution of tenancy agreement (lease)
amongst the parties. Now I would like to refer herein below
the relevant Clause-10 of the tenancy agreement (leaseagreement) dated 09.11.2011 [Exbt.1] is as under:
“That, the lessor of lessee have right to cancel this Lease
agreement during the period of lease in that case will
have to issue 6(six) months written notice intimating his
desire to vacate the lease hold premises/shop room.”
13.
From the aforesaid clause it appears that as per
the tenancy agreement both the parties had the right to
cancel the lease agreement during the period of lease and
for that six months written notice intimating his desire to
vacate the lease hold premises/shop room be given.
14.
Here in the case in hand from the evidence it
appears that it was the case of the respondent-plaintiff that
the appellant-defendant had failed to deliver the possession
of the suit premise/shop to him rather he filed a Criminal
case against the respondent-plaintiff which was ended in
acquittal. It is apparent on record that there was no any
express provision/clause in the said agreement [Exbt.1]
that in the event of non-delivery of possession the tenancy
agreement would come to an end.
15.
The appellant-defendant although took the plea
that he did not receive any security deposit money from the
respondent-plaintiff but before the courts below he could
not
substantiate
his
contention
by
adducing
oral/documentary evidence on record to rebut the claim of
the respondent-plaintiff. So the assertion made by Learned
senior
counsel
for
the
appellant-defendant
cannot
be
accepted at this stage by this court.
16.
As already stated Learned senior counsel for the
appellant in course of hearing relied upon one citation in
Tarsem Singh (supra). I have also gone through the said
citation. In para No.-12, 13, 14 and 15 wherein the Hon’ble
Apex Court has made the following observations:
12. Contract' is a bilateral transaction between two or
more than two parties. Every contract has to pass
through several stages beginning with the stage of
negotiation during which the parties discuss and
negotiate proposals and counter-proposals as also the
consideration resulting finally in the acceptance of the
proposal. The proposal when accepted gives rise to an
agreement. It is at this stage that the agreement is
reduced into writing and a formal document is executed
on which parties affix their signatures or thumb
impression so as to be bound by the terms of the
agreement set out in that document. Such an agreement
has to be lawful as the definition of contract, as set out in
Section 2(h) provides that "an agreement enforceable by
law is a contract". Section 2(9) sets out that "an
agreement not enforceable by law is said to be void".
13. Before we proceed to consider what are lawful
agreements or what are voidable or void contracts, we
may point out that it is not necessary under law that
every contract must be in writing. There can be an
equally binding contract between the parties on the basis
of oral agreement unless there is a law which requires
the agreement to be in writing.
14. Section 10 of the Contract Act provides as under:"10. What agreements are contracts.- All agreements are
contracts if they are made by the free consent of parties
competent to contract, for a lawful consideration and
with a lawful object, and are not hereby expressly
declared to be void.
Nothing herein contained shall affect any law in force in
India and not hereby expressly repealed, by which any
contract is required to be made in writing or in the
presence of witnesses, or any law relating to the
registration of documents."
15. The essentials of contract set out in Section 10 above
are:(1) Free consent of the parties
(2) Competence of parties to contract
(3) Lawful consideration
(4) Lawful object
15A. Competence to contract is set out in Section
11 which provides that every person is competent to
contract who is of the age of majority and who is of
sound mind and is not disqualified from contracting by
any law to which he is subject. Section 12 provides that a
person will be treated to be of sound mind if, at the time
when he makes the contract, he is capable of
understanding it and forming a rational judgment as to
its effect upon his interests.
From the principle of the aforesaid citation
further it appears to me that the aforesaid agreement i.e.
Exbt.1 was made in pursuance of Section-10 of Indian
Contract Act.
17.
From the record of the Learned court below it
transpires that
tenancy agreement
[Exbt.1]
was
duly
executed amongst the parties of this appeal and the said
agreement was a valid contract in the eye of law. The
principles of the aforesaid citation is very much applicable
for just decision of this appeal but by the principles of the
aforesaid citation as referred by Learned senior counsel for
the appellant there is no scope to disbelieve the evidence on
record of the respondent-plaintiff before the Learned Trial
Court below. More so, from Exbt.15 that is the reply notice
dated 08.11.2016 by the appellant-defendant against the
legal notice dated 25.10.2016 to the respondent-plaintiff it
also appears that in para-4 it was asserted on behalf of the
appellant-defendant that the respondent-plaintiff defaulted
in making payment of monthly rent in respect of the let out
premise to the appellant-defendant which attracts Clause11 of the agreement and thus he(respondent) violated
Clause-11 of the tenancy agreement [Exbt.1]. But to
substantiate his contention there is no evidence on record
from the side of appellant-defendant that for violation of the
said clause the appellant-defendant has taken any sort of
legal step against the respondent-plaintiff of this present
appeal. Had there be any violation on the part of the
respondent-plaintiff in respect of Clause-11 of the tenancy
agreement, the appellant-defendant had the legal scope to
challenge the tenancy agreement which he failed to do so.
Thus from the act and conduct and also from the evidence
on record specifically the evidence of DW-1 and DW-2 in
their
examination-in-chief
of
affidavit,
wherein
they
themselves admitted that the suit shop/premise was not
ready for delivery. So it is crystal clear that the plea of the
respondent-plaintiff before the Trial court that the present
appellant-defendant did not hand over possession to the
respondent-plaintiff was/is well established and thus the
Learned Trial court below rightly came to a conclusion that
there was a breach of contract on the part of the appellantdefendant to perform his part of contract in execution of the
tenancy agreement [Exbt.1] inspite of receiving security
deposit amount and the monthly rents for few months in
respect of the suit premise from the respondent and thus
rightly delivered the judgment and similarly the Learned
First Appellate court at the time of delivering the judgment
relied upon Section-91 of the Evidence Act regarding receipt
of
security
deposit
amount
of
Rs.3,50,000/-
by
the
appellant-defendant from the respondent-plaintiff and also
came to the conclusion on perusal of the Clause-10 of the
agreement that the Clause-10 of the agreement would come
into play only after the agreement is actually brought into
force and it was also the observation of the Learned First
Appellate Court that even after execution of the agreement
and also after receipt of the security deposit money as well
as the monthly rents the appellant-defendant failed to hand
over the suit premise to the respondent-plaintiff resulting
which the requirement of six months notice as per Clause10 of the tenancy agreement would not be required for
revocation/termination
of
the
lease
agreement/tenancy
agreement [Exbt.1].
18.
Thus after hearing both the sides and also after
going through the LC records it appears to me that there
was no infirmity in the judgment passed by Learned First
Appellate Court affirming the judgment of the Learned Trial
Court below in T.S. 134 of 2016, passed by Learned Civil
Judge (Senior Division) Court No.1, Agartala, West Tripura.
So the substantial question of law as formulated by this
court
by
the
order
dated
05.09.2022
is
accordingly
answered in negative against the present appellant of this
case.
19.
In the result, the appeal preferred by the
appellant is hereby dismissed on contest with costs. The
judgment and decree dated 28.04.2022 passed by the
Learned District Judge, West Tripura, Agartala in Title
Appeal No.50 of 2019 affirming the judgment and decree
dated 03.06.2019 of the Learned Trial Court numbered as
Title Suit 134 of 2016, is hereby affirmed.
Prepare the decree accordingly and send down
the LCRs along with a copy of the judgment.
JUDGE
signed by
MOUMIT Digitally
MOUMITA DATTA
2023.12.22
A DATTA Date:
04:16:30 -08'00'
Moumita
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review